United India Insurance Company Ltd vs Vipin Kumar And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1
FAO-4825-2017 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
FAO-4825-2017 (O&M)
Reserved on :04.11.2026
Pronounced on: 11.11.2026
Uploaded on 11.11.2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or the full judgment is pronounced: Operative part/full judgment
United India Insurance Company Limited
…...Appellant
Versus
Vipin Kumar and others
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANDEEP PANNU
Present:- Mr. Harsh Aggarwal, Advocate and
Mr. Parit Aggarwal, Advocate for the appellant
Mr. Arun Takhi, Advocate
for respondent No.1-claimant
MANDEEP PANNU, J.
1. The present appeal has been filed by the appellant-insurance
company impugning the award dated 24.03.2017 passed by the learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Chandigarh (hereinafter referred to as
₹
‘Tribunal’) whereby compensation of 38,77,360/- has been awarded to the
respondent No.1-claimant on account of injuries suffered by him in a motor
vehicular accident, fastening the liability to pay the compensation upon the
appellant-insurance company.
2. Learned counsel for the appellant-insurance company has
argued that the learned Tribunal has erred in assessing the monthly income
₹ ₹
of the injured at 12,000/- instead of 8,000/-, as reflected in the salary
certificate. It is submitted that, as per the statement of CW-1, an employee
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.11 16:47
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh

2
FAO-4825-2017 (O&M)
₹
of Score Club, the injured was drawing a monthly salary of 8,000/-.
₹
Therefore, taking his monthly income as 12,000/- by adding an amount of
₹
4,000/- towards tips is not sustainable in law. It is contended that the
amount received by way of tips is voluntary in nature and cannot be treated
as a fixed component of income. Accordingly, the learned Tribunal has
wrongly assessed the income of the injured, resulting in an excessive award
₹
of compensation. It is, thus, prayed that the amount of 4,000/- added
towards tips be excluded while calculating the income of the injured and the
compensation be suitably reduced.
3. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent no.1-
claimant has argued that the injured was working as a waiter and was
₹
earning 8,000/- per month as salary, besides receiving approximately
₹
4,000/- per month by way of tips from customers. It is submitted that the
factum of receipt of tips is duly established from the evidence on record and
has not been disputed by the appellant. Learned counsel has further
submitted that tips received by persons working in the hospitality industry
constitute a regular source of earnings and cannot be excluded merely
because the same are received from customers. Reliance in this regard has
been placed upon the judgments of the Hon’b le Delhi High Court in
Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Ms. Milly Das Gupta and
others , MAC.APP . No. 1069 of 2011, decided on 07.01.2015, and the
Hon’ble Bombay High Court in Mrs. Sangamma Kolkar and another v.
Mr. Vasudev Gaonkar and others , 2015(32) RCR (Civil) 322 . It is, thus,
contended that the learned Tribunal has rightly taken the monthly income of
₹
the injured as 12,000/- by including the amount received towards tips and
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.11 16:47
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh

3
FAO-4825-2017 (O&M)
no illegality or infirmity can be attributed to the impugned award on this
account.
4. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have perused
the impugned award as well as the record.
5. The principal controversy arising for consideration in the
present appeal is whether the amount received by the injured towards tips,
over and above his fixed monthly salary, could be taken into consideration
while assessing his monthly income for the purpose of determining
compensation.
6. The contention raised on behalf of the appellant does not merit
acceptance. It is not disputed that the injured was working as a waiter at
₹
Score Club and was drawing a monthly salary of 8,000/-. The dispute is
₹
only with regard to the addition of 4,000/- towards tips received by him
from customers. The fact that persons employed as waiters in restaurants
and clubs receive tips from customers is a recognised feature of employment
in the hospitality industry. Such receipts, where established by evidence and
shown to be regularly earned, cannot be excluded from the assessment of
income merely on the ground that they are not paid by the employer as a
fixed component of salary. The relevant consideration for determining the
income of the injured is his actual and regular earnings and not merely the
amount reflected in the salary certificate.
7. In Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Ms. Milly Das
Gupta and others (supra) , the Hon’ble Delhi High Court specifically dealt
with the question whether tips received by an employee working in the
hospitality industry could be included while determining her income for the
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.11 16:47
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh

4
FAO-4825-2017 (O&M)
purpose of computation of compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act. The
Court upheld the inclusion of tips, observing that earning of tips by persons
employed in the hospitality industry is a usual feature and constitutes a part
of their regular earnings. The argument of the insurance company that tips
ought to be excluded from the income was accordingly rejected.
8. Similarly, in Mrs. Sangamma Kolkar and another v. Mr.
Vasudev Gaonkar and others (supra) , the Hon’ble Bombay High Court
₹
considered the income of a deceased waiter who was receiving 1,500/- as
₹
salary and 1,300/- by way of tips. The contention of the insurance company
that the amount received as tips was uncertain and depended upon the
customers visiting the establishment was rejected. It was held that what was
required to be considered was the gross monthly earning of the deceased and
the amount received towards tips was accordingly included while
determining his income.
9. The ratio of the aforesaid judgments squarely supports the view
taken by the learned Tribunal. In the present case, the injured was
₹
admittedly employed as a waiter and the receipt of 4,000/- per month
₹
towards tips, in addition to his salary of 8,000/-, has not been disputed by
the appellant by bringing any cogent material on record. The mere fact that
the tips were received from customers and were not part of the fixed salary
paid by the employer would not be sufficient to exclude the same from his
monthly earnings. Accordingly, the learned Tribunal has rightly assessed the
₹
monthly income of the injured at 12,000/- by adding the amount received
towards tips to his fixed salary.
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.11 16:47
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh

5
FAO-4825-2017 (O&M)
10. There is yet another significant aspect of the matter. It is not
disputed that the injured has suffered 100% permanent disability as a result
of the injuries sustained in the accident. The extent of disability has a direct
bearing upon the assessment of compensation, particularly under the head of
loss of future earning capacity. In a case where the injured has suffered
100% disability, the consequences of such disability upon his future life and
earning capacity assume considerable significance. The compensation is
required to be assessed keeping in view the nature and extent of the
disability and its impact upon the injured's ability to earn his livelihood. The
learned Tribunal has assessed the compensation after taking into
consideration the relevant factors, including the income of the injured.
11. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court finds no
illegality or perversity in the assessment of the monthly income of the
₹ ₹
injured at 12,000/- by the learned Tribunal. The amount of 4,000/-
received towards tips has rightly been included in his monthly income. The
appellant has failed to make out any ground warranting interference with the
impugned award on this account.
12. Consequently, the appeal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed
and the award dated 24.03.2017 passed by the learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal is upheld.
13. All the pending miscellaneous applications, if any, are also
disposed of.
11.11.2026 (MANDEEP PANNU)
rekha JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.11 16:47
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh