Moniveda Consultants Llp vs Shajas Developers Private Limited

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 226
NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


CIVIL APPEAL NOS.9052–9053 OF 2022

MONIVEDA CONSULTANTS LLP AND
ANOTHER

… APPELLANTS

VERSUS

SHAJAS DEVELOPERS PRIVATE
LIMITED AND OTHERS

…RESPONDENTS

WITH

CONTEMPT PETITION (C) NOS.616–617 OF 2023

AND

CONTEMPT PETITION (C) NOS.641–642 OF 2025



O R D E R

AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J .

1. The present Appeals are directed against the
order dated 11.10.2022 (“Impugned Order”)
passed by the National Company Law Appellate
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
Tribunal, New Delhi (“NCLAT”), in Company
RAJNI MUKHI
Date: 2026.03.11
17:22:50 IST
Reason:
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 1 of 17

Appeal (AT) No.104 of 2021 along with
Contempt Case (AT) No.02 of 2022, whereby the
NCLAT set aside the order dated 29.07.2021
passed by the National Company Law Tribunal,
Mumbai Bench (“NCLT”) declining interim relief
in CA Nos.147 and 199 of 2021 in CP
No.159(MB) of 2021, but confined interim
protection to a direction restraining the parties
from taking any “perceptive steps” for a period
not exceeding one month, and further directed
that the contempt proceedings be heard by the
NCLT.

2. The Appellant No.1, Moniveda Consultants LLP
(formerly Gauri Rajeshwari Consultants Pvt.
Ltd.), claims to be a 40% shareholder of
Respondent No.1, Shajas Developers Private
Limited. The Appellant No.2 is a partner of
Appellant No.1 and was appointed as a
Promoter-Director of Respondent No.2, JLS
Realty Private Limited. Respondent No.1 is a
holding company which holds the entire share
capital of Respondent No.2. Respondent No.2 is
engaged in the business of slum redevelopment
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 2 of 17

and owns land admeasuring approximately
21,727 square metres situated at Shankarwadi,
Jogeshwari (East), Mumbai, along with
attendant development rights, stated to be
valued at approximately Rs. 1000 crores. Mr.
Suketu Viren Shah, Respondent No.3 is the
personal guarantor of certain loans secured by
the Respondent No.2 and alleged mastermind to
usurp the Appellant’s assets in Respondent
No.2, he is alleged to have full control over
Respondent No.4, Neelakantan Krishnan Iyer
and Respondent No.5, Mangesh Pandurang
Kadam, who are the shareholders of
Respondent No.1.

3. Respondent No.2 was incorporated in February
2008, and Respondent No.1 was incorporated
on 29.07.2009. In 2009, Meshulam Levinstein
Contracting and Engineering Ltd., an Israeli
entity, entered as a strategic joint venture
partner in Respondent No.2. As on July 2009,
Respondent No.1 held 35.92% of the
shareholding of Respondent No.2, while the
Levinstein Group held 64.08%, with a six-
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 3 of 17

member board comprising equal representation
from both sides.

4. Between 2013 and 2016, Respondent No.2
borrowed substantial sums from IIFL Finance
Limited, an NBFC, with total outstanding
liabilities aggregating to approximately Rs. 275
crores as on 31.03.2016. Respondent No.3
furnished personal guarantees in respect of
such borrowings. The project encountered
serious financial and operational distress,
including encroachments, lack of approvals,
and inability to launch sales.


5. In May 2016, Appellant No.2 claimed to have
assisted in negotiating the exit of the Israeli joint
venture partner. By a Securities Purchase
Agreement dated 06.05.2016, the Levinstein
Group exited Respondent No.2 by selling its
64.08% stake to Respondent No.1 for
approximately Rs. 1.2 crores. Consequently,
Respondent No.2 became a wholly owned
subsidiary of Respondent No.1.

C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 4 of 17

6. On the same date i.e. 06.05.2016, Appellant
No.1 entered into arrangements for acquisition
of the entire shareholding of Respondent No.1
in two tranches. Pursuant thereto, Respondent
Nos.4 and 5 handed over 4,000 equity share
certificates of Respondent No.1 along with
signed share transfer forms (SH-4) in favour of
Appellant No.1. The Appellant No.1 agreed to
undertake the responsibility of all present and
future liabilities of Respondent No.2 by entering
into Side Letter dated 06.05.2016. Appellant
No.2 was inducted into the board of Respondent
No.2 as an Additional Director on 23.05.2016,
and his appointment was confirmed at the
Annual General Meeting held on 30.09.2016.

7. It is inter alia the case of Appellants that
between 2016 and 2019, the project is stated to
have been revived under the management of
Appellant No.2. Statutory approvals were
obtained, encumbrances were cleared, slum
rehabilitation buildings were constructed, and
the loan availed from IIFL was fully repaid by
31.03.2018. Respondent No.2 entered into a
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 5 of 17

Joint Development Agreement with Respondent
No.11, Spenta Suncity Private Limited in May
2016, which was subsequently terminated by
mutual consent on 10.12.2019.

8. The Appellants claim that between December
2019 and January 2021, associate entities of
the Appellants infused approximately Rs. 55
crores into Respondent No.2. During this
period, further regulatory approvals were
obtained, and the project value is stated to have
significantly appreciated. It is alleged that
during the same period, Respondent No.3 was
facing acute personal financial distress owing to
defaults exceeding Rs. 73 crores in another
venture, resulting in restraint orders passed by
the Bombay High Court on 10.12.2020.

9. On 01.02.2021, the Appellant No.1 received a
notice of default from IDBI Trusteeship claiming
that Spenta Suncity Private Limited had
obtained a loan of Rs. 240 crores from IDBI
Trusteeship and 39,73,636 shares of
Respondent No.2 were pledged for the said loan.
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 6 of 17

The Appellants contended that the pledge was
only for 100,000 shares which is only 3% of
shares of Respondent No.2. On 12.02.2021,
notice of sale was issued by IDBI Trusteeship.

10. On 01.03.2021, Appellant No.2 claims to have
discovered that a revised Form MGT-7 for the
financial year 2017-18 had been filed by
Respondent No.1, whereby the entire 40%
shareholding of Appellant No.1 was removed,
reflecting Respondent Nos.4 and 5 as the sole
shareholders. Along with this revised form was
annexed a clarificatory note alleging that name
of Appellant No.1 was erroneously shown in
earlier annual returns filed on 27.01.2021. The
revised filing bore a digital signature timestamp
dated 01.03.2021, though it purported to relate
back to 05.09.2018.

11. On 11.03.2021, Appellant No.2 received an
intimation from the Registrar of Companies
regarding the filing of DIR-12 forms reflecting
the appointment of Respondent Nos.6 and 7 as
Additional Directors of Respondent No.2,
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 7 of 17

purportedly pursuant to an Extraordinary
General Meeting (“EGM”) dated 24.02.2021.
Appellant No.2 asserted that no notice of such
meeting was ever served, no board meeting was
held to convene the EGM, and the statutory
requirements under Section 100 of the
Companies Act, 2013 were not complied with.

12. On 08.04.2021, the Registrar of Companies
alerted Appellant No.2 regarding an attempt to
file DIR-12 forms showing his removal as
Director of Respondent No.2, purportedly
pursuant to an EGM dated 13.03.2021. The
said filing was rejected by the Registrar on
account of deficiencies.

13. On 04.05.2021, the Appellants instituted
Company Petition No.159(MB) of 2021
(“Company Petition”) before the NCLT, Mumbai
Bench, under Sections 241, 242, 244 and 59 of
the Companies Act, 2013, alleging oppression
and mismanagement, fabrication of statutory
filings, illegal induction of directors, and
imminent stripping of assets. Interim reliefs
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 8 of 17

were sought to restrain further alienation of
assets and changes in management.

14. The NCLT, by an order dated 29.07.2021
declined to grant interim relief, observing that it
was not inclined to pass any interim orders at
that stage.


15. Aggrieved thereby, the Appellants preferred
Company Appeal (AT) No.104 of 2021 before the
NCLAT on 02.09.2021. During the pendency of
the appeal, it is alleged that Respondent No.2
executed a conveyance deed dated 08.09.2021
in favour of Spenta Suncity Private Limited in
respect of the entire project land, followed by
execution of an Indenture of Mortgage dated
09.09.2021 securing a loan of Rs. 525 crores
availed by Spenta.

16. On 22.10.2021, the NCLAT passed an interim
order directing the parties not to take any
“perceptive steps” in the subject matter.
Despite the said order, further actions were
alleged to have been taken to transfer
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 9 of 17

development rights and alter the management
structure of Respondent No.2.

17. On 11.01.2022, the Appellants filed Contempt
Case (AT) No.02 of 2022 before the NCLAT
alleging willful disobedience of the interim
orders. On 22.07.2022, the NCLAT
strengthened the interim protection by directing
maintenance of status quo and restraining
transfer of redevelopment rights.


18. Ultimately by impugned order dt. 11.10.2022,
the NCLAT set aside the NCLT’s order dated
29.07.2021 and remanded the matter for fresh
consideration. However, interim protection was
confined to a restraint against “perceptive steps”
for a further period of one month, and the
contempt proceedings were directed to be heard
by the NCLT.

19. In these circumstances, the Appellants have
approached this Court, contending that unless
status quo ante is restored and meaningful
interim protection is granted, Respondent Nos.1
and 2 would stand reduced to shell companies.
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 10 of 17

20. On perusal of the material produced on record
it is to be noted that the present appeals arise
at an interlocutory stage, the substantive
Company Petition instituted by the Appellants
under Sections 241, 242, 244 and 59 of the
Companies Act, 2013 remains pending
consideration before the NCLT, Mumbai Bench.
The controversy before this Court, therefore, is
confined to the nature and scope of interim
protection necessary to preserve the subject
matter of the dispute until the adjudication of
the main proceedings.


21. It is in this context that the sequence of orders
passed by this Court during the pendency of the
present proceedings assumes relevance.

22. By order dated 16.12.2022, while entertaining
the present Appeals, this Court granted interim
relief in terms of clause (vi) of paragraph 17 of
the impugned order effectively extending the
direction to the parties to not take any
“perceptive steps” in the subject matter. At the
same time, it was clarified that the proceedings
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 11 of 17

before the NCLT would continue and that there
was no stay of the Company Petition pending
before it. The purpose of the interim
arrangement was, therefore, to ensure that the
subject matter of the dispute remained
protected while permitting the statutory forum
to proceed with the adjudication of the petition.

23. Subsequently, developments were brought to
the notice of this Court indicating that Spenta
Suncity Private Limited, in whose favour the
project land had been conveyed, had been
admitted into corporate insolvency resolution
process under Section 7 of the Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016 on 10.07.2024, and
that an Interim Resolution Professional (“IRP”)
had been appointed. In view of these
developments, this Court by order dated
15.07.2024, after impleading the concerned
entity through its IRP as Respondent No.11,
directed that no construction be carried out on
the property which forms the subject matter of
the present proceedings. The restraint was
intended to ensure that no irreversible changes
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 12 of 17

were made to the project land while the dispute
regarding the underlying corporate control and
transactions remained unresolved.

24. Thereafter, certain applications were moved
before this Court placing on record photographs
depicting excavation pits and expressing
apprehension regarding the safety of adjoining
structures. In order to ascertain the factual
position, this Court by order dated 14.10.2024
directed the concerned officer of the Slum
Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) to inspect the
site and inform the Court regarding the
measures, if any, required to be taken for
protecting the adjacent buildings. While issuing
the said direction, this Court clarified that any
such measures were to be short of permitting
construction of the rehabilitation building.

25. Pursuant thereto, and only with a view to
safeguarding the structural stability of the
neighbouring buildings, this Court by order
dated 25.10.2024 permitted to undertake
limited protective works, namely the laying of
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 13 of 17

foundation in the excavated pits, construction
of retaining walls, backfilling and necessary
barricading of the adjoining area. The
permission was expressly made subject to
obtaining approvals from the competent
authorities, and it was further clarified that the
grant of such limited permission would not
create any equity in favour of the applicant.

26. During the pendency of these Appeals, the
Appellants have also instituted Contempt
Petition (C) Nos.616–617 of 2023 and Contempt
Petition (C) Nos.641–642 of 2025, alleging
violation of the interim directions issued by this
Court, including allegations that certain
construction activities, registration of the
project with regulatory authorities and
marketing of units to prospective purchasers
were undertaken despite the restraint orders.
The Respondents have disputed these
allegations. The said allegations have been
controverted by the Respondents and remaining
matters require factual determination.

C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 14 of 17

27. At this stage, we do not consider it necessary to
enter into the merits of the allegations raised in
the contempt petitions. Suffice it to observe that
the project land constitutes the principal asset
connected with the dispute between the parties,
and the Company Petition raising allegations of
oppression and mismanagement continues to
remain pending before the NCLT, Mumbai
Bench. In such circumstances, the paramount
consideration is to ensure that the subject
matter of the proceedings is preserved until the
competent forum adjudicates the dispute.

28. Having regard to the sequence of orders passed
by this Court and the limited nature of the
dispute presently before us, we are of the
considered view that the interim arrangement
which has been operating pursuant to the
earlier orders of this Court ought to continue
until the competent forum finally adjudicates
the underlying controversy.

29. Accordingly, it is directed that the parties shall
maintain status quo in terms of the earlier
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 15 of 17

orders passed by this Court, and no steps shall
be taken which would alter the nature of the
property or create further third-party interests
therein. The impugned order dated 11.10.2022
passed by the NCLAT is modified in above terms
and shall continue to operate till the disposal of
the Company Petition.

30. We, therefore, direct the NCLT, Mumbai Bench
to proceed with the pending matters between
the parties to the lis making an endeavour to
decide the same expeditiously. Parties to these
appeals are directed to appear before National
Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai Bench on
19.03.2026. The Company Petition No.159(MB)
of 2021, in particular, shall preferably be
decided within a period of two months from the
date of appearance of the parties. All
contentions of the parties on merits are left open
to be considered by the NCLT.

31. These Appeals and Contempt Petitions stand
disposed of in the above terms.

C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 16 of 17

32. Before parting, we make it clear that in the light
of the above order passed by us, any
observations made in the Appeals, and the
contempt proceedings, shall not be taken as
expression of opinion on merits relating to
assertions/counter-assertions made by the
parties.

33. Pending application(s), if any, also stands
disposed of.


34. Copy of this order be forthwith conveyed to
National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, New
Delhi and National Company Law Tribunal,
Mumbai Bench for information and compliance.

.……..………..……………………..J.
[ DIPANKAR DATTA ]


.……..………..……………………..J.
[ AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH ]


NEW DELHI;
MARCH 11, 2026.
C.A. Nos.9052-9053/2022 Page 17 of 17