Oil And Natural Gas Corporation vs Deputy Labour Comissioner

Court
Uttarakhand High Court

UKHC010203352026

2026:UHC:10579


HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL

Writ Petition Misc. Single No.3526 of 2026
th
18 November, 2026

Oil And Natural Gas Corporation ………….Petitioner

Versus

Deputy Labour Comissioner
and another ……….Respondents

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:-
Mr. Pankaj Miglani, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Mr. Piyush Tiwari, learned Central Government Counsel for the
respondents.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
This writ petition has been filed by the
petitioner for a direction in the nature of certiorari for
quashing the reference order dated 01.03.2023, passed
by learned Deputy Labor Commissioner (Central),
Dehradun, Government of India, Ministry of Labour and
Employment by means of which learned Deputy Labour
Commissioner has referred the industrial dispute raised
by the respondent for adjudication to the Central
Government Industrial Tribunal-II.
2. Brief facts of the case are that respondent
initially served as a Constable (Mahila) in the CRPF. After
being discharged from the CRPF she joined at ONGC
where she was appointed as a Security Receptionist from
December 1994 to December 1995. Thereafter, she was
appointed as a Security Inspector Grade II from
23.08.1996 to 31.12.2004. She was further engaged on a
fresh tenure basis with effect from 01.01.2005, and
consequently, vide letter dated 31.01.2005, she was
1

UKHC010203352026

2026:UHC:10579

appointed under specific conditions. Subsequently, on
01.02.2005, another order was issued, specifying her
tenure up to 31.12.2008. She was again appointed on a
tenure basis, with her last tenure appointment being
from 01.01.2013 to 31.12.2016. Thereafter, the
respondent was not re-engaged, which was
communicated to her vide order dated 29.12.2016 and
throughout her entire tenure, she was employed in
Dehradun only. Respondent earlier approached this
Court by filing a writ petition bearing WPSS No.341 of
2016, which was disposed of by this Court vide order
dated 31.11.2016. The respondent then moved a
representation before the petitioner-Corporation for
extension of her term, which was rejected vide order
dated 24.03.2017 by means of a reasoned and speaking
order. Writ petitions filed by the respondent were
dismissed by this Court vide a common order dated
01.08.2018. The learned Single Judge specifically held
that the respondent does not fall within the definition of
'workman' as defined under the Industrial Disputes Act,
1947, and that since the respondent was a tenure
appointee and was no longer in service, no direction for
regularization could be passed. Against the order dated
01.08.2018 passed by the learned Single Judge, the
respondent filed a special appeal before the Division
Bench of this Court as SPA No.629 and 630 of 2018,
Poonam Dobriyal Vs. ONGC and Ors . The said special
appeal was disposed of by this Court, holding therein
that ONGC in its counter affidavit has raised an objection
that the petitioner has an alternate remedy before the
Industrial Tribunal and therefore dismissal of the petition
on the ground that the applicant was not a 'workman' is
2

UKHC010203352026

2026:UHC:10579

not sustainable. The Division Bench did not examine the
issue whether or not the respondent herein is a workman
and directed that it shall be open to the Industrial
Tribunal to examine this issue if raised by the
respondent. Post thereto the respondent filed her
application before learned Assistant Labour
Commissioner instituting conciliation proceedings and
praying therein that on failure of conciliation proceedings
the matter be referred to CGIT Delhi. The Ld. Labour
Commissioner vides its order dated 01.03.2023 referred
the industrial dispute for adjudication to CGIT Delhi. The
learned Deputy Labour Commissioner did not refer the
dispute regarding the fact that whether the respondent is
a Workman or not to C.G.I.T. hence this writ petition.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner pleads
that the Division Bench of this Court has specifically vide
its order dated 25.08.2022 directed the Tribunal to
decide the status of the respondent as to whether she
was a Workman or not but the reference is silent on this
aspect. He further states that the reference is itself
defective as it is not made by the appropriate
Government. He further states that the reference has
been made to C.G.I.T. Delhi whereas it is an admitted
fact that the respondent has throughout her career was
employed in Dehradun and therefore the appropriate
Industrial Tribunal would be C.G.I.T. Lucknow.
4. Having heard the submissions made by
learned counsel for the petitioner and after perusal of
material available on record this Court is of the
considered opinion that it is a settled principle of law that
the reference made under Section 10 of Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 is merely an administrative function
3

UKHC010203352026

2026:UHC:10579

of the appropriate Government and the power exercised
under Section 10 is not judicial or quasi judicial and it is
also a settled principle of law that the scope of
interference by High Court is limited only on the grounds

of mala fide , perversity in the reference order, lack of
jurisdiction by the referring authority or if the reference
is made even when there is no industrial dispute. As far
as the contention of learned counsel for the petitioner
that C.G.I.T. Lucknow is seized of the jurisdiction and
C.G.I.T. Delhi does not have the territorial jurisdiction is
concerned this argument can be raised as a preliminary
issue before the Tribunal. This Court is not inclined to
interfere in this matter.
5. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Madras Vs. C.P. Sarathy reported in AIR 1953 SC 53 has
held that “But, it must be remembered that in making a
reference under Section 10(1) the Government is doing
an administrative act and the fact that it has to form an
opinion as to the factual existence of an industrial
dispute as a preliminary step to the discharge of its
function does not make it any the less administrative in
character. The Court cannot, therefore, canvass the order
of reference closely to see if there was any material before
the Government to support its conclusion, as if it was a
judicial or quasi-judicial determination. No doubt, it will
be open to a party seeking to impugn the resulting award
to show that what was referred by the Government was
not an industrial dispute within the meaning of the Act,
and that, therefore, the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to
make the award. But, if the dispute was an industrial
dispute as defined in the Act, its factual existence and
the expediency of making a reference in the
4

UKHC010203352026

2026:UHC:10579

circumstances of a particular case are matters entirely
for the Government to decide upon, and it will not be
competent for the Court to hold the reference bad and
quash the proceedings for want of jurisdiction merely
because there was, in its opinion, no material before the
Government on which it could have come to an
affirmative conclusion on those matters."

6. Accordingly writ petition stands dismissed.


( .)
Pankaj Purohit, J
18.11.2026

SK









SHUBHAM
KAPRUWAN
Digitally signed by SHUBHAM KAPRUWAN DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, 2.5.4.20=a29a2f80b93835a432d093afc472d9355959ee0ff878380c645e17d546a24821, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND, serialNumber=B505B049BA2FDAC35E7AE325DEE1505D6C35AF3D290C229CDC609D61801E1E4F, cn=SHUBHAM KAPRUWAN Date: 2026.11.19 19:48:07 +05'30'
5