VALLIAMMAL- died vs S.MEENA

Court
Madras High Court

SA No. 1477 of 2010
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 12-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
SA No. 1477 of 2010
CNR: {HCMA010119402010}
1. VALLIAMMAL [died] W/o Late Murugesan
2. Thulukanam S/o Late P.Murugesan
3. Ajay Kumar S/o Late P.Murugesan
4. Ramesh S/o Late Murugesan
5. Nagammal D/o Late P.Murugesan
W/o Vijayakumar.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. S.Meena W/o M.Sunder
2. Suhasini D/o Sunder
3. Subbulakshmi D/o Sunder
4. Ramu S/o Sunder
..Respondent(s)
[Sole appellant died. Appellants 2 to 5 brought on record
as Legal Representatives of the deceased sole appellant
Viz., Valliammal vide order dated 20/04/2021 made in
CMP Nos.5260, 5261 and 5264/2020]
PRAYER : The Second Appeal has been preferred under Section 100 of Civil
Procedure Code as against the decree and judgment passed in A.S No.411 of
2008 dated 26.10.2009 on the file of the Additional District Judge, II Fast Track
Court, Chennai confirming the decree and judgment of the trial Court passed in
O.S. No.942 of 2007 dated 25.02.2008 on the file of the XII Assistant City Civil
Court, Chennai.
__________
Page 1 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
For Appellant(s): M/S. C.R. RUKMANI
For Respondent(s): No Appearance
JUDGMENT
The Second appeal has been preferred as against the decree and judgment
passed by the Additional District Judge, II Fast Track Court, Chennai in A.S
st
No.411 of 2008 dated 26.10.2009. The 1 appellant is the Plaintiff, who filed a
Suit in O.S. No.942 of 2007 on the file of the XII Assistant City Civil Court,
Chennai for the relief of recovery of possession as against the respondents
herein. The said Suit was dismissed. Aggrieved by the said decree and
judgment, the Plaintiff has preferred an appeal in A.S. No.411 of 2008 on the
file of the Additional District Judge, II Fast Track Court, Chennai and the said
appeal was also dismissed by confirming the decree and judgment passed by the
st
trial Court. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the 1 appellant has
st
preferred this second appeal. While pending appeal, the 1 appellant died and
her legal heirs were impleaded as the appellants 2 to 5.
2. The case of the Plaintiff before the trial Court is that the Suit property
originally belonged to her husband Murugesan. The said Murugesan had first
wife namely Poongavanam and she died. Thereafter, the Plaintiff married the
nd
said Murugesan as his 2 wife. The said Murugesan purchased the Suit
property. During his life time, he bequeathed the Suit property through a
__________
Page 2 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
registered Will dated 26.11.1984 in favour of the Plaintiff. The said Murugesan
died on 18.02.1992 . After the demise of Murugesan, the Plaintiff filed a
petition for grant of Letters of Administration in O.P. No.358 of 1994, where
one Sundar S/o. Murugesan had appeared and thereafter, the said original
petition was converted as T.O.S. No.17/99 and thereafter, they have not
contested the said Suit and it was decreed on 22.06.2004, thereby, the Plaintiff
became the absolute owner of the Suit property. While so, the said Sundar, son
of Murugesan, who was living at Sivarajapuram, along with his family, came to
the death ceremony of Murugesan and began to stay and reside in one room
measuring 11’ x 10’ and also was using a portion of the varandah as a bath
room in the ground floor of the premises. Thereafter, they were residing in the
premises as permissive occupants. After the demise of the said Sundar, the
defendants created problems to the Plaintiff and therefore, she revoked the
permission through notice dated 14.02.2006 and despite the notice, the
defendants failed to deliver the possession and thereby, she filed the Suit.
st
3. The case of the 1 defendant before the trial Court is that the
defendants denied the allegations levelled in the Plaint except those that are
specifically admitted thereunder. The Schedule property originally belonged to
st
the father-in-law of the 1 defendant and grand father of the other defendants.
The Plaintiff is not a legally wedded wife of the deceased Murugesan. The
__________
Page 3 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
st
mother-in-law of the 1 wife Poongavanam was alive and during her life time,
she was neglected by her son Murugesan. At that time, the Plaintiff had an
illicit intimacy with the deceased Murugesan and managed to get a Will dated
26.11.1984 and the said Will has not been probated at the earliest point of time.
The said Murugesan died in the year 1992 and the Suit is barred by limitation.
The defendants denied the allegation that they came to the premises only at the
time of death of Murugesan, but even prior to the death of Murugesan, they
were in possession and even from the version of the Plaintiff, from the year
1992 till 2007, they were absolutely in possession of the property and therefore,
they perfected the title by way of adverse possession. Thereby, the Suit is liable
to be dismissed.
4. Based on the above said pleadings and after hearing both sides, the trial
court has framed the following issues for trial:-
Issues:
1. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to recover the Suit property?
2. To what other reliefs, the Plaintiff is entitled?
Thereafter, the issues were recasted as follows:-
1. Whether the defendants perfected the title by adverse possession?
2. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to recover the Suit property?\
__________
Page 4 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
3. To what relief?
5. Before the trial court, on the side of the plaintiff, witness P.W.1 was
examined and marked exhibits, Ex.A.1 to A7. On the side of the defendants,
witness D.W.1 was examined and Ex.B1 to Ex.B.4 have been marked. The trial
court, after evaluating the oral and documentary evidences adduced on both
sides and perusing the records, dismissed the Suit through its judgment and
decree dated 25.02.2008. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the
Plaintiff has preferred an appeal in A.S. No.411 of 2008 on the file of the
Additional District Judge, II Fast Track Court, Chennai on various grounds.
5.1. The First Appellate Court has framed the points for determination as
follows:-
(i) Whether the appeal is liable to be allowed or not?
(ii) To what other reliefs?
6. After hearing both sides and perusing the records, the First Appellate
Court dismissed the appeal by confirming the judgment and decree passed by
the trial Court. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the present second
appeal has been preferred by the appellant / Plaintiff.
__________
Page 5 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
7 . For the sake of convenience and brevity, the parties herein are referred
as plaintiff and defendants, as referred before the trial Court.
8. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants would submit that the
st
1 appellant is the Plaintiff, who filed the Suit for recovery of possession. In
st
fact, the Suit property originally belonged to the husband of the 1 appellant
nd
Murugesan and the Plaintiff is the 2 wife of said Murugesan. The said
Murugesan had got one son namely Sundar through his first wife. The said
Sundar died and the respondents herein are the legal heirs of the said Sundar.
The said Murugesan bequeathed the property in favour of the Plaintiff through a
Will dated 26.11.1984 and he died on 18.02.1992. Thereafter, the Plaintiff filed
a petition in O.P. No.358 of 1994 for grant of Letters of Administration, where
st
the husband of the 1 defendant and the father of the other defendants, arrayed
as a party and he filed a Caveat. Thereby, the said original petition was
converted as TOS No.17 of 1999 and thereafter, they have not contested the
case and the said Suit was decreed on 22.06.2004, thereby, the Plaintiff became
the absolute owner of the Suit property. While so, the said Sundar, son of
deceased Murugesan came to the death ceremony of Murugesan and began to
stay and reside in one room measuring 11 x 10 feet and also using a portion of
the Varandah as a bath room in the ground floor of the premises. The said
Sundar also died and even after his demise, the defendants did not vacate the
__________
Page 6 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
portion, but on the other hand, they have been continuously picking up quarrels
with the Plaintiff and caused nuisance. Thereby, the Plaintiff revoked the
permission granted to the defendants through a notice dated 14.02.2006. Even
after the notice, the defendants failed to vacate the premises and thereby, the
Plaintiff filed the Suit.
8.1. The learned counsel would further submit that the Courts below
without considering the evidences in a proper and perspective manner and
without considering that already the Will has been probated and the Plaintiff is
the owner of the Suit property, erroneously held that the defendants perfected
the title by way of adverse possession. There are no proper pleadings and
evidences for the adverse possession. Without any proper pleadings and
evidences, the Courts below have rendered findings that the defendants are
entitled to the property by way of adverse possession. Therefore, the judgments
and decrees passed by the Courts below are liable to be set aside.
9. Despite several adjournments granted to the respondents, none
appeared.
10. Therefore, this Court heard the appellants’ side, perused the entire
materials available on record, and inclined to pass judgment.
__________
Page 7 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
11. There is no dispute that the Suit property originally belonged to one
st
Murugesan. The 1 defendant is none other than the daughter-in-law and the
defendants 2 to 4 are grand daughters and grand son of the deceased
Murugesan. The Plaintiff is claiming that the said Murugesan executed a Will
dated 26.11.1984 in her favour and the said Will was probated through T.O.S.
No.17 of 1999 on 22.06.2004. The defendants have also not denied the above
said execution of the Will and the Will has been duly proved in accordance with
law. The defendants through their written statement have not specifically
denied the averments of the Plaint. However, the Plaintiff has not pleaded
st
about the date of permission granted to Sundar, the husband of the 1 defendant
and father of other defendants. The Courts below came to a conclusion that the
defendants have been in possession and enjoyment of the Suit property from
1992 to 2006 and for the past 14 years, the Plaintiff has not taken any steps and
thereby, the defendants are entitled to the property by way of adverse
possession.
12. This Court perused the entire pleadings and evidences. There are no
proper evidences for the adverse possession and in the written statement, the
defendants have stated in one line that ‘if they had come in the year 1992 upto
2007, they absolutely in possession of the property as if they have got share in
the property, thereby they perfected their title by way of adverse possession’.
__________
Page 8 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
Apart from these pleadings, there are no other pleadings and those pleadings are
not sufficient to claim adverse possession. In order to claim adverse possession,
the defendants have to admit the title of the Plaintiff, whereas they denied the
title of the Plaintiff. Even according to the pleadings of the defendants, they
have been in possession and enjoyment of the property, as if they have got share
in the property. Therefore, they have not admitted the title of the Plaintiff and
thereby the possession is not adverse to the original owner i.e., the Plaintiff.
13. It is a well settled law that to prove adverse possession, there should
be specific pleadings and the possession of the defendants must be nec vi, nec
clam, nec precario , but there is no evidence and the defendants’ possession is
hostile to the original owner. However, the Courts below, without any
evidence, came to an erroneous conclusion that the defendants proved their
adverse possession. Therefore, the findings of the Courts below are liable to be
set aside in respect of the adverse possession of the defendants, accordingly set
aside.
14. However, the Plaintiff has filed the Suit for the relief of ‘recovery of
possession’ alleging that she permitted the defendants to occupy the property,
but there is no specific date mentioned that when they were permitted to occupy
the property. According to the pleadings and evidences, immediately after the
__________
Page 9 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
demise of Murugesan in the year 1992, the Sundar along with the defendants,
came to the Plaintiff’s house and occupied the property. Apart from that, there
are no other pleadings. Therefore, the Plaintiff failed to prove that the
possession of the defendants are permissive possession.
15. It is an admitted fact that from the year 1992 till date, the defendants
are in possession and enjoyment of the property, i.e., for more than 12 years. It
is a well settled law that mere long possession is not sufficient to prove the
‘adverse possession’, unless the Plaintiff has animus possidendi. In this case,
there are no pleadings that the defendants are in possession and enjoyment of
the property by admitting the title of the Plaintiff and their possession is adverse
to the original owner of the property. Therefore, the defendants failed to prove
that their possession is adverse to the Plaintiff.
16. Moreover, the Plaintiff filed the Suit for recovery of possession of the
property to an extent of 600 sq. ft. and there is no proper identification of the
Suit property. The Plaintiff has not even mentioned the Survey number in the
Plaint. The Survey Number has been kept as ‘blank’ in the schedule of property
and measurement has also been given as 600 sq. ft. There are no particulars of
measurement and it has only been mentioned as 600 sq. ft. Further as per the
pleadings, the portion occupied by the defendants is 11 x 10 feet, whereas in the
__________
Page 10 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
notice, it has been stated as 9 x 9 feet. In the notice, no description of property
has been mentioned. Therefore, the Plaintiff failed to identify the property
properly. It is a well settled law that as far as ‘recovery of possession’ is
concerned, the Plaintiff has to identify the property properly. In this case, the
Plaintiff has not even given the Survey number and in the notice, the
measurement of the property has been given as 9 x 9 feet, whereas in the Plaint,
it has been mentioned as 11 x 10 feet. But in the description of property,
measurement has not been given and thereby, it is not proper to order for
‘recovery of possession’. Since the Suit is only for ‘recovery of possession’,
without any proper identification of the property, the Plaintiff is not entitled to
the relief of ‘recovery of possession’. The Courts below have rendered
erroneous findings in respect of adverse possession in favour of the defendants.
Without any proper identification of the property and without giving Survey
number and other particulars, it is not appropriate to grant relief of ‘recovery of
possession’ and thereby, the Plaintiff is not entitled to any relief.
17. Therefore, in view of the above said reasons, the Plaintiff is not
entitled to any relief through the Suit. However, the Plaintiff is at liberty to file
a fresh Suit in accordance with law by giving proper identification of the
property. Further, this Court also perused the entire materials including the
__________
Page 11 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
grounds of appeal and there are no any substantial questions of law involved in
this case.
18. In view of the above discussions, this Court is of the opinion that this
second appeal has no merits and deserves to be dismissed.
19. In the result, the Second Appeal stands dismissed. There shall be no
order as to costs.
12-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
MJS
To
1. The Additional District Judge, II Fast Track Court, Chennai.
2. The XII Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai.
__________
Page 12 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )

SA No. 1477 of 2010
P.DHANABAL, J.
MJS
SA No. 1477 of 2010
12-11-2026
__________
Page 13 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:39 pm )