THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS vs N B BALIHALLI S/O BASAPPA BALIHALLI,

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD

TH
DATED THIS THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026



PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA

AND

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI


WRIT PETITION NO.100778 OF 2025 (S-KAT)
C/W
WRIT PETITION NO.107738 OF 2024 (S-KAT)

IN WP NO.100778/2025:
BETWEEN:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
FOREST, ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT,
M.S BUILDINGS, BENGALURU-560001.








2. PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
TH
ARANYA BHAVAN, 18 CROSS, MALLESHWARAM,
BENGALURU-560003.

3. CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
DHARWAD CIRCLE, DHARWAD-580001.


Digitally signed
by PRATIBHA
M PATIL
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD
BENCH
Date:
2026.11.19
14:51:47 +0530

4. DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
HAVERI DIVISION, HAVERI-581110.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SMT.GIRIJA S.HIREMATH, HCGP)

AND:

1. N.B BALIHALLI S/O. BASAPPA BALIHALLI,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
RETD DAILY WAGE WATCHER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER,
HANGAL RANGE, HANGAL-581104,
R/AT. PUTTARAJA GAVAYI NAGAR,
HANGAL-581104, HAVERI DISTRICT.

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



2. P.Y.POOJARI S/O. YALLANNA POOJARI,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, DAILY WAGE DRIVER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER, HANGAL RANGE,
HANGAL-581104, R/O. RFO OFFICE COMPOUND,
HANGAL-581104, HAVERI DISTRICT.

3. G.S.HIREMATH S/O. SHIVAYYA HIREMATH,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
RETD. DAILY WAGE WATCHER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER, HANGAL RANGE,
HANGAL-581104, R/O. RFO OFFICE COMPOUND,
HANGAL-581104, HAVERI DISTRICT.

4. M.N.MANAKUR S/O. N.D MANAKUR,
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
DAILY WAGE WATCHER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER,
HANGAL RANGE, HANGAL-581104,
R/O. RFO OFFICE COMPOUND, HANGAL-581104,
HAVERI DISTRICT.

5. V.R.PATIL S/O. R.V.PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
DAILY WAGE WATCHER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER,
HANGAL RANGE, HANGAL-581104,
R/AT. GURUKRUPA, OPP. KURUBARA BAVI,
INDIRA NAGAR, HANGAL-581104, HAVERI DISTRICT.

6. M.B KADLEPPANAVAR
S/O. BHARMAPPA KADLEPPANNAVAR,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, DAILY WAGE WATCHER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER, RANEBENNUR RANGE,
RANEBENNUR-581 115, KURUBARAGERI,
KADLEPPANAVAR GALLI, RANEBENNUR-581115,
HAVERI DISTRICT.

7. B.R.CHANNAGIRI S/O. RAMAPPA CHANNAGIRI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

7(A). SMT. LAKSHMAVVA B.CHANNAGIRI
W/O. LATE B.R.CHANNAGIRI,
AGE. 52 YEARS.

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



7(B). SRI. MALATESHA B.CHANNAGIRI
S/O. LATE B.R.CHANNAGIRI,
AGE. 31 YEARS,

BOTH ARE R/A ARABAGONDA,
GUNDENAHALLI POST-581106,
BYADAGI TALUK, HAVERI DISTRICT.

8. B.H PATIL S/O. HANUMANTHEGOUDA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
DAILY WAGE WATCHER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER, BYADAGI RANGE,
BYADAGI-581106, R/O ARABAGONDA,
GUNDENAHALLI POST, BYADAGI TALUK,
HAVERI DISTRICT.

9. S.P MUDENURMATH
S/O. PUTTAYYA MUDENURMATH,
AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
RETD. DAILY WAGE WIRELESS OPERATOR,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER, BYADAGI RANGE,
BYADAGI-581106, R/AT. SHETTARA ONI,
BYADAGI-581106, HAVERI DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI.K.B.MURALIDHAR, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1 TO R6, R8 AND R9)


THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT,
ORDER OR DIRECTION IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI TO QUASH
THE ORDER DATED 24.07.2023 PASSED BY THE KARNATAKA STATE
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BELAGAVI IN APPLICATION NO.11457
TO 11465/2022 (ANNEXURE-A TO THE WRIT PETITION); AND ETC.

IN WP NO.107738/2024:
BETWEEN:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
FOREST, ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT,
M.S BUILDINGS, BENGALURU-560001.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025




2. PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
TH
ARANYA BHAVAN, 18 CROSS, MALLESHWARAM,
BENGALURU-560003.

3. CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
DHARWAD CIRCLE, DHARWAD-580001.

4. DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
HAVERI DIVISION, HAVERI-581110.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SMT.GIRIJA S.HIREMATH, HCGP)

AND:

1. NEELAPPA G. HAVERI S/O. GUDDAPPA HAVERI,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
DAILY WAGE WIRELESS OPERATOR,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER,
RANEBENNUR RANGE, RANEBENNUR-581115,
R/O. UKKUNDA, RANEBENNUR TALUK,
HAVERI DISTRICT.

2. ASHOKA I.KUMACHIGI
S/O. ISHWARAPPA KUMACHIGI,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
DAILY WAGE WATCHER,
O/O RANGE FOREST OFFICER,
HANGAL RANGE, HANGAL-581104,
R/O. SARKARI DYAMANAKOPPA,
SIRAGODA POST, HANGAL TALUK,
HAVERI DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.K.B.MURALIDHAR, ADVOCATE FOR R1 AND R2)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT,
ORDER OR DIRECTION IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI TO QUASH
THE ORDER DATED. 25.07.2023 PASSED BY THE KARNATAKA
STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BELAGAVI IN APPLICATION

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



NO. 11466 AND 11467/2022 (ANNEXURE-A TO THE WRIT
PETITION) IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.

THESE PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI


ORAL ORDER

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA )



1. The State is before us in both these petitions calling
in question orders dated 24.07.2023 and 25.07.2023 of the
Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal, Belagavi (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Tribunal’, for short) by which the Tribunal
allows the claim of the respondents for consideration of their
cases for regularization from the date on which they completed
10 years of service notwithstanding the fact that they were
bought under the Daily Wage Welfare Act of 2012 or the Rules
thereunder and had received the benefits under the said Act.


2. Heard Smt. Girija S. Hiremath, learned High Court
Government Pleader appearing for the appellant/State and the

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



learned counsel Sri. K.B. Muralidhar appearing for the
respondents.


3. Facts in brief are as follows:


4. The respondents were appointed on daily wage
basis as forest watchers, drivers or wireless operators as the
case would be in the forest department. The appointment is
between 1985 to 1988. Notwithstanding the State passing an
order directing regularization of the employees who have been
working on daily wages and appointed prior to 01.07.1984 and
who had completed 10 years of service, the respondents’ claim
could not be considered. The respondents then prefer
application before the Tribunal in Application Nos.9551-
9560/2001 which comes to be disposed on 09.09.2002 to
consider the case of the respondents in the light of the law that
was prevailing at that point in time. This did not happen and in
the interrugnum, the Daily Wage Welfare Act comes to be
promulgated by the State and the Rules were framed
thereafter. The respondents herein were bought under the
purview of the Daily Wage Welfare Act unilaterally by the State.
The respondents accepted the benefit that they would get

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



under the Daily Wage Welfare Act and after such acceptance
are said to have knocked at the doors of the Tribunal in the
impugned proceedings and the Tribunal allows the applications
by the following order:
“14. This Tribunal its earlier order dated 25.10.2019 in
A.Nos.428 to 436/2017 had observed thus at para 7
which is extracted below:

‘7. The Hon’ble Apex Court in Prem Singh Vs.
State of Uttar Pradesh & others [Civil Appeal
No.6798/2019 decided on 02.09.2019] (2019 SCC
online SC 1134), while considering extension
service rendered in work charge establishment for
the purpose of pension, at Para-35 considering
judgment of Umadevi’s case has held as follows:

“35. As it would be unjust, illegal and
impermissible to make aforesaid
classification to make the Rule 3(8) valid
and non-discriminatory, we have to read
down the provisions of Rule 3(8) and hold
that services rendered even prior to
regularisation in the capacity of work-
charged employees, contingency paid fund
employees or non-pensionable
establishment shall also be counted towards
the qualifying service even if such service is
not preceded by temporary or regular
appointment in a pensionable
establishment.”

Thereby, it is clear that the Umadevi’s case
itself directs to regularise the service of the
employees who were appointed earlier to the said
judgment. In view of the said judgment also, the
applicants were all entitled for consideration, on the
other hand, the endorsement issued by the 4th
Respondent rejecting the request of the applicants
for regularisation is on erroneous reasons, and the
said reasons are without any basis, on the other

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



hand, as already stated, the respondent authorities
have extended the benefit to the persons similarly
placed. Under the circumstances, the endorsement
is without any substance, further the said
endorsement is without considering anything and
hence the same calls for interference.’

15. Therefore, in the light of the above, we are of the
considered opinion that the eligible daily wagers have a
right for regularization. We concur with the reasoning that
when earlier order has been passed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court it must be complied with. The excuse of the
Respondents that rules of regularization has changed after
Umadevi’s case is not acceptable. It is really a pity that
the applicants are seeking regularization since 2002 and
are yet to be regularized. The fact that the employees
have been allowed to continue indicate existence of post
and necessity of their post. The right of the applicants has
already been adjudicated by this Tribunal in 2002 itself
which received finality after the Writ Petition was
dismissed by the Hon’ble High Court in 2005.

16. The learned AGA’s contention that they (the
applicants) have been considered under Karnataka Daily
Wages Welfare Act 2012 and are ineligible for being
regularized has not been mentioned in the impugned
endorsement. As otherwise too the Welfare Act is about
protection of pay and other allowances so as not to be
detrimental to daily wage employee vis a vis directly
recruited employees. As such this contention of learned
AGA is rejected by us.

17. The case of the applicants is totally identical to case of
Narsimharaju & others (supra) and is covered by the
judgment dated 01.03.2000 confirmed by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in order dated 09.07.2001. The sole
ground taken by the Respondent is rejecting the claim of
the applicants is that it does not confirm to the
Umadevi’s case judgment and subsequent Order of
Government dated 10.04.2006 for regularization. The
respondents are losing sight of the fact that the order
directing them for regularization was passed much before
this order and thus their right for regularization had

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



crystallized much before that. The applicants have been
agitating regularization of their service for a long time.

18. The learned counsel for applicant has brought to our
notice the decision in Bharti Singh Vs. others Vs.
Union of India & others [(2020) 18 SCC 733] wherein,
while dealing with the similar circumstances of rejection of
claim of regularization of similarly situated employees
whose decision attained finality during 2003 i.e., before
the judgment of Umadevi’s case during 2006. The
principle held in this cited case come in favour of the
applicants.

19. In view of the observation of facts and circumstances,
we are of the considered view that the Respondents have
erred in rejecting the representation and non-compliance
of the Tribunal direction reiterated dated 25.10.2019. A
subsequent order dated 10.09.2006 in Umadevi’s case
should not jeopardies the chance of regularization of the
applicants. The learned counsel for the applicants fairly
submits that the principle of parity requires that the
orders already passed in order dated 01.03.2000, Hon’ble
High Court order dated 30.01.2001 and Hon’ble Supreme
Court order dated 09.07.2001 in Narsimraju & others
(supra) are considered and benefit extended to
Narsimharaju and others is also to be extended to the
applicants.

20. Therefore, based on the circumstances and facts, we
are of the considered opinion that the applicants have
made out a case for our interference for injustice meted
out to them and it can be remedied applying doctrine of
parity with the case of Narsimharaju & others for issuing
appropriate direction to the Respondents for considering
similar benefits. In N.K. Rajgavia Vs. M/s Mahavir
[2006 (1) SC 70] the Hon’ble
Plantation Ltd. & others
Supreme Court had observed that service jurisprudence
postulates that all persons similarly situated should be
treated similarly.

21. In conclusion we pass the following:
(i) Applications are allowed.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



(ii) The impugned order bearing No. Aa Pa Jee 12 Aa
Aa Se 2021 dated 27.12.2021 (AnnexureA27)
st
passed by the 1 Respondent are setaside.

(iii) The Respondents are directed to regularize the
service of Applicants from the date of
completing 10 years of service as done in case
of Narsimharaju & others’ case (AnnexureA9)
within four months from the date of receipt of
copy of this order.
(iv) The applicants will also be entitled to all
consequential financial and other benefits as per
law emanating from this order. The same
should also be finalized within four months of
the receipt of this order.”


5. The State is before us in both these petitions
calling in question the said order on one solitary ground. The
ground is that, the respondents having received the benefit or
accepted the fact that they were bought under the ambit of the
Daily Wage Welfare Act and the Rules thereon and accepted
those benefits, cannot turn around and seek regularization of
their services. The learned HCGP would submit that, if, this is
permitted, then it would open pandorus box, where every
employee who has taken the benefit of the Daily Wage Welfare
Act will claim regularization notwithstanding the receipt of the
amount or the benefits under the Daily Wage Welfare Act.
Therefore, the learned HCGP would submit that the order of the
Tribunals be set at not.

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025





6. Per contra, the learned counsel K. B. Muralidar
representing the respondents would submit that this very
contention is advanced not once but twice or thrice before 2 or
3 division benches and the division benches have all negated
the submissions of the State and held that merely because the
employees accepted the Daily Wage Welfare Act would not
mean that the claim for regularization would vanish. Therefore,
the petitions be dismissed.


7. We have given our anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and
perused the material on record.


8. The issue lies in a narrow compass quay, the
submissions and the contra submissions.


9. The only issue that falls for consideration in terms
of the submissions made by the learned HCGP is whether an
employee after more than 20 to 25 years of service, as a daily
wager, if would accept him being bought under the benefit of

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



the Daily Wage Welfare Act or the Rules and receives those
benefits, is precluded from seeking regularization or otherwise.


10. The issue need not detain us for long or delve deep
into the matter. The 3 division benches of this Court have
considered this issue and held as follows:

1
“8. Insofar as petitioner no. 1 is concerned, the records
would reveal that he was taken on employment on
16.03.1997 as per Annexure-A and certificate was issued
that he was working against a sanctioned post. Further
insofar as the said petitioner the Correspondence
addressed by the Assistant Executive Engineer,
Panchayathraj Division to the Executive Engineer,
Panchayathraj Engineering Division at Annexure-C dated
26.03.2014 would indicate that petitioner no. 1 was
working on daily wage basis and having worked against a
vacant post and having fulfilled the four criteria laid down
by the Supreme Court as contained in the Circular of
13.11.2006, his case for regularisation may be
considered.

9. Thus from the documents referred to above, it is clear
that the petitioner was working against the sanctioned
post and that he had fulfilled the four criteria which were
eligibility for regularisation in terms of Circular referred to
at Annexure-B.

10. Insofar as second petitioner is concerned, the
document at Annexure-D is the Certificate of the Assistant
Executive Engineer, Panchayathraj Engineering Sub-
Division dated 31.03.2012 to the effect that he was
appointed on 06.09.1993 on daily basis against vacant
post.


1
WA No.100349/2024 dd 18.08.2026

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



11. The details of available vacant posts as on 29.02.2012
is enclosed at Annexure-F which would indicate that as
regards the post of Junior Engineer at Karwar Division
there were about 13 vacant posts.

12. The case of the second petitioner was recommended
for regularisation in terms of the correspondence of the
Assistant Executive Engineer, Panchayathraj Sub-Division,
Ankola addressed to the Executive Engineer,
Panchayathraj Engineering Division, Karwar at Annexure-J
dated 02.01.2024. Annexure-J also includes
recommendation insofar as the first petitioner is
concerned.

13. The reference to the documents above insofar as
petitioner no. 1 and petitioner no. 2 would estop the State
from taking any contention as now being urged.

14. Though the State has contended regarding extension
of benefit under the Welfare Act, however, no statement
of objections was filed in the Writ proceedings nor in the
present proceedings any document is produced to
demonstrate extension of benefit under the Welfare Act in
the absence of which, it would not be necessary to enter
into the contention by the State which is not supported by
any material. No material is produced to substantiate such
contention and no grounds are made out on behalf of the
State.

15. Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that
extension of benefit under the ‘Welfare Act’ even
otherwise would not disentitle the case of regularization.
It is further contended that Annexure-J dated 02.01.2024
addressed by the Assistant Executive Engineer,
Panchayathraj Engineering Sub-Division, Ankola to the
Executive Engineer, Panchayathraj Sub-Division Karwar
does not make any reference to the provisions of ‘Welfare
Act’ as constituting a bar to consider regularization. In
light of the same, the State is estopped from raising any
contention as regards such aspect.

16. Clearly, the recommendations made by the State
Agencies would indicate that petitioner no. 1 and
petitioner no.2 were working against vacant posts and

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



had worked for 10 (ten) years. Annexure-J would further
crystalize their rights regarding regularisation. Once such
recommendation is made based on a factual foundation,
the decision making authority cannot renege from such
findings made.

17. The order of the learned Single Judge is detailed and
has considered all such documents as referred to by this
court. The learned Single Judge has also referred to the
various requirements of the need to regularize taking note
of the principle that the State cannot exploit individuals
and that those employees engaged to work for the State
for long years should be considered for regularisation,
failing which action of the State would amount to a
violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
18. We find no other grounds made out by the State to
interfere with the order of the learned Single Judge and
accordingly dismiss the Writ appeal and affirm the order
of the learned Single Judge.

19. The State is granted three months' time to implement
the directions of the learned Single Judge, which stands
affirmed.

Pending IAs stand disposed of in view of disposal of
the appeal on merits.”


11. A little earlier to the afore quoted judgment and
2
another division bench in Writ Appeal No.1882/2024 has held
as follows:
“4. Having considered the contentions advanced, we
notice that the learned Single Judge has clearly found that
in an earlier round of writ petitions, which had ended in
Annexure-G - Judgment, it was clearly held that the
appointment of writ petitioner was against a sanctioned
post and that only question which was to be examined
was whether the writ petitioner possesses the educational
qualification to hold the post of a driver.

2
DD on 27.11.2025

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



5. The learned Single Judge, after considering the entire
contentions, had come to the specific conclusion that the writ
petitioner had worked as a driver from 1995 to 2018, till he
attained the age of superannuation. At the relevant time when
he was appointed, there were no statutory rules which
prescribed any educational qualification for the post of driver.
On these findings it was found that the contentions raised in the
endorsement could not be accepted.
6. Having considered the contentions advanced, we find
no reasons to differ from the view taken by the learned Single
Judge since no rules have been bought to our notice by which
educational qualifications were prescribed for the post of driver
in a Town Municipal Council before 2010.
7. Learned AGA also contends that since the writ petitioner
had already availed benefits under the Karnataka Daily Wage
Employees Welfare Act, 2012, (for short, 'the Act' ) the
question of regularization cannot be considered. We notice that
the said question has also been decided as against the appellant
on several occasions by this Court itself. The extending of the
benefits under the Act cannot be a ground for rejecting a
request for regularizing in service if the necessary pre-requisites
for such regularization are satisfied.
8. In the above view of the matter, we find no reasons to
interfere with the impugned judgment of the learned Single
Judge. The appeal fails and the same is accordingly dismissed.
The respondent No.2 shall implement the order of the
learned Single Judge within a period of three weeks from the
date of receipt of copy of this judgment.”



12. The said judgment of the Division Bench dated
27.11.2025 was tossed by the State before the Apex Court.
The Apex Court rejects the SLP (Civil) Diary No(s).18625/2026
by the following order:
“UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following

ORDER

1. Delay in filing as well as in refiling is condoned.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025




2. We have heard learned counsel for the petitioners.

3. Having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances
of the case, we are not inclined to interfere with the
impugned judgment.

4. The Special Leave Petition is hence dismissed.

5. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.”


13. Subsequent to the aforesaid orders, another
Division Bench answering this very contention in Writ Petition
No.104676/2023 DD on 27.03.2026 holds as follows:
“4. The KSAT has dismissed the petitioner’s application
on the ground that he was extended the benefits under
the Karnataka Daily Wage Employees’ Welfare Act, 2012
(‘the Act of 2012’) , and that his salary had been fixed
under the said enactment. It was further held that merely
because some subordinates of the petitioner were
regularised, his case could not be considered. The KSAT
also held that the petitioner was not entitled for
regularisation in view of the judgment in Secretary,
1
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi .

5. Learned Additional Government Advocate relied upon
the judgment of Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the
case of
Sri.Rakesh Rahidas Prabhu and Another
2
Vs.The State of Karnataka and Others , wherein the
petitioner therein, was granted the benefit under the Act
of 2012 and hence held that he was not entitled to
regularization and dismissed the petition.

6. The said judgment is not applicable to the facts of the
present case, as the petitioners therein were appointed on
02.02.1993 and 04.08.1993 respectively; however, the
petitioner in the present case was appointed on
26.11.1983, i.e., prior to the cut-off date contemplated in

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



Dharwad District P.W.D., Literate Daily Wage
Employees Association and others Vs. State of
3
Karnataka and others .
The interpretation of Umadevi’s
case cited supra by the Tribunal is erroneous.

th
7. The petitioner is appointed by the 4 respondent -
Deputy Conservator of Forest, Sirsi Division, Sirsi. Several
cases of regularisation of employees who had been
appointed and working on daily wage basis became the
subject matter of the proceedings before the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Dharwad District P.W.D., Literate
Daily Wage Employees Association (cited supra).
Pursuant to the order passed by the Apex Court, the State
th
Government has issued a Circular on 6 August 1990
directing regularisation of the employees, who were on
NMR basis or any other form of daily wage. The cutoff
date in the said Government Order was 01.07.1984.

8. Further, recently the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the
case of Daram Singh and Ors. Vs. State of U.P. and
4
Another , has reiterated the relevant principles governing
regularisation. Paragraph 11 of the same is extracted
hereunder:

11. Furthermore, it must be clarified that the
reliance placed by the High Court on Umadevi
(Supra) to non- suit the appellants is misplaced.
Unlike Umadevi (Supra) , the challenge before us
is not an invitation to bypass the constitutional
scheme of public employment. It is a challenge to
the State’s arbitrary refusals to sanction posts
despite the employer’s own acknowledgement of
need and decades of continuous reliance on the
very workforce. On the other hand, Umadevi
(Supra) draws a distinction between illegal
appointments and irregular engagements and does
not endorse the perpetuation of precarious
employment where the work itself is permanent
and the State has failed, for years, to put its house
in order. Recent decisions of this Court in Jaggo v.
Union of India and in Shripal & Another v.
Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad have emphatically
cautioned that Umadevi (Supra) cannot be
deployed as a shield to justify exploitation through
long-term “ad hocism”, the use of outsourcing as a

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



proxy, or the denial of basic parity where identical
duties are exacted over extended periods. The
principles articulated therein apply with full force to
the present case. The relevant paras from Shripal
(supra) have been reproduced hereunder:

“14. The Respondent Employer places
reliance on Umadevi (supra) to contend that
daily-wage or temporary employees cannot
claim permanent absorption in the absence of
statutory rules providing such absorption.
However, as frequently reiterated, Uma Devi
itself distinguishes between appointments
that are “illegal” and those that are
“irregular,” the latter being eligible for
regularization if they meet certain conditions.
More importantly, Uma Devi cannot serve as
a shield to justify exploitative engagements
persisting for years without the Employer
undertaking legitimate recruitment. Given the
record which shows no true contractor-based
arrangement and a consistent need for
permanent horticultural staff the alleged
asserted ban on fresh recruitment, though
real, cannot justify indefinite daily-wage
status or continued unfair practices.

15. It is manifest that the Appellant Workmen
continuously rendered their services over
several years, sometimes spanning more than
a decade. Even if certain muster rolls were
not produced in full, the Employer's failure to
furnish such records-despite directions to do
so allows an adverse inference under well
established labour jurisprudence. Indian
labour law strongly disfavors perpetual daily-
wage or contractual engagements in
circumstances where the work is permanent
in nature. Morally and legally, workers who
fulfill ongoing municipal requirements year
after year cannot be dismissed summarily as
dispensable, particularly in the absence of a
genuine contractor agreement. At this
juncture, it would be appropriate to recall the
broader critique of indefinite “temporary”
employment practices as done by a recent
judgment of this court in Jaggo v. Union of
India in the following paragraphs:

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025




“22. The pervasive misuse of temporary
employment contracts, as exemplified in
this case, reflects a broader systemic issue
that adversely affects workers' rights and
job security. In the private sector, the rise
of the gig economy has led to an increase in
precarious employment arrangements,
often characterized by lack of benefits, job
security, and fair treatment. Such practices
have been criticized for exploiting workers
and undermining labour standards.
Government institutions, entrusted with
upholding the principles of fairness and
justice, bear an even greater responsibility
to avoid such exploitative employment
practices. When public sector entities
engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it
not only mirrors the detrimental trends
observed in the gig economy but also sets a
concerning precedent that can erode public
trust in governmental operations.
………
25. It is a disconcerting reality that
temporary employees, particularly in
government institutions, often face
multifaceted forms of exploitation. While
the foundational purpose of temporary
contracts may have been to address
shortterm or seasonal needs, they have
increasingly become a mechanism to evade
long-term obligations owed to employees.
These practices manifest in several ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary” Labels: Employees
engaged for work that is essential,
recurring, and integral to the functioning of
an institution are often labelled as
“temporary” or “contractual,” even when
their roles mirror those of regular
employees. Such misclassification deprives
workers of the dignity, security, and
benefits that regular employees are entitled
to, despite performing identical tasks.

Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees are
frequently dismissed without cause or notice, as seen
in the present case. This practice undermines the
principles of natural justice and subjects workers to a
state of constant insecurity, regardless of the quality
or duration of their service.

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025




• Lack of Career Progression: Temporary employees
often find themselves excluded from opportunities for
skill development, promotions, or incremental pay
raises. They remain stagnant in their roles, creating a
systemic disparity between them and their regular
counterparts, despite their contributions being equally
significant.

Using outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions
increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed by
temporary employees, effectively replacing one set of
exploited workers with another. This practice not only
perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates a
deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to offer
regular employment.

• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits: Temporary
employees are often denied fundamental benefits such
as pension, provident fund, health insurance, and paid
leave, even when their tenure spans decades. This
lack of social security subjects them and their families
to undue hardship, especially in cases of illness,
retirement, or unforeseen circumstances.”

9. In the aforesaid judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
referred to its recent judgments in the case of Jaggo Vs.
5
Union of India and Shripal & Another Vs. Nagar
6
Nigam, Ghaziabad .

10. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the
judgment of the Coordinate Bench of this Court in the
case of Sri P. Junjappa Vs. The Principal Chief
7
Conservator of Forests and Others , wherein at
paragraphs 26 and 27, it is held as under:

“26. We have given our anxious consideration to
the submissions of both the side. Perused the record.
The fundamental issue raised for adjudication in the
present writ petition pertains to the alleged denial of
pensionary benefits to the respondents, despite the
fact that such benefits have been extended to other
employees who are similarly placed in terms of
employment and service conditions. Therefore, the
core question, that emerges for consideration is,
"whether this differential treatment meted out to the

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



respondents amounts to violation of their
constitutional rights enshrined under Articles 14, 16
and 39D of the Constitution of India. Article 14 of the
Constitution, mandates that, the State shall not deny
any person equality before the law or the equal
protection of the laws. This constitutional provision
ensures that, no individual or group of individuals is
subjected to arbitrary discrimination by the State. The
Doctrine of Equality embedded in Article 14 extends to
employment related matters and prohibits any
unreasonable classification among individuals who are
similarly placed. Further, Article 16 reinforces, this
principle by guaranteeing equal opportunity in matters
relating to public employment and prohibiting
discrimination on unreasonable grounds. The act of
granting pensionary benefits to certain employees
while simultaneously denying the same to the
respondents, who are identically situated, constitutes
an instance of hostile discrimination. Such a
discriminatory treatment is impermissible under the
constitutional scheme and violates the fundamental
rights of the respondents. The Hon'ble Apex Court in
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Arvind Kumar
Srivastava , reported in (2015) 1 SCC 347 , has
categorically held that, if a particular benefit is
extended to one set of employees, the same cannot
be denied to another set of employees who are
similarly placed unless a reasonable and rationale
classification is established. In the instant case, the
State Government has failed to demonstrate any
distinguishing factor or valid reason justifying the
denial of pensionary benefits to the respondents while
granting the same to their counter parts. This lack of
justification renders the State's action, arbitrary and
discriminatory violating the fundamental rights of the
respondents under the Constitution.

27. In addition to this, Article 39D of Constitution,
which is a part of the directive principles of State
Policy enshrines the principle of "Equal Pay for Equal
Work". This principle has been consistently upheld by
the judiciary in various judgments. In State of
Punjab and Others v. Jagjit Singh and Others,
reported in (2017) 1 SCC 148, the Hon'ble Apex
Court reaffirmed that artificial classification which
deny equal benefits to employees performing the

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



same work cannot withstand constitutional scrutiny.
The respondents, having performed duties similar to
those of their colleagues who have been granted
pensionary benefits, cannot be arbitrarily excluded
from receiving the same. The Doctrine of `Equal pay
for equal work' applies in full force to the present case
and denial of pensionary benefits to the respondents
is indirect contravention of this wellestablished
constitutional principle. More so, the doctrine of
legitimate expectation as expounded by the Hon'ble
Apex Court in Union of India and Others v.
Hindustan Development Corpn. and Others,
reported in (1993) 3 SCC 499 , is also relevant to the
facts of the present case. The respondents having
served under identical conditions and for an
equivalent period as their counterparts who have been
granted pensionary benefits reasonably expect that,
the same treatment would be extended to them. The
State's failure to fulfill this legitimate expectation
amounts to administrative arbitrariness and unfair
treatment. Such arbitrary actions undermine the
principles of good governance and transparency that
the State as a model employer is expected to uphold.”

11. Learned counsel further relied upon the decision of
the Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Sri. N.
8
Ashok Vs. The State of Karnataka and Others ,
wherein at paragraphs 11 and 12, it is held as under:
“Analysis and Findings:
11. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in various
decisions has categorically held that, in such
circumstances, employees who have completed 10
years of service in sanctioned post prior to the
pronouncement of Umadevi supra, are entitled for
regularization. In this regard the decision in
M.L.Kesari and Jaggo (supra) are relied upon. In
M.L.Kesari , the Apex Court clarified as under:

'those who rendered over ten years of
service in sanctioned post should not be
deprived of regularization merely due to the
procedural delays on the part of the
authority'.

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



The said clarification is taken assistance by
this Court in WP Nos.6238/2020 clubbed with WP
No.49123/2019 vide judgment dated 17.3.2025.

12. In this case, it is a specific plea of the
petitioner that, he was in continuous service in
Forest Department as daily wager and he worked
on par with regular employees. He has been
engaged in said services right from the date of his
initial entry. This fact so asserted by the petitioner
is not denied by any of the respondents. The KSAT
has not appreciated this plea of the petitioner and
non-appreciation of this continuous service of more
than 30 years definitely and squarely falls within
the protective ambit of the principles laid down in
the aforesaid decisions.”

12. In the present case, the KSAT erred in dismissing the
application and denying service benefits to the petitioner,
despite his continuous engagement by the Government.
Merely because the petitioner was extended benefits
under the Act of 2012, he cannot be deprived of his right
to seek regularisation, particularly when his case was
covered under Dharwad District P.W.D. Literate Daily
Wage Employees Association and others (cited supra),
having been appointed in the office of respondent Nos.3
and 4 prior to the cut-off date of 01.07.1984, i.e.,
petitioner being appointed on 26.11.1983. Therefore, the
petitioner is entitled to the same treatment that is meted
out to all the employees who were appointed prior to
01.07.1984 in terms of the Government Orders issued
from time to time, which were issued pursuant to the
judgment of the Apex Court in the Dharwad District
P.W.D. Literate Daily Wage Employees Association and
others (cited supra). Therefore, the petition succeeds and
the petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought. The
impugned orders are liable to be set aside.

13. Accordingly, we proceed to pass the following:

ORDER

i. The writ petition is allowed.


ii. The impugned endorsement bearing
No.B1/Shbbandhi/Kshe.Di. Now

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



Ethare/CR/2020-21/74 dated 20.04.2020
vide Annexure-A6 issued by 4 th respondent
and impugned endorsement bearing
No.AaPaJi 76 AaASe 2019 dated 07.08.2021
vide Annexure-A10 issued by 1st respondent
are hereby quashed.


iii. The order of the Karnataka State
Administrative Tribunal (KSAT), Belagavi, in
Application No.10944 & 10955 of 2021 is
hereby set aside. Consequently, Application
No.10944 & 10955 of 2021 are allowed.


iv. The services of petitioner shall be considered
for regularization in terms of the government order
dated 6.08.1990 at Annexure-A2.
v. The entire process of consideration and
regularization shall be completed within a period of
three (3) months from the date of receipt of
certified copy of this order.”


14. All the afore quoted orders of the Division Benches
of this Court were in tune with what the Apex Court had long
ago in 2019 considered this very aspect as to whether an
employee in the State of Karnataka, who has accepted the
Daily Wage Welfare Act and the Rules framed thereunder is
precluded from claiming regularization of his services. The Apex
Court in Civil Appeal No(s).5292 of 2019 holds as follows:

“Leave granted.

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



The Appellants are aggrieved by the judgment of the
Karnataka High Court by which they were directed to
regularize the service of the Respondent.

The Respondent was appointed on a daily wage
basis on 01.03.1995 in the Government SC/ST Boys
College Hostel, H.D. Kote Taluk, Mysore. As he was
continued for a long time on daily wages, he filed a Writ
Petition before the High Court of Karnataka which was
disposed of on 18.04.2007 with a direction to the
Appellants to consider his regularization. The Appellants
rejected the request of the Respondent to regularize his
service, aggrieved by which he approached the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal, Bengaluru. The Tribunal disposed
of the original application on 09.03.2012 directing the
Appellants to consider regularization of service of the
Respondent.

The Appellants rejected the request of the
Respondent for regularization on the ground that he did
not complete 10 years of continued service without the
aid of the interim order passed by the High Court.

The Karnataka Daily Wage Employees Welfare Act,
2012 (Act of 2012) was notified on 15.02.2013. Certain
benefits pertaining to the continuance of daily wage
employees on completion of 10 years and the payment of
minimum time scale along with other benefits were
provided in the said Act. The above Act does not
contemplate regularization of daily wagers.

Aggrieved by the rejection of his request for
regularization, the Respondent filed application Nos.5168-
5169 of 2013 which was allowed by the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal. A direction was issued to the
Appellants to consider the regularization of the service of
the Respondent. Dissatisfied with the direction to consider
his case for regularization, the Respondent filed a Writ
Petition in the High Court of Karnataka. On a
consideration of the history of the case, the High Court
issued a positive mandamus to the Appellants to
regularize the service of the Respondent.

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



Mr. Basava Prabhu Patil, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the Appellants submitted that the
Respondent does not have a right for regularization,
especially after the Act of 2012 was brought into
existence. According to him, the Respondent is entitled to
be considered only for the benefits flowing from the Act.

In its judgment dated 09.03.2012, the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal held that the Respondent worked
for more than 10 years in a duly sanctioned post without
the benefit or protection of an interim order passed by
any Court or Tribunal. While holding so, the Tribunal
observed that the rejection of Respondent’s request for
regularization on the ground that he does not comply with
the requirements of paragraph 53 of the judgment in the
case of Secretary, State of Karnataka and Others Vs.
Umadevi and Others1 was erroneous. The said judgment
of the Tribunal has become final as it was not challenged
by the Appellants. In view thereof, the Respondent had a
right to be considered for regularization of his service in
accordance with the judgment in Umadevi’s case on the
basis of the findings recorded by the Tribunal in its
judgment dated 09.03.2012.

The rejection of the request of the Respondent for
regularization of his service in the light of the Act of 2012
is not correct. It is relevant to note that the Act of 2012
does not deal with the judgments which were passed
earlier granting the benefit of regularization to daily wage
employees. Therefore, the judgments of the Tribunal and
the High Court on regularization remain unaffected.

In view of the peculiar facts and circumstances of
this case, we do not see any reason to interfere with the
direction issued by the High Court to regularize the
service of the Respondent.

Eight weeks’ time is granted to comply with the
order.

The Civil Appeal and pending applications stand
dispose of accordingly.”



- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025




15. In the light of the order of the Apex Court and that
of the Division Benches of this Court as quoted supra, the
submissions of the learned HCGP for the State, though
vehemently contented, is noted only to be rejected, as it is trite
that an employee who serves for 25 to 30 years, who is not
regularized despite his repeated claim for regularization, is
shown a Daily Wage Welfare Act and promised certain benefits
that he would get from the Act would pounce upon it, as it is
the hungry man who would pounce upon food and
not any other person. If the said metaphor is paraphrased to
these proceedings, it would become unmistakably clear that
mere fact that the employees who were hungry for
regularization took benefit of the Act would not take away their
right to seek regularization for the entire services that they
render as it would give them more benefit than that of the
Daily Wage Welfare Act.


16. It is rather surprising or shocking for us to see that
the State despite 3 orders and the order of the Apex Court in
Civil appeal No(s).5292/2019 (supra) which was rendered in
the year 2019 repeatedly makes this submission before the

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025



Constitutional Courts that the employees who have taken
benefit under the Daily Wage Welfare Act cannot turn around
and challenge. Though the law being clear, it appears that
there is no clarity in thought by the State. Therefore, while
admonishing the State not to repeat these submissions in every
case and drive every litigant to the Court, we refrain or hold
our hands from imposing exemplary costs on the State lest it
should fall upon the employee.


17. The learned HCGP submits that the amount that is
taken under the Daily Wage Welfare Act of ₹3,00,000/- ex
gratia or any other amount that is fixed to an employee under
the Act should be refunded.


18. While there cannot be refund from the hands of an
employee when the State itself for implementing the order of
the Tribunal will have to pay certain amount to the employee.
Therefore, the said amount that is received by the employee
under the Act shall be set off while determining the claim of the
employees under the order of the Tribunal.

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18719-DB
WP No. 100778 of 2025
C/W WP No. 107738 of 2024

CNR: KAHC020026592025




19. Finding no merit in these petitions, the petitions
stand rejected. The time for compliance granted by the Tribunal
is extended by another 4 weeks from today.



Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE






kmv
CT:VH