RAVI S/O MAHADEVAPPA BHATTA vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
ND
DATED THIS THE 2 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.200167 OF 2018
(374(Cr.PC)/415(BNSS))
BETWEEN:
RAVI
S/O MAHADEVAPPA BHATTA,
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS,
OCC: PRIVATE WORK,
R/O. NIMBAL,
TQ. ALAND,
DIST. KALABURAGI.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. MAHANTESH H. DESAI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
MADANHIPPARGA POLICE STATION,
TQ. ALAND, DIST. KALABURAGI-585103.
REP. BY SPP, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH, KALABURAGI
Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
2. KAVITA D/O DATTAPPA THAKKA,
AGE: 44 YEARS,
R/O. NIMBAL VILLAGE, TQ. ALAND,
DIST. KALABURAGI.
AMENDED AS PER ORDER OF
COURT DATED.16.10.2026
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ANILKUMAR NAVADAGI, ADDL.SPP, FOR R1;
R2 IS SERVED)
THIS CRL.A. IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374 (2) OF
CR.P.C., PRAYING TO
(A) CALL FOR THE LOWER COURT RECORDS, ADMIT THE
APPEAL.
(B) SET ASIDE THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT OF
CONVICTION AND SENTENCE DATED: 29.11.2018 PASSED BY
II-ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE, AT KALABURAGI IN SPL. CASE
(POCSO) NO.42/2017 AND ACQUIT THE APPELLANT FOR THE
ALLEGED OFFENCES.
(C) ACQUIT THE APPELLANT OF ALL CHARGES IN SPL.
CASE (POCSO) NO.42/2017 ON THE FILE OF II-ADDL.
SESSIONS JUDGE, AT KALABURAGI.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI)
The appellant has filed this appeal under Section
374(2) of Cr.P.C., challenging the judgment of conviction
and order of sentence dated 29.11.2018 passed in Special
Case (POCSO) No.42/2017 by the learned II-Additional
Sessions Judge, Kalaburagi, (for short, ‘Special Court’)
convicting the appellant for the offences punishable under
Sections 366-A and 376 of Indian Penal Code, (for short,
‘IPC’) and Section 4 of the Protection of Children from
Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (for short, ‘POCSO Act, 2012’).
The appellant was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for
life and to pay a fine of Rs.1,00,000/- for the offence
punishable under Section 376 of IPC and Section 4 of the
POCSO Act, 2012. In default of payment of fine, he shall
undergo simple imprisonment for a period of two years.
Further, the appellant was sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a period of ten years and to pay a fine of
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
Rs.1,00,000/- for the offence punishable under Section
366-A of IPC. In default of payment of fine, he shall
undergo further simple imprisonment for a period of two
years.
02. Brief facts giving rise to filing of this appeal are
as under:
The mother of the victim girl by name Kavitha lodged
a complaint stating that she has four daughters. It is
alleged that the appellant used to tease the victim and the
complainant advised the appellant not to behave in such a
way. It is alleged that on 16.05.2017 at about 5.30 a.m.,
the victim who went to attend a second nature call did not
return back home. Therefore, the complainant searched
for her daughter, but could not find her. It is further
alleged that on 18.05.2017 at about 05:30 p.m., in the
evening, the complainant's daughter returned home. On
enquiry by the complainant, the victim revealed that when
she had gone to attend a second nature of call on Dudani
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
road, the appellant came there, caught the victim and
stated that he loves her and forcibly took her to
Kalaburagi and kept her in an unknown room and that on
16.05.2017 at about 10:00 p.m., the appellant forcibly
had a sexual intercourse with the victim. When the victim
questioned about the same, he left the victim on
18.05.2017 abusing her in a filthy language and asking
her to go home. Therefore, the complainant lodged a
complaint against the appellant. The police registered the
case in Crime No.32/2017 for the offences punishable
under Sections 366-A, 376(2)(n) and 506 of IPC and
Sections 4 and 6 of the POCSO Act, 2012.
03. The police, after investigation, filed charge-
sheet for the offences punishable under Sections 506,
366-A and 376(2)(n) of IPC and Sections 4 and 6 of the
POCSO Act, 2012. The Special Court in compliance of
Section 207 of Cr.P.C, furnished the charge-sheet papers
to the appellant.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
04. After hearing the learned counsel for the
parties, the Special Court framed the charges. The charges
were read over and explained to the appellant and he
denied the charges and claimed to be tried.
05. Out of 24 chargesheeted witnesses, the
prosecution in order to prove its case, examined 19
witnesses as PW.1 to PW.19 and marked 22 documents as
Exs.P1 to P.22. The prosecution gave up CWs.19, 20, 21
and 22. Since the statement under Section 164 of Cr.P.C.,
was not substantial evidence, by rejecting the prayer of
the learned Special Public Prosecutor, CW.16 was dropped.
06. The appellant’s statement was recorded under
Section 313 of Cr.P.C., by reading out all incriminating
material against him. The appellant denied the evidence
led by the prosecution and did not lead any either oral or
documentary evidence.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
07. The Special Court, after hearing the learned
counsel for the parties, framed the following points for
consideration:-
“1. Whether the prosecution proves that,
accused Ravi on 16.05.2017 at about 05.30
a.m. on the road leading to Dudani near bus-
stand at Nimbal village, within the limits of
Madanhipparga police station when CW 2
victim aged 16 years was proceeding to
answer second call of nature, kidnapped her
with intent that she may be compelled or
knowing it likely that she will be compelled to
marry the accused against her will or in order
that she may be forced or seduced to illicit
intercourse and thereby committed an offence
punishable under section 366-A of Indian
Penal Code?
2. Whether the prosecution proves that, the
accused Ravi on the above said date, time
and place, after kidnapping CW 2 minor girl,
took her to Bhankur village, kept in the house
of CW 9 Sarubai and during night committed
rape on her and thereby committed an
offence punishable under section 376 of
Indian Penal Code?
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
3. Whether the prosecution proves that the
accused Ravi, on the above said date, time
and place, committed penetrative sexual
assault on CW 2 minor girl aged about 16
years and thereby committed an offence
punishable under section 4 of POCSO Act?
4. What order or sentence?”
08. The Special Court, after appreciating the entire
evidence on record, answered point Nos.1 to 3 in the
affirmative and point No.4 as per the final order. The
Special Court has passed the judgment of conviction and
order of sentence and sentenced the appellant as
aforestated.
09. The appellant aggrieved by the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 29.11.2018 passed
in Special Case (POCSO) No.42/2017 by the II-Additional
Sessions Judge, Kalaburagi, filed this appeal.
10. Heard the arguments of the learned counsel for
the appellant and learned Additional State Public
Prosecutor for respondent No.1-State.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
11. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that
the Special Court has not properly appreciated the
evidence of the prosecution. He submits that the victim
was aged about more than 17 years and she was in the
age of understanding what is right and wrong for her. He
submits that the victim was in love with the appellant and
both with the consent had a sexual intercourse.
12. He submits that the prosecution has examined
the relatives of the victim. PW.2, PW.3, PW.4, PW.7,
PW.10 and PW.11 turned hostile. He also submits that
none of the prosecution witnesses supported the case of
the prosecution. He also submits that the alleged
commission of offence has taken place on 16.05.2017 and
complaint was lodged on 18.05.2017. He submits that the
prosecution has failed to explain the delay in lodging the
complaint. He submits that the prosecution has failed to
prove the guilt of accused beyond the reasonable doubt.
The Special Court has not properly appreciated the entire
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
evidence on record and committed an error in passing the
judgment of conviction and order of sentence. Hence, on
these grounds he prays to allow the appeal.
13. Per contra , learned Addl. SPP. submits that
admittedly the victim is a minor and the appellant knowing
fully well that the victim is a minor and he has kidnapped
her and committed her rape on her. The appellant has
committed an offence punishable under Section 376 of IPC
and Section 6 of the POCSO Act. He also submits that
there is a presumption under Section 29 of the POCSO Act.
The Special Court was justified in drawing the presumption
under Section 29 of the Act and rightly passed the
Judgment of conviction and order of sentence. Hence, on
these grounds he prays to dismiss the appeal.
14. Perused the records and considered the
submissions of the learned counsel for the parties. The
points that would arise for our consideration are:
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
i. Whether the appellant proves that the
judgment of conviction and order of sentence
passed by the Trial Court is perverse and
arbitrary and without appreciation of evidence.?
ii. What order.?
15. The prosecution to prove its case examined the
victim as PW.1. She has deposed that the house of the
accused is situated about 60 to 70 houses away from her
home. Her father started to construct a house in the
village at Nimbal. The appellant - accused was coming to
see the construction. At that time she came to know that
the appellant was teasing her, he collected her mobile
number when she left the mobile outside the house. The
appellant was calling her on her mobile and was talking to
her and was expressing that he is in love with her. The
victim had informed the same to her mother – PW.4. At
that time her mother warned the appellant. In spite of it
the appellant continued to call her mobile. On 16.05.2017
at 05:30 a.m. when she came to the house to attend a
second nature call and was going back, at that time the
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
accused came on a motorcycle, took her forcibly and kept
her in a house for 02 days and committed a rape on her in
spite of her resistance. The appellant went out of the
house stating that he will come back. Thereafter, she
alone went to Dudini by Train. She came to Nimbal village
in a jeep. Her parental aunt took her inside the house and
enquired her. She did not narrate anything to her. Her
parental uncle and another two villagers took her near
Hawa Mallikarjun Temple. Her parental uncle enquired her,
at that time, she narrated the incident before him. They
took the victim to the police station, at that time her
mother – PW.2 lodged the complaint against the appellant.
Her statement was recorded by the learned Magistrate and
statement recorded under Section 164 of Cr.P.C. The said
statement was marked as Ex.P.1.
16. During the cross-examination, it is elicited that
th
she is studying 9 standard at Nimbal School. It is also
elicited that she has not stated before the police that she
had kept mobile on the table, at that time the appellant
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
collected her mobile number. It is also elicited that she has
not stated before the police that when she was coming
after attending the second nature call, the appellant came
on a motorcycle and forcibly took her. She has denied that
she has not stated before the police that at Bhankur
village, the appellant by force tied Tali to her. She admits
that she has not stated before the police that her mother
was standing in a little distance. She has further admitted
that the appellant is working in a private company at
Wadi. Her father had getting for 22 acres of land, out of
which he has sold 16 acres of land to one Mallinath Zalki,
resident of Dudani village and retained 06 acres of land.
She has confessed before the doctor that she knows the
appellant. Since, 4 to 5 months they were in love with
each other and they participated in the sexual intercourse
on many times and she voluntarily went with the accused
to Bhankur village. She has taken a bus and changed the
clothes on and on 18.05.2017 at 07:00 a.m. they married
in a Temple at Bhankur village and they came back to
Nimbal village in the evening at 05.00 p.m. by Train.
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
17. Since, both family members opposed their
marriage, complaint is lodged against the appellant.
Further, she has given her statement under Section 164 of
Cr.P.C. before the learned Magistrate. She has deposed
that police tutor that the appellant forcibly took her to
Bhankur village and committed a rape on her. It is further
elicited that on 16.05.2017 the appellant informed that he
is going to Bhankur and called her to accompany him.
Therefore, she went with the appellant. In Bhankur she
went to the house of her younger paternal uncle and the
appellant went to the relatives’ house and she came back
to Nimbal. She admits that during these 2 to 3 days the
appellant not met her and the police instructed her to give
her statement in a particular manner. PW.1 was partly
treated as a hostile.
18. The mother of the victim was examined as
PW.2. She has deposed that the appellant teasing the
victim and she warned the appellant. But, at last she has
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
warned him not to tease the victim. She has deposed that
about 04 to 05 months back in the morning the victim
went out of the house to attend a second nature call. After
03 days she came back and on enquiry the victim narrated
that the appellant has took her to Bhankur and thereafter,
in order to go to the house of her aunt she went with the
appellant and she stayed there in the house of her aunt.
The victim has not informed anything about the accused
when she informed the matter to the police. She has
lodged the complaint and the copy of the complaint is
marked as Ex.P.2 and she admits that she has not stated
in Ex.P.2 that the accused kidnapped. She has deposed
that police never visited her house and not inspected the
spot. The learned Public Prosecutor has treated this
witness as a hostile.
19. The prosecution examined relative of the
accused as PW.3. Even he has not supported the case of
the prosecution. She has turned hostile.
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
20. The prosecution examined the father of the
victim as PW.4. From the perusal of the evidence of PW.4,
he is a hearsay witness.
21. The prosecution examined the circumstantial
witness as PW.7. Even the PW.7 has treated hostile by the
learned Public Prosecutor.
22. The sister of the victim was examined as
PW.10. Even she has been treated as a hostile.
23. The brother-in-law of the victim was examined
as PW.11 and even he has not supported the case of the
prosecution.
24. PW.13 and PW.16 are the circumstantial
witnesses and they were also treated as a hostile.
25. PWs.5, 6, 8 and 12 are the witnesses to
mahazars. The mahazars are marked as Exs.P.6 to P.8.
Even these witnesses have been turned hostile i.e., PW.5,
6, 8 and 12.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
26. The prosecution examined the doctor as PW.14
who has examined the accused and issued a potency
certificate and the said potency certificate is marked as
Ex.P.16. He has opined that the appellant is a potent and
capable of performing a sexual act.
27. The prosecution examined the doctor as PW.9
who has examined the victim. She has deposed that on
19.05.2017 when she has examined the victim, the victim
narrated that she was in love with one Ravi, many times
she had intercourse with him and voluntarily she went with
him to Bhankur village for 3 days, stayed in a room for 3
days and nights, they had an episode of sexual intercourse
and after that she took a bath, changed and washed her
clothes and they got married on 18.05.2017 at 07:00 a.m.
in a Temple at Bhankur and they returned to Nimbal
village at 05:00 p.m.
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
28. The mother of the victim lodged a complaint as
per Ex.P.2. PW.9 has issued the certificate marked as
Ex.P.10 i.e., the medical certificate and her signature is
marked as Ex.P.10(a). The FSL report is marked as
Ex.P.12. She has deposed that on examination she found
that the victim was conscious, co-operative, well oriented,
both breasts were well developed, normal adult pattern,
axillary and pubic hair present and normal adult pattern.
No injuries were found on her body and private parts.
Menarche was at 13 years, last menstrual period was
about 06 days back (13.05.2017), menstrual history was
for a period of 3 to 4 days in 30 days regularly. Cervix and
vagina was healthy, vagina admits two fingers easily and
hymen was torn. Two vaginal and two cervical smears and
swabs was taken for examination and sent them for FSL.
29. She has deposed that abdominal ultra sound
was normal, x-ray of long bones show the age of the
victim as 16 to 17 years. X-ray of both Mandible show the
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
age of the victim as below 18 years. Accordingly, she has
issued a preliminary report. It is marked as Ex.P.10. Her
signature is marked as Ex.P10(a). After the receipt of FSL
report she has given a final report. The FSL report shows
that seminal stain was not detected in Article Nos.1 and 2.
Spermatozoa was not detected in Article Nos.3 and 4. The
bloodstain was not detected in Article No.1. Therefore, she
was of the opinion that there is no evidence of recent
sexual intercourse and the age of the victim is less than 18
years. The final report is marked as Ex.P.11. Her signature
was marked as Ex.P.11(a). FSL report is marked as
Ex.P.12.
30. She has also deposed that recent sexual
intercourse means, intercourse within 01 week. Since, the
victim had taken the bath and washed her clothes.
Seminal stains, spermatozoa and bloodstains were not
detected. Normal hymen injury may remain for 3 to 4
days.
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
31. During the cross-examination she has admitted
that she has not read over the history of the incident
written by her in Ex.P.10. She admits that even in a
cycling and while doing heavy work, hymen tear may
occur and also admit that hymen tear is not an injury and
it is a natural human being and she also admits that if
bath is taken and clothes are washed, if there is
ejaculation, spermatozoa can be formed inside the vagina.
32. The prosecution examined the Panchayath
Development Officer as PW.15 who has issued a Khata
extract as per Ex.P.17. The Ex.P.17 pertaining to the
house of Sarubai i.e., PW.3.
33. The prosecution to prove the age of the victim
examined the Headmaster as PW.17 who has deposed that
the victim has studied in the school and as per the school
th
records the victim studied in 10 standard during the year
during 2016-17 and he has issued certificate marked as
Ex.P.19 on the basis of school records and he has
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
produced the original admission register. The relevant
portion of the register is marked as Ex.P.19. The signature
of PW.17 is marked as Ex.P19(A). During the cross-
examination it is elicited that on the basis of transfer
certificate of previous school, the date of birth of the
victim is mentioned and he admits that only on the basis
of a transfer certificate issued by the previous school the
date of birth is mentioned and he has not enquired with
the primary school on what basis the date of birth of
victim was mentioned.
34. The prosecution examined the Assistant Sub
Inspector of Police as PW.18, who has deposed that on
18.05.2017 at about 08:30 p.m. he had received a
complaint from PW.2 and the said complaint is already
marked as Ex.P.2 and on the basis of the complaint he had
registered the case in Crime No.32/2017 and forwarded
the copy of the FIR to the learned Magistrate and the copy
of the FIR is marked as Ex.P.20. He has recorded the
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
statement of the complainant as per Ex.P.2 and he had
handed over the further investigation to the CPI. He
further deposed that on the direction of CPI on 20.05.2017
he visited the Nimbal village - Dudhini main road and
secured the presence of panchas and drawn the mahazar
as per Ex.P.6. On 26.05.2017 he brought the appellant
and produced before the CPI along with his report and his
report is marked as Ex.P.21. On 27.05.2017 he visited the
Chittapur Taluk, Bhankur village to the house of Sarubai
and drawn the mahazar as per Ex.P.7 in the presence of
panchas.
35. During the cross-examination, it is elicited that
only complainant and her daughter i.e. PWs.1 and 2 came
to the police station to lodge a complaint and he enquired
them, who was the scribe of the complaint. On the same
day he recorded the statement of the victim and on the
same day he had sent the victim for the medical
examination. He has deposed that Nimbal is situated about
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
15 km away from Madanhipparga. He admits that there is
a main road from Madanhipparga to Nimbal. He has
deposed that on the date of complaint or on the next day
he had not visited the spot to draw the mahazar.
36. The prosecution examined the second
Investigating Officer as PW19, who has deposed that on
19.05.2017 he received further investigation of this case
and verified the records and he sent the victim for medical
examination through CW19 and on the same day he
recorded the statement of CW1 as per Ex.P3. He directed
CW23 to trace and produce the appellant. On 19.05.2017
he recorded the statement of CW3 as per Ex.P5, CW.4 as
per Ex.P13, CW5 as per Ex.P14, CW6 as per Ex.P15, CW7
as per Ex.P9 and CW8 as per Ex.P18. On 20.05.2019
CW19 along with the victim produced the samples
collected by the Doctor-PW9 and her statement was
recorded under Section 164 of CrPC by the learned
Magistrate.
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
37. On 26.05.2017 CW23 produced the accused
before him and he sent the accused for medical
examination through CW21 and after medical examination
of the appellant, he has produced the appellant before the
Court along with the remand application and CW21
produced the clothes of the appellant before him, namely,
shirt, pant, baniyan and innerwear and he has seized the
said articles and drawn a mahazar as per Ex.P8 and
received the sketch as per Ex.P22 and khata extract as per
Ex.P17 and he went to seize the articles for FSL
examination and he has received Exs.P10 and P16. After
the completion of investigation, he has filed a charge sheet
against the appellant. During the cross-examination, it
was suggested to PW.19 that the complainant has not
given a statement as per Ex.P3. The said suggestion was
denied by PW19.
38. From the perusal of the evidence of PW1 to
PW19, none of the witnesses have supported the case of
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
the prosecution including the victim. On the contrary,
PW1-victim stated before PW9-Doctor, wherein, she has
stated that she was in love with the appellant and both of
them had a sexual intercourse and she never resisted the
act of the appellant while having a physical relationship.
39. Even the panchas have not supported the case
of the prosecution. The prosecution has failed to prove the
age of the victim that she is a minor and further the
prosecution has not complied Section 94 of the Juvenile
Justice Act.
40. We would like to place reliance on the judgment
of the Hon'ble Apex Court in a case of P.Yuvaprakash vs.
State Rep. by Inspector of Police in Criminal Appeal
No.1898 of 2023 , wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court held in
para-19, which reads as follows:
“19. It is clear from the above narrative that
none of the documents produced during the trial
answered the description of “the date of birth
certificate from the school” or “the matriculation or
equivalent certificate” from the concerned
examination board or certificate by a corporation,
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
municipal authority or a Panchayat. In these
circumstances, it was incumbent for the prosecution
to prove through acceptable medical
tests/examination that the victim’s age was below
18 years as per Section 94(2)(iii) of the JJ Act.”
41. Though the prosecution examined PW9-Doctor,
but she has admitted that the accused was not subject to
the test of radiology. The prosecution has failed to prove
that the victim is less than 18 years and the prosecution
did not comply with the provisions of Section 94 of the
J.J.Act. Thus, the prosecution has failed to prove that the
victim was aged less than 18 years as on the date of
alleged incident.
42. Further, we would like to place reliance on the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of State
of Uttar Pradesh vs. Anurudh and Anr. reported in
2026 SCC OnLine SC 40 , wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court
held in para-19, which reads as follows:
“ 19 . As the conclusions drawn above indicate the
impugned judgment and order of the High Court has
to be set aside on grounds of transgression of the
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
jurisdiction present and thereby lacking the
appropriate directions. It is to be set aside also
because it goes against the statutory prescription
under the JJ Act. Be that as it may, this Court has
not lost sight of the well-intentioned purport of this
order. The POCSO Act is one of the most solemn
articulations of justice aimed at protecting the
children of today and the leaders of tomorrow. Yet,
when an instrument of such noble and one may even
say basic good intent is misused, misapplied and
used as a tool for exacting revenge, the notion of
justice itself teeters on the edge of inversion. Courts
have in many cases sounded alarm regarding this
situation. Misuse of the POCSO Act highlights a grim
societal chasm - on the one end children are silenced
by fear and their families are constrained by poverty
or stigma, meaning thereby that justice remains
distant and uncertain, and on the other hand, those
equipped with privilege, literacy, social and monetary
capital are able to manipulate the law to their
advantage. The impugned judgment is one amongst
many where Courts have spoken out. Not only are
instances rife where the age of the victim is
misrepresented to make the incident fall under the
stringent provisions of this law but also there are
numerous instances where this law is used by
families in opposition to relationships between young
people. In Satish alias Chand v. State of U.P., the
High Court, noted that on few occasions concern had
been expressed by the Court with respect to
application of the Act on consenting adolescence
when it comes to consensual relationships between
teenagers, four factors have been highlighted which,
is crucial for the Courts to consider:
“A. Assess the Context: Each case should be
evaluated on its individual facts and
circumstances. The nature of the relationship
and the intentions of both parties should be
carefully examined.
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
B. Consider Victim's Statement: The statement
of the alleged victim should be given due
consideration. If the relationship is consensual
and based on mutual affection, this should be
factored into decisions regarding bail and
prosecution.
C. Avoid Perversity of Justice: Ignoring the
consensual nature of a relationship can lead to
unjust outcomes, such as wrongful
imprisonment. The judicial system should aim
to balance the protection of minors with the
recognition of their autonomy in certain
contexts. Here the age comes out to be an
important factor.
D. Judicial Discretion: Courts should use their
discretion wisely, ensuring that the application
of POCSO does not inadvertently harm the very
individuals it is meant to protect.”
[See also : Mrigraj Gautam @
Rippu v. State of U.p.]
The Delhi High Court in Sahil v. the State NCT
of Delhi the Court noted in para 11 of the order that
POCSO cases filed at the behest of a girl’s family
objecting to romantic involvement with a young boy
have become common place and consequent thereto
these young boys languish in jails. Therein, reference
is also made to an order of the Gujarat High Court,
where the Court noted that considering the closeness
in age of the prosecutrix and the accused as also the
fact that she had left home of her own accord
observed that the application deserved
consideration.
This chasm between access and abuse is also
mirrored in the misuse of Section 498-A IPC and the
Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961. Amongst numerous
examples, we may only refer to Rajesh Chaddha v.
State of U.P, where this Court lamented the use of
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
these Sections without specific instances or relevant
details, among other cases. It is also to be stated
though that no amount of judicial vigilance against
misuse can alone bridge this ever-widening gap. The
first line of defence lies with the Bar i.e., the body
that translates grievance into action and is the
gatekeeper of justice at the point of entry. When it
comes to matters such as these, the responsibility of
the advocate is profound – to examine the
allegations with detachment and necessary discretion
and to counsel restraint when grievance masks
vengeance and to refuse participation in litigation
when it can be seen that an ulterior motive is sought
to be agitated under the guise of seeking protection
of the law. It is only when the Bar takes a principled,
proactive role, that the legislation intended as a
shield can be stopped from being twisted into a
weapon. A lawyer who tempers aggression with
calm, reason and rationality, protects not only the
opposing party from unwarranted harm but also the
client from the long-term consequences of frivolous
or malicious litigation, including adverse orders, and
judicial censure. By taking a principled stand, the Bar
acts as a crucial filter, preventing the legal system
from being overwhelmed by abuse masquerading as
enforcement. Such self-regulation strengthens public
faith in the profession, ensures that judicial time is
reserved for genuine disputes, and reinforces the
foundational idea that law is a means of justice, not
a weapon of convenience. In this sense, the ethical
vigilance of lawyers is not ancillary to justice, it is
indispensable to it. When they do not do so, the
chasm alluded to above widens. Society also must
match institutional reform with moral awakening.
The intent and object of these legislations must be at
the forefront when a person wishes to lodge a
complaint thereunder. The misuse of these laws is a
mirror to the opportunistic and self-centered view
that pervades the application of law. It is only
through discipline, integrity and courage that these
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
problems can be remedied and rooted out. Any
legislative amendment or judicial direction will
remain lack-luster without this deeper change.
We have referred to certain instances of the
High Courts noting the misuse/misapplication of the
POCSO Act, somewhat in line with the indices
appended to the impugned judgment as also its
progenitors.
Considering the fact that repeated judicial
notice has been taken of the misuse of these laws,
let a copy of this judgment be circulated to the
Secretary, Law, Government of India, to consider
initiation of steps as may be possible to curb this
menace inter alia, the introduction of a Romeo –
Juliet clause exempting genuine adolescent
relationships from the stronghold of this law;
enacting a mechanism enabling the prosecution of
those persons who, by the use of these laws seeks to
settle scores etc.”
43. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Nitin B.
Nikhare vs. State of Maharashtra & Anr. arising out of
Spl(Crl.)No.1889 of 2024 has held in paragraph No.6 as
follows:
“6. This Court in a catena of judgments has
held that the mere fact that physical relations were
established pursuant to a promise to marry will not
amount to a rape in every case. In order for the
offence of rape to be made out, two conditions
need to be satisfied i.e. that the promise of
marriage was made by the accused solely with a
view to obtain consent for sexual relations without
having any intention of fulfilling said promise from
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
the very beginning, and that the false promise of
marriage had a direct bearing on the prosecutrix
giving her consent for sexual relations.”
44. Admittedly, the victim had made a statement
before CW9 that the appellant and victim both of them
have married and with her consent, the appellant had
performed a sexual intercourse. There is no force from the
appellant to have a sexual intercourse with the victim.
45. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Paramjit
Singh Bedi vs. State of Punjab reported in 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 2009 held in para 29, which reads as follows:
“29. When the learned Sessions Judge had
disbelieved the prosecution version insofar the
charge under Section 366 IPC is concerned, the
very same prosecution version could not have been
accepted to convict the accused-appellant under
Section 376 IPC. While the conduct of the appellant
may be immoral and unethical, that by itself would
not justify a conviction under Section 376 IPC
without any clinching evidence. Such a charge must
be proved on the basis of hard evidence and not on
the basis of the surmises and conjectures based on
the value judgment of the presiding judge.
Immorality of an act sans credible evidence cannot
justify a conviction.”
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
46. Admittedly, even the medical evidence does not
support the case of the prosecution. From the perusal of
the FSL report, the Deputy Director has opined that
i)Seminal stains was not detected in article No.1, 2, 5, 6, 7
and 8; ii)Spermatozoa was not detected in article No.3
and 4; iii)Blood stains was not detected in article No.1, 2,
5, 6, 7 and 8.
47. From the perusal of evidence of PW.9, during
her cross-examination, she has admitted that she has not
read over the history of the incident written by her in
Ex.P10 and she has admitted that hymen tear may occur
even in cycling and while doing heavy work and she has
admitted that hymen tear is not an injury and it is a
nature of human being.
48. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of
Santhosh Kumar N.P. vs. State – Station House
Officer, Kadirur Police, Tellicherry, Kannur District &
Another, DD 30.10.2026 arising out of SLP (Crl.)
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
Nos.10173-10174 of 2025, wherein the Hon'ble Apex
Court held that:
“43. We wish to note a worrying trend in
recent years wherein consensual relationships that
have come to an end are retrospectively combed
with a fine tooth so as to identify what can post-
facto be construed as violence and sexual assault.
There is thus a need to distinguish between an
absence of consent in its entirety because of it
having been built entirely on a mirage of deceit and
falsehood at the outset on the one hand from the
experiencing of regret over having consented to
past sexual acts, owing to the later demise of the
relationship. While the latter scenario is
unfortunate, such hindsight on its own cannot
constitute a consensual relationship as a crime and
set the gears of the criminal justice system into
motion in a manner that deprives the accused of his
liberty and reputation. In fact, such an approach
denudes the man of any agency entirely, as the
mere factum of being in a consensual relationship
at one point would bind him to it entirely for fear of
being accused of rape at a subsequent point of
time.
44. In such a scenario, can it be said that the
man had no right to withdraw from the
relationship? Can such a decision be termed as
deceit or fraud? Clearly not. In such cases, physical
intimacy that occurred during the currency of a
functioning relationship cannot be retrospectively
branded as acts of rape merely because the
relationship soured and no longer subsists.
46. At this juncture, this Court must also
sound a note of caution. Rape is an offence that
strikes at the core of a woman’s bodily autonomy
and dignity. It continues to be heavily
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
underreported and victims are encouraged to
choose silence so as to protect their and their
family’s honour and reputation over seeking justice.
For every case where the provisions related to rape
are misused, there are several cases that never see
the light of day. We must emphasise that genuine
cases must be pursued with vigour where the facts
clearly show sexual assault and violence. But
equally, the justice system must not be turned into
a tool of vengeance when relationships fail. The
legislature has never intended that consensual
sexual acts between adults occurring during a
mutually affectionate relationship, to be
retrospectively. criminalised merely because the
relationship came to an end. It is unfortunate that
despite judicial deprecation, this trend is increasing,
and it is a matter of concern for the courts as often
settlement of disputes comes with huge monetary
considerations to be borne by the male accused.”
49. Admittedly, in the instant case the victim has
deposed before PW.9 that the appellant has married the
victim. The said aspect was not considered by the Special
Court.
50. Further, PWs.2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 have turned
hostile. The prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of the
accused beyond all reasonable doubt.
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
51. Further, the alleged incident took place on
16.05.2017 and complaint was lodged on 18.05.2017.
There is a delay of 2 days in lodging a complaint. The
prosecution has failed to offer explanation of delay in
lodging a complaint. The prosecution has failed to prove
the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The
Special Court without properly appreciating the evidence
on record, committed an error in passing the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence.
52. Considering the proposition of law laid down by
the Hon'ble Apex Court in the cases referred to supra , we
are of considered view that the judgment of conviction and
order of sentence passed by the Special Court is perverse,
arbitrary and without appreciation of evidence. We inclined
to interfere with the impugned judgment and order fo
sentence. In view of the above discussion, we answer
Point No.1 in the Affirmative.
53. Point No.2: we proceed to pass the following:
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11781-DB
CRL.A No. 200167 of 2018
CNR: KAHC030080372018
ORDER
(i) The Criminal Appeal is allowed .
(ii) The Judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 29.11.2018 passed in
Special Case (POCSO) No.42/2017 by the
II-Additional Sessions Judge, Kalaburagi, is
hereby set aside.
(iii) The appellant is acquitted for the offence
punishable under Section 376 of IPC and
Section 4 of POCSO Act, 2012.
(iv) The bail bond executed by the appellant
stands cancelled.
(v) The Special Court is directed to refund the
fine amount, if any, deposited by the
appellant.
Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO)
JUDGE
NB,KJJ,SDU
LIST NO.: 2 SL NO.: 35;CT:PK