C M NAGARAJA MURTHY vs V S RAJU

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 328 OF 2026

BETWEEN:

C M NAGARAJA MURTHY
S/O MADAIAH,
AGED 61 YEARS,
TH
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 54, 5 CROSS,
I MAIN, BIKASPURA (BDA ISRO LAYOUT)
TH
BANASHANKARI 5 STAGE,
BENGALURU – 560 061.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ALDEN D SOUZA, ADVOCATE)

AND:

V S RAJU
S/O SRI SIDDAIAH,
AGED 47 YEARS,
PROP. R K CONSTRUCTION,
HAVING OFFICE AT NO.28,29 AND 30,
TH
GROUND FLOOR, 7 CROSS, GYANAJYOTHI NAGARA,
ULLALA MAIN ROAD, BENGALURU – 560 110.
…RESPONDENT
(RESPONDENT SERVED)

THIS COMAP/COMMMERCIAL APPEAL FILED UNDER SECTION
13(1A) OF THE COMMERCIAL COURTS ACT, 2015, PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 10.06.2026 IN COMMERCIAL
O.S.NO.230/2025 (ANNEXURE A) PENDING BEFORE THE HON’BLE XI
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE (COMMERCIAL
COURT), BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT, BENGALURU.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:










Digitally
signed by
MALA K N
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

ORAL JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)

This Commercial Appeal is filed by the defendant
challenging the Judgment and Decree dated 10.06.2026 passed
by the XI Additional District and Sessions Judge, (Dedicated
Commercial Court), Bengaluru Rural District, Bengaluru
( ‘Commercial Court’ ) in Commercial O.S.No.230/2025,
whereby the review petition filed under Order XLVII Rule 1 read
with Section 114 of the Code of Civil Procedure, by the
defendant came to be allowed, modifying the order dated
02.05.2026 passed on I.A. filed under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and
2 of CPC.

2. For the sake of convenience, and to avoid any
confusion, the parties are referred to herein by their respective
rankings before the Commercial Court.

(i) Facts of the plaintiff:
3. The plaintiff, who is the proprietor of
M/s.R.K.Constructions, instituted Com.O.S.No.230/2025

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

against the defendant seeking recovery of a sum of
Rs.9,15,290/- together with interest at 12% per annum,
alleging that the said amount was due towards the construction
work undertaken by him in the defendant's residential building
bearing site No.229, situated at Sir M.Visveshwaraiah Layout,
9th Block, Bengaluru ( 'suit schedule property '). According to
the plaintiff, he was engaged by the defendant to execute
certain construction works and, despite having carried out the
work, the defendant failed to pay the entire amount due.

4. The plaintiff contended that the defendant was
attempting to proceed with the construction by engaging
another contractor without settling his claim and that such
action would prejudice his interest and affect his ability to
recover the amount due. Along with the suit, the plaintiff filed
I.A. No.1 under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of CPC, seeking an
order of temporary injunction restraining the defendant, his
men, agents or anybody claiming under him from engaging the
services of any other contractor to construct the residential
building over the suit schedule property during the pendency of
the suit.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

(ii) Defence of the defendant:
5. The defendant resisted the suit as well as I.A.No.1,
contending that the plaintiff had been engaged only for carrying
out specified portions of the construction under an oral
arrangement for a fixed consideration of Rs.9,50,000/-. It was
his specific case that the agreed amount had already been paid
through cheques dated 01.05.2024, 16.09.2024 and
25.09.2024, together with cash payment, and that the plaintiff
was subsequently raising an unjustified claim by relying upon
inflated invoices.

6. The defendant disputed the quality and nature of
the work executed by the plaintiff and asserted that the
construction suffered from defects. He further contended that
the suit was essentially one for recovery of money and that
there was no justification for preventing him, being the owner
of the suit schedule property, from completing the construction
of his own residential building through another contractor.

7. It was also contended that continuation of the
injunction would cause serious prejudice to him, whereas the
plaintiff's alleged monetary claim could be adjudicated in the

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

suit itself. On these grounds, the defendant sought dismissal of
I.A. No.1.

(iii) ORDER DATED 02.05.2026 ON I.A. NO.1 UNDER
ORDER XXXIX RULE 1 & 2 OF CPC:

8. The Commercial Court, after considering the
pleadings and objections filed by the defendant and hearing the
parties, by order dated 02.05.2026, allowed I.A.No.1 filed by
the plaintiff under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of CPC. The Court
proceeded on the premise that the plaintiff had undertaken
construction work in the suit schedule property and that, if the
defendant was permitted to engage another contractor and
proceed with the construction, the plaintiff would be left
without an effective means of protecting his interest in respect
of the amount claimed. Accordingly, the Court granted the
temporary injunction restraining the defendant from engaging
the services of any other contractor to complete the residential
building pending disposal of the suit.

9. The operative portion of the order dated
02.05.2026 reads as follows:
"IA No.1 filed by the plaintiff under Order 39 Rules
1 and 2 CPC seeking an order of temporary injunction

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

restraining the defendant, his men, agents or anybody
claiming under him from engaging the services of any
other contractor to construct the residential building over
the suit schedule property pending disposal of the suit is
allowed.

By way of temporary injunction, the defendant, his
men, agents or anybody claiming under him are hereby
restrained from engaging the services of any other
contractor to construct the residential building over the
suit schedule property pending disposal of the suit."

Aggrieved by the order dated 02.05.2026, the defendant filed
an application dated 01.06.2026 under Order XLVII Rule 1 read
with Section 114 of CPC, seeking review of the said order.

(iv) Review application filed by the defendant:

10. The defendant contended that the order proceeded
on an erroneous factual premise, particularly in describing the
plaintiff as the owner of the suit schedule property, whereas
the defendant himself was the owner. It was further contended
that the suit was one for recovery of an alleged monetary claim
of Rs.9,15,290/- and that there was no justification for

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

restraining the owner from proceeding with the construction of
his residential building.

11. The defendant also relied upon photographs
produced along with the review application to demonstrate the
damage likely to be caused to the building if the construction
was not completed. He therefore sought reconsideration of the
injunction order and appropriate modification thereof.

12. The plaintiff filed objections dated 04.06.2026
opposing the review application. The plaintiff contended that
the review application was not maintainable, that the defendant
was attempting to reopen the matter as though in an appeal
and that no error apparent on the face of the record or any
other ground recognized under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC had
been made out. The plaintiff accordingly sought dismissal of the
review application.

(v) Order dated 10.06.2026 in the review petition:
13. The Commercial Court, by order dated 10.06.2026,
allowed the review application filed by the defendant under
Order XLVII Rule 1 read with Section 114 of CPC and modified

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

its earlier order dated 02.05.2026. The Court directed certain
corrections in paragraph No.11 of the earlier order by
substituting the descriptions of the plaintiff and defendant and
added paragraph No.16.

14. More importantly, taking note of the photographs
produced by the defendant and the prima facie damage likely
to be caused to the building under construction, the
Commercial Court held that, instead of restraining the
defendant, being the owner of the suit schedule property, from
proceeding with the construction, directing him to furnish
security by way of a bank guarantee for the plaintiff's suit claim
would meet the ends of justice.

15. The relevant operative portion of the review order
dated 10.06.2026 reads as follows:
"Review Petition filed by the defendant under Order
47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 of the Code of Civil
Procedure is hereby allowed.

Order dated 02.05.2026 passed on IA, under Order
39 Rules 1 and 2 by the plaintiff is hereby modified as
under:
At para No.11, second line, the word plaintiff has to
be substituted by the word defendant. At line No.3 the

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

word defendant has to be substituted by the word
plaintiff. At line No.5, word defendant has to be
substituted by the word plaintiff.

Para No.16 to be added as under:

In view of the photographs produced by the
defendant to establish a prima facie damage that would
be caused to the building under construction in the suit
schedule property, instead of restraining defendant or
owner of the suit schedule property from proceeding with
the completion of the construction work, directing the
defendant to furnish bank guarantee for the suit claim of
the plaintiff to the tune of Rs.10 lakhs renewable until
disposal of the suit would meet the ends of justice.

Operative portion of the order under review to be
as follows:

Defendant is directed to furnish bank guarantee to
the tune of Rs.10 Lakhs renewable until disposal of the
suit towards suit claim of the plaintiff."

Thus, the earlier restraint against the defendant from engaging
another contractor was removed and substituted by a direction
to furnish a bank guarantee of Rs.10,00,000/-, renewable until
disposal of the suit.

16. Aggrieved by the order dated 10.06.2026, the
defendant has preferred the present commercial appeal under

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, contending
that the Commercial Court, having allowed the review
application and removed the restraint on construction, could
not have imposed an independent condition directing him to
furnish a bank guarantee of Rs.10,00,000/- without recording
proper reasons.

(vi) Grounds urged in the commercial appeal:

17. It is urged that the direction is arbitrary and beyond
the scope of the original application under Order XXXIX Rules 1
and 2 CPC, particularly when the suit is essentially for recovery
of money and the plaintiff has not sought any such relief. The
defendant further contends that there is no material to indicate
that he has attempted to alienate the suit schedule property,
defeat any decree that may ultimately be passed, or otherwise
obstruct the recovery of the plaintiff's alleged dues. On the
contrary, he has appeared before the Court, filed his written
statement and contested the claim.

18. It is also contended that the direction to furnish a
bank guarantee operates in the nature of an attachment before

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

judgment, without satisfying the requirements of Order XXXVIII
Rule 5 CPC. The Commercial Court, according to the defendant,
has not recorded any finding regarding the existence of a prima
facie case, balance of convenience or irreparable injury
warranting such a condition. The defendant, therefore,
contends that the impugned order suffers from non-application
of mind, imposes an unreasonable financial burden upon him
and is liable to be set aside.

19. We have heard Sri.Alden D'Souza, learned counsel
appearing for the appellant/defendant. Upon consideration of
the pleadings, the records placed before this Court and the
submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant, the following
point arises for our consideration:
Whether the defendant has made out any ground
warranting interference with the Judgment and
Decree dated 10.06.2026 passed by the XI Additional
District and Sessions Judge, (Dedicated Commercial
Court), Bengaluru Rural District, Bengaluru in
Commercial O.S.No.230/2025?

(vii) Reasons and Analysis:
20. The principal question that arises for our
consideration is, whether the Commercial Court was justified in

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

modifying its earlier order dated 02.05.2026 by directing the
defendant to furnish a bank guarantee of Rs.10,00,000/-,
instead of continuing the restraint on construction of the
residential building. In considering this question, the
subsequent order dated 10.06.2026 cannot be read in isolation.
The nature of the suit, the relief sought by the plaintiff and the
prejudice likely to be caused to either party were all relevant
considerations.

21. The plaintiff's claim in Com.O.S.No.230/2025 is for
recovery of Rs.9,15,290/- with interest. The defendant, on the
other hand, is the owner of the suit schedule property and has
asserted that he has already paid Rs.9,50,000/- towards the
agreed construction work. These rival claims are yet to be
established at trial. In such circumstances, the Commercial
Court was justified in reconsidering the earlier restraint,
particularly when continuation of the injunction would prevent
the defendant from completing his residential building during
the pendency of a suit which is essentially for recovery of
money.

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

22. It is true that the power of review under Order
XLVII Rule 1 read with Section 114 CPC is limited. A review
cannot be converted into an appeal, nor can a Court reconsider
the entire matter merely because another view is possible.
However, the present case has to be examined in the light of
the material placed before the Commercial Court by the
defendant. The photographs produced along with the review
application were taken into consideration to assess the likely
damage to the building under construction if the work was not
permitted to proceed.

23. The earlier order had the effect of restraining the
owner from engaging another contractor and completing the
building. The Commercial Court, upon noticing the factual
position and the consequences of continuing such restraint,
modified its earlier order. The correction of the description of
the parties and the consideration of the photographs were also
noticed in the review order. Therefore, the modification cannot
be treated as an exercise undertaken merely to substitute one
possible view for another. The Court sought to balance the
competing interests of the parties.

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

24. There is yet another aspect which assumes
significance. Order XXXIX Rule 2(2) CPC expressly empowers
the Court to grant an injunction subject to such terms as
regards duration, keeping of accounts, furnishing of security or
otherwise, as it considers appropriate. Therefore, the
contention that the Commercial Court had no authority to
impose a condition of furnishing security cannot be accepted.

25. The direction to furnish a bank guarantee has to be
considered in the context in which it was issued. The Court did
not direct attachment of the defendant's property, nor did it
prevent him from proceeding with the construction. On the
contrary, the earlier restraint was removed and the defendant
was permitted to complete the building, subject to furnishing
security for the claim made in the suit. The distinction between
an order directing security under Order XXXIX Rule 2(2) and an
attachment before judgment under Order XXXVIII Rule 5 CPC
cannot be overlooked.

26. The latter provision operates in a different field and
its requirements cannot be mechanically imported into an order
passed while regulating temporary injunctive relief. The amount

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

of Rs.10,00,000/- directed to be secured is also broadly
referable to the plaintiff's claim of Rs.9,15,290/-. In these
circumstances, the direction cannot be characterised as wholly
without jurisdiction.

27. The principles governing interference by an
appellate Court with an order relating to temporary injunction
are equally well settled. In the present case, the Commercial
Court has removed the restraint which was preventing the
defendant from completing construction and has imposed a
condition of security to protect the plaintiff's monetary claim.
Merely because the defendant considers the condition onerous
or would prefer that no security be furnished, that by itself is
not a ground to interfere with the order. The impugned order
dated 10.06.2026 reflects an attempt to protect the interests of
both parties without bringing the construction activity to a
standstill.

28. The impugned order has been passed in the interest
of both parties, balancing their respective rights and equities,
and to secure the ends of justice. No grounds are made out
warranting interference by this Court.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62568-DB
COMAP No. 328 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010442892026

29. This Court does not find any perversity or such
patent illegality in the exercise of discretion as would warrant
interference in the present appeal. The grounds urged by the
defendant, therefore, do not make out a case for setting aside
the impugned order. Therefore, the appeal is liable to be
dismissed. Accordingly, the following;
ORDER
(i) The Commercial appeal is dismissed.
(ii) The Judgment and Decree dated 10.06.2026 passed
by the XI Additional District and Sessions Judge, (Dedicated
Commercial Court), Bengaluru Rural District, Bengaluru, in
Commercial O.S.No.230/2025, is hereby affirmed.
No order as to costs.



Sd/-
(D K SINGH)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE

KNM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 22