SRI. BHIMASETHU MUNIVRUNDA MATHA vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S.INDIRESH

WRIT PETITION NO.29451 OF 2026 (KLR-RES)
C/W
WRIT PETITION NO.10011 OF 2022 (GM-KEB)



IN WP No. 29451/2026

BETWEEN:

1. SRI. BHIMASETHU MUNIVRUNDA MATHA
BHIMANAKATTE MULUBAVILU VILLAGE.
DOORVASAPURAM POST,
THIRTHAHALLI TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT,
KARNATAKA - 577 432.

REPRESENTED BY ITS DIWAN
SRI. SAGAR BHAT
S/O HARISH KUMAR P.S.
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
NO.25/1, RAGHUNANDANA,
NEAR BHIMANAKATTE
RAGHAVENDRA SWAMY MATHA,
VENKATAGIRIYAPPA LAYOUT,
DODDABOMMASANDRA,
VIDYARANYAPURA,
BENGALURU - 560 097.










Digitally signed by
CHAYA S A
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


(NOTE AS THE PETITIONER IS A RELIGIOUS
INSTITUTION, THERE IS NO REGISTRATION)

…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. D.R. RAVISHANKAR, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. S. HEMANTH BHARWAJ, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
TH
ROOM NO. 505, 5 FLOOR,
M.S. BUILDING,
BENGALURU - 560 001
REPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY.

2. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
’A’ BLOCK, RAJATADRI,
MANIPAL, UDUPI DISTRICT,
UDUPI - 576 104.

3. THE TAHSILDAR,
CIRCUIT HOUSE ROAD,
BANANJE, UDUPI DISTRICT,
UDUPI - 576 101.

4. THE MANGALORE ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY
LIMITED,
MESCOM BHAVANA, BEJAI,
KAVOOR CROSS ROAD,
MANGALURU,
DAKSHINA KANNADA,

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


KARNATAKA - 575 004.
REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR.

…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ADITYA DIWAKARA, AGA FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI. SHABHAAZ HUSSAIN, ADVOCATE FOR R4)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO DIRECT
THE RESPONDENTS TO CONSIDER THE REPRESENTATIONS
DATED 14.02.2023, 07.12.2023 AND 08.09.2026 VIDE
ANNEXURE-A TO A2.
IN WP NO. 10011/2022
BETWEEN:
1. SRI. BHEEMA SETU MUNIVRUNDA MUTT
BHEEMANAKATTE DHRUVASAPURA
THIRTHAHALLI TALUK
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT
KARNATAKA - 577432
REP. BY SRI SAGAR HARISKUMAR DIWAN
ADMINISTRATOR AND GPA HOLDER.

...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. D.R. RAVISHANKAR, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. S. HEMANTH BHARWAJ, ADVOCATE)

AND:

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


1. GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
VIDHANA SOUDHA
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
BENGALURU - 560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS
CHIEF SECRETARY.

2. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
ND
ROOM NO.236, 2 FLOOR
VIKASA SOUDHA
BENGALURU - 560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.

3. KARNATAKA POWER TRANSMISSION
CORPORATION LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE
KAVERI BHAVAN, K G ROAD
BENGALURU - 560009
REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR.

4. THE MANGALORE ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY
LIMITED
MESCOM BHAVANA
BEJAI KAVOOR CROSS ROAD
MANGALURU,
DAKSHINA KANNADA
KARNATAKA - 575004
REP. BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.

...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ADITYA DIWAKARA, AGA FOR R1 & R2;
SRI. H.V. DEVARAJU, ADVOCATE OF R3

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


SRI. SHABHAAZ HUSSAIN, ADVOCATE FOR R4)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
RESPONDENT NO.4-COMPANY, NAMELY, MESCOM TO
COMPLY INTER ALIA WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE
TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT, 1882 AND OTHER
APPLICABLE LAWS, AND NOT TO ASSERT RIGHTS
UNLAWFULLY AS THREATENED IN THE REPLY NOTICE
DATED 31.03.2022 (ANNEXURE-A); AND ETC.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR
ORDERS, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY,
E.S. INDIRESH J ., MADE THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S.INDIRESH

CAV ORDER
In W.P.No.29451 of 2026

1. The petitioner-Mutt has sought for direction to
the respondent No.2-Deputy Commissioner, to
consider the representations dated 14.02.2023,

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


07.12.2023, and 08.09.2026 (Annexure-A to A2) at
the earliest.
In W.P.No.10011 of 2022

2. The petitioner-Mutt has sought for direction to
respondent No.4- The Mangalore Electricity Supply
company Ltd., ((hereinafter referred to as
respondent-MESCOM) to comply with the provisions of
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and to desist from
setting up an electric sub-station or any other
structure on the leased premises in violation of the
Lease Deed dated 27.11.1937, (Annexure- B) and to
direct the respondent No.4-MESCOM to deliver vacant
possession of the leased premises to the petitioner-
Mutt and such other reliefs;

3. Since common questions of law and facts arise
for consideration in both the writ petitions, they have

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


been clubbed together, heard and are being disposed
of by this common order.

4. The relevant facts for adjudication of the case, as
averred in W.P. No. 10011 of 2022, are that the
petitioner-Mutt had entered into a registered Lease
Deed dated 27.11.1937 with the predecessors-in-
interest of respondent No. 4 – MESCOM, in respect of
the southern portion of the land bearing Sy. No.
130/2A3, situated at Mudanidamburu Village, Udupi
Taluk, measuring to an extent of 1 acre and 35 cents,
for a period of 99 years, on payment of an annual rent
of Rs. 275/-, as per Annexure-B. The said lease was
executed subject to the terms and conditions
stipulated in the registered Lease Deed.

5. It is further stated that the erstwhile Udupi
Electric Supply Corporation Limited was nationalised
under the provisions of the Madras Electricity Supply

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Undertakings (Acquisition) Act, 1949. Thereafter,
electricity distribution in Udupi District was taken over
by the Karnataka Electricity Board, which was
subsequently succeeded by the Karnataka Power
Transmission Corporation Limited (respondent No. 3)
and thereafter, eventually by the Mangaluru Electricity
Supply Company Limited (respondent No. 4 herein). It
is the case of the petitioner that respondent No. 4 –
MESCOM, a Government of Karnataka undertaking, is
presently in occupation of the leased premises.

6. It is further stated in the writ petition that the
petitioner-Mutt had addressed several letters to
respondent No.4 – MESCOM, seeking enhancement of
the annual rent since 2018, however, respondent No.4
– MESCOM has not taken any steps in that regard. It
is also contended by the petitioner-Mutt that
respondent No.4 – MESCOM had illegally cut down

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


trees situated on the leased premises, in violation of
the terms and conditions of the Lease Deed. In this
regard, the petitioner-Mutt had lodged a complaint
dated 12.08.2020 (Annexure-D) before the Zonal
Forest Officer, Udupi District.

7. It is further stated in the writ petition that, as per
the report of the District Disaster Management Plan
dated 20.09.2020 (Annexure-E), the leased premises
are prone to excessive rainfall and flooding and are
susceptible to natural disasters. It is also contended
that respondent No. 4 – MESCOM has erected an
electricity sub-station on the leased premises in
violation of the terms and conditions stipulated in the
Lease Deed, without obtaining the permission of the
petitioner-Mutt. It is further contended that, since the
demised premises are situated in a densely populated
area, the establishment and commissioning of the

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


electricity sub-station are in violation of the provisions
of the Indian Electricity Rules. On these grounds, the
petitioner-Mutt has sought for interference of this
Court.

8. It is further stated that the use of the leased
premises for the establishment and operation of an
electricity sub-station would result in the degradation
and devaluation of the leased land. It is also
contended that respondent No. 4 – MESCOM has
failed to pay the outstanding arrears of lease rent due
and payable to the petitioner-Mutt. In view of the
same, the petitioner-Mutt issued a legal notice dated
18.02.2022 (Annexure-K) to respondent No. 4 –
MESCOM. It is further contended that the land in
question has not been converted for the purpose of
establishing an electricity sub-station and, therefore,
the reply notice dated 31.03.2022 (Annexure-A),

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


issued by respondent No. 4 – MESCOM, is contrary to
law. On these grounds, the petitioner-Mutt has sought
for interference of this Court.

9. In W.P. No. 29451 of 2026, the petitioner-Mutt
has sought a direction to respondent No. 2 – Deputy
Commissioner, to consider the representations dated
14.02.2023, 07.12.2023 and 08.09.2026, produced at
Annexures-A, A1 and A2, respectively, and to pass
appropriate orders thereon at the earliest.

10. Heard Sri. D.R. Ravishankar, learned Senior
Counsel appearing on behalf of Sri. S. Hemanth
Bharadwaj, learned counsel for the petitioner-Mutt;
Sri. Aditya Diwakara, learned Additional Government
Advocate appearing for the respondent-State; Sri.
H.V. Devaraju, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No.3- Karnataka Power Transmission

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Corporation Ltd., and Sri. Shabhaaz Hussain, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent No.4-MESCOM.

11. Sri. D.R. Ravishankar, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the petitioner-Mutt, contended that
respondent No. 4 – MESCOM has violated the
conditions stipulated under Section 108 of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, and that the
establishment of an electric sub-station on the leased
premises is contrary to the land-use provisions of the
Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964, as well as the
applicable regulations under the Karnataka Town and
Country Planning Act, 1961. On these grounds,
learned Senior Counsel sought for interference of this
Court.

12. Learned Senior Counsel further contended that
the land in question is situated in the heart of Udupi
City and that respondent No.4 – MESCOM is paying

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


lease rent at a negligible rate, which is not
commensurate with the prevailing market rent.
Therefore, learned Senior Counsel submitted that this
Court's interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is warranted for enhancement of
the lease rent, in respect of subject premises.

13. Nextly, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
contended that the Lease Deed dated 27.11.1937 was
executed with erstwhile entities of respondent No. 4
– MESCOM for a period of 99 years and that the
petitioner-Mutt had been receiving the lease rent in
terms of the Lease Deed until 2017 and annual lease
rent fixed under the Lease Deed was Rs. 275/-
(approximately Rs.23/- per month), which is highly
inadequate in the present circumstances and that
apart, less than the tax paid by the petitioner-Mutt in
respect of the subject land. Learned Senior Counsel

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


further contended that, with an intention to harass the
petitioner-Mutt, the respondent authorities had sought
for GST and PAN particulars of the petitioner-Mutt to
pay the annual rent of Rs.275/-. On these grounds,
learned Senior Counsel sought for interference of this
Court.

14. The principal contention of the learned Senior
Counsel is that this Court, vide order dated
14.02.2025, had directed respondent No. 4 –
MESCOM to negotiate for enhancement of the lease
rent. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that
this Court had also taken note of the fact that
respondent No. 4 – MESCOM was in default of
payment of even the meager amount of rent payable
in respect of the leased property. Learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner further invited the attention
of this Court to the order dated 21.02.2025 and

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


submitted that respondent No. 4 – MESCOM had been
directed to pay the lease rent in accordance with the
PWD norms. Hence, it is argued by the learned Senior
Counsel that, no steps have been taken by the
respondent authorities in this regard. On these
grounds, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
sought for interference of this Court.

15. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioner-Mutt also relied upon the following
judgments in support of his contentions:

i) Craft Interiors (P) Ltd v. CCE, Bangalore
and another reported in (2006) 12 SCC
250;

ii) Syed Mohummed Raziuddn v. Corporation
of Culcutta in Crl. Rev.No.105 of 1919
dated 30.04.2019;

iii) Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay
and another v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd
reported in 1991 Supp (2) SCC 18;

iv) Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehrawardi
reported in (1981) 1 SCC 722;

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026



v) Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute
of Chemical Biology and others reported in
(2002) 5 SCC 111.


16. Per contra, Sri. H.V. Devaraju, learned counsel
appearing for respondent No. 3 – KPTCL, contended
that, since the petitioner-Mutt has instituted the
present writ petition on the basis of the Lease Deed, it
is required for the petitioner-Mutt to approach the
competent Civil Court for redressal of its grievances
relating to the payment of arrears of lease rent.

17. It is further contended by the learned counsel
that the establishment and commissioning of the
electricity sub-station on the schedule property is in
the larger interest of the general public, as the same
would improve voltage and prevent interruptions in
the supply of electricity. Therefore, learned counsel
submitted that there is no violation of the terms and

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


conditions of the Lease Deed and further argued that
the petitioner-Mutt cannot invoke the writ jurisdiction
of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India for the purpose of recovery of outstanding lease
rent. Accordingly, he sought for dismissal of the writ
petition.

18. Sri. Shabhaaz Hussain, learned counsel
appearing for respondent No.4 – MESCOM contended
that, being a statutory body, respondent No.4 is
required to maintain the necessary statutory and
financial records and, therefore, had called upon the
petitioner-Mutt to furnish its GST and PAN particulars
and further contended that, the petitioner-Mutt is
required to approach the competent Civil Court for
redressal of its grievance. On these grounds, learned
counsel sought dismissal of the writ petition.

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026



19. Sri. Aditya Diwakara, learned Additional
Government Advocate appearing for the respondent-
State sought to justify the arguments of the
respondent-MESCOM.

20. In the light of the arguments advanced by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties, it is not in
dispute that the subject land belonged to the
petitioner-Mutt and that the same was leased in
favour of respondent No.4 (predecessor-in-interest of
respondent No.4) for a period of 99 years under the
registered Lease Deed dated 27.11.1937 (Annexure-
B). Thereafter, the erstwhile Udupi Electric Supply
Corporation Limited was nationalised under the
provisions of the Madras Electricity Supply
Undertakings (Acquisition) Act, 1949. Subsequently,
the electricity distribution activities were taken over
by the Karnataka Electricity Board, and thereafter, by

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


respondent No.3 – Karnataka Power Transmission
Corporation Limited. It is also to be noted that
respondent No.4 – Mangalore Electricity Supply
Company Limited (MESCOM), is the successor-in-
interest of the Karnataka Power Transmission
Corporation Limited and is, accordingly, in possession
of the leased land, paying an annual rent of Rs.275/-.
A perusal of the terms and conditions of the Lease
Deed indicates that the lessee, namely respondent
No.4-MESCOM, is obligated to pay the rent regularly
and without any default.

21. At this stage, it is relevant to mention that
respondent No.4 – MESCOM is a statutory body under
Article 12 of the Constitution of India and, being an
‘authority’ discharging public duties, is obliged to
adhere to the terms and conditions of the Lease Deed
in letter and spirit. It is forthcoming from the writ

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


petition that respondent No.4 – MESCOM had cut
down the trees standing in the leased premises, which
was objected to by the petitioner-Mutt. In this regard,
the petitioner-Mutt lodged a complaint dated
12.08.2020, which is produced at Annexure-D. It is
further contended that the leased premises is situated
in an area prone to a high risk of flooding due to
natural disasters, as indicated in Annexure-E to the
writ petition. In this regard, the petitioner-Mutt
addressed a representation dated 11.09.2021 to the
Hon'ble Chief Minister, seeking appropriate action in
the matter.

22. It is the specific case of the petitioner-Mutt that
respondent No.4 – MESCOM has undertaken the
erection and commissioning of an electric sub-station
in the leased premises without obtaining the
permission of the petitioner-Mutt, being the lessor of

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


the land in question. A perusal of the Lease Deed at
Annexure-B indicates that an extent of 1 acre and 35
cents of land in Sy. No.130/2A3 was leased in favour
of respondent No.4 and its predecessors-in-interest.
The land in question continues to be classified as
agricultural land. However, pursuant to the
notice/representation submitted by the petitioner-
Mutt, respondent No.3 addressed a letter dated
18.03.2022 (Annexure-M) to respondent No.4, calling
upon it to desist from violating the terms and
conditions of the Lease Deed in respect of the land in
question.

23. It is also forthcoming from the statement of
objections filed by respondent No.4 – MESCOM that
the areas surrounding the leased premises have
undergone considerable development, with several
commercial complexes having come up in and around

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Udupi town. In view of the increased demand for
electricity, respondent No.4 – MESCOM has taken
steps to augment the existing feeders to avoid
frequent interruptions in the electricity supply to
Udupi city and therefore, I am of the opinion that,
non-payment of the rent by the respondent No.4-
MESCOM is contrary to the Lease Deed and being a
statutory body, respondent No.4 is required to pay the
same without any demand made by the petitioner-
Mutt.

24. In this regard, respondent No.4 – MESCOM has
produced the proceedings of the 37th Technical
Advisory Committee Meeting held on 28.11.2017
(Annexure-R3 of Statement of Objections filed by
respondent No.4 in W.P.No.10011 of 2022), wherein a
proposal was considered for establishing a 1 x 12.5
MVA, 33/11 KV Sub-Station in Udupi Division.

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Thereafter, respondent No.4 addressed a letter dated
05.05.2021 (Annexure-R4) to M/s. Jyothi Electricals in
connection with the award of proposed sub-station
work.

25. At paragraph 6 of the statement of objections,
respondent No.4 has stated that the existing building
has been retained and renovated for the purpose of
maintaining the same, as evident from the
photographs produced at Annexures-R6 and R7. It is
further stated that, out of the total extent of 1 acre
and 35 cents of leased land, an extent of 33.94 cents
has been utilised for establishing the sub-station and
that the said portion has been enclosed with a fence,
as reflected in Annexure-R8 of the Statement of
Objections. It is also contended that the work has
been completed, except for the installation of the
transformer and spreading of jelly and if such being

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


the case, there is no impediment for rising rental
value of the land in question, as the annual rent is
being fixed at meager rent at the time of execution of
the Lease Deed.

26. At paragraph 7 of the statement of objections,
respondent No.4 – MESCOM has stated that rent was
paid to the petitioner-Mutt up to the year 2017.
However, the rent for the subsequent years has been
withheld on the ground that the petitioner-Mutt failed
to furnish its GST and PAN particulars. In this regard,
I have carefully examined the letter dated 23.08.2004
addressed by the petitioner-Mutt to respondent No.4 –
MESCOM and the reply dated 30.09.2005 issued by
respondent No.4 thereto, which is produced at
Annexure-R10 and after evaluating the same, as the
respondent No.4-MESCOM intends to establish sub-
station, which is not found place in the original Lease

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Deed, then it is the duty of the respondent No.4 to
pay the rent on prevailing market rate in the said
area, after obtaining necessary inputs for the PWD.

27. It is further contended by respondent No.4 –
MESCOM that the sub-station has been enclosed with
a fence and all safety measures prescribed under the
relevant Regulations, 2010, have been duly complied
with. It is also contended that only one-fourth of the
demised premises has been utilised for the
establishment of the sub-station and that the
remaining extent of land has been retained in its
original condition. On these grounds, respondent No.4
has sought dismissal of the writ petition, contending
that the petitioner-Mutt has an efficacious alternative
remedy of approaching the competent Civil Court for
appropriate reliefs under Section 108 of the Transfer
of Property Act and the said contention cannot be

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


accepted on the sole ground that the respondent
No.4, being instrumentality of the State cannot itself
behave as private parties (lessee) in paying annual
rent.

28. In this regard, a perusal of the order sheet would
indicate that this Court, vide order dated 14.02.2025,
held as follows;
“I.A. No.1/2025 filed seeking permission to deposit
the amount.
Learned senior counsel appearing for the petition
would contend that the application is not
maintainable, and they would file a statement of
objections to the said application.
It is noticed that the rent agreement between the
petitioner and respondent No.4 was entered in the
year 1937. Rs. 237/- is the annual rent in respect of
the property. The tenure of the lease would come to
an end in 2036.
It is also noticed that the respondent No.4 is a
defaulter of the said petty amount of rent payable in

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


respect of the property which is under lease. It is not
in dispute that the property is a non-agricultural land
i.e., in the heart of Udupi city.
It is stated that the officers of the respondent No.4
visited the office of the petitioner to negotiate the
escalation of the rental amount. Respondent No.4 is
the instrumentality of the State.
Under these circumstances, respondent No.4 is
required to make an offer in writing as to how much
rent they are going to pay to the petitioner for the
remaining period of the lease and the offer should be
communicated in writing within one week.
List this matter on 21.02.2025”

29. A perusal of the said order would indicate that an
attempt was made by the petitioner-Mutt to negotiate
with respondent No.4-MESCOM regarding the
enhancement of the rental amount, particularly since
respondent No.4-MESCOM is an instrumentality of the
State. It is also relevant to refer to the order dated
21.02.2025, which reads as under:

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


“Heard learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as
well as the learned counsel appearing for 4th
respondent on the prayer made in the affidavit filed by
4th respondent.
4th respondent has filed an affidavit dated
10.02.2025. In the said affidavit 4th respondent prays
this Court to take note of the said affidavit dated
10.02.2025, wherein it has made a request to
complete the structure in the petition premises and
4th respondent has undertaken to de-commission the
structure on or before the expiry of the lease period.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has filed
a counter to the said affidavit. The petitioner has
objected to the said affidavit on the premise that this
Court vide order dated 05.12.2022 has restrained 4th
respondent from putting up any structure in the leased
premises. It is further stated that an appeal is filed
against the said order and the appeal is dismissed.
Learned counsel for 4th respondent does not dispute
the fact that appeal is filed against the said order and
appeal is dismissed.
After going through the contents of the affidavit, it is
noticed that the prayer made in the affidavit (without
any application) is to permit 4th respondent to put up
the structure in the petition premises, which act is

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


restrained by this Court in terms of order dated
05.12.2022. The said order admittedly has attained
finality.
Under these circumstances, this Court is of the view,
that prayer made in the affidavit cannot be considered.
Accordingly, the same is rejected.
This Court vide order dated 14.02.2025 has directed
the respondent/Corporation to make an offer in writing
as to how much enhanced rent the
respondent/Corporation is willing to pay to the
petitioner. The said direction was issued pursuant to
the submission made by the learned counsel for
respondent No.4 that respondent No.4 visited the
office of the petitioner to negotiate the escalation of
rental amount. It is also relevant to note that the
direction is issued considering the fact that the lease
agreement was entered into in the year 1937
considering the fair rent of the said era. The same rent
at any stretch of imagination can be considered as a
fair rent payable for the premises, in present times.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondent -
Corporation seeks a short accommodation to obtain
instructions from the PWD with regard to the rental
value, and also necessary approval by the higher

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


officers of 4th respondent and to make an offer
relating to prevalent fair rent.
Considering the submission made, ten days time is
granted to 4th respondent to comply the order dated
14.03.2025.”

30. Despite the aforementioned orders passed by
this Court, it appears that the officials of respondent
No.4 have remained adamant and have not taken any
steps towards payment of the arrears of rent, which,
incidentally, amounts to a meagre annual rent of
Rs.275/- and such lethargic acts of the officials of
respondent No.4 is hereby deprecated. At this
juncture, it is relevant to note that respondent No.4
had preferred W.A. No.290 of 2023 before the Division
Bench of this Court, challenging the interim orders
referred to hereinabove. The said writ appeal came to
be dismissed on 20.06.2023. Being aggrieved by the
same, respondent No.4 approached the Hon'ble

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Supreme Court by filing SLP (Civil) No.22621 of 2025.
The said Special Leave Petition came to be disposed of
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court on 04.08.2025,
granting liberty to respondent No.4 to approach this
Court for final disposal of the matter.

31. Respondent No.4-MESCOM has been attempting
to evade payment of even the meager rent payable in
respect of the subject land, despite the fact that the
said land is situated in the heart of Udupi City, and
has been prolonging the matter by raising one reason
or the other to avoid payment of rent. Such conduct
on the part of respondent No.4-MESCOM is
unreasonable and arbitrary, particularly having regard
to the fact that it is an instrumentality of the State. In
this regard, it is relevant to refer to the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Malpe
Vishwanath Acharya and others v. State of

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Maharastra and another reported in AIR 1998 SC
602 , particularly paragraphs 22 to 28, which read as
under:
“22. That the tenants are, by and large, now getting
an unwarranted benefit or windfall can also be
illustrated by taking an example of hypothetical
tenant, i.e., an Assistant in the Government of India
posted at Bombay in the year 1948. At that time the
pay scale of the Assistant was Rs 160-10-300-15-450
+ 20% HRA + Rs 15.50 CCA. On the basis that he was
drawing the maximum of scale, his total monthly
emoluments would be Rs 485.50 and if he had in 1948
taken premises on rent at Rs 100 per month, he would
be paying approximately 20% of his total emoluments
by way of rent, without taking into consideration any
deduction for repairs. That Assistant in 1997, after the
report of the 5th Pay Commission, would get a
maximum basic salary of Rs 9000 + 30% HRA + Rs
200 p.m. as CCA making the total emoluments of Rs
11900 p.m. After taking into consideration the 1987
increase in rent, he would be paying about Rs 170
p.m. in respect of the same premises instead of Rs
100 which he was paying in 1948. This enhanced rent,
would, however, represent only 0.9% of his salary.
With the passage of time, the percentage of rent which

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


would be paid by that hypothetical tenant would have
gone down from 20% of his total salary to only 0.9%
and this would be the case of most of the tenants as
we can take judicial notice of the fact that from 1948
till now, incomes have increased considerably,
whereas the rent has increased only from Rs 100 p.m.
to Rs 170 p.m.

23. On the other hand, in the aforesaid example, the
hardship to the landlord is that it was only in 1940 that
he had agreed to accept rent of Rs 100 p.m. That was
the real income from rent which he had agreed to
receive. Now with the increase in taxes etc., he gets
only Rs 54 p.m. whereas in 1940, he got Rs 100 minus
Rs 21.54 (municipal tax) i.e. Rs 78.46. So not only is
he getting lesser amount in hand but in terms of real
value, after taking inflation into account, he is getting
only a pittance. For Rs 100 p.m. of gross rent which he
was getting in 1940, he now in 1997 gets a gross rent
of about Rs 170 which in real money terms, after
taking the inflation into account, will be only about Rs
2 p.m. of the 1940 value. Had the Rent Control Act not
been in force the landlord today may have been able
to get today's equivalent of Rs 100 of 1940 as rent i.e.
about Rs 6600 p.m.


- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


24. It is true that one of the reasons for enacting the
rent control legislation is to prevent exploitation of the
tenants by the landlords. One of the protections which
has been provided to the tenants in the rent legislation
throughout the country is the concept of standard
rent. Each State has definite laws with regard thereto.
In some case, like in Delhi, the Rent Control Act is not
applicable if the rent is Rs 3500 or more while in the
other States Rent Control Act is not applicable to
certain categories of persons. In the Bombay Rent Act,
with which we are concerned, the standard rent as on
1-9-1940 or the first rent of the premises which was
let out thereafter is the standard rent. The pegging
down of rent, coupled with the inability of the landlord
to evict the tenants, has given rise to unlawful
tendencies. In the Statement of Objects and Reasons
annexed to LA Bill No. 79 of 1986 introduced in the
Maharashtra Legislature providing for amendment to
the Bombay Rent Control Act with regard to clause 3 it
was, inter alia, stated as follows:
“The freezing of standard rent prevailing on 1st
September, 1940 has deprived the landlords of getting
reasonable and adequate return to undertake
maintenance and repairs to the old buildings. Despite
the penal provisions in the Act for charging any
premium from a tenant, such freezing of rent results in

- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


charging ‘pugree’ or deposit or similar illicit payments
which are widely prevalent. The construction of new
tenements on rental basis has considerably ceased
with the result that low and middle income groups are
not getting premises on rent….”
(emphasis added)

25. Notwithstanding the fact that the State Legislature
was conscious of the illegal payments which are made
because of the rent restriction law no effective steps
have been taken so far to strike a balance between the
interests of the landlords and the tenants.

26. It is true that whenever a special provision, like
the Rent Control Act, is made for a section of the
society it may be at the cost of another section, but
the making of such a provision or enactment may be
necessary in the larger interest of the society as a
whole but the benefit which is given initially if
continued results in increasing injustice to one section
of the society and an unwarranted largess or windfall
to another, without appropriate corresponding relief,
then the continuation of such a law which necessarily,
or most likely, leads to increase in lawlessness and
undermines the authority of the law can no longer be

- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


regarded as being reasonable. Its continuance
becomes arbitrary.

27. The legislature itself, as already noticed
hereinabove, has taken notice of the fact that pugree
system has become prevalent in Mumbai because of
the Rent Restriction Act. This Court was also asked to
take judicial notice of the fact that in view of the
unreasonably low rents which are being received by
the landlords, recourse is being taken to other
methods to seek redress. These methods which are
adopted are outside the four corners of the law and
are slowly giving rise to a state of lawlessness where,
it is feared, the courts may become irrelevant in
deciding disputes between the landlords and tenants.
This should be a cause of serious concern because if
this extra-judicial backlash gathers momentum the
main sufferers will be the tenants, for whose benefit
the Rent Control Acts are framed.

28. Insofar as social legislation, like the Rent Control
Act is concerned, the law must strike a balance
between rival interests and it should try to be just to
all. The law ought not to be unjust to one and give a
disproportionate benefit or protection to another
section of the society. When there is shortage of

- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


accommodation it is desirable, may, necessary that
some protection should be given to the tenants in
order to ensure that they are not exploited. At the
same time such a law has to be revised periodically so
as to ensure that a disproportionately larger benefit
than the one which was intended is not given to the
tenants. It is not as if the Government does not take
remedial measures to try and offset the effects of
inflation. In order to provide fair wage to the salaried
employees the Government provides for payment of
dearness and other allowances from time to time.
Surprisingly this principle is lost sight of while
providing for increase in the standard rent — the
increases made even in 1987 are not adequate, fair or
just and the provisions continue to be arbitrary in
today's context.”

32. In view of the declaration of law made by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforementioned
judgment, respondent No.4-MESCOM, being an
instrumentality of the State, is obligated to pay the
prevailing market rent in respect of the subject
premises to the petitioner-Mutt. The respondent No.4,
in its statement of objections, has admitted as to

- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


withholding the annual rent of Rs.275/- payable to the
petitioner-Mutt on the ground that the petitioner-Mutt
had not furnished its PAN and GST particulars. It is
relevant to note that the said demand was raised by
respondent No.4 only after receipt of the legal notice
issued by the petitioner-Mutt. Therefore, the said
reason cannot be accepted as a justification for
withholding the rent, which is a meagre amount,
particularly having regard to the fact that respondent
No.4 continues to be in possession and enjoyment of
the entire extent of 1 acre and 35 cents of land
situated in the heart of Udupi City and have
established sub-station without the consent of the
petitioner-Mutt.

33. In the circumstances, the conduct of respondent
No.4-MESCOM amounts to a violation of the terms
and conditions of the Lease Deed and warrants

- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


appropriate consequences in accordance with law.
Under similar circumstances, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, in the case of National Company v. Territory
Managerr, Bharat Petroleum Coportaion Ltd ,
reported in AIR Online 2021 SC 1014 , particularly
at paragraphs 16 to 21, has held as under:
“16. This Court has upheld the orders passed by the
High Court that the appellant tenants would not be
entitled to the benefit and rights under the Tenants
Act unless they are in actual physical possession of
the building constructed by them. The position is
amply made clear by observing that in case the
appellants have let out or sublet the building or given
it to third parties, including dealers or licensees, they
would not be entitled to protection and benefit under
the Tenants Act.
17. Though Shri Kailash Vasdev, learned Senior
Counsel, attempted to assail the correctness of the
said judgment, such an exercise is not permissible in
law. The said judgment of this Court in the case of R.
Chandramouleeswaran (supra) is delivered by a

- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


Bench consisting of three judges and we are bound by
the view taken therein.
18. We have perused the agreement between the re
spondent No.1BPCL and the respondent No.2 herein.
Shri Kailash Vasdev, learned Senior Counsel, fairly
concedes that all the agreements between the
respondent No.1BPCL and its dealers are identical. As
such, when a Bench of three judges of this Court in
the case of R. Chandramouleeswaran (supra), while
considering a similar agreement between the
appellantBPCL and the dealer, has held that since the
appellant tenant was not in actual physical
possession, it was not entitled to the protection under
the Tenants Act, the said view is bound even in the
facts of the present case.
19. In the result, we find that the view taken by the
High Court, thereby relegating the appellant to the
alternate remedy available in law, is not sustainable.
20. As observed by the High Court, the conduct of the
respondent No.1BPCL in continuing with the
occupation of the said premises without paying any
rent from 31 st December, 2009 is unbecoming of a
statutory corporation, which is a State within the
meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India. We
therefore find that while directing the respondents to

- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


vacate the said premises and handover peaceful and
vacant possession to the appellant, it will also be
necessary in the interests of justice to direct the
respondent No.1BPCL to pay arrears of market rent
from 31st December, 2009, till the date of delivery of
possession at the market rate.
21. In the result, the appeal is allowed in the
following terms:
(i) The respondent No.1BPCL is directed to vacate and
handover peaceful and vacant possession of the said
premises to the appellant within a period of three
months from today.
(ii) The respondent No.1BPCL is directed to pay
arrears of market rent to the appellant from 31 st
December, 2009 till the date of handing over of
possession.”


34. At this juncture, it is relevant to refer to the
declaration of law made by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of Malpe Vishwanath Acharya
(supra) , wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that
a statute which was justified at the time of its

- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


enactment may, with the passage of time, become
arbitrary and unreasonable, warranting
reconsideration in the light of changed circumstances.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court, taking into consideration
the steep increase in the cost of living and the
passage of time, emphasised the necessity of
determining and ensuring payment of fair rent to the
landlord. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in unequivocal
terms, emphasized the importance of ensuring that
the landlord receives fair and reasonable rent.

35. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. and
another vs. Dollydas reported in (1999) 4 SCC
450 at paragraph 9 held as follows:
“9. We may now advert to the contention that the writ
remedy is not appropriate in this case. Where
interpretation of a contract arises in relation to
immovable property and in working such a contract or

- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


relief thereof or any other fallout thereto may have the
effect of giving rise to an action in tort or for damages,
the appropriate remedy would be a civil suit. But if the
facts pleaded before the court are of such a nature
which do not involve any complicated questions of fact
needing elaborate investigation of the same, the High
Court could also exercise writ jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution in such matters. There can be
no hard and fast rule in such matters. When the High
Court has chosen to exercise its powers under Article
226 of the Constitution we cannot say that the
discretion exercised in entertaining the petition is
wrong.”

36. Recently, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
of Neha Chandrakanth Shroff and another vs.
State of Maharastra and others reported in 2025
SCC Online SC 777 at paragraph 10 to 12 held as
follows:
“10. To ask the appellants to file a suit and recover the
possession would be like adding insult to the injury. At
this point of time, if the appellants are asked to
institute a suit, we wonder how many years it would
take by the time the litigation would come to an end if

- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


at all it reaches upto the highest Court of the country.
These are the hard facts, the High Courts are expected
to keep in mind in today's times.
11. The rule of exclusion of writ jurisdiction by
availability of an alternative remedy is a rule of
discretion and not one of compulsion. There can be
many contingencies in which the High Court may be
justified in exercising its writ jurisdiction inspite of
availability of an alternative remedy.
12. This is one of those cases wherein the High Court
should have readily exercised its writ jurisdiction. The
constitutional powers vested in the High Court or the
Supreme Court cannot be fettered by any alternative
remedy available to the party concerned. Injustice,
whenever and wherever it takes place, should be
struck down as an anathema to the rule of law and the
provisions of the Constitution.”


37. In view of the declaration of law by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the aforementioned judgments, I
am of the considered opinion that the contention
advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No.4-MESCOM, seeking to relegate the

- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


petitioner-Mutt to the competent Civil Court for
recovery of rent, particularly when the annual rent
payable is a meagre sum of Rs.275/- is untenable and
the respondent No.4-MESCOM is an instrumentality of
the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution of India, cannot raise such objections
contrary to Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The
respondent No.4-MESCOM being acted arbitrarily in
withholding payment of the annual rent of Rs.275/-
payable to the petitioner-Mutt since the year 2017
and such conduct and attitude on the part of
respondent No.4-MESCOM deserve to be deprecated.

38. In the facts and circumstances of the case, I am
of the opinion that this is a fit case for exercise of the
extraordinary, equitable and discretionary writ
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India to grant appropriate relief to the

- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


petitioner-Mutt. The petitioner-Mutt has made out a
case for interference by this Court as to direct the
respondent No.4-MESCOM to pay the arrears of rent
due payable under the Lease Deed. Further, the
conduct and callousness exhibited by respondent
No.4-MESCOM in withholding the rent and failing to
consider the petitioner's request for enhancement
thereof despite the earlier orders passed by this court,
referred to above, are contrary to the principles of
fairness, reasonableness and legitimate expectation
on the part of the petitioner-Mutt. Hence, I pass the
following:
ORDER

i. The writ petitions are allowed .

ii. Respondent No.4-MESCOM is directed to
pay the arrears of rent due and payable to
the petitioner-Mutt within a period of four

- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


weeks from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this order.

iii. Respondent No.4-MESCOM shall maintain
the nature and character of the subject land
in accordance with the terms and conditions
of the Lease Deed dated 27.11.1937,
without undertaking any alteration or
change thereto and further directed not to
establish Sub-Station, without there being
enhancement of fair and reasonable rent till
the efflux of period stipulated in the Lease
Deed.

iv. The Deputy Commissioner, Udupi, is
directed to consider the representations
dated 14.02.2023, 07.12.2023 and
08.09.2026 (Annexures-A to A2 in W.P.
No.29451 of 2026) and take an appropriate

- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62670
WP No. 29451 of 2026
C/W WP No. 10011 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010647802026


decision thereon in accordance with law,
within an outer limit of four weeks from the
date of receipt of a certified copy of this
order.

v. Respondent No.4-MESCOM, is directed to
pay cost of Rs.25,000/- to the petitioner-
Mutt, as litigation expenses.

SD/-
(E.S.INDIRESH)
JUDGE


SB
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 70