Shankar Lall Agrawal vs The State Bank of India

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.15466 of 2023
======================================================
Shankar Lall Agrawal Son of Late Sohan Lall Agrawal, resident of Ward No.
1, P.S. Kamalpokhari, District Kathmandu (Nepal).
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State Bank of India through its Chairman, M. C. Road, Nariman Point,
Mumbai.
2. The Chairman, State Bank of India, Banking Operation Department,
National Banking Group, State Bank Bhawan, Mumbai.
3. The Chief General Manager State Bank of India, Banking Operation
Department, National Banking Group, State Bank Bhawan, Mumbai.
4. The Chief General Manager, State Bank of India, LHO, Patna.
5. The Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Jogbani Branch, Jogbani,
District- Araria.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : M/s Mrigank Mauli, Sr. Advocate
Sanket
Navin Kumar Singh, Advocates
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Sanjiv Kumar, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. G. ANUPAMA CHAKRAVARTHY
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 05-08-2026
1. The petitioner has filed the Writ petition
for the following reliefs:
“(a) For direction upon the Respondent
Branch Manager, Jogbani Branch, Araria
to return the matured value of three
Term Deposits bearing TDR/STIR No.
926482 amounting to Rs. 12,00,372/-,
TDR/STIR No. 926483 amounting to Rs.
13,59,826/- & TDR/STIR No. 926484
amounting to Rs. 13,59,826/- along with

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
2/21
interest @ 18% per annum since the
date of its maturity 21.11.2003 till the
date of its paymentas the same has
been arbitrarily & illegally withheld by
the Respondent Bank and has not been
paid to the Petitioner till date despite
repeated requests by the Petitioner;
(b) For a direction upon the respondents
to release the maturity proceeds with
interest of the said three TDR/STDR to
the Petitioner as Petitioner is the only
surviving holder of the three TDR/STIR
and as such entitled for the release of
the same in his favor, and/or for any
other relief or reliefs to which the
petitioner is found entitled in the facts
and circumstances of this case.”
2. The brief facts culled out of the
petition are that the petitioner, a citizen of Nepal,
has filed the present Writ petition seeking direction
to the respondent-State Bank of India for release of
the maturity proceeds of three Term Deposit
Receipts (TDRs/STDRs) along with interest. The
petitioner states that he had invested a total
amount of Rs. 14,41,370/-, in three TDRs/STDRs

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
3/21
bearing Nos. 926482, 926483 and 926484 dated
21.11.1993 issued by the SBI, Jogbani Branch,
jointly with his brother, namely, Ramesh Kumar
Agrawal. The deposits were made with the
mandate of “Either or Survivor”, and the maturity
date of the said deposits was 21.11.1998, which
were subsequently renewed for a further period of
five years.
3. The petitioner submits that on the
date of maturity, i.e. 21.11.2003, he approached
the respondent Bank with the original TDR
certificates for payment of the maturity amount.
Despite of the receipt of the original documents,
the Bank failed to release the maturity proceeds
and informed the petitioner that duplicate TDRs
had allegedly been issued in favour of his brother,
on the ground that the original certificates were
lost. The petitioner contends that neither he nor
his brother ever applied for issuance of duplicate
TDRs and the action of the Bank in issuing
duplicate certificates was wholly illegal and without
authority.

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
4/21
4. It is the case of the petitioner that
despite of repeated representations dated
21.11.2003, 22.11.2003 and subsequent
communications, the Bank did not release the
amount and repeatedly insisted upon the presence
of the joint holder, contrary to the mandate of
“Either or Survivor”. The petitioner submits that
the Bank also failed to provide any copy of the
alleged application for issuance of duplicate
certificates or any other document justifying
withholding of the maturity amount.
5. The Learned Senior counsel Mr.
Mrigank Mauli for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner continuously pursued the matter before
the Bank authorities and even approached the
competent authorities, including the CBI, seeking
enquiry into the alleged irregular issuance of
duplicate TDRs. It is stated that the petitioner’s
brother, who was the joint holder of the deposits,
subsequently died issueless on 03.02.2021.
According to the petitioner, after the death of his
brother, he is the sole surviving claimant, and is

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
5/21
entitled to receive the maturity amount along with
interest.
6. The Learned Senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner submits that the action
of the respondent Bank in withholding the maturity
proceeds since the year 2003 is arbitrary, illegal
and contrary to the terms and conditions of the
deposit. It is submitted that under the “Either or
Survivor” mandate, either of the deposit holders
was entitled to receive the maturity amount and
there was no requirement for the presence or
consent of the other joint holder.
7.The Learned Senior counsel further
submits that the Reserve Bank of India, by its
circular dated 04.11.2011, has clarified that in case
of deposits operated under the “Either or Survivor”
instruction, the signature or presence of both
depositors is not required for payment of the
deposit on maturity. Therefore, the insistence of
the respondent Bank for production of the joint
holder or his legal heirs is wholly unjustified.
8. The Learned Senior counsel for the

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
6/21
petitioner further submits that the Bank has failed
to produce any material to show that the duplicate
TDRs were issued on a valid application made by
the joint holder or that there existed any legal
impediment in releasing the amount to the
petitioner. It is contended that the petitioner has
been repeatedly approaching the Bank since the
date of maturity and there has been no delay or
abandonment of his claim.
9. The Learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner further submitted that the petitioner is a
senior citizen and has been deprived of his
legitimate dues for a long period without any
authority of law. Hence, the respondent Bank is
liable to release the maturity amount of the three
TDRs along with appropriate interest and the Writ
petition deserves to be allowed.
10. In support of his submissions, the
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner has relied
upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reported in (2004) 8 SCC 498 . The relevant
observations contained in paragraphs 12 and 13 of

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
7/21
the said judgment are reproduced hereunder::
"12. A fixed deposit in the joint
names of two persons is nothing but a joint
account which, as the name itself suggests,
is repayable on the expiration of the agreed
period. The fixed deposit receipt is merely a
Written acknowledgement by the bank that
it holds a certain sum to the use of its
customers. The bank is thus a debtor to the
account-holders in respect of the amount
deposited — a debt which is repayable by
the bank to the account-holders with
interest on the expiry of an agreed period.
An “either or survivor” clause in such an
account means that the amount payable by
the bank on maturity of the fixed deposit
may be paid to either of the account-holders
by the bank in order to obtain a valid
discharge. In other words, under a tripartite
agreement between the joint account-
holders inter se and the bank, the bank
may, on maturity, make payment only to
either of them. This tripartite agreement
cannot be bilaterally modified by one of the
joint account-holders for example by
pledging the account with any third party
including the bank itself in its capacity of
creditor, so that the amount becomes
payable to such third party, without the
consent of the joint account-holder. Thus in
Tannan: Banking Law and Practices in India [

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
8/21
(20th Edn.), 2001, Vol. 1, Chapter VIII, p.
259.] the legal position has been
summarised thus:
“On the view that the terms of
operation of a joint account constitute a
term of the contract of deposit, any
variation or revocation of instructions in a
joint account, whether the operation is by
‘either or survivor’ or ‘former or survivor’
can be effected only under the joint
signatures of all persons entitled to operate
the joint account. One of the joint account-
holders thus cannot unilaterally instruct the
bank not to honour cheques signed by the
others, issue duplicate deposit receipt,
premature repayment or loan against fixed
deposit.”
13. This was also held by a
Division Bench of the Lahore High Court
(Shadi Lal, C.J. and Broadway, J.) in Simla
Banking and Industrial Co. Ltd. v. Bhagwan
Kuar [AIR 1928 Lah 316] . In that case
Bhagwan Kuar and her son Raghunandan
Singh had deposited an amount with the
Bank against a fixed deposit receipt which
was payable to “either or survivor”.
Raghunandan had borrowed money from
the Bank. The Bank credited the amount
due under the fixed deposit receipt to the
overdraft account of Raghunandan.
Bhagwan Kuar thereupon filed a suit against
the Bank for recovery of the amount due.

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
9/21
The Bank pleaded a general lien and
claimed to have acted within its rights in
appropriating the amount as it had done.
The Division Bench was of the view that the
action of the Bank was neither supported by
authority nor in law nor in equity."
11. A counter affidavit was filed on
behalf of the respondents. The Learned counsel for
the respondent Bank submits that the present Writ
petition is not maintainable as the petitioner has
invoked the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court
for enforcement of a disputed money claim
involving disputed questions of fact. It is further
submitted that the petitioner has approached this
Court after an unexplained delay of about 20 years
from the date of maturity of the STDRs/TDRs and
the Writ petition is liable to be dismissed on the
ground of delay and laches.
12. The Learned counsel for the
respondents Bank submits that on maturity of the
three STDRs on 21.11.2003, the petitioner had
presented the original certificates before the Bank
for payment. The Bank had prepared banker’s

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
10/21
cheques for release of the maturity proceeds, but
before handing over the same, it was found that
duplicate STDRs had already been issued at the
request of the other joint holder, namely, Ramesh
Kumar Agarwal, who had informed the Bank that
the original certificates were lost.
13. The Learned counsel for the
respondents further submits that the Bank had
repeatedly requested the petitioner to come along
with the other joint holder for receiving the
payment. However, the petitioner never appeared
before the Bank along with the joint holder. It is
submitted that subsequently, the other joint holder
raised objection and requested the Bank not to
release the amount exclusively in favour of the
petitioner. In such circumstances, the Bank could
not make payment to either of the depositors
individually and required joint discharge or
appropriate order from the competent court.
14. The Learned counsel for the
respondents further submits that although the
deposits contained the mandate of “Either or

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
11/21
Survivor”, the said mandate stood disputed when
one of the joint depositors objected to payment in
favour of the other. Therefore, the Bank acted in
accordance with the applicable rules and did not
release the amount without resolving the dispute
between the joint holders.
15. The Learned counsel for the
respondents further submits that after the death of
the joint holder, Ramesh Kumar Agarwal, on
03.02.2021, the petitioner again approached the
Bank for payment. The Bank informed the
petitioner to either produce the consent of the
legal heirs of the deceased joint holder or obtain
an appropriate order from the competent court. It
is submitted that the Bank has even recently
requested the petitioner to receive the STDR
proceeds after furnishing the required documents,
but the petitioner refused to accept the payment
without claiming interest from the date of maturity.
16. The Learned counsel for the
respondents submits that the Bank has already
prepared banker’s cheques against the matured

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
12/21
STDRs and the amount has remained unpaid only
due to the dispute between the joint holders.
Therefore, the petitioner is not entitled to claim
interest from the date of maturity. It is further
submitted that the Bank has acted bona fide and
there is no illegality or arbitrariness in withholding
the payment under the circumstances.
17. The Learned counsel for the
respondents, therefore, submits that the Writ
petition, being devoid of merit and involving
disputed questions of fact, deserves to be
dismissed.
18. A rejoinder on behalf of the
petitioner to the counter affidavit of the
respondents was filed. The Learned Senior counsel
for the petitioner submits that the objection of the
respondent Bank regarding delay and laches is
misconceived, as the petitioner has been
continuously pursuing his claim before the Bank
since the date of maturity of the STDRs. It is
submitted that the petitioner was denied payment
on one ground or the other by the Bank authorities

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
13/21
and, therefore, there has been no negligence or
abandonment of claim on his part.
19. The Learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner further submits that the stand taken by
the Bank regarding issuance of duplicate STDRs is
not sustainable, as the petitioner had produced the
original STDR certificates before the Bank on
21.11.2003. Once the original instruments were
available with the Bank, there was no justification
for withholding the maturity proceeds on the
ground that duplicate STDRs had been issued.
20. The Learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner further submits that the Bank has taken
shifting stands for denying payment to the
petitioner. Initially, payment was refused on the
ground of issuance of duplicate STDRs, thereafter
on the ground of non-presence of the joint holder,
and subsequently on the alleged ground of family
dispute. It is submitted that there was no order of
any competent court restraining the Bank from
releasing the maturity amount, nor was any
material produced to establish any subsisting legal

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
14/21
dispute between the joint holders.
21. The Learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner submits that the STDRs were issued with
the mandate of “Either or Survivor” and, therefore,
either of the depositors was entitled to receive the
maturity proceeds. The insistence of the Bank for
the presence of the joint holder or for obtaining a
court order was contrary to the terms of the
deposit and could not have been a ground for
withholding the legitimate dues of the petitioner.
22. The Learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner further submits that the maturity
amount has remained with the respondent Bank
since 2003 and the petitioner has been deprived of
the benefit of his investment without any fault on
his part. Therefore, the petitioner is entitled to
payment of the maturity proceeds along with
appropriate interest.
23. The Learned Senior counsel lastly
submits that the petitioner, being a senior citizen,
has been made to suffer due to the inconsistent
and arbitrary stand taken by the Bank. Hence, the

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
15/21
petitioner is entitled to the reliefs prayed for in the
Writ petition.
24. Heard the Learned Senior counsel
for the petitioner and the Learned counsel for the
respondent Bank and perused the pleadings,
documents brought on record and the materials
available therein.
25. The petitioner has approached this
Court seeking direction upon the respondent-State
Bank of India for release of the maturity proceeds
of three STDRs/TDRs along with interest. It is not in
dispute that the petitioner and his brother, namely,
Ramesh Kumar Agarwal, had jointly invested in
three STDRs issued by the SBI, Jogbani Branch,
with the operating instruction of “Either or
Survivor”. It is also not in dispute that the
petitioner had produced the original STDR
certificates before the Bank on the date of
maturity, i.e. 21.11.2003.
26. The case of the petitioner is that
despite production of the original instruments, the
respondent Bank failed to release the maturity

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
16/21
amount and subsequently took different grounds
for withholding the payment, including issuance of
duplicate STDRs, non-presence of the joint holder
and alleged family dispute between the depositors.
27. On the other hand, the Learned
counsel for the respondent Bank submits that the
Bank had prepared banker’s cheques for payment
of the matured amount but could not hand over
the same as duplicate STDRs had already been
issued at the request of the other joint holder, who
subsequently objected to payment in favour of the
petitioner. It is further submitted that in view of the
objection raised by the joint holder, the Bank
required either joint discharge or an appropriate
order from the competent court.
28. Having considered the rival
submissions, this Court finds that the controversy
essentially relates to the effect of the mandate
“Either or Survivor” attached to the STDRs. The
Reserve Bank of India, by its circular dated
04.11.2011, has specifically clarified that where
fixed/term deposit accounts are opened with the

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
17/21
operating instruction “Either or Survivor”, the
signatures of both depositors are not required for
payment of the deposit amount on maturity. The
purpose of such mandate is to enable either of the
depositors to receive the maturity proceeds and to
avoid unnecessary delay and hardship to
customers.
29. In the present case, the deposits
had already matured on 21.11.2003 and the
petitioner had approached the Bank with the
original STDR certificates. The Bank has not
disputed receipt of the original instruments. The
objection raised by the Bank regarding issuance of
duplicate STDRs or subsequent objection by the
joint holder cannot override the contractual
mandate of “Either or Survivor”, particularly when
the deposits had matured and the petitioner was
one of the joint depositors.
30. The stand of the respondent Bank
that the “Either or Survivor” mandate stood
withdrawn merely because the other joint holder
raised an objection, is not supported by any

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
18/21
material placed on record. No order of any
competent court restraining the Bank from
releasing the maturity amount has been brought
on record. The Bank has also failed to demonstrate
any legal impediment which prevented it from
making payment to the petitioner in terms of the
mandate attached to the deposits.
31. The issue is no longer res integra in
view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in (2004) 8 SCC 498 . The Apex
Court has categorically held that an "Either or
Survivor" mandate forms part of the contractual
arrangement between the Bank and the joint
depositors and that the operational instructions
governing such deposits cannot be altered
unilaterally by one depositor. It has further been
held that issuance of duplicate fixed deposit
receipts or any variation in the operational
instructions can be effected only with the consent
of all the joint account holders. Therefore, the
respondent Bank cannot rely upon duplicate STDRs
allegedly issued at the unilateral request of one

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
19/21
joint depositor to defeat the contractual rights of
the other.
32. It is also evident from the materials
on record that the stand of the Bank has changed
from time to time. Initially, the payment was
withheld on the ground of issuance of duplicate
STDRs, thereafter on account of non-presence of
the joint holder, and subsequently on the ground of
alleged family dispute. Such shifting stands, in
absence of any legal restraint, cannot justify
withholding of the petitioner’s legitimate dues for a
prolonged period.
33. The contention of the respondent
Bank that the present Writ petition involves a
money claim and disputed questions of fact is also
not acceptable in the facts of the present case. The
basic facts regarding issuance of STDRs, the joint
holding, the “Either or Survivor” mandate, maturity
of the deposits and presentation of original
certificates by the petitioner are not in serious
dispute. The issue involved in the Writ petition is
primarily regarding the obligation of the Bank to

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
20/21
honour the mandate attached to the deposits.
34. So far as the claim of interest is
concerned, the petitioner has been deprived of the
use of his money since the date of maturity due to
the action of the respondent Bank. The amount has
remained with the Bank for no fault attributable to
the petitioner. Therefore, the petitioner would be
entitled to receive the maturity proceeds along
with appropriate interest in accordance with law.
35. This Court is also of the view that
the death of the other joint holder subsequently on
03.02.2021, does not defeat the claim of the
petitioner, as his right had already accrued on the
date of maturity when he had presented the
original STDRs before the Bank. The RBI guidelines
specifically clarify that payment to the survivor on
maturity cannot be denied merely on account of
the death of the other depositor.
36. In view of the aforesaid facts and
circumstances, this Court finds that the action of
the respondent Bank in withholding the maturity
proceeds of the STDRs was unjustified and

Patna High Court CWJC No.15466 of 2023 dt.05-08-2026
21/21
contrary to the mandate of “Either or Survivor” as
well as the guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank
of India.
37. Accordingly, the Writ petition is
allowed. The respondent Bank is directed to
release the maturity proceeds of the three
STDRs/TDRs in favour of the petitioner along with
interest as applicable in accordance with law from
the date the amount became payable till the date
of actual payment. The entire exercise shall be
completed within a period of three months from
the date of receipt/production of a copy of this
order.
38. Interlocutory Application(s), if any,
shall stand disposed of.

(G. Anupama Chakravarthy, J)
Spd/-
AFR/NAFR NAFR
CAV DATE NA
Uploading Date 07.08.2026
Transmission Date