S.K. Anand vs Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.

Court
Delhi High Court

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
% Reserved on: 10 August, 2026
th
Pronounced on: 17 November, 2026
th
Uploaded on: 17 November, 2026
# CNR No : DLHC011841792014
+ W.P.(C) 6822/2014
S. K. ANAND,
S/o Late Shri Raghubar Dayal,
H.No.10, Road No.18,
East Punjabi Bagh, Delhi. .....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Rupeeka Panwar, Mr. Vaibhav
Kadyan and Mr. Vishal Chaubey,
Advocates.
versus
ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
Through Chairman & Managing Director,
A-25/27, Asaf Ali Road, New Delhi. .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Rahul Ranjan Verma and
Mr. Vivek Sinha, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T
1. Writ Petition under Article 226 read with Article 311 of the
Constitution of India has been filed on behalf of the Petitioner, Sh. S.K.
Anand, seeking issuance of a Writ of Certiorari, Mandamus or any other
appropriate Writ, Order or direction for quashing: (i) the Order dated
19.07.2011 of the Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy General
Manager, imposing on him the penalty of demotion from Assistant
Manager (Scale-II) to Administrative Officer (Scale-I); (ii) the Order dated
16.04.2012 of the Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, General Manager,
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 1 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

dismissing his Appeal ; and (iii) the Order dated 25.02.2013 of the
Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Dr. A.K. Saxena, rejecting his
Memorial. The Petitioner has also sought a direction to restore him to the
post of Assistant Manager (Scale-II), and to restore his salary from the date
on which it was reduced, along with compensatory costs.
2. The brief facts are that the Petitioner joined the Respondent
Company, a nationalised insurance company whose ownership, control and
management vest in the Government of India under the General Insurance
Business (Nationalisation) Act, 1972, as an Assistant in the year 1979. He
was promoted as Stenographer in 1982, as Assistant Administrative Officer
in 1997 and as Administrative Officer in 2002. In 2004, he was re-
designated as Assistant Manager (Scale-II).
3. On Friday, 02.03.2001, while the Petitioner was posted as Assistant
Administrative Officer at the Branch Office, Karampura, New Delhi, he
issued Cover Note No. 010401 at about 2.15 p.m., from the office Cover
Note Book No. 417. The Cover Note granted comprehensive insurance to a
Bus bearing No. DL-1PA-5299, owned by Sh. Sukhbir Singh, for one year,
from 02.03.2001 to 01.03.2002. The premium of Rs. 15,359/- was paid by
cheque. The business was booked under Agency Code No. 4334 of Ms.
Seema Arora, an agent attached to the Development Officer, Sh. Rajneesh
Kapoor. The credit for the business thus went to the agent, Ms. Seema
Arora, and to the Development Officer, Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, under whom
she worked.
4. On the next day, Saturday, 03.03.2001, at about 01.50 p.m., the Bus
met with an accident in which a child died, resulting in the registration of the
FIR No.28/2001 , on the same day.
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 2 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

5. Since 03.03.2001 and 04.03.2001 were Saturday and Sunday, the
office reopened on Monday, 05.03.2001. On that day, the premium cheque
was accounted for vide Collection No.13263, and the Cover Note was
underwritten.
6. The parents of the deceased child filed a MACT Case No.290/01,
Naresh v. Pradeep, before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, in which the
Respondent Company was impleaded as the Insurer of the bus. The Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, vide Award dated 15.05.2004, awarded
compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- with interest @9% per annum from
24.09.2001, against the Respondent Company. The Respondent Company
satisfied the Award, on 29.07.2004.
7. Since the accident had occurred within five days of the insurance, the
claim was treated by the Respondent Company as a “close proximity”
claim. The Regional Office deputed Sh. A.D. Dwivedi, Investigator, to
investigate it.
8. Sh. A.D. Dwivedi, Investigator, submitted his Report dated
18.06.2004, finding that there was “ no discrepancy, whatsoever of any
nature in the issuance of the documents” .
9. In the year 2005, Sh. S.K. Gaba, Vigilance Officer , Regional Office-
I, New Delhi, investigated the issuance of the Cover Note. He recorded the
statements of various employees, including Sh. S. Trivedi, the then Senior
Branch Manager, on 08.11.2005, and Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, Development
Officer, on 11.11.2005. In his Report dated 19.12.2005, he concluded that
the Cover Note had in fact been issued on Monday, 05.03.2001, after the
accident, but was shown as issued on Friday, 02.03.2001, i.e. before the
accident, so as to bring the accident within the insurance cover.
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 3 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

10. On the basis of the Vigilance Report, Sh. Ram Niwas, Regional
Manager & Disciplinary Authority , issued a Charge-Sheet dated
01.05.2006 to the Petitioner, under Rule 25 of the General Insurance
(Conduct, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1975 (hereinafter referred to as the
“CDA Rules”) , which was served on the Petitioner, on 08.05.2006.
11. The Charge-Sheet contained three Articles of Charge :
(i) that the Petitioner had dishonestly granted insurance
to an already accidented vehicle, by ante-dating Cover Note
No. 010401 to 02.03.2001, though it was actually issued
after the accident (Charge No.1);
(ii) that he had allowed 20% No Claim Bonus (hereinafter
referred to as “NCB”) without obtaining the previous
insurance details (Charge No.2); and
(iii) that he was running a dummy Agency in the name of
Ms. Seema Arora (Charge No.3).
12. The Petitioner, in his Reply dated 18.05.2006, pointed out that the
date of the accident had been wrongly mentioned in the Articles of Charge
as 03.03.2002. The Disciplinary Authority corrected it to 03.03.2001 vide
Corrigendum dated 29.05.2006.
13. The Petitioner then, filed his Statement of Defence dated 28.06.2006,
denying all three charges.
14. Ms. Neeta Kumar, Manager , was appointed as the Inquiry Officer on
17.06.2006. She was replaced by Sh. N.K. Sahni, Deputy Manager, on
25.04.2007, who in turn was replaced by Sh. V.K. Parikh, Manager , on
15.04.2009. Sh. Kuldeep Singh, Assistant Manager, was appointed as the
Presenting Officer on 17.07.2006, and was succeeded by Sh. S.S. Yadav on
14.01.2008.
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 4 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

15. The inquiry commenced with the preliminary hearing on 03.07.2007,
at which the Petitioner denied the charges.
16. The Management examined only Sh. S.K. Gaba, Vigilance Officer,
who deposed in support of his Report, and was cross-examined on behalf of
the Petitioner. The documents listed with the Charge-Sheet were admitted as
PD-1 to PD-15. The original underwriting docket of the Cover Note was not
produced, the Branch Office having reported vide letter dated 03.02.2003
that it was not available.

17. The Petitioner examined DW-1, Sh. Rakesh Kumar , the then Motor
Underwriter of the Branch and DW-2 Sh. Rajeev Chopra , the then Cashier .
The Petitioner however, did not depose as a witness, in support of his
defence. The evidence was concluded on 25.11.2009, after which both sides
filed their written briefs.
18. Sh. V.K. Parikh, Inquiry Officer, submitted his Report dated
12.10.2010, wherein Charge No.1 and Charge No.2 were held not proved,
giving the Petitioner the benefit of the doubt. Charge No.3, of running a
Dummy Agency, was held proved . The reasoning was that the Petitioner had
booked business from the office Cover Note Book, which was meant for
direct clients, under the codes of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor and Ms. Seema
Arora, without any explanation. In the concluding part of the Report, the
Inquiry Officer further observed that the Petitioner, being in a supervisory
capacity, had failed to ensure compliance with the laid down procedures of
the Respondent Company, and had thereby failed to maintain devotion to
duty.
19. The Disciplinary Authority, Ms. Rita Singh, Regional Manager,
forwarded the Inquiry Report to the Petitioner vide letter dated 06.12.2010,
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 5 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

seeking his representation against the findings of the Inquiry Officer within
fifteen days. The Petitioner received it on 09.12.2010.
20. The Petitioner objected that he had not been given a certified copy of
the Inquiry Report, and questioned the authority of Ms. Rita Singh, Regional
Manager, to act as the Disciplinary Authority. After an exchange of letters,
he was allowed to inspect the original Inquiry Report. He submitted his
Representation dated 16.02.2011.
21. The Disciplinary Authority, Ms. Rita Singh, Regional Manager, did
not pass any Order . Instead, the matter was placed before the Appointing
Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy General Manager, an authority higher
than the Disciplinary Authority. By Order dated 19.07.2011, he held the
Petitioner guilty of all the three charges, and imposed the penalty of
demotion to the cadre of Administrative Officer (Scale-I). As a
consequence, the basic pay of the Petitioner was brought down to
Rs.32,640/-, the ceiling of that scale.
22. The Petitioner filed an Appeal dated 07.10.2011 under Rule 31 of the
CDA Rules. The Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, General Manager,
dismissed it vide Order dated 16.04.2012. Though the Appointing Authority
had held the Petitioner guilty of all three charges, the Appellate Authority
examined only Charge No. 3. He observed that the insured had placed the
business directly in the office, but it was booked under the Agency Code of
Ms. Seema Arora, and held the penalty to be commensurate with “the charge
proved”.
23. The Petitioner then submitted a Memorial dated 26.07.2012, under
Rule 40 of the CDA Rules. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Dr.A.K.
Saxena, rejected the Memorial vide Order dated 25.02.2013, which the
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 6 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

Petitioner received on 08.05.2013.
24. The Petitioner filed W.P.(C) 2531/2014 , on 14.04.2014, assailing
only the Order dated 19.07.2011 whereby he was held guilty of the charges
and the penalty of demotion, was imposed . On the objection of the
Respondent Company that this Order had merged in the Order dated
25.02.2013, he withdrew the Petition on 18.09.2014, with liberty to file a
substantive Writ Petition against all three Orders. Hence, the present Writ
Petition, has been filed.

25. The grounds of challenge are that the Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S.
Tandon, Deputy General Manager, held the Petitioner guilty of all three
Charges, though the Inquiry Officer had found only Charge No. 3 proved.
He did so without informing the Petitioner that he proposed to differ from
the findings of the Inquiry Officer, and without giving him any opportunity
to meet the grounds of such disagreement.
26. That the finding on Charge No. 3 rests on no evidence. Ms. Seema
Arora, whose licence was renewed even after the Petitioner had left the
Branch, was a genuine Agent working under Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor. Neither
of them was examined, and the Presenting Officer never pursued this
Charge.
27. That the Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, General Manager,
upheld for one Charge the very penalty that had been imposed for three
Charges. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Dr. A.K. Saxena, justified
the penalty on reasoning relating to a Charge on which the Petitioner stood
exonerated.
28. The Respondent Company, in its Counter Affidavit, has contended
that the Petitioner held no civil post and cannot invoke Article 311 of the
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 7 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

Constitution of India. This Court, in exercise of Writ jurisdiction, cannot
reappreciate the evidence, so long as there is some evidence, to support the
findings. Reliance has been placed on, Union of India v. H.C. Goel, AIR
1964 SC 364; Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai , (2003) 6 SCC 675;
Apparel Export Promotion Council v. A.K. Chopra , AIR 1999 SC 625;
Union of India v. Sardar Bahadur , (1972) 4 SCC 618; and General
Manager (P), Punjab & Sind Bank v. Daya Singh , (2010) 11 SCC 233.
29. The petition is also stated to be barred by delay.

30. On merits, it is asserted that the Petitioner ante-dated the Cover Note
after the accident, and booked the premium of a walk-in client, i.e. one who
had come directly to the office, under the code of Ms. Seema Arora. The
inquiry was held in accordance with the CDA Rules, and the Petitioner was
given full opportunity, including the right to cross-examine the Vigilance
Officer. Under Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules, the Inquiry Report does not
bind the Competent Authority, which extended the findings to all three
Charges. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director relied on no new fact.
31. The Petitioner, in his Rejoinder, has reiterated his averments, and has
asserted that no opportunity was given to him when the findings of the
Inquiry Officer were differed from.
32. Both parties have filed Written Submissions , reiterating their
respective stands.
Submissions heard and record perused.
33. Briefly summarised, the Petitioner was charged with (i) ante-dating a
Cover Note, (ii) allowing NCB without previous insurance details, and (iii)
running a dummy Agency . The Inquiry Officer found the Petitioner not
guilty of the first two Charges. He held him guilty only of the third Charge,
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 8 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

observing that the Petitioner had booked business from the office Cover
Note Book, meant for direct clients, under the codes of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor
and Ms. Seema Arora without any explanation, and that Sh. Rajneesh
Kapoor had denied introducing the business.
34. Though the Inquiry Officer had found only the third Charge proved,
the Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy General Manager, held
the Petitioner guilty of all the three Charges and demoted him to Scale-I.
The Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, General Manager, upheld the
penalty treating Charge No. 3 alone as proved. The Chairman-cum-
Managing Director, Dr. A.K. Saxena, rejected the Memorial relying on facts
pertaining to Charge No. 1, which had been held not proved. The same
penalty has thus been sustained at each stage on a different basis.
35. The issues that arise for consideration are: (i) whether the Writ
Petition is maintainable; (ii) whether it is barred by delay and laches; (iii)
whether the finding of the Inquiry Officer on Charge No. 3 is sustainable;
(iv) whether the Order dated 19.07.2011 of the Appointing Authority is in
conformity with Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules and the principles of natural
justice; (v) whether the Order dated 16.04.2012 of the Appellate Authority
and the Order dated 25.02.2013 of the Chairman-cum-Managing Director
on the Memorial are sustainable; and (vi) whether the matter merits
remand.

I. Whether the Writ Petition is Maintainable:
36. A preliminary objection was taken in regard to the maintainability of
the Writ Petition, on the ground that the Petitioner does not hold a civil post ,
and Article 311 of the Constitution of India, has no application.
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 9 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

37. That, however, does not oust the jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 226. The Respondent Company is owned and controlled by the
Government of India, and the penalty has been imposed under the CDA
Rules framed for its employees.
38. The Respondent Company itself relies on Apparel Export Promotion
Council v. A.K. Chopra (supra), wherein the Supreme Court recognised that
judicial review extends to examining whether the decision has been arrived
at in accordance with the principles of natural justice and whether the
individual has received fair treatment. The present Petition raises precisely
this question. It is, therefore, maintainable under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.

II Whether the Writ Petition is not Maintainable because of Delay
and Laches:
39. The Respondent Company has also objected that the Writ Petition is
barred by delay. This objection is also without substance. The Order dated
25.02.2013 was received by the Petitioner on 08.05.2013. He filed W.P.(C)
2531/2014 within a year, on 14.04.2014. He withdrew it on 18.09.2014, with
liberty to file a substantive petition, and the present petition followed in
September, 2014. It is evident that the Petitioner has pursued his remedy
with due diligence, and no delay or laches are attributable to him. There is
no delay, much less laches, and the Petition is within time.

III. Whether the Finding of the Inquiry Officer, Sh. V.K. Parikh, on
Charge No. 3, is Sustainable:
40. The Statement of Imputation in respect of Charge No. 3 reads:
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 10 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

“3. This business was placed by Sh. S.K. Anand, under Dev.
Officer code no.712 (Rajneesh Kapoor) and Agency code
no. 4334 (Ms. Seema Arora). Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, Dev.
Officer under whose code such business was brought shown
by Sh. S.K. Anand, has also denied introducing the business
under such Cover note, vide his statement dated 11.11.2005.
Agent, Mrs. Seema Arora, under whose code such business
was brought shown by Sh. S.K. Anand was not traceable in
spite of writing several letters/registered post. It clearly
showed that Sh. S.K. Anand was running a dummy agency
in the name of Mrs. Seema Arora .”
41. Sh. V.K. Parikh, Inquiry Officer, held the charge proved, for the
following reasons:
“From the Cover Note issuance Register, it is quite evident
that Cover Note book was issued to Mr. S. K. Anand for the
office use only. Further, the Branch Manager of the branch
in his written statement dated 08.11.2005 to the Vigilance
Officer, has also confirmed that the Cover Note Book was
being issued to the Officer to cater the Direct Clients. Mr.
Anand was not supposed to use this Cover Note Book for
underwriting the case of other development officers/agents
because as per the written statement of the SBM, the said
Cover Note Book was to cater the needs of Direct Clients .
It has been brought on record during inquiry proceeding
through the pink color carbon copy of Cover Note No.64500
that Dev. Officer/Agency Code was being incorporated in
the handwriting of Mr S. K. Anand, Charged Employee only
on the office pink carbon copy of the Cover Note. Mr
Rajneesh Kapoor, Dev Officer, in his statement dated
11.11.2005 to Vigilance Officer, has stated that he has not
introduced the client and/or asked Mr. Anand to issue Cover
Note on his behalf in respect of Cover Note No. 10401.
During the entire inquiry proceedings vis a vis in the
Written Brief, the Charged Employee has not come with
the explanation/clarification/justification as to why the
premium was booked under Agency . Further, from the
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 11 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

Cover Note Control Register it has been observed that most
of the cases of the Cover Note Book in question have been
booked under the code of Mr Rajneesh Kapoor/Ms Seema
Arora. This Cover Note Book was issued to Mr. S.K.Anand
to cater the Direct Clients and no reasonable satisfactory
explanation has been given by the Defence Assistant /
Charged Employee during Inquiry Proceeding and/or in
their Written Brief as to why code of Mr Rajneesh Kapoor
and Mrs Seema Arora was being used by Mr S. K. Anand
so frequently . Further, Ms Seema Arora became agent just
two months after the joining of the Charged employee in the
said Branch. Thus documentary as well as circumstantial
evidence proves that Mr. S. K. Anand was running a
Dummy Agency in the name of Mrs. Seema Arora (Agency
Code No.4334).Charge No. 3 is proved.”
42. In the conclusion of the Inquiry, after recording “Charge is proved”
against Charge No. 3, the Inquiry Officer added:
“Being in supervisory capacity, the charged employee was duty bound to
ensure strict compliance of the Co‟s set laid down procedures & guidelines
which have been laid down to have check on such incidents also, Due to non
compliance of these laid down procedures in the office in general, non
availability of original documents and delay in the matter, the charged
employee has got the benefit of the doubt in respect of first two charges but
certain facts which have come to lime light during this inquiry clearly
proves that the Charged Employee failed to maintain devotion to duty,
acted in a manner, unbecoming of a public servant and prejudicial to the
interest of the company.”
43. The Respondent relied on Union of India v. H.C. Goel (supra) to
contend that the finding must stand, so long as there is some evidence to
support it. In this very judgment, the Supreme Court held that the High
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 12 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

Court under Article 226 has jurisdiction to enquire whether the conclusion
“is not supported by any evidence at all”. The test laid down was: “ if the
whole of the evidence led in the enquiry is accepted as true, does the
conclusion follow ... that the charge in question is proved against the
respondent?” The Supreme Court also cautioned that “ mere suspicion
should not be allowed to take the place of proof even in domestic enquiries”.
44. In Sher Bahadur v. Union of India , (2002) 7 SCC 142, the Supreme
Court explained that the expression „sufficiency of evidence‟ “postulates
existence of some evidence which links the charged officer with the
misconduct alleged against him”.
45. The misconduct charged is not that the Petitioner booked the business
of a direct client, under the code of an Agent. The charge is that he was
running a “dummy” Agency in the name of Ms. Seema Arora, i.e. that the
Agency existed only in name , and was in reality being operated by the
Petitioner. What had to be established was that the Agency was a sham, and
that it was the Petitioner who was running it.
46. The finding of the Inquiry Officer rests on the following:
(i) the statement of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor that he
had not introduced the business;
(ii) the assertion that Ms. Seema Arora was not
traceable;
(iii) the handwriting of the Petitioner on the office
copy of another Cover Note;

(iv) the absence of any explanation from the
Petitioner for booking the business under the Agency;
(v) the premise that Cover Note Book No. 417 was
meant only for direct clients; and
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 13 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

(vi) the frequent use of the codes of Sh. Rajneesh
Kapoor and Ms. Seema Arora, and the timing of her
appointment as Agent.
Each of these is examined below.
47. The Statement of Imputation founded the charge on two
circumstances. The first was the denial of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor,
Development Officer, that he had introduced the business. The second was
that Ms. Seema Arora, was not traceable.
48. Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, who alone could have established that he had
not introduced the business, was neither cited as a witness, nor produced
during the inquiry.
49. Rule 25(11) of the CDA Rules provides:
“(11) On the date fixed for the inquiry, the oral and
documentary evidence by which the articles of charge are
proposed to be proved shall be produced by or on behalf of
the competent authority. The witnesses shall be examined
by or on behalf of the Presenting Officer and may be
cross-examined by or on behalf of the employee. ...”
50. Sh. S.K. Gaba, the Vigilance Officer, who had conducted the
vigilance investigation, was the only witness of the Management. In his
examination-in-chief dated 25.08.2009, he stated only that “I confirm
having recorded the statement of Sh. Rajnish Kapoor the then Dev. Officer
on 11.11.2005” . The statement of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor was thus, proved
only as a statement recorded during the vigilance investigation, and its
maker was never produced for cross-examination by the Petitioner.
51. In Kuldeep Singh v. Commissioner of Police , (1999) 2 SCC 10, the
Supreme Court held that the previous statements of witnesses who were not
produced at the inquiry, could not have been brought on record, and that
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 14 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

findings which “ could not have been reached by an ordinary prudent man”
are liable to be interfered with.
52. In Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank , (2009) 2 SCC 570, the
Supreme Court held that “The purported evidence collected during
investigation by the Investigating Officer” “could not be treated to be
evidence in the disciplinary proceeding”, and noticed that “ No witness was
examined to prove the said documents”.
53. Even as it stands, the statement of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, as extracted
in the Inquiry Report, records that “ As regard agent name Seema Arora
bearing agency no. 4334 was working with me”. On the issuance of the
Cover Note through the Petitioner, it records: “I might not have been in the
office”. The very document relied upon by the Management, describes Ms.
Seema Arora as an Agent working under Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor.
54. There was, thus, no admissible evidence that Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor
had not introduced the business. On the contrary, his own statement
confirms that Ms. Seema Arora was a genuine Agent, working under him.
55. The second circumstance which was considered for holding the
Charge as proved, was that Ms. Seema Arora “was not traceable in spite of
writing several letters/registered post” . The Inquiry Officer himself had
recorded, thus:
“9. Only one letter dated 08.12.2005 under Registered
Cover is said to be sent by BO Karampura to Ms.Seema
Arora Agent at her Residential Address for appearing
before the Vigilance Officer (PD-10). No evidence was
produced for actual dispatch of the said letter, delivery of
the said letter to the Addressee. No follow up
letter/reminder was produced. Any letter “Under Certificate
Of Posting” was sent to the Agent or not, was not brought
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 15 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

to the lime light during the Inquiry proceedings by the
P.O.”
56. The observations of the Inquiry Officer reflect that only one letter
dated 08.12.2005 was sent to Ms. Seema Arora, under Registered Cover. No
evidence was produced either of its dispatch, or of its delivery to her. It is
thus, evident that no sincere effort was made to summon Ms. Seema Arora,
who was admittedly an Agent under Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, Development
Officer. The assertion that Ms. Seema Arora “was not traceable in spite of
writing several letters/registered post” was, therefore, without any basis.

57. The cross-examination of Sh. S.K. Gaba dated 28.08.2009 is also
significant in relation to the allegation that the Petitioner was running a
dummy Agency. He admitted that during the investigation, it was revealed
that Ms. Seema Arora was attached to Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, Dev-Officer.
When asked whether he had examined “ the expiry date of the license of the
said Agent and whether the commission payment was being made to her or
not”, and “ whether her agency was Running on the date of your
investigation” , he replied: “ I do not find it relevant for the enquiry
purposes”.
58. Thus, no inquiry was conducted into the very facts which would have
shown whether the Agency was genuine or a sham.
59. The Petitioner, had examined DW-2 Sh. Rajeev Chopra, the then
Cashier, who in his cross-examination by the Presenting Officer on
25.11.2009, stated as under:
“Q.8 Do you know Mr. Rajnish Kapoor, Dev-Officer ?
Ans. Yes.
Q.9 Do you know Ms. Seema Arora his agent?
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 16 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

Ans. Yes.
Q.10 Whether Ms. Seema Arora used to visit the office in
connection with her agency work?
Ans. Yes.”
60. This evidence, elicited by the Presenting Officer himself, establishes
that Ms. Seema Arora was not a fictitious Agent . There is no evidence
whatsoever, that the Petitioner had any concern with the Agency of Ms.
Seema Arora, that her Agency was run by the Petitioner, or that any part of
the commission earned by her Agency, reached him.

61. The reasons recorded by the Inquiry Officer, do not provide this
missing link. The Inquiry Officer found that the Agency and Development
Officer Codes on the office copy of another Cover Note, No. 64500, were in
the handwriting of the Petitioner, and from this, he inferred: “Since the code
has been written on C/Note No. 64500 by Mr S.K.Anand so it is clear that
the same was being Written by the Charged employee only in other cases
also”. The subject Cover Note, No. 010401, was never produced, in
original. When its photocopy was shown to Sh. S.K. Gaba, Vigilance
Officer, in cross-examination on 27.08.2009, he stated: “A portion of the
photocopy supplied to me is quite dark so I am unable to comment on this by
seeing the photocopy of the cover note copy”.
62. In the light of this admission, and with the original documents not
produced, it stood not proved that the Agency Code and the Development
Officer Code on Cover Note No. 010401, were written by the Petitioner.
63. Further, the observation that the Petitioner gave no explanation for
booking the premium under the Agency, is contrary to the record. The
Inquiry Officer himself extracted the statement of the Petitioner to the
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 17 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

Vigilance Officer (PD-13), wherein he had stated: “On Dt. 2-3-2001
Development Officer (Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor)/Agents (Mrs Seema
Arora)/Insured requested me to give credit as the Insurance was through
them”. This explanation was given during the vigilance investigation itself,
long before the Charge-Sheet was issued. The contention of the Respondent
Company in its Counter Affidavit, that this plea is an afterthought, is,
therefore, without merit.
64. The other circumstance relied upon to assert that the Petitioner was
running the Dummy Agency was that Cover Note Book No. 417 was meant
only for direct clients, but it is also not borne out by the Report itself. Sh. S.
Trivedi, the then Senior Branch Manager, in his statement as extracted by
the Inquiry Officer, stated that “to cater direct clients to office, cover note
book to any officer can be issued” . The Inquiry Officer himself observed
from the Cover Note Control Register that the premium of Cover Note No.
10403, from the same Book, “was booked under Agency Code No. 4392”.
The Book was thus, not confined to direct clients, nor to the codes of Sh.
Rajneesh Kapoor and Ms. Seema Arora
65. The finding of the Inquiry Officer on Charge No. 3 was acted upon
not by the Disciplinary Authority, Ms. Rita Singh, Regional Manager, who
passed no Order, but by the Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy
General Manager. The only observation in his Order dated 19.07.2011
which relates to this Charge, is Observation 8, which reads:
“8. No explanation has been given during the inquiry proceedings as also in
the written brief as to why the direct business in respect of cover-note No.
010401 was booked in the Agency of Ms. Seema Arora”.
66. The Appointing Authority thus proceeded on the premise that the
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 18 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

business under Cover Note No. 010401 was direct business, and that no
explanation had been offered for booking it under the Agency. As already
noted in paragraph 63 above, the Petitioner had given such an explanation
during the vigilance investigation itself.
67. Sh. S.K. Gaba, Vigilance Officer, admitted in his cross-examination
dated 22.09.2009 that “No statement was recorded in respect of all the three
persons i.e. Driver, Insured or Claimant”. The insured was never examined
in the Inquiry, to establish that he had approached the office directly, and not
through any Agent.
68. The conclusion that the business under Cover Note No. 010401 was
direct business, which the Petitioner diverted to the Agency of Ms. Seema
Arora without any explanation, is thus, without any evidence whatsoever.
69. The remaining circumstances are that several Cover Notes from
Cover Note Book No. 417 were booked under the codes of Sh. Rajneesh
Kapoor and Ms. Seema Arora, and that Ms. Seema Arora became an Agent
two months after the Petitioner joined the Branch. To infer from these
circumstances alone that the Petitioner was running the Agency of Ms.
Seema Arora, is speculative. At best, they give rise to a suspicion, and
“Suspicion, as is well known, however high may be, can under no
circumstances be held to be a substitute for legal proof” , as reiterated by the
Supreme Court in Roop Singh Negi (supra).

70. The Inquiry Officer, in the concluding paragraph of the Report,
extracted in above, further observed that the Petitioner, being in a
supervisory capacity, failed to ensure compliance with the laid down
procedures, and thereby failed to maintain devotion to duty. This
observation does not relate to Charge No. 3, or to any other Article of
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 19 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

Charge. It is founded on “non compliance of these laid down procedures in
the office in general” , which was never an Article of Charge against the
Petitioner.
71. Rule 25(19)(i) of the CDA Rules, which provides for the contents of
the Inquiry Report, provides in its Explanation, thus:
“ Rule 25(19)(i):
….
Explanation :-
If in the opinion of the inquiry authority the proceedings of
the inquiry establish any article of charge different from
the original articles of charge, it may record its findings
on such article of charge.
Provided that the findings on such article of charge shall
not be recorded unless the employee has either admitted
the facts on which such article of charge is based or has
had a reasonable opportunity of defending himself against
such article of charge. ”
72. The Petitioner neither admitted any facts constituting a charge of
failure to ensure compliance with office procedures, nor was he called upon
to defend himself against any such charge. Pertinently, during the cross-
examination of Sh. S.K. Gaba, Vigilance Officer, on 23.09.2009, the
Presenting Officer, Sh. S.S. Yadav, had contended that any procedural lapse
in the Branch could be fastened on the Petitioner, irrespective of the working
practice prevailing in the office. The Inquiry Officer rejected this contention,
observing:
“...this inquiry has been set up to inquire about the ante-
dating of the cover-note besides other two charges and not
on the procedure lapse. For any procedure lapse the first
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 20 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

and the most important responsibility is that of the Incharge
of the office along with his official team and this is not the
issue before this inquiry and the object of this inquiry is to
see whether the allegation put on the charged employee are
based on the facts or factual positions or merely on
presumptions.”
73. In his Report, the Inquiry Officer further recorded that “ The Charged
employee would have taken the advantage of this system cannot be ruled out
but mere on presumption, one cannot be held guilty unless proved otherwise
as per law of natural justice”. The concluding paragraph is thus, contrary to
the Inquiry Officer‟s own ruling and findings, and cannot by itself sustain
any penalty.
74. In view of the foregoing discussion, the finding on Charge No. 3 is
not supported by any evidence linking the Petitioner with the misconduct
charged, and cannot be sustained.

IV. Whether the Order dated 19.07.2011 of the Appointing Authority
is in Conformity with Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules and the Principles of
Natural Justice:
75. The Inquiry Officer exonerated the Petitioner of Charge No. 1 and
Charge No. 2. The Appointing Authority reversed these findings and held
him guilty of all three Charges. The question is whether he could do so
without telling the Petitioner that he proposed to differ from the Inquiry
Officer, and without giving him an opportunity to answer.
76. The Petitioner, while posted as Assistant Administrative Officer at the
Branch Office, Karampura, New Delhi, faced three Articles of Charge.
Charge No. 1 read:
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 21 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

“1. He dishonestly and with a mala-fide intention, granted
comprehensive insurance by ante dating the Cover note no.
10401 mentioning the date of issuance thereon as
02.03.2001 (Friday), 2.15 p.m. to an already accidented
Vehicle No. DL-1PA-5299 (Bus) A/c Sukhbir Singh for the
period 02.03.2001 to 01.03.2002 whereas the said vehicle
had already met with an accident on 03.03.2001 (Saturday)
at 1.50 p.m. killing one child.”
77. Sh. V.K. Parikh, Inquiry Officer, in his Report dated 12.10.2010,
concluded on Charge No. 1 that “Prosecution Witness statements inspired
no confidence. There was lack of evidence to corroborate his statements
which helped the Charged Employee of Benefit of the Doubt Charge No.1
thus not specifically proved.”
78. He recorded that “No concrete proof with regard to ante dating of
Cover Note No. 10401 has been brought to notice/record except procedural
lapses”. He further recorded that the “Other statements based on which
inference of ante dating was inferred by Prosecution side in the statement
No. 1 of Statement of Imputation of the Charge Sheet have not been found
correct/proved during the inquiry”.
79. Charge No. 2 read:
“2. He allowed 20% NCB to Vehicle No. DL-1PA-5299
(Bus) A/c Sukhbir Singh without obtaining any previous
insurance details.”
80. On Charge No. 2, the Inquiry Officer concluded that it “ has lost the
relevance because during inquiry it has been found, on the basis of
documents obtained through the use of Right to Information Act by the
Charged Employee, that the said vehicle was eligible for 20% NCB”.
81. Charge No. 3 read:
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 22 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

“3. He was running a Dummy Agency in the name of Ms.
Seema Arora (Agency code no. 4334).”
82. The Inquiry Officer held this Charge proved, for the reasons
considered under Head III above.
83. The Inquiry Report thus, found the Petitioner guilty of only one of the
three Charges, and it was against this Report that the Petitioner was called
upon to make his representation.
84. The Inquiry Report, along with the Representation of the Petitioner,
was placed before the Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy
General Manager, who, in his Order dated 19.07.2011, recorded the
following observations:
“ 1. There has been no supporting evidence in the Inquiry
which could reveal that the cover-note No. 010401 was
submitted by Shri S.K. Anand on the same day in the office.
2. Fard Maujudagi prepared just after the accident on
03.03.2001 also does not show impounding of any insurance
cover-note in respect of the vehicle involved.
3. The DCB dated 02.03.2001 and 05.03.2001 also shows
that it had been countersigned by the Charged Officer Shri
S.K. Anand who was looking after the Underwriting and
Accounts.
4. As per the Charged Officer, the client is said to have
come direct to the office and the premium had been paid
through cheque to him but still it was not treated on priority
and the cover-note was not underwritten on the same day.
5. The premium for the Cover-Note No. 010402 was also
received through cheque of the same account-holder
whereas the insured in both the cases were different.
6. Not only that, two cover-notes were issued on the basis of
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 23 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

cheques of one person‟s bank account which tantamount to
violation of Accounts Manual guidelines relating to
acceptance of Third Party cheque.
7. There is nothing on record which could prove that NCB
had been granted after obtaining the NCB confirmation
from the previous insuring office.
8. No explanation has been given during the inquiry
proceedings as also in the written brief as to why the direct
business in respect of cover-note No. 010401 was booked in
the Agency of Ms. Seema Arora.
WHEREAS all the above observations clearly point out that Shri S.K.
Anand is guilty of the charges levelled against him and warrant imposition
of severe penalty on him.”
85. A bare perusal of the Order reflects that Observations 1 to 4, which
concern the deposit of the Cover Note, the Fard Maujudagi, the
countersigning of the DCB and the delay in underwriting, all pertain to the
question whether the Cover Note was issued on 02.03.2001 or on
05.03.2001 . They relate to Charge No. 1, which the Inquiry Officer had held
not proved.
86. The Observation 7 relates to Charge No. 2, which was also held not
proved.
87. The Observations 5 and 6 relate to matters which are not the subject
of any Article of Charge. Only Observation 8 relates to Charge No. 3.
88. The Respondent Company, in its Counter Affidavit, admits that “the
Departmental Enquiry Report findings were extended against the Petitioner
for all the 3 charges” . The Order dated 19.07.2011 thus, reverses the
findings of the Inquiry Officer on Charge No. 1 and Charge No. 2.
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 24 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

89. The Order dated 19.07.2011 was passed not by the Disciplinary
Authority, Ms. Rita Singh, Regional Manager, but by the Appointing
Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy General Manager. Rule 24 of the CDA
Rules provides:
“24. Disciplinary Authority
The Disciplinary Authority, as specified in these rules or in
the Schedule or any authority higher than it, may impose
any of the penalties specified in Rule 23 on any employee.”
The Appointing Authority, being an authority higher than
the Disciplinary Authority, was competent to impose the
penalty. In doing so, it acted as the Competent Authority
under Rule 26 of the CDA Rules, and was bound by the
procedure prescribed therein.
90. The Competent Authority is not bound by the findings of the Inquiry
Officer, and may arrive at a different conclusion. However, the procedure
for doing so is prescribed in Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules , which reads as
under:
“(2) The competent authority shall , if it disagrees with the
findings of the inquiring authority on any article of
charge, record its reasons for such disagreement and
record its own findings on such charge, if the evidence on
record is sufficient for the purpose.”
91. The Order dated 19.07.2011 of the Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S.
Tandon, Deputy General Manager, records eight observations and concludes
that the Petitioner “is guilty of the charges levelled against him”. It does not,
however, state that he disagrees with the findings of the Inquiry Officer on
Charge No. 1 and Charge No. 2. Nor does it deal with the reasons for which
the Inquiry Officer had held those Charges not proved, or record a finding
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 25 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

on each Article of Charge, as Rule 26(2) mandates. The observations are
bare conclusions drawn from the record. They are not reasons for
disagreeing with the Inquiry Officer. Moreover, the Petitioner had been
asked to respond only to the Inquiry Report, which was in his favour on
Charge No. 1 and Charge No. 2. He was never told, before the penalty was
imposed, that these findings were proposed to be reversed, or on what
grounds. He thus, never had an occasion to meet the case on which he was
ultimately held guilty of those Charges.

92. In Punjab National Bank v. Kunj Behari Misra , (1998) 7 SCC 84, the
Supreme Court considered Regulation 7(2) of the Punjab National Bank
(Officers) Employees‟ (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1977, which is
pari materia with Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules. It was held that the
principles of natural justice have to be read into the Regulation, and that
“whenever the disciplinary authority disagrees with the inquiry authority on
any article of charge ”, then before recording its own findings, “ it must
record its tentative reasons for such disagreement and give to the delinquent
officer an opportunity to represent before it records its findings ”.
93. The same principle was reiterated in Yoginath D. Bagde v. State of
Maharashtra , (1999) 7 SCC 739, in respect of Rule 9(2) of the Maharashtra
Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979. The Supreme Court
held that the Disciplinary Authority “ has to communicate to the delinquent
officer the „TENTATIVE‟ reasons for disagreeing with the findings” of the
Inquiry Officer, and that this requirement “ has to be read into Rule 9(2)”.
94. The Order dated 19.07.2011 complies neither with Rule 26(2) of the
CDA Rules, nor with the requirement laid down in Kunj Behari Misra
(supra) and Yoginath D. Bagde (supra). The Competent Authority may
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 26 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

indeed disagree, but only in the manner which Rule 26(2) and the principles
of natural justice require.
95. Further, Observations 5 and 6 in the Order of the Appointing
Authority relate to Cover Note No. 010402, issued to a different insured, and
to the receipt of the premium of both Cover Notes through cheques of one
account holder, contrary to the Accounts Manual guidelines on third party
cheques. Neither matter forms part of any Article of Charge or of the
Statement of Imputation. The Inquiry Officer expressly declined to consider
them, recording that “This issue is not before the Inquiry and original
underwriting documents have not been produced so no comment is made on
this issue”.
96. The Order dated 19.07.2011 nonetheless, relies upon these matters,
though the Petitioner was never charged with them, and was never called
upon to answer them.
97. In view of the foregoing discussion, the Order dated 19.07.2011 of the
Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy General Manager, is in
breach of Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules and the principles of natural
justice, and cannot be sustained.

V. Whether the Order dated 16.04.2012 of the Appellate Authority
and the Order dated 25.02.2013 of the Chairman-cum-Managing
Director on the Memorial, are Sustainable:
98. Rule 37(2) of the CDA Rules deals with the scope of interference by
the Appellate Authority. It reads :
“(2) In the case of an appeal against an order imposing any
of the penalties specified in Rule 23, the appellate authority
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 27 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

shall consider :-
(a) whether the procedure prescribed in these Rules has
been complied with, and if not, whether such non-
compliance has resulted in failure of justice;
(b) whether the findings are justified; and
(c) whether the penalty imposed is excessive, adequate, or
inadequate, and pass orders :-
(i) setting aside, reducing, confirming or enhancing the
penalty; or
(ii) remitting the case to the authority which imposed the
penalty or to any other authority with such direction as it
may deem fit in the circumstances of the case.”

99. In his Appeal dated 07.10.2011, the Petitioner expressly invoked Rule
26(2). He contended that “The Appointing Authority has fail to describe as
to whether he is agreeing with the findings of the Inquiry Officer or
discerning with his findings” , and that “The Authority have not given me
any notice/show cause”.
100. The Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, General Manager, in
the Order dated 16.04.2012, observed:
“...in respect of charge 3, it was clearly brought out that the
Insured visited the office and placed the business directly to
the office whereas it was underwritten under the Agency
Code of Seema Arora and under the Development Officer
code of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor, that the net effect of penalty
imposed is loss of 2 increments only, that quantum of
penalty imposed upon CO is commensurate with the charge
proved.
AND THEREFORE in the absence of any fresh
evidence/information penalty imposed by the Disciplinary
Authority is here by upheld.”
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 28 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

101. The Order of the Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, General
Manager, does not advert to the contention under Rule 26(2) at all. He did
not consider whether the procedure prescribed in the CDA Rules had been
complied with, though Rule 37(2)(a) obliged him to do so.
102. The Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, considered only Charge
No. 3, and held the penalty to be “commensurate with the charge proved”.
The penalty, however, had been imposed by the Appointing Authority on
holding the Petitioner guilty of all three Charges. The Appellate Authority
neither upheld the findings of the Appointing Authority on Charge No. 1 and
Charge No. 2, nor considered whether the same penalty would be warranted,
if only Charge No. 3 stood proved.
103. Moreover, the penalty was described as a “loss of 2 increments only”.
The penalty actually imposed is demotion from Assistant Manager (Scale-II)
to Administrative Officer (Scale-I). The reduction in pay, is merely its
consequence.
104. In Ram Chander v. Union of India , (1986) 3 SCC 103, the Supreme
Court, construing Rule 22(2) of the Railway Servants (Discipline and
Appeal) Rules, 1968, which requires the Appellate Authority to “consider”
the same three aspects, held that the word must “ mean an objective
consideration by the Railway Board after due application of mind which
implies the giving of reasons for its decision”. It further held that “ the
Appellate Authority must not only give a hearing to the Government servant
concerned but also pass a reasoned order”. The Order dated 16.04.2012
reflects no such consideration.
105. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Dr. A.K. Saxena, in the
Order dated 25.02.2013, observed:
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 29 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

“...although the EO has returned the findings that only
charge of Running Dummy Agency was proved but in CDA
cases malafide is inferred from the event and not proved
separately . In this case Charged Officer issued a cover
note during office hours from a cover note book meant for
office use but he neither deposited it in office immediately
nor mentioned in the Late Cash Register or D.C.B. Hence,
the penalty imposed is justified.”
106. Having noticed that only Charge No. 3 stood proved, the Chairman-
cum-Managing Director, Dr. A.K. Saxena, justified the penalty entirely on
the timing of the deposit of the Cover Note, and its non-entry in the Late
Cash Register or the DCB. That is the very subject matter of Charge No. 1,
on which the Inquiry Officer had found the Petitioner not guilty.
107. On this aspect, the Inquiry Officer had recorded that “The Defence
witnesses confirmed that there was no such system being followed in the
Branch for Cheque supported underwriting proposals”. He further recorded
that “During Inquiry Proceedings, not a single entry of Late Receipt
Proposal supported by Cheque Payment was produced by prosecution
side”.
108. The Order dated 25.02.2013 thus, rests on a Charge of which the
Petitioner was not found guilty, and on which he was never heard after the
Inquiry Report was submitted to the Disciplinary Authority. It says nothing
on Charge No. 3, the only charge found proved.
109. The Appellate Authority upheld the penalty “in the absence of any
fresh evidence/information” . Rule 37(2) does not require the employee to
produce fresh evidence in appeal. It obliges the Appellate Authority itself to
examine whether the procedure was complied with, whether the findings are
justified, and whether the penalty is adequate. The Appellate Authority thus
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 30 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

applied a test which the Rule does not contain. The Chairman-cum-
Managing Director adopted the same approach, upholding the penalty “in
the absence of any fresh explanation/information which would merit re-
consideration of penalty imposed”.
110. The three Orders also do not sustain the penalty, on the same basis.
The Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy General Manager, after
recording eight observations, concluded that “all the above observations
clearly point out that Shri S.K. Anand is guilty of the charges levelled
against him” , i.e. of all three Charges.
111. The Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G. Rokade, General Manager,
recorded that “the Inquiry Officer returned the findings that charge No. 1
and No. 2 are not specifically proved whereas charge No. 3 is proved.
Accordingly DGM R.O. 1, New Delhi being Disciplinary Authority imposed
the following penalty” . It thus, proceeded as if the penalty rested on Charge
No. 3 alone, without noticing that the Appointing Authority had departed
from the findings of the Inquiry Officer on Charges No. 1 and 2, and held
the penalty to be “commensurate with the charge proved”.
112. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Dr. A.K. Saxena, made a
similar recital, and then accepted that “ the EO has returned the findings that
only charge of Running Dummy Agency was proved” . Yet, he justified the
penalty on the ground that the Petitioner “ neither deposited it in office
immediately nor mentioned in the Late Cash Register or D.C.B.” and that
“ malafide is inferred from the event”. That is the subject matter of Charge
No. 1, which the Inquiry Officer had held not proved. At no stage have two
Authorities agreed on what misconduct stood proved against the Petitioner.
A penalty upheld at each level on a different footing, does not rest on any
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 31 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

consistent finding of guilt, and shows that the Orders were not passed “after
due application of mind ”, as mandated in Ram Chander (supra).
113. The Orders dated 16.04.2012 and 25.02.2013 , therefore, neither cure
the defect in the Order dated 19.07.2011, nor independently sustain the
penalty; they cannot be sustained.

VI. Whether the Matter merits Remand:
114. With the Order dated 19.07.2011 vitiated, and the finding on Charge
No. 3 unsustainable, the question is whether the matter should be
remitted, i.e. sent back to the Competent Authority to decide afresh
after hearing the Petitioner.
115. The alleged misconduct relates to March, 2001. The Charge-Sheet
was issued in May, 2006, and the penalty was imposed in July, 2011. The
Petitioner stated in his Appeal dated 07.10.2011 that he was then 56 years of
age. The Inquiry Officer held Charge No. 1 and Charge No. 2 not proved
after considering the entire evidence, and Charge No. 3, the only Charge
found proved, does not survive scrutiny.
116. In Kunj Behari Misra (supra), the Supreme Court declined to remand
the matter, observing that “ More than 14 years have elapsed since the
delinquent officers had superannuated” and that “ It will, therefore, not be in
the interest of justice that at this stage the cases should be remanded”.

117. In Yoginath D. Bagde (supra), the Supreme Court examined the
disagreement, held that the Disciplinary Authority “ was wholly in error in
disagreeing with the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer” , and directed
reinstatement with all consequential benefits.
118. More than twenty-five years have elapsed since the alleged
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 32 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

misconduct. The Inquiry Officer exonerated the Petitioner of Charges No. 1
and 2 on the entire evidence, and the finding on Charge No. 3 rests on no
evidence. No fruitful purpose would, therefore, be served by remitting the
matter.

Conclusion:
119. In view of the above, the Writ Petition is allowed. The Order dated
19.07.2011 of the Appointing Authority, Sh. C.S. Tandon, Deputy General
Manager; the Order dated 16.04.2012 of the Appellate Authority, Sh. H.G.
Rokade, General Manager; and the Order dated 25.02.2013 of the Chairman-
cum-Managing Director, Dr. A.K. Saxena, are quashed.

Relief:
120. Consequently, the Respondent Company shall:
(i) treat the Petitioner as having continued in the post of Assistant
Manager (Scale-II) without interruption, and re-fix his pay from
19.07.2011 accordingly, with the increments admissible to him
under the Rules;
(ii) pay to the Petitioner the arrears of the difference in pay and
allowances arising therefrom;
(iii) in case the Petitioner has since superannuated, re-compute his
retiral benefits on the basis of the pay so re-fixed, and pay the
difference to him; and
(iv) comply with the above directions within twelve weeks from the
date of this judgment, failing which the amounts payable shall
carry simple interest @ 6% per annum from the date of this
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 33 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24

judgment till the date of payment.
121. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.

(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
November 17, 2026/ va/RS
W.P.(C) 6822/2014 Page 34 of 34

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:43:24