Rajeshwar Ghuman (Minor) Etc. vs Narain Singh Etc.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
111 Date of decision :16.11.2026
111(1) FAO No.3672 of 2002 (O&M)
RAJESHWAR GHUMAN AND OTHERS …APPELLANTS
VERSUS
NARAIN SINGH AND ORS. ...RESPONDENTS
111(2) FAO No.3685 of 2002 (O&M)
RAJESHWAR GHUMAN …APPELLANT
VERSUS
NARAIN SINGH AND ORS. ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Ms. Kuljinder Bir Kaur, Advocate
for appellant in FAO No.3685 of 2002 and
for appellant No.1 in FAO No.3672 of 2002.
Mr. G.S. Jagpal, Advocate
for appellant No.2 in FAO No.3672 of 2002.
Mr. Ashish Verma, Advocate
for respondent No.2 in both the appeals and
for cross-objector in both the cross-objections.
Mr. Vinod Gupta, Advocate
for respondent-Insurance Company.
*
PARMOD GOYAL, J.
Present appeals have been preferred by the appellants-claimants
being aggrieved by award dated 22.01.2002 passed by learned Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ludhiana (hereinafter referred to as ‘ Tribunal ’)
for enhancement of compensation .
2 . Since the present appeals have arisen from common impugned
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -2-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
award passed by learned Tribunal vide which two claim petitions preferred
on account of motor vehicular accident dated 29.12.1997 caused by rash and
negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving truck bearing
registration No.PB-04-2818 were decided and since dispute involved in both
the appeals are identical, they are being decided by way of this common
judgment. Gist of claim petitions is given as under:-
Claim Compensatio
pertains to n awarded by
the Tribunal
1. Rajeshwar
Ghuman Singh
& Ors. Vs.
Narain Singh &
Ors.
MACT Case
No. / Appeal
No.
Sr. Case title
No. before the
MACT
Rs.5,76,000/-
Compensation
on account of
death of
Ranjit Singh
Ghuman by
son and
parents.
MACT Case
No.49 of 1998/
FAO No.3672
of 2002
2. Rajeshwar
Ghuman Vs.
Narain Singh &
Ors.
MACT Case
No. 38 of
1998/FAO
No.3685 of
2002
Compensation
on account of
death of
Inderjit Kaur
by son.
Rs.1,34,400/-
3. Since in present appeal the only issue raised by appellants-
claimants is as regards to quantum of compensation and no appeal or cross-
objection challenging finding of negligence has been preferred by any of the
respondents, therefore, the detailed facts as regards to manner of accident are
not being noticed herein for the sake of brevity.
FAO No.3672 of 2002
4. The claimants i.e. son and parents of Ranjit Singh Ghuman
(hereinafter referred to as ‘ deceased ’) have filed the present appeal seeking
enhancement in compensation. Learned Tribunal had assessed the income of
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -3-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
the deceased as Rs.5,000/- per month and had awarded following
compensation accordingly :-
Income of deceased Rs.5,000/- per month
Multiplier 16
Loss of dependency Rs.5,76,000/-
(Rs.3,000/-X16X12)
Total Compensation Rs.5,76,000/-
awarded
5. The appellants-claimants have sought enhancement in
compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal on the following grounds:
●
That the Learned Tribunal has erred in not assessing the
income of deceased as pleaded and proved by the claimants.
●
That the learned Tribunal has failed to apply the correct
multiplier, as per age of deceased.
●
That no addition towards future prospects has been made
while calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects
ought to have been added, as per the age of deceased.
●
That the learned Tribunal has also failed to award just and
appropriate compensation under the conventional heads,
namely funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of parental,
and filial consortium, in accordance with the law laid down by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant-claimant asserted that the
deceased was earning Rs.8/9,000/- per month being a practicing Advocate at
Ludhiana. In order to prove the pleaded income and vocation of the deceased
reliance has been placed on statement of PW1-Adv. Major Singh Mangat,
who stated that he used to pay 25% of the fee charged by him in cases which
SUNIL CHANDER
were booked by him directly to the deceased and he also used to pay 50% of
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -4-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
the fee of the cases which were referred to him by the deceased. However,
PW-1 has not produced any record regarding the said payments of the fee of
the cases to the deceased. Fact that the deceased was a practicing Advocate
is very well established on the record from his enrolment certificate as
Advocate Ex.P2 and identity card Ex.P3. Therefore, in absence of any
material to conclude income of deceased as was pleaded by appellants-
claimants, the Court is bound to take in consideration average income of
advocate keeping in view income tax limits. The learned Tribunal had
assessed the income of the deceased as Rs.5,000/- per month which is equal
to income tax free income in year 1997. Accordingly, income of the
deceased as taken by learned Tribunal i.e. Rs.5,000/- per month is upheld.
7. Admittedly, deceased was 30 years old at the time of accident as
per the post mortem report Ex.PY, addition of 40% towards future prospects
in view of judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in National
Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC 680
is to be made. In view of age of deceased to be 30 years, multiplier of ‘17’
would be applicable as per judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. ,
2009(6) SCC 121. Similarly, deduction towards personal expenses has to be
made on the basis of number of dependents which are three in present case
i.e. son and parents. Accordingly, deduction to the extent of 1/3rd shall be
applicable.
8. The loss of dependency, therefore, has to be determined by
taking monthly income of deceased to be Rs.5,000/- ,by adding future
prospects to the extent of 40% , applying multiplier of ‘17’ and by making
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -5-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
deduction of 1/3rd towards personal expenses.
9. Apart from compensation for loss of dependency, appellants-
claimants shall also be entitled to Rs . 15,000 /- towards funeral expenses and
Rs . 15,000 /- towards loss of estate . Appellant-claimant No.1 shall be entitled
to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of parental consortium .
Appellants-claimants No.2 and 3 shall be entitled to compensation of
Rs . 40,000 /- each towards loss of filial consortium . It is however made
clear that in case Hon’ble Supreme Court answers the reference regarding
quantum of compensation under conventional heads made in Hasina
Yasmin & Ors. Vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. , 2025 SCC Online SC
2919 in favour of appellants-claimants, appellant-claimants shall be free to
seek said amount by moving appropriate application in this regard.
10. Accordingly, reworked compensation is as under :-
Income Rs.5,000/- Rs.5,000/-
per month per month
Future prospects 40% Rs.7,000/-
(Rs.5,000/-+2,000)
Deduction 1/3rd Rs.4,667/-
(Rs.7,000/- – 2,333)
Multiplier 17 17
Total loss of Rs.4,667/-X12X17 Rs.9,52,068/-
dependency
Loss of Estate Rs. 15,000/-
Funeral Expenses Rs.15,000/-
Loss of parental
consortium to
claimant No. 1
Rs.40,000/-
Loss of filial
consortium to
claimant Nos. 2 & 3
Rs.40,000X2 Rs.80,000/-
Total compensation Rs.11,02,068/-
awarded in appeal
Total compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs.5,76,000/-
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -6-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
Enhanced amount of Rs. 11,02,068/-
compensation (awarded in appeal)
–
Rs.5,76,000/-
(awarded by the
Tribunal)
Rs.5,26,068/-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
11. The claimant i.e. son of Inderjit Kaur (hereinafter referred to as
‘the deceased ’) has filed the present appeal seeking enhancement in
compensation. The learned Tribunal had assessed the income of the deceased
as Rs.1,000/- per month and had awarded following compensation
accordingly :-
Income of deceased Rs.1,000/- per month
Multiplier 16
Loss of dependency Rs.1,34,400/-
(Rs.700/-X16X12)
Total Compensation Rs.1,34,400/-
awarded
12. The appellants-claimants have sought enhancement in
compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal on the following grounds:
●
That the Learned Tribunal had erred in not assessing the
income of deceased as pleaded by the claimants.
●
That the learned Tribunal has failed to apply the correct
multiplier, as per age of deceased.
●
That no addition towards future prospects has been made
while calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects
ought to have been added, as per the age of deceased.
●
That the learned Tribunal has also failed to award just and
appropriate compensation under the conventional heads,
namely funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of spousal,
SUNIL CHANDER
parental, and filial consortium, in accordance with the law
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -7-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
13. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants asserted that the
deceased was running a beauty parlor at 90A, Sarabha Nagar, Ludhiana and
was earning Rs.6,000/- per month. In order to prove the pleaded income and
vocation of the deceased reliance has been placed on statement of Gurcharan
Singh AW2, who stated that the deceased had done the course of beautician
from Shehnaz Hussain Herbal Skin and Hair Care Saloon, Ludhiana.
However, no cogent and reliable evidence has been adduced in order to
prove the income of the deceased. Therefore, in absence of any material to
conclude income of deceased earned from her vocation, income should be
taken as per minimum wages payable to a skilled worker in the year 1997
which is Rs.1,729/-. Accordingly, income of the deceased is taken as
Rs.1,729/- per month.
14. Admittedly, deceased was 26 years old at the time of accident as
per the post mortem report Ex.PY, addition of 40% towards future prospects
in view of judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in National
Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC 680
is to be made. In view of age of deceased to be 26 years, multiplier of ‘17’
would be applicable as per judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. ,
2009(6) SCC 121. Similarly, deduction to the extent of 1/3rd shall be
applicable as the deceased is only survived by her son.
15. The loss of dependency, therefore, has to be determined by
taking monthly income of deceased to be Rs.1,729/-, by adding future
prospects to the extent of 40% , applying multiplier of ‘17’ and by making
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -8-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
deduction of 1/3rd towards personal expenses.
16. Apart from compensation for loss of dependency, appellants-
claimants shall also be entitled to Rs . 15,000 /- towards funeral expenses and
Rs . 15,000 /- towards loss of estate . Appellant-claimant No.1 shall be entitled
to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of parental consortium . It is
however made clear that in case Hon’ble Supreme Court answers the
reference regarding quantum of compensation under conventional heads
made in Hasina Yasmin & Ors. Vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. , 2025
SCC Online SC 2919 in favour of appellant-claimant, appellant-claimant
shall be free to seek said amount by moving appropriate application in this
regard.
17. Accordingly, reworked compensation is as under :-
Income Rs.1,729/- Rs.1,729/-
per month per month
Future prospects 40% Rs.2,420/-
(Rs.1,729/-+ 691)
Deduction 1/3rd Rs.1,613/-
(Rs.2,420/- – 807)
Multiplier 17 17
Total loss of Rs.1,613/-X12X17 Rs.3,29,052/-
dependency
Loss of Estate Rs.15,000/-
Funeral Expenses Rs.15,000/-
Loss of filial
consortium to
claimant No. 1
Rs.40,000/-
Total
compensation
awarded in appeal
Rs.3,99,052/-
Total
compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs.1,34,400/-
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.3672 of 2002 -9-
FAO No.3685 of 2002
Rs.2,64,652/-
Enhanced amount Rs.3,99,052/-
of compensation (awarded in appeal)
–
Rs.1,34,400/-
(awarded by the
Tribunal)
18. Appellants-claimants shall be entitled to enhanced
compensation awarded in appeal along with 7.5% interest from the date of
filing of claim petition till realization (except under the conventional heads
i.e. loss of consortium, funeral expenses, loss of estate). Under conventional
heads interest shall be payable from August 2017 onwards till realization.
Apportionment and liability to pay compensation shall be as per award.
19. Appeals are accordingly allowed in above terms.
20. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand(s)
disposed of accordingly. Photocopy of this order be placed on the file of the
connected case.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
16.11.2026 JUDGE
Sunil Chander
Whether Speaking/Reasoned : Yes
Whether Reportable : Yes/No
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document