Ningthoujam Memma Devi vs State of Manipur and 4 Others
- Court
- Manipur High Court
ca
REPORTABLE
2026:MNHC:221-DB
Special DB Sl. No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Crl.) No. 22 of 2026
Ningthoujam Memma Devi, aged about 59 Years, W/o (Late) N.
Subol Singh and M/o Ningthoujam Chalamba Singh of Khurai
Kongpal Sajor Leikai, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Porompat, Imphal East
District, Manipur.
……Petitioner
Vs.
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt.
of Manipur at Old Secretariat, Babupara, Imphal, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Pin Code No. 795001, Manipur.
2. The District Magistrate, Imphal West, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Govt.
of Manipur.
3. The Commissioner (Home), Govt. of Manipur at Old Secretariat,
Babupara, Imphal, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Pin
Code No. 795001.
4. The Union of India, represented by the Secretary, Govt. of India,
Ministry of Home Affairs (Department of Internal Security),
North Block, New Delhi-110001.
5. The Superintendent of Prison, Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa.
……Responden ts
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For petitioner Mr. S. Jhalajit Singh, Advocate
For respondent Nos. 1, 2, 3 & 5 Mr. S. Chittaranjan, Additional Advocate
General, Manipur along with Mr. A. Priyokumar
Sharma, Advocate
For respondent No. 4 Mr. W. Darakeshwar, Senior Panel Counsel for
Central Government (Sr. PCCG)
Date of Judgment & Order 05.10.2026
Page 1 of 19
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(ORAL)
(M. Sundar, CJ)
[1] The following abbreviations/short forms have been used in
this order (for the sake of brevity, convenience and clarity):
Sl.
No.
Abbreviation/Short
Full Form/Expansion
Form/other short
references
1. WP Writ Petition
2. MC Miscellaneous Case
3. FIR First Information Report
4. FIRs First Information Reports
5. BNS the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023
(45 of 2023)
6. BNSS the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 (46 of 2023)
7. BSA the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam,
2023 (47 of 2023)
8. Explosive Substances
Act
the Explosive Substances Act, 1908
(6 of 1908)
9. UAPA the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Act, 1967 (37 of 1967)
10. Arms Act the Arms Act, 1959 (54 of 1959)
11. IPC the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860)
12. CrPC the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(2 of 1974)
13. Evidence Act the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of
1872)
14. NSA the National Security Act, 1980 (65 of
1980)
15. MHA Ministry of Home Affairs
Ningthoujam Chalamba Singh, aged
16. Detenu
about 29 years, s/o late N. Subol Singh
of Khurai Kongpal Sajor Leikai, PS-
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
Page 2 of 19
Sl.
No.
Abbreviation/Short
Full Form/Expansion
Form/other short
references
Ningthoujam Memma Devi (mother of
17. Writ petitioner
detenu)
st nd rd
18. R1, R2, R3, R4, R5 1 respondent, 2 respondent, 3
th th
respondent, 4 respondent, 5
respondent respectively
19. Detaining authority R2 (District Magistrate, Imphal West
District, Manipur)
20. Sponsoring authority Superintendent of Police, Imphal
West District, Manipur
21. Impugned preventive
detention order
order dated 06.04.2026 made by R2
under section 3(3) of NSA bearing
reference No. Crl/NSA/No. 2 of 2026
22. Impugned approval
order
order dated 13.04.2026 made by
R1/R3 under Section 3(4) of NSA
bearing Reference No. H-14/4/2026-
HD-HD
23. Impugned
confirmation order
order dated 27.04.2026 made by
R1/R3 under Section 12(1) of NSA
bearing Reference No. H-14/4/2026-
HD-HD
[2] Captioned WP has been filed in this Court on 30.06.2026 by
writ petitioner with a habeas corpus plea assailing impugned preventive
detention order, impugned approval order and the impugned confirmation
order vide which her son {Ningthoujam Chalamba Singh (detenu)} now
remains incarcerated in Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa. Detenu was arrested
on 09.02.2026 pursuant to FIR No. 46(2)2026 on the file of Singjamei
Police Station dated 08.02.2026 for alleged offences under Sections
109/351(3)/324(4) BNS and 3 – Explosive Substances Act. Detenu moved
a bail application in the Trial Court on 01.04.2026, pending bail application,
Page 3 of 19
sponsoring authority wrote to detaining authority a letter dated
06.04.2026 bearing Reference No. 22/Spl-Cell/2026(02):/6380
recommending the clamping of a preventive detention order qua detenu,
acting on this letter of sponsoring authority, detaining authority made the
impugned preventive detention order on the same day and this impugned
preventive detention order was served on the detenu on the same day i.e.,
06.04.2026. This means that the detenu who remains incarcerated from
09.02.2026 was formally arrested pursuant to impugned preventive
detention order on 06.04.2026. To be noted, the grounds of detention
dated 06.04.2026 was also served on the detenu on the same day.
Thereafter, the regular bail application of the detenu filed on 01.04.2026
was rejected by the Trial Court in and by an order dated 30.04.2026. In
such circumstances, captioned WP has been filed in this Court on
30.06.2026. R2, detaining authority has filed an affidavit-in-opposition
dated 05.08.2026 and the same has been adopted by R1 and R3. R5 has
filed a separate affidavit-in-opposition dated 06.08.2026. As regards R4,
an affidavit-in-opposition dated 30.07.2026 has been filed. Thereafter, writ
petitioner filed MC [W.P. (Crl.)] No. 3 of 2026 with a prayer to raise
additional grounds and this MC was allowed by this Court in and by an
order dated 17.09.2026. In the interregnum, post filing of captioned WP
on 30.06.2026, 90 days from the date of arrest (actual arrest on
09.02.2026) elapsed on 10.05.2026 but charge sheet/final report had not
been filed. No application for extension of time for filing charge sheet/final
Page 4 of 19
report as well as extension of remand by resorting to Section 43D(2) of
UAPA was filed. In such circumstances, the detenu filed a default bail
application on 28.07.2026 being Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 272 of 2026 in the
Trial Court and after putting on notice and hearing the Special Public
Prosecutor, the default bail application has been allowed by the Trial Court
on the same day i.e., 28.07.2026 on condition that a bond for Rs.
1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh only) with one surety of like amount should
be furnished. A further condition that detenu should not leave the State of
Manipur without the permission of the Court was also imposed. The detenu
was unable to come out of jail and he remains incarcerated solely because
of the impugned preventive detention order. In this regard, it is to be
noted that prior to his arrest on 09.02.2026 (pursuant to FIR dated
08.02.2026) the detenu was arrested on 13.10.2023 pursuant to FIR No.
808(10)2023 on the file of Imphal Police Station for alleged offences under
Section 20 of UAPA and 25 (1-B) of Arms Act but was released on bail on
20.10.2023, he was again arrested on 21.3.2025 pursuant to FIR No.
17(3)2025 on the file of Lamsang Police Station for alleged offences under
Sections 20/38 of UAPA and 25 (1-C) of Arms Act but was released on bail
on 27.03.2025, however considering the scope of legal drill at hand it is
not necessary to dilate further on these details and it will suffice to write
that the detenu now remains incarcerated solely owing to impugned
preventive detention order.
Page 5 of 19
[3] In the hearing today, Mr. S. Jhalajit, learned counsel for writ
petitioner, Mr. S. Chittaranjan, learned Additional Advocate General for
State of Manipur along with Mr. A. Priyokumar Sharma, learned State
counsel for R1, R2, R3 & R5 and Mr. W. Darakeshwar, learned Senior Panel
Counsel for Central Government (Sr. PCCG) for R4 are before this Court.
[4] Pleadings are complete in the aforesaid manner. As regards
the additional grounds raised by writ petitioner vide MC [W.P. (Crl)] No. 3
of 2026, learned Additional Advocate General submitted that he would
argue on the basis of records and the records are before this Court. The
captioned WP was heard out in full.
[5] After hearing out the captioned WP in full, this Court comes
to the conclusion that the captioned WP deserves to be allowed and the
reasons are as follows:
(i) The impugned preventive detention order is vitiated by
non-application of mind on the part of detaining authority
resulting in flawed subjective satisfaction. The impugned
preventive detention order proceeds on the basis that the
detenu is a hardcore member of Kangleipak Communist Party
(Apunba) [KCP-Apunba] and that this KCP-Apunba is an
‘ unlawful association ’ as notified by the Government of India,
MHA vide Notification No. SO 4899(E) dated 13.11.2023.
impugned preventive detention order also very clearly says that
Page 6 of 19
detenu joined KCP-Apunba in July of 2023. The sponsoring
authority has placed before the detaining authority the
13.11.2023 notification of MHA declaring KCP as an ‘ unlawful
.’ This notification clearly states that vide proviso to
association
sub-Section (3) of Section 3 of UAPA, the declaration shall take
immediate effect i.e., on the same day (13.11.2023) but it is
subject to any order that may be made under Section 4 of UAPA
and it has also been made clear that the declaration is subject
to any order under Section 4. Though this has been clearly
articulated in the notification of MHA, the detaining authority
has not verified whether the declaration has been confirmed by
the Tribunal under Section 4. To be noted, Section 4 of UAPA
vide sub-Section (3) makes it clear that the Tribunal shall make
such a decision within six months from the date of issue of the
notification (on or before 13.05.2024 in this case) and vide sub-
Section (4) of Section 4, it has been made clear that the order
of the Tribunal shall be published in the Official Gazette. The
detaining authority should have at least checked the Official
Gazette. This is more so as the 13.11.2023 notification of MHA
was placed before the detaining authority on 06.04.2026 nearly
2(two) and half years after the notification. Another flaw in the
subjective satisfaction is the grounds of detention order vide
Page 7 of 19
B.1. says that detenu joined KCP-Apunba in July of 2023 which
is prior to 13.11.2023. This means that as per the material
before the detaining authority, the detenu joined KCP-Apunba
prior to it being declared as an by MHA
‘ unlawful association ’
on 13.11.2023 and there is neither material or averment to the
effect that detenu continued to be a member post 13.11.2023
also. Therefore, for these two reasons i.e., not verifying
whether any order has been made by the Tribunal under
Section 4 within six months but proceeding on the basis that
the 13.11.2023 notification continued to operate on 06.04.2026
and further proceeding on the basis that detenu joined the
unlawful association even before it was declared to be
without any material or averment that he
‘unlawful’
continued to be a member post such declaration also the
subjective satisfaction is flawed by non-application of mind
which vitiates the impugned preventive detention order. As
regards subjective satisfaction, in Ameena Begum vs. State
of Telangana & Ors . reported in (2023) 9 SCC 587 , Hon’ble
Supreme Court after a survey of various case laws on
preventive detention including preventive detention orders
under NSA made it clear that subjective satisfaction of detaining
authority though subjective can be tested albeit on certain
Page 8 of 19
grounds and Hon’ble Supreme carved out six grounds. An
adumbration of these six grounds is as follows.
(a) When the detaining authority has not applied its mind
at all;
(b) When there is dishonest exercise of power by
detaining authority;
(c) Exercise of power of detaining authority for improper
purpose;
(d) Detaining authority acting under dictation of another
body;
(e) When the subjective satisfaction recorded by
detaining authority is based on application of wrong
test or misconception of a statute;
(f) When the detaining authority has arrived at and
recorded subjective satisfaction without the same
being grounded on materials which are rationally
probative value.
In the case at hand, we respectfully followed and applied
Ameena Begum case. We find that the impugned preventive
detention order is vitiated by (a), (e) and (f). Detaining authority
has not applied its mind at all as the MHA notification itself clearly
says that it is subject to any order under Section 4 and it is dated
13.11.2023, and it proceeds on the basis that the detenu is
alleged to have joined KCP in July of 2023 without even an
averment that he continued to be a member post 13.11.2023
also. This is also based on misconception of a statute i.e., UAPA.
Page 9 of 19
As regards ‘unlawful associations’ vide 2(1)(p) of UAPA it is clear
that the notification made by MHA should be referred to the
Tribunal under Section 4 and the Tribunal should confirm the
same within 6(six) months. It is also vitiated by (f) as the
subjective satisfaction has been arrived at and recorded without
the same being grounded on material which are of rationally
probative value. In this case, material which is of rationally
probative value is confirmation order of the Tribunal which was
admittedly not before the detaining authority. This Court also had
the benefit of perusing the records and it finds that other than
the 13.11.2023 notification of MHA, no other material in this
regard was before the detaining authority. To be noted, this MHA
notification point popped up in the course of hearing and learned
State counsel submitted records in response to above point and
it is clear as daylight that no confirmation order of Tribunal was
before detaining authority and in any event there is no mention
either about this or continued membership in the impugned
preventive detention order.
(ii) In the impugned preventive detention order, the detaining
authority has set out in unambiguous terms that representations to
State as well as Central Governments should be submitted within
3(three) weeks from the date of detention. In Premlata being
Premlata Sharma (Smt.) vs. District Magistrate, Mathura &
Page 10 of 19
Ors. reported in (1998) 4 SCC 260 , Hon’ble Supreme Court made
it clear that right of a detenu to make representations subsists as
long as the preventive detention order operates. This Court, by
respectfully following Premlata principles inter alia in Yambem
Manichandra Singh case reported in 2026:MNHC:100-DB
(High Court of Manipur Neutral Citation) held that fixing of 3(three)
weeks cap for sending representations is a clear infraction of Article
22(5) of the Constitution. Even prior to Yambem Manichandra
Singh , this Court first so held in Mutum Ranjan Meitei @
Lamjingba vs. District Magistrate, Thoubal, Thoubal District
& Ors. being order dated 11.02.2026 made in W.P.(Crl.) No. 34 of
2025 followed by Smt. Laishram Nilajit Shija vs. State of
Manipur & Ors . being order dated 12.03.2026 made in W.P.(Crl.)
No. 1 of 2026. All these orders viz, Mutum Ranjan Meitei ,
Laishram Nilajit Shija and Yambem Manichandra Singh have
attained finality as State has accepted these orders and they have
released the detenus in those cases. In the case at hand, the date
of detention i.e., formal detention pursuant to impugned preventive
detention order is 06.04.2026 and 3(three) weeks therefrom
elapsed on 27.04.2026. The detenu sent representations dated
10.04.2026 to the detaining authority, 13.04.2026 to State
Government, 15.04.2026 to the Central Government and
17.04.2026 to the Advisory Board. Therefore, the detenu in this
Page 11 of 19
case has sent representations within 3(three) weeks but in the
additional grounds, more particularly, paragraph No. 5, the detenu
has raised an additional ground that after 3(three) weeks, post
submission of representations, the detenu wanted to send a second
representation but did not do so owing to the 3(three) weeks time
cap fixed. Paragraph No. 5 of the additional grounds to the extent
relevant reads as follows:
‘5. ... Since the detaining authority set 3 (Three) weeks' time
st
for submission of representation, after submission of the 1
nd
representation to the detaining authority, the right of 2 time
representation to the detaining authority is curtailed in
violation of Article 22(5) of the Constitution.
...’
As already alluded to supra learned State counsel as
regards the additional grounds submitted that he will argue on
the basis of the records. Learned State counsel submitted that
the detenu has not made out any grievance regarding disposal
of the first set of representations and therefore the question of
sending second set of representations does not arise. This
argument, though attractive in first blush, does not find favour
with us as detenu has not said that he wanted to send second
set of representations because he is not satisfied with the
disposal of the first set of representations. All that the detenu
Page 12 of 19
says is that he wanted to send representation/s again (second
time) which means he has been put on the wise about better and
newer points or some other new circumstances, say ‘grant of
default bail’ had to be projected but he respectfully did not do so
owing to the 3(three) weeks cap. We find that grant of default
bail is a very important point and that could have been articulated
in a second representation if it had been made. In this view of
the matter, this Court has no hesitation in coming to the
conclusion that there is infraction of Article 22(5) of the
Constitution owing to the impugned preventive detention order
prescribing 3(three) weeks time cap i.e., 3(three) weeks from the
date of detention for sending representations to State and
Central Governments. In this regard, it is deemed appropriate to
write that it has been repeatedly held that ‘representation’ has
been interpreted as ‘effective representation’ and includes
multiple representations.
[6] Though we have set out two points on which the impugned
preventive detention order, impugned approval and confirmation orders
stand vitiated, we noticed one other point and we deemed it appropriate
to set out the same. In the listing on 07.09.2026, this Court noticed that
the prosecution has not resorted to Section 43D(2) of UAPA and sought
extension of period of remand/extension of time for filing charge
Page 13 of 19
sheet/final report and wanted to know the reasons. The proceedings made
in 07.09.2026 listing of captioned WP reads as follows:
‘ 07-09-2026
[1] Read this in conjunction with and in continuation of earlier
proceedings made in the previous listings.
[2] When the matter was taken up, Mr. S. Jhalajit, learned counsel
on record for writ petitioner (mother of detenue), Mr. S.
Chittaranjan, learned Additional Advocate General for the State of
Manipur along with Mr. Y. Max, learned counsel for respondent
Nos. 1 to 3 & 5 and Mr. W. Darakeshwar, learned Sr. PCCG
(Senior Panel Counsel for Central Government) for respondent No.
4 were before this Court.
[3] At the outset, referring to earlier proceedings made in the
previous listing on 01-09-2026, more particularly paragraph No. 5
thereat, learned Additional Advocate General, on instructions,
submitted that the affidavit-in-opposition dated 05-08-2026 filed by
respondent No. 2 (detaining authority) is adopted by respondent
Nos. 1 & 3. This submission is recorded. This also means that
respondent Nos. 1 & 3 are not filing separate affidavits-in-
opposition.
[4] Adverting to the same paragraph No. 5 of the proceedings
made in the listing on 01-09-2026, learned Additional Advocate
General further submitted that all relevant official files are ready
with him for production before this Court.
[5] Be that as it may, a point which pops up repeatedly, popped
up in instant case also. Detenue was arrested on 09-02-2026
pursuant to FIR No. 46(2)2026 on the file of Singjamei Police
Station pertaining to Sections 109, 351(3), 324(4) of the ‘Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (45 of 2023)’ {‘BNS’ for the sake of brevity},
Section 3 of the ‘Explosives Act, 1884 (4 of 1884)’ {hereinafter
‘Explosives Act’ for the sake of brevity}, Section 25 (1-B) of the
‘Arms Act, 1959 (54 of 1959)’ {hereinafter ‘Arms Act’ for the sake
of brevity} and Sections 16 and 38 of the ‘Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967 (37 of 1967)’ {‘UAPA’ for the sake of
brevity}. To be noted, this FIR is dated 08-02-2026. Learned
Page 14 of 19
Additional Advocate General submitted that the UAPA provisions
were added on the next day i.e., 09-02-2026.
[6] We find that as regards UAPA provisions, Section 16 finds
its place under Chapter IV and Section 38 finds its place under
Chapter VI.
[7] In the above scenario, detenue filed Cril. Misc. (B) Case No.
142 of 2026 seeking regular bail which was first listed on 01-04-
2026 and ultimately rejected by the Trial Court concerned on 30-
04-2026.
[8] 90 days from the date of arrest elapsed on 10-05-2026 but
neither final report was filed nor an application under Section
43D(2) of UAPA for extension of time for filing charge-sheet and
extension of period of remand to 180 days (from 90 days) was filed.
In this scenario, detenue filed a default bail application in Cril
Misc. (B) Case No. 272 of 2026 on 28-07-2026 (nearly 2½ months
after elapsing of 90 days) and the same (default bail) had been
granted by the Trial Court concerned.
[9] This Court is informed that charge-sheet has not been filed
in the trial court concerned until today.
[10] It was submitted by learned counsel for writ petitioner that
the State having missed the bus in the regular law and order drill
by not filing an application under Section 43D(2) and allowed the
detenue to get default bail cannot now continue to detain the
detenue relying solely on the impugned preventive detention under
the National Security Act, 1980 (65 of 1980) {‘NSA’ for the sake of
brevity}. However, learned counsel for writ petitioner sought time
to ferret out case law inter alia on this point. This request acceded
to.
[11] Mr. Y. Max, learned counsel assisting AAG sought time to
get instructions as to why an application under Section 43D(2) of
UAPA was not filed. This request of Mr. Y. Max, learned counsel is
also acceded to. It is desirable that Prosecutor concerned is also
present in Court along with learned AAG in the next listing to assist
him.
[12] Owing to aforementioned request from both sides, let
captioned matter stand over to 12-09-2026 (Saturday). List under
Page 15 of 19
the caption ‘PART HEARD HEARING’ on 12-09-2026
(Saturday).’
The response to above by learned State counsel was captured in
the proceedings made in the listing on 12.09.2026 and the proceedings
made on 12.09.2026 reads as follows:
‘ 12.09.2026
[1] Read this in conjunction with and in continuation of earlier
proceedings made in the previous listing on 07.09.2026.
[2] Today, Mr. S. Jhalajit, learned counsel on record for writ
petitioner, Mr. S. Chittaranjan, learned Addl. AG (Additional Advocate
General) for State of Manipur for respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and 5 and Mr.
W. Darakeshwar, learned Sr. PCCG (Senior Panel Counsel for Central
Government) for respondent No. 4 are before this Court (Physical
Court).
[3] Owing to earlier proceedings dated 07.09.2026, Mr. A.
Gopendro Sharma, learned Spl. PP (Special Public Prosecutor),
Imphal West is present in Court. Adverting to earlier proceedings, as
regards the application under Section 43D(2) of ‘Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967’ (‘UAPA’ for the sake of convenience),
following two points were made by learned State counsel:
(i) advent of new Act namely, ‘Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita 2023 (46 of 2023)’ (‘BNSS’ for the
sake of convenience), in place of erstwhile ‘Criminal
Procedure Code, 1973’ (‘CrPC’ for the sake of
convenience);
(ii) investigating officer has not approached learned
Prosecutor with a request for extension of time for filing
final report/extension of remand by resorting to Section
43D(2) of UAPA.
[4] In our considered opinion, as regards the second point supra,
suffice to say that investigating officer had not been qui vive (alert). Be
that as it may, if it becomes necessary, we will examine the first point,
as the matter progresses.
Page 16 of 19
[5] As regards hearing today, Mr. S. Jhalajit, learned counsel on record
for writ petitioner, after some arguments, sought further adjournment
stating that he needs to examine legal position, particularly regarding
representations of detenu disposal turning on Article 22(5) of the
Constitution of India. This adjournment request of learned counsel for
writ petitioner is acceded to.
[6] In the light of narration thus far, we make it clear that Spl. PP,
Imphal West, Mr. A. Gopendro Sharma need not be present in this
Court in the ensuing listing/s.
[7] List under the same cause list caption i.e., ‘HEAIRNG PART
HEARD’ on 17.09.2026.
[8] List on 17.09.2026.’
As regards the two reasons for not resorting to Section
43D(2) of UAPA, while the submission of prosecutor that the Investigating
Officer did not approach the prosecutor with a request to file an application
under Section 43D(2) of UAPA is acceptable from the prosecutor’s shoes
but as a Court we find that the Investigating Officer not having requested
learned prosecutor resort to Section 43D(2) of UAPA clearly means that
State has allowed the matter to slip through its hands as regards the
regular Law and Order drill, having allowed the matter to slip through its
hands in the regular Law and Order drill and having allowed detenu to get
default bail in the regular Law and Order drill, preventive detention order
cannot be used to detain the detenu. Be that as it may, as regards the
second reason, learned State counsel submitted that Section 531 of BNSS
does not save provisions of erstwhile IPC, CrPC and Evidence Act. As
Section 43D(2) of UAPA mentions only about CrPC and more particularly
Section 167 of CrPC, with the advent of BNSS on 01.07.2024, application
could not be filed. Though Section 531 of BNSS does not save the
Page 17 of 19
provisions of erstwhile CrPC, post 01.07.2024 i.e., post the three new
enactments coming into force, the Ministry of Law and Justice has issued
a notification dated 16.07.2024 bearing reference No. S.O. 2790(E) and
scanned reproduction of this notification is as follows:
The above means that Section 167 of CrPC should now be
read as Section 187 of BNSS. There is absolutely no impediment in filing
an application under Section 43D(2) of UAPA seeking extension of time for
filing charge-sheet/extension of remand by referring to the afore-referred
notification of Ministry of Law and Justice and predicating the prayer on
the plea that Section 167 of CrPC occurring in Section 43D(2) of UAPA
should now be read as Section 187 BNSS. We make it clear that we have
set out the obtaining correct legal position for the benefit of all concerned.
Though detaining a person by resorting to a preventive detention statute
after State allowing the matter to slip through its hands in the regular Law
and Order drill may qualify as a ground, we make it clear that we are
allowing the writ petition on the aforesaid two grounds.
Page 18 of 19
[7] Ergo, sequitur is, captioned WP is allowed. The impugned
preventive detention order dated 06.04.2026 bearing Reference No.
Crl/NSA/No. 2 of 2026 made by R2 (District Magistrate, Imphal West
District, Manipur), impugned approval order dated 13.04.2026 bearing
Reference No. H-14/4/2026-HD-HD made by R1/R3 and impugned
confirmation order dated 27.04.2026 bearing reference No. H-14/4/2026-
HD-HD made by R1/R3 are all set-aside and Ningthoujam Chalamba Singh,
aged about 29 years s/o late N. Subol Singh of Khurai Kongpal Sajor Leikai,
PS-Porompat, Imphal East District now lodged in Manipur Central Jail,
Sajiwa, is directed to be set at liberty forthwith, if not required in
connection with any other case/s. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sandeep/Indrajeet
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by web copy uploaded in High Court
website inter alia as the same is QR coded.
P.S. III: Learned Registrar General is directed to circulate this order to all
the learned District Judges and more particularly, the NIA Court
being Special Court for NIA cases, Thoubal, with a request to
circulate it to all other Judicial Officers in the State for clarity and
specificity regarding the obtaining position qua saving of IPC, CrPC
and Evidence Act.
Digitally signed by
KABORAMBAM
SANDEEP SINGH
Date: 2026.10.06
19:23:07 +05'30'
KABORAMBA
M SANDEEP
SINGH
Page 19 of 19