Raj Kumar vs State Of Haryana And Ors.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 1 of 10
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
212 CWP-28371-2024 (O&M)
Date of decision: 19.11.2026
Raj Kumar ...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
State of Haryana and others ...Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
Present:- Mr. Rakesh Nagpal, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Parveen Mehta, Addl.A.G., Haryana.
*
NIDHI GUPTA, J.
Present Civil Writ Petition under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioner for the issuance of an
appropriate writ particularly in the nature of Certiorari for quashing the
order dated 08.08.2024 (Annexure P-8) passed by Respondent No. 3
whereby claim of the petitioner for grant of 3rd A.С.Р. has been wrongly
and erroneously rejected; AND Further a writ in the nature of mandamus
directing the respondents to grant the 3rd A.C.P. to the petitioner after
completion of 30 years satisfactory service from the due date and all other
consequential benefits with regard to revised pension and stepping up of
pay equal to the juniors to the petitioner.
2. Brief facts of the case are that vide order dated 20.07.1968,
petitioner was appointed as Cleaner in the Haryana State Roadways
DIVYANSHI
Department and was posted at Rohtak Depot. Vide order dated
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 2 of 10
04.11.1970, petitioner was promoted as Assistant Fitter. Vide order dated
01.05.1974, petitioner was further promoted as Fitter. Upon attaining age
of superannuation, petitioner retired on 31.05.2008.
3. As per the Haryana Civil Service (Assured Career Progression)
Rules 1998 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the 1998 Rules’), petitioner was
st
entitled for grant of 1 ACP on completion of 10 years regular service; and
nd
2 ACP on completion of 20 years service. As per the New Rules, namely,
Haryana Civil Service (Assured Career Progression) Rules, 2008
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Rules, 2008’) notified on 30.12.2008 applicable
rd
w.e.f. 01.01.2006, petitioner was entitled for 3 ACP upon completion of
30 years regular satisfactory service i.e. in 1998. Accordingly, petitioner
had served a legal notice dated 27.11.2016 seeking grant of third ACP. As
no reply was received, second legal notice dated 14.02.2018 (Annexure P-
rd
1) was served upon the respondents seeking grant of 3 ACP and revised
pensionary benefits by stepping up his pay equal to his juniors. However,
vide order dated 09.03.2018 (Annexure P-2), claim of the petitioner was
rejected on the ground that record of the petitioner was not good as there
was adverse remarks with regard to honesty of the petitioner in the ACR
for the year 2004-2005 which had been duly conveyed to the petitioner
vide letter dated 04.02.2005. Petitioner had challenged the said order
dated 09.03.2018 before this Court by way of CWP-2269 of 2019 titled as
Raj Kumar vs. State of Haryana and others , which was disposed of vide
order dated 31.10.2023 directing the respondents to consider the claim of
the petitioner by taking into account his record up to 20.7.1998 .
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 3 of 10
4. Pursuant thereto, respondents passed order dated
03.01.2024 (Annexure P-6) wherein again petitioner was held not entitled
rd
to get 3 ACP on same ground of bad service record. Petitioner challenged
the said order dated 03.01.2024 (Annexure P-6) before this Court by way
of CWP-7615-2024 titled as Raj Kumar vs. State of Haryana and others ,
which was disposed of as infructuous vide order dated 05.04.2024
(Annexure P-7) upon the submission made by ld. Counsel for the
respondents that the order dated 03.01.2024 (Annexure P-6) “ be treated
as withdrawn with liberty to pass a fresh order in accordance with law
keeping in view the order passed in CWP No.2269 of 2019. ” Thereafter,
present impugned order dated 08.08.2024 (Annexure P-8) has been
rd
passed again denying 3 ACP to the petitioner, however, for entirely
different reasons .
5. It is inter alia submitted by ld. Counsel for the petitioner that
the petitioner has completed regular satisfactory service of 30 years from
20.7.1968 to 19.7.1998. No complaint whatsoever has ever been received,
and no punishment has been awarded to the petitioner for that period of
30 years. Hence, the petitioner is entitled for 3rd A.C.P. as per rules.
6. However, in the previous orders dated 09.03.2018 (Annexure
P-2) and 03.01.2024 (Annexure P-6), respondents had taken the ground
that as per Instructions dated 21.05.1973 (Annexure P-9) ACR is valid for
10 years; and as ACR of petitioner for the year 2004-05 was ‘integrity
rd
doubtful’, therefore petitioner is not entitled for 3 ACP. Ld. Counsel
contends that the said Instructions dated 21.05.1973 are not applicable in
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 4 of 10
the present case as, vide order dated 31.10.2023 (Annexure P-5),
respondent had been given specific direction to consider the period from
20.07.1968 to 20.07.1998.
7. Ld. Counsel submits that the present impugned order dated
08.08.2024 (Annexure P-8) has been passed on the ground that 2008
Instructions are not applicable to case of the petitioner. It is submitted
that the said ground is not tenable as it is well settled law that the person
who has completed regular satisfactory service of 30 years and last 10
years there was stagnation and he has no financial upgradation in the last
10 years, then he is entitled for third ACP. It is nowhere mentioned in the
Instructions that the person who has completed 30 years after 2008 will
be entitled for 3rd ACP. Even some juniors to the petitioner have already
been granted the benefit of 3rd A.C.P. after completion of 30 years of
service. By way of example, one junior namely Sh. Kishan Chand son of Sh.
Megh Raj has been given the benefit of 3rd A.C.P.
8. He accordingly prays that present Writ Petition be allowed.
9. Per contra, learned State Counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondents vehemently opposes submissions advanced on behalf of the
rd
petitioner and submits that the petitioner is not entitled to 3 ACP as the
petitioner has already availed 2 financial upgradation/promotion upto
01.05.1974. Therefore, he is not entitled to benefit of Higher Standard
Scale. It is submitted that as per ACP Rules, if there is no financial
upgradation/promotion during the past 10 years of service, only then
there is a provision of grant of ACP.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 5 of 10
10. Moreover, it is 1998 ACP Rules, which are applicable to the
petitioner as petitioner had already retired on 31.05.2008; whereas New
Rules had been notified only on dated 30.12.2008 (Annexure R-1). As
such, under the 1998 Rules, petitioner is not entitled to grant of benefit of
rd
3 ACP scale as there is no provision of third ACP Scale in 1998 Rules. He
accordingly prays for dismissal of the present Writ Petition.
11. No other argument has been raised on behalf of learned
counsel for the parties. I have heard learned counsel and perused the case
file in detail. I find merit in the submissions of the petitioner.
12. It is not disputed that as per the 2008 Rules (Annexure P-3),
rd
3 ACP is to be granted upon completion of 30 years of regular
rd
satisfactory service. In the first instance, 3 ACP was denied to the
petitioner by the respondents vide order dated 09.03.2018 (Annexure P-2)
on the ground that:
“ Thereafter, Haryana Government, Finance
Department issued another notification on 30.12.08 and
granting the benefit of new pay scale to the Haryana
Government officers/employees which was applicable from
01.01.06. And after completion of 30 years service the
rd
provision of grant of 3 A.C.P. has been given. It is clarified
rd
here with the benefit of 3 pay scale was applicable from
01.01.06 and whenever it is due was to granted to the
employee.
Sh. Raj Kumar Fitter firstly appointed on dated
20.7.1968 therefore, he had completed 30 years of service
rd
before 2006 but his case was to be considered for 3 A.C.P. on
01.01.06. But retired employees ACR for the year of 2004-05
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 6 of 10
has been written by Competent Officer with adverse remarks
with regard to honesty. And adverse remarks was conveyed
to retired employee vide office Letter No. 4065/ECV dated
04.02.05. The retired employee did not file any appeal/case
against the adverse remarks.
According to instructions of Chief Secretary of Haryana
Government if ACR of any employee has been noted
adversely with regard to honesty (honesty doubtful) in that
situation the said confidential report remains effective upto
10 years and the employee cannot be given the benefit of
promotion A.C.P. and efficiency bar for that period.
The ACR of for the year 2004-05 of Sh. Raj Kumar was
written honesty doubtful by the Competent Officer. And which
remains effective atleast upto 31.03.15 whereas the
employee has already been retired on 31.05.08. Therefore
finding no merit in the Legal Notice send through you by Sh.
Raj Kumar is not accepted.”
13. As already noted above, said order dated 09.03.2018 was
challenged by the petitioner before this Court by way of CWP-2269-2019,
which was disposed of vide order dated 31.10.2023 (Annexure P-5) with
the following direction to the respondents: -
“8. It is a conceded fact that as per the rules governing the
grant of ACP, an employee, who has completed 10/20/30
years of service in a particular cadre but has not been
granted the benefit of promotion, is entitled for the benefit of
ACP. That being so, the petitioner, who was appointed on
20.07.1968, completed 30 years of service on 20.07.1998.
Concededly, the report regarding the integrity doubtful which
has been taken into account for denying the benefit of ACP is
for the year 2004-2005, which is much after completion of 30
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 7 of 10
years of service hence could not have been taken into account
to deny the benefit of ACP as being claimed by the petitioner
in the present petition.
9. Hence, the respondents are directed to consider the claim
of the petitioner for the grant of 3rd ACP by taking his record
upto 20.07.1998 and appropriate order be passed within a
period of two months from the receipt of copy of this order as
to whether, on the basis of the service record upto the year
1998 the petitioner is entitled for the grant of ACP or not. In
case, after the passing of the order, the petitioner is found
entitled for the grant of benefit of ACP, the consequential
benefits will also be released to him within a further period of
eight weeks.”
14. Despite the above clear direction, respondents had passed
rd
order dated 03.01.2024 (Annexure P-6) again denying 3 ACP to the
petitioner on the following ground that services of the petitioner were not
satisfactory: “… since the ACR of the petitioner for the year of 2004-05 has
been written by the Reporting Authority with adverse remarks with regard
to integrity. As per instructions of Govt. of Haryana vide letter No. 2759-4
GSI-73/12854 dated the 21 May, 1973 that if ACR of any employee has
been noted adverse with regard to integrity (integrity doubtful) in that
case, said confidential report remains effective up-to 10 years. ”
15. The said order dated 03.01.2024 (Annexure P-6) was
challenged by the petitioner vide CWP-7615-2024 , which was disposed of
as infructuous vide order dated 05.04.2024 (Annexure P-7) as order dated
03.01.2024 was unconditionally withdrawn by the respondents.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 8 of 10
16. Now again, vide the present impugned order dated 8.8.2024,
rd
3 ACP is being denied to the petitioner on a wholly different ground
taken by the respondents to the effect that: -
“Since petitioner Sh. Raj Kumar Fitter (Retd.,) had
already availed two promotions on 01.05.1974. Therefore, he
was not entitled for the benefits of Higher Standard Scales.
Further the Finance Department Govt. Of Haryana Issued
another instruction dated 07.01.1998 vide which the Haryana
Government employees were given the benefits of new pay
scale and Higher Standard Scale was converted to Assured
Carrier Progression (A.C.P.), which was applicable w.e.f.
01.01.1996. In which during the past 10 years of the services
if, there is no promotion then there was provision for grant of
1st ACP and even after serving of 20 years if there is no
promotion then there was provision for grant of 2nd ACP. Sh.
Raj Kumar Fitter (Retd.) had already availed two promotions
on 01.05.1974.
So far as question of the 3rd ACP scale is very
concerned that there was not any provision in the
rule/instructions dated 07.01.1998 (which was applicable
upon the petitioner) for grant of 3rd ACP scale in the year
1998. As such, 3rd ACP scale cannot be granted to the
petitioner by taking his service record upto 20.07.1998 in
view of the (Assured Carrier Progression) Rules, 1998.”
17. Thus, in an attempt to circumvent the clear and categoric
directions contained in the order dated 31.10.2023, respondents have
deliberately wrongly applied the 1998 Instructions and held the petitioner
ineligible. Respondents cannot be permitted to do so. Even otherwise,
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 9 of 10
reasoning given by the respondent in the impugned order is untenable as
2008 Rules are applicable w.e.f. 01.01.1996 – on which date, petitioner
was very much in service as he had retired only on 31.05.2008. In this
view of the matter, 2008 Rules are very much applicable to the petitioner;
rd
and, therefore, petitioner is entitled to grant of 3 ACP upon successful
completion of 30 years on 28.07.1998. Respondents are also unable to
dispute that benefit of third ACP has been granted to Junior of the
petitioner, namely Sh. Kishan Chand son of Sh. Megh Raj.
18. The order dated 08.08.2024 (Annexure P-8) is not sustainable
also on the ground that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rashmi Metaliks
Ltd. v. Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority (SC): Law Finder
Doc Id # 479301, has held that once the order is passed, it cannot be
supplemented by further grounds. The relevant para of the said judgment
reads as under:
“12..........The impugned Judgment is indubitably a cryptic one
and does not contain the reasons on which the decision is
predicated. Since reasons are not contained in the impugned
Judgment itself, it must be set aside on the short ground that a
party cannot be permitted to travel beyond the stand adopted
and expressed by it in its earlier decision. The following
observations found in the celebrated decision in Mohinder
Singh Gill v. The Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi, AIR
1978 Supreme Court 851 , are relevant to this question:
"8. The second equally relevant matter is that when a
statutory functionary makes an order based on certain
grounds, its validity must be judged by the reasons so
mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh
DIVYANSHI reasons in the shape of affidavit or otherwise.
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-28371-2024 (O&M) 10 of 10
Otherwise, an order bad in the beginning may, by the
time it comes to court on account of a challenge, get
validated by additional grounds later brought out. We
may here draw attention to the observations of Bose J. in
Gordhandas Bhanji (AIR 1952 Supreme Court 16) (at
p.18):
"Public orders publicly made, in exercise of
a statutory authority cannot be construed in the
light of explanations subsequently given by the
officer making the order of what he meant, or of
what was in his mind, or what he intended to do.
Public orders made by public authorities are
meant to have public effect and are intended to
affect the acting and conduct of those to whom
they are addressed and must be construed
objectively with reference to the language used in
the order itself.
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as they
grow older.”
19. Keeping in view the entire conspectus of the afore-noted
factual and legal position, present Writ Petition is allowed ; and impugned
order dated 08.08.2024 (Annexure P-8) stands quashed. Respondents are
rd
directed to grant 3 ACP to the petitioner after completion of 30 years
satisfactory service from due date and all consequential benefits with
regard to revised pension and stepping up of pay equal to the juniors
within a period of 6 months, failing which respondent shall be liable to
pay interest to the petitioner, @ 6% p.a.
20. Pending application(s) if any also stand(s) disposed of.
19.11.2026 (NIDHI GUPTA)
Divyanshi JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document