BHAGIRATH ENGINEERS COOP. SERVICE CONSTR. SOCIETY LTD & ANR vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee
(Samarpita)
WPA/22267/2015
BHAGIRATH ENGINEERS CO-OPERATIVE SERVICE
& CONSTRUCTION SOCIETY LTD & ANR.
VS
STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.
Mr. Anirban Banerjee
For the petitioner :
Mr. Sayantan Banerjee,
Mrs. Shreshtha Gupta
For the State : Mr. Amit Chakraborty, Ld. AGP
Mr. Falguni Bandyopadhyay,
Mr. Suvendu Bandyopadhyay
th
Heard on : 17 November, 2026
th
Judgment on : 17 November, 2026
th
Uploaded on : 19 November, 2026
Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.
th
1. The petitioner No. 1 is a co-operative society. On 12 October, 2012, a tender was
floated by the District Project Officer, Sarva Shiksha Mission, Murshidabad, for
inviting applications from eligible bidders for the job of wall writing at all
primary, SSK, upper primary, MSK, DM office, SDO offices, Block Development
Offices, and all Panchayat Offices of the district. In the said tender notice, the
specifications of the said wall writing work were mentioned. The petitioner no. 1
2
th
participated in the said tender and by an order dated 18 March, 2013, the
petitioner no. 1 was awarded the said work.
th
2. By another memo dated 8 May, 2013, the District Project Officer, Sarva Shiksha
Mission, Murshidabad, informed the petitioners that as per resolution of the
th
Purchase Committee dated 17 November, 2012, the work order for wall writing
had been issued in favour of the petitioners and the rate for each wall writing was
fixed at the rate of Rs. 631.27. It was further informed that the total bill amount in
respect of these 26 blocks was fixed as Rs. 38,49,484/-. The petitioner was
directed to submit the bill on a block-wise basis.
3. The petitioners in this writ petition have annexed one of the certificates issued by
the Block Development Officer, Bhagwangola-II, Murshidabad, wherefrom it
appears that the petitioners completed the work in terms of the said tender in
respect of the office of the CPC, Bhagwangola-II Development Block.
4. Subsequently, the petitioners submitted their bills. Since the bills were not paid,
th
the petitioners, by their letter dated 11 November, 2013, requested the District
Project Officer to release the bill amount. A reminder was sent to the District
nd
Project Officer on 22 September, 2013, along with a block-wise list of the wall
writing work.
th
5. Since nothing fruitful happened, the petitioner sent representations dated 30
nd th
October, 2013, 22 January, 2014, and 26 May, 2014. Being aggrieved by the
inaction on the part of the respondents in not releasing the bill amount, the
petitioner filed a writ petition before this Court being W.P. 23673 (W) of 2014. A
th
coordinate Bench of this Court, by an order dated 16 June, 2015, having
considered the rival submissions of the respective parties, directed the District
3
Project Officer to consider the issue of release of the bill amount in favour of the
petitioner in accordance with law and upon granting them an opportunity of
hearing.
6. Pursuant to such direction, the District Project Officer, by an order dated
th
13 August, 2015, passed an order whereby the claim of the petitioner was
rejected. The relevant portion of the impugned order is set out herein below:
“But, all the efforts of the authorities became in vain only
as because the specified work as quoted under the work
order (vide Memo. No. 1177/CM&AS/SSM/2013 dated 18-
03-2013) was neither done on 1274 walls out of 6098
walls and the rest work on 4824 (i.e. 6098-1274) walls
were not done as per specification by the Bhagirathi
Engineering Co-operative & Construction Society.
Under the above facts and findings, I am
constrained to pass the order with an instruction upon
the petitioner to complete the work on 6098 walls
throughout the District as per specification laid down
under work order vide Memo. No.
1177/CM&AS/SSM/2013 dated 18-03-2013. After
completion of the same work he shall submit the Work
Completion Report (as per specification work order) duly
authenticated by the Circle Project Concerned or the
Block Development Officer concerned to the office of the
undersigned in support of his claim for payment.”
th
7. Challenging the order dated 13 August, 2015, the petitioner filed this writ
petition.
8. Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that in terms of the tender
th
notice dated 12 October, 2012, they completed the work and submitted bills
accordingly. However, the respondents, without citing any cogent reason,
withheld the said amount for an inordinate period. He further submits that the
th
order dated 13 August, 2015, is perverse in nature as the relevant issues raised
4
by the petitioners were not considered by the District Project Officer. He submits
th
that the order dated 13 August, 2015 is liable to be quashed.
9. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the State respondents submits that the
District Project Officer found that out of 6098 walls, the petitioner had completed
only 4824 walls, that too in violation of the specifications stipulated in the tender
document. In view of the above, he submits that the petitioner is not entitled to
receive any amount in connection with the bills raised by them.
10. Heard the parties.
th
11. The order dated 13 August, 2015 is a quasi-judicial order. The scope of judicial
review in respect of administrative or quasi-judicial orders is limited. A writ
court may interfere if it is found to be arbitrary or perverse, if the decision-
making authority has exceeded its jurisdiction, if there has been a violation of the
rules of natural justice or if the decision is such that no reasonable man could
have come to such a decision.
12. In the instant case, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has failed to
th
demonstrate that the order dated 13 August, 2015, suffers from any procedural
impropriety.
13. However, there is another aspect of the matter. The District Project Officer
admitted in the impugned order that out of 6098 walls, the petitioner completed
4824 walls. However, it was also indicated that the work relating to those 4824
walls had not been executed as per the specifications mentioned in the tender
document. The violation of the execution of the work has been mentioned in the
th
impugned order dated 13 August, 2015, which are as follows:
“(IV) The quality of wall writing is very poor.
5
(V) The writings were done by stencil and not
by hand.
(VI) The Asian Paints Colour was not used.”
14. The deficiencies, as mentioned by the District Project Officer, were taken into
consideration in the month of August, 2015, whereas the work was completed by
the petitioners prior to November, 2013, as it is evident from the records that, on
th
11 November, 2013, the petitioners had requested the District Project Officer to
release the bill amount. Therefore, an inference can be drawn that by the time the
District Project Officer considered the issue of the alleged inferior quality of work,
more than one and a half years had lapsed.
15. The District Project Officer received several letters and representations from the
petitioners with a request to release the bill amount. However, at the relevant
point of time, neither any inventory nor an enquiry was conducted by the District
Project Officer in order to ascertain whether the work was properly executed by
the petitioners in terms of the tender specifications. Therefore, the finding of the
District Project Officer vis-à-vis the gross inaction on his part in not deciding the
issue within the reasonable time clearly demonstrates an arbitrary approach on
his part towards the petitioners to deprive them from their legitimate claim.
16. The District Project Officer, at a belated stage, after a lapse of almost one and a
half years from the date of execution of the work, cannot take the plea that the
quality of the wall writing was poor. In other words, the District Project Officer
cannot take advantage of his own inaction.
th
17. In view of the above, I set aside the order dated 13 August, 2015, passed by the
District Project Officer, Sarva Shiksha Mission, Murshidabad.
6
18. The District Project Officer is directed to release the proportionate amount in
respect of 4824 walls in favour of the petitioners within two weeks from the date
of communication of this order along with interest at the rate of 10% per annum
th
from the date of the representation dated 11 November, 2013, till the actual date
of disbursement.
19. So far as the remaining walls are concerned, since the issues involve disputed
questions of fact, such issues cannot be decided in this writ proceeding and the
petitioner is at liberty to file a suit against the respondents seeking appropriate
relief in accordance with law.
20. The writ petition stands disposed of along with all applications.
21. The writ petition being WPA 22267 of 2015 is disposed of. There will be no
order as to costs.
22. Parties shall act on the server copy of this order.
(Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.)