MINOR.S.ABIRUTH vs R.PRAVEEN
- Court
- Madras High Court
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved on 15.09.2026
Pronounced 20.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE K.K. RAMAKRISHNAN
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
CNR:{HCMD010862282019}
Minor.S.Abiruth
S/o.Sekar
(Represented by his mother /
Natural Guardian Ezhilarasi)
..Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. R.Praveen
S/o.Rajendran
2. Cholamandalam M.S.General Insurance Company limited,
Through its Branch Manager,
Madurai Town,
Madurai.
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER: This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed under section 173 of
Motor Vehicles Act to enhance the compensation made on the judgement
and decree dated 22.07.2019 in M.C.O.P.No.68 of 2017 on the file of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/ Chief Judicial Magistrate court at
Sivagangai District.
For Appellant (s) : Mr.A.R.Kannappan
For Respondent(s) : Mr.N.Shyllappa Kalyan for R2
: R1 – No Appearance
__________
Page 1 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
JUDGMENT
The guardian of the minor injured claimant has filed the present C.M.A.
(MD).No.1025 of 2023 seeking enhancement of the compensation awarded in
M.C.O.P. No. 68 of 2017, on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-
Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sivagangai, by judgment and award dated 22.07.2019.
2.Facts of the case:
2.1. According to the claim petition, on 17.09.2016, at about 12.00 noon, the
minor claimant, aged about three years, was accompanying his family members on
the Madurai–Rameswaram National Highways Road. While he was standing on
the left side of the road near the Silaiman East Bus Stop, waiting to board a bus,
the offending vehicle bearing Registration No. TN-64-D-8644 was driven by its
driver in a rash and negligent manner and hit him.
2.2. In the accident, the minor sustained a crush injury to his right ankle,
resulting in extensive tissue loss, apart from a grievous injury to his forehead and
abrasions all over his body. He was immediately admitted to Vellammal Hospital,
Madurai, where he underwent treatment from 17.09.2016 to 16.10.2016. He
subsequently continued to receive medical treatment, both as an inpatient and as an
outpatient. Contending that the accident had caused serious and permanent
__________
Page 2 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
impairment to the minor's right lower limb, his mother, as guardian, filed the claim
petition seeking compensation of Rs.10,00,000/- with interest.
2.3. The Insurance Company filed its counter denying the manner of the
accident and disputing the quantum of compensation claimed. It also raised a
defence concerning the validity of the driver's licence and its liability to indemnify
the insured.
2.4. Before the Tribunal, the mother of the minor claimant was examined as a
witness and Exs.P1 to P12 were marked. The disability certificate issued by the
Government Medical Board, Sivagangai, was marked as Ex.C1.
3.Findings of the Tribunal:
3.1.Upon consideration of the oral and documentary evidence, the Tribunal
awarded compensation of Rs.3,78,448/- with interest at 7.5% per annum.
Heads Amounts in Rs.
Sl.
No.
1 Transport Charges 10,500/-
2 Attender Charges 7,500/-
3 Extra Nutrition 5,000/-
4 Pain and suffering 25,000/-
5 Medical Bills 1,84,948/-
6 Loss of School fees 25,500/-
7 40% Disability (1% disability Rs.3000/-) 1,20,000/-
Total Compensation Awarded Rs.3,78,448/-
__________
Page 3 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
3.2. Not being satisfied with the quantum of compensation awarded,
the minor claimant, represented by his guardian, has preferred the present
appeal seeking enhancement.
4. Submissions of the Learned Counsel appearing for the appellant
/ Claimant:
4.1. The learned counsel for the claimant submitted that the minor
was only three years old at the time of the accident and sustained a severe
crush injury to his right ankle. The photographs produced before this Court
demonstrate the seriousness of the bodily injuries sustained and the resultant
deformity of the affected limb.
4.2. It was contended that the Tribunal failed to appreciate the lifelong
consequences of the injury upon a child of such tender age. The impairment
of the right lower limb would affect not only his mobility but also his
childhood charm, physical development, social participation and future
prospects. The claimant would have to grow up with a permanent physical
impairment and face the difficulties associated with it throughout his life.
4.3. The learned counsel further submitted that the Tribunal awarded
only Rs.1,20,000/- towards permanent disability, despite the assessment of
disability at 40%. It was contended that the amount awarded was
__________
Page 4 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
inadequate, considering the severity of the crush injury and its
consequences. The Tribunal also failed to award any amount towards future
medical expenses and awarded only Rs.25,000/- towards pain and suffering.
4.4. The learned counsel relied upon a judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court reported in 2025 SCC OnLine 3446 , contending that the
principles laid down therein concerning the assessment of compensation for
children who sustain permanent injuries were applicable to the present case.
It was submitted that the multiplier method should be adopted to assess the
loss of future earning capacity, with an appropriate assessment of notional
income and future prospects. Accordingly, enhancement was sought under
all the relevant heads.
5. Submissions of the Learned Counsel appearing for the
Insurance Company:
5.1. Per contra, the learned counsel for the Insurance Company
submitted that the Tribunal had already awarded reasonable compensation
and that no grounds had been made out for further enhancement. It was
contended that the principles relied upon by the claimant were not
applicable to the facts of the present case and that the compensation
awarded by the Tribunal was adequate.
__________
Page 5 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
5.2. The learned counsel, therefore, sought dismissal of the appeal.
6. This Court considered the rival submissions and perused the
records.
7. Point for Determination:
7.1. Whether the minor injured claimant is entitled to enhancement of
compensation, having regard to the nature of the crush injury sustained by
him, the permanent impairment of his right lower limb and the lifelong
consequences of the injury?
8. Discussion and Findings:
8.1. The medical evidence, particularly the wound certificate marked
as Ex.P5, indicates that the minor sustained a crush injury to his right ankle.
The photographs produced before this Court further demonstrate the
seriousness of the injury and the resultant deformity of the affected limb.
8.2. The claimant was only three years old at the time of the accident.
An injury sustained at such a tender age cannot be assessed merely by
reference to the immediate medical consequences or the percentage of
physical disability. The Court must also consider the continuing effect of the
injury upon the child's growth, mobility, education, participation in ordinary
childhood activities and future prospects.
__________
Page 6 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
8.3. The photographs reveal the unfortunate consequences of the crush
injury to the right lower limb. The resulting impairment cannot be treated as
a mere numerical percentage detached from the actual condition of the child.
The medical disability must be considered alongside its functional
consequences and the difficulties that the child will encounter throughout
his life.
8.4. A child who sustains permanent physical impairment at a tender
age is deprived, to some extent, of the freedom and charm ordinarily
enjoyed by children of the same age. The injury may affect participation in
games, recreational activities, social interaction and other ordinary pursuits
of childhood. The consequences may continue during his adulthood and
affect the child's independence and quality of life.
8.5. In assessing compensation, the Tribunal is required to adopt a
humane and purposive and pragmatic approach consistent with the principle
of just compensation under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The
award must be neither a windfall nor a pittance. It must reasonably
compensate the injured child for the consequences of the injury, including
those that may manifest over the course of his lifetime.
8.6. As per the principles laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine 3446 , governing compensation for children
who sustain permanent injuries require the Court to consider the nature of
__________
Page 7 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
the injury, the degree of disability, its functional consequences and the long-
term impact upon the child's life.
9. Loss of Future Earning Capacity:
9.1. The Tribunal assessed the permanent disability at 40% and
awarded Rs.1,20,000/- under the relevant head. Having regard to the age of
the claimant and the permanent impairment of his right lower limb, the
assessment requires reconsideration.
9.2. A child of three years cannot reasonably be expected to establish
his future occupation or actual earning capacity. The absence of evidence
regarding a specific future profession cannot operate to the child's
disadvantage. The Court must adopt a reasonable basis for assessing the
future economic consequences of the disability. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court, in Hitesh Nagjibhai Patel v. Bababhai Nagjibhai Rabari and
Another , reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 3466 , laid down in the said case
while assessing in the case of child enter sustained injury or dies and
relevant para 15. Following the said guideline this Court, for the purpose of
quantifying future loss of earning capacity, this Court considers a notional
monthly income of Rs.6,000/-. In view of the claimant's age, an addition of
40% towards future prospects is applied. Accordingly, the notional monthly
income after the addition of future prospects works out to Rs.8,400/-.
__________
Page 8 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
9.3. Having regard to the evidence concerning the impairment of the
right lower limb, this Court assesses the functional loss of future earning
capacity at 30%, subject to the medical and functional findings supported by
the record.
9.4. Accordingly, the compensation towards loss of future earning
capacity is calculated as follows:
Rs.8,400 × 12 × 15 × 30/100 = Rs.4,53,600/-.
10. Compensation towards permanent disability:
10.1. The disability certificate issued by the Government Medical
Board, Sivagangai marked as Ex.C1, assessed the claimant's disability at
40%. The Tribunal awarded only Rs.1,20,000/- towards permanent
disability.
10.2. Having regard to the claimant's tender age, the nature of the
crush injury, the resultant deformity and the permanent impairment of the
right lower limb, and date of accident the amount awarded by the Tribunal is
inadequate.
10.3. This Court considers it appropriate to assess compensation for
permanent disability at the rate of Rs.6,000/- per percentage of disability.
Accordingly, the compensation under this head is calculated as follows:
Rs.6,000 × 40 = Rs.2,40,000/-.
__________
Page 9 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
10.4. After giving credit to the amount already awarded by the
Tribunal under this head, the enhancement works out to Rs.1,20,000/-.
10.5. The assessment of permanent physical disability and the assessment of
loss of future earning capacity serve distinct purposes. The former
compensates for the permanent physical impairment, while the latter
addresses the economic consequences of the disability.
10.5. This assessment is distinct from the compensation awarded
towards permanent physical disability, provided that the two heads
compensate different consequences as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
in the case of K. Suresh v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. , reported in
(2012) 12 SCC 274 which reads as follows:
20. In Ramesh Chandra reported in (1990) 3 SCC 723, the learned Judges
proceeded to address the issue of difficulty or incapacity to earn and how
it stands on a different footing than pain and suffering affecting enjoyment
of life and stated as under: (Ramesh Chandra case reported in (1990) 3
SCC 723
“ 7. … the inability to earn livelihood on the basis of
incapacity or disability which is quite different. The
incapacity or disability to earn a livelihood would have
to be viewed not only in praesenti but in futuro on
reasonable expectancies and taking into account deprival
of earnings of a conceivable period. This head being
totally different cannot in our view overlap the grant of
__________
Page 10 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
compensation under the head of pain, suffering and loss
of enjoyment of life. One head relates to the impairment
of person's capacity to earn, the other relates to the pain
and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life by the person
himself.” (B. Kothandapani case reported in (1990) 3
SCC 723, SCC p. 424, para 14)
After referring to the said passage, the Bench in B. Kothandapani
case reported (2011) 6 SCC 420, SCC p. 424 , para 15 proceeded to
state that it is true that the compensation for loss of earning
power/capacity has to be determined based on various aspects
including permanent injury/disability, but at the same time, it cannot
be construed that that compensation cannot be granted for permanent
disability of any nature. It has been mentioned by way of an example
that in a
“ case of a non-earning member of a family who has been
injured in an accident and sustained permanent disability
due to amputation of leg or hand, it cannot be construed
that no amount needs to be granted for permanent
disability. It cannot be disputed that apart from the fact
that the permanent disability affects the earning capacity
of the person concerned, undoubtedly, one has to forego
other personal comforts and even for normal avocation
they have to depend on others.”
21. In view of the aforesaid enunciation of law, the view of
__________
Page 11 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
the High Court that no compensation can be granted towards
permanent disability once compensation is computed for the loss
of earning capacity and loss of future earnings is unsustainable.
As is perceivable, the High Court has computed the loss of
earning power at Rs 4,68,000 instead of Rs 5,00,000 as
determined by the Tribunal and deleted sum of Rs 3,00,000 that
was awarded by the Tribunal towards permanent disability. In our
considered opinion, total deletion is absolutely unjustified and, in
fact, runs counter to the principles laid down by this Court in
Ramesh Chandra case reported in (1990) 3 SCC 723.
11. Pain and Suffering:
11.1. The Tribunal awarded only Rs.25,000/- towards pain and
suffering. Considering the severe crush injury, the prolonged treatment, the
nature of the medical intervention and the suffering endured by a child of
three years, the amount awarded is inadequate.
11.2. The injury was not a transient one. It involved substantial
damage to the right ankle and has left the child with a permanent
impairment. The pain and distress associated with the accident and
subsequent treatment must be assessed in the context of the claimant's
tender age.
11.3. Accordingly, this Court enhances the total compensation towards
pain and suffering to Rs.50,000/-, inclusive of the amount already awarded
under this head.
__________
Page 12 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
12. Future Medical Expenses:
12.1. The Tribunal did not award any amount towards future medical
expenses. Having regard to the nature of the crush injury and the permanent
impairment of the right lower limb, the possibility of future medical
consultations, treatment and corrective procedures requires consideration.
12.2. Subject to the medical evidence and the reasonable necessity of
future treatment, this Court awards a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- towards future
medical expenses.
13. Conclusion:
13.1. On a cumulative consideration of the oral and documentary
evidence, the medical records, the disability certificate and the photographs,
this Court finds that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal does not
adequately reflect the consequences of the injury sustained by the minor
claimant.
13.2. The compensation requires enhancement towards loss of future
earning capacity, permanent disability, pain and suffering and future
medical expenses. The amounts awarded under the remaining heads shall be
retained unless a specific deficiency is established.
__________
Page 13 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
S.
No
Heads Amount
awarded by
the Tribunal
(Rs.)
Re-quantified
amount by
this Court
(Rs.)
Status
1 Transport Charges 10,500/- 10,500/- Confirmed
2 Attender Charges 7,500/- 7,500/- Confirmed
3 Extra Nutrition 5,000/- 5,000/- Confirmed
4 Pain and suffering 25,000/- 50,000/- Enhanced
5 Medical Bills 1,84,948/- 1,84,948/- Confirmed
6 Loss of School fees 25,500/- 25,500/- Confirmed
7 Permanent Disability 1,20,000/- 2,40,000/- Enhanced
8 Loss of Income ---- 4,53,600/- Awarded
9 Future Medical
Expenses
---- 1,00,000/- Awarded
Total Compensation
3,78,448/- 10,77,048/- Enhanced
Awarded
14.Result:
14.1.In the result, this C.M.A.(MD).No.1025 of 2023 is partly
allowed.
14.2. The award dated 22.07.2019 in M.C.O.P.No.68 of 2017 on the
file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Chief Judicial Magistrate Court,
Sivagangai is modified and the compensation is enhanced from
Rs.3,78,448/- to Rs.10,77,048/- , together with interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum from the date of the claim petition.
14.3. The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the enhanced
compensation of Rs.10,77,048/- , together with interest at 7.5% per annum
__________
Page 14 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
from the date of filing of the claim petition, within eight weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of this judgment, after giving credit to the amounts
already deposited.
14.4.On such deposit, the guardian of the minor claimant is entitled to
withdraw the amount in accordance with law, subject to the condition that
the minor’s interest would be protected.
No order as to costs.
20-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
aas
To:
1.The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
The Chief Judicial Magistrate Court,
Sivagangai.
2.The Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, Madurai.
__________
Page 15 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
K.K.RAMAKRISHNAN, J.
aas
CMA(MD) No. 1025 of 2023
20-11-2026
__________
Page 16 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:49:22 pm )