IN THE GOODS OF SRI DHIRENDRA MOHAN OJHA (DEC.) -AND- SMRITIREKHA OJHA AND BIVA NANDY vs MUKTI OJHA (KUMAR), MALA OJHA (KUNDU) DIPTI OJHA, TRIPTI OJHA (ROY) BANANI OJHA (INDU)
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
TESTAMENTARY AND INTESTATE JURISDICTION
ORIGINAL SIDE
IA NO. GA/5/2024 In TS/1/2022
IN THE GOODS OF SRI DHIRENDRA MOHAN OJHA (DEC.)
-AND
SMRITIREKHA OJHA AND BIVA NANDY
Vs
MUKTI OJHA (KUMAR), MALA OJHA (KUNDU) DIPTI OJHA, TRIPTI
OJHA (ROY), BANANI OJHA (INDU)
BEFORE: The Hon’ble JUSTICE APURBA SINHA RAY
For the petitioners
: Mr. Rupak Ghosh, Adv.
Mr. Arnab Dutt, Adv.
For the
respondents
: Ms. Suparna Basu, Adv.
Mr. Saikat Chatterjee, Adv.
Mr. Manabendranath Bandhopadhyay,
Adv.
CAV on : 13.10.2026
Judgment on : 17.11.2026
1. This application was filed by the defendants/ the erstwhile caveatrix
praying for recall of the order dated 26/04/2024 whereby the
propounders’ prayer for grant of probate of the will executed by the
Testator Late Dhirendra Mohan Ojha was allowed ex-parte. The
grounds, as found in the instant application as well as two
supplementary affidavits, are, inter alia, the petitioners changed their
advocates but the new advocate appointed by them failed to take
Page 1 of 9
appropriate steps at the appropriate time and further, no notice was
served upon them to inform the date of holding ex-parte hearing. The
Court wrongfully discharged the caveat on the prayer of the
propounders and passed the order dated 26/04/2024 without dealing
with the issues framed by the Court. It is also urged that the petitioners
were busy with prolonged illness of Ahana Kundu, daughter of Mala
Ojha (Kundu), one of the petitioners herein, and ultimately Ahana
passed away after suffering from a chronic illness. The other petitioners
also were not medically fit to appear before the court. Due to all these
reasons they could not appear before the court personally and the Court
probated the will without affording the petitioners to cross examine the
propounders’ witnesses. If the order dated 26/04/2024 is not recalled,
the petitioners would suffer irreparable injury.
2. Mr. Rupak Ghosh, learned Advocate for the petitioners have relied upon
the following judgments:
i) In the matter of Goods of Saroj Kumar Chatterjee
(deceased) in T.S. No. 14 of 2006 and G.A. No. 3120 of 2006
reported in 2017 SCC OnLine Cal 21463
ii) Malkiat Singh and another vs. Joginder Singh and
Ors. reported in (1998) 2 SCC 206
iii) G.P. Srivastava vs. R.K. Raizada and Ors. reported in
(2000) 3 SCC 54
iv) Sushila Narahari and others vs. Nandakumar and
another reported in (1996) 5 SCC 529
3. The propounders’ learned counsel Mr. Suparna Basu vehemently
opposes the prayer for recall. According to Ms. Basu, it is not correct that
Page 2 of 9
no notice was served upon the caveatrix. They appeared and contested
the proceedings till the framing of the issues, and thereafter suddenly
disappeared from the proceedings and the appointed Counsel from M/s
R L Dutta did not take steps in the proceedings due to lack of material
instructions from the caveatrix (quoted in the written argument at page
no. 9). It is also not correct that due to illness of several persons the
caveatrix failed to appear in the proceedings since during the relevant
period they changed their Advocates and executed vokalatnama in favour
of their new Advocate, Mr. Ajit Keshari who eventually filed the
vokalatnama after the order dated 26/04/2024 was passed. Therefore,
it is not at all true that the caveatrix were not aware of the proceedings.
After the order dated 26/04/2024 was passed, the caveatrix again
engaged M/s R L Dutta to file an appropriate application for recall of the
said order. The original recall petition did not contain all the above
grounds for recall and by filing two supplementary affidavits the
caveatrix ultimately were able to bring on record all the abovesaid
grounds which are afterthought with an aim to reopen a finally concluded
proceedings. The record speaks of several opportunities given to the
caveatrix before proceeding ex parte. According to Ms. Basu the order
dated 26/04/2024 was rightly passed by the Court after discharging the
caveat filed by the defendants on their continued no-appearance. She
has relied upon the following decisions.
i) Budhia Swain & Ors. v. Gopinath Deb & Ors., (1999) 4
SCC 396 : AIR 1999 SC 2089.
ii) Parimal v. Veena @ Bharti, (2011) 3 SCC 545
iii) Salil Dutta v. T.M. & M.C. Private Ltd., (1993) 2 SCC 185
Page 3 of 9
iv) Eruch Rustom Irani v. Limji Kaikashroo Pandey, 1993 (1)
Bom CR 340 ; 1992 (94) Bom LR 351.
v) In the Goods of Pashupati Nath Banerjee, PLA No. 113 of
2010, order dated 5th September, 2024 (Calcutta High Court).
4. After considering the rival submissions of the learned counsel of
the parties and the judgments cited by them, I would like to say that it
is not correct that before passing of the order dated 26/04/2024, the
issues framed were not considered by the court. Let us examine the
issues framed by the court. They are:
1. Is the suit maintainable in its present form?
2. Whether the signature appearing in the Will dated
13th August, 2017 is the original signature of Late
Dhirendra Mohan Ojha?
3. Whether the Will of Late Dhirendra Mohan Ojha was
executed out of his free will, volition and with sound mind
and health ?
4. Whether the attesting witnesses had seen the
testator to sign the Will on the relevant date and time ?
5. Whether the testator affixed the signature in presence
of both the attesting witnesses or not ?
6. Whether the Will of Late Dhirendra Mohan Ojha dated
13th August, 2017 has been executed as per the provisions
of the Indian Succession Act, 1925?
7. Are the plaintiffs entitled to reliefs as prayed for?
8. To what other relief or reliefs are the plaintiffs entitled
?
5. Now, let me reproduce the order dated 26/04/2024 in the
following paragraphs:
Page 4 of 9
“The instant application for grant of probate has been
initiated at the instance of two executors, namely, Mrs.
Smritirekha Ojha and Mrs. Biva Nandy. According to them,
Sri Dhirendra Mohan Ojha who died on 25.10.2017 at
Narayani Superspeciality Hospital, Barasat, had made his
last Will and Testament on 30.08.2017 whereby he
appointed the above petitioners as joint executrix. After his
death, the probate application has been filed showing the
names of his legal heirs. It appears from the record that
there are seven legal heirs which include his wife, one son
and five daughters. After citations were effected, five
daughters appeared and submitted caveats and in support
of such 2 caveats, one affidavit was filed. The matter
became contentious accordingly. Issues were framed on 6th
September, 2023 and subsequent to framing of issues the
caveatrix did not appear and did not contest in spite of
getting sufficient opportunities. However, the plaintiffs have
been able to examine two attesting witnesses, namely, Mr.
Sahidullah and Mr. Arun Goswami as witness no.1 and
witness no.2 respectively. On 25.04.2024 this Court
passed an order discharging the caveat filed by the five
daughters of the deceased. After going through the records,
it appears that the attesting witness being PW-1, Mr.
Sahidullah has stated on oath that the testator affixed his
signature on the Will in his presence. He has further stated
that the testator, Sri Dhirendra Mohan Ojha, since
deceased, had made the said Will out of his own accord
and when he was in sound mind. The said witness has also
been able to identify the signatures of the testator and other
witnesses. PW-2, Mr. Arun Goswami has also identified the
relevant Will as the Will of Sri Dhirendra Mohan Ojha. He
has also deposed that the testator has signed on all the
pages of the Will. According to PW-2, apart from Sri
Page 5 of 9
Dhirendra Mohan Ojha, one Mr. Sahidullah and he himself
were present at the time of execution of the said Will. He
has also deposed on the question put to him by the Court
that he had seen the testator to sign the document. It
appears from the record that in spite of having the
opportunity to crossexamine the said witnesses, the
defendants did not take any steps to crossexamine them. It
is a settled principle of law that when statements are made
on oath and the same remain uncontroverted and
unchallenged by the other sides 3 in spite of having
opportunity to do so, such statements shall be deemed to
have been admitted by them. In view of the above
unchallenged testimonials of the attesting witnesses, it
appears that the plaintiffs have been able to prove their
case in accordance with law. Let there be an order in terms
of prayer (c) of the original application, subject to
compliance of all the legal formalities. TS/1/2022 stands
disposed of accordingly.”
6. From the above it appears that at the time of passing the order
th
dated 26 April, 2024, the Court had dealt with all the relevant issues
th
framed on 6 September, 2023. The Court has subsequently taken into
consideration the deposition of two attesting witnesses who proved the
relevant Will by deposing that the testator himself affixed his signature
on the Will in their presence. They had also deposed, as PW 1 and PW 2,
that the deceased had made the said Will out of his own accord and when
he was in sound state of mind. All the attesting witnesses had recollected
the presence of the other attesting witness. They had also stated that the
testator put his signatures in their presence. Therefore, all the relevant
Page 6 of 9
issues whether the late Dhirendra Mohan Ojha has executed the Will out
of his free will and volition and with sound mind and health and also the
other issues whether the attesting witnesses had seen the testator to sign
the will on the relevant date and time and the issues whether the testator
affixed the signature in presence of both the attesting witnesses were
taken into consideration. As the said statements of the attesting
witnesses remain unchallenged and unshaken from the side of the
defendants, the Court came to the conclusion that the plaintiffs were
able to prove their case in accordance with law. In view of the above, I do
find that the basic ingredients of proving the Will were considered in the
order dated 26.04.2024 in connection with TS 1 of 2022.
7. Therefore, I find no merit in the contention of the learned counsel
for the applicants. However, I find one important aspect of the case in
dealing with the recall application. Admittedly, the previous advocate for
the present applicants from M/s. R.L. Datta refused to appear on behalf
of the applicants/defendants in contesting the probate proceedings.
Nevertheless, it is evident that prior to the passing of the order dated
26.04.2024, the applicants engaged a new counsel, Mr. Ajit Keshari, and
executed a Vakalatnama in place of their previous advocate. Mr. Ajit
Keshari, learned counsel for the applicants, failed to take appropriate
steps before the Court on or before 26.04.2024 and instead submitted
the Vakalatnama to the department in May 2024—subsequent to the
passing of the order dated 26.04.2024. Ironically, the applicants were
compelled to re-engage their previous advocate, and subsequently,
Page 7 of 9
advocates from M/s. R.L. Datta resumed taking steps for the recall of the
order dated 26.04.2024.
8. These facts, as narrated above, highlight the predicament faced
by litigants. Despite attempting to substitute one counsel for another,
the newly engaged counsel failed to act diligently at the appropriate time.
The foregoing facts also disclose that the previous advocates, who had
earlier withheld appearance due to a lack of material instructions, were
once more called upon to represent the applicants—who are the
daughters of the testator. Without entering into the merits of the case
and without apportioning blame for whose fault the order dated
26.04.2024 was passed in the absence of the applicants, I have come to
the irresistible conclusion that it would result in a gross miscarriage of
justice if the five daughters of the testator are precluded from contesting
the proceedings, particularly given the unfortunate circumstances
surrounding the engagement of counsel and their consequent non-
cooperation.
9. The applicants have successfully demonstrated that the order
dated 26.04.2024 was passed in their absence, and that such absence
was directly attributable to the non-cooperation of their learned
counsel—whether previously or subsequently engaged. It is a settled
principle of law that a litigant public should not suffer on account of the
non-cooperation, laches, or inaction of their counsel. Accordingly, I am
constrained to allow the recall application, subject to the payment of a
cost of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) to be paid to the
Page 8 of 9
propounders by the applicants within a period of two weeks from the date
of this order, failing which this order shall stand recalled. The applicants
are granted an opportunity to cross-examine PW 1 and PW 2, and both
parties are granted liberty to adduce further oral and documentary
evidence in support of their respective cases. The caveat filed by the five
daughters of the testator is hereby restored.
10. Accordingly, GA 5 of 2024 stands allowed subject to payment of
cost as aforesaid.
11. Liberty is granted to the parties to mention the matter before the
appropriate Bench for expeditious listing and directions.
12. The order dated 26.04.2024 passed in connection with T.S. No. 1
of 2022 is hereby recalled, subject to the payment of costs as aforesaid.
13. All parties shall act in terms of the server copy of the order
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
14. Urgent photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all necessary formalities.
( Apurba Sinha Ray, J. )
Page 9 of 9