LEELA @ ANURADHA VILAS MELALKI vs GAJKUMAR KALLAPPA LENGADE

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD

TH
DATED THIS THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI


REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.5158 OF 2010 (PAR-)


BETWEEN:

SMT. LEELA @ ANURADHA VILAS MEKALKI,
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.,

1(A) SMT. URMILA D/O. VILAS MEKALKI,
AGE: 46 YEARS, OCC: HOMEMAKER

1(B) RAJESH S/O. VILAS MEKALKI,
AGE: 43 YEARS, OCC: PRIVATE SERVICE

BOTH ARE R/O. H.NO.2121,
KORE GALLI, SHAHAPUR, BELAGAVI-590 003.

THE LRS OF SOLE APPELLANT HAVE COME ON RECORD AS
APPELLANT NO.1 (A) & (B) AS PER ORDER DATED 17.06.2026











Digitally
signed by
BHARATHI
H M
Date:
2026.11.17
15:35:56
+0530
…APPELLANT

(BY SRI.CHETAN MUNNOLI, ADVOCATE FOR A1(A) AND (B))

AND:

1. SHRI. GAJKUMAR KALLAPPA LENGADE,
SINCE DEAD BY HIS L.RS.,

1(A) SMT. NALINI, W/O. GAJKUMAR LENGADE,
AGE: 65 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/A. H.NO.2121, KORE GALLI, SHAHAPUR, BELAGAVI.

1(B) SHRI. ANAND, S/O. GAJKUMAR LENGADE,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC: CIVIL CONTRACTOR,
BHARATHI
H M

- 2 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


R/A. H.NO.2121, KORE GALLI, SHAHAPUR, BELAGAVI.

2. SHRI. JINENDRA KALLAPPA,

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.,

2(A) SANDYA W/O. JINENDRA LENGADE,
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. NO.2121, KORE GALLI, SHAHAPUR, BELAGAVI,
NOW RESIDING AT H.NO.59, KAMALAKSHI NILAYA,
ST ND
1 BLOCK, 2 STAGE, NAGARBAVI, BENGALURU.

2(B) TEJASHREE W/O. PARSHWANATH,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. H.NO.59, KAMALAKSHI NILAYA,
ST ND
1 BLOCK, 2 STAGE, NAGARBAVI, BENGALURU.

2(C) SMT. ANJALI D/O. JINENDRA LENGADE,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. NO.2121, KORE GALLI, SHAHAPUR, BELAGAVI.

2(D) SHRI. NARENDRA S/O. JEENENDRA LINGADE,
AGE: 27 YEARS, R/O. NO.2121, KORE GALLI,
SHAHAPUR, BELAGAVI, NOW RESIDING AT H.NO.59,
ST ND
KAMALAKSHI NILAYA, 1 BLOCK, 2 STAGE,
NAGARBAVI, BENGALURU.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. MRUTYUNJAYA TATA BANGI, ADVOCATE FOR R1(A),
R1(B) AND R2(A TO D))

THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER
SECTION 100 OF CPC, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT
AND DECREE DATED 11.11.2009 IN R.A.NO.293/2009 ON THE
FILE OF FAST TRACK COURT-II AND ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE,
BELAGAVI, THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 21.04.2006 IN
O.S.NO.329/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE SECOND ADDL. CIVIL
JUDGE (JR.DN.) AND JMFC, BELAGAVI BE RESTORED AND THIS
APPEAL BE ALLOWED WITH COST THROUGHOUT.

THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING, HAVING
BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 23.09.2026, THIS
DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI

- 3 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


CAV JUDGMENT


The plaintiff in OS No.329/2003 on the file of learned
II Additional Civil Judge (Jr.Dn.) and JMFC, Belagavi has
maintained this regular second appeal.

2. The plaintiff namely Smt. Leela @ Anuradha
Vilas Mekalki instituted the suit in OS No.329/2003 against
Sri Gajkumar Kalappa Lengade and Sri Jinendra Kalappa
Lengade for the relief of permanent injunction restraining
them and any person acting on their behalf from
disturbing her peaceful possession and enjoyment of the
suit property.

3. The case of the plaintiff is that she is the full
sister and step sister of Defendant Nos.1 and 2
respectively. She states that after the death of her
husband, she was constrained to shift her family from
Mumbai to Belagavi and she was residing with her mother
in the suit property since 1987. She alleges that after the
death of her mother on 25.04.2003, the defendants tried
to oust her and her children from the suit property without

- 4 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


having any manner of right. Hence, she filed the suit for
permanent injunction.

4. On service of suit summons, the defendants
entered their appearance before the trial court through
their Counsel and filed their objection to IA No.I, filed by
the plaintiff for temporary injunction. After disposal of the
said application, the defendants filed IA No.II praying to
treat their objection to IA No.I as their written statement.
The said application was allowed on cost and on deposit of
the cost, the trial court treated the objection to IA No.I as
the written statement of the defendants.

5. The defendants contend that they are the
absolute owners of the suit property, i.e., house property
bearing CTS No.2121 at Koregalli, as per bequeath made
by their father. They stated that even the mother of the
plaintiff was given a share in the family properties under
the Will. They claim that they permitted the mother of the
plaintiff to reside in the suit property. They allege that the
plaintiff, who used to visit her mother, under the guise of
staying in the suit property for one or two days and taking

- 5 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


advantage of her visits, created documents to claim a right
of residence. They contend that the plaintiff is a married
woman capable of leading her life and that they are under
no obligation to maintain her or to provide any residence.
Hence, they prayed for dismissal of the suit.

6. The trial court, based on the pleadings of the
parties, framed the following issues for its consideration:
“1.Whether plaintiff proves her possession over
the suit property as on the date of suit?
2. Does she further prove the cause of action?
3. What order or decree?”


7. During the trial of the case, the plaintiff got
examined as PW-1, examined one more witness and got
marked the documents as Ex.P1 to P37. On behalf of the
defendants, Defendant No.1 adduced the evidence as
DW-1 and got marked documents as Exs.D1 to D14.

8. Afterwards, the trial court heard the arguments
of both sides, considered the materials on record and
decreed the suit vide its judgment dated 21.04.2006.

- 6 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010



9. The defendants preferred the appeal in RA
No.293/2009 challenging the judgment and decree of the
trial court. The first appellate court re-weighed the
evidence on record and then allowed the appeal on the
ground that the description of the suit property furnished
by the plaintiff is totally wrong and when the plaintiff has
failed to prove her possession over the suit property by
furnishing its correct description, protecting the possession
of the plaintiff does not arise. Feeling aggrieved, the
plaintiff has directed this regular second appeal.

10. During the pendency of this appeal the plaintiff
as well as the defendants died. Accordingly, their legal
representatives were brought on record.

11. This Court admitted the appeal on 07.04.2014,
to consider the following substantial question of law:
“Whether the first appellate Court has
committed a serious error in up turning a well
considered judgment and dismissing the suit
filed for permanent injunction by ignoring the
material evidence placed on record and thus
the judgment of the first appellate Court is
perverse and illegal?”

- 7 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010




12. As noted above, the plaintiff maintained the suit
for the relief of permanent injunction, seeking protection
from alleged interference of the defendants with her
possession and enjoyment of the suit property. The
plaintiff has described the suit property as follows:
“The suit property consist of three rooms, one
bathroom and space in front of bathroom along
with common area in the house property standing
upon CTS No.2121 situate at Koregalli, Shahapur,
Belguam and bounded as follows:
to the East : CTS No.2120,
to the West : CTS No.2122,
to the North : by a Bangi passage,
to the South : by a road calling
itself Koregalli, Shahapur”.


13. Further, the plaintiff has annexed a hand sketch
map to the plaint, showing the suit property in red colour,
which depicts as under:

- 8 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010




14. The defendants contested the suit mainly on
three grounds, i.e., they are the owners of the suit
property, the plaintiff is in unauthorized occupation of the
suit property and that the description of the suit property
is not correct.

15. The judgment rendered by the trial court
indicates that it did not consider the question of title to the
suit property so as to prima facie satisfy itself as to the
plaintiff’s right or interest therein and the nature of her

- 9 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


possession over the same. The trial court proceeded to
consider the materials on record with an observation that
for the purpose of the granting the relief of the permanent
injunction what is to be looked into is whether the plaintiff
has proved the identity of the property in respect of which
injunction is sought. Even then, the trial court did not give
a clear finding on this aspect and held that there is ample
evidence to show the plaintiff’s possession over the suit
property and decreed the suit.

16. The first appellate court reversed the decree of
the trial court mainly on the ground that the description of
the suit property is totally wrong and it does not confine to
three rooms, one bathroom and common passage as
claimed. The first appellate court also held that the
plaintiff has no semblance of right over the suit property
and her possession is unauthorized possession. Hence, the
first appellate court held that the prayer of the plaintiff for
permanent injunction is not sustainable and dismissed the
suit.

- 10 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010



17. Sri Chetan Munnoli, learned Counsel for the
Plaintiff vehemently submitted that the first appellate
court has erred in reversing the judgment and decree of
the trial court on the ground of lack of proper description
of the suit property, particularly in the absence of a
specific pleading, framing of an issue in that regard and
any dispute raised by the defendants regarding difficulty in
identifying the property in dispute. He submitted that
admittedly the plaintiff is in possession of portion of
property bearing CTS No.2121. As such, he contended the
impugned judgment of the first appellate court is perverse
and illegal, ignoring the oral and documentary evidence on
record.

18. Per contra, Sri Mrutyunjaya Tata Bangi, learned
Counsel for the Defendants vigorously supported the
findings of the first appellate court and its conclusion. He
submitted that the plaintiff has no semblance of any right
over the suit property. He further submitted that the
plaintiff has not whispered anything about nature her
possession over the property in question. He also

- 11 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


submitted that the plaintiff has come up with a suit for
permanent injunction against the true owners of the
property and by giving wrong description of the property.
In view of the same, he contended that the first appellate
court was justified in allowing the appeal and reversing the
judgment and decree of the trial court.

19. In Maria Margarida Sequeira Gernandes
and others Vs Erasmo Jack De Sequeira (dead)
through LRS, reported in (2012) 5 SCC 370, Hon’ble
Apex Court has re-emphasized the importance of the
pleading and held that the person averring a right to
continue in possession must give all details, such as who is
the owner of the property, date of entry into possession,
how he came into possession, who are in possession and
in what capacity, basis of his claim to continue in
possession, etc. It further held that apart from the
pleadings, the court must insist on documentary proof in
support of the pleadings.

20. Reverting to the case on hand, the averments
of the plaint make it clear that the plaintiff has not

- 12 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


whispered anything about her right or interest in the suit
property or the nature of her possession over the suit
property. She merely stated that she is staying along with
her children in her parental house bearing CTS No.2121
situated in Koregalli and that after the death of her
husband she is staying in the said property along with her
mother since 1987. She further contends that the
defendants have no manner of right to drive her out of the
suit property, and that they are harassing her through
their illegal activity. Even in the affidavit filed in lieu of her
examination-in-chief, by the plaintiff has not stated any
additional facts except reiterating the averments of the
plaint. The plaintiff has produced a CTS extract pertaining
to the property in question as Ex.P1. As per the said
document the property bearing CTS No.2121 stands in the
names of the defendants and others. Thus, it becomes
clear that the plaintiff has neither pleaded nor placed any
document before the court to show her right or interest in
the property and the nature of her possession over the
property in question.

- 13 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010



21. On the other hand, Ex.D1 goes to show that the
plaintiff and her mother had moved an application in FDP
No.17/1978 praying to implead them as additional
defendants in the said proceeding on the ground that they
are also the Class-I legal heirs of deceased Kallappa
Lengade and that they are entitled to have share in the
properties therein. The said application came to be
dismissed with the following observations:
rd
“…The fact that the 3 parties were arrayed as
defendants 15 and 18 in RCS No.11 of 1961
before the Civil Judge, Belgaum and that these
very defendants had filed written statement
contending that Kallappa Lengade had executed a
will in favor of defendant numbers 4A and 4B
which is not at all challenged by the proposed
defendant Nos.7 and 8. It is also not contended
by the proposed defendant Nos. 7 and 8 that they
have not filed such a written statement in RCS
No.11/61. It has to be observed that these
proposed defendant Nos.7 and 8 cannot blow hot
and cold in each of the proceedings so as to put
obstacles in the proceedings before the court
indefinitely. …”

- 14 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010



22. Undisputedly, the reference of ‘third parties’,
‘proposed Defendant Nos.7 and 8’ in the above extract
relates to the plaintiff herein and her mother. Similarly,
the reference of ‘Defendant Nos.4A and 4B relates to the
defendants herein. The first appellate court considering
the materials on record held that the defendants have got
right, title and interest over entire property bearing CTS
No.2121 and that the plaintiff has no sort of right, title or
interest over the said property.

23. Coming to the question of the plaintiff’s
possession over the suit property, she has claimed that
the suit property consists of three rooms, one bath room
and the space in front of bath room along with common
areas in the property bearing CTS No.2121 situated at
Koregalli, Shahapur, Belagavi. Further, she has annexed a
hand sketch map to the plaint, for the sake of brevity.
However, the plaintiff did not furnish the measurement of
the portion said to be in her possession either in the plaint
or in the hand sketch map. Moreover, the hand sketch
map coupled with the boundaries mentioned in the plaint

- 15 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


make it clear that the plaintiff has furnished the
boundaries of entire property bearing CTS No.2121 and
not the boundaries of the portion said to be in her
possession. Besides, the contents of hand sketch map give
an impression that the plaintiff is in possession of
altogether six rooms as against three rooms and a
bathroom claimed by her in the plaint. Thereby, it is amply
clear that the first appellate court was fully justified in
recording a finding that the description of the suit property
is totally wrong and it does not confine to three rooms,
one bathroom and common passage as averred in the
plaint.

24. The first appellate court, relying on the legal
principles laid down in T.L. Nagendra Babu Vs Manohar
Rao Pawar (ILR 2005 Kar.884), Ambanna Vs
Ghanteappa (AIR 1999 Kar.421) and two other decisions
that unless the court is satisfied with regard to
identification of the property, no relief can be granted,
concluded that the plaintiff having failed to furnish correct
description of the suit property, protecting her possession

- 16 -
RSA No. 5158 of 2010


does not arise. Such finding of the first appellate court is
purely a question of fact, based on re-weighing the
evidence on record and it is not perverse. The first
appellate court reversed the judgment and decree of the
trial court by assigning valid reasons and on justifiable
ground. This Court finds no valid reason to interfere with
such factual findings of the first appellate court. For the
foregoing reasons, the substantial question of law framed
in this appeal is answered in the negative.

25. In the result, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER

i. The regular second appeal is dismissed .

ii. Pending applications if any, stand disposed of
as they do not survive for consideration.

SD/-
(B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
JUDGE



RH/ASN/HMB
CT:PA