Deshraj vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
CWP-3716-2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
222
CWP-3716-2023
Date of Decision: 12.11.2026
Deshraj
....Petitioner
VERSUS
Haryana Staff Selection Commission
….Respondent
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present : Mr. Ravinder Singh Dhull and Mr. Navneet Sharma,
Advocates for the petitioner.
Mr. Rahul Dev Singh, Addl. AG Haryana.
HARPREET SINGH BRAR , J.
1. This civil writ petition has been filed under Article 226/227
of the Constitution of India seeking the issuance of an appropriate writ,
order or direction, particularly a writ in the nature of certiorari , for
quashing the impugned final result dated 23.01.2023 (Annexure P-4),
whereby the name of the petitioner has not been recommended in the
selection list for the post of Welder (Gas and Electric) Instructor
(Theory), Category No. 26, on account of non-grant of 5 marks under the
socio-economic criteria.
1.1. A further prayer has been made for the issuance of a writ in
the nature of mandamus , directing the respondent-Commission to grant 5
marks to the petitioner under the socio-economic criteria, as the
petitioner's father had died before he attained the age of 43 years and the
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
2
CWP-3716-2023
certificate issued by the competent authority in this regard was duly
appended by the petitioner.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner , inter alia, contends that
the petitioner applied for the post of Welder (Gas and Electric) Instructor
(Theory) under the Backward Class-A (BCA) category, in terms of
Advertisement No. 12/2019. The final result was declared on
23.01.2023. However, the petitioner was not granted 5 marks under the
category of 'fatherless'. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the issue involved in the present writ petition is squarely covered by the
judgment passed by this Court in Manjeet Kumar v. State of Haryana
and others, CWP-20593-2022 , decided on 15.10.2026. He has further
placed reliance upon the judgment rendered by this Court in Nisha v.
Haryana Staff Selection Commission, CWP-11894-2021 , decided on
30.07.2021 (Annexure P-10).
3. Learned State counsel is not in a position to controvert
the fact that the petitioner in Nisha (supra) had submitted the
certificate claiming 5 marks under the socio-economic criteria after
the last date prescribed for submission of the application.
4. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have
gone through the paper book. The relevant portion of the judgment
passed in Manjeet Kumar (supra) reads as under:-
“ 11. In Nisha (supra ), this Court considered a
similar issue wherein the candidate had uploaded a
certificate establishing her status as an orphan but had
not submitted the certificate in the prescribed format
along with the application. The respondent-Commission
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
3
CWP-3716-2023
had objected to the subsequent submission of the
requisite certificate after the prescribed cut-off date.
Upon consideration of the facts and the applicable legal
principles, this Court granted relief to the candidate.
12. In Nisha (supra ), this Court considered a
similar issue wherein the candidate had uploaded a
certificate establishing her status as an orphan but had
not submitted the certificate in the prescribed format
along-with the application. The respondent-Commission
had objected to the subsequent submission of the
requisite certificate after the prescribed cut-off date.
Upon consideration of the facts and the applicable legal
principles, this Court granted relief to the candidate.
13. In Nisha (supra) the following observations
was observed by the Co-ordinate Bench:-
“The question which arises before this Court
for determination in the present petition is
‘whether, the petitioner, in the facts and
circumstances of this case, is entitled for the
grant of 5 marks as being claimed by her
under the socio economic criteria’?
It is a matter of fact, which is not disputed,
that the petitioner had attached the orphan
certificate issued to her by the authorities
dated 17.9.2018 (Annexure P-5) as
Annexure A-II existed on the said date along
with the application form, which clearly
depicted her date of birth and the date of the
death of her father. It is also a conceded fact
that while filling the form, a copy of which
has been appended along with the petition
as Annexure P-2, the petitioner gave the
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
4
CWP-3716-2023
information while claiming the benefit of
socio-economic criteria that she qualifies
the condition of being first/second child and
her father died before she had attained the
age of 15 years. That being so, the only
objection which the respondent-Commission
is raising for non grant of 5 marks under
socio-economic criteria, is that the
petitioner had not appended the proforma
Annexure A-II which has been attached by
the Government of Haryana along with the
instructions dated 11.6.2019 (Annexure P-7)
before the last date of submission of
application form. As per the respondent, in
the amended Annexure A-II, the additional
information was required to be given about
the age of the applicant at the time of death
of the father as well as whether the applicant
is the first or the second child and the same
was submitted by the petitioner after the last
date of submission of application form which
disentitles the petitioner to claim 5 marks
under socio-economic criteria.
This Court has to opine whether, the said
certificate Annexure P-6 though admittedly
given by the petitioner after the last date of
submission of application form but at the
time of scrutiny of documents, is to be
treated as a fresh document or a
clarificatory document in the facts and
circumstances of this case. It is not disputed
that even the orphans were entitled for
claiming benefit of 5 marks under the socio-
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
5
CWP-3716-2023
economic criteria which benefit was
initiated by the Government of Haryana in
the year 2017 concededly. It is also not
disputed that the petitioner was granted an
orphan certificate by the competent
authority, on the prescribed Annexure A-II,
as it existed at that time, a copy of which has
been attached as Annexure P-5 with this
present petition and was attached by the
petitioner with application form. The said
orphan certificate underwent a
nomenclature change vide instructions dated
11.6.2019 to be read as ‘certificate for an
applicant whose father had died’ and also
included additional information ‘as to
what was the age of the applicant at the time
of death of her father’ and ‘whether the
applicant is the first or the second child’.
The only difference being pointed out by the
learned counsel for the respondent is that
Annexure A-II, attached with the instructions
dated 11.6.2019, had additional clauses
of information which were missing in
previous certificate submitted by the
petitioner i.e. Annexure P-5 dated
17.9.2018, hence cannot be treated as valid
for the grant of 5 marks under socio-
economic criteria.
In my opinion, certificate Annexure P-6
dated 15.3.2021, issued on amended
annexure A-II, is only a clarificatory
certificate for the reason that even Annexure
P-5, which was issued to the petitioner on
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
6
CWP-3716-2023
17.9.2018 and was attached by the petitioner
along with the application form, depicted
her date of birth as well as the date of death
of her father, which could easily clarify what
was the age of the applicant on the date of
death of her father. Regarding the second
issue that Annexure P-5 did not include the
information ‘whether the petitioner is the
first or the second child’, the same can also
be taken care of as the petitioner had given
the said information while filling up the
application form wherein the petitioner was
required to furnish the said information and
the same was provided by the petitioner. It is
not a case where the information, for which
the amended certificate i.e. Annexure P-6
was given by the petitioner on 15.3.2021,
was not submitted by the petitioner or was
not available with the authorities before the
last date of submission of application form.
Hence, the certificate Annexure P-6, given
by the petitioner on 15.3.2021, was only a
clarificatory certificate regarding the
information which was already on record of
the respondent-Commission before the last
date of submission of application form. The
treatment of certificate Annexure P-6 as a
fresh document submitted after the last date
of submission especially in view of the facts
and circumstances of this case, by the
respondent-Commission, cannot be termed
as correct. Once all the information, which
is depicted in the certificate dated 15.3.2021
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
7
CWP-3716-2023
(Annexure P-6), was mentioned in the
certificate dated 17.9.2018 (Annexure P-5),
read with the information given by the
petitioner while filling the application form
hence, the objection being taken by the
respondent-Commission that the required
certificate was submitted by the petitioner
after the last date, is not a correct factual
aspect.
Once, the information which makes the
petitioner eligible for the grant of 5 marks
under socio-economic criteria was available
with the respondent-Commission along with
required certificates, merely supporting the
said information/certificate by another
clarificatory certificate, though given after
the last date of submission of form, cannot
oust the petitioner from the grant of the said
marks so as to deny her claim. The law on
this aspect is also clear. Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Civil Appeal No.6506 of
2004 (arising out of SLP (Civil) No.21153 of
2003) titled as “Dolly Chhanda Vs.
Chairman, JEE” decided on 5.10.2004,
settled this question of law in somewhat
similar circumstances. Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India held as under: -
7. The general rule is that while
applying for any course of study
or a post, a person must possess
the eligibility qualification on the
last date fixed for such purpose
either in the admission brochure
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
8
CWP-3716-2023
or in application form, as the
case may be, unless there is an
express provision to the contrary.
There can be no relaxation in
this regard i.e. in the matter of
holding the requisite eligibility
qualification by the date fixed.
This has to be established by
producing the necessary
certificates, degrees or
marksheets. Similarly, in order to
avail of the benefit of reservation
or weightage etc. necessary
certificates have to be produced.
These are documents in the
nature of proof of holding of
particular qualification or
percentage of marks secured or
entitlement for benefit of
reservation. Depending upon the
facts of a case, there can be some
relaxation in the matter of
submission of proof and it will
not be proper to apply any rigid
principle as it pertains in the
domain of procedure. Every
infraction of the rule relating to
submission of proof need not
necessarily result in rejection of
candidature.
XXXX
9. The appellant undoubtedly
belonged to reserved MI
category. She comes from a very
humble background, her father
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
9
CWP-3716-2023
was only a Naik in the armed
forces. He may not have noticed
the mistake which had been
committed by the Zilla Sainik
Board while issuing the first
certificate dated 29.6.2003. But it
does not mean that the appellant
should be denied her due when
she produced a correct
certificate at the stage of second
counselling. Those who secured
rank lower than the appellant
have already been admitted. The
view taken by the authorities in
denying admission to the
appellant is wholly unjust and
illegal.
10. The appellant had qualified
in the JEE-2003 but the said
academic year is already over.
But for this situation the fault lies
with the respondents, who
adopted a highly technical and
rigid attitude and not with the
appellant. We are, therefore, of
the opinion that the appellant
should be given admission in
MBBS course in any of the State
medical colleges in the current
academic year.
A bare perusal of the above would show that
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that where a
candidate has the requisite eligibility to
his/her credit on the last date of submission
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
10
CWP-3716-2023
of the application form, submitting a
corrected certificate, after the said date
cannot come in the way to be treated as
eligible especially when the candidate has
already been allowed to compete.
In the present case, the petitioner is on a
better footing. All the required information
was submitted by the petitioner before the
last date of submission of application form
along with the certificates and it was only a
clarificatory certificate depicting the said
information, which was submitted after the
last date but at the time of scrutiny of the
documents. Once the petitioner has been
allowed to compete and all the information
required to get 5 marks under the socio-
economic criteria was available with the
respondent-Commission in one form or the
other i.e. on combine reading of the
information given by the petitioner in the
application form and the orphan certificate
issued to her by the competent authority of
the Government of Haryana dated
17.9.2018, it cannot be said that the
respondent-Commission was not having the
required information adjudging the
admissibility of the petitioner with regard to
grant of 5 marks under the socio-economic
criteria.
In the facts and circumstances of this case,
once the information required to get 5 marks
under the socio-economic criteria was
already with the respondent-Commission
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
11
CWP-3716-2023
before the last date of submission of
application form and only a clarificatory
certificate for the said information was
submitted by the petitioner though after the
last date of submission of application form
but at the time of scrutiny of documents,
non-grant of 5 marks to the petitioner under
the socio-economic criteria cannot be
sustained and is liable to be rejected."
14. The aforesaid issue also requires
consideration in the light of the principles laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Charles K. Skaria and
others v. Dr. C. Mathew and others, (1980) 2 SCC 752;
Dolly Chhanda v. Chairman, JEE and others, (2005) 9
SCC 779; Ram Kumar Gijroya v. Delhi Subordinate
Services Selection Board and another, (2016) 4 SCC
754; and Vashist Narayan Kumar v. State of Bihar,
2024 INSC 2 , as well as the judgments in Divya Kalia v.
State of Haryana and others, decided on 20.03.2025,
and Staff Selection Commission v. Smt. Bala, decided
on 28.04.2025. These decisions elucidate the distinction
between substantive eligibility and proof thereof and the
circumstances in which subsequent submission of
supporting documents may be permissible.
15. The claims of both petitioners for five marks
under the Socio-Economic Criteria are required to
be examined in the light of these principles, having
regard to the applicable recruitment conditions and the
documents submitted by each petitioner. The entitlement
of each petitioner would depend upon the relevant
advertisement, the applicable criteria and the documents
available on the respective recruitment record.”
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
12
CWP-3716-2023
5. In view of the above, the claim of the petitioner for grant
of 5 marks under the socio-economic criteria is required to be
examined in the light of the documents available on record and the
principles laid down in Manjeet Kumar (supra) . Accordingly, the
present writ petition is disposed of in terms of the judgment passed in
Manjeet Kumar (supra) , with a direction to the respondents to
examine and verify the petitioner's entitlement to 5 marks under the
applicable socio-economic criteria, in the light of the aforesaid
judgment and the certificate submitted by the petitioner. Upon such
verification, the respondents shall award the admissible marks to the
petitioner and recast the merit list accordingly.
6. In case the petitioner falls within the zone of
consideration after such exercise, the respondents shall take
appropriate steps for issuing an appointment letter to him, in
accordance with law. In case the petitioner is selected and appointed
pursuant to the aforesaid exercise, he shall be entitled to the benefit of
notional pay fixation and seniority at par with his counterparts
appointed in the same selection process. However, he shall be entitled
to actual salary only from the date of his joining.
7. It is, however, clarified that the candidates who were
originally selected and appointed and have been working continuously
since then shall not be removed from service. This Court is of the
considered view that unseating them at this stage would be contrary to
public interest, as they have gained considerable experience in the
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
13
CWP-3716-2023
meantime. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the judgments of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited v.
Sandeep Choudhary, 2022(2) SCT 657 , and the Constitution Bench
judgment in Sivanandan C.T. v. High Court of Kerala, 2024(3) SCC
799 .
7. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
12.11.2026 (HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
parul verma JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned. : Yes/No
Whether Reportable. : Yes/No
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.16 10:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment