BIDYADHAR SAHOO vs STATE OF ODISHA
- Court
- Odisha High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) Nos. 38299 of 2020, 29433 & 33911 of 2026
CNR Nos. ODHC010808902020, ODHC010691822026 &
ODHC010691742026
W.P.(C) No. 38299 of 2020
CNR No. ODHC010808902020
In the matter of an application under Articles 226 & 227 of the
Constitution of India.
………………
Bidyadhar Sahoo
…. Petitioner
-versus-
State of Odisha & Ors. Opposite Parties
….
: Mr. S.N. Mishra , Advocate
For Petitioners
: Dr. P.P. Behera, Addl. Standing Counsel
For Opp. Parties
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Date of Hearing: 12.11.2026 & Date of Judgment:12.11.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J .
1. This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
// 2 //
2. Heard Mr. S.N. Mishra, learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner
and Dr. P.P. Behera, learned Addl. Standing Counsel appearing for the
Opp. Parties.
3. All these writ petitions have been filed challenging order
dtd.11.07.2019 so passed by Opp. Party No. 4 under Annexure-9. Vide
the said order claim of the Petitioners to get the benefit of regularization
has been rejected by Opp. Party No. 4.
4. It is the main contention of the learned counsel appearing for the
Petitioners that the Tribunal while disposing the matter vide order
dtd.22.01.2019 in O.A. No. 194(C) of 2019 though directed the Director,
Family Welfare-Opp. Party No. 2 to take a decision on the Petitioners’
claim to get the benefit of regularization, taking into account the decision
in the case Secretary, State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi (3), (2006) 4
SCC-1 so followed in the case of State of Karnatak vs. M.L. Keshari,
(2010) 9 SCC 247 , but CDMO, Jajpur-Opp. Party No. 4 rejected the
claim vide the impugned common order dtd.11.07.2019, which is
impugned in the present batch of writ petitions.
4.1. It is first of all contended that since the Tribunal had directed the
Director, Health & Family Welfare to take a decision on the Petitioners’
Page 2 of 22
// 3 //
claim, such a claim could not have been rejected by Opp. Party No. 4. It
is further contended that even though all the Petitioners are continuing
on DLR basis for a substantial period, but such claim of the Petitioners
has been illegally rejected without proper appreciation of the decision in
the case of M.L. Keshari so cited (supra).
4.2. It is further contended that similar order passed by the Tribunal in
O.A. No. 1385(C) of 2019 on 16.07.2019 was implemented by the State
vide its order dtd.17.10.2019. It is also contended that similar order
passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No. 1944(C) of 2001 & batch has been
implemented by the State in the meantime.
4.3. It is further contended that taking into account the long continuance
of the Petitioners on DLR basis in the office of Opp. Party No. 4, in view
of the recent decision of the Apex Court in the case of Jaggo vs. Union
of India & Ors., 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826; Shripal & Anr. vs. Nagar
Nigam, Ghaziabad, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 221, as well as Dharam
Singh & Ors. vs. State of U.P. & Anr. (Civil Appeal No(s).8558 of 2018
and another decision of the Apex Court in the case of Bhola Nath Vs.
State of Jharkhand and Others , 2026 INSC 99 and in the case of
Sukhendu Bhatacharjee & Ors. vs. the State of Assam & Ors. reported
in 2026 INSC 523, Petitioners are eligible and entitled to get the benefit
Page 3 of 22
// 4 //
of regularization, prior to their retirement, as during pendency of the
matter, all the three (3) Petitioners retired from their work on attaining
the age of superannuation, with release of the retiral benefits under OCS
(Pension) Rules, 1992.
4.4. View expressed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Jaggo in
Para-22 to 25 and 27 reads as follows:-
“22. The pervasive misuse of temporary employment
contracts, as exemplified in this case, reflects a broader
systemic issue that adversely affects workers' rights and job
security. In the private sector, the rise of the gig economy has
led to an increase in precarious employment arrangements,
often characterized by lack of benefits, job security, and fair
treatment. Such practices have been criticized for exploiting
workers and undermining labour standards. Government
institutions, entrusted with upholding the principles of fairness
and justice, bear an even greater responsibility to avoid such
exploitative employment practices. When public sector entities
engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it not only mirrors
the detrimental trends observed in the gig economy but also
sets a concerning precedent that can erode public trust in
governmental operations.
23. The International Labour Organization (ILO), of which
India is a founding member, has consistently advocated for
employment stability and the fair treatment of workers. The
ILO's Multinational Enterprises Declaration6 encourages
companies to provide stable employment and to observe
obligations concerning employment stability and social
security. It emphasizes that enterprises should assume a
leading role in promoting employment security, particularly in
contexts where job discontinuation could exacerbate long-term
unemployment.
24. The landmark judgement of the United State in the case of
Vizcaino v. Microsoft Corporation7 serves as a pertinent
example from the private sector, illustrating the consequences
of misclassifying employees to circumvent
Page 4 of 22
// 5 //
providing benefits. In this case, Microsoft classified certain
workers as independent contractors, thereby denying them
employee benefits. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit determined that these workers were, in fact, common-
law employees and were entitled to the same benefits as
regular employees. The Court noted that large Corporations
have increasingly adopted the practice of hiring temporary
employees or independent contractors as a means of avoiding
payment of employee benefits, thereby increasing their profits.
This judgment underscores the principle that the nature of the
work performed, rather than the label assigned to the worker,
should determine employment status and the corresponding
rights and benefits. It highlights the judiciary's role in
rectifying such misclassifications and ensuring that workers
receive fair treatment.
25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary employees,
particularly in government institutions, often face multifaceted
forms of exploitation. While the foundational purpose of
temporary contracts may have been to address
short-term or seasonal needs, they have increasingly become a
mechanism to evade long-term obligations owed to employees.
These practices manifest in several ways:
• Misuse of "Temporary" Labels:
Employees engaged for work that is essential,
recurring, and integral to the functioning of an institution are
often labeled as "temporary" or "contractual," even when their
roles mirror those of regular employees. Such misclassification
deprives workers of the dignity, security,
and benefits that regular employees are entitled to, despite
performing identical tasks.
• Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees are
frequently dismissed without cause or notice, as seen in the
present case. This practice undermines the principles of
natural justice and subjects workers to a state of constant
insecurity, regardless of the quality or duration of their
service.
• Lack of Career Progression: Temporary employees
often find themselves excluded from opportunities for skill
development, promotions, or incremental pay raises. They
remain stagnant in their roles,
creating a systemic disparity between them and their regular
counterparts, despite their contributions being equally
significant.
Page 5 of 22
// 6 //
• Using Outsourcing as a Shield:
Institutions increasingly resort to outsourcing roles
performed by temporary employees, effectively replacing one
set of exploited workers with another. This practice not only
perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates a deliberate
effort to bypass the obligation to offer regular employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits:
Temporary employees are often denied fundamental benefits
such as pension, provident fund, health insurance, and paid
leave, even when their tenure spans decades. This lack of
social security subjects them and their families to undue
hardship, especially in cases of illness, retirement, or
unforeseen circumstances.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxx
27. In light of these considerations, in our opinion, it is
imperative for government departments to lead by example in
providing fair and stable employment. Engaging workers on a
temporary basis for extended periods, especially when their
roles are integral to the organization's functioning, not only
contravenes international labour standards but also exposes
the organization to legal challenges and undermines employee
morale. By ensuring fair employment
practices, government institutions can reduce the burden of
unnecessary litigation, promote job security, and uphold the
principles of justice and fairness that they are meant to
embody. This approach aligns with international standards
and sets a positive precedent for the private sector to follow,
thereby contributing to the overall betterment of labour
practices in the country.”
4.5. Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Shripal in Para-14, 15, 17 &
18(IV)has held as follows:-
“14. ...... More importantly, Uma Devi cannot serve as a shield
to justify exploitative engagements persisting for years without
the Employer undertaking legitimate recruitment.
15.
……. Indian labour law strongly disfavors perpetual
daily-wage or contractual engagements in circumstances
where the work is permanent in nature.
xxx xxx xxx xxx
Page 6 of 22
// 7 //
17. Indeed, bureaucratic limitations cannot trump the
legitimate rights of workmen who have served continuously in
de facto regular roles for an extended period.
18.(IV) The Respondent Employer is directed to initiate a fair
and transparent process for regularizing the Appellant
Workmen within six months from the date of reinstatement,
duly considering the fact that they have performed perennial
municipal duties akin to permanent posts. In assessing
regularization, the Employer shall not impose educational or
procedural criteria retroactively if such requirements were
never applied to the Appellant Workmen or to similarly
situated regular employees in the past. To the extent that
sanctioned vacancies for such duties exist or are required, the
Respondent Employer shall expedite all necessary
administrative processes to ensure these longtime employees
are not indefinitely retained on daily wages contrary to
statutory and equitable norms.
”
4.6. Placing reliance on the decision in the case of Jaggo and Shripal ,
in Paragraph-13, 14,
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Dharam Singh,
15 & 17, 18, 19 & 20 has held as follows:
As we have observed in both Jaggo (Supra) and Shripal
“13.
(Supra) , outsourcing cannot become a convenient shield to
perpetuate precariousness and to sidestep fair engagement
practices where the work is inherently perennial. The
Commission’s further contention that the appellants are not
“full-time” employees but continue only by virtue of interim
orders also does not advance their case. That interim
protection was granted precisely because of the long history of
engagement and the pendency of the challenge to the State’s
refusals. It neither creates rights that did not exist nor erases
entitlements that may arise upon a proper adjudication of the
legality of those refusals.
14 . The learned Single Judge of the High Court also declined
relief on the footing that the petitioners had not specifically
assailed the subsequent decision dated 25.11.2003. However,
that view overlooks that the writ petition squarely challenged
the 11.11.1999 refusal as the High Court itself directed a fresh
decision during pendency, and the later rejection was placed
on record by the respondents. In such circumstances, we
Page 7 of 22
// 8 //
believe that the High Court was obliged to examine the legality
of the State’s stance in refusing sanction, whether in 1999 or
upon reconsideration in 2003, rather than dispose of the
matter on a mere technicality. The Division Bench of the High
Court compounded the error by affirming the dismissal without
engaging with the principal challenge or the intervening
material. The approach of both the Courts, in reducing the
dispute to a mechanical enquiry about “rules” and “vacancy”
while ignoring the core question of arbitrariness in the State’s
refusal to sanction posts despite perennial need and long
service, cannot be sustained.
15. Therefore, in view of the foregoing observations, the
impugned order of the High Court cannot be sustained. The
State’s refusals dated 11.11.1999 and 25.11.2003,in so far as
they concern the Commission’s proposals for sanction/creation
of Class-III/Class-IV posts to address perennial
ministerial/attendant work, are held unsustainable and stand
quashed.
xxx xxx xxx
17. Before concluding, we think it necessary to recall that the
State (here referring to both the Union and the State
governments) is not a mere market participant but a
constitutional employer. It cannot balance budgets on the
backs of those who perform the most basic and recurring
public functions. Where work recurs day after day and year
after year, the establishment must reflect that reality in its
sanctioned strength and engagement practices. The long-term
extraction of regular labour under temporary labels corrodes
confidence in public administration and offends the promise of
equal protection. Financial stringency certainly has a place in
public policy, but it is not a talisman that overrides fairness,
reason and the duty to organise work on lawful lines.
18.
Moreover, it must necessarily be noted that “ad-hocism”
thrives where administration is opaque. The State Departments
must keep and produce accurate establishment registers,
muster rolls and outsourcing arrangements, and they must
explain, with evidence, why they prefer precarious engagement
over sanctioned posts where the work is perennial. If
“constraint” is invoked, the record should show what
alternatives were considered, why similarly placed workers
were treated differently, and how the chosen course aligns with
Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Sensitivity
to the human consequences of prolonged insecurity is not
Page 8 of 22
// 9 //
sentimentality. It is an institutional discipline that should
inform every decision affecting those who keep public offices
running.
19. Having regard to the long, undisputed service of the
appellants, the admitted perennial nature of their duties, and
the material indicating vacancies and comparator
regularisations, we issue the following directions:
i. Regularization and creation of Supernumerary posts: All
appellants shall stand regularized with effect from 24.04.2002,
the date on which the High Court directed a fresh
recommendation by the Commission and a fresh decision by
the State on sanctioning posts for the appellants. For this
purpose, the State and the successor establishment (U.P.
Education Services Selection Commission) shall create
supernumerary posts in the corresponding cadres, Class-III
(Driver or equivalent) and Class-IV (Peon/Attendant/Guard or
equivalent) without any caveats or preconditions. On
regularization, each appellant shall be placed at not less than
the minimum of the regular pay-scale for the post, with
protection of last-drawn wages if higher and the appellants
shall be entitled to the subsequent increments in the pay scale
as per the pay grade. For seniority and promotion, service
shall count from the date of regularization as given above.
ii. Financial consequences and arrears: Each appellant shall
be paid as arrears the full difference between (a) the pay and
admissible allowances at the minimum of the regular pay-level
for the post from time to time, and (b) the amounts actually
paid, for the period from 24.04.2002 until the date of
regularization /retirement/death, as the case may be. Amounts
already paid under previous interim directions shall be so
adjusted. The net arrears shall be released within three months
and if in default, the unpaid amount shall carry compound
interest at 6% per annum from the date of default until
payment.
iii. Retired appellants: Any appellant who has already retired
shall be granted regularization with effect from 24.04.2002
until the date of superannuation for pay fixation, arrears under
clause (ii), and recalculation of pension, gratuity and other
terminal dues. The revised pension and terminal dues shall be
paid within three months of this Judgment.
iv. Deceased appellants: In the case of Appellant No. 5 and any
other appellant who has died during pendency, his/her legal
Page 9 of 22
// 10 //
representatives on record shall be paid the arrears under
clause (ii) up to the date of death, together with all
terminal/retiral dues recalculated consistently with clause (i),
within three months of this Judgement.
v. Compliance affidavit: The Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Government of Uttar Pradesh, or the
Secretary of the U.P. Education Services Selection Commission
or the prevalent competent authority, shall file an affidavit of
compliance before this Court within four months of this
Judgement.
20. We have framed these directions comprehensively because,
case after case, orders of this Court in such matters have been
met with fresh technicalities, rolling “reconsiderations,” and
administrative drift which further prolongs the insecurity for
those who have already laboured for years on daily wages.
Therefore, we have learned that Justice in such cases cannot
rest on simpliciter directions, but it demands imposition of
clear duties, fixed timelines, and verifiable compliance .As a
constitutional employer, the State is held to a higher standard
and therefore it must organise its perennial workers on a
sanctioned footing, create a budget for lawful engagement, and
implement judicial directions in letter and spirit. Delay to
follow these obligations is not mere negligence but rather it is
a conscious method of denial that erodes livelihoods and
dignity for these workers. The operative scheme we have set
here comprising of creation of supernumerary posts, full
regularization, subsequent financial benefits, and a sworn
affidavit of compliance, is therefore a pathway designed to
convert rights into outcomes and to reaffirm that fairness in
engagement and transparency in administration are not
matters of grace, but obligations under Articles 14, 16 and 21
of the Constitution of India.”
4.7. It is contended that in the recent decision of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Bhola Nath
so cited (supra), Hon’ble Apex Court
in Para-13.5 to 14 of the judgment has held as follows:-
“13.5. Such a decision must necessarily be a conscious and
reasoned one. An employee who has satisfactorily discharged
his duties over several years and has been granted repeated
extensions cannot, overnight, be treated as surplus or
Page 10 of 22
// 11 //
undesirable. We are unable to accept the justification
advanced by the respondents as the obligation of the State, as a
model employer, extends to fair treatment of its employees
irrespective of whether their engagement is contractual or
regular.
13.6. This Court has, on several occasions, deprecated the
practice adopted by States of engaging employees under the
nominal labels of “part-time”, “contractual” or “temporary”
in perpetuity and thereby exploiting them by not regularizing
their positions. In Jaggo v. Union of India , this Court
underscored that government departments must lead by
example in ensuring fair and stable employment, and evolved
the test of examining whether the duties performed by such
temporary employees are integral to the day-to-day functioning
of the organization.
13.7. In Shripal v. Nagar Nigam , and Vinod Kumar v. Union
of India , this Court cautioned against a mechanical and blind
reliance on Umadevi (supra) to deny regularization to
temporary employees in the absence of statutory rules. It was
held that Umadevi (supra) cannot be employed as a shield to
legitimise exploitative engagements continued for years
without undertaking regular recruitment. The Court further
clarified that Umadevi itself draws a distinction between
appointments that are “illegal” and those that are merely
“irregular”, the latter being amenable to regularization upon
fulfilment of the prescribed conditions.
13.8. In Dharam Singh v. State of U.P ., this Court strongly
deprecated the culture of “ad-hocism” adopted by States in
their capacity as employers. The Court criticised the practice
of outsourcing or informalizing recruitment as a means to
evade regular employment obligations, observing that such
measures perpetuate precarious working conditions while
circumventing fair and lawful engagement practices.
13.9. The State must remain conscious that part-time
employees, such as the appellants, constitute an integral part
of the edifice upon which the machinery of the State continues
to function. They are not merely ancillary to the system, but
form essential components thereof. The equality mandate of
our Constitution, therefore, requires that their service be
reciprocated in a manner free from arbitrariness, ensuring that
decisions of the State affecting the careers and livelihood of
such part-time and contractual employees are guided by
fairness and reason.
Page 11 of 22
// 12 //
13.10. In the aforesaid backdrop, we are unable to persuade
ourselves to accept the respondent-State’s contention that the
mere contractual nomenclature of the appellants’ engagement
denudes them of constitutional protection. The State, having
availed of the appellants’ services on sanctioned posts for over
a decade pursuant to a due process of selection and having
consistently acknowledged their satisfactory performance,
cannot, in the absence of cogent reasons or a speaking
decision, abruptly discontinue such engagement by taking
refuge behind formal contractual clauses. Such action is
manifestly arbitrary, inconsistent with the obligation of the
State to act as a model employer, and fails to withstand
scrutiny under Article 14 of the Constitution.
FINAL CONCLUSION:
14. In light of our discussion, in the foregoing paragraphs, we
summarize our conclusions as follows:
I. The respondent-State was not justified in continuing the
appellants on sanctioned vacant posts for over a decade under
the nomenclature of contractual engagement and thereafter
denying them consideration for regularization.
II. Abrupt discontinuance of such long-standing engagement
solely on the basis of contractual nomenclature, without either
recording cogent reasons or passing a speaking order, is
manifestly arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution.
III. Contractual stipulations purporting to bar claims for
regularization cannot override constitutional guarantees.
Acceptance of contractual terms does not amount to waiver of
fundamental rights, and contractual stipulations cannot
immunize arbitrary State action from constitutional scrutiny.
IV. The State, as a model employer, cannot rely on contractual
labels or mechanical application of Umadevi (supra) to justify
prolonged ad-hocism or to discard long-serving employees in a
manner inconsistent with fairness, dignity and constitutional
governance.
V. In view of the foregoing discussion, we direct the
respondent-State to forthwith regularize the services of all the
appellants against the sanctioned posts to which they were
initially appointed. The appellants shall be entitled to all
consequential service benefits accruing from the date of this
judgment.”
Page 12 of 22
// 13 //
4.8. Hon’ble Apex Court in Para 73 to 79 of the decision in the case of
Sukhendu Bhatacharjee has held as follows:-
73. As regards the contention of Shri Gupta that after the decision in
Umadevi (supra) no regularization can be effected in respect of
employees who were not appointed against duly sanctioned posts, we
are unable to accept such a sweeping proposition in the facts of the
present case. The submission proceeds on the premise that Umadevi
(supra) lays down an absolute and inflexible embargo against all
forms of regularization irrespective of the surrounding
circumstances. Such an interpretation, in our considered view, does
not reflect the true scope and ratio of the decision.
74. This Court in Jaggo (supra), deprecated the tendency of the State
to take mechanical shelter under Umadevi (supra) to deny relief to
employees who had been performing work of a permanent and
essential nature for long years. This Court observed as follows: -
“12. Despite being labelled as “part-time workers,” the
appellants performed these essential tasks on a daily and
continuous basis over extensive periods, ranging from over a
decade to nearly two decades. Their engagement was not
sporadic or temporary in nature; instead, it was recurrent,
regular, and akin to the responsibilities typically associated
with sanctioned posts. Moreover, the respondents did not
engage any other personnel for these tasks during the
appellants' tenure, underscoring the indispensable nature of
their work.
13. The claim by the respondents that these were not regular
posts lacks merit, as the nature of the work performed by the
appellants was perennial and fundamental to the functioning of
the offices. The recurring nature of these duties necessitates
their classification as regular posts, irrespective of how their
initial engagements were labelled. It is also noteworthy that
subsequent outsourcing of these same tasks to private agencies
after the appellants' termination demonstrates the inherent
need for these services. This act of outsourcing, which
effectively replaced one set of workers with another, further
underscores that the work in question was neither temporary
nor occasional.
Page 13 of 22
// 14 //
19. It is evident from the foregoing that the appellants' roles
were not only essential but also indistinguishable from those of
regular employees. Their sustained contributions over
extended periods, coupled with absence of any adverse record,
warrant equitable treatment and regularization of their
services. Denial of this benefit, followed by their arbitrary
termination, amounts to manifest injustice and must be
rectified.
20. It is well established that the decision in Uma Devi (supra)
does not intend to penalize employees who have rendered long
years of service fulfilling ongoing and necessary functions of
the State or its instrumentalities. The said judgment sought to
prevent backdoor entries and illegal appointments that
circumvent constitutional requirements. However, where
appointments were not illegal but possibly “irregular,” and
where employees had served continuously against the
backdrop of sanctioned functions for a considerable period, the
need for a fair and humane resolution becomes paramount.
Prolonged, continuous, and unblemished service performing
tasks inherently required on a regular basis can, over the time,
transform what was initially ad-hoc or temporary into a
scenario demanding fair regularization. In a recent judgment
of this Court in Vinod Kumar v. Union of India, it was held that
held that procedural formalities cannot be used to deny
regularization of service to an employee whose appointment
was termed “temporary” but has performed the same duties as
performed by the regular employee over a considerable period
in the capacity of the regular employee.
22. The pervasive misuse of temporary employment contracts,
as exemplified in this case, reflects a broader systemic issue
that adversely affects workers' rights and job security. In the
private sector, the rise of the gig economy has led to an
increase in precarious employment arrangements, often
characterized by lack of benefits, job security, and fair
treatment. Such practices have been criticized for exploiting
workers and undermining labour standards. Government
institutions, entrusted with upholding the principles of fairness
and justice, bear an even greater responsibility to avoid such
exploitative employment practices. When public sector entities
engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it not only mirrors
Page 14 of 22
// 15 //
the detrimental trends observed in the gig economy but also
sets a concerning precedent that can erode public trust in
governmental operations.
25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary employees,
particularly in government institutions, often face multifaceted
forms of exploitation. While the foundational purpose of
temporary contracts may have been to address short-term or
seasonal needs, they have increasingly become a mechanism to
evade long-term obligations owed to employees. These
practices manifest in several ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary” Labels: Employees engaged for work
that is essential, recurring, and integral to the functioning of
an institution are often labeled as “temporary” or
“contractual,” even when their roles mirror those of regular
employees. Such misclassification deprives workers of the
dignity, security, and benefits that regular employees are
entitled to, despite performing identical tasks.
• Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees are frequently
dismissed without cause or notice, as seen in the present case.
This practice undermines the principles of natural justice and
subjects workers to a state of constant insecurity, regardless of
the quality or duration of their service.
• Lack of Career Progression: Temporary employees often find
themselves excluded from opportunities for skill development,
promotions, or incremental pay raises. They remain stagnant
in their roles, creating a systemic disparity between them and
their regular counterparts, despite their contributions being
equally significant.
• Using Outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions increasingly
resort to outsourcing roles performed by temporary employees,
effectively replacing one set of exploited workers with another.
This practice not only perpetuates exploitation but also
demonstrates a deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to
offer regular employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits: Temporary employees
are often denied fundamental benefits such as pension,
provident fund, health insurance, and paid leave, even when
Page 15 of 22
// 16 //
their tenure spans decades. This lack of social security subjects
them and their families to undue hardship, especially in cases
of illness, retirement, or unforeseen circumstances.
26. While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) sought to curtail
the practice of backdoor entries and ensure appointments
adhered to constitutional principles, it is regrettable that its
principles are often misinterpreted or misapplied to deny
legitimate claims of long-serving employees. This judgment
aimed to distinguish between “illegal” and “irregular”
appointments. It categorically held that employees in irregular
appointments, who were engaged in duly sanctioned posts and
had served continuously for more than ten years, should be
considered for regularization as a onetime measure. However,
the laudable intent of the judgment is being subverted when
institutions rely on its dicta to indiscriminately reject the
claims of employees, even in cases where their appointments
are not illegal, but merely lack adherence to procedural
formalities. Government departments often cite the judgment in
Uma Devi (supra) to argue that no vested right to
regularization exists for temporary employees, overlooking the
judgment's explicit acknowledgment of cases where
regularization is appropriate. This selective application
distorts the judgment's spirit and purpose, effectively
weaponizing it against employees who have rendered
indispensable services over decades.
27. In light of these considerations, in our opinion, it is
imperative for government departments to lead by example in
providing fair and stable employment. Engaging workers on a
temporary basis for extended periods, especially when their
roles are integral to the organization's functioning, not only
contravenes international labour standards but also exposes
the organization to legal challenges and undermines employee
morale. By ensuring fair employment practices, government
institutions can reduce the burden of unnecessary litigation,
promote job security, and uphold theprinciples of justice and
fairness that they are meant to embody. This approach aligns
with international standards and sets a positive precedent for
the private sector to follow, thereby contributing to the overall
betterment of labour practices in the country.”
Page 16 of 22
// 17 //
75. Recently, this Court in Bhola Nath (supra) while relying on the
judgment of Jaggo (supra), Shripal (supra), and Dharam Singh
(supra) observed as follows:-
“13.6. This Court has, on several occasions, deprecated the
practice adopted by States of engaging employees under the
nominal labels of “part-time”, “contractual” or “temporary”
in perpetuity and thereby exploiting them by not regularizing
their positions. In Jaggo v. Union of India, this Court
underscored that government departments must lead by
example in ensuring fair and stable employment, and evolved
the test of examining whether the duties performed by such
temporary employees are integral to the day-to-day functioning
of the organization.
13.7 In Shripal v. Nagar Nigam, and Vinod Kumar v. Union of
India, this Court cautioned against a mechanical and blind
reliance on Umadevi (supra) to deny regularization to
temporary employees in the absence of statutory rules. It was
held that Umadevi (supra) cannot be employed as a shield to
legitimise exploitative engagements continued for years
without undertaking regular recruitment. The Court further
clarified that Umadevi itself draws adistinction between
appointments that are “illegal” and those that are merely
“irregular”, the latter being amenable to regularization upon
fulfilment of the prescribed conditions.
13.8. In Dharam Singh v. State of U.P., this Court strongly
deprecated the culture of “adhocism” adopted by States in
their capacity as employers. The Court criticised the practice
of outsourcing or informalizing recruitment as a means to
evade regular employment obligations, observing that such
measures perpetuate precarious working conditions while
circumventing fair and lawful engagement practices.
13.9. The State must remain conscious that part-time
employees, such as the appellants, constitute an integral part
of the edifice upon which the machinery of the State continues
to function. They are not merely ancillary to the system, but
form essential components thereof. The equality mandate of
our Constitution, therefore, requires that their service be
reciprocated in a manner free from arbitrariness, ensuring that
Page 17 of 22
// 18 //
decisions of the State affecting the careers and livelihood of
such part-time and contractual employees are guided by
fairness and reason.”
76. What emerges from the principles enunciated in the aforesaid
decisions is that the State cannot rely upon the mere form of
engagement to deny fair and equitable treatment to employees who
have served it for long years. The consistent thread running through
these judgments is that Umadevi (supra) cannot be invoked as a
blanket barrier to justify prolonged and continued engagements of a
temporary or ad hoc nature, especially where the employees have
been discharging essential and recurring functions of the State. The
Court has repeatedly emphasised that the distinction between
“illegal” and “irregular” appointments must be kept in view, that
long and continuous service is a relevant consideration, and that the
State, as a model employer, is under a constitutional obligation to
act with fairness, consistency and reasonableness. The practice of
retaining employees for decades under deceptively titled
designations, while simultaneously extracting regular work integral
to the administration, has been disapproved consistently.
77. Applying these principles to the present case, it is evident that
engaging workers on muster rolls was a consistently employed policy
of the State which continued for prolonged period of time. The
appellants were not engaged for sporadic or seasonal purposes but
were taken on muster rolls and have rendered continuous service for
decades in departments performing regular governmental functions.
The State itself acknowledged the magnitude of the issue and framed
a Cabinet policy to regularize similarly situated workers, acting
upon it in respect of nearly 30,000 employees. In such circumstances,
to deny consideration to the fraction of remaining eligible workers
including the appellants, by taking shelter under a rigid reading of
Umadevi (supra) would defeat the very principles of fairness and
non-arbitrariness that this Court has consistently upheld.
78. In the aforesaid backdrop, we are unable to accept the contention
of the State that the appellants cannot be granted regularization on
the ground that they were not initially appointed against duly
sanctioned posts. The State, having engaged the appellants prior to
1st April, 1993, utilised their services continuously for decades, and
having itself framed and implemented a Cabinet policy regularizing
nearly 30,000 similarly situated workers, cannot now exclude the
Page 18 of 22
// 19 //
appellants by taking shelter behind a rigid or technical reading of
Umadevi (supra). In absence of any cogent distinction or reasoned
decision justifying such exclusion, the action of the State is
manifestly arbitrary. It is inconsistent with its obligation to function
as a model employer and does not withstand scrutiny under Article
14 of the Constitution.
79. In view of the discussion made hereinabove, the impugned
judgment dated 8th June, 2017 passed by the Division Bench cannot
be sustained and is set aside and the judgment of the learned Single
Judge dated 20th December, 2013 is affirmed. Consequently, we
pass the following directions:-
I. The appellants shall be treated as regularised in service in
terms of the Cabinet decision dated 22nd July, 2005 and from
the date on which similarly placed 30,000 employees were
given benefit of the said Cabinet decision.
II. The State of Assam shall identify and verify the eligible
appellants and, where necessary, create supernumerary posts
to facilitate their regularization.
III. Upon regularization, the appellants shall be entitled to all
consequential benefits, including fixation of pay in the regular
scale, continuity of service, and all applicable pensionary and
post retiral benefits in the same terms, as were extended to
similarly situated 30,000 employees.
IV. In case of retired appellants, they shall be granted notional
regularization with consequential monetary benefits and
arrears from the relevant date until their superannuation for
the purpose of recalculating pension, gratuity, and terminal
dues.
V. In case of deceased appellants, arrears and other benefits
shall be released to their legal heirs in accordance with law.
VI. The entire exercise, including the calculation and payment
of all financial arrears, shall be completed within a period of
one year from the date of this judgment.
VII. We make it clear that the benefit of the above directions
shall only be applicable to the appellants who were working in
Page 19 of 22
// 20 //
the departments of the State before the cut-off date prescribed
in Cabinet decision dated 22nd July, 2005 i.e. before 1st April,
1993.”
5. Learned Addl. Standing Counsel on the other hand while supporting
the impugned rejection contended that since Petitioners were never
appointed by facing any recruitment process and reservation principle
has not been followed, such claim of the Petitioners was rejected by
Opp. Party No. 4 pursuant to the order passed by the Tribunal in O.A.
No. 194(C) of 2019. It is accordingly contended that since Petitioners’
very engagement is wrong and illegal, they are not covered by the
decision in the case of Uma Devi so followed in the case of M.L.
Keshari . It is accordingly contended that no illegality or irregularity can
be found with the impugned order as following the direction of the
Tribunal, Petitioners were found not covered by the decision in the case
of M.L. Keshari . Not only that, since Petitioners have already retired in
the meantime, they are not eligible to get the benefit of regularization.
6. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties and
considering the submissions made, this Court finds that all the
Petitioners were before the Tribunal in O.A. No.194(C) of 2019 claiming
the benefit of regularization. As found, the said Original Application was
disposed of vide order dtd.22.01.2019 with a direction on the Director,
Page 20 of 22
// 21 //
Family Welfare to take a decision on the Petitioners’ claim, taking into
account the decision in the case of Uma Devi as well as M.L. Keshari so
cited (supra).
6.1. As found, the impugned order has been passed by Opp. Party No. 4-
CDMO, Jajpur, even though the direction was to the Director, Family
Welfare-Opp. Party No. 2 to take a decision on the Petitioner’s claim.
6.2. Since the direction contained in order dtd.22.01.2019 has not been
undertaken by the Director, Family Welfare and claim of the Petitioners
was rejected by the CDMO, Jajpur-Opp. Party No. 4, on that ground
only, this Court is inclined to quash order dtd.11.07.2019 so passed by
Opp. Party No. 4. While quashing the said order, this Court directs Opp.
Party No. 1 to take a fresh decision on the Petitioners’ claim to get the
benefit of regularization by taking them to have retired as regular
employee with their coverage under OCS (Pension) Rules, 1992, taking
into account the judgment delivered by the Apex Court in the meantime
in the case of Jaggo, Shripal and Dharam Singh, Bhola Nath and the
decision in the case of Sukhendu Bhatacharjee so cited (supra) within a
period of three (3) months from the date of receipt of the order, with due
communication.
Page 21 of 22
// 22 //
6.3. Petitioners are permitted to provide a copy of this order along with
the aforesaid decisions so cited (supra) and so also the benefit extended
pursuant to the order passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No. 1385(C) of
2019 and O.A. No. 1247(C) of 2001 before Opp. Party No. 1 for
compliance.
7. All the writ petitions accordingly stand disposed of.
Photo copy of the order be placed in the connected case records.
(BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
th
Dated the 12 November, 2026/Sneha
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SNEHANJALI PARIDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 17-Nov-2026 10:59:23
Page 22 of 22