Deeplaxmi Co Operativew Housing Society Limited vs Hare Krishna Builders
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM020280672025
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
Digitally
signed by
CHAITANYA
ASHOK
JADHAV
Date:
2026.11.19
17:17:15
+0530
CHAITANYA
ASHOK
JADHAV
ARBITRATION PETITION (L) NO. 28067 OF 2025
Deeplaxmi Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. & Anr. … Petitioners
Versus
Hare Krishna Builders & Ors. … Respondents
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 7934 OF 2025
IN
ARBITRATION PETITION (L) NO. 28067 OF 2025
Tarabai Rajaram Waradkar … Applicant
Through legal heir Sachin Chipkar
In the matter between:
Deeplaxmi Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. & Anr. … Petitioners
Versus
Hare Krishna Builders & Ors. … Respondents
Mr. Ashish Kamat, Senior Advocate a/w Mr. Nishant Tripathi, Ms.
Sonali Humane, Mr. Pranav Vaidya, i/b Ms. Ranjana Todankar, for
Petitioners.
Mr. Vikram Garewal a/w Mr. Mangesh Sawant, for Applicant in
IA/7934/2025.
Mr. Karl Tamboly a/w Mr. Aadil Parsurampuria, Ms. Dhwani
Mehta Desai, for Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 in ARBPL/28067/2025.
Mr. Aseem Naphade i/b Anita Murgude, for Respondent Nos. 7 to
20, 22 to 28 and 30.
Page 1 of 26
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
CORAM: SOMASEKHAR SUNDARESAN, J.
RESERVED ON: DECEMBER 19, 2025
PRONOUNCED ON: NOVEMBER 19, 2026
JUDGEMENT :
Context and Factual Background:
1. The captioned Petition is an appeal under Section 37(2)(b) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (“ Arbitration Act ”) by which the
Petitioner No. 1, Deeplaxmi Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. (“ Society ”)
along with an individual member, challenges the order dated April 4, 2025
(“ Impugned Order ”) of a Learned Sole Arbitrator (“ Arbitrator ”), passed
under Section 17 of the Arbitration Act. The Impugned Order was
communicated to the Society only on September 3, 2025.
2. The Society has 322 members. It was formed out of four chawls (Nos. 13
to 16) at Agripada, Mumbai, on land owned by the Brihanmumbai Municipal
Corporation (“ BMC ”). By 2005, the chawls were dilapidated. On December 5,
2005, the four chawl societies executed Development Agreements (“ 2005
DA ”) with the predecessor of Hare Krishna Builders (“ HK Builders ”). The
members vacated their premises between 2006 and 2008 and moved into
transit accommodation.
Page 2 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
3. The BMC issued a Letter of Intent in 2007 for redevelopment under
Development Control Regulation 33(7) and sanctioned the plans in 2008. The
agreements contain an arbitration clause.
4. The narratives diverge after 2012. The Society says that the project was
abandoned after about 60% of the RCC work was completed. HK Builders says
that work continued until 2016, when it was obstructed at site. The Society
issued a show cause notice on March 12, 2016. The BMC did so on January 22,
2018.
5. On January 22, 2019, the four chawl societies and the Society executed a
Rectification cum Supplementary Deed with HK Builders (“ 2019 SDA ”).
Clause 11 is central to the question of delay and is extracted verbatim , below:
“(11) The Developer agree and assure the society that they will complete the
balance of the redevelopment process within 24 months from the date from
which the society permits the Developer to start work again or from the date
of receipt of full commencement certificate. The parties also agree that the
said time period to complete the work is subject to force majeure clause and
there will be a grace period of 6 months beyond the above time limit in
circumstances beyond of the parties control. It is also agreed that the said
time limit will be also the subject to phase wise shifting of the eligible
members from the transit camp to the permanent alternate accommodation in
timely manner by the society since as on date many of the members are
occupying the completed rehabilitation component flats in the same project as
transit accommodation.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
Page 3 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
6. Clauses 5, 8, 14 and 17 of the 2019 SDA are relevant to the breaches
alleged. Clause 5 required a performance guarantee of Rs. 1 crore in three
instalments. It is alleged that only Rs. 75 lakhs had been provided. Clause 8
earmarked flats worth Rs. 12 crores as security for the corpus fund. It is
alleged that the flats were mortgaged to a finance company. Clause 14 imposed
the obligation to pay property taxes on HK Builders. It is alleged that
municipal authorities raised a property tax demand of over Rs. 11 crores,
which remains unpaid, risking attachment of the property for recovery of the
tax. Clause 17 barred any transfer of rights to a third party without the
Society’s previous permission. It is alleged that the induction of new partners
to the extent of 80% is nothing but a transfer of rights in the garb of a
reconstitution.
7. COVID-19 struck in March 2020. According to the Society, it issued a
show cause notice on February 14, 2021 and a legal notice on March 13, 2021.
On December 6, 2021, HK Builders inducted Mr. Irfan Mitha and Mr. Shakeel
Siddiqui as partners (“ New Partners ”) with an 80% share. An Extraordinary
General Meeting held on August 7, 2022 is disputed. On March 10, 2023, 96
members sought a Special General Meeting to remove HK Builders and
appoint a new developer.
Page 4 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
8. HK Builders had filed a petition under Section 9 of the Arbitration Act
on July 17, 2023 (numbered Arbitration Petition No. 207 of 2024). The Society
issued a show cause notice to HK Builders on July 25, 2023. On August 10,
2023, a Learned Single Judge declined to restrain HK Builders and directed
that the decision of the General Body be placed before the Section 9 Court and
that no termination notice be issued without the same being placed before the
Section 9 Court.
9. A Special General Meeting held on September 10, 2023 is said to have
resolved to terminate HK Builders and appoint Shubham Lifespaces. The
Society wrote to the BMC on October 11, 2023 and November 6, 2023 to
process the change of developer.
10. On December 14, 2023, another Learned Single Judge passed an order
restraining the Society from issuing a termination notice pursuant to the
resolution, until the next date (collectively, along with the order dated August
10, 2023, “ Holding Order ”). On March 27, 2024, an independent architect,
Mr. Avinash Pendse, was appointed by the Section 9 Court in view of
conflicting claims by the parties about the extent of completion of work. The
architect conducted an inspection on April 3, 2024 and submitted his report,
which the Court took note of on April 18, 2024.
Page 5 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
11. On July 23, 2024, another Learned Single Judge passed an order
(“ Reference Order ”) referring the disputes to arbitration and the Section 9
Petition came to be treated as an application under Section 17. Paragraph 5 of
the Reference Order reads thus:
“5. Given that this is a redevelopment and there is anxiety on both sides of
some urgency, the Learned Arbitrator is requested to dispose of Section 17
Petition as expeditiously as possible preferably within a period of two weeks
from today. Interim orders passed to continue till such date. Needless to state
that the Learned Tribunal will decide the Section 17 Petition uninfluenced by
the interim orders passed in this Petition.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
12. On the status of the site, the architect reports that there are five wings.
Wings A, C and D stand at 16 floors, Wing B at 6 and Wing E at 12. Even on the
Society’s showing, 252 of the 300 sanctioned flats are built. The Society says
that 33% of the RCC work is yet to start. HK Builders says that 80% of the
work is done and that 12 to 15 months will suffice to complete it.
Impugned Order:
13. The findings in the Impugned Order may be summarised thus:
A] A change in the constitution of HK Builders is no ground for
termination. The contracts do not prohibit it. The Society was kept
informed and prima facie there is a waiver;
Page 6 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
B] Delay is the serious issue. It was examined by reference to Clause
11, force majeure and the rule that time is not of the essence in a
1
construction contract;
C] The 2019 SDA is “a complete answer” to defaults prior to its
execution. Instances of obstruction, whether the August 7, 2022 meeting
was valid, waiver, and loss of confidence would need to await trial;
D] The Society is “a house divided” and the case falls in Category 3 of
2
Rajawadi Arunodaya , a judgement that was invoked by the Society
to contend that it has lost confidence in HK Builders;
E] Termination would leave HK Builders with only a money claim.
The Holding Order is the status quo ante ; and
F] HK Builders’ statements on instructions are accepted as
undertakings to the Tribunal, and a conditional order, narrower than
the prayers, is appropriate.
14. The operative directions are:
1
Hind Construction Contracts v. State of Maharashtra, (1979) 2 SCC 70, paras 8 and 9, cited
at footnote 21 of the Impugned Order; and S. Brahmanand & Ors. v. K R Muthugopal,
(2005) 12 SCC 764, cited at ¶ 7.1.17; Viraj Kamman Real Estate Developers Pvt. Ltd. v.
Gopal Terrace CHSL, 2023 SCC OnLine Bom 904, cited at ¶ 7.1.20 of the Impugned Order,
concerns Section 14 of the Specific Relief Act.
2
Rajawadi Arunodaya CHSL v. Value Projects Pvt. Ltd., 2021 SCC OnLine Bom 9572, paras
52 to 54.
Page 7 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
“10.2 The statements made by HK Builders set out in para 9.6 above are
accepted as undertakings to the Tribunal.
10.3 HK Builders shall set aside the flats mentioned above, admeasuring
altogether 5000 sq ft from the free sale component as security for (i) payment
of corpus contribution and (ii) performance completion until part occupation
certificates are received for the rehab component.
10.4 The Society and its members are not to obstruct or hinder the
development work by HK Builders in any way.
10.5 The Society is not to act in furtherance of its 10 September 2023 SGM
and is not to terminate the 2005 DA or the 2019 SDA.
10.6 The office bearers of the Society shall sign such documents as may be
required to enable HK Builders to obtain further permissions.
10.7 The Society shall immediately write to the BMC asking it to keep in
abeyance its letters of 11 October 2023 and 6 November 2023.
10.8 HK Builders shall adhere to the timelines set out above, to be
computed from 19 November 2024, the date of the signed written submission.
10.9 If 71 units in Wing A and 79 units in Wing B are not completed by 18
November 2025 despite all cooperation from the Society, this order shall
immediately stand vacated and the Society shall be fully at liberty to proceed
with issuing a termination letter, appointing a new developer and reviving its
applications to the BMC.
10.10 Equally, a failure by the Society to comply with the directions to sign
documents and to write to the BMC shall result in a pro rata extension of time
to HK Builders.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
Page 8 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
Contentions of the Parties:
15. Against this backdrop, I have heard at length, Mr. Ashish Kamat,
Learned Advocate on behalf of the Society, Mr. Karl Tamboly, Learned
Advocate on behalf of HK Builders and Mr. Aseem Naphade, Learned
Advocate on behalf of Respondent Nos. 7 to 20, 22 to 28 and 30, who would
submit that 130 members of the Society support the Petition. With their
assistance, I have examined the voluminous material the parties have brought
on record before the Learned Arbitral Tribunal.
16. The Society contends that:
A] The Arbitrator wrongly treated the Holding Order as the baseline
and required the Society to dislodge it, contrary to paragraph 5 of the
Reference Order ( extracted above );
B] The finding of a prima facie case is perverse. Work done before
2016 is used as a shield. There is no appreciable progress since the 2019
SDA. The claim of “80%” is false;
C] The mortgage of the Clause 8 flats on May 15, 2019, tax dues of
over Rs. 11 crores and the clandestine transfer of control to the New
Partners were ignored;
D] Loss of trust was left for trial though the contract is personal and
cannot be specifically enforced;
Page 9 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
E] Balance of convenience and irreparable harm lie in the Society’s
favour; and
F] In its written submissions of December 17, 2025, the Society adds
that a “with prejudice” offer was converted into binding terms, thereby
rewriting the contract. The Society has also made submissions on the
basis of the delay in communicating the Impugned Order.
17. HK Builders contends that:
A] The scope of Section 37 is extremely limited. Indeed 80% of the
work is completed, 252 flats are built, permissions are in place and Rs.
150 crores has been invested;
B] The 2019 SDA truly cures the pre-2019 defaults. Time is not of the
3
essence. The Clause 11 period was never triggered since the full
commencement certificate and the Society’s no objection certificate
were not available. Obstruction at site, recorded in a 32-item table,
caused delay;
C] The New Partners were invited by the members. The change in
constitution was waived. HK Builders paid Rs. 40 lakhs towards
property tax, had the BMC’s regularisation demand reduced from Rs. 9
3
Hind Construction Contracts v. State of Maharashtra, (1979) 2 SCC 70.
Page 10 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
crores to Rs. 3.83 crores and furnished a bank guarantee of Rs. 25 lakhs;
and
D] The Society has not shown authority from its 322 members to
appeal. A letter of September 6, 2025 from 160 members supports HK
Builders.
Points for Determination:
18. The grounds of challenge give rise to the following Points for
Determination:
A] Did the Arbitrator wrongly use the Holding Order as the baseline
in a manner contrary to Paragraph 5 of the Reference Order;
B] Is the finding of a prima facie case on the pre-2016 work, the
post-2019 position and the “80%” claim, open to interference;
C] Is the finding of a prima facie case, on the mortgage, the tax dues,
the transfer of control and the August 2022 waiver, open to
interference;
D] Is the treatment of loss of trust open to interference;
E] Was the Petition duly authorised by the Society; and
F] Do the with-prejudice offer accepted by the Arbitrator and the
delay in communicating the Impugned Order warrant interference.
Page 11 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
Analysis and Findings:
19. Each of these points is dealt with below, bearing in mind the scope of
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 37 of the Arbitration Act. In a
nutshell, it must be remembered that the Section 37 Court must not substitute
the wisdom of a Learned Arbitral Tribunal only because another view is
possible but it has to consider whether the Learned Arbitral Tribunal being the
best judge of the matter in hand has taken a view that is perverse and
untenable, warranting intervention.
Standard of Review:
20. It is well settled law that an appeal (and this would include appeals
under Section 37 of the Arbitration Act) is to be regarded as a continuation of
the original proceeding, and unless there is a statutory requirement to the
contrary, the powers of the appellate forum are co-extensive with the power of
4
a forum whose adjudication is under appeal - in this case the Section 17
jurisdiction of the Learned Arbitral Tribunal. Therefore, it is well settled that
when this Court exercises its jurisdiction under Section 37 of the Arbitration
Act its power may be exercised in the same manner in which power was
exercisable under Section 17 of the Arbitration Act.
4
Jute Corporation of India Ltd. v. CIT, (1991) Supp (2) SCC 744
Page 12 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
21. Equally, an appellate Court exercising its power under Section 37 of the
Arbitration Act to review the exercise of discretion by an Arbitral Tribunal is
well guided by the principles set out by the Supreme Court in Wander vs.
5
Antox . The Section 37 Court may interfere only if there is something
perverse or implausible in the exercise of discretion. The following extract
would suffice:
14. The appeals before the Division Bench were against the exercise of discretion by
the Single Judge. In such appeals, the appellate court will not interfere with the
exercise of discretion of the court of first instance and substitute its own discretion
except where the discretion has been shown to have been exercised arbitrarily, or
capriciously or perversely or where the court had ignored the settled principles of
law regulating grant or refusal of interlocutory injunctions. An appeal against
exercise of discretion is said to be an appeal on principle. Appellate court will not
reassess the material and seek to reach a conclusion different from the one reached
by the court below if the one reached by that court was reasonably possible on the
material. The appellate court would normally not be justified in interfering with the
exercise of discretion under appeal solely on the ground that if it had considered the
matter at the trial stage it would have come to a contrary conclusion. If the
discretion has been exercised by the trial court reasonably and in a judicial manner
the fact that the appellate court would have taken a different view may not justify
interference with the trial court's exercise of discretion.
[Emphasis Supplied]
22. In a plethora of judgements, the principle articulated in Wander vs.
Antox has been followed and reiterated. Interference is thus confined to
5
Wander Ltd. & Anr. v. Antox India (P) Ltd., (1990) Supp SCC 727, para 14.
Page 13 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
cases where the discretion was exercised arbitrarily, capriciously or perversely,
or where settled principles were ignored. That another view is possible is not
enough.
Holding Order as Baseline:
23. Paragraph 5 of the Reference Order, extracted above, required the
Section 17 application to be decided uninfluenced by the interim orders. The
Arbitrator identified the status quo as the High Court’s orders of August 10,
2023 and December 14, 2023 (Paragraph 8.5.2) and observed that it fell on the
Society to dislodge the ad interim order (Paragraph 8.3.5). The Impugned
Order describes the order of December 14, 2023 as “indeed the status quo
ante” (Paragraph 9.5) and records that the Arbitrator confined the ambit of
enquiry to whether that order should continue (Paragraph 4.1).
24. Having carefully examined the Impugned Order, I find it simplistic to
attempt to paint it as treating the holding position as the baseline to be met.
Indeed, that position has been arrived at by the Learned Arbitral Tribunal but
as a position after analysis of the factual matrix rather than as a dogmatic
postulate without reason. The Impugned Order does record that “it falls to the
Society therefore to show a breach that has not been waived or condoned”
(Paragraph 8.3.5) and that the order of December 14, 2023 “is indeed the
status quo ante” (Paragraph 9.5). Indeed, the Reference Order indicated that
Page 14 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
the Section 17 proceedings must be conducted without being influenced by the
ad interim arrangements. However, that does not mean that the Learned
Arbitral Tribunal was prevented from arriving at a view, for reasons, that the
ad interim arrangement was a reasonable baseline to adopt in the course of
conduct of the interlocutory proceedings. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal has
examined the factual matrix and come to a view that the 2019 SDA dealt with
the delays occurring until then; examined the architect’s report to take a view
on how much work had been completed; analysed the deep divisions in the
Society to term it a “house divided”; noticed the Holding Order and then came
to a view on that being the baseline. In my view, this is analytical and does not
mean that a view that effectively justifies continuing with the Holding Order is
necessarily violative of Paragraph 5 of the Reference Order.
25. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal took note, for example, of the report of
the architect Mr. Pendse, and the findings therein have informed the adoption
of the baseline. I do not find merit in finding fault with the Impugned Order
on the ground that ad interim arrangement was treated as a baseline.
Prima Facie View on Work, Waiver, Loss of Confidence:
26. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal did analyse the factual matrix to arrive at
a view on the strength of a prima facie case with reasons for that view. For
instance, the architect’s report indicates the scale of work done and the
Page 15 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
number of floors built. At a prima facie stage, this is a reasonable approach for
the Learned Arbitral Tribunal to take. One could quarrel with the findings but
that would be subjected to trial.
27. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal analysed the conduct of the parties
before and after the COVID-19 Pandemic. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal took
a view that the 2019 SDA reset the parties’ position about the defaults that
preceded it and took a view that blame for delays after the 2019 SDA could not
be placed at the doorstep of HK Builders alone. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal
observed that the Society could not show what it did during the year before the
pandemic and made no demand from April 2020.
28. The Society disputes the 80% completion claim and contends that the
post-2019 default, read with the default prior to the 2019 SDA must be seen
and that Clause 11 of the 2019 SDA gave no more than 30 months from
January 22, 2019. HK Builders says that the Clause 11 period was never
triggered and that COVID-19 and obstruction explain the delay. At this stage,
I can only examine the record and the Impugned Order, to see if the prima
facie view of the Learned Arbitral Tribunal is perverse, warranting
interference. Ultimately, the Learned Arbitral Tribunal is the best judge and
the master of the quality and quantity of evidence and must therefore have a
Page 16 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
reasonable play in the joints to take a prima facie view of the material on
record.
29. In my view, the prima facie view on the various counts, taken by the
Learned Arbitral Tribunal cannot be faulted. Indeed, the parties have serious
contentions about the accuracy of the architect’s findings and the Learned
Arbitral Tribunal took a view that a mini trial at this stage would not be
appropriate and instead the evidence must be led and tested in trial. As
already stated above, the principles laid down in Wander vs. Antox for the
approach to testing an appeal to an interlocutory decision must inform the
decision of the Section 37 Court. I can see that the factual matrix is fraught
with serious dissension of perspectives between the parties and it is also
apparent that even among the constituents of the Society, there is a deeper
division of views than dissent by a small minority, as can be seen in some
cases. Therefore, what has to be examined is whether the Learned Arbitral
Tribunal’s approach to assessing the most appropriate balance between the
parties’ competing interests is reasonable, logical and plausible. I am of the
view that the Learned Arbitral Tribunal has indeed taken a prima facie view
that cannot be brushed aside as perverse and untenable.
30. The scale of work done, the apportionment of blame, the import of the
2019 SDA, the degree of investment and sunk cost incurred by HK Builders,
Page 17 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
the acknowledgement of the presence and role of the New Partners and
thereby the inference of waiver, and the loss of confidence, are all facets that
have been perceived by the Learned Arbitral Tribunal from a prima facie
perspective. Lest there be any doubt, regardless of a seeming firmness to the
findings, it is clear to me that the expression of views in the Impugned Order
are indeed prima facie views and that too those made in aid of fashioning
what appears to be the most appropriate interlocutory framework that appeals
to the Learned Arbitral Tribunal.
31. The Society relied on Rajawadi Arunodaya to contend that loss of
trust is a ground to terminate a development agreement. The Learned Arbitral
Tribunal placed the case in Category 3 as articulated in Paragraph 52(c) of
Rajawadi Arunodaya which reads thus:
“(c) Category 3 cases, and this is where I believe the present case falls, are
those where the society has vacated, the developer has taken possession, has
done some amount of work, but then at some point falls behind in payment of
financial obligations and completion of development. This is a downward
spiral. The developer gets mired more and more in debt. The arrears of transit
rent keep mounting with each passing month, and then there is a near
financial impossibility. Sometimes, these matters are resolved by negotiations,
but it is here that the questions of law and of assessment of contracts really
arise.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
Page 18 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
32. Indeed, seriously disputed facts have to be subjected to trial and indeed,
the scale of work already undergone is prima facie significant, and at trial, the
prima facie view could get displaced. The fact that the New Partners came in
with some involvement and knowledge of the Society cannot be displaced at
this prima facie stage. The findings on impact of COVID-19 also do not, prima
facie , appear perverse and unreasonable. In the result I am of the view, that a
case for displacement of the Impugned Order is not made out.
33. While the grounds of challenge in the Petition do not explicitly deal with
the “house divided” reasoning, the with-prejudice offer that has been accepted
and the delay in communicating the Impugned Order, these have been
pleaded and were seriously pressed into service at the hearing of the Petition
and also dealt with on behalf of HK Builders and placed by the parties in their
submissions. I have thought it fit to consider the record in relation to these
facets as well.
34. I am not satisfied with the contention that the Petition itself was not
duly authorised. The Society’s Annual General Meeting of September 28, 2025
is the focus of whether the captioned Petition is duly authorised. The
observer’s report dated November 20, 2025, addressed to the Assistant
Registrar and filed by HK Builders, is said to record that 158 members were
present. It records that 73 opposed the appeal, 79 showed consent and 6 were
Page 19 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
neutral. After a commotion and a call to the police, 78 members left and the
Chairman continued with 80. The report records the Chairman informing the
house that the Managing Committee had taken the decision to appeal. The
Petition has been considered on merits on the premise that the Managing
Committee had chosen to appeal regardless of the Society’s general meeting;
and indeed on the premise that the Society had pursued the Section 17
proceedings and if aggrieved, it has a statutory right to appeal under
Section 37.
35. The deep division in the Society appears to be a feature of the factual
matrix. I am afraid that even where the strength of feeling between the two
warring camps of a “divided house” is high, it is for the Learned Arbitral
Tribunal to fashion an interlocutory arrangement that appears most
appropriate to it. Unless the view taken is one that no reasonable person
would take i.e. that the discretion was exercised arbitrarily, capriciously or
perversely, I am afraid the needle does not turn in favour of displacing the
Learned Arbitral Tribunal’s view. To my mind, the view adopted by the
Learned Arbitral Tribunal is a view reasonably possible. This is the standard
stipulated in Wander vs. Antox . If one were to do that, it would constitute
taking an alternate view merely because another view is possible rather than
testing whether the challenged view is reasonable.
Page 20 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
36. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal’s view that certain facets of deep
controversy, including who attended the meeting of August 7, 2022 at which
HK Builders’ engagement is said to have been revalidated with induction of
the New Partners being waived, must await trial, cannot be faulted. The view
that whether there was a loss of confidence and trust must await trial
(Paragraph 8.3.11) also cannot be faulted. Necessarily, the Learned Arbitral
Tribunal must engage with the contentions on the mortgage and the property
tax dues and the current status. HK Builders contends that the BMC’s
regularisation demand has been reduced from Rs. 9 crores to Rs. 3.83 crores
and that it has paid Rs. 40 lakhs towards property tax. The prima facie view
that the induction of the New Partners was not prohibited by contract cannot
be faulted in the absence of a ‘change in control’ clause which is not unheard
of. Trial can indeed unravel the ultimate true and accurate findings on the
basis of evidence. It would not be proper for the Section 37 Court to conduct a
mini trial during the appeal. The prima facie view can be displaced by trial
and the test, at the risk of repetition, at this stage is whether the prima facie
view is something that no reasonable person could take.
37. The balance of convenience and irreparable harm are also indeed in
favour of not terminating the 2019 SDA rather than terminating it, in the
peculiar facts of this case. That HK Builders would be reduced to a money
Page 21 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
claim at this stage of the project is a reasonably justifiable view. The effect of
the COVID-19 Pandemic, within months of the 2019 SDA and the conduct of
parties thereafter, are not perverse findings.
38. I have read the contents of all the sub-paragraphs of Paragraph 9 of the
Impugned Order including the with-prejudice offer accepted in Paragraph 9.6,
being accepted as a condition of the interlocutory arrangement. The contents
of sub-paragraphs of Paragraph 10 including the vacation of the interlocutory
arrangement as set out in Paragraph 10.9, read with Paragraph 10.10, are
clearly in the realm of a reasonable arrangement that a Learned Arbitral
Tribunal is entitled to impose. These are conditions imposed as part of
moulding of relief rather than re-writing of a contract.
Delay in Communicating the Impugned Order:
39. On the issue of delay in the communication of the Impugned Order, I
have carefully gone through the correspondence between the Society’s
advocates and the Arbitrator (Exhibits I to P, pages 716 to 723). It is
unfortunate that the Impugned Order is dated April 4, 2025, and was collected
by the Society on invitation, on September 3, 2025. However, the
correspondence can fill this gap. It appears that the Impugned Order was
ready on April 4, 2025 and that the Learned Sole Arbitrator was leaving the
Page 22 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
country that day in the afternoon, and his internet services were disrupted
amidst shifting of his office completely for extensive renovation. A temporary
office address is also indicated in the covering letter of April 4, 2025 (page 56).
The later correspondence i.e. Exhibits K, M and P describe the printed copies
as having remained undelivered in the Chamber, and Exhibit M places the
issue of the hard copy on April 3, 2025, which could be a typographical error
in conveying the date as April 4, 2025.
40. It transpires that the Advocates for the Society had followed up for the
order on March 12, 2025 (Exhibit I, page 716). Then on July 28, 2025
(Exhibits J and K, pages 717 and 718) the Advocates and the Learned Sole
Arbitrator exchanged emails in which the Learned Sole Arbitrator stated that
he believed he had sent the Impugned Order out long ago, having instructed
his staff to despatch it before travelling, and that he would check and get back
in a day or two because his staff was unavailable. This was followed up on
August 5, 2025 (Exhibits L and M, pages 719 and 720) to which the Learned
Sole Arbitrator replied that his chamber was in a shambles and under
renovation, with his office manager resuming work in a couple of days. He
stated that he had printed two copies and signed and handed them over for
delivery and that he would trace them out, failing which he would re-issue it.
Two more reminders followed – on August 18, 2025 and August 29, 2025
Page 23 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
(Exhibits N and O, pages 721 and 722), which the Learned Sole Arbitrator
replied to on August 31, 2025 (Exhibit P, page 723) stating that he had missed
these emails completely and he was in the midst of moving back to his
renovated office and in the course of doing so, found the signed orders, which
had remained in his office and not been delivered. He called for them to be
collected on Wednesday, September 3, 2025 since the office was likely to be
closed on Monday and there would be workmen in on Tuesday.
41. The Society has narrated these facts but has not pleaded in its grounds
that this sequence of events vitiates the bona fides of the Impugned Order.
However, in the hearing these facts were pointed out and the written
submissions contend that this vitiates the Impugned Order. The sequence of
events leading to the delay in locating and releasing the Impugned Order is
unfortunate. Having given this considerable thought, and taking into account
the sequence narrated and the contents of the correspondence, and factoring
in the merits of the matter, and the fact that the grounds of challenge do not
impeach the bona fides of the explanation for the delay, I am not inclined to
interfere with the Impugned Order on this ground, having found no need to
interfere with the Impugned Order on merits.
Page 24 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
Conclusions:
42. In the result, I am not satisfied that the attack on the Impugned Order
on the premise that the Holding Order was blindly used as a baseline, and that
Paragraph 5 of the Reference Order was thereby violated, is tenable. The
prima facie findings on the 2019 SDA, the degree of completion of work,
waiver of the induction of the New Partners, and the treatment of loss of
confidence, are not perverse findings by the Learned Arbitral Tribunal,
necessitating intervention. The challenge founded on the want of authority to
maintain the Petition, the with-prejudice offer accepted in Paragraph 9.6 of
the Impugned Order and the delay in the communication of the Impugned
Order also does not warrant interference. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal must
apply itself to the creation of the mortgage as well as the issue of property
taxes as part of the trial.
43. Therefore, the Petition is dismissed without any interference. With
the disposal of the Petition, the Interim Application filed in the matter also
stands disposed of .
44. Both parties shall present the precise factual position as on date to the
Learned Arbitral Tribunal, which shall assess the implications of subsequent
events for the interim arrangement formulated in the Impugned Order. There
shall be no order as to costs, but the parties shall be at liberty to address the
Page 25 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Judgement-ARBP(L)-28067-2025.-F.docx
Learned Arbitral Tribunal about costs for until this round of litigation in the
course of the arbitral proceedings.
45. After the judgement was pronounced, the Learned Advocate for the
Petitioner seeks that the interim directions issued on September 17, 2025, be
continued. Having applied my mind, I am not inclined to continue such
interim directions.
46. All actions required to be taken pursuant to this order shall be taken
upon receipt of a downloaded copy as available on this Court’s website.
[SOMASEKHAR SUNDARESAN J.]
Page 26 of 26
November 19, 2026
Chaitanya
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 17:38:41
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)