MANJUNATHA @ MANJA vs STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 2038 OF 2019 (C)
BETWEEN:
MANJUNATHA @ MANJA
S/O LATE MUNIRAJ,
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS,
R/A NO.205, NEW BINNAMANGALA SLUM,
INDIRA NAGAR, BENGALURU-560 038.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S.R. SREEPRASAD, ADVOCATE)
AND:
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY INDIRA NAGAR POLICE STATION,
BENGALURU-560 038.
REPRESENTED BY
THE STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS,
BANGALORE-560 001.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. VIJAYKUMAR MAJAGE, SPP-II ALONG WITH
SRI. SUDHINDRA B.S., HCGP)
Digitally
signed by
LAKSHMI T
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
THIS CRL.A. IS FILED U/S 374(2) OF CR.P.C., PRAYING
TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER DATED 28.11.2019
PASSED BY THE LX ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS
JUDGE, BENGALURU IN S.C.NO.727/2014 AND ACQUIT THE
APPELLANT.
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 16.10.2026, COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE
FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
This appeal is filed against the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 28.11.2019 passed
in S.C.No.727/2014 by the LX Additional City Civil and
Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, whereby the
appellant/accused has been convicted for the offence
punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code
and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay
a fine of Rs.25,000/-, in default, to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a period of six months.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
2. The case of the prosecution is that the
deceased, Smt. Shobha, was earlier married to one
Marappa and had two daughters and a son from the said
wedlock. Owing to certain differences, Marappa is stated
to have left her company. Thereafter, the deceased
developed a relationship with the appellant. The appellant,
who used to consume alcohol, frequently quarrelled with
the deceased. On 13.03.2014, at about 1.45 p.m., when
the deceased was in her house situated at No.205, New
Binnamangala Slum, Indiranagar, Bengaluru, the appellant
picked up a quarrel with her and assaulted her with a
knife, inflicting injuries on her chest. The deceased,
immediately thereafter, came out of the house and went
to the house of PW.1 – Jayamma, who is her aunt, holding
her chest and bleeding. She informed PW.1 and the other
persons present there, namely, PW.2 – Shyamala and
PW.3 – Sumitra, that the appellant had stabbed her with a
knife. When PW.1 to PW.3 proceeded towards the house of
the deceased, they saw the appellant coming out of the
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
house with a knife, which he threw away before fleeing
from the spot. The deceased was thereafter shifted to
Bowring Hospital, Bengaluru, for treatment. However, she
succumbed to the injuries at about 2.40 p.m. on the same
day.
3. On the basis of the complaint lodged by PW.1,
Indiranagar Police registered a case in Crime No.95/2014
for the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC.Upon
completion of investigation, charge sheet was filed against
the appellant. The trial Court framed the charge for the
offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC against the
appellant to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be
tried.
4. In order to establish its case, the prosecution
examined 22 witnesses as PWs.1 to 22 and got marked
Exs.P.1 to P.21, besides producing MOs.1 to 8. The
prosecution examined, inter alia, PW.1 – the complainant,
PWs.2 to 4 – the witnesses to the circumstances
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
surrounding the occurrence, the mahazar witnesses, the
police officials who conducted the investigation and PW.19
– the medical officer who conducted the post-mortem
examination. The post-mortem report was marked as
Ex.P.18 and the forensic report as Ex.P.17.
5. Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary
evidence, the Trial Court held that the death of Smt.
Shobha was homicidal and that the prosecution had
established the charge against the appellant beyond
reasonable doubt. The Trial Court placed reliance, inter
alia, on the testimony of PWs.1 to 3, the statement
allegedly made by the deceased before them, the
circumstances in which the appellant was stated to have
come out of the house with a knife, the medical evidence,
the seizure of material objects and the evidence relating to
the plea of alibi. Holding that the act of the appellant
attracted the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC,
the Trial Court convicted him and imposed the sentence as
stated hereinabove.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
6. Being aggrieved by the said judgment of
conviction and order of sentence, the appellant has
preferred the present appeal, challenging the findings
recorded by the Trial Court and seeking interference with
the conviction and sentence.
7. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant
would contend that the judgment of conviction and order
of sentence passed by the Trial Court are contrary to law,
facts and circumstances of the case and are therefore
liable to be set aside. It is submitted that the prosecution
case rests entirely on circumstantial evidence and there is
no eyewitness to the alleged incident. None of the
prosecution witnesses has actually witnessed the appellant
assaulting the deceased. PWs.1 to 4 are stated to have
seen the appellant only after the occurrence, when he was
allegedly coming out of the house and running away. Such
evidence, by itself, is insufficient to establish that the
appellant had caused the fatal injuries.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
8. It is further contended that the evidence of
PWs.1 to 3 is not free from material discrepancies and
improvements. Their presence at the alleged place of
occurrence is doubtful and their versions are not
consistent with the statements recorded by the
Investigating Officer during the course of investigation.
The learned counsel would submit that PWs.1 to 3 are
closely related to the deceased and are interested
witnesses. Their evidence is not corroborated by
independent witnesses. PW.4 has not supported the
prosecution case, while PW.2 and PW.3 have only shifted
the injured to the hospital in an autorickshaw. The other
independent witnesses have also not supported the
prosecution in material particulars. In such circumstances,
the Trial Court was not justified in placing reliance upon
the testimony of PWs.1 to 5 to record a conviction for the
offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC.
9. Learned counsel would further contend that the
alleged statement of the deceased before PWs.1 to 3
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
cannot be treated as a reliable dying declaration. The
statement is not supported by any independent or
contemporaneous record, and the versions attributed to
the deceased are not free from contradictions. It is
submitted that the Trial Court failed to properly consider
the inconsistencies in the evidence of the witnesses and
mechanically accepted the alleged statement as one
admissible under Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act.
The mere fact that the deceased sustained injuries and
subsequently succumbed to them would not, by itself,
establish the identity of the assailant.
10. It is also contended that the medical evidence
does not establish the prosecution case against the
appellant. Though the post-mortem report indicates that
the deceased died due to shock as a result of stab
wounds, there is no medical evidence directly connecting
the appellant with the infliction of those injuries. The
learned counsel would submit that the medical evidence
and the oral evidence have not been properly appreciated
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
together and that the Trial Court failed to consider the
discrepancies arising between the prosecution version and
the medical evidence.
11. Learned counsel would further submit that the
appellant was not present at the scene of occurrence at
the relevant time and that he had been admitted to a de-
addiction center. The defence examined DWs.1 to 3 in
support of the said plea. It is contended that the Trial
Court failed to properly appreciate the defence evidence
and the circumstances relied upon by the appellant. It is
also urged that the first husband of the deceased,
Marappa, used to visit her house, quarrel with her and
threaten her with dire consequences, including taking her
life. This circumstance, according to the learned counsel,
was not properly considered by the Trial Court while
evaluating the possibility of false implication and the
alternative defence version.
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
12. It is further contended that the alleged
recoveries have been created for the purpose of the case
and that the prosecution has failed to establish the seizure
of the material objects in a manner inspiring confidence.
The evidence relating to the seizure mahazars and the
material objects does not provide reliable corroboration to
the prosecution version. The learned counsel would submit
that the true genesis of the incident has been suppressed
and that the Trial Court failed to take into consideration
the material contradictions, omissions and improvements
appearing in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses.
13. Lastly, it is submitted that even assuming,
without admitting, that the appellant had caused the
injuries sustained by the deceased, the evidence on record
does not establish the requisite intention to commit
murder so as to attract Section 302 of IPC. It is argued
that, at the highest, the act may fall within the ambit of
Section 304(1) of IPC. The learned counsel would
therefore contend that the Trial Court has failed to
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
properly appreciate the evidence and the defence put forth
by the appellant and that the findings recorded therein are
unsustainable. Accordingly, it is prayed that the appeal be
allowed, the judgment of conviction and order of sentence
be set aside and the appellant be acquitted of the charge
levelled against him.
14. Learned SPP-II, supporting the judgment of
conviction, would contend that the Trial Court, upon
proper appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence
on record, has rightly held that the prosecution has
established the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable
doubt. It is submitted that, though none of the witnesses
had witnessed the actual act of stabbing, the evidence of
PWs.1 to 3, particularly the statement made by the
deceased immediately after sustaining injuries, coupled
with the circumstances in which the appellant was seen
coming out of the house holding a knife and fleeing from
the spot, clearly establishes his involvement in the
commission of the offence.
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
15. It is further contended that the statement made
by the deceased before PWs.1 to 3, identifying the
appellant as the person who had stabbed her, is
admissible under Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act.
The said statement is consistent with the surrounding
circumstances and finds corroboration in the medical
evidence. The deceased had approached PW.1
immediately after the occurrence, holding her chest and in
an injured condition, and there is no material to indicate
that she had any reason to falsely implicate the appellant.
16. Learned SPP-II would further submit that the
presence of PWs.1 to 3 at the relevant time is natural and
their evidence cannot be discarded merely on the ground
that they are related to the deceased. Their testimonies
have to be appreciated in their entirety, and minor
discrepancies or variations in their statements, particularly
with regard to events occurring in the immediate
aftermath of the incident, would not discredit the
prosecution case. The material particulars regarding the
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
deceased having sustained injuries and having attributed
the assault to the appellant remain consistent.
17. It is also submitted that the medical evidence
lends assurance to the prosecution case. The post-mortem
examination conducted by PW.19 and the report at
Ex.P.18 establish that the deceased sustained multiple
injuries, including stab injuries, and that her death was
due to shock resulting from the stab wounds. The medical
evidence, therefore, supports the prosecution version that
the deceased had suffered a homicidal death. The seizure
of the material objects, the evidence of the mahazar
witnesses and the forensic report at Ex.P.17 are also relied
upon as corroborative circumstances.
18. With regard to the defence plea of alibi, it is
submitted that the appellant has failed to establish that he
was admitted to the Yeshodha De-addiction and
Rehabilitation Centre at the time of the incident. On the
contrary, the evidence of PW.22, who was the Managing
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
Director of the said Centre, and the register produced at
Ex.P.21 disclose that the appellant was not admitted to the
Centre on the relevant date. The evidence of DWs.1 to 3,
particularly their admissions in cross-examination that
they had gone to the Centre only in the evening to secure
admission for the appellant and that the Centre had
refused admission, does not support the plea of alibi. The
Trial Court has, therefore, rightly rejected the said
defence.
19. It is further contended that the evidence on
record, when considered cumulatively, establishes a
consistent chain of circumstances pointing towards the
guilt of the appellant. The conduct of the appellant in
leaving the house with the knife and fleeing from the spot,
immediately after the deceased emerged with bleeding
injuries and disclosed the identity of her assailant, is a
relevant circumstance which lends support to the
prosecution case. The defence has not brought on record
any material to probabilise the suggestion that the
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
deceased was assaulted by some other person or that the
appellant has been falsely implicated.
20. Lastly, it is submitted that the nature and
location of the injuries, particularly the stab injuries
inflicted on the chest of the deceased with a knife,
establish the intention or, in any event, the requisite
knowledge on the part of the appellant. The act cannot be
brought within either of the parts of Section 304 of IPC, as
no circumstances warranting such alteration of the offence
have been established. The Trial Court has, therefore,
rightly convicted the appellant for the offence punishable
under Section 302 of IPC and imposed the sentence of
imprisonment for life. Accordingly, it is submitted that the
appeal is devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
21. We have heard the learned counsel appearing
for the appellant, learned SPP-II along with High Court
Government Pleader for the State and perused the
material placed on record.
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
22. At the outset, there is no serious dispute with
regard to the homicidal nature of the death of Smt.
Shobha. The evidence of PW.19, who conducted the post-
mortem examination, coupled with Ex.P.18 – the post-
mortem report, establishes that the deceased had
sustained several ante-mortem injuries. The external
injuries included sutured wounds on the left side of the
chest, a wound on the left side of the back of the chest, a
punctured wound on the right upper chest and an incised
wound over the left shoulder. The doctor has opined that
the death was due to shock as a result of stab wounds
sustained by the deceased. He has further opined that
injuries Nos.1 to 8 were not self-inflicted. The evidence of
PW.19, therefore, establishes that the death of the
deceased was homicidal and not due to natural causes.
23. The fact that the death was homicidal, however,
does not by itself establish the identity of the assailant.
The prosecution is required to establish, by reliable
evidence, that the appellant was responsible for causing
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
the injuries which resulted in the death of the deceased. In
the present case, admittedly, none of the witnesses have
witnessed the actual act of assault. The prosecution
principally relies upon the evidence of PWs.1 to 3, the
statement allegedly made by the deceased immediately
after sustaining the injuries, the circumstance of the
appellant being seen coming out of the house holding a
knife and thereafter fleeing from the spot, apart from the
medical and forensic evidence and the seizure of material
objects.
24. PW.1 – Jayamma is the complainant and the
aunt of the deceased. Her evidence discloses that on the
relevant day, she was engaged in cloth-vending business
and PWs.2 and 3 were also present. The deceased, after
stating that she was going to the church, went inside her
house. After about fifteen minutes, she came out crying,
holding her chest, with blood oozing from the injury. She
informed PW.1 that the appellant had stabbed her with a
knife. PW.1 has further stated that PWs.2 and 3 held the
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
injured and, by that time, the appellant came out of the
house holding a knife. On seeing them, he threw the knife
and ran away. She has also spoken about the deceased
being shifted to Bowring Hospital and lodging the
complaint at Ex.P.1.
25. The evidence of PW.2 – Shyamala, who is the
sister of the deceased, is substantially in consonance with
the version of PW.1. She has stated that the deceased
came out of the house holding her left chest and informed
them that the appellant had stabbed her. She has further
stated that she saw the appellant holding a knife and that,
on seeing them, he threw the knife and ran away. PW.3 –
Sumitra has also spoken about the deceased emerging
from the house with injuries and attributing the assault to
the appellant. She has further supported the circumstance
of the appellant fleeing from the spot after throwing the
knife.
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
26. It is true that PWs.1 to 3 are related to the
deceased. However, relationship by itself is not a ground
to discard their testimony. The evidence of a related
witness requires careful scrutiny, particularly when the
prosecution case rests substantially upon such evidence.
The relevant consideration is whether the witness was
naturally present, whether the testimony is consistent on
material particulars and whether there is any circumstance
indicating that the witness had reason to falsely implicate
the accused.
27. In the present case, the evidence of PWs.1 to 3
discloses that they were present in the vicinity of the
house of the deceased and that the deceased approached
them immediately after sustaining the injuries. Their
presence is also supported to an extent by the evidence of
PW.4 – Srinivas @ Seenee and PW.6 – Chandru, who have
spoken about the deceased falling near the road and being
shifted to the hospital by PWs.2 and 3 in an autorickshaw.
Though PWs.4 and 6 have not supported the prosecution
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
in its entirety, their evidence lends assurance to the
circumstance that the deceased emerged from the house
with injuries and was immediately taken to the hospital.
28. The fact that PWs.1 to 3 are related to the
deceased does not render their evidence inherently
unreliable. Their relationship with the deceased also
explains their presence at the relevant place. The defence
has suggested that the first husband of the deceased,
Marappa, used to visit the house, quarrel with the
deceased and threaten her with dire consequences. PW.1
has denied the said suggestion. Except for putting such
suggestions, the defence has not brought any material on
record to establish that Marappa had any role in the
occurrence or that PWs.1 to 3 had any reason to falsely
implicate the appellant. The possibility suggested by the
defence, without supporting material, cannot displace
otherwise credible evidence.
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
29. The principal circumstance emerging from the
evidence of PWs.1 to 3 is the statement allegedly made by
the deceased immediately after she came out of the house
with bleeding injuries. The statement, as noticed by the
Trial Court, was to the effect that Manja had stabbed her
with a knife below the left side of her chest. The said
statement is relevant under Section 32(1) of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872, as it relates to the cause of the death
of the deceased and the circumstances of the transaction
which resulted in her death.
30. It is well settled that a dying declaration need
not necessarily be recorded by a Magistrate or reduced
into writing. An oral dying declaration can form the basis
of conviction if the Court is satisfied that it was made
voluntarily, that the maker was in a fit state of mind and
that the statement is otherwise trustworthy. The absence
of a formal recording of the statement is not, by itself,
fatal to its admissibility or evidentiary value.
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
31. In the present case, the deceased is stated to
have emerged from the house, approached PW.1 and, in
the presence of PWs.2 and 3, identified the appellant as
the person who had stabbed her. The statement was made
immediately after the occurrence and before the deceased
was shifted to the hospital. PW.4 and PW.6 have stated
that the deceased was conscious when she was taken to
the hospital and remained conscious during the journey.
There is no material on record to indicate that the
deceased was incapable of speaking or that she was not in
a fit condition to make the statement at the relevant time.
32. The fact that the deceased had sustained
serious injuries does not necessarily mean that she was
incapable of making a statement. The surrounding
circumstances, including the fact that she came out of the
house, approached PW.1 and communicated the identity of
her assailant, support the version of PWs.1 to 3. The
statement is also consistent with the injuries found on the
body of the deceased and the circumstance of the
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
appellant being seen coming out of the house holding a
knife. We find no material circumstance on record to
suggest that the deceased had any reason to falsely
implicate the appellant at that critical juncture.
33. The Trial Court has also observed that the
accused had not disputed the mental condition of the
deceased while considering the alleged dying declaration.
We are of the view that the evidentiary value of a dying
declaration cannot be founded merely on the absence of a
specific denial by the accused. The Court is required to
independently satisfy itself about the fitness of the maker
and the reliability of the statement. In the present case,
however, such satisfaction is available from the evidence
of PWs.1 to 4 and 6, particularly the evidence that the
deceased was conscious and was able to communicate
immediately after the occurrence. The alleged oral dying
declaration, therefore, cannot be discarded merely
because it was not formally recorded.
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
34. Another circumstance relied upon by the
prosecution is that the appellant was seen coming out of
the house holding a knife and, on seeing PWs.1 to 3,
threw it away and fled from the spot. This circumstance
assumes significance when considered along with the
statement made by the deceased immediately after
sustaining the injuries. The deceased had attributed the
assault to the appellant, and almost contemporaneously,
PWs.1 to 3 saw the appellant emerging from the very
house where the deceased had sustained the injuries,
holding a knife. The appellant's conduct in throwing the
knife and running away from the spot is a relevant
circumstance which lends assurance to the prosecution
version.
35. The Trial Court has considered the circumstance
of the appellant and the deceased having been last seen
together. Strictly speaking, the principle of last seen
together is not the most appropriate description of the
evidence in the present case, since PWs.1 to 3 did not
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
speak of having seen the appellant and the deceased
together immediately before the assault. Their evidence is
that the deceased came out of the house after sustaining
injuries and that the appellant emerged thereafter holding
a knife. Therefore, the finding of the Trial Court in that
regard requires to be understood in the context of the
actual evidence. Nevertheless, the prosecution case does
not rest merely upon the theory of last seen together. The
immediate oral statement of the deceased identifying the
appellant, the circumstance of the appellant emerging
from the house with a knife and fleeing from the spot, and
the medical evidence, when considered cumulatively,
constitute the relevant circumstances connecting the
appellant with the occurrence.
36. The medical evidence further lends support to
the prosecution case. As noticed above, PW.19 found
multiple injuries on the body of the deceased. Injuries
Nos.2 to 4 were sutured wounds on the left side of the
chest and back of the chest. The doctor has opined that
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
force was used in causing these injuries and that, except
injuries Nos.1, 6 and 7, the other injuries could be caused
by MO.1 – knife. He has further opined that injuries Nos.1,
6 and 7 could have been caused in a scuffle or by a hard
and blunt object. Thus, the medical evidence is consistent
with the prosecution version that the deceased had been
subjected to a forceful assault involving a sharp-edged
weapon. The medical evidence does not contradict the
ocular circumstances spoken to by PWs.1 to 3.
37. The forensic report at Ex.P.17 is also a relevant
circumstance. The articles sent for examination included
mud, one knife, one baniyan, one nicker, the clothes worn
by the deceased and other articles. The report records the
presecnce of human blood on the articles examined and
identifies the blood group as 'O'. The report, therefore,
lends corroboration to the circumstance that the knife and
the clothes sent for examination bore human blood.
Though the report, by itself, does not identify the source
of the blood as that of the deceased, it has to be
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
considered along with the oral and medical evidence and
cannot be viewed in isolation.
38. The evidence relating to the seizure of MO.1 –
knife and MO.2 – bloodstained mud is spoken to by
PWs.14 and 15, who are the mahazar witnesses to Ex.P.2.
They have stated that the police took them to the house of
the deceased, where they noticed bloodstains on the wall
and floor and that the police seized the knife and
bloodstained mud under the mahazar. Their evidence
supports the seizure of the material objects from the
scene of occurrence. PW.20, the first Investigating Officer,
has also spoken about conducting the spot mahazar and
seizure of MO.1 and MO.2.
39. It is true that the evidence of PWs.1 to 3 is that
the appellant threw the knife before fleeing from the spot,
whereas the evidence of PWs.14 and 15 is that the police
subsequently seized the knife from inside the house during
the spot mahazar. The precise place where the knife was
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
found and the manner in which it was seized have to be
appreciated in the context of the entire evidence. The fact
that the knife was not recovered pursuant to any
disclosure statement of the appellant does not, by itself,
render the seizure inadmissible or unreliable. The seizure
is supported by the mahazar witnesses and the
Investigating Officer. Further, the identity of the knife as
the weapon allegedly used in the assault is spoken to by
the witnesses, and the forensic report records the
presence of human blood on it. The said circumstance,
therefore, provides corroboration to the prosecution case.
40. The evidence relating to the seizure of the
appellant's clothes under Ex.P.8 also requires
consideration. PWs.7 and 8 have spoken about the seizure
of the T-shirt and nicker, though their evidence indicates
that the police showed the clothes to them at the police
station. The Trial Court has noticed that these witnesses
partly turned hostile. The Investigating Officer has stated
that the appellant led the police to his house and produced
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
the clothes. The evidentiary value of this recovery is,
therefore, not as strong as the prosecution would seek to
make it appear. Nevertheless, the forensic report records
human blood of group 'O' on the clothes sent for
examination. This circumstance can be taken into
consideration as corroborative material.
41. The appellant has also raised a plea of alibi,
contending that he was admitted to the Yeshodha De-
addiction and Rehabilitation Centre at the relevant time. In
support of the said plea, the defence examined DWs.1 to
3. The Trial Court has considered their evidence and found
that, during cross-examination, they admitted that they
had gone to the Centre along with the mother of the
appellant only at about 4.30 p.m. to 5.00 p.m. to secure
admission for him and that the Centre had refused
admission as the appellant had consumed alcohol.
42. The evidence of PW.22, the Managing Director
of the said Centre, assumes significance in this regard. He
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
has stated that the appellant had been admitted to the
Centre on 21.05.2013 and was discharged on 21.07.2013.
He has further stated that during 2014 the appellant came
to the Centre along with three women and his brother for
the purpose of admission. However, as the appellant had
consumed alcohol and had not brought the admission fee,
he was not admitted to the Centre. He was advised to
approach a Government hospital and waited in the visiting
hall for some time. PW.22 has produced the register at
Ex.P.21 and stated that the appellant was not admitted to
the Centre during the year 2014.
43. The evidence of DWs.1 to 3, when considered in
the light of their admissions in cross-examination and the
evidence of PW.22 supported by Ex.P.21, does not
establish that the appellant was admitted to the Centre at
the time of the occurrence. On the contrary, the defence
evidence indicates that the appellant and the persons
accompanying him had approached the Centre only in the
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
evening to secure admission. The plea of alibi, therefore,
has not been established.
44. The defence has also suggested that the first
husband of the deceased, Marappa, had threatened the
deceased and was responsible for the occurrence.
However, no material has been brought on record to
substantiate the said suggestion. The mere fact that there
were differences between the deceased and her first
husband, or that he had allegedly threatened her, cannot
be treated as proof that he committed the offence. In the
absence of any supporting evidence, the said suggestion
does not create a reasonable doubt in the prosecution
case, particularly when the deceased herself is stated to
have identified the appellant as her assailant immediately
after the occurrence.
45. The appellant has further contended that the
witnesses have made material improvements and that the
Trial Court failed to consider the contradictions between
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
their testimony before the Court and their earlier
statements recorded by the police. We have considered
the said contention. It is true that the Trial Court has
described certain discrepancies as minor and has not
discussed each alleged contradiction separately. However,
every variation in the testimony of a witness would not
necessarily affect the credibility of the prosecution case.
What is required to be examined is whether the
discrepancy relates to a material circumstance bearing
upon the identity of the assailant or the manner of
occurrence.
46. In the present case, the core version of PWs.1
to 3, namely, that the deceased came out of the house
with bleeding injuries, identified the appellant as the
person who had stabbed her and that the appellant
emerged from the house holding a knife and fled from the
spot, remains consistent. The evidence of PWs.4 and 6
lends support to the circumstance that the deceased was
found injured immediately thereafter and was taken to the
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
hospital. The discrepancies referred to by the defence do
not, on the material placed before us, discredit the central
part of the prosecution version.
47. It is also contended that the prosecution has
not examined independent witnesses who could have
spoken about the actual occurrence. As already noticed,
there is no eyewitness to the act of stabbing. However, the
absence of an eyewitness is not fatal if the prosecution
establishes its case through reliable circumstantial
evidence. In the present case, the evidence of PWs.1 to 3
is not confined to the mere fact that the deceased was
found injured. They have also spoken about the statement
made by the deceased identifying the appellant and the
circumstance of the appellant emerging from the house
with a knife and fleeing from the spot. Their evidence is
supported by the medical evidence and the surrounding
circumstances. The evidence of the hostile witnesses, to
the extent it supports the factum of the deceased having
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
sustained injuries and being shifted to the hospital, can
also be taken into consideration.
48. On an overall consideration of the evidence, we
find that the circumstances established by the prosecution
are not isolated or disconnected circumstances. The
deceased was inside the house shortly before the
occurrence. Within a short time, she emerged with
bleeding injuries and immediately attributed the assault to
the appellant. PWs.1 to 3 saw the appellant coming out of
the same house holding a knife and fleeing after throwing
it. The medical evidence establishes that the deceased
sustained multiple ante-mortem stab injuries and died due
to shock resulting from those injuries. The forensic report
records the presence of human blood on the knife and
other articles seized during investigation. The plea that the
appellant was admitted to the de-addiction center at the
relevant time has not been established.
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
49. These circumstances, when considered
cumulatively, lend assurance to the prosecution case and
establish a close and proximate connection between the
appellant and the homicidal death of the deceased. The
possibility of the occurrence having been caused by some
other person is not supported by any material on record.
We are, therefore, of the view that the prosecution has
established beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant
was responsible for causing the fatal injuries to the
deceased.
50. The next question is whether the offence
established against the appellant would fall under Section
302 of IPC or whether the act would attract either of the
parts of Section 304 of IPC, as contended by the learned
counsel for the appellant.
51. The nature of the weapon used, the location of
the injuries and the manner in which the assault was
carried out are relevant considerations. The deceased
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
sustained several injuries, including multiple stab wounds
on the chest and back of the chest. The medical evidence
indicates that force was used in causing injuries Nos.2 to
4. The injuries were not confined to a single superficial
wound. The use of a knife to inflict repeated injuries on
vital parts of the body, particularly the chest,
demonstrates the intention to cause bodily injuries of such
nature as are likely to result in death.
52. There is no material on record to establish that
the occurrence took place in circumstances attracting any
of the exceptions to Section 300 of IPC. Though the
evidence indicates that the appellant and the deceased
used to quarrel, particularly when the appellant consumed
alcohol, there is no satisfactory material to establish that
the fatal assault was committed in the course of a sudden
fight, without premeditation, in the heat of passion and
without the appellant having taken undue advantage or
acted in a cruel or unusual manner. The mere fact that the
parties were involved in frequent quarrels would not, by
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62726-DB
CRL.A No. 2038 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010569122019
itself, bring the case within Exception 4 to Section 300 of
IPC. We are, therefore, unable to accept the submission
that the offence should be altered to one punishable under
Section 304(1) of IPC.
53. For the foregoing reasons, we find that the Trial
Court, on an appreciation of the evidence on record, has
rightly concluded that the prosecution has established the
charge against the appellant/accused. We find no reason
to interfere with the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence passed by the Trial Court.
dismissed.
54. Accordingly, the appeal is
Sd/-
(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(B.PRAMOD)
JUDGE
HB
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1