Santokben Rana vs M/o Defence
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
:: 1 :: OA No.234/2018
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 234/2018
th
Dated this the 08 day of September, 2026.
CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. Santokben Rana
Wife of Sureshbhai Rana
Age 61 years, Female,
Residing at: Ranchhodkrupa, Ravatsheri
Ranavas, Fatehpura, Vadodara 390 006.
… Applicant
(By Advocate Ms. S.S. Chaturvedi)
V/s.
1. Union of India
Notice to be served through Secretary,
Ministry of Defence,
New Delhi 110 001.
2. The Principal Controller of Defence Account (Pension)
Draupadighat,
Allahabad 211 014.
3. Garrision Engineer (I) (AF)
Ministry of Engineer Services,
Air Force Station, Makarpura,
Vadodara – 390 014.
4. Central Record Keeping Officer,
(National Pension System Limited),
th
NSDL, 4 Floor A Wing,
Trade World Kamla Mill Compound
Senapati Bapat Marg,
Lower Parel, Mumbai – 400 013.
… Respondents
(By Advocate Mr. H D Shukla for respondent no. 1 to 3 &
Mr. P I Shah, respondent no. 4)
P ANUKUMA
:: 2 :: OA No.234/2018
ORDER
Per: Hon’ble Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. The applicant has filed this Original Application (OA) under Section
19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following
reliefs:
“Para 8
(a) To admit this application;
(b) To direct the respondent to forthwith release the amount
of NPS Accumulate Fund with exemplary cost.
(C) To call for the records and proceedings pertaining to the
application made by the applicant for family pension and
other benefits.
(d) Any other order thought fit be passed;
2. The brief facts of the case, as stated by the applicant, are that her son,
Shri Vikas Sureshbhai Rana, was working as Lower Division Clerk
under respondent No. 3.
2.1 He died while in service on 17.10.2011.
2.2 The applicant had earlier approached this Tribunal seeking payment of
terminal benefits and family pension by filing O.A. No. 505/2014. The
said Original Application was disposed of on 16.09.2015 with a
direction to the respondents to finalise the settlement of benefits and to
take a decision regarding payment of interest on the delayed amounts.
2.3 The applicant was sanctioned family pension of ₹3,500 per month with
effect from 18.10.2011 under the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 1972. Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity, leave encashment and
the amount payable under the Central Government Employees Group
Insurance Scheme were also sanctioned and paid to her vide order
dated 15.07.2015.
2.4 The grievance of the applicant in the present Original Application is
regarding the accumulated pension corpus lying in the National
Pension System account of her deceased son. The applicant submitted
representations, indemnity bonds, relinquishment deeds and other
documents for release of the amount to the respondents. According to
her, despite compliance with the requirements communicated by the
respondents, the amount was not released due to procedural issues
between the Nodal Office, the concerned Accounts Office and
respondent No. 4, the Central Recordkeeping Agency.
P ANUKUMA
:: 3 :: OA No.234/2018
3. Learned counsel for the applicant further submits that the applicant
furnished all the documents demanded by the respondents, including
translated documents, indemnity bonds and documents relating to the
legal heirs. It is contended that the respondents failed to process and
release the amount despite the death having occurred in 2011. The
applicant claims that, being the mother and legal heir of the deceased
employee, she is entitled to receive the amount admissible from his
NPS account.
4. Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 have opposed the Original Application. They
submit that the service-related terminal benefits and family pension
admissible under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 have already been
sanctioned and paid to the applicant. According to them, the delay in
settling the NPS account occurred because of the requirement of
procedural clarification and verification of documents between the
Regional Office, the concerned Accounts Office and respondent No. 4.
4.1 Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 have further relied upon the instructions issued
by the Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority on
30.07.2014 which provides that where the family of a deceased NPS
subscriber was granted family pension by the Central Government, the
accumulated pension wealth in the NPS account was required to be
transferred to the Government. According to the respondents, the
applicant had opted for and was receiving family pension and,
therefore, the NPS corpus was not payable directly to her.
4.2 Respondent No. 4 submits that it functions as the Central
Recordkeeping Agency appointed by PFRDA and is not the employer
of the deceased employee. It relies upon the PFRDA (Exits and
Withdrawals under the National Pension System) Regulations, 2015
and the PFRDA circular dated 26.05.2016. According to respondent
No. 4, the instructions prevailing at the relevant time required the
accumulated NPS corpus to be remitted to the mapped bank account of
the Nodal Office where family pension under the CCS (Pension) Rules
had been sanctioned. It could process the transfer only after the Nodal
Office uploaded the prescribed request and furnished the requisite
forms and documents.
P ANUKUMA
:: 4 :: OA No.234/2018
5. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and carefully perused the
pleadings and material available on record. The limited question
requiring determination is whether, after the grant of family pension
under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the applicant is entitled to
receive any portion of the accumulated pension corpus standing in the
NPS account of her deceased son.
6. The respondents have relied upon the DoP&PW Office Memorandum
dated 05.05.2009, the PFRDA circular dated 30.07.2014 and the
procedural circular dated 26.05.2016. Under the arrangement then
prevailing, where the family of a deceased NPS subscriber availed
family pension under the CCS (Pension) Rules, the accumulated
pension corpus was required to be transferred to the Government. The
communication issued by respondent No. 4 in September 2018
reflected the position prevailing under those instructions.
7. The legal and administrative position has, however, subsequently
undergone a material change. Rule 20(2) of the Central Civil Services
(Implementation of National Pension System) Rules, 2021 provides
that where benefits under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 or the CCS
(Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939 are payable to the family of a
deceased subscriber, the Government contribution and returns thereon
forming part of the accumulated pension corpus shall be transferred to
the Government account. The remaining accumulated pension corpus
is required to be paid in lump sum to the person or persons in whose
favour a valid nomination has been made and, in the absence of a valid
and subsisting nomination, to the legal heir or legal heirs.
8. The deceased employee in the present case died on 17.10.2011, before
the notification of the CCS (Implementation of National Pension
System) Rules, 2021. The case is, therefore, specifically governed by
Department of Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare Office Memorandum
No. 57/06/2021-P&PW(B) dated 14.10.2024. The said Office
Memorandum deals with cases in which an NPS-covered Central
Government employee died, or was discharged on account of
disablement or invalidation, before notification of the 2021 Rules and
benefits under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 or the CCS
P ANUKUMA
:: 5 :: OA No.234/2018
(Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939 were granted in place of NPS
benefits.
9. Paragraph 6 of the Office Memorandum dated 14.10.2024 provides
that, in such cases, only the Government contribution and returns
thereon shall be retained in the Government account. The remaining
corpus is required to be paid to the Government servant, nominee or
legal heir, as the case may be, in accordance with the CCS
(Implementation of National Pension System) Rules, 2021.
10. Paragraph 7 of the aforesaid Office Memorandum expressly makes
these instructions effective from 01.01.2004. It further provides that the
employee’s contribution, together with the returns thereon, shall be
paid to the nominee, legal heir or Government servant, as the case may
be, along with interest calculated from the date of death or boarding
out up to the date of actual payment, at the rates and in the manner
applicable to Public Provident Fund deposits from time to time.
11. Thus, the fact that the applicant has been granted family pension under
the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 does not result in forfeiture of the
contribution made by the deceased employee to his NPS account or of
the returns attributable to that contribution. The applicant’s claim for
payment of the entire accumulated NPS corpus cannot be accepted
because the Government contribution and returns attributable thereto
are liable to be retained by or transferred to the Government. At the
same time, rejection of the applicant’s claim in its entirety would be
contrary to the CCS (Implementation of National Pension System)
Rules, 2021 and the Office Memorandum dated 14.10.2024.
12. In view of the facts and reasons stated above, the Original Application
is partly allowed with the following directions:
(i) Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 shall, in coordination with respondent
No. 4, determine separately the contribution made by the
deceased employee and the returns on it;
(ii) They shall separately determine the contribution made by the
Government and the returns on it;
(iii) The Government contribution and the returns shall be retained in
or transferred to the appropriate Government account;
P ANUKUMA
:: 6 :: OA No.234/2018
(iv) The employee’s contribution, together with interest calculated in
terms of paragraph 7 of DoP&PW Office Memorandum No.
57/06/2021-P&PW(B) dated 14.10.2024, shall be released to the
valid nominee or legal heirs;
(v) A detailed statement of calculation showing the employee’s
contribution, the returns attributable thereto and the interest
allowed shall be supplied to the recipient.
13. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed and the admissible amount
shall be released within a period of sixty days from the date of receipt
of a certified copy of this order.
14. The Original Application stands disposed of in the above terms.
Pending MAs, if any, also stand disposed of. There shall be no order as
to costs.
(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)
//Anu//pv//
P ANUKUMA