Ghanshyam Kulmi vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34935
1 WA-664-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE G. S. AHLUWALIA
&
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE ANURADHA SHUKLA
th
ON THE 17 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT APPEAL No. 664 of 2026
CNR No.: MPHC030057572026
GHANSHYAM KULMI
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Sanskar Sharma - Advocate for appellant.
Shri G.K. Agrawal - Govt. Advocate for respondent No. 1 / State.
Shri Gaurav Mishra - Advocate for respondent Nos. 2, 3, and 6.
Shri Sanjay Kumar Mishra - Advocate for respondent Nos. 4, 5, and 7.
ORDER
Per: Justice Gurpal Singh Ahluwalia
This writ appeal under Section 2(1) of Madhya Pradesh Uchcha
Nyayalaya (Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 has been filed
against the order dated 24/12/2025 passed by learned Single Judge in W.P.
No. 1226/2025, by which petition filed by appellant for extension of benefit
of old pension scheme has been dismissed.
2. It is the case of appellant that by order dated 15/7/1986, he was
temporarily appointed as Technical Assistant in the Operational Research
Project, Sidhi. Said project came to an end and accordingly, by order dated
20/1/1993, he was transferred in the same capacity to the post of Technical
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
5:48:20 PM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34935
2 WA-664-2026
Assistant (P.B.N.A.R.P.), College of Agriculture, Mandsaur. Thereafter, by

order dated 11/8/2004, he was engaged on contract basis on consolidated pay
of Rs. 17,000/- against the post of Training Organizer under Krishi Vigyan
Kendras and was posted at Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Khargone. Thereafter, by
order dated 22/1/2007, he was appointed temporarily to the post of Training
Associate (Agronomy) at Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Khargone. By order dated
16/6/2009, he was transferred to Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Rajgarh, which he
joined on 8/7/2009. Thereafter, by order dated 7/6/2011, he was transferred
to Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Aron (Guna) temporarily. By order dated
10/10/2016, on the recommendation of the Selection Committee and
approval of the Board of Management, appellant was appointed temporarily
by Rajmata Vijayaraje Scindia Krishi Vishwa Vidyalaya, Gwalior (in short
"RVSKVV") to the post of Programme Coordinator (Senior Scientist and
Head) under the Other Backward Class (Physically Handicapped) category
and was posted at Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Mandsaur. Thereafter, by order
dated 18/7/2018, he was posted at Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Khargone.
3. It is submitted by counsel for appellant that on 19/1/1995 he had
opted for Pension and Gratuity Scheme as well as Contributory Provident
Fund Scheme of Jawaharlal Nehru Krishi Vishwa Vidyalaya, Jabalpur (in
short "JNKVV") (Although counsel for appellant was trying to project that
the aforesaid option was for old pension scheme, but fairly conceded that by
that time new pension scheme had not come and, therefore, he fairly
conceded that it was only an option for Pension and Gratuity Scheme as well
as Contributory Provident Fund Scheme).
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
5:48:20 PM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34935
3 WA-664-2026
4. From the service book of appellant, it is also clear that the option

given by the appellant for JNKVV Service Pension Rules was accepted by
Vishwa Vvidyalaya vide order dated 16/2/1998. By order dated 1/2/2007, it
was directed by JNKVV that in view of the amendment carried out in the
Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976, it has been decided
that the said pension scheme, namely 'Paribhashit Anshdan Pension Pranali',
shall be made applicable to the employees who are appointed subsequent to
1/1/2005.
5. It is submitted by counsel for appellant that after the retirement of
appellant, he was not given the benefit of old pension scheme, but has been
given the benefit of new pension scheme. Therefore, he filed Writ Petition
No. 1226/2025, which has been dismissed by the learned Single Judge. It is
further submitted that not only appellant was appointed much prior to
1/1/2005, but he had also opted for old pension scheme.
6 . Per contra, appeal is vehemently opposed by counsel for
respondents. It is submitted that earlier the appellant was working in different
projects introduced by JNKVV. After the bifurcation of said University,
RVSKVV came into existence, and appellant was temporarily appointed to
the post of Programme Coordinator (Senior Scientist and Head) under OBC
(Physically Handicapped) category. It is submitted that the learned Single
Judge has rightly held that appellant was appointed after 1/1/2005 and,
therefore, he is not entitled for old pension scheme.
7. Considered the submissions made by counsel for parties.
8. The learned Single Judge, while deciding the case of appellant, has
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
5:48:20 PM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34935
4 WA-664-2026
elaborately dealt with the nature of services rendered by the appellant.

Initially, appellant was appointed in a project at Sidhi as well as Mandsaur,
which were being run with the aid of Indian Council for Agricultural
Research (in short "ICAR"). Certain persons working in projects sponsored
by ICAR in JNKVV approached this Court seeking regularization of their
service. The High Court allowed their writ petition, which was assailed by
JNKVV before the Supreme Court in the case of Jawaharlal Nehru Krishi
Vishwavidyalaya vs. Bal Kishan Soni and Ors.. The Supreme Court allowed
the SLP filed by JNKVV and, by its judgment reported in (1997) 5 SCC 86,
and held as under:
"2. This appeal by special leave arises from the order of the High Court of
Madhya Pradesh passed in Miscellaneous Petition No. 2935 of 1986 on 9-
2-1995 and the order passed in review petition (MCC No. 461 of 1995)
dated 12-7-1996. On a Scheme sponsored by the Indian Council of
Agricultural Research, the appellant Institute had taken up the Project. As
many as 625 posts were created in different scales. The respondents while
working as Binders, Machine Operators and Class IV employees
respectively in the regular pay scales of Rs 750-945, filed a writ petition in
the High Court for regularisation of their service. By the impugned order,
the High Court allowed the writ petition. Feeling aggrieved, the appellant
Institute has filed this appeal by special leave.
3. It is not in dispute that the Scheme is sponsored by the Indian Council
of Agricultural Research and, therefore, permanent posts cannot be
created. The posts are coterminous with the Scheme. On abolition of the
Scheme, the posts also necessarily stand abolished. We are informed that
the Scheme may continue to be in force; but it depends upon the Scheme
being sponsored and the posts made available by the Indian Council of
Agricultural Research. Therefore, the direction to regularise the services is
violative of their right to posts. The order of the High Court to that extent
is modified. On whatever posts the respondents are working and
discharging their duty, the scale of pay of the said post is directed to be
paid."
Accordingly, the learned Single Judge came to a conclusion that in
absence of any material to show otherwise, it has to be held that the services
rendered by the appellant with effect from 15/7/1986 cannot be counted
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
5:48:20 PM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34935
5 WA-664-2026
towards pensionary benefits.

9. Thereafter, appellant was appointed as Training Organizer vide
order dated 11/8/2004 on contract basis. After taking note of Clause 3(b) and
3(g) of the appointment order, it was held that the appointment of appellant
was purely a contract engagement for a maximum period not exceeding 3
years or till the completion of the project, whichever is earlier. Accordingly,
appellant was not entitled to employer's share for Contributory Provident
Fund benefit, pensionary benefits or gratuity, etc., and it was held by the
learned Single Judge that services rendered by the appellant on the post of
Training Organizer was not accountable towards the pensionary benefits.
10. Thereafter, appellant was appointed as Training Associate vide
order dated 22/1/2007. According to this appointment order, his appointment
was on probation for a period of 2 years and appellant was to be governed by
New Pension Scheme. Appellant accepted these terms and conditions of
appointment without demur and continued as such till 2023 when for the first
time he raised his claim for benefit of the Old Pension Scheme. Thus, it was
held that right from 22/1/2007 appellant was aware that he is governed by
New Pension Scheme and not by Old Pension Scheme.
11. After his appointment as Technical Associate (Agronomy),
appellant himself submitted his option under the New Pension Scheme
wherein his date of appointment is mentioned as 27/1/2007. Accordingly, it
was also held that once the appellant has voluntarily and willingly accepted
the benefit of New Pension Scheme, then the same cannot be challenged.
12. The contention of appellant that the submission of option and
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
5:48:20 PM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34935
6 WA-664-2026
filling of forms under New Pension Scheme were under compulsion and

pressure was also not accepted by the learned Single Judge.
13. The counsel for appellant could not point out any perversity in the
order passed by the learned Single Judge.
14. The Supreme Court in the case of R. Saravanan vs. Periyar
University Rep by its Registrar & Ors., decided on 16.10.2026 in Civil
Appeal No. .... of 2026 (Arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.
4216 of 2020), has held as under:
"28. However, the jurisdiction of the Letters Patent Bench to interfere
with the concurrent findings of fact should not be understood as if the
Letters Patent Bench can interfere in every matter because it is exercising
the powers of the appellate Court. The jurisdiction of the Letters Patent
Bench to examine a question of fact is not without fetters. The Letters
Patent Bench can be justified in reopening a question of fact if it
necessarily touches upon the merits of the case and is likely to have a
bearing on the decision in the case. It may be argued that the Letters
Patent Bench of the High Court is entitled to review findings of fact. But
what is necessary to keep in mind is that there is an inherent limitation on
exercise of powers by the appellate Bench. This is one of the well settled
legal principles that the appellate Court should not interfere with the
judgment of the Court of first instance unless a clear mistake which will
change the outcome of the case is found to have been committed by the
Court. The Letters Patent Bench should ordinarily be slow and refrain
from interfering with the discretion exercised by the writ Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution. A Letters Patent Bench sitting as a Court
of Correction exercises the same jurisdiction as is vested in the Single
Judge but the Letters Patent Bench is required to give due weight to the
decision of the writ Court where it has exercised its discretion on relevant
considerations.
29. There may be different situations and the aggrieved party may raise
a host of grounds before the Letters Patent Bench. Some of the grounds
may be based on a question of law and the other may be just a question of
fact. The aggrieved party may also raise issues pertaining to appreciation
of evidence. But the Letters Patent Bench can interfere in the matter only
where the findings are demonstrably erroneous and the mistake is glaring
on the face of record. There must exist cogent grounds and such grounds
are not projected on some minor mistake in the judgment under challenge.
The Letters Patent Bench is not entitled to interfere with the decision of
writ Court on mere showing of some error of fact or in law. If the decision
rendered by the writ Court in exercise of the powers under Article 226 of
the Constitution is in furtherance of justice, equity and good conscience
and is not against public policy then the Letters Patent Bench constituted
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
5:48:20 PM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34935
7 WA-664-2026
under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent of Madras High Court or similar
provisions of the Letters Patent of other High Courts cannot exercise its
appellate jurisdiction under the Letters Patent to interfere with the writ
Court’s decision. Simply put, the Letters Patent Bench can not interfere
with the decision rendered by the writ Court which is otherwise just and
reasonable."

15. As no illegality could be pointed out by counsel for appellant,
accordingly, no case is made out warranting interference.
16. The appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.
(G. S. AHLUWALIA)
(ANURADHA SHUKLA)
JUDGE
JUDGE
AKS
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
5:48:20 PM