SRI SHIVABEERAIAH vs UNITED INDIA INSU.CO.LTD.,

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.2470 OF 2017(MV-I)

BETWEEN:

SRI SHIVABEERAIAH
S/O AKKIBEERAIAH @ CHIKKABVEERAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
TH
R/AT NO.113, 7 CROSS,
TH
6 MAIN, VINAYAKANAGAR,
KENGERI SATELLITE TOWN,
BANGALORE - 560 060.

…APPELLANT






[BY SRI K.T. GURUDEV PRASAD, ADVOCATE (PH)]

AND:

1. UNITED INDIA INSU.CO.LTD.,
T P CLAIMS HUB,
TH TH
5 & 6 FLOORS,
KRUSHI BHAVAN,
HUDSON CIRCLE,
BANGALORE - 560 002
BY ITS MANAGER.

2. M/s. SAPHIRE MOTORS PVT. LTD.,
NO.108, SY NO.36/2A,
PATTANAGERE, B M S FARMS,
TH
13 KM, MYSORE ROAD,
BANGALORE - 560 059.

…RESPONDENTS



Digitally signed
by ANUSHA V
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka

[BY SRI LAKSHMI NARASAPPA KS., ADVOCATE FOR
SRI A.M.VENKATESH, ADVOCATE FOR R1 (PH);
SRI V.B.SHIVA KUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR R2]

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 18.10.2016 PASSED IN MVC
NO.3915/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE XXI ADDL.SMALL CAUSES
JUDGE AND THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL (SCCH-
23) AT BENGALURU, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION
FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF
COMPENSATION.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING , THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI

ORAL JUDGMENT

Challenging judgment and award dated 18.10.2016
passed by XXI Additional Small Causes Judge and MACT
(SCCH-23), Bengaluru (' Tribunal '), in MVC no.3915/2014, this
appeal is filed.


2. Sri Gurudev Prasad K.T., learned counsel for
appellant submitted that appeal was by claimant for
enhancement of compensation.


3. Brief facts leading to this appeal as per claimant
were that at 11:30 am on 20.03.2014, when claimant standing
in front of Aravinda Garments at Kengeri, driver of Car no.KA-

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



41/TC-NT-02 drove it in rash and negligent manner and dashed
against claimant causing accident. In accident, claimant
sustained grievous injuries and despite treatment at
Rajarajeshwari Hospital, BGS Global Hospital and Shreya
Hospital, he did not recover fully and sustained permanent
physical disability and loss of earning capacity. Claiming
compensation, he filed claim petition in MVC no.3915/2014
under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (' MV Act ')
against owner and insurer of Car.


4. On contest, wherein claim petition was opposed on
all grounds, including alleging violation of terms and conditions
of policy and contributory negligence, Tribunal framed issues
and recorded evidence.


5. Claimant along with 3 others including Dr.Nagesh
S.A., deposed as PWs.1 to 4 and got marked Exs.P1 to P29. On
other hand, respondents also examined 4 witnesses marked as
RWs.1 to 4 and got marked Exs.R1 to R19.


6. On consideration, Tribunal held accident had
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of Car by its driver,

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



claimant had sustained permanent physical disability/loss of
earning capacity and was entitled for compensation of
Rs.
26,51,246/- with interest at 6% per annum from owner and
insurer. Dissatisfied with same, claimant was in appeal.


7. It was submitted that as on date of accident
claimant was 43 years of age, auto owner/driver earning
Rs.18,000/- per month. To substantiate same, he had produced
Auto Driving Licence as Ex.P10 and RC Book and Loan Pass
Book as Exs.P11 and P13 respectively. Despite same, Tribunal
erred in considering his monthly income at only Rs.7,500/-. It
was submitted that in accident claimant sustained severe head
injury due to which bifrontal craniotomy for bifrontal contusions
and diffuse cerebral oedema was conducted on 20.03.2014.
Thereafter he underwent bone flap replacement surgery on
25.07.2014. Despite same, claimant became virtual deadwood.
He had sustained loss of partial memory, slurring of speech,
watering in his right eye, cognitive and behavioral deficit
rendering him unfit for avocation, Tribunal rightly considered
his functional disability at 100%. However, it erred in not
adding future prospects to monthly income. Apart from above,

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



it was submitted that Tribunal erred in awarding only sum of
Rs.
1,00,000/- towards pain and suffering, Rs.11,00,000/-
towards medical expenses, Rs.25,000/- towards food,
nourishment and conveyance charges, Rs.20,000/- towards
loss of earning during laid-up period, Rs.20,000/- towards
attending charges, award of Rs.75,000/- towards loss of
amenities and Rs.50,000/- towards future medical expenses
were on lower side and sought enhancement.


8. On the other hand, Sri Lakshmi Narasappa, learned
counsel appearing for Sri A.M. Venkatesh, advocate for
respondent no.1 - insurer opposed appeal. It was submitted
that Tribunal had considered facts and circumstances of case in
proper perspective and assessed total disablement. Therefore,
there was no scope for enhancement.


9. Heard learned counsel, perused impugned
judgment, award and record.


10. From above, only point that would arise for
consideration is:

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



"Whether claimant is entitled for
enhancement of compensation?"


11. Same is answered partly in affirmative for
following reason:

i. At outset, it is seen that claimant stated that he
was 43 years of age, owner/driver of auto and
earning Rs.18,000/- per month by driving auto
rickshaw and produced Driving Licence, RC Book in
respect of auto rickshaw as well as Loan Pass Book
as Exs.P10, P11 and P13. Accident occurred in year
2014, notional income for said period being
Rs.8,500/-. Tribunal would not be justified in taking
it at Rs.7,500/-. Considering fact that claimant was
also remitting loan instalments towards purchase of
auto rickshaw, it is found appropriate to consider
his monthly income at slightly higher than notional
income, at Rs.9,000/-.


ii. As per decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Erudhaya Priya v. State Express Transport
Corporation Ltd. , reported in 2020 SCC OnLine

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



SC 601 , future prospects has to be added to
monthly income even in personal injury claim. Since
claimant was self-employed and aged between 40
and 50 years, appropriate multiplier would be '14'
and future prospects at 25% has to be added. Thus,
compensation towards future loss of income would
be (Rs.9,000/- + 25%) = Rs.11,250/- X 100% X 12
X 14 = Rs.18,90,000/- .


iii. Tribunal has awarded some of Rs.75,000/- towards
loss of amenities. Considering fact that claimant has
lost partial memory, hearing and partial sight which
he would rendering him unable to enjoy faculties
during remainder of his life, said amount would be
grossly inadequate and therefore enhanced to
Rs.1,50,000/- .


iv. Claimant sustained head injury and had to undergo
craniotomy for bifrontal contusions and diffused
cerebral oedema and bone flap replacement surgery
involving inpatient treatment for period of 115

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



days. Considering pain endured, award of
Rs.1,00,000/- towards same would be inadequate
and is enhanced to Rs.2,00,000/- . Tribunal has
awarded Rs.11,01,246/- towards medical
expenses, which is in full reimbursement of bills,
there would be no scope for enhancement.


v. Tribunal has awarded Rs.20,000/- towards
attendant charges and Rs.25,000/- towards food,
nourishment and conveyance which would be
approximately Rs.500/- for each day of inpatient
treatment and same appears just and proper.


vi. Since assessment of disability is at 100% from date
of accident, there would be no scope for
enhancement of compensation towards loss of
income during period of treatment, Rs.20,000/-
awarded towards loss of earning during period of
treatment is sustained.


vii. PWs.1 and 4 have stated about claimant suffering
from loss of partial memory, slurring of speech,

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017



watering in his right eye, cognitive and behavioral
deficit, Tribunal has awarded only Rs.50,000/-
towards same would be inadequate. Therefore, if it
is enhanced to Rs.1,50,000/-, it would appear
proper. Thus, claimant is held entitled for enhanced
compensation of Rs.35,56,246/- .


12. In view of above, following:
ORDER

(a) Appeal is allowed in part , judgment
and award dated 18.10.2016 passed by
Tribunal, in MVC no.3915/2014 is
modified , enhancing total
compensation to Rs.35,56,246/- as
against Rs.26,51,246/- assessed by
Tribunal.


(b) Same shall carry interest of 6% per
annum from date of claim petition till its
realization.


(c) Insurer is directed to deposit enhanced
compensation with interest at 6%
before Tribunal within six weeks.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62754
MFA No. 2470 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010380012017




(d) On deposit, Tribunal is directed to
release 40% of amount in favour of
claimant and keep remaining 60% in
fixed deposit in any nationalized bank,
at highest rate of interest, for a period
of five years, with liberty to claimant to
seek release of same in case it is
required for treatment.


Sd/-
(RAVI V HOSMANI)
JUDGE



GRD
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 29