Pinaki Misra vs State & Anr

Court
Delhi High Court

$~82
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Date of Decision: 17.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010228362019
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019, Crl.M.A.10470/2019
+
PINAKI MISRA .....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Rebecca M. John, Sr. Adv. and
Ms. Anushka Baruah, Adv.
versus

STATE & ANR .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Aashneet Singh, APP for State.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA

SACHIN DATTA, J. (ORAL)

The matter is taken up today as 16.11.2026 was declared a holiday on
account of Chatth Puja .

1. The present petition has been filed under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“Cr.P.C.”) seeking setting aside of the
summoning order dated 20.04.2019 passed by the learned Additional Chief
Metropolitan Magistrate-I, Rouse Avenue Courts Complex, New Delhi
(“ACMM”) in Complaint Case No. 11/2019 titled as ‘ Siddhartha Singh v.
Pinaki Mishra’ . By that order, the petitioner was summoned for the offence
under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (“IPC”). The petition also
seeks quashing of the complaint itself and all proceedings emanating
therefrom.
2. The petition was filed in 2019, prior to the coming into force of the
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 1 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (“BNSS”); it is, therefore,
governed by the provisions of the Cr.P.C. and the IPC.
3. The relevant factual background, in brief, is as follows:
(i) The petitioner is a Senior Advocate and, at the relevant time, was a
Member of Parliament (Lok Sabha) and Chairperson of the Parliamentary
Standing Committee on Urban Development.
(ii) The respondent no.2, a practising advocate, was the counsel for the
applicant in O.A. No. 122/2017 titled Balbir Singh v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
& Anr. before the Principal Bench of the National Green Tribunal (“NGT”),
in which the petitioner appeared for certain power distribution companies.
Respondent no.2 objected to the appearance of the petitioner in the said
proceedings, contending that the Standing Committee chaired by the
petitioner had made adverse recommendations against the power distribution
companies on the very issue of e-waste management. The respondent no.2
also preferred a complaint (Complaint No. 111/2018) before the Bar Council
of Delhi, alleging professional misconduct on account of conflict of interest.
(iii) On 27.08.2018, the Economic Times carried a report in respect of the
said complaint. The report set out the allegations of the respondent no.2. The
said report also quoted the petitioner as having stated, inter alia , that the
person who has filed the complaint before the BCD is a “crook” . According
to the complaint subsequently filed by the respondent no.2, the said
statement of the petitioner was defamatory and lowered his reputation in the
eyes of the public.
(iv) On 31.08.2018, the respondent no.2 sent a legal notice to the
petitioner demanding an unconditional apology. The petitioner sent a reply
dated 07.09.2018 (Annexure P-12 to the present petition).
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 2 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

(v) The Bar Council complaint came to be dismissed by the Bar Council
of Delhi vide order dated 16.11.2018. Thereafter, the respondent no.2 filed
the complaint under Sections 190 and 200 Cr.P.C. read with Sections 499
and 500 IPC, which is, Complaint Case No. 11/2019, before the learned
ACMM-I, Rouse Avenue Courts Complex, New Delhi.
(vi) The learned ACMM took cognizance of the complaint on 15.01.2019.
On 02.02.2019, the respondent no.2 examined himself as CW-1 and stated
that he did not wish to examine any other witness; the pre-summoning
evidence was, accordingly, closed.
(vii) By order dated 20.04.2019, the learned ACMM summoned the
petitioner for the offence under Section 500 IPC. Consequently, the present
petition has been filed.
(viii) Vide order dated 15.05.2019 passed in the present proceedings, notice

was issued in the present petition and the operation of the impugned order
was stayed; the said interim order has continued since then.
4. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has been heard at some
length. She submits that:
(a) the requirement of Explanation 4 to Section 499 IPC is not satisfied,
inasmuch as the respondent no.2 examined only himself as CW-1 and did
not examine any other person to show that his reputation was lowered in the
estimation of others;
(b) the summoning order is mechanical and nearly identical to the
summoning order passed in Complaint Case No. 10/2019, which was also
filed by the respondent no.2 against the petitioner. The summoning order
and the proceedings in the said complaint case have been quashed by a
Coordinate Bench of this Court vide judgment dated 25.08.2026 in
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 3 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

CRL.M.C. 2595/2019. It is submitted that the said judgment covers the
factual conspectus of the present case as well; and
(c) the respondent no.2 has not been appearing in the matter, despite
notice, either before this Court or before the learned trial Court.
5. Section 499 IPC defines the offence of defamation. Explanation 4 to
Section 499 IPC reads as under:
“Explanation 4.—No imputation is said to harm a person's reputation,
unless that imputation directly or indirectly, in the estimation of others,
lowers the moral or intellectual character of that person, or lowers the
character of that person in respect of his caste or of his calling, or lowers
the credit of that person, or causes it to be believed that the body of that
person is in a lothsome state, or in a state generally considered as
disgraceful.”

6. In Jeffrey J. Diermeier v. State of West Bengal , (2010) 6 SCC 243,
the Supreme Court held as under:
“30. However, as per Explanation 4 to the section, no imputation is said
to harm a person's reputation, unless that imputation directly or
indirectly lowers the moral or intellectual character of that person, or
lowers the character of that person in respect of his caste or of his
calling, or lowers the credit of that person, in the estimation of others or
causes it to be believed that the body of that person is in a loathsome
state, or in a state generally considered as disgraceful.”

7. More recently, in Jaideep Bose v. M/s Bid & Hammer Auctioneers
1
Pvt. Ltd. , 2025 SCC OnLine SC 348
, the Supreme Court set aside the

1
“20. ……The complainant failed to produce any witness to prima facie establish that the alleged
imputations had lowered their reputation in the estimation of others and the Magistrate, after merely
reviewing the complainant's statement, proceeded to issue summons. Thus, the Magistrate's order clearly
suffers from procedural irregularity. Ordinarily, such irregularities would warrant a remand. However, in
the present case, the auction was conducted on 27.06.2014 and the complaint was filed on 22.08.2014. No
material has also been placed before us to suggest that the auction was unsuccessful or that any damage or
loss was actually caused, due to the alleged news articles published in the newspapers. Irrespective of the
same, at this stage, remanding the matter for fresh examination of witnesses before issuance of summons
would serve no useful purpose, given the remote likelihood of securing witnesses. It would only prolong
the litigation yielding little to no benefit especially, since the auction has already concluded and more than
a decade has passed….”
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 4 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

summoning order, inter alia , on the ground that the complainant had failed
to produce any witness to prima facie establish that the alleged imputations
had lowered its reputation in the estimation of others. Similarly, in Madanjit
2
Kumar v. J.P. Singh & Ors. , 2019 SCC OnLine Del 6853
, this Court
upheld the dismissal of a complaint where the complainant had not
examined any person to whom the imputation was published.
8. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, I find merit in the
present petition. It is evident that the complaint of the respondent no.2 is
predicated on the premise that the publication tarnished his image. However,
he has not named any person who read the report or in whose estimation his
reputation stood lowered, and he did not examine anybody other than
himself at the stage of pre-summoning evidence.
9. Importantly, in the context of the connected complaint, i.e., Complaint

Case No. 10/2019, based on a publication on another platform viz . Dailyhunt
News dated 24.01.2019, a Coordinate Bench of this Court has had occasion
to consider the matter at length.
10. The judgment dated 25.08.2026 came to be pronounced in CRL.M.C.
2595/2019 (2026:DHC:7169). In that case, the Coordinate Bench set aside
the summoning order dated 20.04.2019 in Complaint Case No. 10/2019. The
complaint was between the same parties and arose from the same
controversy. The Coordinate Bench held that the complainant’s claim of
harm to his reputation rested only on his own assertion, with no other
material to show that his reputation was lowered in the estimation of others.

2
9. The core issue that arises is as to whether any evidence has been led to show the imputation to have
been “published” within the mischief of Section 499 IPC…….
11. Given the fact that the petitioner did not examine any other person to whom the incriminating material
may have been published, the view taken by the courts below cannot be faulted.”
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 5 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

It also noted that no reporter or other person associated with the publication
had been examined to prove the alleged statement.
11. The operative portion of the aforesaid judgment dated 25.08.2026
reads as under:
“18. In the present case, the respondent no. 2 examined himself as
the sole witness in the pre-summoning evidence. There is no
material on record, in the form of statement of any other person or
otherwise, to prima facie demonstrate that the alleged imputation
had the effect of lowering the reputation of respondent no. 2 in the
estimation of others. The allegation that the publication caused
damage to his reputation, by itself, remains an assertion of the
complainant and does not establish the statutory requirement
contemplated by Explanation 4 to Section 499 IPC

.
19. This Court is conscious that, at the stage of taking cognizance
or issuance of process, the Court is not required to undertake a
meticulous appreciation of evidence or conduct a mini-trial.
However, the limited nature of the inquiry at such stage cannot
dispense with the requirement that the basic ingredients of the
offence must be prima facie disclosed from the material placed
before the Court

.
20. There is, however, another aspect which also merits
consideration. The allegation against the petitioner is founded upon
the contents of an online news report published by ‘Dailyhunt’. It is
pertinent to note that the petitioner has specifically denied having
given any such interview. In support of his stand, he had also
addressed a letter dated 22.03.2019 to the Editor of Odisha Post,
denying having given the alleged interview and seeking publication
of a clarification. At this stage, it is also relevant to note that the
material placed before the learned ACMM does not disclose
examination of the concerned reporter or author of the publication,
or any person associated with the concerned newspaper/news
portal, who could prima facie establish that the alleged words were
in fact uttered by the petitioner. Rather, as pointed out by the
learned counsel for petitioner, the respondent no. 2 had
subsequently arrayed the editor/owner of the said news portal as an
accused in the complaint. Thus, apart from the publication itself,
there was no independent material before the learned ACMM
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 6 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

connecting the alleged statement with the petitioner. In these facts,
this Court also takes note of the decision of the Allahabad High
Court in R.P. Goenka (supra), wherein, while considering a
challenge to criminal defamation proceedings and after taking note
of the law laid down by the Hon ‟ble Supreme Court, it was
observed that a newspaper report is, at best, hearsay or secondary
evidence and its contents are required to be duly proved. The Court
observed that such report could be proved by examining the
reporter who had heard the alleged statement and sent it for
publication, or by producing the concerned reporter and/or editor
of the newspaper.
The said decision, therefore, lends further
support to the proposition that the mere production of a newspaper
report, without the examination of the person who authored or
reported the alleged statement, cannot by itself furnish sufficient
material to establish that the statement was in fact made by the
accused.

21. In view of the aforesaid discussion, and upon an overall
conspectus of the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present
case, this Court is of the considered view that the continuation of
the criminal proceedings against the petitioner would not serve the
ends of justice, particularly when the respondent no. 2, having
examined himself as the sole witness, has not placed any material
to prima facie demonstrate that the alleged imputation had lowered
his reputation in the estimation of others as contemplated under
Explanation 4 to Section 499 of IPC and, further, the alleged
imputation is founded upon an online news report which has not
been supported by examination of the concerned reporter, author,
editor or any other person associated with the news portal,
particularly when the petitioner had specifically denied having
made the alleged statement and had also addressed a
communication seeking clarification in this regard, and in these
peculiar facts and circumstances
.”
12. The dicta laid down in the aforesaid judgment squarely applies to the
facts and circumstances of the present case as well.
13. As noticed, the respondent no.2 has not been appearing in these
proceedings. No one appeared on behalf of the respondent no.2 on
13.12.2024, 14.05.2025, 08.09.2025, 24.03.2026 and 28.04.2026, despite the
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 7 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

last and final opportunity granted to him vide order dated 24.03.2026 to
address arguments; nor has anyone appeared on his behalf on 02.09.2026 or
today. It was also brought to the notice of this Court on 02.09.2026 that the
complainant has not been appearing before the learned trial Court for the last
several dates.
14. This Court has, nevertheless, considered the counter affidavit dated
03.09.2019 filed by the respondent no.2. The same essentially reiterates the
allegation of conflict of interest against the petitioner and asserts, in general
terms, that the publication caused damage to his reputation and that the
evidence need not be appreciated at the stage of summoning. Nothing
therein addresses the absence of any material to show that the alleged
imputation lowered the reputation of the respondent no.2 in the estimation of
others.
15. Considering the totality of circumstances, the judgment dated

25.08.2026 rendered by the Coordinate Bench, I find no impediment in
allowing the present petition.
16. It is also noticed that the impugned order does not consider the
context in which the words were allegedly used by the petitioner and the
dismissal of the complaint by the Bar Council of Delhi. What particularly
weighs with the Court is the fact that the summoning order in the connected
complaint on the same controversy has already been set aside on grounds
identical to those urged in the present petition.
17. Accordingly, the present petition is allowed. The impugned
summoning order dated 20.04.2019 passed by the learned ACMM in
Complaint Case No. 11/2019 is set aside.
18. The Complaint Case No. 11/2019, and all proceedings emanating
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 8 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11

therefrom stand quashed.
19. The petition stands disposed of in the above terms. Pending
application also stand disposed of.
20. Let a copy of this order be sent to the trial Court for information and
necessary compliance.

SACHIN DATTA, J
NOVEMBER 17, 2026/ cl

Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2617/2019 Page 9 of 9

Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:29:11