Mohan Lal vs State Of Punajb & Ors
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
175
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M)
MOHAN LAL (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HIS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES
... Petitioner
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS
...Respondents
1. The date when the judgment is reserved September 23, 2026
2. The date when the judgment is pronounced November 19, 2026
3. The date when the judgment is uploaded on the website November 19, 2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced
or whether the full judgment is pronounced
Full
5. The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full judgment,
and reasons thereof
Not applicable
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA
Present: Mr. Vipin Mahajan, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Tejinder Kaur, Advocate
for the petitioner
Mr. Satjot Singh Chahal, Assistant Advocate General, Punjab.
Mr. Mandeep Singh Bedi, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Abhishek Thakur, Advocate,
Ms. Rajinder Kaur, Advocate and
Mr. Yuvraj Singh Walia, Advocate
for respondent no.4.
TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA, J.
The petition has been filed seeking a writ of mandamus directing
the respondents to execute sale/conveyance deed in favour of the petitioner
with respect to the plot allotted to him, based upon the State Government
approval given vide memo dated 12.06.1995, Annexure P-7.
2. The facts of the case in brief are, a sub-committee of the
Panchayat Samiti, Pathankot, granted license to the petitioner to do business
on a piece of land measuring 27 feet x 15 feet (405 square feet) (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the plot in question’). After about sixteen years, a resolution
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -2-
was passed by the Panchayat Samiti, dated 20.03.1978, Annexure P-2, for
giving this plot on license to him with effect from April, 1978 on payment of
license fee of ₹100 per month. The resolution also stipulated that for
constructing a roof thereon, expenses would be deferred by the petitioner and
it would vest with the Samiti on expiry of the license.
2.1. On 05.01.1994, the petitioner requested the fourth
respondent/Executive Officer, Panchayat Samiti, to allot the said plot to him
on reserve price. The Executive Officer, vide letter dated 28.01.1994,
Annexure P-3, requested the third respondent/Controller, Panchayat (Funds),
Department of Rural Development and Panchayat, to consider allotment of
the said plot to the petitioner on market/reserve price of ₹42,000. The matter
was sent to the Government. In response, Special Secretary to Government of
Punjab, Department of Rural Development and Panchayat, asked the fourth
respondent vide letter dated 20.01.1995, Annexure P-5, to take further action
in the matter according to the resolution passed keeping in view the provision
of Section 137 of the Punjab Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 (for short, ‘the 1994
Act’). The Panchayat Samiti in turn, vide resolution no.98 dated 05.05.1995,
Annexure R-4/3, conveyed that it had no objection in case the plot in question
was given to the petitioner on reserve price. It requested the Government to
give sanction for selling it on reserve price as per Section 137 of the 1994 Act.
The said resolution is as under:
The Financial Commissioner, Department of Rural
Development and Panchayats Punjab vide its letter No. 9/52/92-
BLJ-2/809 dated 20/1/95 has written that the allotment of plot
on reserve price to Shri Mohan Lal son of Sadhu Ram be
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -3-
considered and action be taken under Section 137 of the Punjab
Panchayati Raj Act, 1994. Shri Mohan Lal son of Sadhu Ram
has helped the Zila Parishad in obtaining possession of valuable
land of Panchayat Samiti Pathankot and the elected Panchayat
Samiti had agreed to give this plot @ Rs 100/- per month as
reward from April, 1978. Shri Mohan Lal has requested that
every year rent is being increased and he has spent quite a lot
on raising construction on empty plot. It is meaning less to give
this kind of reward. Assessment of this plot has been got done
from Raj Kanwar and Associates, Chartered Accountant who
has assessed Rs 42000/- as its price. The Chief Minister, Punjab
vide his order dated 11/1/94 has asked to give this land on
reserve price.
Keeping in view the above said, The Panchayat Samiti
Pathankot has no objection to this in case this plot is given to
Shri Mohan Lal son of Sadhu Ram on reserve price through this
resolution the Govt. is requested to give sanction as per Section
137 of the Punjab Panchayat Samiti and Zila Parishad Act, 1994
for selling it out on reserve price.
Submitted for approval.
Sd/-
Executive Officer,
Panchayat Samiti, Pathankot
Approved. Sanction of Govt. be taken.
Sd/-
Administrator
05.05.1995
2.2. At the time the aforesaid resolution dated 05.05.1995 was passed
by the Samiti, its affairs were being managed by the fourth respondent, as the
elections had not taken place. Keeping this fact in view, the Government
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -4-
considered the resolution and granted conditional approval for allotment of
the plot vide memo dated 12.06.1995, in relaxation of provisions of Rules 4(2)
and 5 of the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads (Sale, Lease and
other Alienation of Property and Public Places) Rules, 1964 (for short, ‘the
1964 Rules’). The memo reads as under:
Approval is hereby accorded under Section 137 of the
Punjab Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 for the allotment of land
measuring 27 x 15 feet, to Shri Mohan Lal, son of Shri Sadhu
Ram, on payment of Rs.42,000/- or the amount which the
Tehsildar, Pathankot, may determine, whichever is more, subject
to the condition that the elected Panchayat Samiti of Pathankot
shall pass a resolution for the sale of this plot. The Panchayat
Samiti shall obtain a clear approval of the Government before
executing a Sale Deed with respect to this plot in favour of Shri
Mohan Lal, son of Shri Sadhu Ram.
This approval is accorded in relaxation of the provisions
of Rules 4(2) and 5 of the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila
Parishads (Sale, Lease and other Alienation of Property and
Public Places) Rules, 1964.
2.3. Pursuant to the said decision of the Government, the fourth
respondent vide memo dated 15.04.1996, Annexure P-11, asked the petitioner
to deposit ₹1,08,000 for the plot in question at the rate of ₹60,000 per marla,
as determined by the Tehsildar, so that the plot could be allotted to him and
further action for registration of sale deed be initiated. The petitioner
deposited the amount by way of a demand draft, vide letter dated 24.04.1996,
Annexure P-12, which was received by the Accountant on 30.04.1996, as
endorsed thereupon.
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -5-
2.4. Thereafter, the elected Panchayat Samiti passed another
resolution dated 16.01.1997, Annexure P-16, unanimously authorising the
fourth respondent to execute the sale deed. The resolution reads as under:
15. In view of the Government approval contained in letter
N.o.12300, dated 12.06.1995 amended by letter No. 25121, dated
26.07.1996, the amount of Rs.1,48,800/- on account of the price
of the land measuring 558 square feet, at the rate of Rs.60,000/-
per Marla, as determined by the Tehsilder, having been deposited
with the Panchayat Samiti as per Receipt No.64/42, dated
03.05.1996 and receipt No.61/44, dated 27.08.1996 which are
hereby confirmed, the Executive Officer is hereby unanimously
authorised to execute the Sale Deed.
Sd/-
Chairperson,
Panchayat Samiti, Pathankot.
The fourth respondent in turn vide letter dated 06.02.1997, Annexure P-17,
sent the attested copy of the resolution to the Department of Rural
Development and Panchayats (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Department’),
requesting him to accord approval for execution of sale deed in favour of the
petitioner.
2.5. On 20.05.1996, the petitioner gave representation that he was in
possession of an additional one hundred and fifty-three square feet of land,
more than what the Government had decided to allot him and, accordingly,
that land should also be allotted. The fourth respondent worked out price of
that additional land at the rate of ₹60,000 per marla and the petitioner was
called upon to deposit ₹40,800 more, vide letter dated 26.07.1996, Annexure
P-14; the amount was accordingly deposited vide receipt dated 27.08.1996,
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -6-
Annexure P-15. The petitioner’s prayer for this additional land was, however,
declined by the Division Bench vide order dated 06.04.1999, when the matter
was taken up for preliminary hearing; the notice of motion was issued only
with respect to the plot in question.
2.6. The Department vide memo dated 24.09.1997, Annexure R-4/4,
objected to the Panchayat Samiti resolution no.15 dated 16.01.1997 on the
ground that it did not bear signatures of all the members and had been signed
only by the Chairperson. The Samiti was, therefore, directed to re-send the
same after obtaining signatures of all the members.
2.7. In response thereto, the fourth respondent vide letter dated
01.10.1997, Annexure R-4/5, informed that signatures of members of the
Pachayat Samiti appeared at one place only showing their presence. But the
approval was still not accorded.
2.8. Realising that there was no progress in the matter of allotment,
the petitioner submitted an application to the Minister of Rural Development
and Panchayat dated 15.05.1998, Annexure P-18, explaining the facts of
allotment as well as the Government sanction, and requested to issue a
direction to execute the sale deed of the plot for which the sale consideration
had already been deposited by him. The application was endorsed to the
Department, which accordingly considered the matter of allotment of the
plot/land of the Panchayat Samiti and rejected the same vide memo dated
05.08.1998, Annexure P-19, on the following grounds:
With reference to the subject cited above your application
is not in accord with the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -7-
Parishads (Sale, Lease and Other Alienations of Property and
Public Places) Rules, 1964, read with First Amendment Rules,
1984. Hence it is rejected.
2.9. The Panchayat Samiti, thereupon, returned the consideration
amount of ₹1,34,867 (after adjusting the license fee) to the petitioner vide
cheque dated 09.03.1999, Annexure P-20, though it was never encashed by
him. He, thereafter, filed the writ petition.
3. In this factual background, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner contended that once the decision to allot the plot in question to the
petitioner had been taken by the Panchayat Samiti vide a unanimously
resolution, with approval of the Government, the permission for execution of
the sale deed could not have been refused by the Department on the specious
plea that the resolution had not been signed by all the members. Once the
Chairperson of the Executive Committee had signed the resolution under his
own hand, and the fact of it having been properly passed was certified by the
fourth respondent also, there was no reason for the Department to disbelieve
the same. Besides, the resolution was in terms of the 1994 Act as well as 1964
Rules, which permitted the Samiti to dispose of any property with the previous
sanction of the Government. Further, he contended that the petitioner is in
possession of the plot for more than fifty-five years. He is running business
from there and has also paid market price of the plot as assessed by the
Tehsildar. All this entitles him to the plot in question.
4. Learned senior counsel for the respondents, on the contrary,
contended that the said resolution passed by the Panchayat Samiti was not
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -8-
signed by all its members and, therefore, could not be accepted as a resolution
of the Samiti consisting of the Chairperson as well as its members. The record
of the Samiti resolutions, viz., ‘Panchayat Samiti Pathankot Proceedings
Register with effect from 17.06.1996’ [produced in the Court] also establishes
that none of the members signed the resolution. Therefore, the Government
rightly rejected the proposal to allot the plot to the petitioner. Further, it has
been contended that under Section 137 of the 1994 Act, the Panchayat Samiti
could dispose of the property only on prior approval of the Government which
was never granted. At the time of passing the resolution dated 05.05.1995,
there was no elected Samiti in existence. The resolution was signed only by
the fourth respondent and approved by the Administrator. Resultantly, it could
not have been acted upon by the Government. Similarly, the later resolution
dated 01.10.1997 was also not signed by all the elected members of the
Panchayat Samiti, which was a mandatory condition of approval of the
allotment in terms of memo dated 12.06.1995. Accordingly, the petitioner
cannot be held entitled to allotment of the plot on the basis of such a
resolution.
5. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have been
considered.
6. It is evident on record that the decision to allot the plot in
question to the petitioner was taken by the Panchayat Samiti vide resolution
dated 05.05.1995, pursuant to an order by the then Chief Minister of
the State, dated 11.01.1994, to give the plot to him on reserve price. As per
provisions of Section 137 of the 1994 Act, prior approval of the Government
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -9-
is required to dispose of the property belonging to the Samiti. Accordingly,
the Samiti vide the said resolution also asked the Government to approve the
allotment. Since there was no elected body/Samiti at the time the resolution
was passed, the Government granted approval for allotment vide letter dated
12.06.1995 subject to two conditions; that the elected Panchayat Samiti shall
pass a resolution for sale of the plot, and clearance of the Government will be
obtained before executing the sale deed. This approval was in relaxation of
provisions of Rules 4(2) and 5 of the 1964 Rules. The price of the plot was
determined in terms of the sanction granted and was deposited by the
petitioner too. Thereafter, the Samiti passed another resolution dated
16.01.1997, confirming the deposit and authorizing the fourth respondent to
execute the sale deed. The resolution was signed by its Chairperson and sent
to the Government seeking approval for execution of the sale deed in the
petitioner’s favour. It was objected to by the Government vide memo dated
24.09.1997, on the ground that it did not bear signatures of members of the
Panchayat Samiti. And a direction was issued to resend the same after
obtaining the signatures, which was never done. Instead, a letter was sent by
the fourth respondent dated 01.10.1997, informing that signatures of members
of the Panchayat Samiti were taken to mark their presence only. But it appears
this explanation was not accepted, as the approval to execute the sale deed
was not granted. In these circumstances, the petitioner pursued the matter
himself by submitting an application to the Minister concerned dated
15.05.1998, seeking directions for execution of the sale deed. Thereupon, the
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -10-
proposal for allotment of plot to the petitioner was finally rejected by the
Government, vide letter dated 05.08.1998.
6.1. It, therefore, remains undisputed that the conditions of sanction
to allot the plot to the petitioner in terms of letter dated 12.06.1995, were not
complied with. Undisputedly, a resolution for allotment duly signed by the
members of the Panchayat Samiti was never submitted to the Government for
approval. And it has not been shown by the petitioner that signatures of the
Samiti members on any such resolution was not a requirement under the
statute. The proposal was, accordingly, rejected by the Government vide
memo dated 05.08.1998. No exception can be taken to it, firstly , because one
of the conditions of sanction has not been complied with, and secondly , there
is no challenge to the order of rejection dated 05.08.1998.
7. Still further, as already mentioned, under Section 137 of the 1994
Act power of the Panchayat Samiti to acquire and dispose of the property is
subject to previous approval of the State Government. The provision reads as
under:
137. Power of Panchayat Samiti to acquire hold and disposed
of property. -- (1) A Panchayat Samiti shall have the power to
acquire, hold, dispose of property and to enter into contracts:
Provided that in all cases of acquisition or disposal of
immovable property the Panchayat Samiti shall obtain the
previous approval of the State Government.
This is to be read with the 1964 Rules laying down that a Samiti shall not
ordinarily sell any property belonging to it if the same can be leased out or
profitably maintained; relevant Rules whereof are as follows:
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -11-
4. (1) A Panchayat Samiti or a Zila Parishad shall not ordinarily
sell any property or public place belonging to or vested in it, if it
can be leased out or profitably maintained:
“Provided that the previous sanction shall be obtained of -
(i) the Deputy Commissioner, if the value of the property or
public place does not exceed ten thousand rupees :
(ii) the Commissioner, if the value of the property or public
place exceeds ten thousand rupees, but does not exceed
fifty thousand rupees; and
(iii) the Government, if the value of the property or public
place exceeds fifty thousand rupees.
(2) All sales shall be by auction after giving publicity as laid
down in rule.
5. When any property or public place is to be sold or given
on lease, the Panchayat Samiti or the Zila Parishad shall publicise
an auction notice in at least one Regional Language Newspaper
and by displaying the auction notice at conspicuous places in the
Samitis area and the headquarter town of the Zila Parishad and
outside the offices of the Panchayat Samiti and Zila Parishad and
in such other manner as may be considered useful by the
Chairman, Panchayat Samiti or Zila Parishad.
6. If a Panchayat Samiti or a Zila Parishad wishes to dispose
of any property or public place in any manner otherwise than by
sale or lease, it shall obtain the previous sanction of the
[Government] after giving details of the proposed transaction.
7. [No Sanction for the sale, lease or other disposition of the
property or public place shall be accorded] under Rules 3, 4 and
6, if such sale, lease or other disposition is not in the interest of
the Panchayat Samiti or Zila Parishad, as the case may be, or
causes inconvenience to the public.
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -12-
7.1. As per sub-rule (2) to Rule 4, in case the property is to be sold in
a given circumstance, it shall only be by auction after giving due publicity as
laid down in Rule 5. Rule 6 is to the effect that in case a Samiti or a Zila
Parishad wishes to dispose of its property in any manner otherwise than by
sale or lease, for instance by allotment, it shall obtain previous sanction of the
Government. Further, Rule 7 is to the effect that no sanction for sale, lease or
disposing of the property shall be accorded under the aforesaid Rules, unless
it is in the interest of the Samiti or the Parishad, as the case may be. So far as
the facts of the instant case are concerned, the reasons mentioned in the
resolution dated 05.05.1995 do not even prima facie indicate that the
allotment of plot to the petitioner is in the Samiti’s interests. And the second
resolution dated 16.01.1997 is completely silent in this regard; it only
authorises the fourth respondent to execute the sale deed, after confirming
receipt of the determined amount from the petitioner pursuant to the
conditional approval dated 12.06.1995. The reason assigned in the former
resolution is that the petitioner helped the Zila Parishad in obtaining
possession of some valuable land of the Panchayat Samiti and, therefore, as a
reward the latter agreed to give the plot in question to him on rent from April,
1978 onwards. But he was dissatisfied with the reward and considered it
meaningless because the rent was being increased from time to time. He,
accordingly, moved an application to the Chief Minister requesting for
allotment of the plot on reserve price in view of exigencies of his business, as
averred in the petition. Accepting the request, the Chief Minister directed vide
order dated 11.01.1994 that the plot be given to him on reserve price, and the
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-4562-1999 (O&M) -13-
aforesaid resolution was passed. Therefore, the entire exercise of allotment of
plot to the petitioner does not involve any interest of the Panchayat Samiti.
Instead, the decision has been taken keeping in view his own business
interests, and for such a purpose sanction for disposing of the plot could not
have been accorded by the Government under Rule 7 of the 1964 Rules, as
discussed hereinbefore. Accordingly, on this account also, no exception can
be taken to the Government’s decision to disapprove the allotment.
8. In view of the discussion, there is no merit in the petition and it
is hereby dismissed.
9. Pending application(s), if any, also stand(s) disposed of.
November 19, 2026 (TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA)
Jaspreet Kaur JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
JASPREET KAUR
2026.11.19 11:14
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document