Narayan Prasad @ Narain Prasad vs The State Of Bihar Through Principal Secretray, Vigilance Department, Bihar, Patna and Anr

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.13826 of 2016
CNR No. BRHC010436002016
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-84 Year-2010 Thana- C.B.I CASE District- Muzaffarpur
======================================================
Narayan Prasad @ Narain Prasad, son of Late Deoki Rai, Resident of
Mohalla - Nalanda Colony Khajpura, P.S. - Rajiv Nagar, District -
Patna. the then Circle Officer, Saraiya Block, P.S. - Saraiya District -
Muzaffarpur.
... ... Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through Principal Secretary, Vigilance Department,
Bihar, Patna.
2. Shailendra Kumar, Son of Late Bhag Narayan Singh, Resident of
Village - Babu Chapra Pokhraira, P.S. - Saraiya, District -
Muzaffarpur.
... ... Opposite Parties
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Javed Aslam, Advocate
For the Vigilance : Mr.Anil Singh, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE CHANDRA SHEKHAR JHA
ORAL JUDGMENT
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the Vigilance Department.
1. The present application has been filed for quashing
of the order dated 07.09.2015 passed by the learned Special
Judge, Vigilance, North Bihar, Muzaffarpur in Vigilance P.S.
Case No. 84 of 2010 corresponding to Special Case No.32 of
2010, whereby cognizance has been taken for the offences
punishable under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120(B)
of the Indian Penal Code as well as Sections 7, 8 and 13(2)
read with Section 13(1)(D) of the Prevention of Corruption

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
2/14
Act, 1988.
2. The prosecution case, in brief, is that on 11.07.2006
the complainant, namely, Shailendra Kumar, instituted
Complaint Case No.25 of 2006 before the learned Special
Judge, Vigilance, North Bihar, Muzaffarpur, alleging, inter
alia, that his father had authorised him to look after the
property in question and to take appropriate legal action. It
was alleged that certain accused persons, in connivance with
each other and misusing their official positions, issued
possession certificate in favour of Ravindra Prasad Singh and
facilitated grant of agricultural loan to him, thereby causing
wrongful loss to the complainant.
3. On the complaint, an enquiry was directed to be
conducted by the Vigilance authorities. Pursuant thereto, a
report was submitted by the S.P., Vigilance vide letter
No.13/08. Thereafter, the learned Special Judge, Vigilance,
vide order dated 05.09.2009, directed institution of the FIR.
Accordingly, Vigilance P.S. Case No.84 of 2010 dated
10.12.2010 came to be instituted.
4. During investigation, the materials collected by the

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
3/14
investigating agency included the relevant land records and
the report submitted by the Halka Karamchari, which was
forwarded through the Circle Inspector to the concerned
Gramin Bank. The allegation against the petitioner, who was
then posted as Circle Officer, Saraiya, is not merely of being
a person holding an official post, but relates to the manner in
which the report concerning the land in question was dealt
with and forwarded, allegedly resulting in issuance of
possession certificate and grant of loan.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that the petitioner had merely discharged his official duty. It
is submitted that the Halka Karamchari had conducted the
enquiry, compared the Jamabandi records and submitted his
report; the petitioner had only forwarded the said report to
the concerned bank. It is further submitted that the loan
amount had subsequently been repaid with interest and,
therefore, no loss had been caused to the bank. It has also
been submitted that the petitioner had rendered long and
unblemished service and had retired in the year 2013.
6. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
4/14
Vigilance Department has opposed the application. It is
submitted that the materials collected during investigation
cannot be brushed aside merely on the basis of the defence
of the petitioner. The investigating agency, after enquiry and
investigation, has submitted charge-sheet and the learned
court below, upon consideration of the materials available on
record, has taken cognizance. It is submitted that whether
the report submitted by the Halka Karamchari was correct,
whether the petitioner acted bona fide in forwarding the
same, whether there was any irregularity in issuance of the
possession certificate and whether the acts of the accused
persons were in furtherance of a common design are all
matters which require evidence and cannot be adjudicated in
exercise of the inherent jurisdiction of this Court.
7. I have considered the rival submissions and perused
the materials placed on record.
8. At the outset, it is to be kept in mind that the
jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is extraordinary in
nature and is required to be exercised sparingly and with
circumspection. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
5/14
Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, reported in 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335,
has indicated the categories in which interference may be
justified, while also cautioning against interference where the
allegations disclose a prima facie case.
9. In Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State
of Maharashtra, reported in 2021 SCC OnLine SC 315 ,
the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated that the power of
quashing is to be exercised sparingly and that the High
Court, while examining the allegations, cannot embark upon
an enquiry into the reliability or genuineness of the
allegations. It was further observed that criminal proceedings
ought not to be scuttled at the initial stage.
10. The present case, in my considered view, does not
fall within the exceptional category warranting exercise of
inherent jurisdiction. The petitioner seeks to demonstrate
that the report submitted by the Halka Karamchari correctly
reflected the position of the land and that he had merely
discharged his official duty by forwarding the same. Such
submission essentially relates to the appreciation of the
materials collected during investigation. At this stage, this

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
6/14
Court cannot conduct an enquiry as to whether the said
report was factually correct or whether the petitioner had
acted bona fide.
11. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Central Bureau of
Investigation v. Aryan Singh and Others, reported in
2023 SCC OnLine SC 379 : (2023) 18 SCC 399 , has
reiterated that at the stage of exercising power under
Section 482 Cr.P.C., the High Court is not required to
conduct a mini trial. The Court is required to consider
whether sufficient material is available to proceed against the
accused and whether the accused is required to be tried. The
question as to whether the allegations would ultimately be
proved is a matter for trial.
12. The plea that the petitioner had merely forwarded
the report also cannot, at this stage, be accepted as
conclusively exonerating him. The prosecution case has to be
considered on the basis of the materials collected during
investigation as a whole. The fact that the initial report was
prepared by the Halka Karamchari or that the petitioner had
forwarded the same does not, by itself, completely exclude

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
7/14
the possibility of his role in the alleged transaction. The
extent of his involvement, the correctness of the report, the
manner of its verification and forwarding, and the existence
or otherwise of any dishonest or culpable intention are
matters which can appropriately be tested only during trial.
13. In this connection, reliance placed by the learned
counsel for the Vigilance Department upon the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Station House Officer,
CBI/ACB/Bangalore v. B.A. Srinivasan and Another,
Criminal Appeal No.1837 of 2019 , decided on
05.12.2019, reported in (2020) 2 SCC 153; 2019 SCC
OnLine SC 1555 , is apposite. The Hon'ble Supreme Court,
while considering the requirement of sanction and the
protection available to a public servant, specifically
considered the position where the public servant had already
retired when cognizance was taken.
14. In paragraph 11 of the said judgment, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, relying upon S.A. Venkataraman v. The
State , held that the protection under the concerned
provisions would not be available to a public servant after he

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
8/14
had “demitted his office or retired from service”. The Court
further noted that where the accused had ceased to be a
public servant at the time when the Court was asked to take
cognizance, the requirement of previous sanction under the
corresponding provision was absent.
15. It would be apposite to reproduce Para No. 11, 12
and 13 of the Station House Officer Case ( Supra)
‘’11. In S.A.Venkataraman v. State
[S.A.Venkataraman v. State, 1958 SCR 1040 :
AIR 1958 SC 107 : 1958 Cri LJ 254] while dealing
with the requirement of sanction under the pari
materia provisions of the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1947, it was laid down that the protection
under the provisions concerned would not be
available to a public servant after he had demitted
his office or retired from service. It was stated: (AIR
p. 111, para 14)
“14. … if an offence under Section 161 of the Penal
Code was committed by a public servant, but, at the
time a court was asked to take cognizance of the
offence, that person had ceased to be a public
servant one of the two requirements to make
Section 6 of the Act applicable would be lacking and
a previous sanction would be unnecessary. The
words in Section 6(1) of the Act are clear enough
and they must be given effect to. There is nothing in

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
9/14
the words used in Section 6(1) to even remotely
suggest that previous sanction was necessary before
a court could take cognizance of the offences
mentioned therein in the case of a person who had
ceased to be a public servant at the time the court
was asked to take cognizance, although he had been
such a person at the time the offence was
committed.”
12. The law so declared by this Court has
consistently been followed. For example, in Labh
Singh [State of Punjab v. Labh Singh, (2014) 16
SCC 807 : (2015) 3 SCC (Cri) 601] it was
observed: (SCC p. 810, para 9)
“9. In the present case the public servants in
question had retired on 13-12-1999 and 30-4-
2000. The sanction to prosecute them was rejected
subsequent to their retirement i.e. first on 13-9-
2000 and later on 24-9-2003. The public servants
having retired from service there was no occasion to
consider grant of sanction under Section 19 of the
PC Act. The law on the point is quite clear that
sanction to prosecute the public servant for the
offences under the PC Act is not required if the
public servant had already retired on the date of
cognizance by the court. In S.A.
Venkataraman v. State [S.A.
Venkataraman v. State, 1958 SCR 1040 : AIR 1958
SC 107 : 1958 Cri LJ 254] while construing Section
6(1) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
10/14
which provision is in pari materia with Section 19(1)
of the PC Act, this Court held that no sanction was
necessary in the case of a person who had ceased to
be the public servant at the time the Court was
asked to take cognizance. The view taken in S.A.
Venkataraman [S.A. Venkataraman v. State, 1958
SCR 1040 : AIR 1958 SC 107 : 1958 Cri LJ 254]
was adopted by this Court in C.R. Bansi v. State of
Maharashtra [C.R. Bansi v. State of Maharashtra,
(1970) 3 SCC 537 : 1971 SCC (Cri) 143] and
in KalicharanMahapatra v. State of
Orissa [Kalicharan Mahapatra v. State of Orissa,
(1998) 6 SCC 411 : 1998 SCC (Cri) 1455 : AIR
1998 SC 2595] and by the Constitution Bench of
this Court in K. Veeraswami v. Union of India [K.
Veeraswami v. Union of India, (1991) 3 SCC 655 :
1991 SCC (Cri) 734] . The High Court [Sikandar
Singh v. State of Punjab, Criminal Revision No.
1743 of 2005, order dated 17-1-2006 (P&H)] was
not therefore justified in setting aside the order
passed by the Special Judge insofar as charge under
the PC Act was concerned.”
13. Consequently, there was no occasion or reason
to entertain any application seeking discharge in
respect of offences punishable under the Act, on the
ground of absence of any sanction under Section 19
of the Act. The High Court was also not justified in
observing “that the protection available to a public
servant while in service, should also be available

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
11/14
after his retirement”. That statement is completely
inconsistent with the law laid down by this Court in
connection with requirement of sanction under
Section 19 of the Act.”
16. In paragraph 14, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
further clarified the position under Section 197 Cr.P.C. It
held that protection under the provision is available when the
offence is alleged to have been committed while acting or
purporting to act in discharge of official duty; however,
where the acts are performed using the office as a mere
cloak for unlawful gains, such acts are not protected. The
Court thus drew a clear distinction between a genuine act in
discharge of official duty and an alleged criminal act merely
facilitated by the official position.
17. The aforesaid principle has direct relevance to the
present case. The petitioner admittedly retired in the year
2013, whereas cognizance was taken on 07.09.2015.
Therefore, the protection under Section 19 of the Prevention
of Corruption Act cannot be invoked on the ground that the
petitioner was a public servant when the alleged occurrence
took place. Further, the plea of protection under Section 197

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
12/14
Cr.P.C. cannot be accepted merely because the alleged acts
were performed during his tenure as Circle Officer. Whether
the acts complained of were genuinely connected with the
discharge of official duty or whether the official position was
used in furtherance of the alleged irregularity is a matter
which requires examination on the basis of evidence.
18. In the present case also, the petitioner cannot
seek a finding at this preliminary stage that the entire action
was nothing but discharge of official duty. More particularly,
the petitioner had retired in the year 2013, whereas
cognizance has been taken on 07.09.2015. Thus, the mere
fact that the alleged acts were performed during the tenure
of the petitioner as Circle Officer cannot, by itself, furnish a
ground to terminate the prosecution.
19. The further submission that the loan amount was
subsequently repaid with interest also does not, at this
stage, wipe out the allegations relating to the manner in
which the loan was sanctioned or the alleged acts committed
in connection with the possession certificate and the land
records. Subsequent repayment of the loan may be a

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
13/14
circumstance which can be brought on record during trial,
but it cannot by itself lead to quashing of the criminal
proceeding.
20. It is also relevant that the investigation has
already culminated in submission of charge-sheet and
cognizance has been taken by the competent court. Once the
materials collected during investigation disclose a prima facie
case requiring adjudication, the High Court ought not to
substitute its own appreciation of such materials for that of
the trial court. The principles laid down in Amit Kapoor v.
Ramesh Chander, reported in (2012) 9 SCC 460, also
require the power of quashing to be exercised very sparingly
and with circumspection, particularly where the allegations
disclose a triable case.
21. On an overall consideration of the materials placed
on record, this Court is unable to hold that the allegations
against the petitioner, even if taken at their face value, are
so inherently improbable or absurd that the continuance of
the criminal proceeding would amount to abuse of the
process of the Court. On the contrary, the materials

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.13826 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
14/14
collected during investigation disclose sufficient matter
requiring the petitioner to face trial.
22. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed
any opinion on the merits of the allegations or the defence of
the petitioner. The learned Trial Court shall consider the
evidence independently and uninfluenced by any observation
made in the present order.
23. Accordingly, the Court finds no merit in the
present application. The same is, accordingly, dismissed.
24. The interim order, if any, stands vacated.
25. The learned Trial Court shall proceed with the case
in accordance with law.
26. Let a copy of this judgment be sent to the learned
trial court forthwith.


(Chandra Shekhar Jha, J.)
Rajeev/-
AFR/NAFR AFR
CAV DATE NA
Date of Pronouncement 19.11.2026
Uploading Date 19.11.2026
Transmission Date 19.11.2026