State Of U.P.. vs Zafar Ali
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 753
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3954 OF 2018
STATE OF U.P. & ORS. … APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
ZAFAR ALI & ORS. … RESPONDENT(S)
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3956 OF 2018
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3955 OF 2018
AND
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 8137 OF 2012
J U D G M E N T
S.V.N. BHATTI, J.
1. The respondents in Writ (Tax) No. 507 of 2011 are the Appellants
herein.
2. The Appeal examines the levy and demand of penalty for non-
performance of Minimum Guaranteed Quota (for short, ‘MGQ’) by the
Respondents, under the Uttar Pradesh Excise (Settlement of Licences for
Retail Sale of Country Liquor) Rules, 2002 (for short, ‘Rules 2002’). It concerns
a dispute arising out of an excise licence granted to the Respondents for the
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
LOKESH ARORA
Date: 2026.07.28
18:18:33 IST
Reason:
years 2006-07 and 2007-08, namely, whether a retail country liquor licensee,
who has fulfilled and lifted the entire annual minimum guaranteed quantity
1
fixed for the excise year, can still be held liable to pay deficit licence fees,
penalties, and interest if there was a short-fall in lifting the monthly minimum
guaranteed quantity in a particular month. The prayer in the Writ Petition
reads as follows:
“(i) Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari
be passed quashing the impugned reply dated 17.08.2010
sent on behalf of U.P. Government and others by the D.G.C.
Civil. Bijnore and letter of Excise Commissioner dated
09.03.2010 and notices of demand dated 17 March, 2009
and 20 March, 2009 which are filed as Annexure No. 1, 3 &
4 to this writ petition be quashed, and also declaring the
same legal on just.
(ii) Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Mandamus,
thereby directing respondent to release the security amount
of the petitioners deposited with the District Officers, Bijnore
for the Excise Year 2006-07 of the Petitioners No. 4, 19, 25,
32 & 33 and also of the deposits of all the petitioners
deposited in the Excise Year 2007-08 as Security Deposits,
as the licensees of country made liquor shops of District
Bijnore for the period of 01.04.2006 to 31.03.2007 and
01.04.2007 to 31.03.2008 and which have been illegally
deducted in the name of penalty and interest imposed upon
penalty and details of which is shown in Annexure Nos. 5 &
6 of the Writ Petition be directed to be immediately released
to the petitioners of the Excise Year 2007-08 on the basis of
parity as has been given to the Country Liquor Licensees of
District Lucknow and Unnao.
(iii) To issue directions in the nature of mandamus
commanding to oppose parties to immediately refund the
security deposits after deducting only Rs. 5000/- of each
shops of the petitioners without any delay and also with
interest for illegal withelding of the aforesaid security
amounts of the petitioners @ 18% per annum or any amount
of interest of which this Hon’ble Court pleased to fix, to the
petitioners.”
3. To appreciate the controversy between the parties, illustratively, the
relevant portion of an impugned Demand Notice dated 20.03.2009 issued to
the Petitioner in Writ (Tax) No. 507 of 2011 is excerpted hereinunder:
“…Under para 15(a) Uttar Pradesh Excise (Settlement of
Licence for retail sale of Country liquor), Rules, 2002, licensee
may lift quantity of Country liquor in excess of the monthly
minimum guaranteed quantity without satiating any
additional payment. In case licensee lifts quantity of Country
liquor in excess of the minimum monthly guaranteed quantity
2
in the month under para 15(c), then he would be entitled to
earn the residual amount of licence fee. But such adjustment
would not be excess of 20 percent of the monthly licence fee.
The details of the Country liquor lifted by you in the month of
March, 2008 in the year 2007-08 are as under: -
S.No Name
of
Shop
Annual
MGQ (in
B.L)
Monthl
y MGQ
((in B.L)
Prescribe
d
quantity
lifted in
after
adjustme
nt of 20%
of MGQ
Quanti
ty
lifted
in the
month
of
March
07 in
B.L
Differen
ce of
quantit
y lifted
(in B.L)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 Bijna
ur No.
2
92230.0
0
7685.0
0
6148.00 4662.0
0
1486.00
Therefore, in compliance of order of the respected District
Collector dated 20.03.09 you are directed to deposit the
amount consideration fee payable and amount of penal
interest Rs.1,61,320.00 on the less quantity lifted in the
Government Treasury at once and ensure making producing
treasury challan before the undersigned.
Sd/-
(R.K Ram)
District Excise Officer,
Bijnaur
4. The circumstances preceding the filing of the Writ Petition before the
High Court are that on 21.07.2004 and 27.05.2006, licences for country
liquor shops were granted and subsequently renewed for the periods 2006-
2007 and 2007-2008. On 09.03.2009, the Excise Commissioner issued a
Circular directing Officers to ensure strict compliance with MGQ lifting to
meet revenue targets. It stipulated that adjustments for excess lifting were
permissible only up to 20% in the next month and that shortfalls below 80%
must be adjusted from security deposits. On 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009,
3
Demand Notices were issued to the licensees for failing to lift the required
MGQ for specific months, imposing penalties and initiating deductions from
their security deposits. On 27.07.2009, the Deputy Excise Commissioner (for
short, ‘DEO’) requested a partial amendment and clarification of Rule 15(c) of
the Rules 2002 to avoid ongoing confusion regarding penalties. On
06.07.2010, the aggrieved licensees sent a legal notice to the State demanding
the release of their security deposits, arguing that the MGQ is to be calculated
on an annual, not monthly, basis. On 17.08.2010, the State replied to the
legal notice, refusing the refund and reiterating that adjustments beyond 20%
were not permissible under the Rules 2002. On 25.11.2010, the licensees filed
a Writ Petition (Writ Tax No. 507 of 2011) in the High Court of Judicature at
Allahabad.
5. The Respondents' case before the High Court is that they were granted
licences for Country Liquor Shops in District Bijnor. As per the terms of the
licences and the U.P. Excise Act, 1910 (for short, ‘Excise Act’), each
Respondent deposited the required annual licence fees and security money.
Such security deposits were legally required to be refunded after the end of
the Excise year if there were no outstanding Excise revenue dues. The
Respondents had lifted the entire annual MGQ fixed for their shops for both
the 2006-07 and 2007-08 Excise years, and were not defaulters, because the
annual MGQ is divided into 12 monthly instalment quotas. Under the existing
adjusting system, if a licensee failed to lift the quota in a particular month,
they were entitled to lift the balance or even excess up to 20% in subsequent
months. The Excise Commissioner issued a Circular on 09.03.2009, directing
the imposition of penalties for failing to lift monthly quotas. Following this
4
Circular, the DEO issued new Demand Notices in March 2009, fixing duty as
a penalty and calculating interest. These amounts were then unilaterally
adjusted and deducted from the Respondents’ security deposits. The
Appellants wrongly refused the refund, claiming that the Respondents were
barred by the principle of ‘Estoppel and Acquiescence’ because they accepted
the balance of their security deposits. It was contended that the Respondents
accepted the remaining amount only because they urgently needed funds to
continue their business for the next year and never intended to waive their
claim for a full refund. In a similar case (Writ Petition No. 11820 (M/B) of
2009) involving licensees in Unnao and Lucknow, the High Court’s
intervention led the Commissioner to fix a nominal charge of only Rs. 5,000
per shop instead of full penalties. Hence, the Respondents are entitled to the
same benefit of parity. It was prayed that the rejection reply dated 17.08.2010,
the Excise Commissioner's Order dated 09.03.2010, and the Demand Notices
from March 2009, be quashed. Further, a direction may be passed to release
the withheld security deposits for the Excise Years 2006-2007 and 2007-
2008.
6. The Appellants opposed the Writ Prayer before the High Court. The
Appellants’ case was that the Respondents had an alternative statutory
remedy of appeal under Section 11(1) of the Excise Act. Hence, the Writ
Petition was not maintainable in the presence of an alternative statutory
remedy. The Respondents voluntarily applied for a refund of their security
deposits after the State adjusted consideration fees under Rules 14 and 15 of
the Rules, 2002 and received the refunded balance. By concealing these
voluntary refund applications in their petition and accepting the refunded
5
amounts, the Respondents are barred by estoppel. Trade in country liquor
is res extra commercium , i.e., outside the scope of normal commerce.
Under Section 24B of the Excise Act, the State holds the exclusive privilege
over its manufacture and sale. The Respondents accepted the licence
conditions and remain bound by them. Under Rule 15(c) of the Rules, 2002,
any credit balance earned by lifting excess liquor in a month cannot be
adjusted beyond 20% of that month’s licence fee. The Respondents
adjusted more than 20% of their monthly licence fee in March while short-
lifting their MGQ. This directly breached Rule 15(c) and Condition No. 2 of
their licence. The Respondents incorrectly relied on communications from the
Excise Commissioner dated 04/06.03.2010 and 11.03.2010 to contend that
their liability could be settled by paying a Rs. 5,000 penalty. It is clarified that
the Rs. 5,000 fee is a compounding fee under Section 74 of the Excise Act,
paid strictly in lieu of an offence to prevent licence cancellation or criminal
prosecution. Accepting the Writ Prayer would be absurd because paying a
compounding fee for an operational offence does not legally relieve a licensee
of their separate, outstanding contractual debts, which can run into lakhs or
crores.
7. The Impugned Judgment has dealt with the controversy and has
allowed the Writ Petition. It quashed demand notices issued by the DEO,
holding that if a licensee fulfils their Annual MGQ for the entire Excise year,
the State cannot penalise them for a shortfall in an isolated month by ignoring
the cumulative “credit balance” they earned in prior months. The summary of
the view of the High Court is stated as thus:
6
A. Under Rule 15(c) of the Rules 2002, if a licensee lifts excess liquor in a
given month, they earn a “credit balance of licence fee”. This credit is designed
to be carried forward to ongoing months. The Excise Department acted
arbitrarily by calculating the deficit for a single isolated month without
factoring in the accumulated credit balance the Respondents had earned in
previous months. Because the Respondents fulfilled the annual MGQ, the
prior credit balances more than covered any isolated monthly shortfall.
B. Rule 14(c) of the 2002 Rules mandates that if a licensee falls short of
rd
their monthly quota, the District Excise Officer must issue a notice by the 3
day of the next month. This allows the licensee to replenish the deficit within
10 days. The authorities failed to issue any such notices during the currency
of the Excise years. Issuing Demand Notices retroactively, well after the Excise
year had ended and the annual quotas were fulfilled, was deemed wholly
unreasonable and arbitrary.
C. The Court rejected the State’s argument that the Respondents should
have filed an appeal to the Excise Commissioner under the Excise Act. It was
held that because the initial recovery notices were directly triggered by a
Circular issued by the Excise Commissioner himself on 09.03.2009, an appeal
to that same Authority would not be appropriate.
D. The State’s argument that because the Respondents accepted a partial
refund of their security deposits, they forfeited their right to sue was
dismissed. It was held that accepting a partial refund of their security deposit
did not forfeit the Respondents’ right to challenge an illegal demand raised
before the refund occurred.
7
E. Therefore, the Demand Notices dated 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were
quashed, and the State was ordered to refund the security amounts to the
Respondents within one month of the Order being produced before the
Authority.
8. Hence, the Civil Appeal(s).
9. Advocate Namit Saxena, appearing for the Appellants argues that the
Respondents were granted a licence under Form C.L. 5-C for the retail sale of
light and high-degree country liquor in sealed bottles and containers for use
outside the outlet. The licence sets out the conditions under which it has been
granted. As an illustrative case, he has invited our attention to Annexure P-
1, which pertains to Shop Bijnor No. 2, District-Bijnor. The basic licence fee
is Rs. 7,39,200/-, and the minimum annual guaranteed quantity is 73,920
bulk litres, which works out to 6,160 bulk litres per month. The annual
licence fee is Rs. 58,39,618/-, and the monthly instalment of licence fee is Rs.
4,86,640/-. The licensee is obliged to comply with the MGQ of 6,160 bulk
litres every month. Referring to the Notice, it is argued that there is a
difference in quantity at Shop No. 2 of Bijnore. The MGQ payable comes to
Rs. 1,36,712/-. It is argued that the adjustment is available in the following
month, and there is also a provision for higher requisitioning of liquor; since,
for the month of March, 2008, the licensee has not complied with the MGQ,
the levy is demanded.
9.1. He has invited our attention to the Rules 2002, and argues that the
Impugned Judgment does not conform to the plain and simple construction
of Rules 14 and 15 of the Rules 2002. He prays for the setting aside of the
Impugned Judgment.
8
10. Advocate A. T. Rao, appearing for the Respondents, argued that the
licensees have not committed a breach of MGQ. The licensees have purchased
the MGQ stipulated under each licence. The dispute has arisen on account of
short purchase of MGQ, particularly in the month of March of the Excise year.
Ignoring the annual compliance of MGQ performance and looking only at the
short performance for the month of March, MGQ is levied and demanded. He
invited our attention to the definition of licence fee and to Rules 13 to 15 of
the Rules 2002. The conditions in Form ‘C’ licence are construed and read
consistently with the Rules. There is no occasion to impose penalty and
interest on penalty for non-performance of MGQ. He relies upon the detailed
consideration of all the contentions by the High Court and prays for dismissal
of the appeals.
11. We have taken note of the rival contentions and perused the record.
12. At the outset, we would like to observe that the Impugned Judgment
has considered the contentions on facts and law, applied correct
interpretations to the Rules and the terms and conditions of the Country
Liquor 5-C licence, and has quashed the impugned Notice issued by the
Appellants. A ground is canvassed before us; we would like to test the
correctness of the Appellants' arguments as follows:
12.1. The preface to the country liquor ‘5-C’ licence refers to the licence fee
and MGQ. The levy and demand for non-compliance with MGQ are either for
one month or for two months, but the same licensee has, admittedly, complied
with the Minimum Annual Guaranteed Quantity. For our purpose, we excerpt
the definition clause (m) of licence fee and monthly instalment licence fee
hereinbelow:
9
“(m) “licence fee” means the remaining part of consideration
for grant of licence for exclusive privilege of retail sale of
country liquor under Section 24 of the Act, payable by the
licencee, in addition to the basic licence fee. This sum shall
be equal to the excise duty leviable on the annual minimum
guaranteed quantity fixed for the shop”
14. Payment of monthly instalment of license fee and
consequence of failure –
(a) The licensee shall be liable to pay the monthly intalment
of licence fee by the last day of the month. However the duty
involved in the quantity of country liquor lifted by him during
the month and credit balance of licence fee from previous
month, if any, shall be adjusted against the monthly
instalment of licence fee according to provisions of these
rules.
(b) the licensee shall be required to submit his account and
licence fee passbook, giving details of the country liquor lifted
by him and the licence fee deposited, to the District Excise
st
Officer by 5.00 p.m. of the 1 day of the next month for
verification and calculation of licence fee due from him.
(c) In case there is any short fall in the licencee fee, after due
adjustment of duty involved in the country liquor lifted by the
licensee and credit balance of licence fee from previous
month, according to provisions of these rules and District
Excise Officer shall adjust the outstanding balance amount of
licence fee from the security deposit of the licensee and also
rd
issue a notice to the licensee by the 3 day of the next month
to replenish the deficit in security amount either by lifting
such quantity of country liquor involving duty equivalent to
the adjusted amount of by depositing cash or a combination
of both. In case the licensee fails to replenish the deficit in
th
security amount by the 10 day of the next month his licence
shall stand cancelled.”
13. A perusal of the aforesaid Rules indicates that the licence has a licence
fee, an annual licence fee, and an MGQ. The fixed element may be termed the
basic licence fee, and the licence fee is in addition to the basic licence fee
payable under the licence. The licence fee is distributed over the period of the
Excise year, and in the event of a licensee lifting excess of Country Liquor over
and above the MGQ, the licensee is entitled to a Credit Balance of the licence
fee. It is not the case of the Appellants that the licence conditions in this behalf
are not complied with. The situation arose from overstretching the
understanding of the performance of the minimum annual guaranteed
quantity and the minimum monthly guaranteed quantity. The Appellants
10
insists on performing the minimum annual guaranteed quantity and the
minimum monthly guaranteed quantity. We hypothetically test the
understanding of the performance of the licence conditions by an example: if
a licensee completes the minimum annual guaranteed quantity within six
months and continues to pay the minimum monthly licence fee for the
remainder of the licence period, should he be demanded to pay a penalty for
non-performance if the minimum monthly guaranteed quantity is not
th
achieved? In such an event, the licensee will continue to pay 1/12 of the
monthly licence fee and the underperformance penalty without proper credit
for the already performed minimum annual guaranteed quantity. The
definition of licence fee in Clause (m) of Rule 2 of the Rules 2002 does not
support the view of the Appellants.
14 . The enforcement of licence terms and conditions, as noted above, prima
facie, suffers from an infirmity of fact. The Appellants do not dispute that it
has received the annual licence fee from the licensee. The complaint is of non-
performance with respect to MGQ for the defaulted month. The non-
performance also occurred during the last phase of the Excise year. The
licensee has since paid the licence fee and performed the minimum annual
guaranteed quantity well before the completion of the Excise year. Non-
performance of MGQ at the time of completion of the licence period is not a
ground for levying and demanding a penalty, both under the Rules 2002, and
as per the terms of the Form 5-C licence. We are not expressing a view that
the licensee is under no obligation to conform to MGQ, but insisting upon the
licensee to adhere to MGQ, and finally to the Monthly Guaranteed Quota, is
11
not an available and correct interpretation of the Licence Fee Rules and the
terms and conditions.
15. The mode and manner of performance insisted upon by the Appellants
through the impugned Demand Notice do not conform to the plain meaning
of the statutory rules. The Demand Notice was not issued contemporaneously,
but after the lapse of a reasonable time. These infirmities go to the root of the
impugned demand. Therefore, through the Impugned Judgment, the High
Court has rightly interfered with the Demand Notice. The Impugned
Judgment has considered every aspect in great detail and recorded correct
and available conclusions, and hence does not call for interference.
16. Except the above, no other point is argued.
17. The Civil Appeals are, accordingly, dismissed.
18. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
..……….…………………J.
[S.V.N. BHATTI]
...…………………………J.
[N.V. ANJARIA]
New Delhi;
July 28, 2026.
12