(O&M)Suresh Chander Anand vs Keshav Chander Anand

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN
N THE HIGH COURT OF PUN
NJAB AND HARYANA
GARH
AT CHANDIG



RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&
&M)
Reserved on : 13.07.20
Pronounced on : 17.09.20
026
026

Suresh Chan
nder Anand (deceased) thr. L.Rs.
.
... Appell
lant
Versus
Col. Keshav
v Chand (retd.)/Anand (deceased
d) thr. L.Rs. & Ors.
...Responde
ents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PA
ARMOD GOYAL
Present:



Mr. Kabir Sarin, Advocate
for appellant.

PARMOD G



GOYAL, J.
Present appeal has been pre
ferred by unsuccessful appella
ant-
plaintiff bei
ng aggrieved by impugned judg
gment and decree dated 31.10.19
986
passed by
learned Sub-Judge First Cla
ass, Jalandhar, whereby suit
for
declaration
to the effect that sale deed
d dated 19.04.1982 executed
by
respondent-
defendant No.1 in favour of re
espondents-defendants No.2 and
d 3
was not bin
nding on the rights of appellan
nt-plaintiff, was dismissed and
by
judgment a
and decree dated 03.08.1988 p
passed by learned District Jud
dge,
whereby firs
st appeal preferred by appellant-
plaintiff was also dismissed.
2.
Appellant-plaintiff in suit fo
or declaration claimed that s
suit
property dul
ly mentioned in head note of pla
aint along with other properties w
was
owned by h
his father-Hari Chand and resp
pondent-defendant No.1. That H
Hari
Chand, duri
ing his lifetime, had executed W
Will dated 06.05.1957 and therea
fter
had execute
ed Codicil on 01.01.1959 to h
his Will dated 06.05.1957. It w
was
claimed tha
t the shop in dispute as well as
dodge car was given to appella
ant-
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -2-

plaintiff by deceased-Hari Chand vide Codicil dated 01.01.1959. That
respondent-defendant No.1 was appointed as one of the executors under the
Will by Hari Chand, who had died on 21.12.1963. Thereafter, property was
inherited by sons of deceased-Hari Chand and they became full owners.
However, appellant-plaintiff got his name entered as owner of the property in
the property tax register as well as in register maintained by House Tax
Authorities and started depositing the property tax. It was further claimed that
subsequently respondent-defendant No.1 had sold the suit property in favour of
respondents-defendants No.2 and 3 vide sale deed dated 19.04.1982. That
respondent-defendant No.1 had no right or interest in the suit property,
therefore, property could not have been sold by respondent-defendant No.1 in
favour of respondents-defendants No.2 and 3. It was asserted that no power of
attorney was ever given by appellant-plaintiff to respondent-defendant No.1
and knowing fully well that respondent-defendant No.1 had no right,
respondents-defendants No.2 and 3 had purchased the suit property with mala
fide intentions. Accordingly, declaration that sale deed dated 19.04.1982 is not
binding on his rights was sought.
3. Respondent-defendant No.1 in his written statement took
preliminary objections as regards to maintainability etc. It was asserted that
memorandum dated 19.03.1964 was executed amongst heirs of Hari Chand at
that time Codicil was not produced. The execution of Codicil was denied and
same was stated to be forged and fabricated. It was claimed that suit property
was part of joint property and share of appellant-plaintiff would be adjustable
from other properties. Respondent-defendant No.1, however, admitted
ownership of his father over suit property as well as execution of Will dated
SUNIL CHANDER
06.05.1957. Execution of Codicil dated 01.01.1959 was, however, denied. The
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -3-

fact that Hari Chand had died on 21.12.1963 was also admitted. It was asserted
that Codicil was never pressed or acted upon and parties had settled all their
disputes vide award dated 02.05.1967 passed by Justice Kesho Ram Passi,
relative of parties and at that time alleged Codicil was not produced or pressed.
It was asserted that appellant-plaintiff had never filed suit during the lifetime
of attesting witnesses of the Will. It was also claimed that respondent-
defendant No.1 had rightly sold the suit property being owner and had claimed
that suit property was let out by him and he was getting rent from the tenant
for the last 14 years being owner of the suit property. Accordingly, dismissal of
suit was prayed for.
4. Written statement was filed by respondents-defendants No.2 and
3, wherein preliminary objections as regards to maintainability etc. were
raised. It was stated that suit property was under tenancy of Madan Lal under
respondent-defendant No.1 and now under respondents-defendants No.2 and 3.
Site plan of suit property was stated to be wrong. It was asserted that
respondent-defendant No.1 had been receiving rent from Madan Lal for more
than 18 years prior to sale by respondent-defendant No.1 and Rs.30,000/- was
spent by respondents-defendants No.2 and 3 for renovating the shop after
purchase of same. It was claimed that respondents-defendants are owners in
possession being bona fide purchaser for consideration. It was claimed that
respondent-defendant No.1 had rented the shop 18 years back to father of
respondent-defendant No.1 and was realizing rent as owner. Execution of will
and codicil by Hari Chand-father of appellant-plaintiff and respondent-

defendant No.1 was denied and accordingly dismissal of suit was prayed for.
5. Following issues were framed from the pleadings of the parties:-
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -4-

i. Whether the Codicil dated 01.01.1959 to Will dated
06.05.1957 was executed by Sh. Hari Chand in favour of
the plaintiff? OPP
ii. Whether the suit is properly valued for the purpose of Court
fee and jurisdiction? OPP
iii. Whether the plaintiff is estopped from filing the present suit
by his own act, conduct and admission ? OPD.
iv. Whether the suit for property in dispute is not
maintainable? OPD
v. Whether memorandum dated 19.03.1964 was executed by
the heirs of late Sh. Hari Chand. If so, its effect? OPD.
vi. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of Sh. Madan Lal as
necessary party? OPD 2 &3.
vii. Whether the site plan is correct? OPP.
viii. Whether the defendants No.2 and 3 have made
improvements in this suit property, if so, to what extent and
to what effect? OPD 2 & 3.
ix. Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present
suit? OPD. 2/3
x. Whether defendants No.2 and 3 are bona fide purchasers
for valuable consideration of he suit property? OPD. 2/3.
xi. Whether defendant No.1 is owner by adverse possession?
OPD. 1
xii. Relief.

6. Issues No.1, 3 5, 7 and 9 were decided against appellant-plaintiff
and in favour of respondents-defendants holding that execution of Codicil
dated 01.01.1959 is not proved. Issues No.10 was decided against appellant-
plaintiff and in favour of respondents-defendants No.2 and 3. Issues No.2, 4, 6
and 8 were decided in favour of appellant-plaintiff and against respondents-
defendants.
7. Learned Court of first instance had dismissed the suit of
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -5-

appellant-plaintiff and learned first appellate court had also dismissed the first
appeal preferred by appellant-plaintiff.
8. In present case, the entire case of appellant-plaintiff is based upon
Codicil dated 01.01.1959 claiming that vide Codicil dated 01.01.1959,
property was given to appellant-plaintiff by his father-Hari Chand by way of
correction of Will dated 06.05.1957.
9. Both the learned Courts below have concluded that execution of
Codicil is surrounded by grave suspicion and therefore is not proved. Both the
Courts have noticed following facts:-
i. That father of appellant-plaintiff had died on 12.12.1963.
ii. That Will was executed on 06.05.1957 and alleged Codicil
was allegedly executed on 01.01.1959, however, despite
death of father of appellant-plaintiff in 1963, Codicil had not
seen light for 20 years till filing of present suit in the year
1983.
iii. That appellant-plaintiff had not claimed any right over the
suit property by relying upon Codicil dated 01.01.1959 in
previous proceedings relating to succession of properties of
Hari Chand.
iv. That the suit property being a shop was under tenancy of
Madan Lal who was tenant over the shop for more than 18
years prior to filing of suit, however tenant was never asked
by appellant-plaintiff to pay the rent nor any notice was
SUNIL CHANDER
issued by appellant-plaintiff to the tenant claiming
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -6-

ownership of suit property.
v. That at the time of execution of agreement (Ex.D36) on
19.03.1964 between the parties, Codicil was not pressed or
produced.
vi. That Bal Kishan Nagar-PW3 was neither the registered
scribe nor typist, therefore, his evidence is not above doubt.
vii. That original Codicil was not produced, rather photocopy
was sought to be proved by secondary evidence after lapse
of more than 19 years of its execution.
viii. That appellant-plaintiff while appearing as PW1 in his cross-
examination had admitted that matter regarding properties
inherited from Hari Chand was referred to Arbitrator Justice
Kesho Ram Passi who was their uncle. The issues regarding
succession of properties inherited from their father were
settled vide Award dated 02.05.1967 and Codicil was not
produced by appellant-plaintiff in the arbitration
proceedings, despite his admission that Codicil was in his
possession.
10. On re-appreciation of evidence lead by parties, I find that finding
of facts recorded by both the Courts below that Codicil dated 01.01.1959 is
suspicious, is well founded and based upon evidence lead by parties. Perusal of
evidence of appellant-plaintiff goes to show that he had admitted that earlier
the suit property was occupied by Sham Lal as tenant during lifetime of his
father and shop was got vacated after death of his father. Thereafter, Madan
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -7-

Lal, father of respondent-respondents-defendants No.2 and 3 was inducted as
tenant by respondent-defendant No.1. Appellant-plaintiff had also admitted
that Sham Lal was evicted in the year 1965-1966 and new tenant Madan Lal
was inducted vide rent note dated 16.10.1965 (Ex.DX). It is also clearly made
out from the evidence of appellant-plaintiff that respondent-defendant No.1
was living in Delhi, appellant-plaintiff himself was carrying out his business at
Jalandhar, where the suit property is situated, however, he had never tried to
evict earlier tenant after death of his father nor had objected to letting of shop
to Madan Lal by respondent-defendant No.1. Appellant-plaintiff never raised
objection against respondent-defendant No.1 who had been receiving rent
since 1963 till he sold the suit property vide sale deed 19.04.1982 in favour of
respondents-defendants No.2 and 3. No plausible explanation is forth coming
except for claim that since respondent-defendant No.1 was appointed executor
of Will dated 06.05.1957, therefore, he was realizing the rent. This explanation
is without any basis as admittedly parties have been litigating regarding claim
over properties which they had inherited with each other and in fact matter was
also referred and settled between the parties vide agreement (Ex.D36) as well
as by Arbitrator Justice Kesho Ram Passi who happens to be uncle of
appellant-plaintiff and respondent-defendant No.1. Therefore, status of
respondent-defendant No.1 as executor of Will is only a sham explanation and
is not acceptable. The above noted claim made by appellant-plaintiff
explaining realization of rent by respondent-defendant No.1 is again belied by
Ex.D36 dated 19.03.1964, which goes to show that parties had settled all their
issues regarding property left by Hari Chand way back in the year 1964 and in
1967 before Arbitrator. There was no reason for appellant-plaintiff for not
producing and relying on Codicil dated 01.01.1954 if it had existed.
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -8-

11. I am also in agreement with conclusion drawn by learned Courts
below that failure of appellant-plaintiff to produce original Codicil and fact
that he had not pressed his rights under the Codicil for 19 long years also raises
grave suspicion regarding the existence and execution of Codicil by Hari
Chand. It is admitted fact that after death of Hari Chand on 21.12.1963, dispute
arose between the family members of Hari Chand, which was settled by them
vide Ex.D36 dated 19.03.1964 executed between the heirs of Hari Chand,
which was duly signed by appellant-plaintiff also. The ownership of
respondent-defendant No.1 was recorded thereafter which was duly accepted
and has never been challenged by appellant-plaintiff till date. Subsequently,
also in the year 1967 when Justice Kesho Ram Passi was appointed family
Arbitrator even then appellant-plaintiff had not claimed his rights under the
Codicil dated 01.01.1959. Appellant-plaintiff had also failed to assert his rights
under alleged Codicil dated 01.01.1959 when the suit property was being
vacated, rented and rent was being claimed by respondent-defendant No.1. All
these facts, especially failure of appellant-plaintiff to assert his right under
Codicil dated 01.01.1959 till the year 1982 in fact raises grave suspicion over
its execution.
12. I am also in agreement with the conclusion drawn by learned
Courts below that in absence of proof regarding due execution of Will dated
06.05.1957, which was required to be proved by way of secondary evidence
but was not proved also raises doubt over Codicil especially when Will dated
06.05.1957 was acted upon and Codicil dated 01.01.1959 was never pressed or
shown by appellant-plaintiff to claim his rights over suit property. Moreover,
perusal of Codicil goes to show that it was signed by Hari Ram at two places.
SUNIL CHANDER It appears that blank paper for affidavit or filing petition was used for showing
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


RSA No.2029 of 1989 (O&M) -9-

execution of Codicil. This suspicious circumstances has also gone
unexplained.
13. Codicil is required to be proved like a Will and any suspicion
regarding its due execution is to be dispelled by its pro-pounder. In present
case, the suspicious circumstances noted above, duly creates grave doubt over
due execution of Codicil and therefore Codicil dated 01.01.1959 was rightly
rejected by both the learned Courts below. Findings of facts recorded by
learned Courts below is based upon evidence and therefore cannot be
interfered by this Court in present regular second appeal. No substantial
question of law arises in present appeal.
14. Present appeal is liable to be dismissed, hence dismissed.

15. Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.

(PARMOD GOYAL)
JUDGE
17.09.2026
Sunil Chander
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No

Whether reportable Yes/No
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.17 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document