Rajnish Kumar vs State Of Punjab

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH

1. CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M)

Rajnish Kumar ...Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab ...Respondent
2. CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M)
Anil Dogra ...Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab ...Respondent
Sr. No. Particulars Details
1 The date when the judgment is reserved 16.11.2026
2 The date when the judgment is pronounced 18.11.2026
3 The date when the judgment is uploaded on the website 18.11.2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced or full
4 Full
judgment is pronounced
The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full judgment, and Not
5
reasons thereof applicable

CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MANISHA BATRA
Present:- Mr. Ramandeep Singh, Advocate and
Mr. Anutej Singh Barnala, Advocate
for the petitioner (in CRM-M-24957-2015).
Mr. G.S. Jagpal, Advocate and
Mr. S.S. Rai, Advocate
for the petitioner (in CRM-M-31206-2015).
Mr. K.D. Sachdeva, DAG, Punjab.

MANISHA BATRA, J.

1. Since both these petitions arise out of the same FIR and assail
the same orders, they are being decided by this common order. For
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 2
convenience, facts have been taken from CRM-M-24957-2015 and the reply
filed in CRM-M-31206-2015.
2. Prayer in both the petitions filed under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short 'Cr.P.C.') is for quashing of order
dated 14.05.2005 passed by the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ludhiana
(Annexure P-2), order dated 06.06.2012 passed by the Court of Additional
Sessions Judge, Ludhiana (Annexure P-3) and all the subsequent
proceedings, including the charge framed on 22.10.2012 (Annexure P-4),
arising out of FIR No.22 dated 22.02.1994 registered under Sections 406,
420, 465 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code (for short 'IPC') and Section 7
of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 at Police Station Focal Point,
Ludhiana, qua the petitioners.
3. Brief facts of the case are that the FIR in question was registered
on the statement of Jarnail Singh alleging therein that he wanted to purchase
a Maruti car urgently and had approached M/s Saini Motors, Sherpur Chowk,
Ludhiana, which was an authorised dealer. Rajiv Saini, one of the owners of
the firm, told him that he would have to pay about Rs.30,000/- over and
above the actual price as black money. When he again visited the showroom,
Meenakshi Saini and her son Sanjiv Saini quoted Rs.1,96,000/- for the car,
whose actual price was about Rs.1,65,000/-. As per the complainant, the clerk
Anil Dogra and the cashier Rajinder Kumar, who were sitting there, also
refused to reduce the price any further. The complainant then approached the
police. A raid was organised with SI Gurdial Singh as a shadow witness. On
22.02.1994, the complainant handed over the initialled currency notes to
Sanjiv Saini at the showroom. The notes were counted by the employees
present there and were kept in the safe. Bill No.52269 was issued for a sum
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 3
of Rs.1,64,254/-, thereby showing an excess charge of Rs.31,246/-. On a
signal given by the complainant, the raiding party recovered Rs.6,25,160/-
from the safe, which included the initialled notes (Annexure P-1).
4. After investigation, report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. was filed
against Meenakshi Saini, Rajiv Saini, Sanjiv Saini, Anil Dogra, Rajinder
Kumar, Rajnish Kumar and Ashish Kumar. Vide order dated 14.05.2005
(Annexure P-2), the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ludhiana found a prima facie
case under Section 420 IPC against all the accused. It was held that no case of
forgery was made out, as the original documents had not been placed on
record. The revision filed by the accused, including the petitioners, was
dismissed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Ludhiana on 06.06.2012
(Annexure P-3). On 22.10.2012, charge under Section 420 IPC was framed
against Meenakshi Saini, Rajiv Saini, Anil Dogra, Rajnish Kumar and Ashish
Kumar (Annexure P-4). By then, Rajinder Kumar had died and Sanjiv Saini
had been declared a proclaimed offender. All the accused pleaded not guilty
and claimed trial.
5. Earlier, the petitioner Rajnish Kumar had approached this Court
by way of a petition, which was dismissed as withdrawn on 14.07.2014 with
liberty to file a fresh one with better particulars (Annexure P-5). The earlier
petition filed by the petitioner Anil Dogra was dismissed as withdrawn on
27.10.2014 (Annexure R-2). In the present petitions, notice of motion was
issued on 06.08.2015 and 15.09.2015 respectively and the proceedings qua
the petitioners before the trial Court were stayed. The trial against the
remaining co-accused continued. A copy of the judgment dated 08.02.2024
passed by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Chandigarh has been placed on
record showing that all the co-accused who faced trial have been acquitted.
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 4
During the pendency of these petitions, applications were filed by Meenakshi
Saini and Rajiv Saini for impleadment and by the co-accused Ashish Kumar
for intervention and for vacation of the interim order. These applications have
since been dismissed by this Court on 17.08.2026 and 16.11.2026.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioners has argued that the impugned
orders are not sustainable in the eyes of law. The petitioners were mere
employees of M/s Saini Motors. Rajnish Kumar was working as a clerk and
Anil Dogra as a cashier. Neither of them made any demand from the
complainant. The alleged demand of black money was made by the owners of
the firm, as per the version of the complainant himself. The only role
attributed to the petitioners is that they were present at the counter and
counted the currency notes in the course of their employment. No part of the
excess amount was paid to them. Thus, dishonest intention at the inception of
the transaction, which is an essential ingredient of cheating, was wholly
missing qua the petitioners. The Courts concerned did not consider their
individual role and also relied upon photocopies of documents. Learned
counsel has further argued that all the co-accused who faced a full-length trial
on the very same allegations, including the owners at whose instance the
petitioners are alleged to have acted, have been acquitted vide judgment dated
08.02.2024. The evidence against the petitioners is the same and there is no
distinct material against them. The occurrence is of the year 1994 and putting
the petitioners to trial after more than three decades would be an empty
formality. Hence, a prayer has been made for allowing the petitions.
7. Learned State counsel has opposed the petitions on the basis of
the replies. It is argued that the petitioner Anil Dogra has not approached this
Court with clean hands. He did not disclose the petition filed by all the
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 5
accused in the year 2002 for quashing of the same FIR, which was dismissed
as withdrawn on 10.05.2006 (Annexure R-3). The present petition is a
verbatim copy of his earlier petition, which was withdrawn on 27.10.2014
without any liberty. It is further argued that the charge was framed by a
detailed speaking order, which has been upheld in revision. The prosecution
witnesses Jarnail Singh, Tarlochan Singh, Hargobind Singh and Krishan
Kumar Sharma had been examined by then. The petitioner connived with the
owners in receiving Rs.31,246/- in excess and he admittedly counted the
money. Hence, dismissal of the petitions has been prayed for. Reliance has
been placed upon the authorities cited as Manjula Sinha v. State of U.P.,
2007(3) RCR (Criminal) 779 , Moti Lal Songara v. Prem Prakash, 2013(3)
RCR (Criminal) 313 , Vinay Tyagi v. Irshad Ali, 2013(2) RCR (Criminal)
197 and Vinay Devanna Nayak v. Ryot Seva Sahakari Bank Ltd., 2008(1)
RCR (Criminal) 249 .
8. This Court has heard the rival submissions at considerable
length, besides going through the material placed on record.
9. Since these petitions were filed in the year 2015, they continue
to be governed by the Cr.P.C. in view of Section 531(2)(a) of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. Before adverting to the merits, two
objections relating to maintainability need to be dealt with.
10. The first objection is that the petitioners, having already availed
the remedy of revision before the Sessions Court, could not have invoked
Section 482 Cr.P.C. against the same order. A second revision is no doubt
barred by Section 397(3) Cr.P.C. and the inherent power is not ordinarily to
be used to circumvent the bar. However, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Krishnan and another v. Krishnaveni and another, (1997) 4 SCC 241 has
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 6
held that the bar does not take away the inherent power of the High Court
where it finds an abuse of the process of the Court or a grave miscarriage of
justice. The relevant observations are as under:-
“Ordinarily, when revision has been barred by Section 397(3)
of the Code, a person accused/complainant cannot be allowed to
take recourse to the revision of the High Court under Section
397(1) or under inherent powers of the High Court under
Section 482 of the Code since it may amount to circumvention
of the provisions of Section 397(3) or Section 397(2) of the
Code. It is seen that the High Court has suo motu power under
Section 401 and continuous supervisory jurisdiction under
Section 483 of the Code. So, when the High Court on
examination of the record finds that there is grave
miscarriage of justice or abuse of process of the courts or the
required statutory procedure has not been complied with or
there is failure of justice or order passed or sentence imposed
by the Magistrate requires correction, it is but the duty of the
High Court to have it corrected at the inception lest grave
miscarriage of justice would ensue.”
11. The second objection is that the petition of Anil Dogra is a
successive petition, his earlier petition having been withdrawn without
liberty. In Bhisham Lal Verma v. State of Uttar Pradesh and another, 2023
INSC 955 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court, after noticing Superintendent and
Remembrancer of Legal Affairs, West Bengal v. Mohan Singh and others,
(1975) 3 SCC 706 and Anil Khadkiwala v. State (Government of NCT of
Delhi) and another, (2019) 17 SCC 294 , held that a subsequent petition
under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is maintainable in changed circumstances, though
an accused cannot raise pleas in instalments which were available to him at
the first instance. It was observed as under:-
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 7
“11. We are in complete agreement with these observations of
the Madras High Court. Though it is clear that there can be
no blanket rule that a second petition under Section 482
Cr.P.C. would not lie in any situation and it would depend
upon the facts and circumstances of the individual case , it is
not open to a person aggrieved to raise one plea after the other,
by invoking the jurisdiction of the High Court under Section
482 Cr.P.C., though all such pleas were very much available
even at the first instance. Permitting the filing of successive
petitions under Section 482 Cr.P.C. ignoring this principle
would enable an ingenious accused to effectively stall the
proceedings against him to suit his own interest and
convenience, by filing one petition after another under Section
482 Cr.P.C., irrespective of when the cause therefor arose. Such
abuse of process cannot be permitted.”
12. In so far as the petitioner Rajnish Kumar is concerned, his earlier
petition was withdrawn with liberty to file a fresh one with better particulars.
No bar, therefore, operates against him. The earlier petition of Anil Dogra
was no doubt withdrawn without liberty, but it was not decided on merits. As
held in Bhisham Lal Verma's case (supra) , there is no blanket rule against a
second petition and the matter depends upon the facts of each case. The
present petition was entertained in the year 2015, notice of motion was
issued, the State filed its reply on merits and the proceedings have remained
stayed since then. The role attributed to Anil Dogra is also similar to the role
of Rajnish Kumar, whose petition is admittedly maintainable. If this Court
finds on merits that no offence is disclosed against one employee, it would be
anomalous to leave the other employee with a similar role to face trial on a
technical objection. Moreover, the acquittal of the co-accused vide judgment
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 8
dated 08.02.2024 is a subsequent development, which was not available when
the earlier petition was withdrawn in the year 2014.
13. As regards the petition filed in the year 2002, the same was
withdrawn on 10.05.2006 when the State counsel pointed out the pendency of
the revision. It was not decided on merits. The petitioner Anil Dogra ought to
have disclosed it. However, the order was placed on record by the State itself
and its non-mention has not misled this Court on any material aspect. This
lapse alone does not justify non-suiting him. Both the objections are,
therefore, rejected.
14. Coming to the merits, the framing of the charge does not by
itself take away the power of this Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. In Anand
Kumar Mohatta and another v. State (Government of NCT of Delhi),
Department of Home and another, (2019) 11 SCC 706 , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court held that this power is not confined to the stage of the FIR and can be
exercised even after the case has advanced to the stage of the charge-sheet. It
was observed as under:-
“18. There is nothing in the words of this Section which
restricts the exercise of the power of the Court to prevent
the abuse of process of court or miscarriage of justice only
to the stage of the FIR. It is settled principle of law that the
High court can exercise jurisdiction under Section 482 of
Cr.P.C even when the discharge application is pending with the
trial court. Indeed, it would be a travesty to hold that
proceedings initiated against a person can be interfered with at
the stage of FIR but not if it has advanced, and the allegations
have materialized into a charge sheet.”
15. As per the charge framed on 22.10.2012 (Annexure P-4), all the
accused were chargesheeted with having dishonestly induced the complainant
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 9
Jarnail Singh to pay Rs.31,000/- as black money for a Maruti car having an
actual value of Rs.1,65,000/-. It was further stated in the charge that they
received Rs.1,95,500/- and issued Bill No.52269, thereby causing wrongful
loss to the complainant by charging an amount in excess of the prescribed
rate. The question, therefore, is whether the material collected by the
prosecution, taken at its face value, discloses the ingredients of cheating
against the petitioners.
16. The ingredients of cheating were explained by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma and others v. State of
Bihar and another, (2000) 4 SCC 168 . It was held that deception of the
person is the first requirement. The inducement must be fraudulent or
dishonest and such intention must exist at the time of the inducement itself.
The relevant observations are as under:-
“The section requires - (1) Deception of any person. (2) (a)
Fraudulently or dishonestly inducing that person (i) to deliver
any property to any person; or (ii) to consent that any person
shall retain any property; or (b) intentionally inducing that
person to do or omit to do anything which he would not do or
omit if he were not so deceived, and which act or omission
causes or is likely to cause damage or harm to that person in
body mind, reputation or property.
… Therefore it is the intention which is the gist of the
offence. To hold a person guilty of cheating it is necessary to
show that he had fraudulent or dishonest intention at the
time of making the promise. ”
17. It is equally well settled that the Indian Penal Code does not
recognise vicarious liability. A person cannot be prosecuted merely because
of his position or employment with the person who is alleged to have
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 10
committed the offence. In Ravindranatha Bajpe v. Mangalore Special
Economic Zone Ltd. and others, 2021 INSC 555 , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court held that specific allegations regarding the individual role of each
accused are a sine qua non for proceeding against him. In doing so, it relied
upon the following observations made in Sunil Bharti Mittal v. Central
Bureau of Investigation, (2015) 4 SCC 609 :-
“42. … However, at the same time, it is the cardinal principle
of criminal jurisprudence that there is no vicarious liability
unless the statute specifically provides so.
43. Thus, an individual who has perpetrated the commission of
an offence on behalf of a company can be made an accused,
along with the company, if there is sufficient evidence of his
active role coupled with criminal intent. Second situation in
which he can be implicated is in those cases where the statutory
regime itself attracts the doctrine of vicarious liability, by
specifically incorporating such a provision.”
18. Tested on these principles, the very first ingredient of deception
is not borne out from the version of the complainant himself. As per the FIR
(Annexure P-1), he was told at the first visit by Rajiv Saini that he would
have to pay about Rs.30,000/- over and above the price as black money. At
the second visit, Meenakshi Saini and Sanjiv Saini disclosed to him that the
actual price of the car was about Rs.1,65,000/- and demanded Rs.1,96,000/-.
Thus, the complainant was fully aware of the actual price as well as the
excess amount being demanded. Nothing was concealed from him and he was
not made to believe anything which was false. He then approached the police
and paid the initialled currency notes as a part of the raid, so as to have the
accused caught. His delivery of the money was, therefore, not the result of
any deception. The bill showing a lesser amount was issued after the money
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 11
had been paid and could not have induced the payment. Whether the demand
of an excess price attracted any other provision of law is not the question
before this Court, as the petitioners have been chargesheeted only under
Section 420 IPC.
19. Even otherwise, nothing has been attributed to the petitioners
which would show any dishonest intention on their part at the inception of the
transaction. The demand of black money was made by Rajiv Saini,
Meenakshi Saini and Sanjiv Saini, who were the owners of the firm. Anil
Dogra and the cashier Rajinder Kumar are only alleged to have told the
complainant that the price would not be reduced. This was no more than a
repetition of the price which had already been fixed and disclosed by their
employers. No statement at all has been attributed to Rajnish Kumar before
the payment was made. At the time of the raid, the money was handed over to
Sanjiv Saini and was kept in the safe of the firm. The counting of the notes
and the preparation of the bill at the asking of Sanjiv Saini were acts done by
the petitioners in the course of their employment, after the alleged
inducement was complete. There is no allegation that any part of the excess
amount went to the petitioners personally. In the absence of any material
showing their active role coupled with criminal intent, the petitioners could
not have been held liable merely because they were employees of the firm.
20. The Courts concerned did not examine the individual role of the
petitioners. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ludhiana, in the order dated
14.05.2005, observed in general terms that the owners of the firm, in
conspiracy with Anil Dogra, Rajinder Kumar, Rajnish Kumar and Ashish
Kumar, used to sell Maruti cars in black. The order then concluded that a
prima facie case under Section 420 IPC was made out against all the accused
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 12
“for cheating Tarlochan Singh”. The material relating to Tarlochan Singh
concerns his booked car having been sold to another person on the strength of
his blank affidavit. That material is attributed to the owners of the firm and to
Ashish Kumar and not to the petitioners. Moreover, the charge was ultimately
framed in respect of the transaction with the complainant Jarnail Singh. The
Additional Sessions Judge, Ludhiana, while dismissing the revision on
06.06.2012, referred only to the demand made by Rajiv Saini, Meenakshi
Saini and Sanjiv Saini. The role of the petitioners was not considered at all.
Thus, both the orders proceeded on a collective basis, without recording any
satisfaction about the existence of a prima facie case against the petitioners
individually.
21. Thus, the material collected by the prosecution, even if taken at
its face value and accepted in its entirety, does not disclose the commission of
an offence under Section 420 IPC by the petitioners. The case falls within the
categories laid down in State of Haryana and others v. Bhajan Lal and
others, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 , which were applied in Hridaya Ranjan
Prasad Verma's case (supra) . In view of this conclusion, it is not necessary
to go into the plea of the petitioners regarding reliance upon photocopies of
documents.
22. The subsequent acquittal of the co-accused also lends support to
the case of the petitioners. A Division Bench of this Court in Sudo Mandal @
Diwarak Mandal v. State of Punjab, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 453 quashed
the proceedings against the untried accused, as they would only face the
empty formality of a trial on the very same evidence which had failed against
the co-accused. The same view has been taken by Coordinate Benches in
Inderjit Singh v. State of Punjab, CRM-M-14086-2011, decided on
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 13
27.01.2012 , Balwinder Kataria v. State of U.T. Chandigarh and another,
CRM-M-10520-2023, decided on 20.04.2023 and Harpreet Singh v. State of
Punjab, CRM-M-15822-2017, decided on 31.05.2023 .
23. In the present case, the petitioners never absconded. Their trial
could not proceed only because of the interim orders passed by this Court.
Their case has also been independently examined on merits above. The
owners of the firm, who are alleged to have made the demand, have been
acquitted on the same composite charge and the witnesses against all the
accused are common. No witness or document has been pointed out on behalf
of the State which would be available only against the petitioners. Nothing
has been brought on record to show that the judgment of acquittal has been
set aside. The occurrence is of the year 1994. Thus, the acquittal of the co-
accused is not the foundation of this order, but it reinforces the conclusion
reached on merits.
24. The authorities relied upon by learned State counsel do not
advance the case of the State. Manjula Sinha's case (supra) was cited to
contend that a petition for quashing does not lie after the charge has been
framed. This contention stands answered by Anand Kumar Mohatta's case
(supra) . In Vinay Tyagi's case (supra) , it was held that a charge can be
framed if the ingredients of the offence are satisfied with reference to the
record. For the reasons recorded above, the ingredients of cheating are not
satisfied qua the petitioners. Moti Lal Songara's case (supra) relates to
suppression of material facts, which aspect has already been dealt with above.
The principle reiterated in Vinay Devanna Nayak's case (supra) , that every
crime is an offence against the society, presupposes material disclosing an
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-24957-2015 (O&M) and CRM-M-31206-2015 (O&M) 14
offence against the person sought to be prosecuted. Such material is lacking
qua the petitioners.
25. In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that continuation of the proceedings against the petitioners would be
an abuse of the process of the Court. It is a fit case to exercise the inherent
jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to secure the ends of justice.
26. Accordingly, both the petitions are allowed. Order dated
14.05.2005 passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ludhiana (Annexure P-
2), order dated 06.06.2012 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge,
Ludhiana (Annexure P-3), the charge framed on 22.10.2012 (Annexure P-4)
and all the subsequent proceedings arising out of FIR No.22 dated
22.02.1994 registered under Sections 406, 420, 465 and 120-B IPC and
Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 at Police Station Focal
Point, Ludhiana are hereby quashed qua the petitioners Rajnish Kumar and
Anil Dogra.
27. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of. A
photocopy of this order be placed on the file of the connected case.


18.11.2026 (MANISHA BATRA)
Waseem R. Ansari Waseem R. Ansari
Waseem R. Ansari Waseem R. Ansari
JUDGE

Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.18 17:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document