U.P. Education Service Selection Commissioner Prayagraj And Another vs Vijay Sonkar And 4 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
SPECIAL APPEAL No. - 1310 of 2026
U.P. Education Service Selection Commissioner
Prayagraj And Another
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
Vijay Sonkar And 4 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Udayan Nandan
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Ankita Singh, C.S.C.
Court No. - 39
HON'BLE SAUMITRA DAYAL SINGH, J.
HON'BLE SWARUPAMA CHATURVEDI, J.
1. Heard Sri Ashok Khare, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Sri Udayan
Nandan, learned counsel for the appellants-respondents and Ms. Tanya
Pandey, learned counsel for original petitioners.
2. Present intra Court appeal is directed against the order of learned single
judge dated 28.10.2026 in Vijay Sonkar and others vs. State of U.P. and
others, 2026:AHC:225670 . By that order, the learned Single Judge has
disposed of the writ petition with the following observations:
"50. Based upon foregoing paragraphs, this Court concludes that the
principle laid down in Smt. Shimla Singh governs the present controversy,
the appropriate relief be granted to the petitioners in terms of the
following directions:
(i) Question Nos. 36 and 37 of the Master Set shall be excluded from
evaluation, or dealt with in such manner as is consistent with the binding
judicial precedent discussed hereinabove.
(ii) The consequential benefit in respect of the aforesaid questions shall
be extended uniformly to all similarly situated candidates in accordance
with Ashok Yadav, Ran Vijay Singh, and Smt. Shimla Singh cases (supra),
without restricting such benefit solely to candidates who selected either of
the options accepted as correct.
SPLA No. 1310 of 2026
2
(iii) The respondents shall recompute the scores of the petitioners in
accordance with the aforesaid directions and correct their respective
results and scorecards, to the extent necessary."
3. Twin submissions have been advanced by learned Senior Counsel for the
Commission. First, it has been submitted that petitioners-respondents had
not filed any objections to the provisional answers published by the
Commission. Therefore, the challenge first raised by means of filing the writ
petition, after declaration of the final result in August, 2026 was not
maintainable. For reason of objections not filed, to the model answer key,
the petitioners had lost their chance to agitate the issue by filing writ petition
to test the correctness or otherwise of the questions or answer thereto.
4. Reliance has been placed on a decision of a learned single judge in Priti
, and a
Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and others, 2022:AHC:194389
decision of the coordinate bench in Uday Bhan Yadav vs State of Uttar
Pradesh and others, Special Appeal No. 492 of 2020.
5. Second, it has been submitted, both with respect to question no. 36 and 37
(at the UPTET Examination 2026)- on certain objections received by the
Commission to the provisional answer key, on its own appraisal, the
Commission itself found that more than one, i.e. two answer responses were
correct. Therefore, by way of prudence, the Commission decided to award
full marks to any candidate who had attempted either of the two correct
answer responses to question nos. 36 and 37, as their correct answer. That
was the only correction required to be made, in terms of law declared by the
Supreme Court in Guru Nanak Dev University vs. Saumil Garg and
others; (2005) 13 SCC 749.
6. To the extent the petitioners-respondents had not marked either of the two
correct answer responses to question nos. 36 and 37, but had chosen to mark
another option as the correct answer, they have no case to be awarded full
marks for that incorrect answer response. Also, in that case, the petitioners-
respondents cannot successfully contend that the two questions should be
excluded from evaluation. Also, reliance has been placed on a coordinate
bench decision of this Court in Sunil Kumar Singh and others vs. State of
U.P. and others, (2017) 2 UPLBEC 1048.
SPLA No. 1310 of 2026
3
7. Thus, it has been submitted that the view taken by the learned single judge
in Smt. Shimla Singh vs. State of U.P. and another, 2019 (3) ADJ 777 , is
described to be not consistent to the view taken by a coordinate bench in
Sunil Kumar Singh (supra) and the view taken by the Supreme Court in
.
Guru Nanak Dev University (supra)
8. As to the decision in UPSSSC vs. Ashok Yadav and others, SCC
, it has been stressed, while certain observations may exist
OnLine SC 1893
in paragraph 22 of the said decision - that may be read in favor of the
petitioners-respondents, at the same time, they may not be beneficial to the
present petitioners-respondents, inasmuch as they had not followed the
procedure prescribed to raise objections to the provisional answer key. To
the extent petitioners-respondents have not raised any objection to the
questions nos. 36 and 37, they cannot be granted any benefit, at this stage.
9. On the other hand, learned counsel for the petitioners-respondents
contends, there is no error in the order of the learned single judge. Though
the petitioners-respondents may not have filed any objections to the
provisional answer key, once on the own appraisal made by the
Commission, it reached a firm conclusion that more than one answer
response - to question nos. 36 and 37 were correct, the only prudent course
open to the Commission may have been, to award full marks to all
candidates or to exclude those questions for the purpose of award of marks,
in that regard.
10. Further, the petitioners have not had an occasion or opportunity to object
to the correctness of question nos. 36 and 37. Though mistakenly, they were
under an impression (at the time of publication of provisional answer key),
that the answer responses (as disclosed by the Commission), were the only
correct answer response, to those questions. Even though the answer
responses marked by them were shown to be incorrect (as per the provisional
answer key), they did not doubt the correctness of the provisional answer
key. They learnt that the two answer responses to both question nos. 36 and
37 are correct, only after declaration of the final result. At that stage, no
opportunity survived to the petitioners-respondents to file any further
objections. The only course open to them was to file the present writ. That
they did, without laches.
SPLA No. 1310 of 2026
4
11. On the merit issue, relying heavily on the observations made by this
Court in paragraph 22 of Ashok Yadav (supra) , it has been submitted - that
being the latest pronouncement of the law by the Supreme Court, it leaves no
doubt, that on due application of the law, in Ran Vijay Singh and others
, where two correct answers
vs. State of U.P. and others, (2018) 2 SCC 357
exist to any question, against the requirement to mark only one correct
answer, the Court may interfere and order exclusion of the suspect or
offending question from evaluation.
12. Then relying on the decision of a coordinate bench to which one of us
(Saumitra Dayal Singh,J.) was a member, in State of U.P. and others vs.
, it has been submitted
Akhilesh Kumar Yadav, 2025:AHC:227397-DB
that in similar facts, where it was admitted that two answer responses were
correct, (in place of only one correct answer response), applying equitable
principle, the decision of the learned single judge granting benefit to all
candidates, (as has been done in the present case), was affirmed.
13. In so far as the decision of the coordinate bench in Sunil Kumar Singh
is concerned, that decision is described to have been set aside by the
(supra)
Supreme Court on a reasoning that the High Court had erred in exercising
the judicial review. Thus, even though the correctness of the reasoning of the
coordinate bench as to the principle to be applied for award of marks where
more than one answer response may be correct, was not considered, once the
decision has been set aside in entirety, it may not carry precedential value.
14. In so far as the decision of the Supreme Court in
Guru Nanak Dev
University (supra) is concerned, that was a case where marks had been
awarded to such students who had not even attempted the disputed
questions. Here, the petitioners had attempted the disputed questions.
15. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and having perused the
records, we are not in a position to accept the first objection as to laches.
Petitioners-respondents, first gained knowledge of the material fact giving
rise to the writ petition, only on the declaration of the final answer key,
along with the result. At that stage, they had no opportunity to file any other
or further objection. Till then, though mistakenly, they were laboring under
the belief that question nos. 36 and 37 were wholly valid. Even though, they
had marked either of the two correct answer responses, as correct, they had
SPLA No. 1310 of 2026
5
marked another answer response, as correct, against both questions.
16. They first gained knowledge that there were two correct answer
responses at the stage of publication of the final result, and not earlier. The
Commission had itself published only one answer response each (as correct),
against both question nos. 36 and 37, at the stage of publication of the
provisional answer key. Therefore, the petitioners-respondents had no
occasion to suspect or know that there was any fundamental error in the
framing of either question no. 36 or 37. That fact first became known to
them on the declaration of the final answer key/master set. That happened
along with the declaration of results on 26th August, 2026. Thus, the cause
of action first arose to the petitioners on 26th August, 2026 and not earlier.
On that day, clearly the petitioners had no right or opportunity to file any
objections before the Commission. Having filed the writ petitions promptly,
they cannot be non-suited for reason of objections not raised at an earlier
point of time. Thus, we do not find it a fit case to apply the later part of the
observations contained in the Ashok Yadav (supra) , wherein, it has been
observed as below:
22. The legal position that emerges from the aforesaid decision(s) is that
"
a challenge to the correctness of answer key must be entertained only
where the mistake is so glaring and apparent that no inferential process
or reasoning is required to show that the mistake exists. Besides, while
considering a challenge to the correctness of a question or an answer, the
court must bear in mind that there is a presumption about the correctness
of the question/answer, and the onus is on the candidate to demonstrate
that it is incorrect. Further, in the event of a mere doubt about the
correctness of the question or the answer, the benefit should go to the
examining body and not to the candidate. However, where it is
demonstrated that the question itself is incorrect, or there could be two
correct answers to the question when only one is to be chosen from the
options provided, the Court may interfere and order exclusion of the
suspect or offending question from evaluation.........."
emphasis supplied
17. Then, in , the Supreme Court had made the
Ashok Yadav (supra)
following observations.
SPLA No. 1310 of 2026
6
"......... In a situation where the question is correct and is admissible to
only one answer and that answer is amongst the options provided but is
not the one chosen by the examining body, the Court may direct the
examining body to award marks only for the correct answer and revise
the result accordingly. While entertaining a petition in such matters,
courts must be strict in the condoning laches, if any, having regard to the
ensuing consequences. Besides, the court may reject a challenge if the
procedure prescribed to raise objection(s) to the question/ answer, within
may a specified time frame, is not followed."
emphasis supplied.
18. As to the merit objections, the decision of the Supreme Court in
Guru
Nanak Dev University (supra) may not apply to the present fact. The
present is not a case of selection but only of qualification at TET. No job
opportunity is secured solely on the strength of marks obtained at the
examination. In , the selection was for
Guru Nanak Dev University (supra)
the admission to medical course. More substantively, the rule applied by the
Supreme Court in that case would apply to cases where a candidate may not
have attempted a question at all. In para-12 of the report, it has been
observed as below:-
"12. There is yet another problem, namely, that of seven questions which
are so vague that they are incapable of having a correct answer. The
appellant University, in respect of those seven questions, has given the
credit to all the students who had participated in the entrance test
irrespective of whether someone had answered the questions or not. We
do not think that that is the proper course to follow. It is wholly unfair to
give marks to a student who did not even attempt to answer those
questions. This course would mean that a student who did not answer say
all the seven questions would still get 28 marks, each correct answer
having four marks. The reasonable procedure to be followed, in our
opinion, would be to give credit only to those who attempted the said
questions or some of them. Having regard to the circumstances of the
case, we direct that for the students who attempted those questions or
some of those questions, insofar as they are concerned, the said questions
should not be treated to be part of the question paper. To illustrate, if a
SPLA No. 1310 of 2026
7
student answered all the said seven vague questions, insofar as that
student is concerned, total marks would be counted out of 772 i.e. 800
less 28 and likewise depending upon number of such questions, if any,
answered by the student. The seven vague questions are Question 4 in
Physics, Questions 76 and 89 in Chemistry, Questions 147 and 148 in
Botany and Questions 156 and 163 in Zoology of Question Paper Code
A."
emphasis supplied
19. Reading the two decisions of the Supreme Court together, we conclude -
subject to delay and laches, wherever more than one answer response to a
multiple choice question may be found correct, the Court may interfere in
exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India. While granting relief it may order exclusion of a suspect question
or provide for award of equal marks to all candidates.
20. The decision in the case of and
Priti Singh (supra) Uday Bhan Yadav
(supra) do not apply to present facts, inasmuch as in those cases the issue
was with respect to the correctness of the answer responses to which no
objection had been raised at the appropriate time. Issue of two correct
answer responses, was not involved in those cases. Therefore, they stand
distinguished.
21. At the same time, where a candidate may not have attempted such
question at all, he may be deprived of benefit of Guru Nanak Dev
and . To that extent, the
University (supra) Ashok Yadav (supra)
observations of the coordinate bench, in Akhilesh Kumar Yadav (supra) ,
may not apply by way of an absolute principle in law, but the issue may
remain to be tested in individual facts, in line with the above noted decisions
of the Supreme Court in
Guru Nanak Dev University (supra); Ran Vijay
Singh (supra) and Ashok Yadav (supra) . Last, the decision of the
coordinate bench in may not carry any
Sunil Kumar Singh (supra)
precedential value, as that decision has been set aside, even though on
another point.
22. Consequently, we do not find any merit in the substantive challenge
raised, at the same time, considering the fact that the final result has already
SPLA No. 1310 of 2026
8
been declared, and besides the four petitioners-respondents before us, no
other candidate may have challenged the declaration of the result, we
accordingly modify the relief granted by the writ Court, as below:
i) The results of all candidates who may have been declared passed on
declaration of result, on 26th, August 26, shall remain unaffected by this
order.
ii) With respect to remaining candidates - not declared successful, till now,
the Commission may revise their results, as below. To the extent the
Commission has already awarded one mark each to the candidates who have
marked either of the two correct answer responses to question nos. 36 and
37, consistent thereto we provide that the Commission may award one mark
each against any answer response given by such candidates, to question nos.
36 and 37, in line with the decision of the Supreme Court in
Guru Nanak
Dev University (supra).
iii) We clarify, wherever candidate may not have attempted either question
nos. 36 or 37, that candidate may not be awarded any additional mark/s.
23. Such further/supplementary result may be prepared and declared
preferably, within a period of one month from today with liberty to approach
the Court, if any further time is required.
24. Accordingly, the Special Appeal is partly allowed .
(Swarupama Chaturvedi,J.) (Saumitra Dayal Singh,J.)
November 17, 2026
Sartaj
Digitally signed by :-
SARTAJ AHMAD
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad