Bal Kishan vs Union Of India And 6 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

AFR
(Judgment reserved on 08.10.2026)
(Judgment delivered on 12.11.2026)
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - C No. - 41461 of 2024
Bal Kishan
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
Union of India and 6 others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Ajay Kumar Singh, Ashish Kumar
Singh
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Dharmendra Srivastava, A.S.G.I.,
C.S.C., Sanjay Dwivedi
Court No. - 29
HON'BLE SIDDHARTHA VARMA, J.
HON'BLE KUNAL RAVI SINGH, J.
(Per: KUNAL RAVI SINGH, J.)
1. Heard Shri Ashish Kumar Singh, learned Senior Counsel assisted
by Shri Raghav Arora, learned counsel for the petitioner; learned
Additional Chief Standing Counsel for the State-respondents and Shri
Dharmendra Srivastava, learned counsel for the respondent no.3.
2. The present writ petition has been filed with the following prayers:

2
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
“a. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus commanding
the respondent authorities i.e. National Capital Region Transport Corporation
through its officers and men and others not to take possession of the land of
Khasra No.277 total area 950/947 square meter lying within the boundary
wall situated in Village Sivaya, Jamaullapur, Tehsil Sardhana, District Meerut
beyond the acquired area i.e. 320 square meter which the respondents
corporation has acquired under the provisions of The Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013.
b. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus commanding the
respondent authorities not to interfere in remaining 630 square meter land of
Petitioner's Plot No.277 total area 950/947 square meter lying within the
boundary wall situated in Village Sivaya, Jamaullapur, Tehsil Sardhana,
District Meerut.”
FACTS:-
3. The petitioner claims to be the owner in possession of Plot No. 277,
admeasuring approximately 950 sq. mtrs, and contiguous Plot No. 276,
admeasuring 1,900 sq. mtrs, situated in Village Sivaya, Jamaullapur,
Tehsil Sardhana, District Meerut. According to the petitioner, both plots,
including the remaining unacquired land, lie within a boundary wall.
4. For the implementation of the Delhi-Ghaziabad-Meerut Regional
Rapid Transit System (RRTS) Corridor, the National Capital Region
Transport Corporation (“NCRTC” for brevity), Respondent No. 3,
initiated land acquisition proceedings under the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 ("the Act of 2013" for brevity). A notification
under Section 11(1) of the Act of 2013 was issued on 27.04.2023,
followed by a notification under Section 19 dated 25.07.2023, published
in the Gazette on 26.07.2023. The initial notification provided for the
acquisition of 1,720 sq. mtrs of land out of Plot No. 276, in which the
petitioner had a share of 1,900 sq. mtrs, and 404 sq. mtrs of land out of
Plot No. 277, in which the petitioner had a share of 950 sq. mtrs.
5. Pursuant to joint measurement conducted on 05.06.2023 by the
Tehsildar, Sardhana, and Respondent No. 3, the area to be acquired was
determined. The award was declared by the Additional District

3
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
Magistrate (Land Acquisition), Joint Organization, Meerut, on
15.12.2023 in respect of the disputed plots. According to the award,
1,564 sq. mtrs of Plot No. 276 and 359 sq. mtrs of Plot No. 277 (of
which 320 sq. mtrs pertains to the petitioner's share) were acquired. The
petitioner received compensation in accordance with the award.
6. It is an admitted fact that the remaining portions of Plot Nos. 276
and 277 were declared non-agricultural land by an order dated
29.04.2024 passed under Section 80 of the U.P. Revenue Code, 2006.
7. On 20.05.2024, the petitioner approached the authorities for
demarcation of the acquired and unacquired land. When no action was
taken, the petitioner instituted Writ-C No. 20054 of 2024, seeking a writ
of mandamus commanding Respondent No. 3 not to take possession of
land in Plot No. 277 beyond the acquired area of 320 sq. mtrs under the
Act of 2013. The said writ petition was disposed of by this Court on
06.06.2024, directing the authorities to demarcate Plot Nos. 276 and 277
in accordance with law and the prescribed procedure, and not to take
possession of the land until completion of the exercise.
8. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner submitted applications to the Chief
Project Manager of Respondent No. 3, and the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Sardhana, requesting proper demarcation and an opportunity
to remain present during the demarcation. The demarcation was
undertaken on 19.06.2024. Several representations were subsequently
submitted to the revenue authorities, including the District Magistrate,
seeking proper demarcation and a copy of the report. The demarcation
report dated 12.07.2024 was supplied to the petitioner on 22.08.2024.
The report stated that possession had been taken of 0.1564 hectares in
Plot No. 276 and 0.0359 hectares in Plot No. 277, corresponding to the
area mentioned in the award.
9. The petitioner submitted detailed objections on 19/20.09.2024.
Possession of the acquired land was handed over to Respondent No. 3 by
the Addl. District Magistrate (Land Acquisition), Meerut, on 22.10.2024.

4
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
The petitioner submitted supplementary objections on 04.11.2024.
According to the petitioner, the eastern-facing wall was demolished on
29.11.2024.
10. The present writ petition has consequently been filed under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, seeking a direction restraining the
respondents from taking possession of Plot No. 277 beyond the acquired
area and from interfering with the petitioner's possession over the
remaining land until lawful demarcation is carried out and the objections
are considered.
11. After the writ petition had been entertained, the learned senior
advocate for the petitioner pointed out discrepancies between the map
annexed to the report and the map supplied to him. Taking note of the
said discrepancy, this Court, by an order dated 17.03.2025, directed
Respondent No. 3 to specifically respond to the contention that the
demarcation report submitted along with the written instructions by the
State respondents differed from the map annexed at page 75 of the writ
petition. Thereafter, by an order dated 09.12.2025, this Court directed
that a fresh survey be conducted in the presence of the petitioner and the
officials of Respondent No. 3 and that the report be submitted in a sealed
cover through the learned Addl. Chief Standing Counsel.
12. Pursuant thereto, a fresh demarcation report was prepared
following a spot inspection. Instead of the report being submitted to this
Court we find from submitted report that Respondent No. 3 raised
objections to the survey conducted on 22.12.2025, and the district
administration entertained those objections without any such directions
being issued by this Court. Thereafter, another survey was conducted on
12.01.2026 in the presence of the Chief Project Manager of respondent
No.3, namely Shri Aabodh Kumar. The report dated 12.01.2026 was
produced before the Court in a sealed cover, and time was granted to
learned counsel appearing for Respondent No. 3 to file objections.
Respondent No. 3 filed objections to the report dated 12.01.2026 and

5
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
prayed that reliance be placed on the earlier reports dated 05.06.2023
and 14.08.2024 submitted by the district administration.
PETITIONER’S SUBMISSIONS:
13. Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner is the owner in possession of Plot Nos. 276 and 277 to the
extent of his share, having a total area of approximately 2,850 sq. mtrs.
The acquisition proceedings relate only to specified portions of the
aforesaid plots, and the respondents are entitled to take possession only
of the land actually acquired in accordance with law.
14. Learned Senior counsel further submits that this Court, by order
dated 06.06.2024 passed in Writ-C No. 20054 of 2024, specifically
directed the authorities to demarcate Plot Nos. 276 and 277 in
accordance with law and the prescribed procedure and not to take
possession until completion of the demarcation exercise. However, the
demarcation carried out on 19.06.2024 was defective, as the revenue
officials allegedly failed to distinguish the acquired land from the
unacquired land by reference to fixed points prescribed for survey and
demarcation, and relied upon a power pole and a wall instead of fixed
reference points.
15. It is further submitted that the report dated 12.07.2024, supplied to
the petitioner on 22.08.2024, contained incorrect findings regarding Plot
No. 283, which neither belongs to the petitioner nor is in possession of
the petitioner. The same belongs to other persons and is occupied by
buildings and an educational institution. Learned senior advocate
contends that the petitioner's land within the boundary wall comprises
only of Plot Nos. 276 and 277, and the remaining portions of these plots
have wrongly been shown as falling within Plot No. 283.
16. Learned Senior counsel also submits that the authorities are
attempting to take possession of an area of Plot No. 277 exceeding the
area acquired, while leaving an equivalent area of Plot No. 276, despite
the petitioner's objection that a 275 KV high-tension electricity line

6
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
passes over the latter plot No.276. Such an adjustment cannot be made
unilaterally without following the procedure established by law.
17. It is lastly submitted that the petitioner has repeatedly approached
the competent revenue authorities and filed detailed objections against
the demarcation report, but the same have not been decided. Despite the
pending objections, the respondents allegedly demolished the eastern-
facing boundary wall on 29.11.2024. Learned counsel, therefore, prays
that the respondents be restrained from interfering with the petitioner's
possession over the unacquired portion of Plot No. 277 and that the
authorities be directed to undertake lawful demarcation and decide the
petitioner's objections before taking further action.
SUBMISSIONS OF RESPONDENT NO. 3 (NCRTC):-
18. Shri Dharmendra Srivastava, learned counsel for Respondent
No.3, submitted that Respondent No. 3 is executing the aforesaid RRTS
Corridor, a project of national importance aimed at providing efficient
public transport and reducing traffic congestion and pollution in the
National Capital Region.
19. Learned counsel submitted that the land acquisition proceedings in
respect of Khasra Nos. 276 and 277 were initiated under the Act of 2013,
after following the prescribed procedure, and that the petitioner received
the compensation awarded for the acquired land.
20. Furthermore, in compliance with the order dated 06.06.2024
passed in the petitioner's earlier writ petition, demarcation was
conducted on 19.06.2024, and that Respondent No.3 has taken
possession only of the acquired portions of Khasra Nos. 276 and 277. It
is submitted that the petitioner is attempting to obstruct the construction
of the RRTS Corridor by raising an untenable dispute.
21. Learned counsel submitted that the earlier measurement reports
dated 05.06.2023 and 14.08.2024 contain consistent measurements,

7
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
whereas the subsequent reports dated 08.01.2026 and 12.01.2026
disclose materially different figures without any satisfactory explanation.
Respondent No.3 also raised objections to the subsequent measurement
proceedings, particularly regarding the methodology adopted and the use
of a crumpled revenue map.
22. Accordingly, learned counsel for the respodnent No.3 prayed that
reliance be placed upon the earlier consistent measurement reports and
that the petitioner's successive proceedings be rejected, as they are
allegedly delaying a project of national importance and causing
substantial public revenue loss.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE STATE RESPONDENTS:-
23. Learned Additional Chief Standing Counsel, appearing for the
State respondents, submitted that the acquisition proceedings were
conducted in accordance with the Act of 2013 and that possession was
taken only of the area acquired under the award. Furthermore the latest
report, which was prepared under the specific order of the Court, has
been filed which should be taken into consideration while deciding the
rival submissions of the parties.
24. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the records of
the case. Based on the submission and records annexed, the following
points of determination are framed for adjudication of the dispute.
POINTS OF DETERMINATION:-
25. The following points of determination are framed to adjudicate the
issue in hand:
(I) Whether Respondent No. 3 has taken possession of more than the
area acquired in Plot No. 277 what was acquired and
correspondingly less area in plot No.276 than what was acquired?
(II) which of the demarcation reports are to be relied upon for
deciding the dispute?

8
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
DISCUSSION:-
26. It transpires from the record that two plots of the petitioner,
namely, Plot Nos. 276 and 277, were acquired by Respondent No. 3 for
implementation of the RRTS Corridor project. The petitioner is not
challenging the payment of compensation but is aggrieved by the
manner in which the remaining portions of the two plots have been dealt
with and seeks their demarcation. The dispute relates to the manner in
which the land acquired by Respondent No. 3 has been taken into
possession. The present dispute only relates to a factual dispute of
demarcation of the remaining un-acquired area of plot Nos.276 and 277.
Although the writ Courts ordinarily do not deal with issues of fact but in
the present case there is a specific spot inspection report prepared as per
the direction of the Court which has to be taken into consideration to
decide the matter at hand.
27. There have been successive reports indicating different positions
regarding the land actually taken into possession. The first two reports
supported the stand of Respondent No. 3 that possession had been taken
in accordance with the award. However, discrepancies were pointed out
in the report dated 12.07.2024. Taking note of the said discrepancies, this
Court passed the orders dated 17.03.2025 and 09.12.2025. Paragraph 2
of the latter order dated 09.12.2025 being relevant for deciding the
dispute, is extracted hereinbelow:
"2. In view of the observation made by the Division Bench of this Court
dated 17.03.2025, we find that there is some discrepancy and variance to the
map submitted by the Authority. In order to dispel such discrepancy, it would
be appropriate to have a fresh report. Accordingly, we direct to the District
Magistrate, Meerut to constitute another revenue team consisting of Sub
Divisional Magistrate, Sardhna, Meerut who may make a spot inspection and
submit a report in accordance with the Survey Rules after affixing the
boundary mark as per revenue map but certainly in the presence of petitioner
and the official of National Capital Region Transport Corporation in a sealed
cover through learned Additional Chief Standing Counsel in the instant
matter."
28. In our considered view, any report prepared before 09.12.2025
loses its significance, as this Court had already found discrepancies

9
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
which could only be resolved by obtaining a fresh demarcation report
from the revenue officials.
29. The earlier reports dated 05.06.2023 and 14.08.2024, though
consistent with each other, were prepared before this Court noticed the
discrepancy in the maps by its order dated 17.03.2025. Mere consistency
between those reports does not answer the discrepancy so noticed, which
could be resolved only by a fresh measurement on the spot.
30. The report dated 12.01.2026, prepared pursuant to the order dated
09.12.2025, contained the relevant details, which are as under:
" 0 0 0 0 0 –276 277
इस प्रकार ए सी आर टी सी द्वारा गाटा संख्या व में अधि ग्रहित भूहिम का स्थलीय
:–
पैमाइश के अनुसार हिववरण हिनम्नवत् ै

खसरा
नम्बर

कुल
क्षेत्रफल

खतौनी अनुसार
कृषक

का नाम
अधि ग्रहित
भूहिम

आरआरटीएस

द्वारा वत0मान में

भौधितक रूप से

कब्जा प्राप्त भूहिम
अभ्युहि6
276 0.1900
बालकृष्ण पुत्र जगदीश

हिनवासी ग्राम सिसवाया
जमाउल्लापुर
1564
वग0
0
मी
1240 0 0 0 0
वग0 मी आर आर टी ए
0
स द्वारा अधि ग्रण
324
के सापेक्ष वग0

मीटर कम भूहिम पर

कब्जा प्राप्त हिकया

गया ै
277 0.3790
ज्ञानेन्द्र सिंस  पुत्र
,
गुलबीर रणवीर सिंस  व

जगबीर सिंस  पुत्रगण
,
रतन सिंस  महि पाल व

रपाल पुत्रगण

गंगाचरण ग्रामवासी
39
वग0
0
मी
39 0 —
वग0 मी

बालकृष्ण पुत्र जगदीश

हिनवासी ग्राम सिसवाया
(950
जमाउल्लापुर वग0
0)
मी
320
वग0
0
मी
644 0 0 0 0
वग0 मी आर आर टी ए
0
स द्वारा अधि ग्रण
324
के सापेक्ष वग0

मीटर अधि क भूहिम

पर कब्जा प्राप्त हिकया

गया ै
31. A perusal of the details mentioned in the report dated 12.01.2026
indicates that, in respect of Plot No. 276, the acquired area was 1,564 sq.
mtrs, whereas Respondent No. 3 had taken physical possession of only
1,240 sq. mtrs, leaving 324 sq. mtrs yet to be taken into possession.

10
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
However, in respect of Plot No. 277, against the acquired area of 320 sq.
mtrs, Respondent No. 3 had taken possession of 644 sq. mtrs, thereby
encroaching upon an additional area of 324 sq. mtrs.
32. The aforesaid survey conducted on 12.01.2026 disclosed the same
position as that recorded in the demarcation exercise conducted on
22.12.2025. Thus, according to the latest report prepared pursuant to the
order dated 09.12.2025, Respondent No. 3 had taken possession of less
land in Plot No. 276 and more land in Plot No. 277 than the respective
areas required to be acquired under the award.
33. Upon examination of the report, it appears that the dispute
primarily concerns the additional land taken by Respondent No. 3 in Plot
No. 277. The petitioner alleges that a high-tension wire passes over Plot
No. 276, affecting the project of Respondent No. 3, and that, to
compensate for the passage of the high-tension wire over Plot No. 276,
Respondent No. 3 has taken additional land in Plot No. 277. This
contention has been refuted by learned counsel appearing for
Respondent No. 3. Be that as it may, it appears to us that the dispute
primarily concerns the factual position at the site.
34. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the report
prepared pursuant to the directions issued by this Court on 09.12.2025.
The fresh report has been placed before the Court and supplied to
learned counsel for the petitioner. The objections raised by Respondent
No. 3 are that the land measurement conducted on 12.01.2026 was
carried out by holding the revenue map in bare hands, causing it to
become crumpled, and that the measurement was not conducted with due
care and caution. In support of these objections, Respondent No. 3 has
shown a letter dated 13.01.2026 addressed to the District Magistrate,
Meerut, alleging errors in the report dated 12.01.2026 and expressing the
apprehension that the land measurement may have been carried out by
holding the revenue map in bare hands.

11
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
35. However, Respondent No. 3 has not sought a fresh demarcation
report in its objections but has merely requested that the earlier reports
be considered. This contention cannot be accepted because this Court
had already noticed discrepancies in the earlier reports and, taking note
of them, directed that a fresh report be prepared. Furthermore, when the
first spot inspection was done on 22.12.2025, the respondent 3 raised an
objection to the survey and upon that objection, a fresh survey was
conducted on 12.01.2026 which found the position as same to the survey
of 22.12.2025. Thus in essence, the objections of the respondent 3 were
dealt with by the district administration itself. Therefore, we have no
hesitation in holding that the report dated 12.01.2026, submitted in a
sealed cover pursuant to the order dated 09.12.2025, is the report to be
considered for deciding the dispute.
36. While directing fresh demarcation by the revenue officials, this
Court was conscious of the fact that the dispute involved a question of
fact requiring physical verification of the land. Accordingly, the Court
directed the constitution of a revenue team comprising the Sub-
Divisional Magistrate, Sardhana, District Meerut, to conduct a spot
inspection and submit a report in accordance with the survey rules. Since
the survey was conducted pursuant to the directions contained in the
order dated 09.12.2025, we do not find any illegality in the conduct of
the revenue officials.
37. The objections raised by Respondent No. 3, therefore, become
superfluous. Once the revenue team had been directed to demarcate the
disputed area, it was required to carry out the exercise in accordance
with law and without being influenced by any extraneous consideration.
38. In our view, the exercise carried out by the concerned revenue
officials appears to be just and proper, and we see no reason to doubt the
report submitted in the sealed cover. The report clearly states that
Respondent No. 3 has taken possession of a lesser area in Plot No. 276
and a greater area in Plot No. 277 than the respective areas required to be
acquired under the award.

12
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
ANSWER TO THE POINTS OF DETERMINATION:-
39. As regards Issue (I), the report dated 12.01.2026 shows that in Plot
No. 276 the acquired area was 1,564 sq. mtrs, whereas Respondent No. 3
has taken possession of only 1,240 sq. mtrs, that is, 324 sq. mtrs less.
In Plot No. 277, against the acquired area of 320 sq. mtrs,
Respondent No. 3 has taken possession of 644 sq. mtrs, that is, 324 sq.
mtrs more. The point is, therefore, answered in the affirmative and in
favour of the petitioner.
40. As regards Issue (II), the reports prepared before 09.12.2025 lost
their significance, as this Court had already noticed discrepancies in
them and had directed a fresh report. The report dated 12.01.2026,
submitted in a sealed cover pursuant to the order dated 09.12.2025, was
prepared by the revenue team constituted under the directions of this
Court. The objections of Respondent No. 3 to it have been found to be
superfluous. The said report is, therefore, the report to be relied upon for
deciding the dispute.
CONCLUSION:-
41. Therefore, we have no hesitation in holding that the excess area of
324 sq. mtrs in Plot No. 277 shall be returned to the petitioner, and
possession thereof shall be handed over to him forthwith by Respondent
No. 3.
42. Respondent No. 3 shall be at liberty to take possession of the
remaining 324 sq. mtrs in Plot No. 276 in accordance with the award and
the area acquired for the project.
43. If Respondent No. 3 intends to retain the additional land in Plot
No. 277, adequate compensation shall be paid to the petitioner, the
amount of which shall be determined by concerned authority in
accordance with law, after giving notice and an opportunity of hearing to
the petitioner.

13
WRIC No. - 41461 of 2024
44. As regards the demolition of the eastern-facing boundary wall on
29.11.2024, no finding is recorded in this judgment, and the petitioner is
at liberty to avail such remedy as is available to him in law.
45. The writ petition stands allowed in the above terms. The
petitioner's objections dated 19/20.09.2024 and 04.11.2024 stand
disposed of in terms of this judgment. There shall be no order as to costs.
(Kunal Ravi Singh,J.) (Siddhartha Varma,J.)
November 12, 2026
NLY
Digitally signed by :-
NAND LAL YADAV
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad