Mehtab Singh vs State Of Punjab And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
204 CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
Mehtab Singh
... Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
... Respondents
Judgment
Reserved on
Judgment
Pronounced on
Judgment
Uploaded on
Whether only
the operative
part of the
judgment is
pronounced
Whether the full
judgment is
pronounced
18.09.2026 23.09.2026 24.09.2026 No Yes
CORAM:- HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUVIR SEHGAL
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH GAUR
Present: Mr. A.P.S. Sandhu, Advocate,
Mr. Bhavnish Sodhi, Advocate and
Mr. Ashish Kaushik, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Aftab Singh Khara, Sr. DAG, Punjab.
Mr. Nitin Kaushal, Advocate
for respondent No.3.
Mr. Ravi Sharma, Advocate
for respondent No.5.
Mr. Pradeep Duhan, Advocate and
Mr. Shubham Kumar, Advocate
for proposed respondent – Mukesh Kumar.
Mr. Gaurav Chopra, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Darika Sikka, Advocate,
Mr. Nikhil Sebharwal, Advocate
for proposed respondents No.6 to 20.
Mr. Anurag Mor, Advocate and
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 2-
Ms. Ishika Arora, Advocate
for retainer for respondent in
CM-17139-CWP-2026 and CM-17140-CWP-2026.
SUVIR SEHGAL, J.
1. Petitioner has approached this Court for issuance of a writ
of mandamus directing respondents No. 1 to 4 to apply the definition of Non-
Resident Indian (NRI) contained in notice dated 27.05.2026, Annexure P6,
circulated by the Medical Counselling Committee (MCC) for admission to
MBBS/ BDS course for the session 2026 and to permit the petitioner to
participate in the counselling process under the NRI quota.
2. Petitioner is a citizen of India and a resident of Jalandhar.
He qualified NEET (UG) - 2026 examination conducted by the National
Testing Agency (NTA) on 21.06.2026 and is desirous of seeking admission to
the MBBS/ BDS course for the session 2026. Notification dated 10.07.2026,
Annexure P7, was issued by the Government of Punjab for admission to the
aforesaid courses in medical and dental institutes in the State of Punjab. The
schedule for admission to the courses was uploaded on the website of Baba
Farid University of Health Sciences (BFUHS). The last date for the submission
of the online admission application was 10.08.2026, whereas the last date for
submission of physical application form for the NRI quota was 12.08.2026.
3. Counsel for the petitioner submits that Clause 17 of the
notification, Annexure P7, lays down a restricted definition of the NRI. He
urges that although prospectus, Annexure P9, provides that the guidelines
issued by MCC shall be followed, yet MCC notice dated 27.05.2026, Annexure
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 3-
P6, which expanded the definition of NRI, has not been incorporated in the
prospectus. Counsel contends that petitioner was brought up by his Bua
(father’s sister), who is a citizen of USA and she has furnished the certificates
as well as an affidavit in the prescribed proforma, which would make him
eligible to claim admission under the expanded definition of NRI quota, but the
application is not being considered. Counsel states that the petitioner had
approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court and vide order dated 10.08.2026,
Annexure P10, Supreme Court granted him permission to approach this Court.
4. Upon notice, writ petition has been contested by the
official respondents No.1 to 3 by filing a short affidavit of Joint Director,
Medical Education and Research, Punjab wherein it has been stated that the
admission to the NRI quota is governed strictly by Clause 17 of the
notification, Annexure P7, and petitioner is not eligible thereunder. It has been
submitted that the expanded definition of “ward of NRI” as laid down in the
notice, Annexure P6, has not been adopted by the State. It has been stated that
there are 214 vacant seats under the NRI category and the total number of
applicants in the NRI category is 63. Therefore, as provided in the prospectus,
the vacant NRI seats would be converted into the General category. Reliance
has also been placed upon the judgment of a Division Bench of this court in
Devbir Singh Versus State of Punjab and others, Law Finder Doc Id #
2643492 , against which SLP has been dismissed on 24.09.2024, Annexure P5,
to urge that the eligibility criteria for admission to educational institutions
cannot be changed midstream.
5. We have heard counsel for the parties and considered their
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 4-
respective submission besides examining the documents relied upon by them.
6. Relevant extract of Clause 17 of the notification, Annexure
P7, which provides for reservation of seats for NRI candidates is reproduced
hereunder:
“Non-Resident Indian (NRI) Seats :
15% seats in all Private Institutes, Guru Gobind
.
Singh Medical College, Faridkot, and Dr.
B.R. Ambedkar State Institute of
Medical Sciences (AIMS), Mohali.
13 seats each in Government Medical College,
.
Patiala and Amritsar.
3 seats in Government Dental College, Amritsar.
.
4 seats in Government Dental College, Patiala.
.
These seats shall be earmarked for the Non-
.
Resident Indians (NRIs) in following order:
Category I: NRI/Children of NRI who
.
originally belong to the State of Punjab.
Category II: NRI/Children of NRI who
.
originally belong to an Indian State
other than Punjab.”
7. Under Clause 21(J) of the General Conditions of the
notification, it has been provided that guidelines of MCC shall be followed and
referred to during the process of counselling. Under the disclaimer (on page
114 of the paper book), Prospectus provides that admissions shall be made
strictly in accordance with the notifications, policies, regulations, guidelines
etc. issued from time to time by various authorities including MCC.
8. An examination of the above reproduced Clause 17 shows
that an NRI has been defined as a person of an Indian origin who is settled
abroad for the purposes of employment, business or vocation, or for any other
purpose for an uncertain period. An NRI or his/her children have been specified
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 5-
to be eligible for claiming reserved seats under the NRI quota in private
medical institutes in the State. As per his own stand, petitioner is a resident of
India and his native place is Jalandhar. There is nothing on the record to show
that either of his parents is an NRI within the definition contained in Clause 17.
The definition of NRI has been expanded by the MCC vide notice, Annexure
P6, pursuant to the directions passed by the Supreme Court so as to include first
degree relations of the student, who is NRI and residing abroad. A stipulation
has been further added that such a NRI should have looked after the student as
his/her guardian and evidence as well as affidavit to this effect should be
produced before the admission committee. Petitioner claims that his Bua
(father's sister) is an NRI and has furnished an affidavit, on the basis of which
he claims that he is entitled for admission to the MBBS course under the
expanded definition.
9. The inclusion of the expanded definition of NRI category
by virtue of a corrigendum in the original prospectus after the admission
process had started, came up for adjudication before a Co-ordinate Bench of
this Court in Devbir Singh’s case (supra). Noticing the legal position, the
Division Bench observed as under:
3.13 On 20.08.2024, the process of submitting
applications had already come to an end wholly. The
subsequent amendment amounts to the substitution of a
new clause while defining the category of NRI which has
resulted in fundamental changes. This amendment has
been brought against the observations made by the Court
from time to time. In para 17 of a Full Bench judgment in
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 6-
Amardeep Singh Sihota vs. State of Punjab, 1999(4)
R.S.J., 667 , declared that the prospectus cannot be
subsequently changed by the Government to the detriment
of the students to benefit other students. It is also against
the public interest because the paramount consideration
while imparting the medical education is to improve the
facility of availability of good doctors, so that poor health
standards of the country are taken care of. Meritorious
doctors are the need of the hour, as they play a crucial role
in developing the health of the nation. The substitution of
the expanded category of NRI cannot be made applicable
to the applications which had already been submitted and
the process of admission to the college had reached at an
advance stage. Moreover, no plausible explanation has
been put forth that explains the necessity to make changes
in the policy after the process of admission of students had
made substantial progress. The reasons disclosed by the
Government in its written statement also do not justify
changes made in midstream. It is not appropriate for the
Government to take cover of the prospectus issued by the
NMC because that prospectus only relates to 15% 'All
India quota' seats. The State is well within its power to
regulate the reservation of seats with respect to State
quota. The regulations made by MCI does not affect the
competence of the States to make provisions with respect to
reservation. Reliance in this regard can be placed on the
judgment passed by the Constitutional Bench in
Tamilnadu Medical Officers Association and others vs.
Union of India and others (2021) 6 SCC 568 and Modern
Dental College and Research Centre vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh, (2016) 3 CC, 353 . By making changes the
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 7-
underlying principles for admission had been changed
after the admission process had commenced which should
not be permitted. By the evening of 19.08.2024, the total
number of eligible candidates, who had claimed admission
through the original NRI category were known. The
subsequent change inidcates that six (6) private private
medical colleges in the State may have influenced the
process to increase their financial gain. Hence, changes
made after the admissions had commenced are not
permissible in the eyes of law and principles of natural
justice.
10. In Parmender Kumar and others Versus State of Haryana
and others (2012) 1 SCC 177 , Supreme Court categorically held that eligibility
conditions and selection criteria must be disclosed in the prospectus and any
subsequent mid-process amendments cannot govern an ongoing admission
process. It was observed that any late introduction of a notification or change in
criteria after commencement of the process must be discarded as an offending
notification. Recently in Adarsh Dinkar Sontakke (Minor) and others Versus
Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti and others, Law Finder Doc Id # 2961508, Apex
Court re-emphasized the sanctity of Prospectus. The Courts have emphatically
held that rules of the game cannot be changed once the game has begun.
11. This principle applies to this case with all force. The
admission process started on the last date of the submission of the application
which was 12.08.2026 for the NRI category candidates. Once the last date has
passed, respondents cannot make any modification in the eligibility conditions
notified in the original Prospectus, which is likely to enlarge the admission
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25345-2026(O&M)
- 8-
criteria to the detriment of the students, who did not apply on the basis of the
original notified criteria. In this background, there cannot be any direction to
the respondents to include the expanded NRI criteria notified by the MCC vide
Annexure P6.
12. This Court, therefore, does not find any merit in the present
petition. It is dismissed with no order as to costs.
13. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
(SUVIR SEHGAL)
JUDGE
(RAJESH GAUR)
JUDGE
23.09.2026
Brij
Whether Speaking/Reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.09.24 16:01
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.