Minesh Nanu Patil vs The State Of Maharashtra

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010137182018

2026:BHC-AS:46178-DB

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
APPELLATE SIDE CRIMINAL JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 423 OF 2018
1. Umesh Yashwant Patil
Age 26 Yrs.
VISHAL
SUBHASH
PAREKAR
2. Sandip Kaka Patil
Age- 35 Yrs.
Digitally signed by
VISHAL SUBHASH
PAREKAR
Date: 2026.11.21
15:52:12 +0530
3. Kabir Lahu Karbhari
Age- 28 Yrs.
All r/o. Umbarde Village,
Near God Shankar Temple,
Kalyan (w), Dist. Thane. … Appellants
vs.
The State of Maharashtra
(C.R. No. 237 of 2012, Kalyan Crime Branch) …Respondent
WITH
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 424 OF 2018
Kaka Shankar Patil (since deceased through
Smt. Raghubai Kaka Patil)
Age- 58 Yrs.
r/o. Umbarde Village,
Near God Shankar Temple,
Kalyan (w), Dist. Thane. … Appellant
vs.
The State of Maharashtra
(C.R. No. 237 of 2012, Kalyan Crime Branch) …Respondent
WITH
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 425 OF 2018
Vishal Parekar .....1
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
1. Pradeep Baliram Patil
Age- 27 Yrs.
r/o. Umbarde Village, Near God Shankar Temple,
Kalyan (w), Dist. Thane.
2. Anil Kaka Patil
Age- 30 Yrs.
3. Ranbul @ Ranshya Chandrakant Patil
Age- 47 Yrs.
4. Bhagwat Yashwant Patil
Age- 29 Yrs.
5. Sanjay Lahu Karbhari
Age- 39 Yrs.
6. Kisan Kalu Patil
Age- 47 Yrs.
7. Bharat Baliram Patil
Age- 44 Yrs.
8. Yashwant Baliram Patil
Age- 57 Yrs.
9. Sharad Baliram Patil
Age- 44 Yrs.
10. Madhukar Ramchandra Patil
Age- 57 Yrs.
11. Baliram Gajanan Patil
Age- 56 Yrs.
All r/o. Umbarde Village,
Near God Shankar Temple,
Kalyan (w), Dist. Thane. …Appellants
vs.
The State of Maharashtra
(C.R. No. 237 of 2012, Bazarpeth police station,
Kalyan, Crime Branch) …Respondent
Vishal Parekar .....2
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
WITH
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 316 OF 2018
Minesh Nanu Patil
Age- 26 Yrs.
R/o. Umbarde Village,
Near God Shankar Temple,
Kalyan (w), Dist. Thane. … Appellant
vs.
The State of Maharashtra …Respondent
Mr. Kuldeep Patil a/w. Mr. Anay Joshi, Mr. Sumitkumar Nimbalkar, Mr.
Sandeep Salunke, for Appellants in Cri.A. Nos. 423, 424 and 425 of 2018.
Mr. Raju Suryawanshi, for the Appellant in Cri.A. No. 316 of 2018.
Mr. Amit Munde, Spl.PP, for Respondent-State.
CORAM: MANISH PITALE &
SHREERAM V. SHIRSAT, JJ.
th
RESERVED ON: 24 AUGUST, 2026
st
PRONOUNCED ON: 21 NOVEMBER, 2026
---------------
JUDGMENT: ( Per Shreeram Shirsat, J .)
1. The present Appeal has been filed challenging the impugned judgment
and order dated 07.03.2018 passed by the District & Sessions Judge- 2 at
Kalyan, Mumbai in Sessions Case No. 24 of 2013, whereby the Sessions
Court has been pleased to convict all the Accused-Appellants i.e. A-1 to A-16
for the offence punishable under Sections 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149 of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). All the Accused-Appellants are also convicted
for the offence punishable under Section 302 r/w 149 of the IPC each and
Vishal Parekar .....3
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
they are sentenced to suffer Rigorous Imprisonment (R.I.) for Life of each
and to pay a fine of Rs. 10,000/- each and in default, to suffer R.I. for further
3 months each. All the Accused-Appellants are also convicted under Section
201 r/w 149 of the IPC each and are sentenced to suffer R.I. for 3 years of
each and to pay a fine of Rs. 5,000/- each and in default, to suffer R.I. for 3
months each.
2. Additionally, Accused No. 3 (Umesh Yashwant Patil), Accused No. 10
(Sandeep Kaka Patil) and Accused No. 12 (Kabir Lahu Karbhari) are also
convicted for the offence punishable under Section 148 r/w 147 of the IPC
each and are sentenced to suffer R.I. for 3 years of each and to pay a fine of
Rs. 5,000/- each and in default, to suffer R.I. for further 3 months each.
3. All the Accused/Appellants were acquitted for the offences punishable
under Section 120-B r/w 149 of the IPC and Section 37(1) 135 of the
Maharashtra Police Act as per provision under Section 235(1) of the Criminal
Procedure Code (Cr.P.C). All sentences were directed to run consecutively.
4. Since all the appeals are arising out of the same impugned judgment,
all the appeals are being disposed of by a common judgment. The Appellants
are also referred to as accused interchangeably for the sake of convenience
and for situational reference.
Vishal Parekar .....4
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
5. Before proceeding to deal with the facts of the case, it will be
advantageous to give the names of all the accused and their respective
punishments awarded by the trial court, in a tabular form, for easy
reference.
Accused Name of the Sentenced by Trial Court
Number accused
1. Kaka Shankar Patil Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
2. Pradeep Baliram Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC 
3. Umesh Yashwant Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149, 148 r/w 147 of IPC
4. Anil Kaka Patil Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
5. Ranbul @Ranshya Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Chandrakant Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
6. Bhagwat
(Bhagwan)
Yashwant Patil
Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
7. Sanjay Lahu Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Karbhari r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
8. Kisan Kalu Patil Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
9. Bharat Baliram Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
10. Sandip Kaka Patil Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
r/w 149, 201 r/w 149, 148 r/w 147 of IPC
11. Yashwant Baliram Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Vishal Parekar .....5
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
12. Kabir Lahu Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Karbhari r/w 149, 201 r/w 149, 148 r/w 147 of IPC
13. Sharad Baliram Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
14. Madhukar Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Ramchandra Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
15. Baliram Gajanan Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
Patil r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
16. Minesh Nanu Patil Convicted u/s 302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302
r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC
6. Brief facts of the prosecution case are as under:
a. It is the case of the prosecution that Vasant Bendu @ Shankar Patil
(Complainant/ P.W. 1) was residing at Village- Umbarde, Taluka-
Kalyan along with his two sons namely Vilas and Vikas (the deceased),
their wives and children. It is further the case of the prosecution that
in the year 2012, Vikas (the deceased) was the Manager of Royal
Deshi Bar situated at Beturkar Pada, Kalyan. It is further the case that
the deceased used to leave for work in the morning at about 6:45 a.m.
b. It is further the case that Raghunath Bendu Patil (brother of the
Complainant) and all the accused persons hail from the same vicinity.
Raghunath Patil had purchased land from Sitaram Patil and Ganpat
Patil, because of which Kaka Patil (A-1) harboured enmity towards
Vishal Parekar .....6
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
Raghunath Patil, which the Complainant and both his sons were
willing to mediate, but the accused persons were annoyed.
c. It is further the case that on 07.07.2010, the accused had also beaten
up the deceased, for which the deceased was admitted to Rukminibai
Hospital, Kalyan and an FIR was lodged, but the same was settled at
the instance of Kaka Patil (A-1). Even thereafter, the accused
continued to pick quarrels with the Complainant and his sons. It is
further the case that in 2011 on the eve of 'Ganesh Utsav ', i.e. on
01.09.2011, Kaka Patil (A-1) and his associates were involved in a
scuffle with the deceased for which the deceased had complained to
the police. It is further the case that on 20.11.2011, Kaka Patil (A-1)
picked up a quarrel with the deceased and subsequently lodged a
Complaint in connection therewith. In that case, the Complainant,
both of his sons and P.W. 2 (Eknath Dagadu Patil) were arrested. It is
further the case that following the said incident, the accused have
been seeking to falsely implicate the Complainant and his associates.
d. It is further the case that, on 03.10.2012 (date of incident) at about
6:00 a.m., the Complainant had gone to his field for grazing bullocks.
It is further the case that at around 7:45 a.m., Dharmik (grandson of
the Complainant) came to him and informed him that something had
Vishal Parekar .....7
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
happened to the deceased. Therefore, the Complainant rushed towards
the house, where P.W. 2 narrated the incident to him. It is further the
case that P.W. 2 informed the Complainant that all the accused
persons had assaulted the deceased in front of Royal Deshi Bar and
caused his death by inflicting injuries with a sword, knife and chopper,
as well as by subjecting him to fist and kick blows.
e. It is further the case that thereafter the Complainant rushed to the spot
where he found that the deceased was severely injured and was lying
supine in front of Royal Deshi Bar was later shifted to Rukminibai
Hospital, where the doctor declared him dead. Consequently, the
Complainant lodged an FIR with Bajarpeth Police Station on
03.10.2012.
f. It is the case of the prosecution that, upon registration of the FIR,
police set the investigation in motion, made an entry regarding the
incident in the Station Diary and registered Cr. No. I-237/2012 for the
offences punishable under Sections 302, 143, 147, 148, 149 and 120-B
of the IPC and Sections 37(1) read with 135 of the Maharashtra Police
Act. It is further the case of the prosecution that the initial
investigation was carried out by API Ramesh Patil (P.W. 15) and then
handed over to ACP Bharat Nimbalkar (P.W. 17) and thereafter to P.I.
Vishal Parekar .....8
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
Khade. Upon completion of the investigation, the chargesheet came to
be filed before the J.M.F.C., Kalyan and thereafter the case was
committed to the Sessions Court, Kalyan for trial. The charges were
framed against the Accused/Appellants by the Additional Sessions
Judge, Kalyan.
g. To bring home the guilt of the Accused-Appellants, the prosecution
examined 17 witnesses (P.W. 1 to P.W. 17):
P.W NAME ROLE
1 Vasant Bendu alias Complainant/ Father of deceased
Shankar Patil
2 Eknath Dagadu Patil Eye-Witness to the incident
3 Suresh Laxman Dalvi Eye-Witness
4 Mandubai Sudam Bhoir Eye-Witness to conspiracy/ Sister of P.W. 1
5 Kishori Vikas Patil Wife of the the deceased
6 Vinod Balaram Keni Owner of Royal Deshi Bar
7 Raghunath Bendu Patil Brother of P.W. 1
8 Rajan Baliram Mhatre Panch Witness
Seizure of the clothes of the deceased and 6-
inch chopper blade withdrawn from the body
of the deceased on 03.10.2012
9 Devanand Deepak Mali Panch Witness
Recovery of Scorpio and Omni Van at the
instance of Sandeep Kaka Patil (A-10) on
08.10.2012
10 Arun Umakant Panch Witness
Vishal Parekar .....9
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
Chaudhary Disclosure statement made by Kabir
Kharbari (A-12) on 11.10.2012 and the
subsequent spot of the place where the
weapon was thrown by Kabir (A-12)
11 Ravindra Prabhakar Patil Police constable who brought the deceased to
Rukhminibai hospital.
12 Kishor Vasant Ambavane Photographer
13 Nandkishor Gayaprasad Garment Shop Owner
Pal (Hostile Witness)
14 Dr. Shobhana Devidas Medical Officer at Rukminibai Hospital,
Lavankar Kalyan who conducted the Post-Mortem
(P.M.) of the deceased on 03.10.2012.
15 Ramesh Chandrasingh Investigating Officer (I.O.) who conducted
Patil the initial investigation up to 07.10.2012
16 Dr. Minakshi Brijeshwar Medical Officer who examined the injuries
Pande on Kabir Karbhari (A-12)
17 Bharat Papanna Investigating Officer (I.O.) who took over the
Nimbalkar investigation after 07.10.2012
6. After the completion of investigation, the chargesheet came to be filed
against the Accused/Appellants. After conclusion of the trial, the
Accused/Appellants were convicted of the offences by the District & Sessions
Judge- 2 at Kalyan, Mumbai on 07.03.2018, as already stated above.
7. Against the said judgment and order of conviction, the Appellants have
preferred the present appeals. Criminal Appeal No. 424 of 2018 has been
preferred by Kaka Shankar Patil (Accused No. 1). Criminal Appeal No. 423 of
Vishal Parekar .....10
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
2018 has been preferred by Umesh Yashwant Patil (Accused No. 3), Sandip
Kaka Patil (Accused No. 10) and Kabir Lahu Karbhari (Accused No. 12).
Criminal Appeal No. 425 of 2018 has been preferred by Pradeep Baliram
Patil (Accused No. 2), Anil Kaka Patil (Accused No. 4), Ranbul @ Ranshya
Chandrakant Patil (Accused No. 5), Bhagwat Yashwant Patil (Accused No.
6), Sanjay Lahu Karbhari (Accused No. 7), Kisan Kalu Patil (Accused No. 8),
Bharat Baliram Patil (Accused No. 9), Yashwant Baliram Patil (Accused No.
11), Sharad Baliram Patil (Accused No. 13), Madhukar Ramchandra Patil
(Accused No. 14) and Baliram Gajanan Patil (Accused No. 15). Criminal
Appeal No. 316 of 2018 has been preferred by Minesh Nanu Patil (Accused
No. 16).
8. It will be pertinent to mention here that these appeals were heard and
reserved for judgment. During perusal of the record and proceedings before
pronouncement of the judgment, we could not find any records which would
indicate whether the Appellants were still languishing in custody or have
been released on bail during the pendency of the Appeal. This Court
therefore called upon the Ld. Counsels appearing for the Appellants to place
on record the present status of the Accused-Appellants with respect to their
period of incarceration. The Ld. Counsel for the Appellants tendered a chart
of all the Appellants and their status with respect to the period of
Vishal Parekar .....11
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
incarceration. The same is taken on record and marked as ‘X’ for
identification. The Ld. APP was also asked to verify the same, which was
verified to be correct. From the records we also find that the widow of the
deceased (A-1) had filed an Interim Application No. 2908 of 2021 in Cr.A
No. 424 of 2018 seeking permission to prosecute the appeal. This Court vide
order dated 31.11.2021 had already allowed the said application.
9. Heard Ld. Counsel Shri. Kuldeep Patil for the Accused-Appellants No.
1-15 and Ld. Counsel Raju D. Suryawanshi for Accused- Appellant No. 16
and Ld. APP Mr. Amit K. Munde for the Respondent-State.
10. The Ld. Counsel for the Appellants, at the very outset, assertively
submitted that the prosecution has failed to prove the case against the
Appellants beyond reasonable doubt. They further submitted that there are a
lot of inconsistencies, omissions and contradictions in the evidence of the
witnesses, which makes the case of the prosecution doubtful. He further
submitted that the statements of eyewitnesses have been recorded belatedly,
for which there is no explanation offered by the prosecution. He further
submitted that the prosecution has failed to examine any independent
witnesses, although P.W. 2 and P.W. 3 have stated that a crowd had
gathered at the spot of the incident. He further submitted that there is no
recovery of any weapon and there is nothing to connect the Appellants with
Vishal Parekar .....12
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
the commission of the offence. The Ld. Counsel for the Appellants therefore
urged that benefit of doubt be given to the Appellants and that the
Appellants be acquitted.
11. The Ld. Counsel for the Appellants has relied upon a plethora of
judgments which are enlisted hereinbelow :
1
I. Ganesh Bhavan Patel and Anr. v/s State of Maharashtra
II. Harbeer Singh v/s Sheeshpal and Ors. with the State of Rajasthan v/s
2
Sheeshpal and Ors.
3
III. Maruti Rama Naik v/s State of Maharashtra
4
IV. Shahid Khan v/s State of Rajasthan
5
V. Laxman Bapurao Ghaiwane v/s State of Maharashtra
6
VI. Nandkeshwar s/o Shivnarayan Khairwar v/s State of Chhattisgarh
7
VII. Sattatiya alias Satish Rajanna Kartalla v/s State of Maharashtra
8
VIII. Debapriya Pal v/s State of Bengal
9
IX. Thakore Umedsing Nathusing v/s State of Gujarat
10.
X. Mustkeem alias Sirajudeen v/s State of Rajasthan
12. Per Contra , the Ld. APP for the Respondent-State submitted that the
prosecution has proved the case against the Appellants beyond reasonable
1
(1978)4 SCC 371
2
(2016) 16 SCC 418.
3
(2003) 10 SCC 670
4
(2016) 4 SCC 96
5
(2012) SCC Online Bom 2313
6
Cri.A. 1390/2015 Dt. 01/09/25 Chattisgargh HC.
7
(2008) 3 SCC 210
8
(2017) 11 SCC 31
9
(2024) SCC OnLine 320.
10
(2011) 11 SCC 724.
Vishal Parekar .....13
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
doubt. The Ld. APP submitted that the eye-witnesses have categorically
deposed regarding the assault committed by the Appellants upon the
deceased. The Ld. APP further submitted that the discrepancies in the
testimony of the eye-witnesses are minor in nature and that they are bound
to occur in the depositions of natural witnesses and the same do not affect
the credibility of their evidence. He further submitted that the witnesses have
identified the assailants in the Court and therefore there is nothing to
disbelieve the evidence of the prosecution. The Ld. APP therefore, submitted
that the Appellants have brutally committed the murder of the deceased and
the same can be established by the evidence brought on record. Hence, no
case for leniency is made out and thus, all the appeals deserve to be
dismissed.
13. We have gone through the evidence on record. Although, this is not a
case of circumstantial evidence, but we would broadly categorise the
substratum of evidence and deal with the said aspects in seriatim as under:
A. CASE OF HOMICIDAL DEATH :
In order to prove homicidal death, the prosecution has examined P.W.
14 -Dr. Shobana Devidas. She deposed that she had been attached to
Rukminibai Hospital, Kalyan as M.O. since 24.11.2008. She further deposed
that on 03.10.2012, she was on her official duty and had conducted P.M. on
Vishal Parekar .....14
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
the dead body of Vikas Vasant Patil between 2:30 p.m. and 3:45 p.m. She
deposed that there were no signs of decomposition but partial rigor mortis
was found over parts of the dead body. She further deposed that upon
conducting the Post-Mortem examination, she noticed the following injuries
on the dead body of the deceased:
“In para 15 of the Post Mortem following injuries were found
1] Incised wound over penis 1” x ½” x skin deep.
2] Injury over left testis, skin over left testis app. 1” x 1” is absent.
In para No.16 of P.M. report following injuries were found.
Both upper limbs and lower limbs straight.
In para No.17 of P.M. report following injuries were found.
Surface wounds and injuries
1] Incised wound over neck from 1 ½” below left ear to 1
½” below right ear passing upwards posteriorly approx. 8"
x ½" x neck deep upto cervical spine in which two lobes
of thyroid gland, trachea, oesophagas, common
carotidartery. Internal jugular vein and muscles are cut.
2] Three incised wound over neck below the above incised
wound at the level of Isthmus of thyroid gland. No bruises
present.
i] 4" x ½" x skin deep over the middle of neck.
i] Right lateral aspect of neck 1 ½" x ½" x skin deep.
iii] Left lateral aspect of neck 1" x ½" x skin deep.
3] Stab wound over left side of chest between left chavicle
th th
and left nipple at the level between 4 & 5 rib 2" x ½" x
4" deep.
4] Two stab wounds over left side of back.
i] below left scapula region 1" x ½" x 2 ½".
ii] below the above wound app. 1" x ½" x 2".
5] Stab wound over right side of back app. 3" x 1" x 7".
6] Incised wound over right shoulder 3 ½" x 1" x skin
deep.
7] Incised wound over left arm ½" x ½" x skin deep.
8] Incised wound over pubic region above penis app. 1 ½"
x ½" x skin deep.
Vishal Parekar .....15
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
9] Abrasion over right side of temporal side app. ½" x ¼"
one above left knee joint app. ½" x ½".
10] Incised wound over left thumb ½ cm x ½ cm x skin
deep and right ring finger 1 cm x ¼ cm x skin deep.
In para No.18 of P.M. report following injuries were found.
Right side posteriorly 7 and 8 ribs cut. These injuries are ᵗʰ ᵗʰ
ante-mortem injuries. In para No.19 of P.M. report
following injuries were found. Head-opened. No injuries
under the scalp. Skull- No fracture skull. Brain – Congested.
In para No.20 of P.M. report following injuries were found.
1] Right side posteriorly 7 ᵗʰ & 8 ᵗʰ rib cut along with
intercostal space.
2] Pleura – Ruptured.
3] Larynx Trachea and Brouchi- Filled with blood.
4] Right Ling- Stab wounds over right lung middle and
lower lobe. One piece of sharp and pointed weapon found
in right lung appro. 6” x 2 ¼”.
5] Left lung – stab wound over upper lobe.
6] Paricardium – Ruptured.
7] Heart with weight – Stab wound between right ventricle
and left ventricle anterior aspect app. 1” x ¼” x Heart
muscle deep and over left atrium posteriorly app. ½” x ¼”
x Heart muscle deep.
8] Large vessels – Filled with blood…….”
14. She deposed that after the Post-Mortem Report, she opined about
cause of death as “ haemorrhagic shock due to cut throat injury associated
with injuries to vital organs” . She further deposed that the above injuries
were fresh injuries. She further deposed that Injury Nos.1 and 2 mentioned
in para no.17 of the P.M. report are fatal for life and instant death can
occur. She also stated that Injuries Nos. 7 and 10 mentioned in para no. 17
of the P.M. report are possible if the man is avoiding assault. All the injuries
Vishal Parekar .....16
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
mentioned in para no. 17 are possible by a sharp edged weapon. It was
further stated by her that the abrasions are possible by a blunt part of that
weapon or by falling on the ground. She further deposed that a piece of
sharp edged weapon was shown to her which she identified to be the same
as the one which was found in the lung of that dead body. She further
deposed that according to her, the death of that person might have taken
place 6-7 hours prior to the receiving of the dead body by their hospital.
15. From the above we are of the opinion that the death of the deceased
was homicidal in nature.
16. Once the death is homicidal death, the burden lies on the prosecution
to prove that the death was on account of the act committed by the accused
with the intention and knowledge that this act would cause the death of the
deceased which would amount to an offence of murder.
B. TWO EYE WITNESSES AS CLAIMED BY THE PROSECUTION
17. P.W. 2- Eknath Dagadu Patil and P.W. 3- Suresh Laxman Dalvi have
been examined by the prosecution as their star witnesses, who claim to have
witnessed the incident in question. Since these two witnesses are the prime
witnesses for the prosecution and the case of the prosecution primarily
Vishal Parekar .....17
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
hinges on their testimony, it would be necessary to analyse and marshal their
evidence in detail.
18. At this stage it will be apposite to refer to the judgment of the Hon’ble
11
Apex Court in the landmark ruling of Vadivelu Thevar v/s State of Madras ,
wherein it was observed that:
“ Hence, in our opinion, it is a sound and well-established rule of
law that the court is concerned with the quality and not with the
quantity of the evidence necessary for, proving or disproving a
fact. Generally speaking, oral testimony in this context may be
classified into three categories, namely:
(1) Wholly reliable.
(2) Wholly unreliable.
(3) Neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable. In the first
category of proof, the court should have no difficulty in coming
to its conclusion either way-it may convict or may acquit on the
testimony of a single witness, if it is found to be above reproach
or suspicion of interestedness, incompetence or subornation. In
the second category, the court, equally has no difficulty in
coming to its conclusion. It is in the third category of cases, that
the court has to be circumspect and has to look for
corroboration in material particulars by reliable testimony,
direct or circumstantial. ”
19. On this backdrop, we shall analyse the testimony of these witnesses.
P.W. 2 (Eknath Dagadu Patil), a rickshaw driver, deposed that he
knows the Complainant- Vasant Patil (P.W. 1) and all the accused persons.
He stated there were disputes between P.W. 7, the brother of P.W. 1 and
Kaka Patil (A-1) over landed property for the last 7 to 8 years. He further
deposed that on 03.10.2012, at around 6:30 a.m., while proceeding by his
11
1957 SC AIR 614.
Vishal Parekar .....18
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
auto rickshaw from Khadakpada to the railway station via Betturkar Pada
Road, he reached in front of Royal Deshi Bar and saw a Scorpio and an Omni
van along with Kaka Shankar Patil (A-1). He further deposed about seeing
around 15 persons alighting from these vehicles who were from the vicinity,
including Kaka Patil (A-1), Sandeep Kaka Patil (A-10), Anil Kaka Patil (A- 4),
Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12), Sanjay Lahu Kharbari (A-7), Umesh Yashwant
Patil (A-3), Bhagwant Yashwant Patil (A-6), Yashwant Baliram Patil (A-11),
Baliram Gajanan Patil (A-15), Pradeep Baliram Patil (A-2), Sharad Baliram
Patil (A-13), Bharat Baliram Patil (A-9), Madhukar Ramchandra Patil (A-14),
and Ranbul Chandrakant Patil (A-5). He deposed that they were carrying
gupti , sword and chopper in their hands. He further deposed that after
parking his rickshaw, he stood there to observe what was happening, when
he heard someone say “ kill him like a goat ”. He further deposed that the said
15 persons went to the door of Royal Deshi Bar where the deceased was
opening the door and began beating him with fists and kicks. He further
deposed that Sandeep Patil (A-15) inflicted a sword blow on the back of the
deceased, Umesh Patil (A-3) inflicted a gupti blow on his private part and
Kabir Lahu Kharbari (A-12) cut his throat with a chopper. He further
deposed that he was frightened and went to Umbardegaon village and
narrated the incident to P.W. 1 and then returned to Betturkarpada where
Vishal Parekar .....19
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
the deceased was lying in front of Royal Deshi bar on the gutter with
bleeding injuries on his chest, back, neck and private part, having suffered
nine weapon blows. He stated that when he returned, police from Bajarpeth
police had arrived and the deceased was taken to Rukminibai Hospital where
he was declared dead. He further deposed that police recorded his statement
and he identified the chopper blade which was in the hands of Kabir Lahu
Kharbari (A-12).
20. During his cross-examination, several admissions and omissions were
brought on record through this witness. It was brought on record in the
cross-examination that this witness and the deceased were in jail together in
a case for around 60 days. This witness further admitted that near the spot
there is a police chowky. He also admitted that Bajarpeth police station is
nearer from the spot than Umbardegaon village. He further admitted that he
did not go to the police station immediately. He further admitted that at that
time he had a talk with the police that he had seen the incident. He further
deposed that in the evening he had gone to the police station and was
present there for 15 minutes. He also admitted that even after the funeral of
the deceased, he went to the police station again. Further, it has come by
way of omission that he had stated to the police that at that time, Sandeep
(A-10) had inflicted blow of sword on the back of Vikas (the deceased) and
Vishal Parekar .....20
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
Umesh (A-3) had inflicted blow of gupti on the private part of Vikas. He
further stated that police recorded his statement only once but cannot assign
any reason why the police have mentioned the date as 16.10.2012 on his
police statement.
21. A perusal of the testimony of this witness would evince that, although
a police chowki and Bajarpeth police station were closer to the spot, he did
not to go to the police immediately, rather chose to go to Umbardegaon
village at 7:15 a.m. to inform P.W. 1 and thereafter returned to the spot at
8:15 a.m. when the police had already arrived. When this witness was
present on the spot and had informed the police that he had seen the
incident, it is baffling that the police did not record his statement
immediately but recorded his statement only after a period of 13 days.
Although, within a few hours of the incident, he informed the police about
having witnessed the incident, despite which he was not the first informant.
The implication of Sandeep Patil (A-10) and Umesh Patil (A-3) has also come
by way of omission.
22. Further, we also find that P.W. 2 (Eknath Dagadu Patil), has not
identified the remaining accused persons in his substantial deposition.
Although, this witness deposes that he can identify the other accused persons
if they are shown to him, we do not find any evidence which would show
Vishal Parekar .....21
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
that this prosecution witness has identified the rest of the accused persons in
Court. Nonetheless, he has attributed a specific role to Kabir Karbhari (A-12).
23. We are therefore of the opinion that the testimony of this witness falls
into the category of neither ‘wholly reliable’ nor ‘wholly unreliable’. We are
inclined to observe thus, as we find that although the statements have been
belatedly recorded, his testimony with respect to the assault by Kabir
Karbhari (A-12) is categorical and inspires confidence. He has even
identified the chopper blade which was in the hands of Kabir Lahu Kharbari
(A-12) in his substantial deposition. Further we also find that there is a
certain degree of corroboration to the testimony of this witness with respect
to the assault by Kabir (A-12), which we shall discuss in the later part of the
judgement.
24. P.W. 3- Suresh Laxman Dalvi deposed that he resides at Betturkarpada
and sells ice cream on a handcart and knows the deceased. He deposed that
on 03.10.2012, at around 7:20 a.m., while going to purchase salt in front of
Royal Deshi Bar, he saw 10 to 15 persons gathered and out of them he knew
Kabir Lahu Kharbari (A-12) and Sandeep Kaka Patil (A-10), as they were
residents of Umbardegaon. He further deposed that those persons went by
white color Omni vans, towards the southern side. He further deposed that at
that time Kabir (A-12) was having chopper and Sandeep (A-10) was having
Vishal Parekar .....22
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
sword. He further deposed that the clothes of Kabir and Sandeep were
stained with blood. He further deposed that he saw the deceased lying in
front of Royal Deshi Bar with 11-12 blows and bleeding injuries on his neck,
throat, back and private parts with no movement. He further deposed that he
took an auto-rickshaw and went to Umbardegaon to the house of Vasant
Patil (P.W. 1). He further deposed that as P.W. 1 was not at home, he
informed about the incident to the wife of the deceased and to the brother of
the deceased. He further deposed that within one minute P.W. 1 arrived and
he was informed about the incident. He also deposed that P.W. 2 was also
present there. He further deposed that they all went back to the spot where
the police were already present. He further deposed that he was aware that
there were some disputes between Kaka Patil (A-1) and P.W. 1. He further
deposed that he can identify Kabir (A-12) and Sandeep (A-10) alongwith
other persons who were present on the spot. Further, he identified Kaka Patil
(A-1), Sharad Baliram Patil (A-13), Sanjay Kharbari (A-7), Yashwant Baliram
Patil (A-11), Madhukar Ramchandra Patil (A-14), Pradeep Patil (A-2), Anil
Kaka Patil (A-4), Sandeep Kaka Patil (A-10), Bhagwan Patil (A-6), Kabir
Lahu Karbhari (A-12), Ranbul Chandrakant Patil (A-5), Kisan Kalu Patil to be
the same. He wrongly identified Sharad Patil (A-13) as Bharat Patil (A-9)
and also wrongly identified Umesh Patil (A-3) as Pradeep Patil (A-2) during
Vishal Parekar .....23
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
his examination-in-chief. He further deposed that all the accused persons
shown on Video Conference to him were present at the spot at the time of
incident.
25. In his cross-examination, this witness stated that the accused persons
which were identified by him on Video Conference were well known to him
by their names since long however, the same has come by way of omission.
He further admitted that he was not called for the test identification parade.
He further admitted that there was a crowd at the spot of the incident. He
further admitted that he had not informed Dakshata police chowky and that
he had not gone to Bajarpeth police station as well. He further admitted that
after coming back to the spot he found that police were present there and
were making inquiries on the spot, however he had no talk with the police.
He further stated that on 04.10.2012 he had stated about the incident to the
police, for the first time and on that day the police had recorded his
statement. He further stated that police have recorded his statement only
once. He however denies that the police recorded his statement on
20.10.2012. He admits that police had read over the statement to him but
cannot tell why the date- 20.10.2012 is mentioned on his police statement.
He further admits that he had not stated to the police that a wrong date is
mentioned on his police statement and that Sr. PI Nimbalkar (P.W. 17) had
Vishal Parekar .....24
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
recorded his statement at the police station. Further in the cross-
examination, it has come by way of omission that he had stated before the
police that at that time 10-15 persons were gathered on the spot. It has also
come by way of omission that he had seen 11 to 12 blows on the person of
Vikas. He further admitted that at the time of the statement he had stated
before the police that out of those persons gathered, he was acquainted with
two persons. Further, he stated that he had mentioned before the police that
he had seen injuries on the back and private part of Vikas Patil but those
injuries were not mentioned in the statement and he cannot assign any
reason for the same. He further stated that he had stated before the police
that at that time Sandeep Patil (A-10) had a sword in his hand but cannot
assign any reason as to why it was not mentioned in his statement.
26. If we analyse the evidence of P.W. 3, we find that his testimony is
laced with omissions on material aspects. The fact that he saw 10 to 15
persons gathered there has come by way of omission. Initially, in his
examination-in-chief, he deposed that out of those persons, he knew only
two persons by name, namely, Kabir Karbhari and Sandeep Kaka Patil.
Further in the chief, he improvises his version and deposes that he can
identify Kabir Karbhari and Sandeep Kaka Patil alongwith the other persons
on the spot by their name. In the cross-examination, he further improvises
Vishal Parekar .....25
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
his version and states that the accused persons which he identified on Video
Conference by him were well known by their names to him since long and
thereafter it has come by way of omission that he had stated before the
police that he knows all the persons who were present on the spot, but it is
not mentioned in his statement. Even as far as mentioning of the weapon
allegedly held by the accused- Sandeep Kaka Patil has come by way of
omission. Further, with respect to the date of recording of the statement also
there is a discrepancy. He does not dispute that police had read out the
statement to him and that he had not stated to the police that the wrong date
is mentioned in the police statement. In this context if the deposition of P.W.
17- I.O. is seen, he categorically deposed that the statement of P.W. 3 was
recorded on 20.10.2012 as per his say. The rest of the omissions are also
proved by the I.O. Taking into consideration the testimony of this witness, it
will be unsafe to rely upon the same in totality. However, as we have
discussed earlier while dealing with P.W. 2, even in the case of P.W. 3,
though the statement has been belatedly recorded and there are material
omissions and improvisations, however he is consistent on the point of Kabir
(A-12) holding chopper in his hands and there is no cross examination on
this aspect to discredit his testimony.
Vishal Parekar .....26
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
27. Taking into consideration the evidence of P.W. 2 and P.W. 3, this
Court finds that over implication of the accused persons cannot be ruled out.
According to their respective depositions, both were present after the police
had arrived at the spot and were available to the police, however their
statements were recorded after a period of 13 days and 17 days respectively
as admitted by P.W. 17. The prosecution has not challenged this aspect of
evidence or even sought any clarification.
28. In this context, it would be apposite to refer to the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ganesh Bhavan Patel (supra) on which
the Ld. Counsel for the Appellant No. 1 to 15 has also placed reliance:
“15. As noted by the trial court, one unusual feature which
projects its shadow on the evidence of PWs Welji, Pramila and
Kuvarbai and casts a serious doubt about their being
eyewitnesses of the occurrence, is the undue delay on the part
of the investigating officer in recording their statements.
Although these witnesses were or could be available for
examination when the investigating officer visited the scene of
occurrence or soon thereafter, their statements under Section
161 of the CrPC were recorded on the following day. Welji
(PW 3) was examined at 8 a.m., Pramila at 9.15 or 9.30 a.m.,
and Kuvarbai at 1 p.m. Delay of a few hours, simpliciter, in
recording the statements of eyewitnesses may not, be itself,
amount to a serious infirmity in the prosecution case. But it
may assume such a character if there are concomitant
circumstances to investigator was deliberately marking time
with a view to suggest that the decide about the shape to be
given to the case and the eyewitnesses to be introduced. A
catena of circumstances which lend such significance to this
delay, exists in the instant case.
Vishal Parekar .....27
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
29. The Ld. Counsel for the Appellants has also relied upon the judgment
of Maruti Rama Naik (supra) and has invited the attention of this Court to
para no. 7 , which is reproduced as under:
“7. We will now consider whether the evidence of PW-4 in any
manner corroborates the evidence of PW-3 or for that matter the
said evidence of PW-4 is acceptable at all. PW-4 has admitted
that he is a close relative of deceased Krishna Mahada Naik.
While he had noticed the incident of the attack on the deceased
Krishna Mahada Naik, he has not spoken in any manner about
the subsequent attack which includes the attack on PW-3.
According to this witness, at the relevant time, he was going to
the bus-stand to board a bus to reach his factory where he was
working when he saw the assault on the deceased Krishna
Mahada Naik by the assailants including the appellants. Having
noticed the incident, he did not go to any one of his relatives’
house to inform about the attack in question. He knew at that
point of time that Krishna Mahada Naik was injured and still
alive, still he did not make any effort whatsoever to get any help
to shift the injured to a hospital. According to this witness, even
after seeing Krishna Mahada Naik lying injured in a critical
condition, he without informing anybody about the incident,
went to the bus-stand, took a bus and went to his factory and
even at that point of time, he had sufficient opportunity to inform
the other people about the incident or for that matter, even the
Police which he did not do. It is interesting to note from the
evidence of this witness that even though he had an opportunity
of approaching the police, he did go to them because he did not
know whom he had to inform about the incident in the Police
Station. The witness further states that he went to the factory,
worked for a while, took leave from the factory and went back
home. Even after reaching home, he did not bother to find out
from anybody there about the fate of the victims nor did he
inform anybody about he having witnessed the incident. It is only
at about 6 p.m. when PW-21 recorded the statement for the first
time, he came out with the fact of having witnessed the incident.
It is rather surprising as to how and in what manner, PW-21
came to know that PW-4 was a witness to the incident. The
prosecution has also failed to explain the delay in recording the
statement of this witness, therefore, bearing in mind the conduct
of PW-4 in not informing anybody about his having witnessed the
Vishal Parekar .....28
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
incident and the delay in recording his statement makes us
hesitant to place any reliance on his evidence. The only other
piece of evidence relied by the prosecution to support its case
against these two appellants is that of recovery which even
according to prosecution, was made from a place which was not
in the exclusive possession of the appellants and the said place
was easily accessible by other people and also the fact that
recovery was made almost 9 days after the incident in question,
in our opinion, this piece of evidence also would not at all be
sufficient to base a conviction of these appellants without further
acceptable corroboration. Therefore, we are of the opinion that
these appeals must succeed. The conviction and sentence
imposed on the appellants are set aside and the appeals are
allowed.”
30. We may also refer to the judgment of this Court, as submitted by the
Ld. Counsel for the Appellants, in the case of Laxman Bapurao Ghaiwane
(supra) wherein it has been held that delay in recording statement not be
always fatal to prosecution but where recording of statements was delayed
despite there being ample opportunity available to the Investigating Officer
to record statements, then the delay is required to be explained to the
satisfaction of the court. The relevant paragraphs are referred hereinbelow:
“17. Let it be stated here that the delay in recording statements
of witnesses in all cases is not necessarily fatal to the
prosecution. It is well settled that the delay in recording
statements of the witnesses by itself should not be seen as
circumstance adverse to the prosecution. Whether the delay in
recording of statements creates a doubt regarding genuineness
of the evidence of the witnesses will depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case. There might be a case where the
circumstances might have prevented the Investigating Officer to
record statements of witnesses within a reasonable time. In such
a case, the delay by itself should not be fatal to the prosecution
case. However, at the same time, there could be a case where
Vishal Parekar .....29
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
recording of statements was delayed despite there being an
ample opportunity available to the Investigating Officer to
record statements. In such a case, the delay is required to be
explained to the satisfaction of the Court.
18. The effect of delay in recording statements of witnesses
under Section 161 of the Cr PC was examined by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of State of H.P. v. Gian Chand,
reported at (2001) 6 SCC 71: AIR 2001 SC 2075 and it was
observed:
"If the prosecution fails to satisfactorily explain the delay and
there is a possibility of embellishment in the prosecution version
on account of such delay, the delay would be fatal to the
prosecution. However, if the delay is explained to the
satisfaction of the Court, the delay cannot by itself be a ground
for disbelieving and discarding the entire prosecution case."
The effect of delay was also considered by the Supreme Court in
the matter of Dilawar Singh v. State of Delhi, reported at (2007)
12 SCC 641: AIR 2007 SC 3234 and it was observed:
"In criminal trial one of the cardinal principles for the Court is to
look for plausible explanation for the delay in lodging the
report. Delay sometimes affords opportunity to the complainant
to make deliberation upon the complaint and to make
embellishment or even make fabrications. Delay defeats the
chance of the unsoiled and untarnished version of the case to be
presented before the Court at the earliest instance. That is why
if there is delay in either coming before the police or before the
Court, the Courts always view the allegations with suspicion and
look for satisfactory explanation. If no such satisfaction is
formed, the delay is treated as fatal to the prosecution case."
In the present case, it is admitted position that recording of
statements of almost all the witnesses was delayed. The incident
had occurred on 9th June, 2006. The matter was reported to
police by wife of the deceased within a very short time. She was,
however, not witness to the incident. Important witnesses in this
case are P.W. 4 Ashish, P.W. 7 Sachin, P.W. 8 Anup and P.W. 10
Ashwin. The dates of recording their statements have already
been stated herein above. The first ever statement was recorded
Vishal Parekar .....30
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
on 11th June, 2006. The statements of P.Ws. 8 and 9 were
recorded on 11th June, 2006.
19. Let us, therefore, look into the cross-examination of these
two witnesses to find out whether they were available to the
police on 9th and 10th June, 2006 for recording their
statements. It is very clear from the evidence of P.W. 8 Anup
that the Police Officers had been visiting the village daily from
the date of incident and this witness was available to the police.
His statement was recorded on 11th June, 2006 at about 11.00
a.m. His brother Ravindra Sahare was present when his
statement was recorded. Similarly, P.W. 9 in his cross-
examination claims that the police met him in the hospital and
that he disclosed to the police that he had seen the incident. His
statement was not recorded by the police. The Investigating
Officer was cross-examined on this issue. It was suggested to
him that he had avoided to record statements of the eye-witness
when they had approached him and had insisted to give the
statements. He has denied the suggestion. It is admitted by him
that he had not recorded the statements of the witnesses on the
night of 9th and 10th June, 2006 and thereafter also he did not
try to call any eye-witnesses for recording statements.”
31. If we take into consideration the ratio laid down in the aforesaid
judgments, we find that, in the facts of the present case, there is a
considerable delay in recording the statements of the two alleged
eyewitnesses. These witnesses were, in fact, available on the very day of the
incident. However, the police authorities did not record their statements
immediately and instead recorded the same after a lapse of more than 12
days. The I.O. has also failed to offer any explanation for such delay in
recording their statements.
Vishal Parekar .....31
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
32. As stated above, we find the testimony of P.W. 2 and P.W. 3 to be
falling in the third category where their evidence is neither wholly reliable
nor wholly unreliable and therefore it will be necessary to further look for
corroboration.
33. Before proceeding ahead, what is further intriguing is that these two
witnesses claim to have informed the father of the victim P.W. 1 at his
residence at about 7:45 am, before reaching the spot at 8:25 am. However as
per P.W. 1, after reaching the hospital, when police inquired about his
suspicion, he told the names of the suspects and that suspicion was on
account of previous disputes with the accused. P.W. 1 could have very well
informed the police what was informed to him by P.W. 2 and P.W. 3 with the
names of the Appellants but P.W. 1 does not even whisper about P.W. 2 and
P.W. 3 and his conversation with them at the hospital. Further, it has come
in the evidence of P.W. 1 that there was discussion about the incident with
all his family members and relatives. Taking into consideration all these
aspects we feel that we should also analyse other aspects and see if we can
find any corroboration.
34. We find that this is a case of exaggeration and over implication. It
cannot be denied that it is a homicidal death, but whether all the Appellants
were present at the time of assault and whether all of them have assaulted
Vishal Parekar .....32
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
the deceased is something for which there is no clear evidence. As stated
above, we do find that there is sufficient evidence against Kabir (A-12),
which we shall discuss later on.
C. MOTIVE
35. Regarding the motive, the prosecution has examined three witnesses
namely P.W. 1, P.W. 5 and P.W. 7.
36. P.W. 1, the father of the deceased, deposed that he knows all the
accused since their childhood and for the last 7 to 8 years, his brother
Raghunath Patil (P.W. 7) and Kaka Patil (A-1), were having a dispute on
account of land. He further deposed that as Raghunath Patil (P.W. 7) was his
real brother, he and his sons were intending to resolve the dispute, which
was not liked by Kaka Patil (A-1) and therefore he was annoyed with him as
well as with his sons. Thereafter he has deposed about the incidents of
assault, which occurred in the years 2010 and 2011 for which there were
police complaints. He further deposed that at that time Kaka Patil (A-1) had
amicably mediated the matter. He further deposed that by keeping the
grudge of that dispute, Kaka Patil (A-1) had continued his quarrels with his
son. He further deposed that all the accused persons had kept a watch on
each and every activity of them and the accused persons were threatening
Vishal Parekar .....33
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
them that they would be a scapegoat. He further deposed that on
03.10.2012, Eknath Patil (P.W. 2 ) had come to his residence and narrated
the incident and had also given the names of the accused, stating that the
accused persons had arrived by Scorpio and Omni van. He further deposed
that P.W. 2 informed him that at that time, the deceased was opening the
shutter of the bar, after which the accused persons started beating him with
kicks and fist blows. He further deposed that P.W. 2 had told him that
Sandeep Patil (A-10) was having a sword, Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12) was
having a chopper, and Umesh Yashwant Patil (A-3) was having a gupti and
these accused started to beat the deceased with the help of these weapons.
He further deposed that P.W. 2 had told that he had seen the incident and
ran away from there. He also deposed that P.W. 3 arrived there and
informed P.W. 1 and his wife about the incident.
37. In the cross-examination, it has come by way of omission that there
was a dispute between Kaka Patil (A-1) and Raghunath on account of land
and he and his son had tried to mediate the matter, because of which Kaka
Patil (A-1) was annoyed. Further, even the incidents of 2010 and 2011 with
respect to the assault on his son have also come by way of omission.
However, further he deposed that it is true that Kabir Karbhari (A-12) had
lodged a complaint against him, his deceased son, P.W. 2 and others for
Vishal Parekar .....34
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
offences under Sections 326, 143, 147, 148, and 149 of the IPC, for which
they were arrested and were in jail for two months. He further deposed that
at the hospital, the police enquired about his suspicion and accordingly he
had told the names of the suspects. He categorically stated that at that time
he raised suspicion because of the previous disputes with the accused. He
also stated that there were discussions about the incident with all family
members and relatives.
38. P.W. 5- Kishori Vikas Patil (the wife of the deceased) deposed that she
knew Kaka Patil and there were strained relations between their family and
the family of Kaka Patil (A-1). She further deposed that 7 to 8 years prior,
there were civil disputes between Raghunath Patil and Kaka Patil (A-1). She
further deposed that in that dispute, her husband (deceased) and father-in-
law (P.W. 1) used to favor Raghunath Patil and therefore Kaka Patil (A-1)
was annoyed. She further deposed that their road passes through the house
of Kaka Patil (A-1) and whenever her husband used to proceed on the bike
from the house of Kaka Patil (A-1), he and his associates used to stop the
bike of her husband and often abuse and threaten him. She further deposed
that they used to say that he would be killed like a goat and this fact was told
to her by her husband. She further deposed that on 02.10.2012, at about
5:00 p.m. to 5:15 p.m., when she herself and her husband were on the bike
Vishal Parekar .....35
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
and reached near Shankar Mandir, at that time, Kabir, Umesh, Sandeep,
Madhukar, one Prakash and Bhagwan were present there and they told them
that tomorrow they had fixed the killing of a goat. She further deposed that
she and her husband discussed this issue at that time and her husband told
her that these persons would follow him and she had cautioned her husband
by taking note of the previous incidents. She further deposed about the
previous incidents of the years 2010 and 2011. With respect to the previous
incident, she deposed that she had lodged a complaint with the police
authorities that the life of the deceased was endangered. She further deposed
that on 03.10.2012, P.W. 3 arrived there and told that her husband was
killed by Kaka Patil (A-1) and others by using a sword. In the cross-
examination, she admitted that after November 2011, there were no police
complaints from either side. She also admitted that in respect of the incident
dated 02.10.2012, they had not filed any police complaint.
39. P.W. 7- Raghunath Bendu Patil (the brother of P.W. 1) deposed that
P.W. 1 is his real brother. He further deposed that he knows all the accused
persons as they hail from the same vicinity. He further deposed that there
were quarrels between him and Kaka Patil (A-1), for which a complaint was
filed at the police station. In the cross-examination, he further admitted that
Kaka Patil (A-1) had lodged a police complaint, which was not liked by him.
Vishal Parekar .....36
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
It has come by way of omission that he had stated before the police that at
that time Kaka Patil (A-1), his brother and sons had beaten them, for which
they had lodged a police complaint against accused Kaka Patil (A-1), his son
Sandeep and his brother's son.
40. From the evidence of these three witnesses, we are of the opinion that
no doubt there existed a dispute of a civil nature between Kaka Patil (A-1)
and the family of the deceased. However, motive is a double-edged weapon.
As the prosecution seeks to rely upon the previous disputes as a motive for
the alleged offence, the same circumstances demonstrate the possibility of
animosity and false implication. P.W. 5 tried to bring on record an incident
of the previous day where they were threatened as a proximate motive;
however, she admitted that no complaint with respect to the said threat was
lodged with the police. Nonetheless, we find that there is some semblance of
animosity amongst the deceased and accused persons which has culminated
into the occurrence of this incident.
41. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Mahaendra Singh v/s State
12
of Madhya Pradesh has held that only because motive is established, the
conviction cannot be sustained. Thus, even if it is held that motive is proved,
that at the most signifies the prior dispute between the parties, but the same
cannot be said to be such that it automatically involves the persons who are
12
(2022) 7 SCC 157.
Vishal Parekar .....37
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
on inimical terms unless there is some cogent and corroborating material to
show the involvement.
D. RECOVERY OF VEHICLES
42. The prosecution in order to establish recovery of the Scorpio and Omni
vehicle has examined P.W. 9- Devanand Deepak Mali, who has acted as the
panch witness to this recovery. P.W. 9 deposed that on 08.10.2012, he was
called by the police at Crime Branch, Kamala and asked him to act as a
panch. He deposed that Sandeep (A-10) made a disclosure statement before
him that he is ready to tender (show) the vehicle which was used in the
offence and accordingly the police prepared a panchanama to that effect and
obtained his signature on it. He further deposed that they, along with the
accused, went in a police jeep to Bhatsayet Farmhouse. He further deposed
that after reaching there, the accused opened the gate of that farmhouse and
when they entered, they saw one Scorpio vehicle there, which was white in
colour. He further deposed that the police seized that Scorpio vehicle and
showed it to them, where they saw some bloodstains below the backseat of
the Scorpio. He further deposed that the police obtained bloodstains from
that Scorpio and the vehicle was seized in the presence of this witness. He
further deposed that the accused took them through Kongaon to Adarvadi,
where Sandeep (A-10) showed one Omni van, which was parked in front of
Vishal Parekar .....38
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
the gate. He further deposed that nothing was found in that Omni van.
However, the police seized it and obtained his signature on the panchanama.
The panch-witness was cross-examined by the defence counsel.
43. If we analyse the evidence of this witness, it can be seen that the
recovery of the Scorpio is from a farmhouse. It is also not clear whether the
Scorpio car was locked or it was in an open condition lying at this spot. It has
not come in the evidence that keys were used to open the said Scorpio
vehicle and even the prosecution has failed to explain how the vehicle was
opened in the absence of any key. There is no evidence to establish the actual
ownership of this Scorpio. The bloodstain found beneath the rear seat of the
Scorpio also does not connect the present Appellants or in particular,
Sandeep (A-10) in any manner. Even though the prosecution found
bloodstains beneath the rear seat of the Scorpio, there is no forensic evidence
to establish that the blood found on this article matches with the blood group
either with that of the deceased or of Sandeep (A-10). The mere presence of
bloodstains without proof that it is human blood belonging to the deceased
or even to the accused renders the recovery inconsequential.
44. The Ld. Counsel for the Appellant has relied upon the judgement of
Sattatiya alias Satish (supra) to buttress this argument. The relevant
paragraph is produced hereinbelow:
Vishal Parekar .....39
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
“26. The next thing which is to be seen is whether the
evidence relating to the recovery of clothes of the appellant
and the half blade, allegedly used for commission of crime, is
credible and could be relied on for proving the charge of
culpable homicide against the appellant. In this context, it is
important to note that the prosecution did not produce any
document containing the recording of statement allegedly
made by the appellant expressing his desire to facilitate
recovery of the clothes and half blade. The prosecution case
that the accused volunteered to give information and took the
police for recovery of the clothes, half blade and purchase of
handkerchief is highly suspect. It has not been explained as to
why the appellant gave information in piecemeal on three
dates i.e. 3.10.1994, 5.10.1994 and 6.10.1994. Room No.45
of “Ganesh Bhuvan” from which the clothes are said to have
been recovered was found to be unlocked premises which
could be accessed by any one. The prosecution could not
explain as to how the room allegedly belonging to the
appellant could be without any lock. The absence of any
habitation in the room also cast serious doubt on the
genuineness and bonafides of recovery of clothes. The
recovery of half blade from the road side beneath the wooden
board in front of “Ganesh Bhuvan” is also not convincing.
Undisputedly, the place from which half blade is said to have
been recovered is an open place and everybody had access to
the site from where the blade is said to have been recovered.
It is, therefore, difficult to believe the prosecution theory
regarding recovery of the half blade. The credibility of the
evidence relating to recovery is substantially dented by the
fact that even though as per the Chemical Examiner’s Report
the blood stains found on the shirt, pant and half blade were
those of human blood, the same could not be linked with the
blood of the deceased. Unfortunately, the learned Additional
Sessions Judge and High Court overlooked this serious lacuna
in the prosecution story and concluded that the presence of
human blood stains on the clothes of the accused and half
blade were sufficient to link him with the murder.”
45. Needless to mention that unless the bloodstain found beneath the rear
seat is proved to be that of the deceased, the discovery cannot be said to
Vishal Parekar .....40
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
incriminate Sandeep (A-10) or any of the other Appellants beyond
reasonable doubt. Therefore, we are inclined to hold that the recovery of the
vehicle and the bloodstains found on the rear seat of the Scorpio have not
been proved beyond reasonable doubt.
E. RECOVERY OF CLOTHES OF THE ACCUSED
46. In order to establish the recovery of clothes of the accused, the
prosecution has examined P.W. 10- Arun Umakant Chaudhari. He deposed
that on 14.10.2012, he was called by the police along with a co-panch by
name Mhatre. He deposed that at that time, Bhagwan Patil, made a
disclosure statement and he showed his readiness to show the clothes which
were used at the time of the offence. He further deposed that after drawing
the disclosure panchnama in his presence, the accused Bhagwan, along with
the panchas, went by police vehicle to village Bhatsayee as per the say of the
accused. He further deposed that the accused took them to one farmhouse,
where he tendered some clothes, i.e. five shirts and five pants. He further
deposed that out of those clothes, three shirts and three pants were blood-
stained and those stains were dried. He further deposed that the police
seized all these clothes and obtained his signature and the signature of the
accused on it.
Vishal Parekar .....41
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
47. If we analyse the deposition of this witness, in the first place, we find
that there is nothing to indicate that after the police seized these clothes on
which there were bloodstains, there was any sealing done on the spot. It is
pertinent to note that the recovery of the blood-stained clothes on
14.10.2012 is from the same place from where the Scorpio vehicle was
recovered on 08.10.2012. Further, none of the eyewitnesses identify these
clothes as the clothes which were worn by any particular accused at the time
of the incident and that the prosecution has not even established which shirt
or trouser were worn by which of the accused persons. Therefore, even
though human blood has been found on some of the articles, the prosecution
has not established the nexus between those articles with the deceased or
any accused persons. In the absence of such corroboration, we find it difficult
to come to a conclusion that the recovery of blood-stained clothes has been
proved beyond reasonable doubt.
48. It will be pertinent to refer to the judgment of Nandkeshwar (supra) as
relied upon by the Ld. Counsel for the Appellants. The relevant portion is
extracted hereunder:
“21. Upon perusal of the record and in light of the decisions of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, it is evident that although the prosecution
has produced a soil, stick and clothes of the deceased seized from the
spot, there is a complete absence of forensic evidence establishing
that the blood found on these articles matches the blood group of the
deceased. The mere presence of bloodstains, without proof that it is
Vishal Parekar .....42
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
human blood belonging to the deceased, renders the recovery
inconsequential.
“22. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held that such
failure materially affects the evidentiary value of the alleged
recoveries. In Kansa Behera v. State of Orissa, (1987) 3 SCC 480, the
Court held:
“Unless the blood stains found on the clothes or weapons are proved
to be that of the deceased, the discovery cannot be said to incriminate
the accused beyond doubt.”
“23. Similarly, in Sattatiya @ Satish Rajanna Kartalla v. State of
Maharashtra, (2008) 3 SCC 210, it was observed:
“In the absence of a serological report confirming that the blood on
the clothes or weapon belonged to the deceased, the recovery is of no
substantial help to the prosecution.”
“24. Again, in Vijay Shankar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2022) 10 SCC
353, the Apex Court reiterated:
“The prosecution’s failure to establish, through scientific evidence,
that the blood found on the weapon or clothes matched that of the
deceased creates a serious doubt about the veracity of the recovery
and the guilt of the accused.”
“25. These authoritative pronouncements make it abundantly clear
that mere recovery of blood-stained articles, without scientific
corroboration, is insufficient to sustain a conviction, especially when
the case is otherwise based on circumstantial evidence.”
49. Thus, the trial court erred in observing that it is the defence who has
to explain in what circumstances their clothes were blood stained or even
how their vehicles were blood stained and that the defence has not clarified
any of these facts even under their statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C.
We find that such findings are against the basic tenets of criminal
jurisprudence.
Vishal Parekar .....43
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
F. RECOVERY OF WEAPONS
50. In order to prove recovery of weapons the prosecution has examined
P.W. 10- Arun Chaudhary. He deposed that on 11.10.2012, the police called
him at the Crime Branch. He further deposed that Kabir (A-12) made a
disclosure statement before him to the police that he is ready to tender
(show) the weapons which were thrown below the bridge of Gandhari. He
further deposed that police prepared the panchnama in his presence and
thereafter they went towards Gandhari bridge by police vehicle. He further
deposed that the accused pointed out the spot and told them that he had
thrown those weapons in the water. He further deposed that drivers were
called to search for the weapon in the water but it was not found. This
circumstance is not of any avail to the prosecution to connect the Appellants
with the incident in question as no weapons have been recovered.
G. CHEMICAL ANALYSIS
51. The prosecution has also relied upon the Chemical Analyzer (CA)
reports to establish its case with respect to the blood stains found on the
articles and the clothes. The report at Exhibit 289 is the blood sample of the
deceased- Vikas Vasant Patil. The report however indicates that the species
origin was not attempted and the ABO blood grouping was unsuitable. The
Vishal Parekar .....44
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
species origin of hairs and the nail clippings, although identified as human,
was inconclusive as regards the ABO grouping.
52. From Exhibit 275 to Exhibit 291 are the blood examination reports
and the results of analysis of the Appellants issued by Assistant Chemical
Analyser, FSL, Mumbai. The same is tabulated as under:
Accused No. Name of the accused Blood Group
1 Kaka Patil B
2 Pradeep Patil A
3 Umesh Patil B
4 Anil Patil B
5 Ranbul @ Ranshya Patil O
6 Bhagwat Patil A
7 Sanjay Karbhari B
8 Kisan Patil AB
9 Bharat Patil AB
10 Sandip Patil B
11 Yashwant Patil AB
12 Kabir Karbhari O
13 Sharad Patil A
14 Madhukar Patil A
15 Baliram Patil A
Vishal Parekar .....45
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
53. The CA report of the clothes of the Appellant and clothes of the
deceased records the presence of Human Blood and on certain articles as
blood of ‘A’ group, however in the absence of the identification of blood
group of the deceased, the presence of blood group ‘A’ on the recovered
clothes does not take the case of the prosecution any further. Further, the
evidence with respect to which accused was wearing those recovered clothes
is also convoluted and therefore we are inclined to hold that the prosecution
has not been able to successfully establish a nexus between the blood-stained
clothes recovered and the involvement of the Appellants in the offence.
H. FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS
54. After taking into consideration the overall conspectus of the case, we
find that there are several material discrepancies in the case of the
prosecution.
55. While going through the records we find that, the presence of Kaka
Patil (A-1) (now deceased) who is considered to be the genesis of the
dispute, has not been cogently established. It has been the defence of A-1
that he was not present at the spot but was attending his duty at the Fire
Brigade where he was employed. The trial court has observed that it is
disagreeing with the defence put forth by Kaka Patil (A-1) as no defence
Vishal Parekar .....46
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
witness has been examined, no muster roll is proved or exhibited by the
defence in order to show the presence of the accused at the working place
when the incident actually took place. However, the trial court failed to
appreciate the evidence of the I.O. (P.W. 17) who narrates the investigation
done by him. The relevant portion in the deposition of the I.O. (P.W. 17)
with respect to Kabir Karbhari (A-1) is as under:
“It is true that, accused Kaka Patil was doing a job in Fire Brigade
of KDMC. I have recorded statements of witnesses of staff of Fire
Brigade of KDMC. I have recorded statements of Satish Mankame,
Nakul Karbhari, Kundesh Kumbhar, Dilip Palav, Dilip Gund. I have
filed muster roll of accused Kaka Patil showing that on the date of
incident he was present on his duty from 6.00 a.m. to 2.00 p.m.
On that day at about 9.40 am PSI Patil of Bajarpeth Police Station
had taken to accused Kaka Patil for interrogation from his office..”
56. Therefore, taking into consideration the testimony of P.W. 17, we are
of the opinion that the presence of the Kaka Patil (A-1) at the spot cannot be
said to be established beyond reasonable doubt. The prosecution has not
challenged the said evidence of its own witness or that any clarification has
been sought by way of re-examination.
57. Secondly, we found the evidence of P.W. 2 and P.W. 3 to be neither
‘wholly reliable’ nor ‘wholly unreliable’ and therefore we were looking for
some other evidence for corroboration, however we came to a conclusion
that the evidence with respect to recovery of blood stained clothes, recovery
of Scorpio and Omni Car, recovery of weapons, the Chemical Analyser
Vishal Parekar .....47
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
report, have not been proved beyond reasonable doubt and therefore there is
a strong suspicion but lack of admissible evidence connecting the Appellants
(excluding Accused No. 12) to the crime in question and the fact that the
statements have been recorded belatedly with no explanation coming forth
for the delay, the question is further compounded.
58. However, we find that there is incriminating material against Kabir (A-
12). P.W. 2 and P.W. 3 have categorically attributed the role to Kabir (A-12).
P.W. 3 has even identified the weapon which was in the hands of A-12. The
evidence against Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12), stands on a different footing
from that of the other accused. P.W. 2 has specifically deposed that Kabir
was carrying a chopper and that he inflicted a chopper blow on the neck of
the deceased. The witness has not merely attributed a general assault to the
accused persons collectively but has specifically identified Kabir and
attributed the fatal assault to him. We cannot ignore the clear evidence of
P.W. 2 and P.W. 3 on this aspect where even the medical evidence further
lends assurance to the aforesaid version. The Post-Mortem report records a
deep incised injury extending across the neck of the deceased and the
opinion that the said injury was fatal and capable of causing instantaneous
death. The nature and location of the injury are consistent with the specific
allegation of P.W. 2 that Kabir inflicted a chopper blow on the neck of the
Vishal Parekar .....48
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
deceased. Even P.W. 3 deposed that A-12 was holding the chopper. The
specific allegation of inflicting the chopper blow on the neck of the deceased,
coupled with his presence immediately after the incident carrying the said
weapon, distinguishes his case from that of the remaining accused. Thus,
when the testimony of P.W. 2 is considered alongside the corroborative
circumstance emerging from the medical evidence on record, we find that
the prosecution has established the case against Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12),
beyond reasonable doubt.
59. What is also important to note is that there were injuries on the hands
of Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12) which have not been properly explained. The
following are the injuries suffered by Kabir (A-12) as noted and deposed by
P.W. 16- Dr. Minakshi Pande. She deposed that when she examined A-12 she
found the following injuries: 1)Deep Laceration- Hypothenor eminence of
right palm including hypothenor musculation size 10 x 3 cm and 2)
Laceration of right index finger Size 3 x 1 cm. She further deposed that the
age of the injuries was within 72 hours. She further deposed that these
injuries are possible if he assaults other persons with a sharp weapon.
However, in her cross-examination this witness has said exactly the opposite
of what she has stated in examination-in-chief by saying that if any person
tried to assault another person with a weapon then these injuries are not
Vishal Parekar .....49
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
possible. Notwithstanding the somersault, considering the nature of injuries,
for which there is no explanation given by the A-12, we are satisfied that the
A-12 has failed to explain the injuries and the only probable and reasonable
inference that can be drawn is that he has suffered those injuries at the time
of assault of the deceased. This according to us is a corroborative
circumstance which further establishes the involvement of Accused No 12.
60. The law on this aspect is very clear. In the case of Takhaji Hiraji v/s
13
Thakore Kubersing Chamansingh & Ors. it has been held as under:
“The first question which arises for consideration is what is
the effect of non-explanation of injuries sustained by the accused
persons. In Rajendra Singh & Ors. Vs. State of Bihar, (2000) 4
SCC 298, Ram Sunder Yadav & Ors. Vs. State of Bihar, (1998) 7
SCC 365 and Vijayee Singh & Ors. Vs. State of U.P., (1990) 3
SCC 190, all 3-Judges Bench decisions, the view taken
consistently is that it cannot be held as a matter of law or
invariably a rule that whenever accused sustained an injury in the
same occurrence, the prosecution is obliged to explain the injury
and on the failure of the prosecution to do so the prosecution
case should be disbelieved. Before non-explanation of the injuries
on the person of the accused persons by the prosecution
witnesses may affect the prosecution case, the court has to be
satisfied of the existence of two conditions : (i) that the injury on
the person of the accused was of a serious nature; and (ii) that
such injuries must have been caused at the time of the occurrence
in question. Non-explanation of injuries assumes greater
significance when the evidence consists of interested or partisan
witnesses or where the defence gives a version which competes in
probability with that of the prosecution. Where the evidence is
clear cogent and credit worthy and where the Court can
distinguish the truth from falsehood the mere fact that the
injuries on the side of the accused persons are not explained by
the prosecution cannot by itself be a sole basis to reject the
testimony of the prosecution witnesses and consequently the
13
SC Cr.A. 635 of 1992 Dt. 02/05/2001
Vishal Parekar .....50
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
whole of the prosecution case. The High Court was therefore not
right in overthrowing the entire prosecution case for non-
explanation of the injuries sustained by the accused persons. The
High Court ought to have made an effort at searching out the
truth on the material available on record as also to find out how
much of the prosecution case was proved beyond reasonable
doubt and was worthy of being accepted as truthful.”
61. In the present case, the evidence of P.W. 2, insofar as the remaining
accused are concerned, suffers from material omissions and discrepancies.
The identification of several accused by P.W. 3 is also not free from doubt,
particularly in view of the improvements and mistaken identification brought
on record. The alleged recovery of the vehicles and blood-stained clothes has
not been satisfactorily established and the Chemical Analyser reports do not
establish a conclusive nexus between the deceased and the articles allegedly
recovered from the accused persons.
62. We are therefore of the considered opinion that the prosecution has
only succeeded in establishing the guilt of Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12)
beyond reasonable doubt, whereas the evidence against all the remaining
accused falls short of the standard required for sustaining their conviction.
The benefit of doubt must consequently enure to the remaining accused.
63. The question that would arise for consideration is whether Kabir
Karbhari (A-12) can be convicted only under Section 302 IPC, when the
Vishal Parekar .....51
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
other accused are being acquitted under Section 302, Section 201 r/w 147
and 149, Section 302 r/w 149 and Section 201 r/w 149 of IPC.
64. At this stage we find it advantageous to refer to the judgment of the
14
Apex Court in the case of Parvat Singh & Ors v/s State of Madhya Pradesh
wherein although the Courts below had convicted the accused under section
302 r/w 149 of IPC, the Hon’ble Apex Court analysing the specific role
attributed to Accused No. 2 to 5 therein, as compared to the original Accused
No. 1 and by also relying on the testimony of P.W. 8 acquitted Accused Nos.
2 to 5, whereas original Accused No. 1 stood convicted.
65. The aforesaid appreciation of evidence also assumes significance in
light of the the principle laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
15
Nallabothu Venkaiah vs State Of Andhra Pradesh wherein the simpliciter
charge of Section 302 of the IPC was sustained without an aid of Section 149
of the IPC. The relevant paras are referred to hereinbelow:
“ In Achhey Lal v. State of U.P. AIR 1978 SC 1233 as many as
15 named persons had taken part in the assault on the deceased.
14 accused had been acquitted by the High Court but the
conviction and sentences awarded to the appellant by the
Sessions Judge were upheld. This Court held that there is no
finding by the High Court that after acquittal of the accused the
unlawful assembly consisted of five persons or more, known or
unknown, identified or unidentified, the provisions of Sections
149 and 147 cannot be invoked for convicting the sole accused
as no individual act was assigned to him. Analytical reading of
14
(2022) 2 SCR 964.
15
SC Cr.A. 517 of 2000 Dt. 20/08/2002
Vishal Parekar .....52
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
catena of decisions of this Court, the following broad proposition
of law clearly emerges: (a) the conviction under Section 302
simpliciter without aid of Section 149 is permissible if overt act is
attributed to the accused resulting in the fatal injury which is
independently sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to
cause the death of the deceased and is supported by medical
evidence; (b) wrongful acquittal recorded by the High Court,
even if it stood, that circumstance would not impede the
conviction of the appellant under Section 302 r/w Section 149
I.P.C. (c) charge under Section 302 with the aid of Section 149
could be converted into one under Section 302 r/w Section 34 if
the criminal act done by several persons less than five in number
in furtherance of common intention is proved.”
66. We hasten to clarify that the aforesaid benefit cannot be extended to
Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12). His case stands on an entirely different footing.
As discussed hereinabove, P.W. 2 has specifically attributed to A-12 the act of
inflicting a chopper blow on the neck of the deceased. This version finds
material assurance from the testimony of P.W. 3, who identified the chopper
in the hands of A-12, as well as the medical evidence recording a deep
incised injury extending across the neck of the deceased, which was opined
to be fatal and capable of causing instantaneous death. It would be apposite
to refer to the observations made in Nallabothu Venkaiah vs State Of Andhra
Pradesh (supra), wherein it was similarly stated that:
“Considering the evidence of important eye witnesses, we are
convinced that A1 was definitely present at the scene of offence
and the presence of the other accused is doubtful because of
inconsistency in the evidence of P.W. 1 to P.W. 3. Therefore, we
are of the considered view that the other accused may be entitled
for the benefit of doubt.”

Vishal Parekar .....53
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
67. The distinction between A-12 and the remaining accused is, therefore,
material and founded upon the evidence on record. While the prosecution
has failed to establish the requisite intention or common object to commit
murder insofar as the remaining accused are concerned, the specific and
cogent evidence against A-12, read with the medical evidence, establishes his
individual liability for the offence of murder. We are, therefore, satisfied that
the conviction of Kabir Lahu Karbhari (A-12) under Section 302 of the IPC
deserves to be maintained, whereas the conviction of the remaining accused
under all charges deserves to be set aside.
68. We would also like to add that, in view of the aforesaid findings, we
find no material to sustain the conviction of any of the accused persons
under Section 201 of the IPC. The prosecution has failed to establish the
requisite circumstances connecting the accused with the alleged destruction
or disappearance of evidence. The conviction under the said provision,
therefore, deserves to be set aside.
Hence, the following order.
Vishal Parekar .....54
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
ORDER
(1) The judgment and order passed by the District & Sessions
Judge- 2 at Kalyan, Mumbai in Sessions Case No. 24 of 2013
dated 07.03.2018 is partly set aside.
(2) Criminal Appeal No. 423 of 2018 preferred by Umesh Patil
(A-3), Sandeep Patil (A-10) and Kabir Karbhari (A-12) is partly
allowed.
(3) The conviction and sentence of Kabir Karbhari (A-12) for the
offence punishable under Section 302 of the IPC is confirmed.
However, the conviction and sentence of accused Kabir Karbhari
(A-12) for the offences punishable under Section 302 r/w 149,
Section 201 r/w 147 and 149, Section 201 r/w 149 and Section
148 r/w 147 of the IPC is set aside, and Kabir Karbhari (A-12) is
accordingly acquitted of the said offences.
(4) The conviction and sentence of Umesh Yashwant Patil (A-3)
and Sandeep Kaka Patil (A-10) for the offences punishable
under Section 302, Section 302 r/w 149, Section 201 r/w 147
and 149, Section 201 r/w 149 and Section 148 r/w Section 147
of the IPC is set aside. Umesh Patil (A-3) and Sandeep Patil (A-
10) are in judicial custody. In view of our finding of acquittal,
Vishal Parekar .....55
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
they shall be released forthwith upon completion of the
necessary procedural formalities, unless their custody is required
in any other case.
(5) The acquitted Accused-Appellants, who are in custody,
before their release from the custody, shall execute a P.R. Bond
in the sum of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand Only) under
Section 481 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
(Corresponding to Section 437A of the Cr.P.C.) for their
appearances, in the event an appeal is preferred against the
acquittal.
(6) Criminal Appeal No. 424 of 2018 preferred by Kaka Shankar
Patil (A-1) is allowed. The conviction and sentence of the
Accused-Appellant Kaka Shankar Patil (A-1) is set aside. He is
acquitted of the charges for the offences punishable Sections
302, 201 r/w 147 and 149, 302 r/w 149, 201 r/w 149 of IPC.
(7) Criminal Appeal No. 425 of 2018 preferred by Accused-
Appellants namely Pradeep Baliram Patil (A-2), Anil Kaka Patil
(A-4), Ranbul @ Ranshya Chandrakant Patil (A-5), Bhagwat
Yashwant Patil (A-6), Sanjay Lahu Karbhari (A-7), Kisan Kalu
Patil (A-8), Bharat Baliram Patil (A-9), Yashwant Baliram Patil
Vishal Parekar .....56
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
(A-11), Sharad Baliram Patil (A-13), Madhukar Ramchandra
Patil (A-14) and Baliram Gajanan Patil (A-15) is allowed.
(8) The conviction and sentence of the Accused-Appellants
namely Pradeep Baliram Patil (A-2), Anil Kaka Patil (A-4),
Ranbul @ Ranshya Chandrakant Patil (A-5), Bhagwat Yashwant
Patil (A-6), Sanjay Lahu Karbhari (A-7), Kisan Kalu Patil (A-8),
Bharat Baliram Patil (A-9), Yashwant Baliram Patil (A-11),
Sharad Baliram Patil (A-13), Madhukar Ramchandra Patil (A-
14) and Baliram Gajanan Patil (A-15) is set aside. These accused
are on bail. Each of these Accused-Appellants are acquitted of
the charges for the offences punishable Section 302, Section 302
r/w 149, Section 201 r/w 147 and 149 and Section 201 r/w 149
of the IPC.
(9) Criminal Appeal No. 316 of 2018 preferred by Minesh Nanu
Patil (A-16) is allowed. The conviction and sentence of the
Accused-Appellant Minesh (A-16) is set aside. He is already on
bail. He is acquitted of the charges for the offences punishable
Section 302, Section 302 r/w 149, Section 201 r/w 147 and 149
and Section 201 r/w 149 of the IPC.
Vishal Parekar .....57
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00

Cr.A.No. 423-2018
(10) All the acquitted Accused-Appellants who are out on bail
namely, Pradeep Baliram Patil (A-2), Anil Kaka Patil (A-4),
Ranbul @ Ranshya Chandrakant Patil (A-5), Bhagwat Yashwant
Patil (A-6), Sanjay Lahu Karbhari (A-7), Kisan Kalu Patil (A-8),
Bharat Baliram Patil (A-9), Yashwant Baliram Patil (A-11),
Sharad Baliram Patil (A-13), Madhukar Ramchandra Patil (A-
14), Baliram Gajanan Patil (A-15) and Minesh Nanu Patil (A-16)
shall execute a P.R. Bond in the sum of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees
Fifty Thousand Only) under Section 481 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Corresponding to Section
437A of the Cr.P.C.) for their appearances, within 7 days from
the date of this order.
(11) The Appeal is disposed of in the above terms.
(12) Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(SHREERAM V. SHIRSAT, J.) (MANISH PITALE, J.)
Vishal Parekar .....58
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:12:00
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)