ALEYAMMA CHACKO vs STATE OF KERALA

Court
Kerala High Court

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
1
WP(C) No.28923/2019

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
ND
TUESDAY, THE 22 DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026/31ST BHADRA,1948
WP(C) NO. 28923 OF 2019
PETITIONERS:

1 ALEYAMMA CHACKO, AGED 68 YEARS
W/O. LATE CHACKO, MUTTITHOTTATHIL HOSUE,
KARIKULAM P.O., KARIKULAM MURI, RANNI,
PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT.

2 ABRAHAM CHACKO, S/O. LATE CHACKO,
MUTTITHOTTATHIL HOSUE, KARIKULAM P.O.,
KARIKULAM MURI, RANNI, PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT.

3 ALEXANDER CHACKO
LATE CHACKO, MUTTITHOTTATHIL HOSUE, KARIKULAM
P.O., KARIKULAM MURI, RANNI, PATHANAMTHITTA
DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS POWER OF ATTORNEY
HOLDER ABRAHAM CHACKO, S/O. LATE CHACKO,
MUTTITHOTTATHIL HOSUE, KARIKULAM P.O.,
KARIKULAM MURI, RANNI, PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT.

BY ADVS.
SRI.P.K.MOHAMED JAMEEL
SRI.RAFFEEKH.K
SMT. SUHARABI KANNETH
SMT.SMRITHI HARRIS


RESPONDENTS:

1 STATE OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
2
WP(C) No.28923/2019

THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN-695 001.

2 LAND REVENUE COMMISSIONER
COMMISSIONERATE OF LAND REVENUE, GOVERNMENT OF
KERALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN-695 033.

3 DISTRICT COLLECTOR, PATHANAMTHITTA,
COLLECTORATE, PATHANAMTHITTA, PIN-689 645.

4 THE TAHSILDAR, RANNI TALUK, PATHANAMTHITTA
DISTRICT, PIN-689 672.

5 VILLAGE OFFICER
PAZHAVANGADI VILLAGE, RANNI TALUK,
PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689 673.

6 JOHN VARGHESE
ELIMULLUMANKAL HOSUE, KARIKULAM P.O.,
KARIKULAM MURI, PAZHAVANGADI VILLAGE,
RANNI TALUK, PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT,
PIN-689 673.

7 T.J.THOMAS, THEVAROLIYIL THUNDIYIL,
EDAMON P.O., RANNI, PIN-689 676.

8 T.J.PHILIP, THEVAROLIYIL THUNDIYIL,
EDAMON P.O., RANNI, PIN-689 676.


BY ADVS.
SRI. BIJULAL K.R., SR. G.P.
SRI.JACOB P.ALEX
SRI.JOSEPH P.ALEX
SHRI.MANU SANKAR P.



THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 22.09.2026, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:


CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
3
WP(C) No.28923/2019

CR
JUDGMENT

1. Petitioners are mother and two sons. They are
challenging Ext.P7 Order dated 11.04.2019 passed by the
Respondent No.3 under Rule 8(3) of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964, cancelling Ext.P3 Patta dated
31.01.1970 and Ext.P11 Order dated 04.10.2019 passed by
the Respondent No.2 confirming Ext.P7 Order rejecting the

Appeal filed by the Petitioners against Ext.P7 Order.
2.
The case of the Petitioners is that the Petitioner No.1 and
her father purchased 6.53 Acres of land in old Sy. Nos.159/1B
and 170/1/1/511 & 513 of Pazhavangadikkara Village in
Pathanamthitta Taluk, which is recorded as 5.83 Acres in the
Basic Tax Register, as per Ext.P1 Sale Deed dated 11.08.1964;
that out of the said property, 4.90 Acres of land was
Government land; that the father of the Petitioner No.1 applied

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
4
WP(C) No.28923/2019

for assignment of the said land on behalf of them; that the said
4.90 Acres of land was assigned to the father of the Petitioner
as per the Assignment Order of the year 1965 and Ext.P3 Patta
was issued on 31.01.1970; that after the Order of Assignment,
the father of the Petitioner No.1 relinquished all his rights over
the property in favour of the Petitioner No.1 as per Ext.P2
Settlement Deed dated 23.06.1967; that the Petitioner No.1
executed Ext.P4 Settlement Deed dated 17.08.1978 in favour
of Petitioners Nos.2 and 3; that the Respondent No.6
submitted a Petition to the Respondent No.2 to cancel Ext.P3
Patta and Respondent No.3 issued Ext.P7 Order illegally
cancelling Ext.P3 Patta on the ground that the assignee
alienated the property to his daughter within ten years, during
which period there was restriction against alienation; and that
the Respondent No.2 illegally confirmed Ext.P7 Order as per

Ext.P11 Order rejecting the Appeal filed by the Petitioners.

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
5
WP(C) No.28923/2019


3. The Respondent No.3 filed Statement dated 27.12.2019
opposing the prayers in the Writ Petition. The Respondent
No.6 filed Counter Affidavit dated 18.01.2020 opposing the

prayers in the Writ Petition.
4. I heard the learned Counsel for the Petitioners, Sri. P.K.
Mohammed Jameel, the learned Government Pleader, Sri. Biju
Lal, for Respondent Nos.1 to 5, and the learned Counsel for

Respondent No.6, Sri. Jacob P. Alex.

5. Learned Counsel for the Petitioners contended that
Ext.P3 Patta was cancelled nearly 50 years from the date of
issuance of the said Patta invoking Rule 8(3) of the Kerala
Land Assignment Rules, 1964, and the issue is covered in
favour of the Petitioners as per the Division Bench decision of
this Court in Chandy Chandy v. District Collector [2025 KLT OnLine
2260] . In the said decision, the Division Bench considered the
legality of the direction of the learned Single Judge that the

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
6
WP(C) No.28923/2019

Respondent Authorities are free to take fresh proceedings for
cancelling the registry after taking appropriate proceedings in
terms of Rule 8(3) of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964,
or any other law in force, while setting aside the Order
cancelling Patta. It is held that the proceedings for cancellation
are to be taken within 25 years, since Rule 8(1) of the Kerala
Land Assignment Rules, 1964, mentions a period of 25 years
for non-alienation. Learned Counsel contended that the period
of 25 years mentioned in Rule 8(1) for non-alienation of the
land was only 3 years at the time when Ext.P3 Patta was
issued and that is why in Ext.P3, Condition No.3 restricting
alienation for a period of 10 years was struck off. Since
Condition No.3 in Ext.P3 is struck off, there is no condition for
non-alienation for the land assigned as per Ext.P3. The Ext.P2
transfer could not be treated as an alienation as the same was
made within the family of the assignee to his daughter. It is
clear from Ext.P7 Order that Respondent No.6 submitted a

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
7
WP(C) No.28923/2019

Petition for cancellation of Ext.P3 Patta for the first time on
20.02.2017. It is after a period of more than 52 years from the
date of the Assignment Order and 47 years from the date of
issuance of Ext.P3 Patta. The alienation of the assigned land,
which is found in Ext.P7 as a ground for cancellation of Ext.P3
Patta, is in favour of the daughter of the original assignee and
since the assignment is within the family, it could not be treated
as an alienation, which is restricted under Rule 8(1) of the
Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964. Even though the
Respondent No.6 raised several contentions against the
issuance of Ext.P3 Patta, the Respondent No.3 did not find
those contentions sustainable and hence, the Patta was
cancelled not on those grounds raised by the Respondent
No.6. Learned Counsel concluded his arguments, praying to
set aside the impugned Orders.

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
8
WP(C) No.28923/2019


6. On the other hand, the learned Government Pleader
representing the Official Respondents contended that
admittedly, the Assignee in Ext.P3 Patta transferred the
assigned land in favour of his daughter as per Ext.P2
Document of the year 1967. The assignment was made as per
Order dated 15.04.1965 in which the restriction against
alienation was for a period of ten years. It is clear from Ext.P2
Document that the daughter of the assignee, who is the
Petitioner No.1, was a Government Employee, married and
aged 33 years and was not a dependent of the assignee. When
the assignee has violated the conditions of the assignment by
alienating the assigned property within the period in which the
alienation was restricted, the assignment can be cancelled at
any time by invoking Rule 8(3) of the Kerala Land Assignment
Rules, 1964. The impugned Orders passed by the Respondent
No.2 and 3 are perfectly legal and valid and could not be
interfered with in this Writ Petition.

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
9
WP(C) No.28923/2019


7. Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.6 contended
that as per Ext.R6(d) Order of Assignment dated 15.04.1965,
the period restricting alienation of the land was ten years,
during the relevant time. Learned Counsel contended that the
definition of ‘family’ under Rule 2(d) includes a person, his wife
and children living with or dependent on them and also the
parents who are solely dependent on such person, and hence,
the daughter of the assignee, namely, the Petitioner No.1, who
was aged 33 years, married and having Government
employment, could not be a member of the family of the
assignee. Admittedly, the assignee alienated the assigned land
within a period of ten years as per Ext.P2 Document to his
daughter, who was not dependent on him. In such case, the
assignment is liable to be cancelled under Rule 8(3) of the
Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964. The decision in Chandy
Chandy (supra) cited by the learned Counsel for the Petitioners
is clearly distinguishable on facts. It deals only with the

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
10
WP(C) No.28923/2019

cancellation of Patta obtained without complying with the
statutory formalities. When the conditions of assignment are
violated, the Government is fully entitled to cancel the Patta at
any time and there is no restriction in initiating proceedings for
cancellation of Patta for violation of conditions of assignment.
Learned Counsel invited my attention to Rule 8 of the original
Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964, issued by the State
Government as per Notification dated 23.03.1964, in which the
period for non-alienation is ten years from the date of registry.
Learned Counsel contended that in view of Section 8 of the
Kerala Government Land Assignment Act, 1960, all the
provisions, restrictions, conditions and limitations in any Patta
or other document evidencing the assignment of Government
land or of any interest therein shall be valid and take effect
according to their tenor, notwithstanding any law for the time
being in force or any custom or contract to the contrary.
Learned Counsel cited the Division Bench decision of this

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
11
WP(C) No.28923/2019

Court in Treesa Allesh and Another v. State of Kerala and Others
[2016:KER:34188] in which this Court considered the question of
whether the restriction against alienation for a period of 10
years provided in the Patta is valid when Rule 8 of the Kerala
Land Assignment Rules, 1964, prescribes a condition of non-
alienation for a period of 3 years. The Division Bench of this
Court held that in view of Section 8 of the Kerala Government
Land Assignment Act, 1960, the provisions, restrictions,
conditions and limitations contained in the Patta evidencing
assignment of Government land shall be valid and Rule 8 of
the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964, will not supersede
Section 8 of the Kerala Government Land Assignment Act,
1960. Rule 4 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964,
provides that Government lands may be assigned on registry
for purposes of personal cultivation, house-sites and beneficial
enjoyment of adjoining registered holdings. The assignment in
Ext.P3 was for personal cultivation. The Respondent No.6 has

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
12
WP(C) No.28923/2019

been residing near the property assigned as per Ext.P3. When
the Petitioners and Respondents Nos.7 and 8 started making
hasty preparations to start quarrying operations in the assigned
land in violation of the Patta conditions, the Respondent No.6
submitted Petition to the Respondent No.2 highlighting his
grievances and requesting to cancel the Ext.P3 Assignment for
violations of the conditions of assignment and on other legal
grounds. Though several contentions were taken for
cancellation of assignment before the Respondent Nos.2 and
3, they considered only the violation of the condition of non-
alienation alone in the impugned Orders. The Respondent
No.3 illegally found that the assignee has not utilised the land
in violation of the conditions of assignment as the assignee has
not started quarrying operations though he initiated steps to
conduct quarrying operations. Learned Counsel invited my
attention to Rule 11 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules,
1964, which provides for preparation of list of assignable land

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
13
WP(C) No.28923/2019

by the Government. Learned Counsel contended that as per
Clause (viii) of Rule 11(2) of the Kerala Land Assignment
Rules, 1964, lands containing or believed to contain valuable
minerals, quarries, etc., cannot be included in the list of
assignable land. Since the Petitioners attempted to conduct
quarrying in the assigned land, it is clear that the land contains
large quantity of rock. In such case, the subject land could not
be included in the list of assignable land and could not be
assigned as per Ext.P3 Patta. Learned Counsel cited the
decision of this Court in Varkey Abraham v. Secretary to Government
[2007 (3) KLT 702] in which the Division Bench this Court held that
in order to constitute a ‘quarry’ within the meaning of Clause
(viii) of Rule 11(2) of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964,
it is not necessary that actual quarrying is undertaken in the
land and it is sufficient that the land has the potential to be
converted into a quarry as understood in the common
parlance; and that rock available in the land and that too a

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
14
WP(C) No.28923/2019

great extent, would satisfy the requirement of the land being
the one containing valuable minerals within the meaning of
Clause (viii). Learned Counsel cited the Division Bench
decision of this Court in Mathew John v. Land Revenue
Commissioner [2025 (5) KLT 37] in which it is held that a Patta
cannot be issued in contravention of the Order of Assignment
on the registry. Ext.P3 Patta was issued on the basis of
Ext.R6(d) Order of Assignment containing restriction against
alienation for a period of ten years and hence, Ext.P3 Patta
could not be construed as one without the said restriction
against alienation. Learned Counsel pointed out that even
though the Condition No.3 in Ext.P3 is struck off, it is not
authenticated by anybody by subscribing seal and signature.
Learned Counsel cited the decision of this Court in Mahindra
Holidays and Resorts India Limited v. State of Kerala [2019 (2) KLT 978]
in which it is held that if the assignee commits any act defeating
the object of assignment, he is bound to restore the land to the

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
15
WP(C) No.28923/2019

assignor. The purpose of assignment as per Ext.P3 is for
personal cultivation and house-site. The attempt of the
assignee to convert the assigned land into a quarry defeats the
very object of the assignment and in which case, the
assignment is liable to be cancelled. Learned Counsel pointed
out that this Court had called for the Judge’s papers in W.P.(C)
No.33512/2019 filed by the Petitioners and Respondent No.7
when the authorities refused to grant permission to conduct a
quarry in the assigned land. It can be seen that the said Writ
Petition was dismissed as withdrawn and hence all the orders
and actions challenged therein have become final and the
Petitioners cannot conduct quarrying in the assigned land.
Learned Counsel cited the Division Bench decision of this
Court in Varghese Kurian v. State of Kerala [2023 KHC 9226] , in which
this Court followed the earlier decision of this Court in Raphy
John and Others v. Land Revenue Commissioner and Others [2022
KHC 3494] , wherein this Court held that the land assigned for

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
16
WP(C) No.28923/2019

specific purpose cannot be diverted for using for other
purposes. The Division Bench of this Court held that even
without there being a specific stipulation in the Patta
conditions, the land cannot be used by the holder of the land
for the purpose other than the purpose for which the land is
assigned. Learned Counsel concluded his arguments by
praying to sustain Ext.P7 and P11 Orders on account of the
reasons specified therein and also on account of the other
reasons made out by him before this Court.
8. I have considered the rival contentions.
9. The Respondent No.3 passed Ext.P7 Order cancelling
the land assignment as per Ext.P3 on the ground that the
assignee alienated the assigned land in violation of the
conditions of alienation. As per Rule 8 of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964, which was existing on the date of
issuance of Ext.R6(d) Order of Assignment, the condition for

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
17
WP(C) No.28923/2019

non-alienation was for a period of 10 years from the date of
registry. In Ext.R6(d), the condition for non-alienation was for a
period of 10 years. In Ext.P3 Patta also, the Condition No.3 for
non-alienation was for a period of 10 years. The contention of
the Counsel for the Petitioners is that Condition No.3 in Ext.P3
is struck off and hence, there is no condition for non-alienation
for the land assigned as per Ext.P3. Admittedly, Ext.P3 Patta
is issued on the basis of Ext.R6(d) Order of Assignment. In
view of the Division Bench decision of this Court in Mathew John
(supra) , a Patta cannot be issued in contravention of the order
of the assignment on the registry. In such case, it is the
conditions in the Order of Assignment which will prevail over
the conditions in the Patta. That apart, as rightly pointed out by
the learned Counsel for the Respondent No.6, the striking of
the Condition No.3 is not endorsed or authenticated by any
Officer. Hence, I find that the condition for non-alienation for
the land assigned as per Ext.P3 Patta is for a period of 10

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
18
WP(C) No.28923/2019

years. Admittedly, the assignee in Ext.R6(d) Assignment Order
and Ext.P3 Patta alienated the assigned land to his daughter,
Petitioner No.1, as per Ext.P2 Document dated 23.06.1967
within the period of restriction. The contention of the learned
Counsel for the Petitioners is that the Ext.P2 transfer could not
be treated as an alienation as the same was within the family
of the assignee in favour of her daughter. Rule 8 of the Kerala
Land Assignment Rules, 1964, does not permit alienation to
the family members during the period of non-alienation. That
apart, as per the definition of ‘family’ in Rule 2(d) of the Kerala
Land Assignment Rules, 1964, children living with the assignee
or dependent on the assignee alone will come within the
definition of ‘family’. From Ext.P2, it is clear that at the time of
alienation, the Petitioner No.1 was aged 33 years, married and
a Government Employee. Hence, I find that the assignee in
Ext.R6(d) and Ext.P3 alienated the assigned land in violation
of the condition for non-alienation and hence, the assignment

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
19
WP(C) No.28923/2019

as per Ext.P3 is liable to be cancelled under Rule 8(3) of Kerala
Land Assignment Rules, 1964, on this ground.
10. The next contention of the learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.6 is that the land ought not have been included
in the list of assignable land prepared under Rule 11 of the
Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964, as land containing
quarry is specifically excluded in Clause (viii) of Rule 11(2). As
per the Division Bench decision of this Court in Varkey Abraham
(supra), in order to constitute the quarry within the meaning of
Clause (viii) of Rule 11(2), it is not necessary that actual
quarrying should be undertaken in the land; that it is sufficient
that the land has the potential to be converted into a quarry as
understood in the common parlance; and that rock available in
the land and that too to a great extent, would satisfy the
requirement of the land being the one containing valuable
minerals within the meaning of Clause (viii). Of course, there is

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
20
WP(C) No.28923/2019

presence of rock as revealed from the attempt of the
Petitioners to obtain necessary permission for quarrying in the
assigned land. But there is nothing on record to show the
extent of rock in the assigned land. The status of the land
before the date of Ext.R6(d) Assignment Order is the relevant
one to consider. From the Patta Mahazar mentioned in Ext.P7
Order, it is clear that there was rubber cultivation in the land.
There is specific factual finding in Ext.P7 that, at the time of
issuance of Patta, the land was principally cultivated and it was
not rocky puramboke land unsuitable for cultivation. The mere
presence of rock far beneath the surface will not make the land
unsuitable for cultivation. Hence, it could not be assumed that
the assigned land is a quarry which could not be included in
the list of assignable land under Rule 11 of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964. Hence, the contention of the learned
Counsel for the Respondent No.6 that the land assigned as per
Ext.P3 Patta ought to have been excluded from the list of

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
21
WP(C) No.28923/2019

assignable land in the year 1965 is unsustainable. The
question whether the Petitioners are entitled to conduct
quarrying, if so, the question whether the quarrying would be
in violation of the conditions of assignment and the question
regarding the status of the orders/actions impugned in W.P.(C)
No.33512/2019 do not arise for consideration in this Writ
Petition, as admittedly, the Petitioners have not conducted any
quarrying operations in the assigned land. Those questions are
left open for consideration in appropriate proceedings at the
appropriate stage.
11. The next contention of the learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.6 is that the land was assigned for personal
cultivation and house-site, and it could not be used for
quarrying and an attempt to conduct quarrying alone is
sufficient for cancellation of assignment under Rule 8(3) of the
Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964. It is found in Ext.P7

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
22
WP(C) No.28923/2019

Order that though the Petitioners initiated proceedings to
conduct quarrying operations in the assigned land, quarrying
is not done in the assigned land. There is no case for the official
Respondents that the Petitioners have put the assigned
property to any use other than permitted in the Ext.R6(d) Order
of Assignment. There is no case for either the official
Respondents or for the Respondent No.6 that the Petitioners
physically attempted to conduct quarrying. Merely because the
Petitioners attempted to obtain permissions for quarrying, it
could not be said that the Petitioners attempted for quarrying.
Hence, this contention of the learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.6 is also not sustainable. I, once again, make
it clear that I have not said anything regarding the question
whether the quarrying would be in violation of the conditions of
assignment.

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
23
WP(C) No.28923/2019


12. The next question to be considered is whether it is
permissible to cancel the assignment invoking Rule 8(3) of the
Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964, after a long delay in

initiating proceedings for cancellation.
13. The Ext.R6(d) Order of Assignment is dated 15.04.1965.
Ext.P3 Patta is dated 31.07.1970. As revealed from Ext.P7, the
Respondent No.6 submitted a Petition for the first time on
20.02.2017. It is nearly 52 years after the issuance of Ext.R6(d)
Assignment Order and 50 years after the violation of the
condition for non-alienation. It is clear from Ext.P7 Order that
the Respondent No.6 submitted the Petition when he came to
know that the Petitioners are attempting to obtain permission
for quarrying in the assigned land. The Respondent No.6 is the
neighbouring landowner of the assigned land. His principal
grievance is with respect to the use of the assigned land for
quarrying and consequential nuisance to him. Even after a long

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
24
WP(C) No.28923/2019

period of the violation of the conditions of assignment, the
Government did not initiate any proceedings for cancellation of
assignment on its own. The proceedings which resulted in the
Ext.P7 Order of cancellation of assignment were initiated only
on the basis of the Petition submitted by the Respondent No.6.
14. In Chandy Chandy (supra) , the Division Bench of this Court
held that Rule 8 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964,
does not specify a period of limitation for exercising the power
for cancellation of the Patta that is already issued; that the
power must be exercised within a reasonable time; that as
regards what that reasonable time is, other provisions of the
Act are to be looked into for guidance; that Rule 8(1) mentions
a period of 25 years for non-alienation of lands and
simultaneously provides for a power to resume the assigned
lands if there is a breach of any conditions governing the
original assignment; that it is through the same provision that

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
25
WP(C) No.28923/2019

the power to resume lands on discovery of mistake/fraud, etc.,
is conferred; that therefore the statutory provision itself
indicates that the monitoring period for the Patta is only 25
years and if any action for cancellation of the Patta for breach
of the conditions under which it was granted is taken, it has to
be taken within that time. The Division Bench found that in the
said case, no action was taken by the State for almost 30/40
years from the date of issuance of the Patta; that the conduct
of the State in accepting tax in respect of the lands covered by
the Pattas would effectively estop it from contending that it had
no knowledge of the alleged fraudulent acts during all these
years; and that after the expiry of 30 years, the Writ Petitioners
would also be entitled under law to defend any action by the
State towards dispossessing them on the plea of adverse
possession.

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
26
WP(C) No.28923/2019


15. The contention of the learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.6 is that the limitation period prescribed by the
Division Bench is for initiating proceedings for cancellation of
Patta on account of non-compliance with the statutory
formalities. I am unable to accept the said contention. There is
no indication that the limitation period prescribed by the
Division Bench is only for initiating proceedings for cancellation
of Patta on account of non-compliance with the statutory
formalities. The Division Bench of this Court has not made any
such distinction while considering the period of limitation for
initiating proceedings under Rule 8(3) of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964, in the said decision. The purpose of
prescribing limitation period for the proceedings is to have
finality of the rights of the parties. If no limitation period is
prescribed for instituting the proceedings for cancellation of
Patta under Rule 8(3) of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules,
1964, there will be utter chaos and confusion with respect to

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
27
WP(C) No.28923/2019

the title of the land assigned under the provisions of the Kerala
Government Land Assignment Act, 1960, and the Rules made
thereunder, forever. The condition for non-alienation under
Rule 8(1) of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964, was for
a period of 10 years when Ext.R6(d) Order of Assignment was
issued. In Ext.R6(d) also, the same period is prescribed. Now,
as per Rule 8(1A) of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964,
the condition for non-alienation is applicable only for
assignment of unoccupied lands for a period of 12 years from
the date of assignment of the registry. Taking note of the dictum
laid down by the Division Bench of this Court in Chandy Chandy
(supra) , it can safely be concluded that the period of limitation
for initiating the proceedings for cancellation of assignment
under Rule 8(3) of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964,
is the period prescribed in the condition for non-alienation
applicable to the Patta, calculated from the date on which the
cause of action arose for initiating such proceedings. If the

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
28
WP(C) No.28923/2019

Government chooses to file a suit for recovery of the assigned
land, the period of limitation would be governed by the
limitation period of 30 years prescribed under Article 112 of the

Limitation Act, 1963.
16. In the case on hand, the period prescribed for the
condition for non-alienation was for 10 years. The condition for
non-alienation was violated as per Ext.P2 dated 23.06.1967.
The proceedings which resulted in Ext.P7 impugned Order was
initiated nearly 50 years after the violation. Even the limitation
period of 30 years for filing the suit for recovery of possession
by the Government is over by that time. The proceedings which
resulted in Ext.P7 impugned Order are clearly time-barred. The
impugned Ext.P7 Order passed in such proceedings is
unsustainable. The Petitioners are entitled to succeed in this
Writ Petition.

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
29
WP(C) No.28923/2019


17. Accordingly, I allow this Writ Petition by issuing a Writ of
Certiorari setting aside the proceedings which resulted in the
Ext.P7 Order, including Exts.P7 and P11 Orders.

Sd/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
Ncd/shg

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
30
WP(C) No.28923/2019

APPENDIX OF WP(C) NO. 28923 OF 2019

PETITIONER EXHIBITS

EXHIBIT P1 TRUE COPY OF THE SALE DEED NO.2654/1964
OF SRO CHENGANNUR DATED 11.8.1964.
EXHIBIT P2 TRUE COPY OF THE SETTLEMENT DEED
NO.2402/1967 OF SRO RANNI DATED
23.6.1967.
EXHIBIT P3 TRUE COPY OF THE PATTA ISSUED TO THE
PETITIONER DATED 31.1.1970.
EXHIBIT P4 TRUE COPY OF THE SETTLEMENT
NO.2200/1978 OF SRO RANNI DATED
17.8.1978.
EXHIBIT P5 TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE ISUSED TO 2ND
PETITIONER, DATED 22.1.2019.
EXHIBIT P6 TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION FILED BY
PETITIONERS DATED 24.9.2018.
EXHIBIT P7 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.C6-172387/18
OF 3RD RESPONDENT DATED 11.4.2019.
EXHIBIT P8 TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL FIELD BY
PETITIONERS DATED 2.5.2019.
EXHIBIT P9 TRUE COPY OF THE CROSS APPEAL BY THE
RESPONDENTS 6 TO 8 BEFORE THE 2ND
RESPONDENT DATED 25.9.2019.
EXHIBIT P10 TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION TO EXT.P9
FILED BY THE PETITIOENRS BEFORE THE 2ND
RESPONDENT DATED NIL.
EXHIBIT P11 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO:LRJ3-
16767/2019 DATE 4.10.2019 OF THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P12 TRUE COPY OF THE REVISION FILED BY THE
PETITIONERS BEFORE THE IST RESPONDENT
DATED 21.10.2019.
EXHIBIT P13 TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT OF THE
TAHSILDAR DATED 17.7.19
EXHIBIT P14 TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT OF THE
TAHSILDAR DATED 24.9.19

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
31
WP(C) No.28923/2019

EXHIBIT P15 TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER OF TALUK
OFFICE DATED 30.10.2019
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS

EXHIBIT R6(A) TRUE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE UDAMPADY
BEARING NO 2237/1959 OF CHENNANGUR SRO
EXHIBIT R6(A1) TRUE LEGIBLE AND TYPE WRITTEN COPY OF
EXHIBIT R6(A)
EXHIBIT R6(AB) TRUE COPY OF THE SALE DEED NO 2654/1964
OF CHENGANNUR SRO
EXHIBIT R6(B1) TRUE LEGIBLE AND TRYPEWRITTEN COPY OF
EXHIBIT R6(B)
EXHIBIT R6(C) TRUE COPY OF THE ASSESSMENT MAHASSER IN
RESPECT OF LA 368/65
EXHIBIT R6(D) TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF ASSIGNMENT
DATED 15.4.1965 ISSUED TO CHACKO CHANDY
EXHIBIT R6(E) TRUE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE GIFT DEED NO
2402/1967 OF RANNY SRO
EXHIBIT R6(E1) TRUE LEGIBLE AND TYPEWRITTEN COPY OF
EXHIBIT R6(E)
EXHIBIT R6(F) TRUE COPY OF FORM OF PATTA
EXHIBIT R6(G) TRUE COPY OF RELEASE DEED NO 814/1974
PF RANNY SRO IN FAVOUR OF ALEYAMMA
EXHIBIT R6(G1) TRUE LEGIBLE AND TYPEWRITTEN COPY OF
EXHIBIT R6(G)
EXHIBIT R6(H) TRUE COPY OF THE INFORMATION BEARING NO
21/18/PDY DATED 31.8.2018 ISSUED BY
INFORMATION OFFICER, PAZHAVANGADI
VILLAGE OFFICE
EXHIBIT R6(I) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED
20.2.2017 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 3RD RESPONDENT SEEKING TO
CANCEL PATA NO LA 368/65
EXHIBIT R6(J) TRUE COPY OF HE HEARING NOTES SUBMITTED
BY THIS RESPONDENT BEFORE THE 3RD
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT R6(K) TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED

CNR : KLHC010752332019
2026:KER:71963
32
WP(C) No.28923/2019

1.6.2018 IN WPC NO 17902/2018
EXHIBIT R6(L) TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER BEARING NO C6-
172387/18 DATED 11.4.2019 PASSED BY THE
2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT R6(M) TRUE COPY OF THE CROSS OBJECTION FILED
BY THIS RESPONDENT BEFORE THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT R6(N) TRUE COPY OF THE BEARING NOTES
SUBMITTED BY THIS RESPONDENT BEFORE THE
2ND RESPONDENT