Rajkumar Goswami vs State Of U.P. And 4 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
AFR
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - A No. - 14853 of 2026
Rajkumar Goswami
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P. And 4 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Pankaj Kumar Govil
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C.
Court No. - 21
HON'BLE ARINDAM SINHA, J.
HON'BLE SATYA VEER SINGH, J.
(Per Arindam Sinha, J.)
1. Mr. Pankaj Kumar Govil, learned advocate appears for petitioner.
Prayer 'a' is reproduced below.
"a. Issue writ, order or direction of the nature of CERTIORARI quashing
the impugned punishment order dated 28.07.2021 passed by the
respondent no.4/disciplinary authority, order dated 21.04.2022 passed by
the respondent no.3/appellate authority, and order dated 09.10.2022
passed by the respondent no.2/ revisional authority as well as judgment
and order dated 18.05.2026 passed by State Public Service Tribunal
Lucknow in Claim Petition no.773 of 2023 Rajkumar Goswami vs State of
U.P. & Others. (Annexure no.3, 5, 6 & 8 of Writ Petition respectively);"
Mr. S.C. Upadhyay, learned advocate, Standing Counsel appears for
State.
2. Charge against petitioner will appear from paragraph 2 in impugned
judgment and order dated 18th May, 2026 of the tribunal. The paragraph
is reproduced below.
"The case of the petitioner, in substance, is that he was initially appointed
as Constable PAC in the year 1996 and, after qualifying the departmental
examination, was promoted as Sub Inspector (Civil Police) in the year
2015. While posted at Police Chauki Kosma, Police Station Ghiror,
WRIA No. 14853 of 2026
2
District Mainpuri, an incident took place on 26.03.2019 during a
marriage ceremony in village Kosma Musalmeen, where a dispute
allegedly arose between certain persons regarding taking photographs. In
connection with the said incident, Case Crime No.100 of 2019 under
Sections 307, 323 and 506 IPC was registered. On the following day, i.e.,
27.03.2019, one Sherenabi was murdered, leading to registration of Case
Crime No.101 of 2019 under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302 and 506 IPC. On
the allegation that the petitioner failed to take immediate legal action
against the accused persons, a show cause notice dated 26.11.2019
proposing censure entry was issued to him."
Above is faithful English translation of the charge communicated to
petitioner on 26th November, 2019, as made by the tribunal.
3. Petitioner has challenged aforesaid judgment and order of the tribunal
on ground that punishment order dated 28th July, 2021, appellate order
21st April, 2022 and revisional order dated 9th October, 2022 were all
illegally made. Punishment awarded was censure entry.
4. On perusal of impugned judgment and order of the tribunal we see that
case against petitioner was, he ought to have been more vigilant as he
failed to take timely preventive or supervisory action in respect of the
dispute, which culminated in the murder on following day. It appears
from the judgment, the tribunal said that it cannot be over looked
petitioner was posted as Chowki Incharge, within whose jurisdiction the
dispute admittedly arose between rival groups and the incident culminated
into a murder within a short span of time. Paragraph 14 from the
judgment is reproduced below.
"14. Learned counsel for the petitioner has asserted that the entire
departmental proceedings rest upon a fundamentally disputed factual
foundation, namely the allegation that the petitioner and other police
personnel had attended the marriage feast of Tayyaba, sister of Aamir
Chauhan, on 26.03.2019 where the dispute between Jeetu and Arman
allegedly took place. It has been consistently maintained that neither the
petitioner nor any police personnel from Chauki Kosma attended the
marriage function and that no information regarding the altercation was
communicated to the petitioner on 26.03.2019. According to the petitioner,
WRIA No. 14853 of 2026
3
FIR No.100 of 2019 was registered at the instance of Inspector Devendra
Nath Mishra and information regarding the said case was supplied to him
only on 27.03.2019 at about 20:45 hours when he had reached Police
Station Ghiroor for second mobile duty, which circumstance also finds
some corroboration from the General Diary entry dated 27.03.2019. On
the other hand, the preliminary enquiry report contains statements of
Aamir Chauhan, Rashid, Masrat, Vinay Kumar, Akhilesh and Awadhesh
Yadav, who consistently stated that the petitioner and other police
personnel had attended the marriage feast and that the altercation
between Jeetu and Arman had taken place in the presence of police
personnel regarding photography with them. The enquiry report further
records that the petitioner and Head Constable Ratan Singh were residing
near Shanti Garden Marriage Home situated adjoining the outpost area.
The disciplinary authority, while relying upon these statements, arrived at
the conclusion that despite being Chauki Incharge of the area concerned,
the petitioner failed to take timely preventive or supervisory action in
respect of the dispute which ultimately culminated in the murder of Sher-e-
Navi on the following day. The petitioner has strongly emphasized that
FIR No.100 of 2019 does not contain any recital regarding the presence of
police personnel at the marriage function and has attempted to shift the
primary responsibility upon Inspector Devendra Nath Mishra by asserting
that the latter neither acted promptly nor communicated the information
immediately to the petitioner.
However, the consistent version of several
witnesses supporting the presence of the petitioner at the marriage feast
cannot be brushed aside merely because the FIR is silent on that aspect.
At the same time, it cannot be overlooked that the petitioner was posted
as Chauki Incharge within whose jurisdiction the dispute admittedly
arose between rival groups and the incident culminated into a murder
within a short span of time. In such circumstances, the conclusion
drawn by the disciplinary authority that the petitioner failed to exhibit
the degree of vigilance, promptness and preventive supervision expected
from a police officer cannot be said to be wholly arbitrary or
unsupported by material available on record ."
(emphasis supplied)
5. True it is per section 22 in Police Act, 1861, every Police Officer is
WRIA No. 14853 of 2026
4
deemed to be always on duty. The section is reproduced below.
" 22. Police Officer always on duty and may be employed in any part of
district.- Every Police Officer shall for all purposes in this Act contained,
be considered to be always on duty and may at any time be employed as
Police Officer in any part of the general police district."
However, above cannot be invoked against petitioner assuming he had
participated in the wedding festivities, wherein altercation regarding
photographs taken arose, to culminate in murder the following day.
Separate FIRs stood registered. There is no material on record to show
petitioner was authorized to carry out arrest and he had failed to do so.
Even then, the accused, if had been taken into custody and thereafter
released in due course, it would be no guarantee that his follow up
intention to kill would thereby be prevented. The police must be vigilant
and alert but they can only act on information. The first FIR carrying
charge, inter alia, invoking offence under section 307 in Indian Penal
Code, 1860, may have been sufficient for the Investigating Officer (IO) to
have effected arrest. The police can seek to prevent crime. That is by
better policing in preventing unlawful activity. No rule or regulation has
been shown to us regarding what petitioner could have done, assuming he
was at the wedding ceremony/feast and at the time not shown to be or
requisitioned on duty.
6. Impugned judgment and order of the tribunal is set aside and quashed.
So also we set aside the punishment order. Petitioner is entitled to the
consequences in respect of his service.
7. The exemption application is allowed and the writ petition,
disposed
of .
November 12, 2026
sailesh
(Arindam Sinha,J.)
(Satya Veer Singh,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
SAILESH PRAJAPATI
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad