Ashok vs Mahesh
- Court
- Supreme Court
REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 1235
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 5370-5371 OF 2026
[@ Special Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 7056-7057 of 2025]
Ashok ..….Appellant(s)
Versus
Mahesh & Anr. ……. Respondent(s)
J U D G M E N T
K. V. Viswanathan, J.
1) Leave granted.
2) The present appeals call in question the correctness of the
order dated 27.11.2024 in Criminal Application Nos. 1371 of
2020 and 3235 of 2021 passed by the High Court of Judicature
at Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad. By the said order, the High
Court allowed the applications filed by Respondent No. 1 and
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
HARPREET KAUR
Date: 2026.11.17
18:33:20 IST
Reason:
quashed the proceedings pending against him in RCC No.
1020 of 2023 and RCC No. 119 of 2024 before the Chief Judicial
1
Magistrate, Dhule. In RCC No. 1020 of 2023, chargesheet was
filed for offences under Sections 465, 466, 468, 471, 474, 420,
120B and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short ‘the IPC’)
and in RCC No. 119 of 2024, chargesheet was filed for offences
under Sections 465, 466, 468, 471, 474, 420,120B and 34 of the
IPC.
3) The short ground on which the proceedings were
quashed was that under the Maharashtra Amendment Act
XXXIII of 2016 to Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973, (for short ‘the Cr.P.C.’), even for ordering a
Section 156(3) investigation against a public servant in
respect of acts done by such public servant while acting or
purporting to act in the discharge of his official duty, sanction
under Section 197 of the Cr.P.C. was required. Further, it was
held that for the proviso to the said amendment to apply,
providing for application of the principle of deemed sanction,
the application had to be made to the competent authority. In
the present case, applications were made to Settlement
2
Commissioner and Director of Land Records (Maharashtra
State) and in another case to the Settlement Commissioner,
which authorities, according to the High Court, were not the
competent authorities.
4) Under the circumstances, the High Court, by the
impugned order, recorded the following findings: -
“11. …….Therefore, it ought to have been considered
by the learned Magistrate, as to whether the
Settlement Commissioner, who is certainly the
superior officer of the applicant, had the power to
appoint and remove the applicant or not. The learned
Advocate for the applicant is making available the
photocopy of promotion order passed by the
th
Government of Maharashtra on 17 September 2007,
wherein the present applicant was promoted from
Class-III post to Class-II post and therefore, it is not in
dispute that the State Government is the removing
authority. The hierarchy in the office is not relevant for
according sanction to prosecute, but it depends upon
the power to appoint and remove from service.
Therefore, when respondent No.2 had made
application to the wrong authority and the wrong
authority / the authority who was not competent, had
not taken any action on the application filed by
respondent No.2 for more than 90 days, the same will
not give the deeming effect. In other words, inaction
of an authority who is not competent to accord
sanction, will not give advantage to respondent No.2
to take advantage of the deeming provision in Section
156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Here, in the
present case, there was no sanction at all to prosecute
3
the applicant nor there was a deemed sanction. The
learned Magistrate could not have passed the order
directing the investigation to be made under Section
156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The First
Information Reports based on the said orders cannot
be allowed to sustain as there is inherent defect, and
therefore, even the proceedings will not be allowed
to proceed further. It would be unjust to ask the
applicant to face the trial on the basis of such inherent
defect. Therefore, this is a fit case where we should
exercise our powers under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure.”
5) The said order is assailed by the complainant-the
appellant herein before us on the ground that the authority
approached by the complainant was the competent authority
and, in any event, the acts done could not be said to be in
discharge of or in purported discharge of official duties,
thereby obviating the need for prior sanction.
6) The brief facts essential for the disposal of the present
matters are as follows. On 18.09.1992, the Appellant, as a
trustee of the Priyadarshini Charitable Trust, received land
parcel admeasuring 21,000 sq.ft. (City Survey No. 1888) as gift
from its owners Avdhut Anant Adavadkar and others, through
Gopal Anant Adavadkar holding General Power of Attorney.
Eversince, the Trust was in ownership and possession of the
4
said land. Appropriate mutation was made in favour of the
Trust. When matters stood thus, a Special Civil Suit No. 53 of
2003 came to be filed by the original owners of some portion
of the land situated in Devpur, Dhule, being Survey Nos. 42/2
and 44/7, before the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dhule
seeking partition and separate possession, with declarations
that the sale deeds are void and not binding on them,
including the sale deed dated 20.06.1992 by which Shri Swami
Samarth Co-op Housing Society Limited, Devpur, Dhule
purchased 1,05,100 sq.ft. land from Gopal Anant Adavadkar
holding General Power of Attorney.
7) The Appellant alleged that the suit land did not concern
the land owned and possessed by Priyadarshini Charitable
Trust, which was received pursuant to the gift deed of
18.09.1992. It appears that on 01.08.2018, the Civil Judge,
decreed the suit and declared the deeds void and not binding
on the shares of the plaintiffs, including the sale deed of
20.06.1992.
5
8) It is alleged that on the same day, Dinkar Anantrao
Adavadkar (Accused No. 1), made an application to the City
Survey Officer and sought mutation in his name in respect of
his share of the property as per the decree of the Civil Judge,
Senior Division. It is alleged by the Appellant that the said
application was not even signed. It is alleged that an office
noting mentioning that the area involved in the cancelled sale
deed in the civil suit and the gift deed to Priyadarshini
Charitable Trust were one and the same was made, and on that
basis illegal mutation entry was done in favour of the decree
holders by Respondent No. 1, when the property of
Priyadarshini Charitable Trust was not concerned in the suit.
9) It also appears that the decree passed by the Civil Judge,
Senior Division, in Special Civil Suit No. 53 of 2003 dated
01.08.2018, was stayed by the Appellate Court on 22.11.2018.
10) The Appellant, on 19.12.2018, coming to know about the
illegal mutation, sent a notice to Respondent No. 1-Mahesh
Fulpagare (Accused No. 2) and Madhukar More (Accused No.
6
3) and apprised them of the different nature of the properties.
Collusion and conspiracy were also alleged. It was also
alleged that no notice was given to Priyadarshini Charitable
Trust in whose name the mutation stood.
11) By a reply of 29.12.2018, Respondent No. 1-Mahesh
Fulpagare (Accused No. 2) and Madhukar More (Accused No.
3) stated that in view of the civil suit decree no notice was
required to be issued to Priyadarshini Charitable Trust.
12) On 02.01.2019, the Appellant tried to lodge a First
Information Report. Since the First Information Report was not
registered, a complaint was made to the Superintendent of
Police, and on the Superintendent of Police not taking action,
a private complaint on behalf of the Trust under Section 156(3)
of the Cr.P.C. seeking directions for the filing of First
Information Report against Accused Nos. 1, 2, 3 was filed in
Criminal Misc. Application No. 323 of 2019. This Complaint
was filed in the name of the Appellant as trustee of
Priyadarshini Charitable Trust. Another complaint in Criminal
7
Misc. Application No. 421 of 2019 was filed by the Appellant
before the CJM, Dhule as Secretary of the Shri Swami Samarth
Co-op Housing Society Limited, Dhule.
13) On 11.07.2019, the Appellant made an application to the
Settlement Commissioner and Director of Land Records
(Maharashtra State) to accord sanctions to prosecute City
Survey Officer-Accused No. 2 (Respondent No. 1) and
Examination Surveyor-Accused No. 3.
14) In the meantime, on 30.11.2019, the District
Superintendent of Land Records, Dhule, allowed Appeal No.
214 of 2019, and directed Mutation Entry No. 7062 to be
cancelled.
15) On 17.03.2020, in Criminal Misc. Application No. 323 of
2019, the JMFC, Dhule directed investigation under Section
156(3) of the Cr.P.C. and recorded the following findings:-
“5. …..It is alleged that the respondent no.l in
connivance with the respondent nos.2 and 3 have
fraudulently mutated his name along with other persons
in the City Survey No.1888. The judgment and decree of
the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dhule in
8
Spl.C.S.No.53/2003, dated 01/01/2018 declared that the
sale deed dated 20/06/1992 is not binding on the
plaintiffs and defendant nos. 5 to 12. The respondent no.l
is plaintiff no.2 in the said suit. The sale deed dated
20/06/1992 was in respect of 1,05,100 sq. ft area, in
respect of which, based on the Civil Court's decree, the
respondent no.l by following due procedure should
have mutated his name. But instead of that he got
mutated his name on Survey No. 1888, which is having
an area of 21000 sq ft. Prima facie, it shows that the
application dated 01/08/2018 only shows two
documents annexed with it and the City Survey officer
had taken into consideration four more documents
which were not annexed with the application of the
respondent no.l. I find that prima facie case for
investigation for the offences punishable under Sections
465, 466, 468, 471, 474, 420, 120-B r/w Section 34 of
I.P.C. is made out. Considering this fact, the matter
requires investigation…..”
16) Subsequently, on 20.03.2020, FIR No. 79 of 2020 came to
be registered at Dhule City Police Station, and Respondent
No. 1 and Accused No. 3 were arrested on the same day.
17) There is also a document on record which shows that on
05.08.2020, the Settlement Commissioner and Director of
Land Records (Maharashtra State) suspended Respondent No.
1 after noticing the registration of FIR No. 79 of 2020 and the
custody period of the Respondent No. 1 from 20.03.2020, 1:08
am to 23.03.2020 which was for a period exceeding 48 hours.
9
18) On 13.08.2020, Respondent No. 1 filed Criminal
Application No. 1371 of 2020 before the High Court seeking
quashment of FIR No. 79 of 2020.
19) On 04.03.2021, the JMFC, Dhule, in Criminal Misc.
Application No. 421 of 2019 directed investigation under
Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. by recording the following
findings:-
“5. In this case, it is alleged that the accused no.l has
made an application to mutate his name on the property
bearing City Survey Nos. 1889, 4460 and 4496 on the
basis of preliminary decree of Hon'ble Civil Court
Senior Division, Dhule, without annexing necessary
documents and the accused nos. 2 and 3 in connivance
with the accused no.l have entered the name of the
accused no.l and others on the said properties, without
following due procedure of law. The said preliminary
decree was challenged and is in executable unless and
until it is finalized. It is alleged that the application made
by the accused no.l dated 01/08/2018 only mentions the
sale deed. It does not mention the documents as shown
by the accused no.2 in his noting and the accused no.3
has passed the order approving to enter the said names
of the accused no.l and others on the property bearing
City Survey Nos. 1889, 4460 and 4496. The complainant
had sought for information regarding the application of
the accused no. l dated 01/08/2018 through Right of
Information from the Office of City Survey and the Public
Information Officer, City Survey Office, Dhule has
replied that the documents as mentioned in noting of the
accused no.3 were not annexed with the application
10
dated 01.08.2018 of the accused no. l. The said reply
further shows that the application of the accused no. l
was incomplete, illegal and made without following
rules. The said noting and entry made and approved by
accused nos. 2 and 3 is cancelled in Appeal SR
2148/2019, Dhule by District Superintendent of Land
Record, Dhule on 30.11.2019, on the ground that the said
entry was taken without following due procedure of law.
6. In the circumstances, prima facie, a case for
investigation under Section 156(3) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure is made out against the accused
nos. l to 3…..”
On 06.03.2021, FIR No. 62 of 2021 came to be registered by
Dhule City Police Station against the Accused Nos. 1, 2, 3 of
which Respondent No. 1 was Accused no. 2.
20) On 17.12.2021, Respondent No. 1 filed Criminal
Application No. 3235 of 2021 before the High Court of
Judicature at Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad, seeking
quashment of FIR No. 62 of 2021.
21) On 21.12.2023, a charge sheet was filed in case arising
out of FIR No. 79 of 2020. 3 accused were arrayed and
Respondent No.1 was arrayed as Accused No. 2. Crucial
allegations in the charge sheet were as under: -
11
“ ……Upon receiving the requested documents, it was
revealed that Accused No. 1's original application
dated 01/08/2018 had been tampered with. The
following irregularities were found: Alterations
(erasures and overwriting) were made in the original
application, A photograph of Accused No. 1 was pasted
later on the application, A small signature was placed
at the designated signature spot, which was not present
in the original application, Below the subject, a
handwritten note was added stating 'as per the court
order', despite no such mention in the original
application. Additionally, a formal letter was submitted
to the City Survey Office, requesting information
regarding this matter. Upon receiving a response,
copies of all three versions of the application were
obtained. From these documents, it was evident that
Accused No. 1 had not submitted any supporting
documents along with the application dated
01/08/2018.
Furthermore, Accused No. 1 had mentioned 'List
No. 2' as an attachment in the submitted documents.
However, when Nilesh Rambhau Patil requested a copy
of List No. 2 from the Sub-Registrar Office No. 1, it was
revealed that: 'List No. 2' was destroyed in a fire that
occurred at the Sub-Registrar Office on 23/06/2011,
The Sub-Registrar Office No. 1 officially confirmed this
in a written statement. From the above findings, it is
evident that Accused No. 1's application submitted to
the City Survey Office for mutation entry was not in the
prescribed format and was not accompanied by any
valid supporting documents. Furthermore, after the
complainant pointed out the discrepancies in the
application, modifications and alterations were made
twice even after Mutation Entry No. 7062 was
approved. This forged and tampered application was
then falsely presented as a genuine document and was
officially placed in the City Survey Office records.
From this, it is evident that the accused have created
forged documents. Subsequently, Accused No. 2 and
12
Accused No. 3, without conducting a hearing on
Accused No. 1 's application, without verifying the
documents, and without ensuring that the documents
mentioned in the application were actually submitted,
issued an order based on the said application. As a
result, Mutation Entry No. 7062 was approved on
16/11/2018, removing the name of Priyadarshini
Charitable Trust, Dhule, and instead, recording the
names of Accused No. 1, other Adavadkar family
members, and their heirs, totaling 19 individuals, in the
property register. In connection with the said property,
the complainant filed an appeal (SR 2148/2019) before
the Hon'ble Superintendent of Land Records,
requesting the cancellation of Mutation Entry No. 7062,
which was approved by Accused No. 2. After
conducting a hearing, the Hon'ble Superintendent of
Land Records issued a decision on 30/11/2019, stating
that Mutation Entry No. 7062 was found to be incorrect
and, therefore, it was canceled.
As per the findings of the investigation,
Accused No. 1, in collusion with Accused No. 2 and
Accused No. 3, conspired to commit a criminal
offense by preparing forged documents and falsely
presenting them as genuine. These fraudulent
documents were submitted to the City Survey
Office and officially recorded, leading to the
approval of Mutation Entry No. 7062. This resulted
in the wrongful removal of the property ownership
of Priyadarshini Charitable Trust, Dhule, where the
complainant is a trustee, with the intention of
fraudulently transferring the property to Accused
No. 1 and 18 other individuals. Therefore, it has
been established that Accused No. 1, 2, and 3 have
committed the said offences, and criminal charges
have been registered against them under Sections
465, 468, 471, 474, 420, and 120B of the Indian Penal
Code (IPC). ”
[Emphasis supplied]
13
22) Similarly, on 12.02.2024, chargesheet was filed in case
arising out of FIR No. 62 of 2021 registered at Dhule City Police
Station. Crucial allegations in the charge sheet were as
under:-
“ …..In this case, the property located at Survey No.
42/2 + 44/7 in Devpur Shivaar, Taluka & District Dhule,
specifically Plot No. 2, measuring 1,05,100 sq. ft., has
been recorded in the City Land Survey Office, Dhule,
under Property Nos. 1889, 4460, and 4496. As per the
property records, the registered owner and possessor
of the said property is the Chairman of Shri Swami
Samarth Cooperative Housing Society Ltd., Dhule. The
said property was permanently purchased by Shri
Swami Samarth Cooperative Housing Society through
a registered sale deed (Document No. 1725) dated
20/06/1992 at the office of the Sub-Registrar, Dhule.
Since then, the property has been in the possession
and enjoyment of the Society and its members. The
property was permanently sold to Shri Swami Samarth
Cooperative Housing Society by Yopal Anant
Adavadkar (sic), acting as the General Power of
Attorney holder on behalf of the eight brothers of
Dinkar Anant Adavadkar. Although Gopal Anant
Adavadkar was not given a General Power of Attorney,
he sold the said property to Shri Swami Samarth
Cooperative Housing Society, thereby defrauding his
other brothers. However, from 20/06/1992 till the
present date, for approximately 32 years, none of the
Adavadkar brothers or their legal heirs have filed any
complaint against Gopal Anant Adavadkar in any
police station or court. However, a Special Civil Suit
No. 53/2003 was filed regarding the said property in
the Civil Court, Dhule, and the judgment was delivered
14
on 01/08/2018. An appeal (Regular Civil Appeal No.
125/2018) was subsequently filed before the District
Court, Dhule, challenging this decision. The Hon'ble
District Court has granted a stay on the judgment dated
01/08/2018 of the lower court until the final decision of
the appeal. Despite the absence of any written orders
from the Hon'ble Court or higher authorities, Accused
Nos. 1, 2, and 3 fraudulently created false and forged
documents and misrepresented them as genuine with
the intent to illegally transfer the property belonging
to the members of Shri Swami Samarth Cooperative
Housing Society. Accused Nos. 2 and 3, abusing their
official positions, manipulated the property records
(Survey Nos. 1889, 4460, and 4496) and, through
fraudulent Mutation Entry No. 7062 dated 16/11/2018,
wrongfully altered the ownership details.
Consequently, the Secretary of the Society,
Complainant Ashok Shravan Patkar, filed a criminal
application before the Hon'ble Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Dhule. After carefully reviewing and
verifying the submitted documents, the Hon'ble Court
directed the registration of an FIR under relevant
sections of the IPC, leading to the registration of FIR No.
62/2021 at Dhule City Police Station.
The charge against the accused in this case is
that Accused No. 1, in collusion with Accused Nos.
2 and 3, conspired to commit a criminal offense by
fraudulently preparing forged documents and
misrepresenting them as genuine. Using these
fabricated documents, they illegally manipulated
property records at the City Land Survey Office,
Dhule, and executed Mutation Entry No. 7062 to
fraudulently alter the ownership details of Survey
Nos. 1889, 4460, and 4496, which legally belong to
the members of Shri Swami Samarth Cooperative
Housing Society. Their intent was to cheat and
wrongfully transfer ownership of this property to
Accused No. 1 and 18 others. Since substantial and
credible evidence has been gathered against
15
Accused Nos. 1, 2, and 3, a charge sheet has been
prepared under Sections 465, 468, 471, 474, 420, and
120(B) of the IPC and has been submitted before the
Hon'ble Court for judicial proceedings.”
[Emphasis supplied]
23) Respondent No.1 carried out the amendments to the
quash petition and challenged the proceedings themselves in
RCC Nos. 1020 of 2023 and 119 of 2024 pending before the
Learned CJM, Dhule. It is in the said proceedings that the
impugned order has come to be passed.
24) We have heard Mr. Sagar Pahune Patil, Learned Counsel
for the Appellant, Mr. Raman Yadav, Learned Counsel for the
State, and Mr. Siddharth S. Chapalgaonkar with Ms. Sneha
Sanjay Botwe, as Learned Counsels for the first Respondent-
Accused.
25) Learned Counsel for the Appellant vehemently
contended that the offences committed by Respondent No. 1
cannot be said to be in discharge of official duties or in
purported discharge thereof. That it was no part of the duty of
Respondent No. 1 to commit forgery and/or to use a forged
16
document. Learned Counsel submitted that Section 156 (3) of
the Cr.P.C., as amended in Maharashtra, would have no
application since the protection in the amendment applies
only to acts committed in discharge of official duty. It was
further argued that even assuming it was part of the discharge
of official duty, an application for sanction was made to the
competent authority and only on the basis of an oral statement
of the Counsel for Respondent No. 1, the High Court has
assumed the Settlement Commissioner and Director of Land
Records (Maharashtra State) to not be the competent
authorities. It was, however, argued that the authority to whom
sanction was applied was the competent authority. Learned
Counsel prayed for setting aside of the High Court order and
for permitting the trial to proceed.
26) Mr. Raman Yadav, Learned Counsel for the State of
Maharashtra submitted that Section 197 of the Cr.P.C. would
be attracted and, in turn, the Maharashtra Amendment to
Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. would have applied only where
17
the act complained of bears a reasonable nexus with the
discharge of the public servant of his official duties. Learned
Counsel argued that acts involving fabrication of records or
creation of false documents can never form part of discharge
of the official powers, and therefore, the protection under the
relevant Sections were not attracted. Learned Counsel
referring to the allegations in the charge sheets contended
that Respondent No. 1 misused his official position to facilitate
the fabrication of the mutation application, and subsequently,
altered the revenue records.
27) Mr. Siddharth S. Chapalgaonkar, Learned Counsel for
Respondent No. 1, submitted that an application was duly
received for mutation and it was only after obtaining the
opinion of the District Government Pleader that the mutation
was effected.
28) It must be pointed out herein that in the written
submissions of the State of Maharashtra, it is stated that the
District Government Pleader had opined that the decree was
18
in appeal and any appropriate action regarding revenue entry
should await the outcome of the appeal. It was also pointed
out that status quo was ordered by the Appellate Court on
22.11.2018 with the direction that status quo existing prior to
01.08.2018 should be maintained.
29) Reverting to the argument of the Learned Counsel for
Respondent No. 1, Learned Counsel contended that the acts
were clearly done in official capacity, and done with proper
due diligence. Merely because the order is erroneous, no
criminality can be attributed. Learned Counsel relied on the
fact that there was no sanction obtained under Section 156(3)
of the Maharashtra Amendment read with Section 197 of the
Cr.P.C.
30) The Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) reads as
under: -
“ 156. Police officer's power to investigate
cognizable case. —(1) Any officer in charge of a
police station may, without the order of a Magistrate,
investigate any cognizable case which a Court
having jurisdiction over the local area within the
19
limits of such station would have power to inquire
into or try under the provisions of Chapter XIII.
(2) No proceeding of a police officer in any such case
shall at any stage be called in question on the ground
that the case was one which such officer was not
empowered under this section to investigate.
(3) Any Magistrate empowered under section 190
may order such an investigation as above-
mentioned.
STATE AMENDMENT
Maharashtra
Amendment of section 156. —In section 156 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, (2 of 1974) in its
application to the State of Maharashtra (Hereinafter
referred to as "the said Code"), after sub-section (3),
the following provisos shall be added, namely: —
"Provided that, no Magistrate shall order an
investigation under this section against a person
who is or was a public servant as defined under
any other law for the time being in force, in
respect of the act done by such public servant
while acting or purporting to act in the discharge
of his official duties, except with the previous
sanction under section 197 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974) or under any
law for the time being in force:
Provided further that, the sanctioning authority shall
take a decision within a period of ninety days from
the date of the receipt of the proposal for sanction
and in case the sanctioning authority fails to take the
decision within the said stipulated period of ninety
days, the sanction shall be deemed to have been
accorded by the sanctioning authority."
[Vide Maharashtra Act 33 of 2016, s. 2.]
20
31) Relevant part of Section 197 of the CrPC reads as under:-
“ 197. Prosecution of Judges and public servants.-
(1) When any person who is or was a Judge or
Magistrate or a public servant not removable from his
office save by or with the sanction of the Government
is accused of any offence alleged to have been
committed by him while acting or purporting to act in
the discharge of his official duty, no Court shall take
cognizance of such offence except with the previous
sanction [save as otherwise provided in the Lokpal and
Lokayuktas Act, 2013 (1 of 2014)]—
(a) in the case of a person who is employed or, as the
case may be, was at the time of commission of the
alleged offence employed, in connection with the
affairs of the Union, of the Central Government;
(b) in the case of a person who is employed or, as the
case may be, was at the time of commission of the
alleged offence employed, in connection with the
affairs of a State, of the State Government:
xxx xxx “
32) We are inclined to hold that the acts complained of were
not in discharge of or in purported discharge of official duty.
Hence, we are not required to examine the aspect of deemed
sanction and the issue of the authority competent to grant
sanction, insofar as the present facts are concerned.
33) Recently, J.B. Pardiwala J., speaking for this Court in Om
Prakash Yadav vs. Niranjan Kumar Upadhyay and Others ,
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3726 felicitously summed up the law on
21
the concept of discharge of official duty in the following
words: -
“65. Thus, the legal position that emerges from a
conspectus of all the decisions referred to above is
that it is not possible to carve out one universal rule
that can be uniformly applied to the multivarious facts
and circumstances in the context of which the
protection under Section 197 CrPC is sought for. Any
attempt to lay down such a homogenous standard
would create unnecessary rigidity as regards the
scope of application of this provision. In this context,
the position of law may be summarized as under:—
(i) The object behind the enactment of Section 197
CrPC is to protect responsible public servants against
institution of possibly false or vexatious criminal
proceedings for offences alleged to have been
committed by them while they are acting or
purporting to act in their official capacity. It is to
ensure that the public servants are not prosecuted for
anything which is done by them in the discharge of
their official duties, without any reasonable cause. The
provision is in the form of an assurance to the honest
and sincere officers so that they can perform their
public duties honestly, to the best of their ability and
in furtherance of public interest, without being
demoralized.
(ii) The expression “ any offence alleged to have been
committed by him while acting or purporting to act in
the discharge of his official duty ” in Section 197 CrPC
must neither be construed narrowly nor widely and
the correct approach would be to strike a balance
between the two extremes. The section should be
construed strictly to the extent that its operation is
limited only to those acts which are discharged in the
“course of duty”. However, once it has been
ascertained that the act or omission has indeed been
22
committed by the public servant in the discharge of
his duty, then a liberal and wide construction must be
given to a particular act or omission so far as its
“official” nature is concerned.
(iii) It is essential that the Court while considering the
question of applicability of Section 197 CrPC truly
applies its mind to the factual situation before it. This
must be done in such a manner that both the aspects
are taken care of viz. , on one hand, the public servant
is protected under Section 197 CrPC if the act
complained of falls within his official duty and on the
other, appropriate action be allowed to be taken if the
act complained of is not done or purported to be done
by the public servant in the discharge of his official
duty.
(iv) A public servant can only be said to act or purport
to act in the discharge of his official duty, if his act is
such that it lies within the scope and range of his
official duties. The act complained of must be
integrally connected or directly linked to his duties as
a public servant for the purpose of affording
protection under Section 197 CrPC. Hence, it is not the
duty which requires an examination so much as the
“act” itself.
(v) One of the foremost tests which was laid down in
this regard was - whether the public servant, if
challenged, can reasonably claim that, what he does,
he does in virtue of his office.
(vi) Later, the test came to be re-modulated. It was laid
down that there must be a reasonable connection
between the act done and the discharge of the official
duty and the act must bear such relation to the duty
such that the accused could lay a reasonable, but not
a pretended or fanciful claim, that his actions were in
the course of performance of his duty. Therefore, the
sine qua non for the applicability of this section is that
the offence charged, be it one of commission or
omission, must be committed by the public servant
23
either in his official capacity or under the color of the
office held by him such that there is a direct or
reasonable connection between the act and the
official duty.
(vii) If in performing his official duty, the public
servant acts in excess of his duty, the excess by itself
will not be a sufficient ground to deprive the public
servant from protection under Section 197 CrPC if it is
found that there existed a reasonable connection
between the act done and the performance of his
official duty.
(viii) It is the “quality” of the act that must be
examined and the mere fact that an opportunity to
commit an offence is furnished by the official position
would not be enough to attract Section 197 CrPC.
(ix) The legislature has thought fit to use two distinct
expressions “acting” or “purporting to act”. The latter
expression means that even if the alleged act was
done under the color of office, the protection under
Section 197 CrPC can be given. However, this
protection must not be excessively stretched and
construed as being limitless. It must be made
available only when the alleged act is reasonably
connected with the discharge of his official duty and
not merely a cloak for doing the objectionable act.
(x)
There cannot be any universal rule to determine
whether there is a reasonable connection between the
act done and the official duty, nor is it possible to lay
down such a rule. However, a “safe and sure test”
would be to consider if the omission or neglect on the
part of the public servant to commit the act
complained of would have made him answerable for
a charge of dereliction of his official duty. If the answer
to this question is in the affirmative, the protection
under Section 197 CrPC can be granted since there
was every connection with the act complained of and
the official duty of the public servant.
24
(xi) The provision must not be abused by public
servants to camouflage the commission of a crime
under the supposed color of public office. The
benefit of the provision must not be extended to
public officials who try to take undue advantage of
their position and misuse the authority vested in
them for committing acts which are otherwise not
permitted in law. In such circumstances, the acts
committed must be considered dehors the duties
which a public servant is required to discharge or
perform.
(xii) On an application of the tests as aforesaid, if on
facts, it is prima facie found that the act or omission for
which the accused has been charged has a reasonable
connection with the discharge of his official duty, the
applicability of Section 197 CrPC cannot be denied.
66. At the cost of repetition, we say that the position
of law on the application of Section 197 CrPC is
clear - that it must be decided based on the
peculiar facts and circumstances of each case.
This Court has held in a legion of decisions that
any misuse or abuse of powers by a public servant
to do something that is impermissible in law like
threatening to provide a tutored statement or
trying to obtain signatures on a blank sheet of
paper; causing the illegal detention of an accused;
engaging in a criminal conspiracy to create false
or fabricated documents; conducting a search with
the sole object of harassing and threatening
individuals, amongst others, cannot fall under the
protective umbrella of Section 197 CrPC.
67. In light of the same, it follows that when a police
official is said to have lodged a false case, he cannot
claim that sanction for prosecution under Section 197
CrPC was required since it can be no part of the
official duty of a public official to lodge a bogus case
25
and fabricate evidence or documents in connection
with the same. On examining the quality of the act, it
is evident that there exists no reasonable or rational
nexus between such an act and the duties assigned to
the public servant for the claim that it was done or
purported to be done in the discharge of his official
duty. The mere fact that an opportunity to register a
false case was furnished by the official duty would
certainly not be sufficient to apply Section 197 CrPC.
Allowing so, would enable the accused to use their
status as public servants as a facade for doing an
objectionable, illegal and unlawful act and take undue
advantage of their position. If the Case Crime No. 967
of 2007 registered at the Murar Police Station,
Gwalior, by respondent nos. 3, 4 and 5 respectively,
was a false case, then there is no doubt that the refusal
to grant sanction would not operate as a bar for their
prosecution. Moreover, as far as the case of
respondent no. 1 is concerned, it is an undisputed fact
that he was not even posted as the S.H.O or T.I at the
Murar Police Station when the said false case was
registered. The same is evident from the affidavit
submitted by the IO at Firozabad before the High
Court. Additionally, the respondent no. 1 has himself
admitted in his submissions before us that he was in
fact posted at District Shivpuri which is 120 kms away
from Gwalior during the relevant time. Therefore, any
act or offence committed by the respondent no. 1 in
the present case can safely be said to have been
outside the scope of his official duty which obviates
the question of sanction for his prosecution.”
[Emphasis supplied]
26
34) Applying the above law to the facts of the present case, it
is very clear that the case set up against Respondent No. 1 is
of conspiring to commit criminal offence by preparing forged
documents and falsely presenting them as genuine. All this
was done with the intention, according to the prosecution, to
transfer the property to Accused No. 1 and 18 and other
individuals. There is also an allegation with regard to
manipulation of property records at the City Land Survey
Office and execution of a mutation entry with intention to
cheat.
35) On the facts of the case, we are convinced that Section
197 read with Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) of
the Cr.P.C. are not attracted to the facts of the present case.
Needless to state that the observations in this judgment are
only for the purpose of deciding the aspect of sanction to
prosecute. The trial and the other proceedings will be
conducted independently, on their own merits.
27
36) For the reasons stated above, the impugned order dated
27.11.2024 passed by the High Court in Criminal Application
Nos. 1371 of 2020 and 3235 of 2021 is set aside. The appeals
are allowed. We direct that RCC Nos. 1020 of 2023 and 119 of
2024 be restored to the file of CJM, Dhule and shall be
proceeded in accordance with law.
……….........................J.
[ K. V. VISWANATHAN ]
……….........................J.
[ ALOK ARADHE ]
New Delhi;
th
17 November, 2026
28