Nepal Singh vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 869
NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS.2239-2240 OF 2026


NEPAL SINGH … APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH … RESPONDENT(S)


J U D G M E N T

1. By way of the impugned judgment dated 08.03.2018 in
relation to F.I.R.No.6/1993 registered at police station Hatta,
District Damoh, under Sections 147, 148, 149 & 307 of the
1
Indian Penal Code, 1860 the accused persons (6 in number) were
charged to face trial. The genesis of the prosecution story being
that on 06.01.1993 the accused persons formed an unlawful
assembly; and with a common object; caused injuries to Gaflu

1
IPC
1

and Bharat Singh. In furtherance thereof, they also committed an
offence of rioting with deadly weapons. As a result thereof,
Gaflu died.
2. Challan was presented against 11 accused persons in
relation to the very same offence. To establish their case,
prosecution examined 17 witnesses and eventually the
prosecution failed to prove the case against only some of the
accused. Jhallu, Karodi, Sanju, Ujju @ Ujiyar and Hannu @
Hanumat were acquitted of but the remaining five accused
persons, including appellant Nepal Singh were found guilty of
having committed offences under Sections 148, 324/149 and
302/149 of IPC. One additional co-accused Prakash Pateriya
expired during trial.
3. Noticeably, the State did not prefer any appeal against the
judgment of acquittal of 5 accused amongst 11 accused persons.
However, in the common appeal preferred by the convicts, the
High Court in terms of the impugned judgment, dismissed the
appeal and concurred with the view taken by the Trial Court.
4. Before us it cannot be disputed that Gaflu, died as a result
of the injuries sustained by him, which fact also stands proven on
record through the medical record and more specifically the
deposition of PW-14 Dr. P.D. Kargaiyan.
5. The question that arises for consideration is to who were
involved in the untoward incident.
2

6. The prosecution alleges the convicts as also the persons
acquitted to have been involved in the incident, and to establish
such fact reliance is placed upon the testimony of PW-6 the
alleged eye-witness, who also sustained injuries in the very same
incident, and PW-7 who is the wife of the deceased. The
examination-in-chief part of the testimonies of these witnesses
undoubtedly establishes that the assailants were the perpetrators,
who, without any sufficient cause assaulted the deceased as well
as the eye-witness (PW-6). But, on a careful perusal of the cross-
examination part of the testimonies, we find them to have
mutually contradicted themselves. These testimonies are full of
embellishments. To our mind they do not inspire confidence at
all. Their depositions are not worthy of credence. Their
testimonies cannot be believed.
7. PW-6 admits that prior to the incident there was a fight
between Ramsewak and Prakash Pateriya, and on some earlier
occasion there was also a quarrel with Harsewak Pateriya and in
that Ravi Singh sustained injuries. He further admits that Gaflu,
being one of the assailants was also named as an accused in the
said incident. Though the police were hunting for his father, but
however he could not be caught. He contradicts his earlier
version of his mother being present on the spot and having
witnessed the incident. He admits that the police had reached the
spot when Gaflu was still alive, yet the police did not record his
statement. He further admits that his father was not interrogated
3

by the police in his presence. After all, one cannot forget that
Gaflu, himself was an accused. He also admits that Prakash
Pateriya, owned the land which was being cultivated by the
accused persons. It is his case that because of the injuries
sustained he lost his consciousness. Well, if that were so, then
how could he have described as to which of the assailants
inflicted the blow and with which weapon, particularly when he
claims to have fallen unconscious upon receiving the first blow?
What renders his testimony to be not worthy of credence is his
own admission “ I did not personally witness my father being
struck by the farsa ”
8. Similarly, PW-7 admits that, “ On the day of altercation, I
was at home feeding my children when I heard a commotion
inside the house indicating that my husband and son had been
assaulted in the field. I immediately ran towards the scene
accompanied by many villagers ”. She further states that by the
time she reached the spot her husband was already placed on the
cot. This only belies her version in the examination-in-chief part
of the testimony that she had witnessed the incident having taken
place.
9. We notice that the High Court has only considered the
testimonies of the two witnesses on the premise that there was no
other witness who witnessed such an incident. The mere
recovery of weapons such as lathi, farsa, ballam etc., cannot, by
itself establish any linkage with the accused, particularly when
4

such articles are commonly found in every household in the rural
areas. It has already come on record that the owner of the land
tilled by the convicts had, in fact, been assaulted by the
complainant party. This was just prior to the occurrence of the
incident in question. There was a land dispute between the
parties and the possibility of the accused being falsely implicated
cannot be ruled out. We may also notice that testimonies of PW-
8 and PW-9, who allegedly witnessed the occurrence of the
incident is not worthy of credence, for from their cross-
examination part of the testimony, they appear to have been
planted by the prosecution.
10. That apart, we may also observe that on the same set of
facts, the learned Trial Court convicted certain persons and
acquitted others. On the very same set of depositions, assigning
similar roles to all the accused persons, either all should have
been convicted or acquitted. There is no discussion by the High
Court as to why the reasoning adopted by the Trial Court for
acquitting the co-accused could not have been adopted qua the
convicts.

11. Accordingly, the judgment of conviction of the appellant
is hereby set aside, and the appeals are disposed of. Judgment
dated 08.03.2018 passed in Criminal Appeal Nos.1272 of 1995
and 1327 of 1995 titled Bahadur Singh and Ors. vs. The State
of Madhya Pradesh through P.S. Hatta, District Damoh , passed
5

by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur, is quashed and
set aside. Accordingly, the accused, if in jail, is directed to be set
free. Bail bonds, if any, stands cancelled. Pending application(s),
if any, shall stand disposed of.

…………………………………...J.
(SANJAY KAROL)



………………………………..…..J.
(AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH)

New Delhi
August 17, 2026


6