Manoj Kumar Paswan vs State Of U.P. And 5 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 7460 of 2025
Manoj Kumar Paswan
…..Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 5 others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Babu Lal Ram
Counsel for Respondent(s) : G.A.
Court No. - 91 AFR
Reserved On 30.10.2026
Delivered On 17.11.2026
HON'BLE SANTOSH RAI, J.
1. Heard Sri Gyanendra Kumar, Advocate, holding brief of Sri
Babu Lal Ram, learned counsel for the appellant and Sri R.K. Shukla,
learned AGA for the State and perused the material on record.
2. The present appeal has been preferred by the appellant Manoj
Kumar Paswan, son of Munna Pasi, resident of 83/116, Chhoti Juhi,
Parm Purwa, Police Station Juhi, District Kanpur Nagar, challenging
the order dated 9.7.2025 passed by the learned Special Judge
(Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities)
Act), Kanpur Nagar, in Criminal Miscellaneous Case No.547 of
2025, whereby the application moved by the appellant under Section

2
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
173(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (hereinafter
referred to as 'BNSS') was directed to be registered as a complaint
case and the matter was fixed for recording the statement of the
complainant under Section 223 BNSS.
3. The appellant, in his application under Section 173(4) BNSS
dated 9.7.2025, alleged that a false criminal case under Sections 126,
135 BNSS had been registered against him at Police Station Govind
Nagar, Kanpur Nagar, on 24.2.2025, at the instance of the police
personnel arrayed as opposite parties in the application. According to
the appellant, the actual incident had occurred on 10.2.2025, when
his wife, Rita, was filling water outside her house at about 10:00 a.m.
At that time, one Shiv Kumar alias Bhediya, who was residing in the
neighbourhood, was allegedly taking obscene photographs and
singing songs. When the appellant's wife objected to his conduct, he
tried to pull her towards himself. On her raising an alarm, her mother-
in-law Rajkumari and other women came there. The appellant's wife
immediately informed the police through dial 112 and also lodged a
complaint on the Chief Minister's portal. She further approached
Police Outpost Parm Purwa, where Shiv Kumar was allegedly
detained for a few hours and thereafter released.
4. It was further alleged that, after the aforesaid incident, Shiv
Kumar, in collusion with other women and relatives, namely Jaydevi
and others, assaulted them and caused injuries. In this regard, the

3
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
appellant's wife submitted a written complaint, which was sent by
registered post on 14.2.2025 to the concerned police authorities.
However, according to the appellant, no effective action was taken
on her complaint and the local police personnel were acting in
collusion with Shiv Kumar.
5. The appellant further alleged that on 24.2.2025, at about 1:30
p.m., the opposite parties, namely the police personnel posted at
Police Outpost Parm Purwa, came to his house and directed him to
accompany them to the police station. When the appellant questioned
the reason for taking him to the police station, the police personnel
allegedly abused him by referring to his caste and made objectionable
remarks that, being a person belonging to a lower caste, he was
questioning the action of the police. When one of his relatives also
objected to the action of the police, he too was threatened. Thereafter,
the appellant was taken to the police outpost, where the police
personnel, particularly the In-charge of the outpost, allegedly
started assaulting him.
6. It was further alleged that the police personnel also assaulted
his relative Vijay Bahadur by using caste-indicative words and gave
him beatings. The appellant was allegedly assaulted with plastic
sticks on the soles of his feet and other parts of his body by
approximately 25-30 blows. According to the appellant, when a
crowd started gathering at the police outpost, the police personnel, in

4
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
order to conceal their illegal acts, created a false incident outside the
police outpost by showing a quarrel between the appellant and Shiv
Kumar. Thereafter, photographs were allegedly taken and the
appellant was sent for medical examination. The appellant further
alleged that a false medical report was prepared, in which his internal
injuries were not properly recorded. He claimed that he possessed
material showing that he had been taken from his house and illegally
detained at the police outpost. The appellant also stated that his wife
had submitted a complaint dated 14.2.2025 along with the registered
postal receipt. She had further sent a complaint to the Police
Commissioner, Kanpur Nagar, through registered post on 25.2.2025
and had also approached dial 112 and the Chief Minister's portal.
Similarly, the appellant's father had submitted a complaint before the
Public Grievance Redressal Cell (Jan Sunwai) on 24.2.2025, while
the appellant himself had submitted a complaint to the Deputy
Commissioner of Police, Saket Nagar, on 25.2.2025. However,
according to the appellant, no action was taken by the higher police
authorities on the aforesaid complaints. It was also mentioned that,
according to the police report obtained from the concerned police
station, no criminal case had been registered on the basis of his
allegations. The police version was that a quarrel had taken place
between the appellant and Shiv Kumar and that the police had taken
action under Sections 170, 126 and 135 BNSS.

5
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
7. The learned Special Judge, after hearing the learned counsel
for the appellant and examining the material available on record,
observed that the allegations made by the appellant related to an
incident of assault and caste-based abuses allegedly committed by
the police personnel. However, no injury report of any injured person
had been filed along with the application. The learned Special Judge
further referred to the judgment of this Court in Naresh Kumar
Balmiki v. State of Uttar Pradesh, Criminal Miscellaneous
Application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. No.14443 of 2022, decided on
17.10.2022, as well as the decision in Sukhwasi v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, reported in 2008 Cri LJ 472, and observed that, in view of
the principles laid down therein, the application under Section 173(4)
BNSS deserved to be registered as a complaint case rather than being
forwarded for registration of an FIR. Accordingly, by the impugned
order dated 9.7.2025, the learned Special Judge directed that the
application moved by the appellant under Section 173(4) BNSS be
registered as a complaint case and further directed that the statement
of the complainant be recorded under Section 223 BNSS on 3.9.2025.
8. In brief, the grounds of appeal are that the impugned judgment
and order dated 9.7.2025 passed by the learned Special Judge (SC/ST
Act), Kanpur Nagar, is partly illegal, unjustified and contrary to law,
as the learned court below ought to have allowed the application
moved by the appellant under Section 173(4) BNSS and directed the

6
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
concerned police authorities to register an FIR against opposite party
nos. 2 to 6, instead of treating the matter as a complaint case. It is
further submitted that opposite party nos. 2 to 6, who are police
personnel, allegedly assaulted and abused the appellant and
committed obscene acts with his wife, and the allegations disclose
cognizable offences requiring proper police investigation to bring the
true facts to light. The learned trial court has failed to properly
appreciate the allegations and documentary evidence placed on
record by the appellant and has passed the impugned order without
considering the material facts and circumstances of the case. Hence,
the impugned order is liable to be set aside.
9. It is pertinent to mention relevant provision of law in this
regard.
Section 173 B.N.S.S.: Information in cognizable cases-
“(1)……
(2)…..
(3)…….
(4) Any person aggrieved by a refusal on the part of an
officer in charge of a police station to record the
information referred to in sub-section (1), may send the
substance of such information, in writing and by post, to
the Superintendent of Police concerned who, if satisfied
that such information discloses the commission of a
cognizable offence, shall either investigate the case himself
or direct an investigation to be made by any police officer
subordinate to him, in the manner provided by this Sanhita,
and such officer shall have all the powers of an officer in
charge of the police station in relation to that offence failing

7
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
which such aggrieved person may make an application to
the Magistrate.”
10. Section 175(3) & 175(4) B.N.S.S. provides as under:-
“175. Police officer's power to investigate cognizable
case.-
(3) Any Magistrate empowered under section 210 may,
after considering the application supported by an
affidavit made under sub-section (4) of section 173, and
after making such inquiry as he thinks necessary and
submission made in this regard by the police officer, order
such an investigation as above-mentioned.
(4) Any Magistrate empowered under section 210, may,
upon receiving a complaint against a public servant arising
in course of the discharge of his official duties, order
investigation, subject to-
(a) receiving a report containing facts and circumstances
of the incident from the officer superior to him; and
(b) after consideration of the assertions made by the public
servant as to the situation that led to the incident so
alleged.”
11. The impugned order passed by the learned Special Judge,
SC/ST Act, also suffers from non-consideration of the mandatory
procedural requirements contemplated under Sections 175(3) and
175(4) of the BNSS. The learned Special Judge, while proceeding on
the application moved by the complainant, has not examined whether
the statutory conditions prescribed under the aforesaid provisions
were duly complied with. Section 175(3) of BNSS requires the
Magistrate to apply judicial mind to the application, supported by an
affidavit, and to consider the submissions made by the concerned
police officer before passing an order for investigation. Further,
where the allegations relate to a public servant and arise in the course

8
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
of discharge of official duties, the special procedure prescribed under
Section 175(4) of BNSS is required to be followed, including
obtaining the report of the superior officer and considering the
explanation of the public servant concerned regarding the
circumstances leading to the alleged incident. These provisions are
not empty formalities but are statutory safeguards intended to prevent
arbitrary or mechanically initiated criminal proceedings. The learned
Special Judge was, therefore, under a legal obligation to examine the
applicability and compliance of these provisions before proceeding
further. The failure to consider the aforesaid statutory safeguards
reflects non-application of judicial mind.
12. Section 223(1) & 223(2) B.N.S.S. provides as under:-
“223. Examination of complainant.
(1) A Magistrate having jurisdiction while taking
cognizance of an offence on complaint shall examine
upon oath the complainant and the witnesses present, if
any, and the substance of such examination shall be
reduced to writing and shall be signed by the complainant
and the witnesses, and also by the Magistrate:
Provided that no cognizance of an offence shall be taken by
the Magistrate without giving the accused an opportunity
of being heard:
Provided further that when the complaint is made in
writing, the Magistrate need not examine the complainant
and the witnesses-
(a) if a public servant acting or purporting to act in the
discharge of his official duties or a Court has made the
complaint; or
(b) if the Magistrate makes over the case for inquiry or trial
to another Magistrate under section 212:

9
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
Provided also that if the Magistrate makes over the case to
another Magistrate under section 212 after examining the
complainant and the witnesses, the latter Magistrate need
not re-examine them.
(2) A Magistrate shall not take cognizance on a complaint
against a public servant for any offence alleged to have
been committed in course of the discharge of his official
functions or duties unless-
(a) such public servant is given an opportunity to make
assertions as to the situation that led to the incident so
alleged; and
(b) a report containing facts and circumstances of the
incident from the officer superior to such public servant is
received.”
13. It is further evident from the impugned order that the learned
Special Judge, SC/ST Act, has failed to consider the mandatory
procedural requirements prescribed under the BNSS. Even assuming
that the learned Special Judge was inclined to treat the application
moved under Section 173(4) of BNSS as a complaint case, he was
legally bound to follow the procedure prescribed under the first
proviso to Section 223(1) and Section 223(2) of BNSS. In the present
case, opposite party nos.2 to 6 are admittedly police personnel and
public servants and they have initiated proceeding under Sections
170/126/135 of BNSS against the appellant. Therefore, before
proceeding with the complaint, the learned Special Judge was
required to ensure compliance with the special statutory safeguards
applicable to complaints against public servants, including affording
an opportunity of hearing to the public servant concerned in terms of
the first proviso to Section 223(1) and following the requirements of

10
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
Section 223(2) of BNSS. However, the order impugned does not
disclose that any such opportunity of hearing was afforded to the
concerned public servants or that the statutory requirements were
otherwise complied with. Thus, whether the application was to be
considered under Sections 175(3) and 175(4) BNSS as an application
seeking investigation or was to be treated as a complaint case, the
learned Special Judge was required to follow the procedure
prescribed by law. The court could not have bypassed these
mandatory safeguards by simply treating the application as a
complaint.
14. It is an admitted position emerging from the material available
on record that the police personnel concerned were performing their
official duty of maintaining law and order and, in that connection,
initiated preventive proceedings against the appellant Manoj Kumar
Paswan on 24.2.2025 under Sections 170, 126, 135 of the BNSS. It
is also not disputed that a confrontation had taken place between the
appellant and his neighbour Shiv Kumar on 10.2.2025. Thus, the
presence and intervention of the police personnel in connection with
the aforesaid dispute cannot, by itself, be treated as an act of
misconduct or an abuse of their official position. The initiation of
preventive proceedings, on the admitted facts, indicates that the
police had intervened in connection with an existing dispute with a
view to maintaining peace and public order. However, the legality of

11
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
the subsequent conduct of the police personnel and the specific
allegations of caste-based abuse and physical assault are matters
which are required to be examined independently on the basis of the
material placed on record.
15. It is further evident from the material placed on record that the
appellant has not submitted any reliable medical evidence in support
of his specific allegation, made in paragraph 5 of the application
under Section 173(4) BNSS, that he was assaulted by 25–30 blows
of danda or other hard and blunt objects by the police personnel. No
dependable medical document has been brought on record to
substantiate the nature and extent of the injuries allegedly sustained
by him in the aforesaid incident. In the absence of such supporting
material, the aforesaid allegation, particularly regarding the number
and manner of blows allegedly inflicted, remains uncorroborated.
Similarly, the apprehension expressed by the appellant in paragraph
6 of his application that the police personnel might falsely implicate
him in some serious criminal offence does not appear to be founded
upon any specific or reliable material available on record. Such an
apprehension, in the absence of supporting facts or circumstances,
appears to be based merely upon a hypothetical possibility rather than
any concrete and demonstrable threat. However, these circumstances
are relevant only for assessing the material placed in support of the

12
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
application and cannot, by themselves, be treated as conclusive proof
that no offence was committed.
16. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is
of the considered opinion that the learned Special Judge has not
properly appreciated the distinction between the facts of the present
case and the legal principles laid down in Sukhwasi v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, 2008 Cri LJ 472, and Naresh Kumar Balmiki v. State of
Uttar Pradesh, decided on 17.10.2022, which have been relied upon
in the impugned order. The aforesaid decisions cannot be treated as
laying down an inflexible rule that every application moved under
Section 173(4) BNSS must necessarily be registered as a complaint
case. The question whether such an application should be treated as
a complaint or dealt with in accordance with the procedure prescribed
under the BNSS has to be determined on the basis of the nature of
allegations, the material available on record and the statutory
provisions applicable to the facts of each case. In the present case,
the admitted confrontation between the appellant and his neighbour
Shiv Kumar, the preventive proceedings initiated by the police on
24.2.2025 under Sections 170, 126, 135 BNSS, and the absence of
reliable medical material supporting the specific allegation of
repeated blows by hard and blunt objects are relevant circumstances
which required due consideration by the learned Special Judge.
Therefore, mere reliance upon the aforesaid judgments,(much before

13
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
the BNSS came in to existence) without examining the factual and
mandatory statutory requirements governing the application, was not
sufficient to justify the course adopted by the learned Special Judge.
17. In Babu Venkatesh & Ors. Vs. State of Karnataka & Anr.
(2022) 5 SCC 639, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para 25 as
under:-
“25. This Court further held that, in an appropriate case,
the learned Magistrate would be well advised to verify the
truth and also verify the veracity of the allegations. The
Court has noted that, applications under Section
156(3)CrPC are filed in a routine manner without taking
any responsibility only to harass certain persons.”
18. In Om Prakash Ambadkar Vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
(2026) 2 SCC 622, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para 27, 32,
33 as under:-
“27. In fact, the Magistrate ought to direct investigation by
the police only where the assistance of the investigating
agency is necessary and the court feels that the cause of
justice is likely to suffer in the absence of investigation by
the police. The Magistrate is not expected to mechanically
direct investigation by the police without first examining
whether in the facts and circumstances of the case,
investigation by the State machinery is actually required or
not. If the allegations made in the complaint are simple,
where the court can straightaway proceed to conduct the
trial, the Magistrate is expected to record evidence and
proceed further in the matter, instead of passing the buck to
the police under Section 156(3)CrPC. Of course, if the
allegations made in the complaint require complex and
complicated investigation which cannot be undertaken
without active assistance and expertise of the State
machinery, it would only be appropriate for the Magistrate
to direct investigation by the police authorities. The
Magistrate is, therefore, not supposed to act merely as a post

14
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
office and needs to adopt a judicial approach while
considering an application seeking investigation by the
police.
32. However, unlike Section 156(3)CrPC, any Magistrate,
before ordering investigation under Section 175(3) BNSS,
is required to:
(a) Consider the application, supported by an affidavit,
made by the complainant to the Superintendent of Police
under Section 173(4) BNSS;
(b) Conduct such inquiry as he thinks necessary; and
(c) Consider the submissions made by the police officer.
33. Sub-section (4) of Section 175 BNSS is a new addition
to the scheme of investigation of cognizable cases when
compared with the scheme previously existing in Section
156CrPC. It provides an additional safeguard to a public
servant against whom an accusation of committing a
cognizable offence arising in the course of discharge of his
official duty is made. The provision stipulates that any
Magistrate who is empowered to take cognizance under
Section 210 BNSS may order investigation against a
public servant upon receiving a complaint arising in course
of the discharge of his official duty, only after complying
with the following procedure:
(a) Receiving a report containing facts and circumstances of
the incident from the officer superior to the accused public
servant; and
(b) Considering the assertions made by the accused public
servant as regards the situation that led to the occurrence
of the alleged incident.”
19. In Kushal Kumar Agarwal Vs. Directorate of Enforcement
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1221, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para
6 as under:-
“6. The proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 223 puts an
embargo on the power of the Court to take cognizance by
providing that no cognizance of an offence shall be taken by
the Magistrate without giving the accused an opportunity of
being heard.”

15
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
20. In Parvinder Singh Vs. Directorate of Enforcement 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 903, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para 26, 27 as
under:-
“26. Section 223 of the BNSS deals with the examination of
a complainant. The first proviso to Section 223(1) of the
BNSS prohibits the Magistrate from taking cognizance of
an offence, unless the accused is given an opportunity of
being heard.
27. Though Chapter XVI of the BNSS lays down the
procedural law dealing with complaints made to a
Magistrate, we hold that the aforesaid proviso is substantive
in nature, as it does not merely regulate the manner in which
the proceedings are to be conducted, rather it confers a right
upon the accused to be heard before taking cognizance
which forms a part of the right of an accused to a fair trial
enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. We
further hold that the word “shall” occurring in the said
proviso has to be construed to be mandatory in nature,
which enures to the benefit of an accused. Resultantly,
cognizance of an offence taken by a Court without due
compliance of the aforestated proviso would be void ab
initio . ”
21. In the present case, all the opposite parties arrayed in the
application are police personnel. The allegations against them relate
to an incident which allegedly occurred when they intervened in a
dispute between the appellant and his neighbour and initiated
preventive proceedings under Sections 170, 126, 135 BNSS.
Therefore, before passing any order concerning the allegations
against the said police personnel, the learned Special Judge was
required to examine the applicability of Section 223 BNSS. if the
application was to be treated as a complaint, the mandatory procedure
prescribed under the first proviso to Section 223(1) and Section

16
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
223(2) BNSS, wherever applicable, was required to be followed. The
impugned order does not reflect due consideration of these statutory
requirements and the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the aforesaid decisions.
22. In State of Haryana & Ors. Vs. Bhajan Lal & Ors. 1992 Supp
(1) SCC 335, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para 102 as under:-
“102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various
relevant provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of
the principles of law enunciated by this Court in a series of
decisions relating to the exercise of the extraordinary
power under Article 226 or the inherent powers under
Section 482 of the Code which we have extracted and
reproduced above, we have given the following categories
of cases by way of illustration wherein such power could
be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of any
court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice, though it
may not be possible to lay down any precise, clearly
defined and sufficiently channelised and inflexible
guidelines or rigid formulae and to give an exhaustive list
of myriad kinds of cases wherein such power should be
exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first information
report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face
value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie
constitute any offence or make out a case against the
accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report
and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not
disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation
by police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except
under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of
Section 155(2) of the Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the
FIR or complaint and the evidence collected in support of
the same do not disclose the commission of any offence
and make out a case against the accused.

17
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under
Section 155(2) of the Code.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are
so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which
no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that
there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the
accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of
the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under
which a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution
and continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is
a specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act,
providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the
aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended
with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously
instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance
on the accused and with a view to spite him due to private
and personal grudge.”
23. In Popular Muthiah Vs. State represented by Inspector of
Police, (2006) 7 SCC 296, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para
27, 29, 30, 33 as under:-
“27. While exercising its appellate power, the jurisdiction
of the High Court although is limited but, in our opinion,
there exists a distinction but a significant one being that the
High Court can exercise its revisional jurisdiction and/or
inherent jurisdiction not only when an application therefor
is filed but also suo motu. It is not in dispute that suo
motu power can be exercised by the High Court while
exercising its revisional jurisdiction. There may not,
therefore, be an embargo for the High Court to exercise its
extraordinary inherent jurisdiction while exercising other
jurisdictions in the matter. Keeping in view the intention of
Parliament, while making the new law the emphasis of
Parliament being “a case before the court” in
contradistinction from “a person who is arrayed as an

18
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
accused before it” when the High Court is seized with the
entire case although would exercise a limited jurisdiction in
terms of Section 386 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
the same, in our considered view, cannot be held to limit its
other powers and in particular that of Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure in relation to the matter which
is not before it.
29. The High Court while, thus, exercising its revisional or
appellate power, may exercise its inherent powers. Inherent
power of the High Court can be exercised, it is trite, both in
relation to substantive as also procedural matters.
30. In respect of the incidental or supplemental power,
evidently, the High Court can exercise its inherent
jurisdiction irrespective of the nature of the proceedings.
It is not trammelled by procedural restrictions in that:
(i) Power can be exercised suo motu in the interest of
justice. If such a power is not conceded, it may even lead to
injustice to an accused.
(ii) Such a power can be exercised concurrently with the
appellate or revisional jurisdiction and no formal
application is required to be filed therefor.
(iii) It is, however, beyond any doubt that the power under
Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is not
unlimited. It can inter alia be exercised where the Code is
silent, where the power of the court is not treated as
exhaustive, or there is a specific provision in the Code; or
the statute does not fall within the purview of the Code
because it involves application of a special law. It acts ex
debito justitiae. It can, thus, do real and substantial justice
for which alone it exists.
33. In R.P. Kapur v. State of Punjab [(1960) 3 SCR 388 :
AIR 1960 SC 866 : 1960 Cri LJ 1239] this Court
summarised some of the categories of cases where inherent
power should be exercised to quash a criminal proceeding
against the accused, stating: (SCR p. 393)
(i) where it manifestly appears that there is a legal bar
against the institution or continuance e.g. want of sanction;
(ii) where the allegations in the first information report or
complaint taken at its face value and accepted in their
entirety do not constitute the offence alleged;

19
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
(iii) where the allegations constitute an offence, but there is
no legal evidence adduced or the evidence adduced
clearly or manifestly fails to prove the charge.
The said decision has been noticed subsequently by this
Court in State of Karnataka v. M. Devendrappa [(2002) 3
SCR 89 : 2002 SCC (Cri) 539] ”
24. In Ishwar Chand Sharma v. State of U.P., 2026 SCC OnLine
SC 1004, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para 9, 9.1, 9.2, 9.6, 9.7
as under:-
“9. In the backdrop of the facts of the present case, we wish
to underline a worrying trend that has come to our
attention. Parties involved in matrimonial or commercial
relationships with one another are resorting to filing of
frivolous and vexatious claims and allegations of a criminal
nature to settle personal scores and grudges against each
other and therefore turn to nefarious/oblique means to
attain the said objective. We also painfully take judicial
cognizance of the fact that the courts of law are being
misused and overburdened by such vague and vexatious
litigations between spouses as many a times, the recourse
to law and police is taken, in an oblique way so as to
antagonise, pressurise, hound and harass the other spouse
and their family members in order to retaliate and exact
revenge that is carried out due to sheer hatred and disdain
for the said spouse and their family members.
9.1 While we are cognizant of the fact that there are
genuine and bona fide cases in the courts wherein the
aggrieved parties are genuinely looking for relief and
respite from the actions and omissions of their spouses, that
often require immediate care and attention of the courts of
law and public authorities, such cases get frequently
overshadowed and obscured by the overwhelming number
of false and frivolous cases filed by spouses against one
another as an ‘arm-twisting’ method so as to reach a more
favourable outcome or settlement or more lucrative
monetary settlement. The onus is on courts to be careful
and cautious so as to separate the wheat from the chaff and
separate the genuine cases of matrimonial oppression, rape
and offences against women from the cases wherein the

20
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
legal process and procedure is being used as a tool to file
false and frivolous cases out of vengeance. While doing so,
care should be taken to ensure that the rights and
freedoms of innocent parties are not trampled or arbitrarily
taken away by unscrupulous and baseless litigation.
9.2 We are conscious of the fact that there are many
instances where women are gravely affected by
matrimonial disputes and violence that they have to endure
at the hands of the spouse and in-laws and other family
members. Such cases deserve our utmost attention and
judicial scrutiny so as to make sure that the ends of justice
are met and the offenders do not go scot-free and rather get
the punishment they deserve. However such a zeal to
meet the ends of justice should be countenanced, by
courts of law and executive authorities of the State, with a
pragmatic approach bearing in mind the recent trend of
criminal litigation in this country wherein the legal
machinery and statutes are being used as a tool by
mischievous litigants so as to create unnecessary hurdles
and punish unsuspecting and often innocent citizens
particularly in the sphere of matrimonial disputes. The
litigating parties and their advocates should also be
cognizant of the fact that such vexatious filing of false
and frivolous claims and cases cast unnecessary burden
on the already overburdened machinery and apparatus of
the State and Judiciary. This factor also diverts the attention
of courts and its resources whereas genuine cases of the
parties with actual verifiable grievances are not being able
to be adjudicated in time owing to the time spent in
adjudicating upon phantom claims of mischievous
litigators seeking to create litigation out of thin air or in the
absence of a cause to do so.
9.6 While we are conscious of the fact that there are
instances and a plethora of cases that are true and deserve
the utmost attention and deft handling on the side of
authorities and Courts and which should be pursued
vigorously to reach a logical conclusion, on the other side
of the spectrum, are cases invoking such serious and
heinous allegations which are prima facie vague, omnibus
and general in nature and thereby lacking any material
backing or evidence which should be shunned at the very
threshold. We say so for the reason that if a person is made
an accused and forced to face a criminal trial on general and

21
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
sweeping allegations without bringing on record any
specific instances of criminal conduct, it would tantamount
to an abuse of the process of law and court. Hence, legal
practitioners who tender advice in such cases must
restrain parties from filing such false/frivolous complaints
when requested to do so. Further, lawyers/advocates must
also not advise filing of criminal complaints which are
false/concocted so as to keep the opposite parties under a
tight leash so that they could come forward for a settlement
on the terms dictated by their parties or else, to face a
criminal prosecution which can prolong for years. When
such is the trend, on the other side, efforts are made to seek
anticipatory bail by persons apprehending arrest owing to a
false/frivolous complaint being lodged which sometimes
reach the portals of this Court after being unsuccessful at
the level of the trial court and High Court. Also, steps are
taken for seeking quashing of such false/frivolous
complaints before the High Court which has its own saga
of uncertainties causing undue pressure, harassment,
stress and tension on the so-called accused. The
consequence of all this is docket explosion and burden on
Courts resulting in genuine complaints and cases not being
given due time and attention that they need.
9.7 Courts then owe a duty to subject the allegations
levelled in the complaint to a thorough scrutiny to ascertain
if a prima facie case is made out or not, and whether there
is any kernel of truth in the allegations or whether the said
allegations have been made only with the sole intent of
spite so as to harass the opposite party with a prolonged
process of criminal litigation, arrest and sometimes a
conviction which later on may result in an acquittal by a
higher Court or in a worse case, no relief at all being
given to an innocent party. This stands more true when
prosecution arises from a matrimonial dispute.”
25. In the present case, the appeal has been preferred by the
complainant himself, primarily seeking registration of a criminal case
and investigation against the opposite parties. However, upon
examination of the allegations contained in the application and the
material placed before the learned Special Judge, this Court finds that

22
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
no prima facie case was disclosed either warranting a direction for
investigation or justifying the conversion of the application into a
complaint case. The learned Special Judge was required to examine
the basic ingredients of the alleged offences and ascertain whether
the allegations, even if taken at their face value, disclosed
commission of any cognizable offence or any other offence for which
the complaint procedure could legitimately be set into motion. The
mere fact that an application had been filed by the complainant could
not, by itself, confer jurisdiction upon the Court to initiate criminal
proceedings against the opposite parties. The approach adopted by
the learned Special Judge is, therefore, contrary to the principles laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bhajan Lal (supra), Popular
Muthiah (supra) and Ishwar Chand Sharma (supra).
26. The application moved by the complainant under Section
173(4) BNSS was treated as a complaint case and the matter was
fixed for 3.9.2025 for recording the statement of the complainant
under Section 223 BNSS. Such an order itself indicates that the
learned Special Judge had proceeded to take cognizance of the
offence on the basis of the complaint. Once the court decided to
proceed under Chapter XVI of the BNSS, it was incumbent upon the
learned Special Judge to satisfy himself that the allegations and
materials available on record disclosed the commission of an offence
and that the statutory conditions for taking cognizance were fulfilled.

23
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
The procedure of treating an application as a complaint cannot be
adopted merely as a matter of course, without recording the requisite
judicial satisfaction regarding the existence of a prima facie case.
27. The principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Popular Muthiah (supra), particularly paragraphs 27, 29, 30 and 33
requires the Court to exercise its jurisdiction within the limits
prescribed by law and only after examining the existence of the
necessary conditions precedent. In the present case, the learned
Special Judge appears to have proceeded mechanically without
recording such satisfaction.
28. It is also significant that the learned Special Judge, after
converting the application under Section 173(4) BNSS into a
complaint case, fixed the matter on 3.9.2025 for recording the
statement of the complainant under Section 223 BNSS. Thus, the
proceedings had crossed the stage of mere consideration of an
application and had entered the stage of complaint proceedings
following the decision to take cognizance. At that stage, the learned
Special Judge was also required to examine the applicability of the
first proviso to Section 223(1) and the mandatory requirements of
Section 223(2) BNSS, particularly because all the opposite parties
were police personnel/public servants and they have initiated the
proceeding against the appellant Manoj Kumar Paswan under
Sections 170, 126, 135 of BNSS. These provisions provide statutory

24
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
safeguards which cannot be dispensed with merely because the
application was originally presented under Section 173(4) BNSS.
The learned Special Judge, without first examining the applicability
of the statutory bar under Section 218 BNSS and without complying
with the safeguards prescribed under Section 223 BNSS, proceeded
to initiate complaint proceedings. Such an approach amounts to a
failure to follow the procedure established by law and reflects non-
application of judicial mind to the mandatory provisions governing
prosecution of public servants. It is nothing but a failure of justice
and an abuse of process of law.
29. General Directions for All the Judicial Officers of UP:-
Having regard to the statutory scheme of Sections 173(4),
175(3), 175(4), 210, 223, 225, 226 and 227 of the BNSS,
and the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
as discussed hereinabove, the following directions are
issued for all the Magistrates and Special Courts dealing
with criminal matters:-
(i) Every application under Section 173(4) read with Section
175(3) BNSS shall be examined on its own merits. The
Court shall ensure compliance with all the statutory
requirements, particularly prior approach to the
Superintendent of Police and filing of a duly sworn affidavit
etc. The Magistrate must apply judicial mind to the

25
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
allegations, supporting material and necessity of police
investigation before passing an appropriate order.
(ii) An application seeking police investigation shall not
automatically be converted into a complaint merely because
the Court is not inclined to direct investigation. If the court
considers it appropriate to proceed under the complaint
procedure, specific reasons shall be recorded, keeping in
view the nature of the allegations and the relief sought by
the applicant.
(iii) Where an application is treated as a complaint, the
procedure prescribed under Sections 223 to 227 BNSS shall
be strictly followed. The complainant and witnesses shall be
examined as per rule and procedure.
(a) The opportunity contemplated under the first
proviso to Section 223(1) BNSS is mandatory
and must be afforded before taking cognizance.
(b) The proposed accused shall be entitled, to
receive copy of complaint as well as every
document annex with and relied upon by the
complainant in order to effective and meaningful
‘opportunity of hearing’ as provided under
section 223 BNSS.
(c) The expression "opportunity of being heard"
under first proviso of Section 223(1) BNSS is
not restricted to oral hearing. It may encompass

26
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
written submissions also. Only both modes are
permissible at this per-cognizance stage.
(d) The proposed accused may place written
submission before the court to demonstrate,
specific assertions against facts mentioned in
complaint, including facts regarding absence of
territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction, Legal
bar to prosecution, Limitation or statutory
prohibition, absence of an essential ingredient of
the alleged offence, that the allegations even if
accepted as stated do not constitute the alleged
offence etc.
(e) The court shall consider the material legal
objections raised by the proposed accused and
pass a reasoned judicial order.
(f) The Court is not expected to conduct a mini-
trial at the pre-cognizance stage. The Court must
not undertake a roving inquiry, meticulously
appreciate evidence, or adjudicate disputed
defence contentions.
(g) Where, after submission of the Final Report
by Investigating Officer, the Court decides to
reject the same and treat the matter as a
complaint case, the procedure prescribed as
hereinabove under (a) to (f) shall be followed.
(iv) Where a complaint is proceeded with against a public
servant, the Court shall independently examine the
applicability of Section 223(2) BNSS and, wherever
attracted, shall comply with its requirements, including

27
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
obtaining a report from the officer superior to the concerned
public servant and providing an opportunity to such public
servant to make assertions before taking cognizance.
(v) Sections 175(4) and 223(2) BNSS shall not be applied
mechanically merely because the proposed accused is a
public servant. Their applicability shall depend upon the
nature of the allegations and their reasonable connection
with the discharge of official duties.
(vi) The inquiry contemplated under Section 175(3) BNSS
shall not be treated as a full-fledged trial. Similarly, the
inquiry under Section 225 BNSS shall remain confined to
determining whether sufficient grounds exist for proceeding
against the proposed accused in a complaint case.
(vii) While dealing with applications arising out of civil
disputes, property disputes, financial/business transaction
disputes, previous litigation, the Court shall carefully
examine whether the allegations independently disclose the
commission of a criminal offence or whether the criminal
process has been set in motion with malafide intent.
(viii) Wherever cognizance is taken in complaint case, the
order must expressly record that cognizance of the offence
has been taken under Section 210(1)(a) BNSS, read with the

28
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
applicable provisions of Chapter XVI BNSS or other
applicable law.
30. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is
of the considered opinion that the learned Special Judge was required
to exercise greater caution before setting the criminal law into motion
against the opposite parties. The principles laid down in cases as
discussed herein above make it clear that criminal proceedings
cannot be initiated merely on the basis of allegations without
examining whether the essential ingredients of the alleged offences
are prima facie disclosed from the material available on record. The
Court is not expected to act as a mere forwarding authority of the
complainant's allegations. It must independently examine the factual
and legal foundation of the proposed prosecution and ensure
compliance with the statutory safeguards.
31. In the present case, neither a prima facie case warranting
investigation or prosecution has been demonstrated from the material
considered by the learned Special Judge, nor have the mandatory
procedural safeguards applicable to the prosecution of public
servants been duly considered. Consequently, continuation of the
proceedings arising out of the impugned order would amount to
permitting criminal process to operate without adequate legal
foundation and in disregard of the procedure prescribed by law.

29
CRLA No. - 7460 of 2025
32. The impugned order dated 9.7.2025, passed by the learned
Special Judge, SC/ST (PA) Act, Kanpur Nagar, whereby the
application under Section 173(4) BNSS filed by the appellant was
converted into complaint case, therefore, cannot be sustained in the
eyes of law and deserves to be set aside. The impugned order dated
9.7.2025 is hereby set aside.
33. With the above observations and directions, the present appeal
is, accordingly, disposed of.
34. A copy of these directions shall be circulated to all the judicial
officers of Uttar Pradesh through the Registrar General of the High
Court and the Director, Judicial Training and Research Institute
(JTRI), Lucknow, for appropriate dissemination and inclusion in
judicial training programmes.
(Santosh Rai,J.)
November 17, 2026
RA
Digitally signed by :-
RAZIQ ALI
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad