Sh. Amar Gupta vs M/S. Arvi Lights & Anr.

Court
Delhi High Court

$~21
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Date of Decision : 06.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010540982026
+ CM(M)-IPD 59/2026
SH. AMAR GUPTA .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Siddharth Arora, Advocate.
versus
M/S. ARVI LIGHTS & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shravan Kumar Bansal and Mr.
Pankaj Kumar, Advocates for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
TEJAS KARIA, J. ( ORAL )
CM 296/2026 (Exemption)
1. Exemption is allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2. The Application stands disposed of.
CM 297/2026 (Condonation of delay)
3. This Application has been filed under Section 151 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (“ CPC ”) seeking condonation of delay of 19 days in
refiling the present Petition.
4. Having regard to the averments made in the present Application, the
same is allowed. The delay of 19 days in refiling the present Petition is
hereby condoned.
5. The Application stands disposed of.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 1 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

CM(M)-IPD 59/2026
6. The present Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
1950 (“ Constitution ”) has been preferred against the order dated
12.08.2026 (“ Impugned Order ”), passed by learned District Judge,
Commercial Court-13, Central District, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi
(“ Commercial Court ”) in CS(COMM) No. 543/2024 (“ Suit ”), whereby the
application filed by the Petitioner under Order XI Rules 1(5) and 1(12) of
the CPC (“ Application ”), seeking leave to take on record the additional
documents produced as Ex. PW-2/1 to Ex. PW-2/6 (OSR) (“ Additional
Documents ”), was dismissed.
7. The brief facts germane to the present Petition are that the Petitioner
instituted the Suit on 02.05.2024 against the Respondents seeking a
permanent injunction restraining infringement of the registered Trade Mark
‘BAISUN’ (“ Subject Mark ”), passing off, copyright infringement, delivery
up, rendition of accounts and damages.
8. On 11.12.2024, the learned Commercial Court framed issues,
including Issue No. 6, namely, whether the Petitioner is not the owner of the
Subject Mark or is a fraudulent adopter of the Subject Mark from a third-
party. The onus of the said issue was placed on the Respondents. A learned
Local Commissioner was also appointed to record evidence.
9. Respondent No. 1 settled the dispute with the Petitioner on
28.02.2025 under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC, and a compromise decree
was passed qua Respondent No. 1. The Suit is sub judice only against
Respondent No. 2.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 2 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

10. On 25.03.2025, the Petitioner filed a list of witnesses, nominating Mr.
Lokesh Kumar Gupta (“ PW-2 ”), partner of M/s Shri Vinayak Industries
(“ Vinayak Industries ”), as PW-2. On 25.04.2025, the affidavit of evidence
(“ Affidavit ”) of PW-2 was placed on record along with an index of
documents, and advance copies were furnished to learned Counsel for
Respondent No. 2.
11. On 12.06.2025, PW-2 appeared before the learned Local
Commissioner, tendered his Affidavit and produced and exhibited original
Additional Documents. Respondent No. 2 cross-examined PW-2 on the
Additional Documents, while recording an objection that leave of the Court
had not been obtained.
12. On 22.07.2025, the learned Commercial Court noted that the
Additional Documents had not been filed with the Plaint and observed that
the Petitioner should move an appropriate application before the hearing of
final arguments. The Petitioner filed the Application on 21.08.2025.
13. The learned Commercial Court dismissed the Application by the
Impugned Order stating that the Additional Documents, namely the Goods
and Services Tax (“ GST ”) Registration Certificate, the Partnership Deed
along with its reconstitution, and the Aadhaar Card of PW-2, are routine
business documents which cannot be said to be in the exclusive possession
of the father of PW-2.
14. Aggrieved by the Impugned Order, the Petitioner filed the present
Petition.
15. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the Impugned Order
proceeds on a mistaken factual premise. The Impugned Order records that
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 3 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

Mr. Shyam Lal Gupta, a former partner of Vinayak Industries, was the father
of PW-2. It was submitted that Mr. Shyam Lal Gupta was the father of the
Petitioner and not of PW-2, who is the son of Late Mr. R.K. Gupta, as sworn
in his Affidavit and recorded in his cross-examination. It was submitted that
PW-2 is an independent third-party who joined Vinayak Industries only on
08.02.2022, whereas the Petitioner’s late father was a partner in Vinayak
Industries from 07.01.2014 until his demise on 05.11.2021. According to the
Petitioner, this is an error apparent on the face of the record, which led the
learned Commercial Court to wrongly conclude that the Additional
Documents were within the control and possession of the witness’s family
and should have been in the Petitioner’s possession when the Plaint was
filed.
16. It was submitted that the Petitioner is not a partner in Vinayak
Industries, which is an independent entity whose constitutional records,
deeds and tax registrations remained in the custody and control of its own
partners. The Petitioner could not have produced the original partnership
deeds of a third-party at the time of filing the Suit, which, according to him,
constitutes reasonable cause within the meaning of Order XI Rule 1(5) of
the CPC. It was also submitted that the observation in the Impugned Order
that the Additional Documents are routine business documents which cannot be
said to be in the exclusive possession of the father of PW-2 is wholly perverse.
17. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the invoices of
Vinayak Industries are already on record and stand exhibited as Ex. PW-1/5,
and that their placement on record is not disputed. It was submitted on
behalf of the Petitioner that the Additional Documents are sought to be
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 4 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

placed on record with respect to the existence of Vinayak Industries, and
that prior use of Subject Mark is the main issue in the Suit. It was submitted
by learned Counsel for the Petitioner that the finding in the Impugned Order
that no utility of the Additional Documents is mentioned in the Application
overlooks the Application and Issue No. 6.
18. According to the Petitioner, since Respondent No. 2 has challenged
the Petitioner’s title and alleged dishonest adoption in the Written Statement,
the Additional Documents, namely the constituent deeds and GST records of
Vinayak Industries produced through PW-2, establish the commercial use of
the Subject Mark by Vinayak Industries between 2014 and 2018 and its
continuity through the Petitioner’s late father, establish the authenticity of
the invoices, and directly rebut the allegation of fraudulent adoption under
Issue No. 6.
19. It was further submitted by learned Counsel for the Petitioner that the
learned Commercial Court failed to appreciate Order XI Rule 1(12) of the
CPC, under which, according to the Petitioner, the embargo on filing
additional documents without leave does not apply to documents produced
by witnesses during examination for refreshing memory or proving
independent third-party records. It was also submitted that the identity card
of PW-2 is indispensable to establish the competence and identity of the
witness who appeared before the learned Local Commissioner.
20. It was submitted by learned Counsel for the Petitioner that the Application
was filed on 21.08.2025 strictly pursuant to the directions of the learned
Commercial Court dated 22.07.2025, to regularise the record before final
arguments, and not as a belated measure. The Additional Documents had been
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 5 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

on record since 25.04.2025 with advance copies furnished to Respondent No. 2,
and PW-2 was cross examined at length on 12.06.2025 on each of the
Additional Documents.
21. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner further submitted that Trade Mark
suits are ordinarily filed in a state of exigency and sought to explain the non-
filing of the Additional Documents with the Plaint on that basis. Learned
Counsel acknowledged that there was a typographical error in the pleadings
and stated that the pleading requires correction only with respect to
Paragraph No. 4 of the Plaint.
22. Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 2 submitted that the Impugned
Order does not require any interference in exercise of jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution as the learned Commercial Court has given
reasons for not allowing the Application filed by the Petitioner seeking to
produce Additional Documents stating that the Petitioner has described
Vinayak Industries in Paragraph No. 4 of the Plaint as the proprietorship
concern of the Petitioner and, therefore, there was no utility of the
Additional Documents for the purpose of the facts to be proved.
23. Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 2 further submitted that in view
of the categorical averment that Vinayak Industries was a proprietorship
concern of the Petitioner, no documents in the form of Additional
Documents can be placed on record to prove that Vinayak Industries was a
partnership firm. Accordingly, it was submitted by the learned Counsel for
Respondent No. 2 that unless the Petitioner amends the Plaint, no Additional
Documents can be taken on record to prove facts that are contrary to the
pleading in the Plaint.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 6 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

24. Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 2 submitted that when PW-2
was cross-examined on 12.06.2025, the objection was taken by Respondent
No. 2 with regard to relying upon the Additional Documents by PW-2 in
support of his Affidavit. In view of the same, the Impugned Order has
rightly rejected the Application since the Additional Documents cannot
prove the facts that are not even pleaded by the Petitioner in the Plaint.
25. Heard learned Counsel for the Parties. The main issue arising in this
Petition is whether the Petitioner is entitled to place the Additional
Documents to establish commercial continuity and prior lawful use through
Petitioner’s late father, authenticity of the sales invoices, which are
exhibited as Ex. PW-1/5 and to rebut the allegation of fraudulent adoption to
prove Issue No. 6.
26. The Petitioner has not placed a copy of the Application on record of
this Petition explaining the basis pleaded by the Petitioner before the learned
Commercial Court on which the Impugned Order was passed. As per the
averments in the Petition, the Petitioner has sought to rely upon the
Additional Documents to defend Issue No. 6 that the Petitioner is not the
owner of the Subject Mark or is a fraudulent adopter of the Subject Mark
from a third-party.
27. In Paragraph No. 4 of the Plaint, the Petitioner has stated that the
Petitioner adopted the Subject Mark to promote his goods and the Petitioner
has incorporated various entities including Vinayak Industries, which is
stated to be the proprietorship of the Petitioner, for running its business
under the Subject Mark.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 7 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

28. However, in the Affidavit of PW-2, it is stated that Vinayak Industries
is a partnership concern of PW-2 and Mr. Abhishek Gupta. Further, the
Affidavit of PW-2 mentions that PW-2 became the partner of Vinayak
Industries on 08.02.2022 by way of the Re-Constitution of Partnership Deed
dated 08.02.2022 and has filed the same as Ex. PW-2/3 along with the
Affidavit.
29. The Affidavit of PW-2 further states that the father of the Petitioner,
Mr. Shyam Lal Gupta was a partner of Vinayak Industries under the
Partnership Deed dated 07.01.2014 and a copy of the said Partnership Deed
is filed as Ex. PW-2/4 along with the Affidavit. The Affidavit of PW-2 also
states that after the demise of Mr. Shyam Lal Gupta, the father of the
Petitioner, the partnership of Vinayak Industries was Re-Constituted on
28.12.2021 and a copy of Re-Constitution of Partnership Deed has been
filed as Ex. PW-2/5. Further, PW-2 has also filed his Aadhaar Card as Ex.
PW-2/6 along with the Affidavit. In addition, the Affidavit of PW-2 also
contains the GST Registration Certificate of Vinayak Industries marked as
Ex. PW-2/1.
30. The above documents filed along with the Affidavit of PW-2 are
proposed to be filed as the Additional Documents by the Petitioner, which
have been rejected by way of the Impugned Order.
31. For examining the correctness of the Impugned Order, it is necessary
to determine whether the Additional Documents sought to be produced by
the Petitioner are relevant and necessary for determining the real
controversy between the Parties in the Suit pending before the learned
Commercial Court.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 8 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

32. It is settled law that additional documents may be taken on record
with the leave of the Court on showing reasonable cause, provided such
additional documents do not contradict to the pleadings already on record.
The additional documents sought to be placed on record must be in aid of
the pleaded case, and no document which is contrary to or inconsistent with
the pleaded case can be permitted to be filed. If by filing the additional
documents a new case is sought to be set up or any admission is intended to
be withdrawn, such documents cannot be taken on record. A party seeking
to set up a case contrary to its pleaded case must, in the first instance, seek
amendment of the pleadings in accordance with law and merely filing
documents is not sufficient.
33. In the present case, as per the averments in the Plaint, Vinayak
Industries is described as a proprietorship of the Petitioner, however, the
Affidavit of PW-2 describes Vinayak Industries as a partnership firm in
which Petitioner’s father was a partner and after his demise, the Petitioner
was not inducted as the partner of Vinayak Industries. Learned Counsel for
the Petitioner has submitted that since Petitioner is not a partner of Vinayak
Industries, the Additional Documents were not in power and possession of
the Petitioner at the time of filing the Suit, which was filed in a state of
exigency and that the description of Vinayak Industries as the proprietorship
of the Petitioner was a typographical error.
34. The submissions made on behalf of the Petitioner cannot be accepted
as the Petitioner itself has described Vinayak Industries as the proprietorship
firm of the Petitioner and unless such purported typographical error is
corrected in the Plaint by way of amendment, the Additional Documents
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 9 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41

cannot be permitted to be placed on record as the same are contrary to the
pleadings already on record. Since there is no basis or reference of the
Petitioner’s father being the partner of Vinayak Industries in the Plaint, the
Additional Documents are not relevant to determine any controversy in the
Suit.
35. In any event, the invoices of Vinayak Industries are already exhibited
and the Additional Documents to prove the involvement of Petitioner’s
father in the business of Vinayak Industries cannot be permitted in absence
of any corresponding pleading in the Plaint to that effect.
36. In view of the above, there is no perversity in the Impugned Order
dated 12.08.2026, which rejects the Application seeking permission to place
on record the Additional Documents.
37. It is made clear that if the Petitioner moves an application for
amendment of the pleadings, if so advised, such application shall be decided
on its own merits in accordance with law without being influenced by any
observations made hereinabove.
38. Accordingly, the present Petition is dismissed as being without any
merit. There shall be no order as to costs.
TEJAS KARIA, J
NOVEMBER 6, 2026
N
Signature Not Verified
CM(M)-IPD 59/2026 Page 10 of 10
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:24:41