K.M. SHAJI vs THE STATE OF KERALA

Court
Kerala High Court

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..1..
2026:KER:88204
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C. JAYACHANDRAN
TH
THURSDAY, THE 19 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026 / 28TH KARTHIKA,
1948
OP(CRL.) NO. 391 OF 2023
CRIME NO.2/2021 OF VACB, KOZHIKODE
AGAINST CMP NO.132 OF 2020 OF THE ENQUIRY
COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL JUDGE, KOZHIKODE.
PETITIONER/ACCUSED:
K.M. SHAJI
AGED 52 YEARS, S/O.BEERANKUTTY,
KALATHODIKA HOUSE, NEAR A.R. CAMP,
NGO QUARTERS, VENGERI P.O.,
KOZHIKKODE, PIN - 673010
BY
ADV.BABU S. NAIR
ADV.SMITHA BABU
RESPONDENTS/STATE & COMPLAINANT:
1 THE STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY,
GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..2..
2026:KER:88204
2 THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
VIGILANCE AND ANTI CORRUPTION BUREAU,
SPECIAL CELL, MAVOOR ROAD, KOZHIKKODE,
PIN - 673016
3 ADV. M.R. HARISH
AGED 51 YEARS, S/O.RAJEEVAN,
CHEMBARATHI, NEAR R.K. MISSION L.P. SCHOOL,
KALLAI P.O., KOZHIKKODE, PIN - 673003
BY
ADV.C.V.MANUVILSAN
ADV.NAEEM IBRAHIM
ADV.O.A.ANJU
ADV.VRINDA LAKSHMANAN
ADV.SAMEER.S. - PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS OP (CRIMINAL) HAVING BEEN CAME UP FOR HEARING ON
19.11.2026, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..3..
2026:KER:88204

“C.R.”
J U D G M E N T
Petitioner challenges Ext.P4 F.I.R, which was registered by
the Investigating Officer pursuant to Ext.P2 Order of the
Special Court, directing preliminary enquiry. The offences
alleged against the petitioner as per Ext.P4 F.I.R are
under Section 13(2), read with Section 13(1)(e); and
Section 13(2), read with Section 13(1)(b) of the Prevention
of Corruption Act ('the P.C Act', for short).
2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the
learned Public Prosecutor. Perused the records.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that
the registration of Ext.P4 F.I.R, pursuant to Ext.P2 Order,
is illegal for want of sanction under Section 19 of the P.C
Act. It has been categorically held in Anil Kumar and
Others v. M.K. Aiyappa and Another [2013 KHC 4790 (SC)]

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..4..
2026:KER:88204
that even for directing investigation under Section 156(3)
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, sanction under Section
19 is required. The mere fact that the dictum laid down in
Anil Kumar (supra) was referred for consideration by a
larger Bench in Manju Surana v. Sunil Arora, and Others
[2018 KHC 6224 (SC)] cannot impact the precedential value
of Anil Kumar (supra). This aspect was referred and
answered twice by two Division Benches of this Court in
Mohammed V.A and Others v. State of Kerala and Others [2019
(1) KHC 239 (Ker.)]; and recently, in A.K. Sreekumar v.
State of Kerala [Crl.M.C.No.4677/2022]. Thus, according to
the learned counsel, so long as Anil Kumar (supra) holds
the field, registration of Ext.P4 F.I.R, which is
indisputably pursuant to Ext.P2 Order, without obtaining
sanction under Section 19, can hardly be sustained in law.
4. Secondly, learned counsel would also attack Ext.P2
Order by pointing out that the preliminary enquiry ordered
is against the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..5..
2026:KER:88204
Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh and Others
[2013 (4) KLJ 686]. Learned counsel would point out that
there cannot be any preliminary enquiry to ascertain
whether the allegations are genuine and true, as found by
the learned Special Judge in Ext.P2. The said course is
squarely in the teeth of the concluding directions
contained in clause no.(v) of Lalita Kumari (supra). The
scope of preliminary enquiry is only to ascertain whether a
cognizable offence is made out or not. Once a cognizable
offence is made out, the inevitable course is to register
an F.I.R. At any rate, there cannot be a preliminary
enquiry to ascertain the prima facie veracity or otherwise
of the information received in the complaint. Referring to
Ext.P2 impugned Order, learned counsel would submit that
the Special Judge had entertained a view that the complaint
contained allegations regarding offences punishable under
the P.C Act. If that be so, the preliminary enquiry ordered
to ascertain whether the allegations are genuine and true,
vitiates Ext.P2 Order. Yet another contention urged by the

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..6..
2026:KER:88204
learned counsel to attack Ext.P2 is the reference to
Section 17A of the amended Prevention of Corruption Act.
Such reference should not have made, especially when the
Special Court found in paragraph no.7 that the allegation
is not relatable to any recommendation made, or decision
taken by, a public servant in discharge of his duties.
Thus, learned counsel would conclude that, Ext.P2 Order
cannot be sustained.
5. In answer, learned Public Prosecutor would submit
that, Ext.P2 Order only directed a preliminary enquiry to
be conducted and wanted the Investigating Officer to file a
report before the Court. Learned Public Prosecutor argued
that, once a cognizable offence is revealed during the
course of preliminary enquiry, there is no legal bar to
register an F.I.R. In this regard, learned Public
Prosecutor relies on Reghuthaman P. v. State of Kerala and
Others [2016 (4) KHC 166], especially to paragraph no.15
therein.

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..7..
2026:KER:88204
6. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the
respective parties, this Court is of the opinion that
Ext.P4 F.I.R cannot be sustained in law.
7. Before addressing the correctness of Ext.P4 F.I.R,
this Court will first address the challenge against Ext.P2
Order of the learned Special Judge. At the outset, it
requires to be noticed that there is no prayer, as such,
challenging Ext.P2 Order in the Original Petition. Nor is
any relief sought for seeking to quash Ext.P2 Order. True,
in Ground No.B, it is canvassed that the learned Special
Judge committed an error by directing the Investigating
Officer to obtain prior approval under Section 17A of the
P.C Act. The rest of the challenges made are against Ext.P4
F.I.R registered without sanction under Section 19 of the
P.C Act. In such circumstances, this Court is of the
opinion that the arguments now raised during the course of
hearing, as against Ext.P2 - based upon which the

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..8..
2026:KER:88204
petitioner wants Ext.P2 to be quashed - cannot be
entertained. It is true that the reference to Section 17A
in Ext.P2 appears to be erroneous, inasmuch as Ext.P2
- vide paragraph no.7 - observe that the allegations made
are not relatable to any recommendation made, or decision
taken by, the public servant in the discharge of his
official duties. However, that erroneous reference to
Section 17A, by itself, cannot vitiate Ext.P2.
8. This Court is also not in a position to accept the
contention that a clear finding is made in Ext.P2 Order
that cognizable offences are made out, wherefore, there
cannot be any Order directing preliminary enquiry. The
learned Special Judge found in paragraph no.8 that the
complaint contains allegations punishable under the P.C
Act. The said finding has to be read in conjunction with
the following sentence in Ext.P2, to the effect that a
preliminary enquiry is necessary, while considering the
nature of the allegations made in the complaint. Of course,

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..9..
2026:KER:88204
the reference in Ext.P2 to the genuineness and truth, if
any, of the allegations is beyond the scope of preliminary
enquiry, going by the dictum laid down in Lalita Kumari
(supra). When Ext.P2 Order, read as a whole, merely directs
a preliminary enquiry so as to ascertain whether cognizable
offences under the P.C. Act are made out or not, the same
cannot be frowned upon. This aspect is clarified by the
further direction to the Investigating Officer to file a
report before the Special Court, after completion of
preliminary enquiry.
9. The challenge against Ext.P2 will therefore stand
repelled.
10. Coming to Ext.P4 F.I.R, this Court notice that the
same is registered without obtaining necessary sanction
under Section 19 of the P.C Act. Although the power of the
police officer to register an F.I.R is traceable to Section
156(1) of the Code in cases of cognizable cases, one cannot
lose sight of the fact that the genesis of the present

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..10..
2026:KER:88204
proceedings was a private complaint preferred before the
Special Judge under Section 190, read with Section 200 of
the Code. The power to issue Ext.P2 Order, though it
directs only a preliminary enquiry, can only be traced to
Section 156(3) of the Code. The term ' preliminary enquiry '
was coined in Lalita Kumari (supra) by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, having its application limited to cases where a
clear cognizable offence is not made out in the complaint.
A preliminary enquiry can be pressed into service only if
the information received does not disclose a cognizable
offence, but indicates the necessity for an enquiry, to
ascertain whether a cognizable offence is disclosed or not.
Thus, although Ext.P2 Order directs a preliminary enquiry,
the power of the Magistrate, or for that matter the Special
Judge, is relatable only to Section 156(3).
11. Anil Kumar (supra) categorically held that sanction
under Section 19 of the P.C Act is required for ordering an
investigation under Section 156(3). It could possibly be
conceived that, so long as an investigation, as such, is

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..11..
2026:KER:88204
not ordered under Section 156(3), a sanction may not be
required. That is why, in Ext.P2, learned Special Judge
directed the Investigating Officer to file a report before
the Court, after conducting a preliminary enquiry. The
obvious purpose is to take a decision as to whether an
investigation has to be ordered or not, after taking into
account the fact whether the preliminary enquiry discloses
a clear cognizable offence in the information/complaint.
Therefore, directing a preliminary enquiry only, without
obtaining sanction under Section 19, will not offend the
law laid down in Anil Kumar (supra). However, registration
of an F.I.R by the Investigating Officer during the scope
of a preliminary enquiry requires sanction under Section
19, as the source of the Investigating Officer's power is
traceable only to Section 156(3); and not to Section
156(1). Failure to obtain such sanction, while registering
a crime pursuant to a direction under Section 156(3),
offends Anil Kumar (supra). True that a police officer can
register a crime under Section 156(1), if a cognizable

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..12..
2026:KER:88204
offence is revealed in the information/complaint. However,
the said power cannot be exercised in a case where the
proceedings originated from the Order of a Magistrate,
exercising powers under Section 156(3), when Anil Kumar
(supra) holds that an investigation in terms of Section
156(3) requires sanction under Section 19. When the
Magistrate requires a sanction to order an investigation
under Section 156(3), it is incomprehensible that the
police officer conducting a preliminary enquiry - acting on
the Orders of the Magistrate under Section 156(3) - can do
the same without a sanction under Section 19. The
distinction between the powers of the Investigating
Officer, when he acts under Section 156(1), and when he is
conducting a preliminary enquiry pursuant to the directions
under Section 156(3), should necessarily be borne in mind,
while addressing the issue.
12. Coming to Reghuthaman P. (supra), this Court has no
quarrel with respect to the findings in paragraph no.15

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..13..
2026:KER:88204
that the Investigating Officer can register an F.I.R, if a
cognizable offence is revealed during the course of a
preliminary enquiry, except for offences requiring sanction
under Section 19 of the P.C Act. When Anil Kumar (supra)
- which governs the field, as held by two Division Benches
of this Court - holds beyond the cavil of any doubt that an
investigation under Section 156(3) requires sanction, the
proposition that a police officer has power to register an
F.I.R, if a cognizable offence is revealed during the
course of a preliminary enquiry, can hardly be accepted. It
is true that Lalita Kumari (supra) specifically directs
registration of an F.I.R, if cognizable offence is
disclosed. However, the impact of Anil Kumar (supra) on
that legal position - insofar as offences under the P.C Act
are concerned, requiring sanction under Section 19 of the
P.C Act – appears to have been lost sight of in
Reghuthaman P. (supra).
13. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the
opinion that Ext.P4 F.I.R cannot be sustained, as the same

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..14..
2026:KER:88204
is registered without sanction under Section 19 of the P.C
Act. The Investigating Officer should have followed the
course suggested in Ext.P2, that is to say, to file a
report before the learned Special Judge, so as to enable
the Special Judge to take a call as to whether an
investigation under Section 156(3) has to be ordered. If
that course is to be adopted, needless to say, sanction
under Section 19 of the P.C Act has to be obtained, as per
the prevailing law on the subject.
This Original Petition will stand allowed, as indicated
above, quashing Ext.P4 F.I.R and all further proceedings
pursuant thereto. However, it is clarified that, there will
not be any bar to follow the course directed in Ext.P2.
Sd/-
C. JAYACHANDRAN
JUDGE
TR

O.P(Crl)No.391 of 2023
CNR : KLHC010359612023
..15..
2026:KER:88204
APPENDIX OF OP(CRL.) NO. 391 OF 2023
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1 A TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT FILED BY
THE 3RD RESPONDENT BEFORE THE ENQUIRY
COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL JUDGE ON
6-11-2020
Exhibit P2 A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY THE
ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL JUDGE,
KOZHIKKODE DATED, 9-11-2020 IN
C.M.P.NO.132/2020
Exhibit P3 A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION ISSUED
BY THE LEGISLATIVE SECRETARY DATED,
2-12-2020
Exhibit P4 A TRUE COPY OF THE F.I.R. IN CRIME
NO.02/2021/SCK DATED, 11-4-2021 OF THE
VACB SPECIAL CELL, KOZHIKKODE