KAMLESH KUMAR CHOUBEY vs M/O DEFENCE
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1 of 9
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/01684 of 2025
th
DATED WEDNESDAY, THE 18 DAY OF NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
BETWEEN
Kamlesh Kumar Choubey, Son of Mulk Raj Choubey
rd
Aged about 46 years, No.78, 3 Street,
Ma. Po. Si. Nagar, Naraynapuram
Chennai 600 100. ..Applicant
(Advocate: M/s. Balan Haridas)
Versus
1. Union of India
Rep. by its Commanding Officer
'A' Coy 5033 ASC Bn (MT) C/o. 99 APO
Siliguri, West Bengal 905 033;
2. Lieutenant Colonel
'A' Coy 5033 ASC Bn (MT) C/o. 99 ΑΡΟ
Siliguri, West Bengal 905 033;
3. Senior Accounts Officer (PA)
Ministry of Defense,
Office of the Regional Accounts Office
Sewak Road, Siliguri
West Bengal 734 001;
4. Controller of Defense Accounts
No.618, Anna Salai,
Teynampet, Chennai 600 018;
5. Officer Commanding
756 (1) Tpt. Coy ASC (Civ GT)
Fort St. George
Chennai-600 009. ...Respondents
(Advocate: Mr. S. Nagarajan)
CAV ON : 07.10.2026
2 of 9
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)
This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following relief:-
nd
“(i) to quash the order of the 2 Respondent bearing No. Nil dated
29.03.2025 as illegal, arbitrary, in violation of principles of natural
justice and contrary to law;
(ii) Consequently, direct the Respondents not to effect any recovery
from the pay of the applicant on the basis that there was alleged
excess of payment of Rs.1,24,692/- from the monthly pay of the
applicant; and
(iii) Pass such other orders or directions as this Hon'ble Tribunal think
fit in the circumstances of the case.”
2. The brief facts of the case are that the applicant was appointed in a class 'C'
post of Civil Motor Driver (Ordinary Grade) vide order dated 31.07.1999 issued by
st
the 1 Respondent and he joined his duty at Srinagar, Jammu & Kashmir. From
nd
01/01/2019 onwards, he was posted in the office of the 2 Respondent and his pay
was fixed accordingly and he was granted HRA at the rate of 16%. Since then, he has
been drawing his salary accordingly. While so, his HRA was suddenly reduced from
st
16% to 8% by the 1 Respondent from April 2022. Later, on being transferred, he
th
joined the office of 5 Respondent on 03.03.2025. In the Last Pay Certificate issued
3 of 9
nd
by the 2 Respondent, it is mentioned that the applicant has been paid excess HRA
for the period from 01.01.2019 to 31.03.2022 and the excess payment of
rd
Rs.1,24,692/- has to be recovered. Consequent thereto, the 3 Respondent, vide
th
letter dated 31.07.2025, has advised the 4 Respondent to recover the excess
payment of Rs.1,24,692/- on account of HRA from the applicant’s salary and thus
steps are being taken to recover the said amount of Rs.1,24,692/- from his salary.
Hence, applicant has filed this OA for the aforestated relief and he has been granted
interim stay against recovery vide order dated 22/12/2025.
3. Upon notice, the respondents have entered appearance and filed the reply
statement stating that the applicant was appointed as Civil Motor Driver (Ordinary
Grade) as per order dated 31.07.1999 and he joined duty at Srinagar, Jammu &
Kashmir. The applicant was posted in the office of Respondent No. 2 from
01/01/2019 and his pay was fixed and he was granted HRA at the rate of 16%. From
nd
01.01.2019 till 28.02.2025, the applicant has worked under 2 respondent (5033
th
ASC Bn MT) at Sukna location and thereafter, he was posted in the office of 5
respondent (756 (1) Tpt Coy ASC (Civ GT) which is under the pay accounting
th
jurisdiction of 4 Respondent (CDA, Chennai).
4. It is contended by the respondents that for the purpose of regulating HRA,
Sukna is classified as 'Z' Class City with 8% HRA rate. Prior to 01.04.2022, HRA
at the rate 16% was paid erroneously by PCDA Bangalore based on the information
4 of 9
st
given to them by 1 respondent (5033 ASC Bn (MT). On transfer of task from Pr.
rd
Controller of Defence Accounts, Bangalore to 3 Respondent (Area Accounts Office,
Siliguri), the rate of HRA applicable to Sukna station has been corrected as 8%.
Accordingly, the demand for Rs.1,24,692/- was made as there is over-payment of
HRA during the period form 01.01.2019 to 31.03.2022. There is a statutory
obligation under Rule 43(2) and the Note appended thereto, in the Central
Government Account (Receipts and Payments) Rules, 2022, read with Rule 14 of
Financial Regulations, Part 1, Volume 1, to effect recovery of over-payment of pay
and allowances. Since the applicant was posted at Sukna during the period from
01.01.2019 to 28.02.2025, and Sukna station is classified as 'Z' Class City with 8%
HRA rate and not 16%, and HRA at 16% was paid to the applicant during that
period erroneously, there is a need to recover over-payment of a sum of Rs.1,24,692/-
towards HRA. Therefore, prayed for dismissal of the OA as it lacks merit.
5. Heard the submissions made by the learned counsels on both sides and perused
the record.
6. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that while working in the office of
nd
the 2 Respondent, the applicant was extended with HRA at the rate of 16% in
which the applicant had no role to play. The HRA was fixed at 16% in January 2019
by the respondents themselves, and later, it was reduced to 8% by them from April
2022 onwards. Thus, the action of the respondents in reducing the HRA and
5 of 9
unilaterally deciding to effect recovery of alleged excess payment of Rs.1,24,692/-
without any notice to him, is arbitrary, illegal and unjustified. The learned counsel
has relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Punjab and others, etc vs Rafiq Masih (White Washer) [(2015) 4 SCC 334] in support
of his case.
7. On the other hand, it is argued by the learned counsel for the respondents that
there is a statutory obligation under Rule 43(2) and the Note appended thereto, in the
Central Government Account (Receipts and Payments) Rules, 2022, read with Rule
14 of Financial Regulations, Part 1, Volume 1, to effect recovery of over-payment of
Pay and Allowances. Hence, the action of the respondents to recover the excess paid
amount from the salary of the applicant is justified.
8. Therefore, the question before me is whether the respondents are entitled to
recover the excess paid amount of Rs.1,24,692/- from the salary of the applicant
without issuing any notice to him and whether the applicant is entitled to the relief
sought.
9. Admittedly, the applicant is a Group 'C' employee. The wrong fixation of HRA
at the rate of 16% was done by the respondents themselves, and excess payment was
made to the applicant on that basis. The applicant had absolutely no role to play in
such erroneous fixation of HRA, and the excess payment so made was not on account
6 of 9
of any misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the applicant. It is observed that the
wrong fixation of HRA was done in January 2019 and demand for recovery of excess
payment of Rs.1,24,692/- was raised only on 29/03/2025. Therefore, the case of the
applicant falls under the exempted circumstances and is covered by the decision of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab and Others etc. v. Rafiq
Masih (White Washer) (Supra) wherein it is held that the order of recovery is
impermissible in the case of employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV service
(or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service) and when excess payment has been made for a
period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
10. In its judgement in the case of State of Punjab and Others etc. v. Rafiq Masih
(White Washer) etc. (Supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered the issue of
propriety of the recovery of monetary benefits wrongly extended to the employees
due to unintentional mistake committed by the employer and not on account of any
misrepresentation or fraud committed by the employees. It held that in view of the
doctrine of equality enshrined in Arts. 14 to 18 and 38, 39, 39A, 43 and 46 of the
Constitution, equity and good conscience has to be the basis of all Governmental
actions in the matter of livelihood of the people. It further held that recovery of
monetary benefit given in excess of entitlement to the employee would be
permissible in law so long it is equitous and does not have harsh and arbitrary effect
on the employee. It has categorically held that such recovery would be impermissible
in certain cases, and has summarized such cases in para 18 of its judgement, as
7 of 9
under:-
"18. lt is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which
would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments
have mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their
entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to
herein above, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the following
few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers would be
impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class III and Class-IV
service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service);
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due
to retire within one year, of the order of recovery;
(iii) Recovery. from employees, when the excess payment has
been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued;
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post;
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion,
that recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or
harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the
equitable balance of the employer's right to recover."
8 of 9
11. The law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the above case has
consistently been reiterated in several other cases including in recent judgement in
the case of Thomas Daniel vs State of Kerala and others [(2022) SCC online SC
536]. It is observed that consequent upon the Supreme Court judgement in White
Washer case (Supra), the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions,
Department of Personnel & Training has accepted the law laid down by the Apex
Court and has issued instructions dated 02.03.2016 advising all Ministries and
departments to deal with the issue of wrongful/ excess payments made to
Government servants in accordance with the said judgement in White Washer case
(Supra).
12. Learned counsel for the applicant has also produced additional documents, viz.,
Office Memorandum dated 01/04/2025 issued by the Department of Expenditure
regarding waiver of recovery of excess payment made to government employees and
Communication dated 16.07.2025 issued by the respondent department for waiving
off excess payment of HRA made by PCDA, Bangalore w.e.f. 01.04.2015 to
31.03.2025 to the civilian employees which are also based on the Supreme Court
decision in White Washer case (Supra). It is stated in para 3 of the said
communication that “ Based on the judgement dated 18 Dee 2014 of Hon'ble
Supreme Court, the recovery of excess payment from employees belonging to Class-
Ill and Class-IV (Group 'C" and Group D) services is impermissible in law.”.
9 of 9
nd
13. In view of the above, the impugned order dated 29/03/2025 issued by the 2
respondent is hereby quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed not to
effect any recovery of the alleged excess payment of Rs.1,24,692/- from the monthly
pay of the applicant. In case any amount is recovered, the same shall be refunded
forthwith. OA is accordingly allowed. No order as to costs .
(Veena Kothavale)
Member(J)
asvs 18.11.2026
Digitally signed by
ASAPU SRINIVASA
VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20
17:13:55 +05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.