Committee Of Management Mumford Civil Court Club And 2 Others vs State Of U.P. And 4 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - C No. - 46175 of 2026
Committee Of Management Mumford Civil Court
Club And 2 Others
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P. And 4 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Ambuj Mishra, Rajesh Kumar Shukla,
Sr. Advocate
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C., Pooja Agarwal
Court No. - 38 AFR
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH NANDAN, J.
1. Sri Vaibhav Shandilya, Advocate, has put in appearance on behalf of
respondent no. 5, which is taken on record.
2. Heard Sri Anil Bhushan, Senior Advocate, assisted by Sri Ambuj
Mishra, learned counsel for the petitioners, Sri Vivek Shandilya, Senior
Advocate assisted by Sri Vaibhav Shandilya and Sri Anshuman Mishra,
learned counsel for respondent no. 5, and learned Standing Counsel for
the State respondents.
3. The contention of Sri Anil Bhushan, learned Senior Counsel, is that the
impugned order dated 05.08.2026 has been passed by the Additional Sub-
Divisional Magistrate, whereas the State Government, vide notification
dated 28.10.1975, published in the U.P. Gazette dated 28.10.1975, has
authorised the Sub-Divisional Magistrate as the Prescribed Authority in
exercise of the powers under the Explanation to Section 25 of the
Societies Registration Act, 1860 (Act No. 21 of 1860), as amended in its
application to Uttar Pradesh by the Societies Registration (Uttar Pradesh
Amendment) Act, 1975 (U.P. Act No. 52 of 1975). He further contends
that the powers could not have been delegated to the Additional Sub-
Divisional Magistrate and, in view of the aforesaid, the order dated
05.08.2026 has been passed without jurisdiction.
4. Per contra, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of private
respondent no. 5 submits that the petitioners have also filed an appeal

WRIC No. 46175 of 2026
2
against the consequential order dated 17.10.2026. However, he could not
dispute the fact that the Prescribed Authority notified by the State
Government is the Sub-Divisional Magistrate.
5. In response to the aforesaid, Sri Anil Bhushan, learned Senior Counsel,
submits that there are no disputed questions of fact and that a purely legal
question has been raised by the petitioners as to whether the powers
exercisable by the S.D.M. under Section 25(1) of the Act can be delegated
to the Additional S.D.M.
6. In order to buttress his arguments, he relies upon a decision of this
Court in the case of Jai Prakash Agarwal v. Prescribed
Authority/S.D.M. Sadar, Deoria, in Special Appeal No. 940 of 1998,
reported in 1999 (1) UPLBEC 697 wherein the Division Bench has
specifically held that the Prescribed Authority under Section 25 of the Act
, is a Tribunal and possesses the trappings of a Court.
7. Section 25 of the Society Registration Act, as amended by the State
Legislature, is a comprehensive code and creates a designated forum or
Tribunal, for the summary adjudication of all disputes or doubts in respect
of the election or continuance in office of the office-bearers of such
society. It also provides the grounds on which the election of the office-
bearers can be set aside, as well as the consequences arising from the
adjudication under Section 25(1) of the Act.
8. In view of the creation of a specific forum under Section 25 of the Act
and the exhaustive procedure prescribed for determination of the issues
contemplated thereunder, such disputes can be determined by the said
forum in the manner prescribed under the statute.
9. In view of the aforesaid, the Division Bench, having referred to the
notification dated 28.10.1975, had arrived at a specific conclusion that the
determination of disputes contemplated under the Act, more particularly
election disputes, has to be made in the manner prescribed thereunder. As
such, disputes relating to the election or continuance in office of the
office-bearers of a Society, registered under the Societies Registration Act
in the State of U.P., have to be adjudicated by the Prescribed Authority
under Section 25(1) of the Act and not by any other authority. For ready

WRIC No. 46175 of 2026
3
reference para 12 in the case of is
Jai Prakash Agarwal (Supra)
reproduced below:-
"(12) Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the order of the Prescribed
authority ts not final and suit can be filed challenging the same, hence he decides the
dispute administratively and not judicially. We are not prepared to accept this
submission. Prescribed authority under section 25 of the Act decides the dispute
judicially and in exercise of the inherent judicial. powers of the State. This position is
not in any way diluted because against the order of the prescribed authority, a suit
may be filed in the civil court. If this test is accepted, then no Court can exercise
inherent judicial power of the State because orders can be challenged in appeal or
revision or before this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution. Finality of the
order has to be judged from the effect of it on the rights of parties, if the order is not
challenged further. In such a situation, it should finally resolve the dispute between
parties. In our considered opinion, the prescribed authority is a tribunal and
possesses the trappings of the Court. A Division Bench of this Court in All India
Council and another (supra) held in paragraph Nos. 6 and 7 as under: "the
petitioners are clearly right. Section 25 of the Societies Registration Act as amended
by the state Legislature enacts a comprehensive Code and creates a designated forum
or tribunal for adjudication in a summary manner of all disputes or doubts in respect
of the election or continuance in office of an office-bearer of such society. It also
provides the grounds upon which the election of an office bearer can be set aside. The
procedure to be followed for filling up of the vacancies arising from the decisions
rendered by the Prescribed authority under subsection (1) of Section 25 has also been
laid down (Section 25 (2)). It will, therefore, be seen that insofar as disputes or doubts
in respect of the election or continuance in office of the office-bearers of a Society
registered in Uttar Pradesh are concerned the Legislature has created a specific
forum and laid down an exhaustive procedure for determination of the same under
Section 25. There is no other provisions, express or otherwise, providing for
determination of such disputes specifically. It is settled law that where, as here, the
legislature creates a specific forum and lays an exhaustive procedure for
determination of a particular class of disputes in respect of matters covered by the
statute. Such disputes can be determined only in that forum and in the manner
prescribed thereunder and not otherwise. If, therefore, a dispute is raised with regard
to the election or continuance in office of an office-bearer of a society registered in
Uttar Pradesh, the same has to be decided only by the prescribed authority under
Section 25 (1) and not by the Registrar, save, of course, to the decision of the

WRIC No. 46175 of 2026
4
Prescribed authority being subject to the result of a civil suit."
10. In view of the facts and circumstances stated hereinabove, this Court
is of the opinion that once the S.D.M. has been notified as the Prescribed
Authority under Section 25 of the Act, 1860, vide U.P. Gazette
Notification dated 28.10.1975, in the absence of any enabling provision
for delegation of powers, the notified Prescribed Authority can neither
delegate its powers to the Additional S.D.M., Bulandshahar, under
Section 25(1) of the Act, 1860, nor can the Additional S.D.M. exercise
any powers as the Prescribed Authority under Section 25 of the Act.
11. At this stage, Sri Vivek Shandilya, learned Senior Counsel appearing
on behalf of respondent no. 5 submits that the impugned order dated
05.08.2026 and the consequential order dated 17.10.2026 may be set
aside, without prejudice to his rights to contest the matter before the
Prescribed Authority, and that the matter may be directed to be decided
by the Prescribed Authority afresh, and to which the learned Standing
Counsel also has no objection.
12. Considering, since one of the complainants is represented by learned
counsel, i.e., respondent no. 5, service of notice upon respondent no. 4 is
dispensed with and with the consent of the parties, the present writ
petition is being decided at the admission stage itself. However, in case
respondent no. 4 has any objection to the same, he shall have the liberty to
approach this Court within a period of one month from today.
13. In view of the aforesaid, with the consent of the parties, the impugned
order dated 05.08.2026 and the consequential order dated 17.02.2026 are
hereby set aside, with a direction to the Prescribed Authority under
Section 25(1) of the Act, 1860, to decide the reference under Section
25(1) of the Act, 1860, expeditiously, preferably within a period of two
months from the date of service of the certified copy of this order, strictly
in accordance with law, adhering to the principles of natural justice and
affording due opportunity of hearing to respondents nos. 4 and 5.
14. It is made clear that this Court does not express any opinion on the
merits of the case.

WRIC No. 46175 of 2026
5
15. With the aforesaid observations and directions, the writ petition stands
disposed off.
(Siddharth Nandan,J.)
November 16, 2026
piyush
Digitally signed by :-
PIYUSH KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad