SRI. M. VENKATESHAPPA vs SRI B.D. VENKATESH
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 785 OF 2020 (MON)
BETWEEN:
SRI. M. VENKATESHAPPA
S/O LATE MUNIYAPPA
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
RESIDING AT BALLERI VILLAGE,
TEKAL TALUK, MALUR TALUK
KOLAR DISTRICT-563 160.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S VISWESWARAIAH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
SRI B.D. VENKATESH
S/O LATE B R DEVANATH
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS
RESIDING AT BENDU NEW EXTENSION
NEAR DOOMLIGHT CIRCLE
KOLAR-563 101.
…RESPONDENT
Digitally
signed by
VANDANA S
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
(RESPONDENT-SERVED & UNREPRESENTED)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SEC.100 OF CPC., AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 18.11.2019 PASSED IN RA.NO. 114/2018
ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE, KOLAR,
DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND MODIFYING THE JUDGMENT AND
DECREE DATED 30.07.2018 PASSED IN OS.NO.285/2015 ON THE FILE OF
THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, MALUR.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT
WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
Appellant was the defendant in O.S. No. 285/2015
filed by the respondent-plaintiff against the appellant-
defendant for recovery of a sum of Rs.5,92,900/- together
with costs and future interest at 24% per annum from the
date of the suit till realization. The said suit was having
been contested by the appellant-defendant who inter alia
contended that he was due only in a sum of Rs.3,00,000/-
and as such the suit was liable to be dismissed. In addition
thereto, the appellant-defendant also putforth a counter
claim against the plaintiff for redemption of a mortgage
deed dated 30.11.2012 and for other reliefs.
2. Based on the pleadings of the parties, the trial court
framed the following issues and additional issues:
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that defendant has
borrowed a loan of Rs.3,25,000/- at the rate of 25% p.a.
(wrongly typed as 25% instead of 24%) as pleaded in the
plaint?
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
2. Whether plaintiff proves that defendant has executed a
mortgage deed in favour of plaintiff relating to suit property as
a security of the said loan as pleaded in the plaint?
3. Whether defendant proves that suit is not maintainable?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled the relief as sought for?
5. What order or decree?
Additional issues framed on 12.7.2018.
1. Whether the defendant proves that, he had paid interest
to the plaintiff till March 2015 as alleged by him in his written
statement at para No.9?
2. Whether the defendant is entitled for the relief of
redemption of mortgage deed dated 30.11.2012 as prayed in
counter claim?
3. Plaintiff examined as PW1, two witnesses as PWs.2
and 3 and got marked documents at Exs.P.1 to P.23.
Defendant got examined as DW1 and examined one
witness DW2. No documents are marked on their behalf.
4. After hearing the parties, the trial Court held as
under:
“9. Issue No.1 and 2:-. Since both issues are interrelated to
each other, both issues have taken together for discussion in
order to avoid the repetition of facts.
10. It is the case of the plaintiff that the defendant had
obtained a hand loan of Rs.3,25,000/- from him by mortgaging
the suit schedule property as a security of the said amount and
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
he is also agreed that he repaid said amount along with
interest @ the rate of 24% p.a. within 2 ½ years and will
redeem the mortgage, but even after the lapse of 2 ½ years
period, he had not repaid the said amount and redeem the
mortgage deed executed by him. More burden lies upon the
plaintiff to prove that he has lend hand loan of Rs.3,25,000/-
and got executed the mortgage deed with respect to suit
schedule property from the defendant. By way of cross
examination of DW1 with respect to the above said fact, the
plaintiff has proved his case. In the cross examination, DW1
has admitted that on 30.11.2012 he had obtained loan from
the plaintiff but it is his defence that he had obtained only
Rs.3,00,000/-, but the plaintiff had written Rs.3,25,000/- in
Ex.P1 mortgage deed. He had never received Rs.3,25,000/-
from the plaintiff. But in the said cross examination he has also
admitted that he had executed a mortgage deed with respect
to property in Sy.No.10 measuring 3 acre 30 guntas situated
at Kadirenahalli village and he is also admitted that the said
document was in the Kannada language and he read over the
entire averments of Ex.P1 and he has also admitted that he
knows the details about the payment of Rs.3,25,000/ by way
of Ex.P1 Mortgage deed. Thereby it is clear that the defendant
had received Rs.3,25,000 from the plaintiff and by admitting
the receipt of the said amount he had also executed Ex.P1
mortgage deed in favour of the plaintiff with respect to the suit
schedule property. DW1 has also admitted that DW2 has put
his signature on Ex.P1 as a witness.
11. It is the defence of defendant that the plaintiff at the
time of lending amount, has received 2 signed blank cheques
and 2 signed stamp papers of Rs. 100/- each and it is his
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
defence that the plaintiff has created the mortgage deed by
using one of the said bond paper. But Ex.P1 is the document
which is written on stamp paper of Rs.4/-, it contents 2 pages
along with another page which reveals that the plaintiff had
paid Rs.1,680/- before the Sub-registrar for registration of the
said document. Hence it is clear that the plaintiff has not
created any mortgage deed by using the above said alleged
stamp paper of Rs.100/-. Moreover the defendant has not
taken any further steps against the plaintiff either by lodging
any complaint before the jurisdictional police or by filling any
complaint before the jurisdictional court for his fraudulent act.
He even has not issued any legal notice in order to recover the
said signed blank cheques and signed blank papers. More over
he himself has admitted in his cross examination that, in order
to obtained the hand loan, he had executed Ex.P1 mortgage
deed in favour the plaintiff. DW1 has also admitted that he has
put his signatures on Ex. P1 after reading and knowing the
entire averments of Ex.P1. Hence, it is sufficient to believe the
case of plaintiff with respect to lending of amount of
Rs.3,25,000/- for repayment of the same along with interest at
the rate of 24% p.a. on the basis of security of the suit
schedule property. Hence I answered these issues 1 and 2 in
the Affirmative.
12. Additional issue No.1:- It is the specific defence of
defendant that till March 2015 he had paid interest to the
plaintiff with respect to the amount borrowed by him on
30.11.2012. He had taken such a defence in para 9 of written
statement. In the same paragraph is has also taken a defence
that the plaintiff has not issued any receipt with respect to
payment of interest and principle amount is concerned. The
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
defendant has not even furnished single documents to show
that he has paid a single rupee of interest with respect the
hand loan borrowed by him from the plaintiff. Hence this issue
is answered in the Negative.
13. Additional issue No.2 and issue no. 4:- It is also one of
the prayer of defendant in his written statement by way of
counter claim that he is entitled for the relief of redemption of
mortgage deed as he is ready to repay Rs.3,00,000/- principal
amount to the plaintiff. It is true that the defendant had
executed the registered mortgage deed in favour of the
plaintiff with respect to suit schedule property by pledging the
same on 30.11.2012 for the loan amount received by him from
the plaintiff. As admitted by him in his cross examination and
in his written statement it is clear that the defendant has not
even either repaid principal amount or interest as agreed by
him till today. The plaintiff in the present suit is seeking for
direction to the defendant to pay sum of Rs.5,92,900 together
with interest at the rate of Rs.24% p.a. from the date of suit
till realization of entire claim. Even though the defendant has
taken a defence that he has paid interest till March 2015, he
has not furnished any iota of the documents to prove his
defence. Hence it is clear that the defendant has not repaid
any amount to the plaintiff. On the other hand the plaintiff
successfully proved that the defendant has received
Rs.3,25,000/- from him on 30.11.2012 by executing a
registered mortgage deed as security with respect to suit
schedule property. Thereby he is entitled for recovery of
Rs.5,92,900/- as claimed by him in this suit.
14. Apart from the above said amount the plaintiff is also
claiming for future interest @ the rate of 24% p.a. on the
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
above said amount from the date of suit till the realization of
entire claim. On the basis of documents available on record
and evidence of both parties it is clear that, the defendant has
received Rs.3,25,000/- from the plaintiff by agreeing to repay
the same within 2 ½ years along with interest @ the rate of
24% p.a., and he had not repaid the said amount till today.
Hence till filing of the suit the plaintiff has calculated the
interest at the rate of 24% p.a. On the amount lend to the
defendant. If this court is considered the interest at the rate of
24% p.a on the amount of Rs.5,92,900/- from the date of suit
till the realization of entire claim, it will cause injustice to the
defendant. Moreover, it is also clear that, the plaintiff has no
money lending license to lend such a huge amount with
interest at the rate of 24% p.a. Hence, imposing interest at the
rate of 24% p.a is too exorbitant.
15. Moreover, the plaintiff has already calculated the
interest at the rate of 24% p.a. on Rs.3,25,000 and till filing of
the present suit it has already been reached up to
Rs.5,92,900/- and if this court will also imposed the same
percentage of interest i.e., at the rate of 24% p.a. on the
above said amount, the defendant will suffer more hardship for
repayment of the same. Hence, imposing the interest at the
rate of 6% p.a as imposed in nationalized banks from the date
of suit till realization of entire amount will meet the ends of
justice. Even though the defendant has executed a registered
mortgage deed by agreeing to repay the loan amount along
with interest @ 24% P.A. and even though this court has
considered the said fact, it also considered the position of
defendant with respect to his financial condition and the too
exorbitant interest charged by the plaintiff on the said amount.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
In order to avoid the future loss which would be caused to the
plaintiff, this court has imposed 6% of interest p.a. for the
above said amount and it is justifiable. Hence I answer issue
No. 4 in partly Affirmative.
16. If the defendant will be repaid the entire amount which
would be imposed by this court for repayment to the plaintiff,
then only he will be entitled for redemption of mortgage deed
dated 30.11.2012 as prayed by him in the counter claim. Since
the defendant has failed to prove repayment of a single rupee
to the plaintiff with respect to the alleged hand loan, he is not
entitled for redemption of mortgage deed dated 30.11.2012.
Hence additional issue no. 2 is answered in the Negative.
17. Issue No.3:- The defendant has taken a defence that the
suit is not maintainable as such even though he was ready to
repay the principle amount of 3,00,000 to the plaintiff, he had
not received the same and filed this frivolous suit for unlawful
gain from the defendant. Even though he has taken such a
defence, he has failed to prove that he has repaid any amount
or interest to the plaintiff till filing of the present suit or even
after filing of this suit. Since the plaintiff has also proved this
case by way of cogent documents and the admissions of DW1
also clearly disclosing that he had borrowed an amount of
Rs.3,25,000/- by agreeing to repay the same with interest @
24% p.a., the defendant has failed to prove that the present
suit is not maintainable for the reasons stated in the his
written statement. Hence this issue is answered in the
Negative.
18. Issue No.5 :- For the foregoing reasons I proceed to
pass following.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
ORDER
The suit filed by the plaintiff is partly decreed with cost.
The plaintiff is entitled to claim Rs.5,92,900/- with
interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of this suit till realization of
entire amount.
The counter claim of defendant with respect to
redemption of mortgage deed dated 30.11.2012 is hereby
dismissed.
The defendant is directed to repay the above said
amount as per the order within 60 days from the date of this
order, failing which the plaintiff is at liberty to recover the
same through due procedure of law.
Charge has been created over the suit schedule property
till realization of entire claim as per order.
Draw decree accordingly.”
5. As can be seen from the aforesaid judgment and
decree of the trial Court, the suit of the plaintiff was
decreed in part by directing the appellant-defendant to
pay a sum of Rs.5,92,000/- together with interest at 6%
per annum from the date of suit till realization. The
counter claim of the appellant-defendant with respect to
redemption of the mortgage deed dated 30.11.2012 was
dismissed by the trial Court. Aggrieved by the judgment
and decree of the trial Court rejecting the counter claim
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
and decreeing the suit of the respondent plaintiff, the
appellant approached the first appellate Court in R.A. No.
114/2018 which was disposed of by the first appellate
Court by dismissing the appeal filed by the appellant
against rejection of his counter claim but allowing the
cross appeal filed by the respondent-plaintiff thereby
enhancing / increasing the rate of interest from 6% per
annum to 12% per annum by holding as under:
8. Heard the arguments and secured Lower Court
Records.
9. The following points arise for consideration: -
1. Whether the Trial Court has erred in coming to the
conclusion that there was financial transaction between
plaintiff & defendant?
2. Whether the Trial Court has failed to appreciate
the fact that the defendant has proved his contentions?
3. Whether the cross-appeal filed by the appellant
under Order XLI Rules 22 (1) & (2) r/w Section 96 CPC
deserves to be allowed?
4. Whether the Trial Court has erred in appreciating
the oral & documentary evidence on record in proper
perspective?
5. Whether the impugned judgment & decree passed
by the Trial Court is erroneous, capricious and calls for
interference of this Court?
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
6. To what order?
10. The answers to the above points are as under: -
Point Nos.1, 2 : Negative
Point Nos.3 - 5 : Partly Affirmative
Point No.6 : As per final order, for the
following:-
R E A S O N S
Point Nos.1 to 5:-
11. The instant appeal is arising out of the impugned
judgment & decree passed by the Trial Court in the suit
instituted by the plaintiff for recovery of money by averring
that the defendant knew him for many years and as such the
defendant had approached him for financial assistance to meet
his urgent legal necessities for which he had lent Rs.3,25,000/-
to the defendant on 30.11.2012 for which he had executed
registered document and towards repayment of the same the
defendant had got issued two cheques which came to be
dishonoured and as such the present suit.
Before adverting to the factual aspects of the case the
evidence led before the Trial Court is recapitulated.
12. The plaintiff before the Trial Court had got
examined himself as PW1 – Sri. B.D. Venkatesh reiterating the
plaint averments. In the cross-examination PW1 had admitted
that he was running TV showroom earlier and was into real
estate business now and he was not into the money lending
business; however, he helps the people who requests him to
accommodate their urgent financial necessities. PW1 had
specifically stated that he had not availed any licence for
running money lending business. PW1 had denied that he had
lent only Rs.3.00 lakh and the said amount was repaid with
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
interest @ 2% per mensum. PW1 had stated that no amount
was repaid to him by the defendant. That apart, nothing much
was elucidated from PW1.
13. PW2 – Sri. Nagaraj has deposed about execution of the
mortgage deed as per Ex.P1 and also identified his signature
on it as per Ex.P1 (b). In the cross-examination PW2 had
admitted that he was working as Village Accountant and had
attained superannuation in the year 2007. PW2 had stated that
he knew the plaintiff for last 5-6 years and he was not his
relative and he was present at the time of negotiating the loan
amount; however in his presence no amount was paid. PW2
had further stated that he had attested his signature to Ex.P1
along with plaintiff, defendant & Varadarajachari.
14. PW3 – Sri. Rudrappa being the scribe of mortgage deed
– Ex.P1 had deposed about execution of Ex.P1. In the cross-
examination PW3 had stated that he was not present at the
time of negotiations nor at the time of receiving the amount by
the defendant. However, PW3 had stated that he knew the
plaintiff for 7-8 years and also PW2 and also Ex.P1 was drafted
by him in the presence of the parties and attesting witnesses.
15. On completion of the evidence of plaintiff, the defendant
had got himself examined as DW1 – Sri. M. Venkateshappa
reiterating the contentions which he had urged in his Written
Statement. In the cross-examination DW1 had admitted about
receiving the loan from the plaintiff on 30.11.2012; however
he had stated that 6 months prior to the said date he had
requested the plaintiff for loan and at that time plaintiff had
insisted for interest @ 1% per mensum and as such they had
discussed about loan transaction through Varadarajachari and
at that time he had executed the mortgage deed pertaining to
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
land in Sy.No.10 of Kadirenahalli Village, Malur Taluk. DW1 had
admitted about affixing his signature to the said document in
the presence of its scribe and also stated about handing over
the document i.e., cheque as security at the instance of the
plaintiff. DW1 had further stated that he was paying Rs.6,000/-
per month as interest to the plaintiff and he had paid the said
interest in the house of plaintiff and also in his office till 2015.
DW1 had further stated that at certain point of time he alone
went to the house of plaintiff to pay the interest and on some
other occasion he was accompanied by Varadarajachari. That
apart, nothing much was elucidated from DW1.
16. DW2 – Sri. K.V. Varadarajaiah had deposed before the
Trial Court that the plaintiff had only paid Rs.3.00 lakh but not
Rs.3,25,000/- to the defendant and he had issued two blank
cheques towards security and also affixed his signature to the
blank stamp paper. In the cross-examination DW2 had stated
that he was working as teacher at Chinmaya Vidyalaya School
and left the job. That apart nothing much was elicited from
DW2.
17. It is clear that the plaintiff & defendant had entered into
loan transaction between themselves. The registered mortgage
deed at Ex.P1 clearly indicates that the plaintiff had lent
Rs.3,25,000/- to the defendant and though the defendant had
denied receiving the said amount it is well settled that always
presumption will be attached to the registered document.
When the defendant admits his signature on the said document
which is registered certain presumption will be attached to it
and under the circumstances the defendant cannot be
permitted to deny its contents by stating that he had only
received Rs.3.00 lakh but not Rs.3,25,000/-. It is also noticed
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
from records that the defendant had executed registered
mortgage deed as per Ex.P1 wherein it has been specifically
mentioned that plaintiff was lending Rs.3,25,000/- to the
defendant and defendant had agreed to repay the same along
with interest @ 2% per mensum and the same should be
repaid within 2½ years. The entire contents of the document
clearly indicate about mortgage of the property. Besides, the
sale deed – Ex.P10 also indicates about title of the defendant
over the said property. Even for the sake of argument if it is
presumed that the same was not valid mortgage deed then the
defendant has to offer explanation that how the said document
came into the custody of plaintiff from which it can safely be
inferred about existence of financial transaction between the
parties.
18. The lis of dispute is to determine whether the plaintiff
had paid Rs.3,25,000/- or Rs.3.00 lakh as contended by the
defendant. DWs 1 & 2 had both deposed that they had only
received Rs.3.00 lakh and not Rs.3,25,000/- as contended by
the plaintiff. Further, it is pertinent to note that PW2 being
attesting witness to Ex.P1 had also deposed that he was not
present at the time of negotiations. However, no questions
were posed to him with respect to the said aspect. All that it
was suggested to PW2 was that no such transaction had taken
place for which he had denied the same. It has to be borne in
mind that though the attesting witnesses and also the scribe of
Ex.P1 had all specifically deposed that they had not witnessed
the loan transaction; however in the wake of clear cut
admission by the defendant/DW1 that he had repaid some
amount to the plaintiff and also availing money from the
plaintiff the same would establish the case of plaintiff. The
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
Court is fully aware of the fact that the plaintiff has to establish
his case independently and he cannot stand upon the
weakness of the defendant. At the same time, the defendant
also cannot be permitted to blow hot & cold in one breath and
take up divergent stand. No doubt, the defendant is permitted
to take up inconsistent stand; however, the same should not
be contrary and self-destructive. In the wake of presumption
available in favour of the registered document i.e., Ex.P1 it is
clear that the plaintiff had lent Rs.3,25,000/- and not Rs.3.00
lakh as contended by the defendant. Unless the defendant
pleads & proves that the said registered document was
fraudulent and created one the presumption which is attached
to the registered document will not be rebutted. Besides, the
defendant himself has admitted execution of the registered
document and in that circumstances the onus will be upon him
to explain why he had got the said document executed when
he had only received sum of Rs.3,00,000/- and not
Rs.3,25,000/- as mentioned in the said document.
19. The next aspect for consideration is levying of interest at
the rate of 2% per mensum. The defendant/ appellant has filed
cross-appeal contending that the rate of interest imposed by
the Trial Court is meager and it should be enhanced to 24%
p.a. The learned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff has
argued that since the transaction is not commercial nature the
rate of interest shall be 6% p.a. In this regard, the Court has
appreciated the mortgage deed at Ex.P1 wherein nowhere it
has been mentioned that for what purpose the said amount
was borrowed. Under the circumstances, it would not be
appropriate to hold that it was for some commercial purpose.
It is well settled by catena of judgments that the rate of
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
interest that will levied for commercial transaction and that of
other transaction will be different. If at all the defendant claims
that the said transaction i.e., the loan was availed by the
plaintiff for commercial transaction the rate of interest to be
levied will be much higher than in any other transaction. Even
nothing was elicited from DW1 with respect to the same.
20. Firstly, parties have agreed for imposing rate of interest
@ 24% p.a. But the Court should be cautious about the said
aspect so as to ascertain whether it is justifiable to impose
such rate of interest. No doubt in the said document it has
been narrated that the parties had agreed for imposing the
interest at the rate of 24% p.a., the question that has to be
answered is whether the Court can look into the said aspect of
imposing the interest rate or whether the Court has to merely
accept the same as narrated in the document. In order to
better appreciate the said aspect the Court has looked into the
provisions under The Karnataka Money Lenders’ Act, 1961,
hereinafter referred as ‘the Act’ wherein Section 11 clearly
indicates that after expiry of six months from the date on
which this Act comes into force, no Court shall pass a decree in
favour of a money-lender in any suit to which this Act applies,
filed by a money-lender, unless the Court is satisfied that at
the time when the loan or any part thereof to which the suit
relates was advanced, and on the date such suit was filed the
money-lender held a valid licence. Thus, it is necessary to
appreciate the fact that whether the plaintiff can be termed as
‘money-lender’ as per the said Act. In order to better
appreciate the same Section 2 (10) of The Act is appreciated
which defines ‘money-lender’. Further, Section 2 (9) of The Act
defines ‘loan.’ When both the aspects are looked into and
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
appreciated the defendant has not taken up any pains in this
regard to show that the plaintiff was not money-lender. The
learned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff has vehemently
argued that the said amount was lent towards commercial
transaction and further he was licensed money lender. In the
instant case, no such documents are produced and as already
discussed there are no material to indicate that the money was
lent towards commercial transaction. However, the Court
cannot fill up the lacunas and blanks which have been left over
by the plaintiff.
21. It is pertinent to note that during the course of cross-
examination PW1 had admitted that he was running TV
showroom and lastly he was into the real estate business but
he was not money-lender. When the plaintiff/PW1 himself had
admitted that he was not money-lender the question of
imposing rate of interest @ 24% p.a., does not arise at all. In
order to better appreciate the factual aspects and also the
guidelines for imposing of interest the Court has relied upon
the dictum laid down by The Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka
in (2017) 5 Kar.L.J. 378 (Tahira Rehman v. Manipal
Sowbhagya Nidhi Ltd.,) has held thus:
12. Adverting to the arguments advanced by the
Learned Counsel for the parties, it would be beneficial to
refer to the relevant provisions of the Act. Section 2(9),
2(10), 2(20) and Section 11 of the Act, which runs thus:
“2. Definitions.- In this Act, unless the context otherwise
requires—
(9) “Loan” means an advance at interest whether of
money or in kind, and includes any transaction which the
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
Court finds in substance to amount to such an advance,
but does not include, —
(a) a deposit of money or other property in a
Government Post Office Bank or in a Karnataka
Government Savings Bank or in any other bank or in a
company or with a co-operative society;
(b) a loan to, or by, or a deposit with, any society or
association registered under the Karnataka Societies
Registration Act, 1960 (Karnataka Act 17 of 1960);
(c) a loan advanced by Government or by any local
authority authorised by Government;
(d) a loan advanced by a co-operative society;
(e) an advance made to a subscriber to, or a depositor
in, a Provident Fund from the amount standing to his
credit in the fund in accordance with the rules of the
fund;
(f) a loan to or by an insurance company as defined in
the Insurance Act, 1938 (Central Act IV of 1938);
(g) a loan to or by a bank;
(h) an advance of not less than three thousand rupees
made on the basis of a negotiable instrument as defined
in the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (Central Act
XXVI of 1881) other than on the basis of a promissory
note;
(i) except for the purposes of sections 28 and 29,—
(i) a loan to a trader;
(ii) a loan to a money-lender who holds a valid licence;
or
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
(iii) a loan by a landlord to his tenant for financing of
crops or seasonal finance of not more than fifty rupees
per acre of land held by the tenant;
(10) “Money Lender” means, —
(i) an individual; or
(ii) an undivided Hindu family; or
(iii) a company; or
(iv) an unincorporated body of individuals; who or
which, —
(a) carries on the business of money-tending in the
State; or
(b) has his or its principal place of such business in the
State, but shall not include a bank [or any other
financial institution which the State Government may, by
notification specify in this behalf];
(20) “Trader” means a person who in the regular course
of business buys and sells goods or other property,
whether movable or immovable, and includes—
a wholesale or retail merchant,
a commission agent,
a broker,
a manufacturer,
a contractor,
a factory owner,
but does not include an artisan or a person who sells his
agricultural produce or cattle or buys agricultural
produce or cattle for his use.
11. [xxxxxx] Suits by money lenders not holding
licence.— (1) After the expiry of six months from the
date on which this Act comes into force, no court shall
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
pass a decree in favour of a money lender in any suit to
which this Act applies, filed by a money lender, unless
the court is satisfied that at the time when the loan or
any part thereof to which the suit relates was advanced,
[and on the date such suit was filed] the money lender
held a valid licence.
[(2) xxxxxx
(3) xxxxxx
(4) xxxxxx]
(5) Nothing in this section shall affect.—
(a) suits in respect of loans advanced by a money-lender
before the date on which this Act comes into force;
(b) the powers of an official receiver, an administrator or
a Court under the provisions of the Mysore Insolvency
Act, 1925, or other corresponding law in force in any
area of the State, or of a liquidator under the Companies
Act, 1956, to realise the property of a moneylender.”
13. As per Clause (i) of sub-Section (9) of Section 2,
except for the purpose of Section 28, a loan to a trader
cannot be construed as a loan for the purpose of the Act.
To analyze whether the plaintiff is a trader, it has to be
examined with reference to the definition Clause of
trader which includes a contractor. The loan was
borrowed by defendant No. 1 who was a contractor and
defendant No. 2 (both are partners of Regency
Buildersdefendant No. 7). If the case is analyzed in this
angle, certainly the provisions of the Act are not
applicable to the facts of the present case. Yet another
important aspect which keeps the plaintiff out of the
purview of the Act is the Notification dated 9th
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
September, 1992 issued by the Government of
Karnataka under Clause 4(b) of Section 2(10) of the Act.
Section 2(10)(4)(b) contemplates, any other financial
institutions other than a Bank which the State
Government may by notification notify, would not come
within the realm of the expression ‘money lender’. Such
notification being issued by the Government of
Karnataka, the provisions of the Act are totally
inapplicable to the facts of the case. In view of the
same, the arguments of the Learned Counsel for
defendant Nos. 2 and 4 do not inspire any credence as
regards the point of jurisdiction is concerned.
15. It is axiomatic to refer to the Judgments relied upon
by the appellant's Counsel. In the case of Smt
Surasaibalini Debi (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court has
held that in the absence of pleadings, the defendant was
not entitled to rely on the taint of illegality in the
transaction to pursue the Court to reject the relief
claimed by the plaintiff. It was held that where a
contract or transaction ex facie is illegal there need be
no pleading of the parties raising the issue of illegality
and the Court is bound to take judicial notice of the
nature of the contract or transaction and mould its relief
accordingly. In the case of Kalojitalusappa Gangavathi
(supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court was considering the
case wherein the plaintiff had not obtained the license
while advancing the money to the defendants on the
transaction of mortgage and promissory note and
wherein it was proved that the plaintiff was at the date
of transactions carrying on business as a money lender.
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
It was held that the Court was bound to dismiss the suit
for recovery of the amount in the course of his business
as a money lender. The judgment of this Court in the
case of Bawaenterprises (supra) also related to the case
of a money lender vis-a-vis the embargo on the power
of the Court to pass a decree. Similarly, the judgment of
this Court in K. Lakshmipathy (supra) also relates to the
money lender and the bar of passing decree in favour of
money lender in any suit to which the Act applies. In the
judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in
Thota Venkata Rao's case (supra) a specific assertion
was made in the written statement that the plaintiff was
doing money lending business. In that context, it was
held that whether there is a pleading or no pleading, in a
suit relating to a loan under the Act, it is the duty of the
Court to frame issues, whether the plaintiff has money
lending business licence and whether he has been
maintaining accounts for the same as required under the
Act.
16. As discussed above, in all these judgments referred
to above, the fulcrum of dispute revolves round the
money lender engaged in the business of lending money
and seeking for the relief of recovery of the amount in a
suit. In such circumstances, where there is no dispute
regarding the applicability of the provisions of the Act,
the Courts have held that Section 11 of the Act is an
embargo for the Courts to decree the suit. But the same
is not the factual position in the instant case. As
aforesaid, the provisions of the Act are not at all
applicable to the present case. Thus, the said judgments
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
relied on by the Learned Counsel for defendant Nos. 2
and 4 are not applicable to the present case. In addition
to this, the Judgment of the Gujarat High Court also
comes to the assistance of the plaintiff. Hence, we
answer the point No. 1 in the Affirmative.
17. As regards the rate of interest at 26.5% per annum
awarded by the Trial Court, it is beneficial to refer to
Section 3 and Section 5 of the Interest Act, 1978,
whereby it is provided that any interest liable to be paid
on any debt or damages by virtue of an obligation
imposed by contract, the rate of interest payable under
Section 3, shall not be applicable and the contractual
rate of interest stipulated in the agreement prevails.
Sections 3 and 5 of the Interest Act, 1978 reads thus:
“3. Power of court to allow interest.— (1) In any
proceedings for the recovery of any debt or damages or
in any proceedings in which a claim for interest in
respect of any debt or damages already paid is made,
the court may, if it thinks fit, allow interest to the person
entitled to the debt or damages or to the person making
such claim, as the case may be, at a rate not exceeding
the current rate of interest, for the whole or part of the
following period, that is to say,—
(a) if the proceedings relate to a debt payable by virtue
of a written instrument at a certain time, then, from the
date when the debt is payable to the date of institution
of the proceedings;
(b) if the proceedings do not relate to any such debt,
then, from the date mentioned in this regard in a written
notice given by the person entitled or the person making
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
the claim to the person liable that interest will be
claimed, to the date of institution of the proceedings:
Provided that where the amount of the debt or damages
has been repaid before the institution of the
proceedings, interest shall not be allowed under this
section for the period after such repayment.
(2) xxxxxx
(a) xxxxxx
(b) xxxxxx
(3) Nothing in this section,—
(a) shall apply in relation to—
(i) any debt or damages upon which interest is payable
as of right, by virtue of any agreement; or
5. Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 to
apply. - Nothing in this Act shall affect the provisions of
Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of
1908).
18. Section 34 of CPC., and the proviso thereof reads
thus:
“34. Interest - (1) Where and insofar as a decree is for
the payment of money, the Court may, in the decree,
order interest at such rate as the Court deems
reasonable to be paid on the principal sum adjudged,
from the date of the suit to the date of the decree, in
addition to any interest on such principal sum for any
period prior to the institution of the suit, with further
interest at such rate not exceeding six per cent per
annum as the Court deems reasonable on such
principal sum, from the date of the decree to the date
of payment, or to such earlier date as the Court thinks
fit:
Provided that where the liability in relation to the sum
so adjudged had arisen out of a commercial
transaction, the rate of such further interest may
exceed six per cent per annum, but shall not exceed
the contractual rate of interest or where there is no
contractual rate, the rate at which moneys are lent or
advanced by nationalized banks in relation to
commercial transactions.
Explanation I - In this sub-Section, “nationalized bank”
means a corresponding new bank as defined in the
Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of
Undertakings) Act, 1970.
Explanation II - For the purposes of this Section, a
transaction is a commercial transaction, if it is
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
connected with the industry, trade or business of the
party incurring the liability.”
19. Ex. P1 - on demand promissory note bears the
signature of the defendant Nos. 1 and 2. It was argued
that the defendant Nos. 2 and 4 are pardanashin ladies
and they do not have any knowledge or experience of
worldly affairs, they blindly signed the papers, mostly
blank as desired by the 1st defendant as they had
implicit faith and confident in him and they had no
reason to suspect his bona fide at that time as they
were the partners of the 1st defendant. The said
arguments cannot be countenanced primarily for the
reason that the defendant Nos. 2 and 4 were the
partners with the 1st defendant and they were engaged
in the business. The loan was raised as a commercial
loan to meet the financial requirements of the
defendant No. 7 partnership firm. As such, the
defendant Nos. 2 and 4 cannot be considered to have
affixed their signature blindly on the blank papers. Ex.
P20 - the deed of reconstitution of partnership deed
dated 10.01.1992 further clarifies that the managing
partner shall negotiate with the bank/s, financial
institution or such other parties for the purpose of
obtaining loans, overdrafts, cash-credits etc., and he
shall execute the necessary loan papers and documents
etc., and shall operate such account/facilities for and
on behalf of the interest of the firm. The defendant No.
1 was the managing partner of the defendant No. 7
partnership firm and authorized to execute the
necessary documents on behalf of the firm. Ex. P23 -
the certified copy of the release and reconstitution of
partnership firm of the defendant No. 7 executed
between defendant No. 1, defendant No. 5, defendant
No. 6 - who are continuing partners and the defendant
No. 2 and defendant No. 4 - the retiring partners
indicates, the retiring partners (defendant Nos. 2 and
4) have agreed to take upon the entire outstanding
liabilities of plaintiff Company amounting to Rs. 68.06
lakhs as on 31.03.2001 along with all future interest.
The retiring partners have agreed to clear the said
liability on or before 30.09.2002, without fail and
without seeking any extension of time and were
required to make necessary arrangement to release the
properties which was offered as security to the plaintiff
Company, a part of which as now fallen to the share of
continuing partners. Further, it was agreed that the
retiring partners are entitled to sell or mortgage the
properties detailed in Item Nos. 1 and 2 of Schedule ‘B’
on or before 30.09.2002 to discharge the liabilities of
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
plaintiff Company and/or Bank of Madura Limited
(presently merged with ICICI Bank limited). These two
documents clearly establishes that the defendant Nos.
2 and 4 had the knowledge of the liabilities of
discharging the loan amount of Rs. 68.06 Lakhs as on
31.03.2001 with all future interest to the plaintiff
Company. The Ex. P 1 - on demand promissory note
stipulates that the defendants shall pay interest at the
rate of 26.5% compounded with monthly rests on the
loan amount of Rs. 50 lakhs, the purpose of loan was
for the business. Indisputably, the defendants had
agreed to pay interest at the rate of 26.5% per annum
as the loan raised was for a commercial purpose. It is
imperative that in case of bilateral agreements entered
into between the parties agreeing to pay the specified
rate of interest stipulated therein, such rate of interest
shall apply the Learned Counsel for the defendant Nos.
2 and 4 argued that in view of Section 34 of CPC, the
rate of interest has to be reduced. But as per the
proviso, where the liability in relation to the sum so
adjudged had arisen out of a commercial transaction,
the rate of such further interest may exceed 6% p.a.,
but shall not exceed the contractual rate of interest.
The judgments relied upon by the Learned Counsel for
defendants 2 and 4, lays down that award of interest,
pendente lite and post decree, is discretionary with the
Court, as it is essentially governed by Section 34 CPC
dehors the contract between the parties. However,
such discretion shall be exercised fairly and 27 R.A.
No.114/2018 judiciously. Considering the totality of
circumstances of the case particularly, contractual rate
of interest agreed between the parties at 26.5% per
annum, with monthly rests, arising out of a commercial
transaction as explained in Explanation-II read with
Proviso to Section 34 CPC coupled with Sections 3(3)
and 5 of the Interest Act, we find that ends of justice
would be met by awarding simple interest at 12% per
annum from the date of filing of the suit till the
realisation. The judgment and decree impugned is
modified to the said extent. Point No. 2 is answered
accordingly”.
In the above said ruling the Hon’ble High Court of
Karnataka has dealt with the right of the parties to levy
the interest and also the extent to which it could be
levied. Further the Hon’ble High Court has discussed
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
about the manner in which the said interest is to be
levied. Apart from that, the Hon’ble High Court has also
discussed about the provisions of Section 34 CPC which
empowers the Court to impose interest in a suit for
recovery of money. When the said ruling is appreciated
with the judgment rendered by the Trial Court there is
no explanation that why the rate of interest is levied at
6% p.a. It is well settled that the Court has to give
explanation with respect to awarding of interest. In the
instant case, as could be noticed there are no clear
averments to show that the said amount was lent
towards commercial transaction and further there are no
materials to indicate that the plaintiff is a licensed
money lender and the equity has to be balanced. In the
instant case, the execution of the document is already
proved and it is the cardinal principal of law that when
the signature is admitted the party cannot feign his
ignorance about its contents. Though the Court has
accepted the other contention in the said document the
levying of the interest is very high and as such the
intervention of the Court is required and also in order to
balance the equity the Court is of the opinion that the
interest awarded by the Trial Court @ 6% p.a., is
minimum and same requires to be enhanced to 12%
p.a.
22. Considering all these aspects the impugned judgment &
decree is to be modified to that extent only and as such point
Nos.1, 2 need to be answered in the negative and point Nos.3
to 5 need to be answered partly in the affirmative and they are
answered accordingly.
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
Point No.6: -
23. In the result, the Court would like to pass the following:-
O R D E R
1. The cross-appeal filed by the appellant under
Order XLI Rules 22 (1) & (2) r/w Section 96 CPC is
allowed in part.
2. The appeal is dismissed.
3. Consequently, the impugned judgment & decree
dated 30.07.2018 passed by the learned Senior Civil
Judge, Malur, in O.S. No.285/2015 is modified only to
the extent of awarding rate of interest from 6% p.a., to
12% p.a., from the date of the suit till complete
realization.
4. Considering the facts & circumstance of the case
there is no order as to costs.
5. Draw decree accordingly.
6. Aggrieved by the impugned judgment and decree of
the trial Court and first appellate Court, the appellant is
before this Court by way of the present appeal which was
admitted on 08.10.2026 to consider the following
substantial questions of law:
i) Whether the Courts below are justified in decreeing
the suit which is based on calculation of interest at 24%
p.a. on Rs.3,25,000/- from the date of transaction till the
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
date of suit, when the appellant has proved that he
received hand loan of Rs.3,00,000/- only and that he has
paid interest till March 2015?
ii) Whether the Trial Court is justified in rejecting the
counter claim of the appellant for redemption of mortgage
in view of the fact that the Appellant is ready to repay the
principal amount to the Respondent?
iii) Whether the Appellate Court is justified in allowing
the cross objections filed by the Respondent and
dismissing the appeal of the Appellant, though the Apellant
has proved that he has received only Rs.3,00,000/- as
against Rs.3,25,000/- and that he has paid interest till
March 2015 to the Respondent ?
iv) Whether the Appellate court is justified in allowing
the cross objections of the Respondent by modifying the
rate of interest from 6% p.a. to 12% p..a. though the
transaction is not commercial and that apart the
Respondent has not proved that he is a money lender?
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
v) Whether the Appellate court is proper in relying upon
the decision of this Hon'ble court reported in (2017) 5 KLJ
378 to hold that the respondent is entitled for interest at
12% p.a. though the ratio of the said case do not apply to
the facts of the case on hand?
vi) Whether the Appellate Court is justified in awarding
interest at 12% p.a. it is against Section 34 of CPC?
7. Heard learned counsel for the appellant and perused
the material on record. The respondent having been
served with notice of the appeal has chosen to remain
unrepresented and has not contested the appeal.
8. Re. substantial questions of law No. 1 to 3 :
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that
both the Courts have correctly and properly considered
and appreciated the entire material on record and have
come to the conclusion that the appellant was liable to pay
a sum of Rs.5,92,000/- to the respondent-plaintiff which
had been established by legal and acceptable evidence
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
adduced by the respondent-plaintiff before the trial Court.
In addition thereto, both the Courts have also come to the
correct conclusion that the appellant's counter claim for
redemption of mortgage was liable to be dismissed by
correctly and properly appreciating the material on record.
Upon reconsideration, re-appreciation and re-evaluation of
the entire material on record, I am of the considered
opinion that the appellants have not made out valid or
sufficient grounds to interfere with the findings of fact
recorded by both the Courts in relation to decreeing the
suit of the plaintiff and rejection of the counter claim of
the defendant. Accordingly substantial questions of law
Nos. 1, 2 and 3 are accordingly answered against the
appellant.
9. Re. substantial questions of law nos. 4, 5 and 6 :
A perusal of the material on record, in particular the
judgment and decree of the trial Court will clearly indicate
that the trial Court has correctly and properly considered
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
and appreciated the material on record and has come to
the correct conclusion that the appellant was liable to pay
interest at 6% per annum from the date of the suit till
realisation which was in conformity/consonance with the
principles underlying Section 34 CPC. However while in the
cross objections filed by the respondent-plaintiff, the first
appellate Court has clearly committed an error in
enhancing the interest from 6% per annum to 12% per
annum which is contrary to the provisions contained in
Section 34 CPC. In this context, the first appellate Court
also committed an error in placing reliance upon the
decision of this Court in the case of Tahira Rehman
versus Manipal Soubhagya Nidhi Ltd. Reported in
(2017) 5 Kar.L.J. without appreciating that the factual
circumstances obtaining in the said case were completely
different than the factual circumstances of the instant case
and having come to the conclusion that the plaintiff was
not a money lender and the standard rate of interest in
relation to fixed deposits and since the transaction
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
between the parties was not a commercial transaction,
there was no occasion/warrant for the first appellate Court
to increase the rate of interest from 6% to 12% which is
impermissible in law given the factual circumstances
obtaining in the instant case.
10. Under these circumstances, I am of the considered
opinion that the substantial questions of law Nos.4, 5 and
6 deserves to be answered in favour of the appellant by
setting aside the judgment and decree of the first
appellate Court and by restoring the judgment and decree
of the trial Court by granting interest at 6% per annum
instead of 12% per annum in favour of the respondent-
plaintiff against the appellant-defendant no. 1.
11. In the result, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
(i) Appeal is hereby partly allowed.
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
(ii) The impugned judgment and decree of the trial
Court and First Appellate Court rejecting the counter claim
of the appellant defendant is hereby confirmed;
(iii) The impugned judgment and decree of the trial
Court and First Appellate Court directing the appellant to
pay a sum of Rs.5,92,000/- is confirmed.
(iv) The Judgment and Decree of the First Appellate
Court directing the appellant to pay 12% per annum on
Rs.5,92,900/- from the date of suit till payment is hereby
set aside.
(v) The judgment and decree of the trial Court
directing the appellant to pay interest at 6% per annum on
Rs.5,92,900/- from the date of the suit till payment is also
is hereby restored.
(vi) However since the appellant has already paid
deposited a sum of Rs.4,90,750/- before this Court on
22.04.2022 which covers interest at 6% per annum up to
that date, the appellant shall not be liable to pay any
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63631
RSA No. 785 of 2020
CNR: KAHC010090972020
interest on the decretal amount from the date of deposit
till realization
(vii) The aforesaid amount of Rs.4,92,000/- shall be
transmitted to the trial Court for disbursement in favour of
the respondent plaintiff.
(viii) It is made clear that except the amount already
deposited by the appellant-plaintiff which covers interest
at 6% per annum up to the date of deposits which is now
being directed to be transferred amount to the trial Court
for disbursement in favour of the respondent, the
appellant shall not be liable to pay any further amount to
the respondent plaintiff.
Sd/-
(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
BVV
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 14