Chilambarasi vs The Inspector of Police
- Court
- Madras High Court
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved On: 18.09.2026
Delivered On: 13.11.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA
and
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE B.MURUGESAN
CRL A(MD) No. 828 of 2023
CNR:{HCMD010851882023}
Chilambarasi ... Appellant
Vs.
The Inspector of Police
Pattiveeranpatti Police Station,
Dindigul District,
Crime No.102/2014 ... Respondent
PRAYER: Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374 Cr.P.C., to call for
the records relating to the judgment in S.C.No.10/2017 dated 17.10.2022
on the file of the Additional District and Sessions Court, Dindigul set
aside the same and allow this appeal.
For Appellant : Mr.M.Subash Babu,
Senior Counsel
For Respondent : Mr.D.Venkatesh,
Additional Public Prosecutor
__________
Page 1 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
JUDGMENT
[Judgment of the Court was made by B.MURUGESAN, J. ]
Assailing the judgment dated 17.10.2022 of the Additional
District and Sessions Court, Dindigul, hereinafter referred to as ‘the
trial court’, in SC No.10/2017, convicting the appellant/sole accused
and sentencing her to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay a fine
of Rs.10,000/-, in default, to undergo simple imprisonment for three
months, for the offence punishable under S.302 IPC, the appellant/sole
accused has preferred this criminal appeal.
02. Case of the prosecution would run as under:
(1) Accused is the wife of the deceased Kannan and they have
two children. Kannan being a chronic drunkard had been harassing the
accused by beating her up. Therefore, the accused had decided to
murder her husband, Kannan.
(2) On 11.06.2014 at about 23.00 hrs, the accused, at their house
th
situate in Chinnammal Koil Street, 6 Ward, Sitharevu, cut her
husband, Kannan, several times with a knife causing several blood
injuries all over his head and neck. On account of such injuries,
Kannan died at the spot. Thereafter, the accused ran away.
__________
Page 2 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
(3) On 12.06.2014 at about 02.00 hrs, Parvathi, the mother of the
deceased, lodged a complaint with Pattiveeranpatti Police Station.
(4) Pursuant to the registration of FIR in Cr No.102/2014 on the
file of Pattiveeranpatti Police Station, PW21/IO took the case for
investigation, inspected the place of occurrence and prepared the
observation mahazar and rough sketch in the presence of the witnesses,
Chelladurai and Pandi. IO examined the witnesses, Parvathi, Janaki,
Santha, Moorthy, Ganesan, Jeyaseelan, Pramila, Vairamani, Chandran,
Manikandan, Agni, SSI Vellaichamy and SI Aranganayaki, and
recorded their statements. On 12.06.2014 at about 05.00 hrs, IO
conducted inquest on the dead body of Kannan at Vathalakkundu GH
and sent the dead body for postmortem. On the information given by
VAO, Sitharevu, that the accused surrendered and her confession was
recorded, IO went to the office of VAO, arrested the accused and
recorded her confession in the presence of VAO and her assistant. IO,
in pursuance of the confession, recovered the knife and the blood
stained dresses of the accused under a seizure mahazar. IO examined
VAO and her assistant and recorded their statements. IO caused the
accused remanded to judicial custody and sent the case properties to
the court under Form 95. IO examined Mayathevar, Rasu,
Murugeswari, Jeeva, Sivasami, Rajendran and Shanmugarajan and
__________
Page 3 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
recorded their statements. IO caused the case properties sent to RFSL,
Madurai. On 20.06.2014, IO examined the doctor and obtained the
postmortem certificate. IO examined the scientific officer and recorded
her statement. IO examined Constable Rajendran and recorded his
statement. After such investigation, IO filed a final report against the
accused for the offence punishable under S.302 IPC.
03. By an order in PRC No.31/2014, the case was committed by
the Judicial Magistrate, Nilakkottai, to the Principal Sessions Court,
Dindigul District, which made over the case to the trial court, namely,
the Additional District and Sessions Court, Dindigul, for disposal.
04. On appearance of the accused before the trial court, the trial
court satisfied that accused was furnished free of cost with the copies
of the records relied on by the prosecution, as required under S.207
CrPC.
05. Thereupon, the learned Public Prosecutor opened the case
before the trial court, as under S.226 CrPC, and the learned counsel for
the accused was also heard. On due consideration thereof, charge was
framed by the trial court against the accused under S.302 IPC, and the
__________
Page 4 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
same was read over and explained to her by trial court, as under S.228
CrPC.
06. Accordingly, the accused was questioned by the trial court as
to the charge framed against her, and she denied the charge as not true,
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
07. Pursuant thereto, trial was ordered, and the prosecution
produced evidence in support of its case, and therefore, the
prosecution, before the trial court, examined PW1 to PW21 and
marked Ex.P1 to Ex.P17 and MO1 to MO8 through the competent
witnesses.
08. Details of the witnesses and the exhibits on the side of the
prosecution before the trial court are as under:
(1) PW1 is Parvathi, the mother of the deceased Kannan, who
would speak about the events prior to the occurrence, the occurrence,
the arrival of the police to the house of occurrence and the lodging of
the complaint, Ex.P1. MO1 is billhook.
(2) PW2 is Janaki, the sister of the deceased Kannan, who would
speak of the events prior to the occurrence, the occurrence, the arrival
of the police to the house of occurrence, the lodging of the complaint
and the recovery of another knife.
__________
Page 5 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
(3) PW3 is Santha, the sister of the deceased Kannan, who would
speak of the events prior to the occurrence, the occurrence, the arrival
to the police station and another knife wielded by the accused.
(4) PW4 is Moorthy, the brother of the deceased Kannan, who
would speak of the events prior to the occurrence and the lodging of
the complaint.
(5) PW5 is Ganesan, the brother of the deceased Kannan, who
would speak of the events prior to the occurrence and the lodging of
the complaint.
(6) PW6 is Jeyaseelan, the brother of the deceased Kannan, who
would speak of the events prior to the occurrence, the occurrence and
the lodging of the complaint.
(7) PW7 is Vairamani, the husband of PW2, who would speak of
his arrival to the house of occurrence after the occurrence and the
arrival of the police to the house of occurrence soon after the
occurrence.
(8) PW8 is Manikandan, the relative of the deceased Kannan,
who would speak of his arrival to the house of occurrence after the
occurrence, the arrival of the police to the house of occurrence soon
after the occurrence, the presence of the accused in the house of
occurrence, the enquiry of the accused by the police and the lodging of
__________
Page 6 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
the complaint. Ex.P2 is his attesting signature in the complaint, Ex.P1.
(9) PW9, Murugeswari, PW10, Mayathevar, PW11, Rasu, are
neighbours, whose evidence are hearsay.
(10) PW12, Praveena, the wife of PW6, and PW13, Jeeva, a
neighbour, have been declared hostile.
(11) PW14 is Chelladurai, meant for observation mahazar and
rough sketch, who has been declared hostile. Ex.P3 is his signature in
the observation mahazar.
(12) PW15 is VAO Sahira Banu who would speak about the
surrender of the accused (before VAO), the recording of her confession
(by VAO), the handing over of the accused to the police at the police
station, the handing over of the confession statement recorded at the
office of VAO, the recording of the confession of the accused by the
police and the recovery of the Billhook, MO1. Ex.P4 is the
complaint/report given by VAO. Ex.P5 is the confession given by the
accused before the police. Ex.P6 is her signature in the seizure
mahazar for the billhook.
(13) PW16 is Dr Devadoss who conducted the postmortem
would speak of the injuries found in the dead body of the deceased
Kannan. Ex.P7 is the requisition for postmortem and Ex.P8 is the
postmortem certificate.
__________
Page 7 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
(14) PW17 is SI Aranganayaki who would speak of the
registration of FIR, Ex.P9.
(15) PW18 is Constable Rajendran who would speak about his
role in conducting the inquest, in sending the dead body for
postmortem and in sending the case properties to RFSL.
(16) PW19 is SSI Vellaichamy who would speak of his role in
sending the FIR to the jurisdictional Magistrate.
(17) PW20 is Annammal Mary Stella, Deputy Director, RFSL,
Madurai, who would speak about the biological report, Ex.P10, and the
serological report, Ex.P11.
(18) PW21 is Karuppusamy, IO, who would speak about his
investigation in detail and the consequent final report. Ex.P12 is
observation mahazar, Ex.P13 is rough sketch, Ex.P14 is inquest report,
Ex.P15 is admissible portion in the confession, Ex.P16 is seizure
mahazar and Ex.P17 is Forms 95. MO2 is bloodstained soil, MO3 is
sample soil, MO4 is bloodstained shirt, MO5 is bloodstained sleeveless
vest, MO6 is bloodstained lungi, MO7 is bloodstained saree and MO8
is blouse.
09. While questioning under S.313 CrPC in respect of the
incriminating materials appearing against her in the evidence of the
__________
Page 8 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
prosecution, the accused answered before the trial court that all such
evidence are false and that this is a false case.
10. On the other hand, there is no evidence, either oral or
documentary, on the side of the accused.
11. Finding her guilty, the trial court has convicted the accused
for the offence under S.302 IPC, and sentenced her as aforesaid.
12. Assailing such conviction and sentence of the trial court, the
accused has preferred this criminal appeal before us.
13. We have heard the learned counsel for the appellant/accused
and the learned Additional Public Prosecutor, and we have also
perused the records carefully.
14. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant/accused would
submit that this is a case based on circumstantial evidence but the
motive, the starting point, has not been proved by the prosecution, that
the complaint, in the light of evidence of PW1 and PW17, is shrouded
in mystery, that the topography covering the house of occurrence and
the house of the witnesses would show the witnesses could not have
__________
Page 9 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
heard any screams from the house of the occurrence, that there are
material contradictions in the evidence of the witnesses as to the arrival
of the police to the house of occurrence, that there are material
contradictions as to the nature and size of the weapon and also as to the
number of weapons, that the arrest and confession of the accused, in
the light of the evidence of PW15, VAO, and the evidence of PW20,
IO, would create a million dollar question tarnishing the case of the
prosecution, that the evidence of PW8, the attesting witness in the
complaint, would go to the root of the case of the prosecution, that the
recovery of the weapon is also doubtful, that the prosecution is silent
as to the recovery of a knife from the house of occurrence, that the
witnesses examined on the side of the prosecution are close relatives
and no independent witness was examined, that PW8 has given
evidence PW1 to PW6 were not present in the village during the
occurrence, that the prosecution has suppressed the complaint given by
the accused, that PW12 and PW13 who are the close relative of the
deceased have turned hostile, that the medical evidence and the
forensic evidence would not support the case of the prosecution and
that therefore, a judgment reversing the finding and sentence of the
trial court, and acquitting the accused of the charge levelled against her
needs to be passed.
__________
Page 10 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
15. Per contra , the learned Additional Public Prosecutor would
submit that PW1, PW2, PW3, PW6, and PW11, immediately after the
occurrence, have seen the accused holding billhook, MO1, at the house
of occurrence, and running therefrom, that the evidence of a witness, if
found reliable, cannot be discarded for the simple reason that the
witness is the relative of the victim, that even though there are some
inconsistencies as to the arrest and confession of the accused, the
recovery of weapon in consequence of such confession would support
the case of the prosecution, that since the accused and the deceased are
husband and wife, having family disputes, motive for the crime
committed by the wife would not assume any significance, that when
the presence of the accused at the house of occurrence during the
relevant time is established, it is for the accused to give explanation
about the occurrence, as under S.106 of the Indian Evidence Act, that
the prosecution has proved its case to the hilt and that therefore, the
criminal appeal filed by the accused deserves for dismissal.
16. Points for determination in this criminal appeal is whether
the trial court is right in finding the appellant/accused guilty and
thereby convicting and sentencing her under S.302 IPC?
__________
Page 11 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
17. At the outset, we would like to recollect the settled law that it
is the duty of an appellate court to look into the evidence adduced in
the case and arrive at an independent conclusion as to whether the said
evidence can be relied upon or not and even it can be relied upon, then
whether the prosecution can be said to have proved beyond reasonable
doubt on the said evidence, and the credibility of a witness has to be
adjudged by the appellate court in drawing inference from proved and
admitted facts, as held in Iqbal Abdul Samiya Malek and other V
State of Gujarat ((2012) 11 SCC 312).
18. Jogi and others V State of Madhya Pradesh (2021
LiveLaw SC 639) is a case where Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as
under:
‘9 ….. In the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction, the
High Court was required to evaluate the evidence on the
record independently and to arrive at its own findings as
regards the culpability or otherwise of the accused on the
basis of the evidentiary material.’
19. Keeping in mind the above principles, let us get on with the
discussions. PW12, Praveena, the wife of PW6, Jayaseelan who is the
brother of the deceased Kannan, has been declared hostile and she has
__________
Page 12 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
been cross examined by the prosecution. During such cross
examination, a suggestion has been put forward to the effect that as
and when PW1, PW2, PW3, PW4, PW5, PW6 and PW7 rushed to the
house of the occurrence on hearing screams, the accused cut her
husband, Kannan, several times with a knife all over his head and
neck, saying ‘die with this’. It is therefore clear that the case originally
portrayed to have been based on eye witnesses has, during trial, turned
out to be a case based on circumstantial evidence.
20. Be that as it may, the circumstances, as projected by the
prosecution, are (1) deceased being drunkard, (2) tortures by the
deceased on the accused, (3) standing of the accused with billhook at
the house of occurrence, (4) running of the accused with billhook
through the street, (5) complaint, (6) arrest and confession of the
accused, (6) recovery of the billhook in pursuance of the confession
and (7) non explanation of the accused under S.106 of Indian Evidence
Act.
21. Deceased being drunkard and tortures by the deceased
What, according to the prosecution, has driven the accused to
commit the murder of her husband, Kannan, is that her husband had
__________
Page 13 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
been a chronic drunkard and that he had been harassing the accused
recklessly. As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the
accused, the case of the prosecution rests on, and starts from, such
theory of ‘tortures by the deceased, a chronic drunkard’. But, none of
the witnesses would speak either that the deceased had been a chronic
drunkard, the first circumstance, or that the deceased had been
harassing the accused recklessly, the second circumstance. Therefore,
we hold that the prosecution has failed to establish the motive, in
simple terms, the reason for doing the murder of the deceased,
referable to the first and second circumstance.
22. Standing of the accused with billhook at the house of
occurrence
(1) Of 21 witnesses, 7 witnesses, PW15 to PW21, are official
witnesses. 8 witnesses, PW1, PW2, PW3, PW4, PW5, PW6, PW7 and
PW14, are close relatives but PW12, the wife of PW6, has been
declared hostile. 4 witnesses, PW9, PW10, PW11 and PW13, are
neighbours, of which PW9, PW10, PW11 are hearsay witnesses and
PW13 has been declared hostile. PW14 is meant for observation
mahazar but he has been declared hostile. PW8 who is the attesting
witness in the complaint, Ex.P1, is also a hearsay witness.
__________
Page 14 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
(2) Therefore, PW1, the mother of the deceased, PW2, the sister
of the deceased, PW3, the sister of the deceased, PW4, the brother of
the deceased, PW5, the brother of the deceased, PW6, the brother of
the deceased and PW7, the husband of PW2 are the 7 witnesses
intended to prove the standing of the accused with billhook at the
house of occurrence immediately after the occurrence.
(3) PW7, during his examination, has turned out to be a hearsay
witness having reached the house of occurrence long after the
occurrence. PW4, PW5 and PW6 would not state that the accused was
standing with billhook at the house of occurrence immediately after the
occurrence.
(4) What remains is the evidence of PW1, PW2 and PW3 who
would state in unison that as and when they rushed to the house of the
occurrence on hearing screams, the accused was standing with billhook
and the deceased was found dead in a pool of blood.
(5) PW8, a relative of the deceased, who admits to have attested
the complaint, Ex.P1, would state in his cross examination that along
with him, PW2 and PW3 reached the house of occurrence only after
hearing the occurrence and that PW1, who went to Mallayapuram for a
function, returned to the village/house of occurrence only on the next
day because no bus was available during night hours to return
__________
Page 15 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
therefrom. In other words, PW8 would say that PW1, PW2 and PW3
did not witness, or could not have witnessed, the standing of the
accused with billhook at the house of occurrence immediately after the
occurrence.
(6) Therefore, we find that the prosecution has not proved the
standing of the accused with billhook at the house of occurrence
immediately after the occurrence, the third circumstance.
23. Running of the accused with billhook through the street
(1) PW1, the mother of the deceased, PW2, the sister of the
deceased, PW3, the sister of the deceased, PW4, the brother of the
deceased, PW5, the brother of the deceased, PW6, the brother of the
deceased and PW7, the husband of PW2 are also the 7 witnesses
intended to prove the running of the accused with billhook through the
street immediately after the occurrence.
(2) As discussed earlier, PW7, during his examination, has
turned out to be a hearsay witness having reached the house of
occurrence long after the occurrence. PW4 and PW5 would not state
that the accused was running with billhook through the street
immediately after the occurrence.
(3) What remains is the evidence of PW1, PW2 PW3 and PW6
__________
Page 16 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
who would state in unison that the accused was running with billhook
through the street immediately after the occurrence.
(4) PW8, as discussed earlier, would state in his cross
examination that along with him, PW2, PW3 and PW6 reached the
house of occurrence only after hearing the occurrence and that PW1,
who went to Mallayapuram for a function, returned to the
village/house of occurrence only on the next day because no bus was
available during night hours to return therefrom. In other words, PW8
would say that PW1, PW2 PW3 and PW6 did not witness, or could not
have witnessed, the running of the accused with billhook through the
street immediately after the occurrence.
(5) PW11, a distant relative of the deceased, would state in his
chief examination that he saw the accused running with ‘a thing’ at her
hand. But, during his cross examination, he would admit that he did
not see the front side of the lady running, that there were no street
lights in that area and that the area would always be very dark.
(6) Therefore, we find that the prosecution has not proved the
running of the accused with billhook through the street immediately
after the occurrence, the fourth circumstance.
24. Complaint
(1) Ex.P1 is the complaint alleged to have been given by PW1.
__________
Page 17 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
But, PW8, a relative of the deceased, who has attested the complaint,
Ex.P1, would state in his cross examination that the police, at the
police station, has received a complaint from the accused and that he
has affixed his signature in that complaint also as an attesting witness.
(2) Now, the questions, which remained unanswered, are which
complaint is first, why has such a complaint been obtained from the
accused and why have the police suppressed such complaint obtained
from the accused?
(3) It is pertinent to note that when PW8 has given evidence
against the prosecution even in his chief examination to the effect that
when he rushed to the house of occurrence at about 23.00 hrs (on the
date occurrence), the police was present, that the accused was there,
that he went to the police station on the same day but along with the
accused, that the police enquired the accused on the next morning, that
he did not know what was written in the complaint, Ex.P1, and that the
police did not examine him, the prosecution has not chosen to declare
him hostile.
(4) Ex.P1 appears to have been given by PW1 on 12.06.2014 at
about 02.00 hrs but PW1 admits even in her chief examination that the
police arrived the place of occurrence (on 11.06.2014) at about 23.00
hrs. Again the question is on whose complaint, technically speaking,
__________
Page 18 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
first information, did the police arrive at the place of occurrence at the
night itself?
(5) Ex.P1, on its face, appears to have been given by PW1 on
12.06.2014 at about 02.00 hrs and PW21, IO, would state in his chief
examination that he went to the place of occurrence on 12.06.2014 at
about 04.00 hrs but PW1 admits in her cross examination that Ex.P1
was given at about 06.00 hrs on 12.06.2014.
(6) PW8, who has attested the complaint, Ex.P1, would also state
in his cross examination that PW1 and he affixed their signatures in
Ex.P1, the complaint, which had already been drafted by the police.
(7) Therefore, we hold that the complaint, Ex.P1, the fifth
circumstance, is found shrouded in mystery and that the prosecution
has failed to give any plausible explanation on such insistencies and
infirmities as discussed earlier.
25. Arrest and confession of the accused
(1) As discussed earlier, PW8 has given evidence in his chief
examination to the effect that when he rushed to the house of
occurrence at about 23.00 hrs (on the date occurrence), the police was
present, that the accused was there, that he went to the police station on
the same day but along with the accused and that the police enquired
__________
Page 19 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
the accused on the next morning. During his cross examination, PW8
would state that the police retained the accused in the police station
throughout the night, that he was also in the police station throughout
the night and that the police took the accused to the police station to
get a complaint from her for the death of her husband.
(2) PW15, VAO, would state as if the accused appeared before
her on 12.06.2014 at about 13.00 hrs, the accused confessed before her,
she recorded the confession of the accused, she forwarded the accused
to the police station at about 14.00 hrs through her assistant by a bus
and she reached the police station by her two wheeler.
(3) PW21, IO, would state that on receiving the information
from PW15, VAO, he reached the office of VAO, arrested the accused
at the office of VAO and recorded the confession of the accused at the
office of VAO. Ex.P15 is the admissible portion in the confession
alleged to have been recorded by PW21, IO.
(4) PW15, VAO, has given to PW21, IO, a report, Ex.P4, which
would read that the accused along with her confession recorded by
PW15, VAO, were handed over to PW21, IO.
(5) In short, the accused is said to have given two confessions,
one/first, before PW15, VAO, and the other/next, before PW21, IO.
But, the confession said to have been given to the police has been filed
__________
Page 20 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
into the court but the confession said to been given to the VAO, PW15,
has not been filed.
(6) Therefore, we hold that the arrest of the accused and the
consequent confession of the accused are also found shrouded in such
mystery as discussed above without any explanation thereto.
26. Recovery of the billhook in pursuance of the confession
(1) MO1, the billhook, is said to have been recovered in
pursuance of the confession given by the accused to the police and
Ex.P15 is the admissible portion in such confession.
(2) PW2 would state that the police have recovered another knife
in the very same night from the place of occurrence under an almirah.
(3) PW3 would state that the accused has wielded the billhook,
MO1, in one hand, and another knife in other hand.
(4) PW16, Dr Devadoss, who conducted postmortem, would
state inter alia that there were seven injuries in the dead body of the
deceased, that the third injury measuring 3.5 x 3.0 x 3.5 cm over the
thyroid cartilage was a punctured wound, that this third injury was the
direct cause for the death and that MO1 would not have caused such
punctured wound.
(5) Therefore, we hold that the recovery of billhook in pursuance
__________
Page 21 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
of the alleged confession, the sixth circumstance, is also found
shrouded in mystery, raising serious clouds on the case of the
prosecution.
27. Non explanation of the accused under S.106 of Indian
Evidence Act
(1) It is the case of the prosecution that since the deceased was
last seen in the company of the accused shortly before his death, it is
for the accused to explain what happened during the fateful night.
(2) Strictly speaking, none of the witnesses would speak
precisely that the deceased was last seen in the company of the accused
shortly before his death.
(3) PW1, PW2, PW3 and PW6, the mother and the siblings of
the deceased, would state that they have seen the accused at the house
of the occurrence only after the occurrence.
(4) Evidently, the prosecution has not chosen to examine the
neighbours of the house of occurrence, including the owner of the
house or his brothers who were residing around the house of
occurrence.
(5) PW1 would state in her cross examination that when she
rushed to the house of occurrence, the daughter of the deceased was
__________
Page 22 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
crying. But, the prosecution has not chosen to examine such daughter
nor has it chosen to examine the other child in order to prove the
presence of the accused during the occurrence.
(6) Even assuming arguendo that the deceased was last seen in
the company of the accused shortly before his death, S.106 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872, can be invoked only when a prima facie
case has been made out by the prosecution, as held by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of Madhya Pradesh V Balveer Singh (2025
INSC 261) , and the relevant excerpts would read as under:
‘ 76 . Section 106 cannot be invoked to make up the
inability of the prosecution to produce evidence of
circumstances pointing to the guilt of the accused. This
section cannot be used to support a conviction unless the
prosecution has discharged the onus by proving all the
elements necessary to establish the offence. It does not
absolve the prosecution from the duty of proving that a
crime was committed even though it is a matter
specifically within the knowledge of the accused and it
does not throw the burden on the accused to show that no
crime was committed. To infer the guilt of the accused
from absence of reasonable explanation in a case where
the other circumstances are not by themselves enough to
call for his explanation is to relieve the prosecution of its
legitimate burden. So, until a prima facie case is
__________
Page 23 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
established by such evidence, the onus does not shift to the
accused.’
Recently, Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Anand Jakkappa Pujari @
Gaddadar V State of Karnataka (2026 INSC 417) , has held as
under:
‘ 43 . By now, it is a well settled position of law that the
circumstance of “last seen together” does not by itself and
necessarily lead to the inference that it was the accused who
committed the crime. There must be something more
establishing the connectivity between the accused and the
crime. The Courts should look for some corroboration.’
In this case on hand, the prosecution, as discussed earlier, has failed to
establish the foundational facts shifting the onus to the accused.
(7) Therefore, we hold that the prosecution cannot take shelter
under S.106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, by requiring the
accused to give explanation under the guise of ‘special knowledge’ and
thereby to prove the contrary. In short, the seventh circumstance relied
on by the prosecution would also fail.
28. Besides the medical evidence, the forensic evidence would
also not support the case of the prosecution in such a way that the
groping test on MO1, the billhook, and on MO7, the saree of the
__________
Page 24 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
accused, is inconclusive.
29. Five golden principles governing ‘proof’ in a case based on
circumstantial evidence, as affirmed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Abdul Nassar V State of Kerala and another (2025 INSC 35) , are
(1) that the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is
to be drawn should be fully established.
(2) that the facts so established should be consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they
should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the
accused is guilty,
(3) that the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency,
(4) that they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the
one to be proved, and
(5) that there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to
leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with
the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human
probability the act must have been done by the accused.
In this case on hand, almost all the circumstances relied on by the
prosecution, as discussed earlier, stand vanished, driving us to come to
the conclusion that the prosecution has not proved its case against the
accused beyond all reasonable doubt.
__________
Page 25 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
30. It is elementary in criminal jurisprudence that the burden of
proof is proof beyond all reasonable doubt and that the accused is
entitled to the benefit of every reasonable doubt . In this case on hand,
the case of the prosecution bristles with such material infirmities as
aforesaid and the case of the prosecution is thus shrouded in mystery
with reasonable doubts.
31. Resultantly, this court holds that the trial court is not right in
finding the appellant/accused guilty and thereby convicting and
sentencing her under S.302 IPC, and this point is answered,
accordingly.
32. In fine,
(a) that this criminal appeal filed by the appellant/accused shall
stand allowed,
(b) that the finding and sentence of the trial court in SC
No.10/2017 is hereby reversed,
(c) that the appellant/accused is hereby acquitted of the charge
under S.302 IPC,
(d) that the appellant/accused is hereby set at liberty,
(e) that the appellant/accused, unless her detention is required in
__________
Page 26 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
any other case, shall be released forthwith,
(f) that the fine amount, if paid by the appellant/accused, shall be
refunded, and
(g) that the bail bond executed by the appellant/accused shall
stand cancelled.
[A.D.J.C., J.] [B.M., J.]
13.11.2026
gns
To
1. The Additional District and Sessions Court, Dindigul
2. The Inspector of Police
Pattiveeranpatti Police Station
Dindigul District
3. The Additional Public Prosecutor
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
Madurai
Copy To :
Section Officer ( VR Section )
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
__________
Page 27 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )
CRL.A(MD)No.828 of 2023
A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA, J.
AND
B.MURUGESAN, J.
gns
Judgment made in
CRL.A.(MD)No.828 of 2023
13.11.2026
__________
Page 28 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:40 pm )