ROSHAN ARA AND ORS. vs UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ORS. (HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT)
- Court
- Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Item No.13
Regular List
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
WP(C) No.3467/2023
c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025
MEHMOODA MIR & ORS.
ROSHAN ARA & ORS.
...PETITIONERS/APPELLANT(S)
Through:
-
Mr. Shariq J. Reyaz, Advocate (in WP(C) No.3467/2023)
Mr.
Faisal Qadiri, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Numan Zargar, Advocate (in WP(C) No.2130/2025)
Vs.
UT OF J&K & ORS. …RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
-
Mr. Numan Malik, GA.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
ORDER(ORAL)
16.11.2026
1) Through the medium of present order, the afore-titled
two writ petitions are proposed to be disposed of.
2) Vide WP(C) No.3467/2023, the petitioners have sought
a direction upon respondent No.2 to grant permission in
their favour for construction of four number of huts on their
land falling under Survey No.1517/648 situated at Laripora,
Pahalgam, whereas, vide WP(C) No.2130/2025, the
petitioners have assailed corrigendum dated 03.04.2025
issued by Chief Town Planner, Kashmir, rescinding the NOC
dated 26.04.2022, with a further direction to the
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 1 of 9
respondents to process/consider the case of the petitioners
for grant of building permission for construction of huts on
their land measuring 07 kanals falling under Survey
No.1517/648 situated at Laripora, Pahalgam.
3) It appears that the petitioners are owners in possession
of land measuring 07 kanals and 11 marlas falling under
Khasra No.1517/648 situated at Laripora, Pahalgam. The
petitioners intended to raise commercial structure for the
purpose of tourism activities on the aforesaid land, therefore,
they applied for building permission with the respondents in
the year 2012. The requisite NOCs were obtained in the year
2018-19 and submitted to the authorities for grant of
building permission. The petitioners, it seems, had
approached this Court by way of WP(C) No. 2553/2022
seeking a direction upon the respondents to consider their
application for building permission. The said writ petition
was disposed of by this Court by extending a direction to the
respondents to take a decision on the application of the
petitioners within a period of one month.
th
4) The BOCA, in its 11 meeting, held on 25.07.2020,
decided that Executive Engineer, Pahalgam Development
Authority (Inspecting Officer, BOCA), will inspect the land
and furnish his report/comments with regard to the
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 2 of 9
conditions laid down in Master Plan, Pahalgam, i.e. angle of
repose necessitated by vertical gradient of the area is
properly maintained for stability of the area. It was further
decided that upon receipt of report and authentication of
measures, the case shall be forwarded to Town Planning
Organization, Kashmir, for authentication of the plans with
regard to adherence of building code and comments thereof.
5) The requisite report was furnished by the Inspecting
Officer and it was recommended that the applicants, in
addition to average length of 90 feet of the State land, have
to provide further 34 feet beyond the State land, thus leaving
a corridor of 53 feet from Pahalgam Chandanwari Road for
future expansion of PC Road. It was further reported that in
the light of the above setback, the applicants have provision
of nearly 82 feet of land length where they can raise
structure as per the proposal submitted.
6) On 26.04.2022, the Chief Town Planner issued his NOC
in favour of the petitioners, wherein it was categorically
stated that the site falls between Chandanwari Road and
PMGSY Road and its land use is agriculture, but is permitted
for tourism use subject to the condition that angle of repose
necessitated by vertical gradient is properly maintained.
th
However, on 06.10.2022, the BOCA, in its 13 meeting,
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 3 of 9
considered the case of the petitioners, but decided that the
same cannot be considered due to contrary land use.
7) The petitioners are stated to have approached this
Court by way of another writ petition bearing WP(C)
No.2553/2022 challenging the non-consideration of their
case by the BOCA. However, this Court vide order dated
16.11.2022 observed that because no formal order of
rejection has been passed, as such, the respondents were
directed to decide the petitioners' case in respect of their
claim within a period of one month.
8) It has been submitted that Deputy Commissioner,
Anantnag, vide his communication dated 31.12.2022 sought
comprehensive details from Chief Town Planner, and in
response to the same, the Chief Town Planner, vide his
communication/report dated 11.02.2023, reported that
changes have been made in the revised Master Plan vis-a-vis
the subject site, but the same has not been reflected in the
land use plan approved by the Government.
9) It has further been submitted that the respondents, in
their objections to WP(C) No.3467/2023, have stated that on
th
01.02.2024 and 02.02.2024, the BOCA convened its 15
meeting and recommended that the case be forwarded to
Law Department through Administrative Department of
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 4 of 9
Tourism for legal opinion in the matter before consideration
in the BOCA. However, the case was placed before the Chief
Town Planner for clarification vis-a-vis land use of the site.
10) A number of directions came to be issued in WP(C)
No.3647/2023, pursuant to which the Chief Town Planner
issued impugned Corrigendum dated 03.04.2025, in terms
of which NOC dated 26.04.2022 has been treated as null and
void.
11) The issue which has hindered the progress of building
permission case of the petitioners is with regard to approved
land use of the site of construction. The land belonging to
the petitioners is recorded as agricultural land. However, in
the Master Plan, it is mentioned that as per the
recommendations of the Committee, the area in between
Chandanwari Road and Rangward Road, within which the
land of the petitioners is situated, is permitted for tourism
use up to 25% slope from Pahalgam-Chandanwari Road,
subject to condition that angle of repose necessitated by
vertical gradient of the area is properly maintained.
12) As already stated, the issue was deliberated upon by
th
BOCA in its 11 meeting held on 25.11.2020, and it was
decided that Executive Engineer (Inspecting Officer, BOCA),
will inspect the site and furnish his report/comments with
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 5 of 9
regard to conditions laid down in the Master Plan, Pahalgam,
i.e. angle of repose necessitated by vertical gradient of area
is properly maintained. The report was received from the
Executive Engineer, which was favourable to the petitioners.
On the basis of this report, the Chief Town Planner, Kashmir,
furnished his NOC vide communication dated 26.04.2022.
th
The case was again considered by the BOCA in its 13
meeting held on 06.10.2022. In the said meeting, it was
decided that the case cannot be considered due to contrary
land use.
13) The petitioners sought review of BOCA decision,
whereafter comments were sought from Chief Town Planner,
Kashmir. The said officer, vide his communication dated
11.02.2023, furnished his comments that case of the
petitioners was disposed of in terms of NOC dated
26.04.2022 permitting construction of proposed four
number of huts on the basis of site specification
recommended by the Committee constituted by the
Government vide Order No.108-TSM of 2014 dated
05.03.2014 for scrutiny of objections and suggestions and
making recommendations for the modification of the draft
Master Plan 2032, and it was also reported that the said
Committee, being statutory Committee constituted under
the provisions of the Development Act, 1970, the
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 6 of 9
recommendation was incorporated in the Master Plan before
its submission to the Government for accord of approval.
However, while processing the case of the petitioners, it came
to the fore that consequent changes vis-a-vis the subject site,
as recommended by the Committee, were not reflected in the
land use plan approved by the Government. It was also
reported that in such circumstances, the relevant provision
of J&K Development Act provides that in case of any
contradiction between any map and the written statement,
the latter shall prevail.
14) In the aforesaid circumstances, the Chief Executive
Officer, Pahalgam Development Authority, vide his
communication dated 19.09.2025, recommended to the
Administrative Department that opinion be obtained from
the Law Department. It seems that the Law Department has
now rendered its opinion on 19.11.2025, wherein it has been
stated that Section 11-A of the J&K Development Act
provides that upon coming into operation of the Master Plan,
the land use permitted in the area thereunder shall be
governed in terms of the Master Plan. It has also been
observed in the opinion of the Law Department that Rule
5(2)(ix) of the J&K Development Authority Rules, 1976,
provides that where there is any inconsistency between the
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 7 of 9
map and the written statement of the Master Plan, the
written statement shall prevail.
15) Pursuant to the aforesaid opinion of the Law
Department, the Department of Housing and Urban
Development has also rendered its opinion by stating that
the proposed tourism-related activity is contemplated in the
written statement of Pahalgam Master Plan, 2032, and does
not appear to be subject to any absolute prohibition under
the applicable planning framework and that the case of the
petitioners appears fit for favourable consideration by the
competent BOCA authorities for grant of building permission
for construction of the proposed tourist huts.
16) In the face of aforesaid developments, there seems to
be no legal impediment for the respondents to take a fresh
decision in regard to grant of permission in favour of the
petitioner for construction of huts on their aforesaid land. So
far as the withdrawal of NOC by Chief Town Planner vide his
impugned corrigendum dated 03.04.2025 is concerned, the
same is based upon the fact that there is a contradiction as
regards the land use in the map and the written statement
of the Master Plan. Since the matter has been clarified by the
Law Department as also by the Housing and Urban
Development Department, as such, there is no justification
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 8 of 9
for the Chief Town Planner to withdraw the NOC already
granted by him pursuant to the report of inspection issued
by the Inspecting Officer. The impugned corrigendum dated
03.04.2025 has lost its significance and is, therefore, liable
to be quashed.
17) For what has been discussed hereinbefore, the writ
petitions are disposed of by extending the following
directions:
(I) Impugned Corrigendum dated 03.04.2025 issued by
Chief Town Planner, Kashmir, shall stand quashed.
(II) Respondent BOCA is directed to take a fresh
decision on the application for building permission
submitted by the petitioners in the light of the
opinion tendered by the Law Department and
Housing and Urban Development Department.
(III) The needful shall be done by the BOCA most
expeditiously, preferably within a period of two
months from the date a copy of this order is made
available to them .
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
SRINAGAR
16.11.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the Order is speaking: YES
Whether the Order is reportable: YES/NO
WP(C) No.3467/2023 c/w
WP(C) No.2130/2025 Page 9 of 9