Kishan Lal Deceased Through Lrs & Ors. vs R K Associates

Court
Delhi High Court

$~
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Judgment reserved on: 07.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 18.11.2026

# CNR No. DLHC010748372023
+ EX.F.A. 1/2023
KISHAN LAL DECEASED THROUGH LRS & ORS.
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Rajesh Yadav, Sr.
Advocate with Mr. Tanmay
Nagar, Mr. Gurpreet Singh
Sethi, Ms. Shamli Verma and
Mr. Kapil Kumar, Advs.
versus

R K ASSOCIATES .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sachin Gupta and Ms.
Anupriya, Advs.

# CNR No. DLHC010748362023
+ EX.F.A. 2/2023 & CM APPL. 25392/2024 (Exemption)
KISHAN LAL SINCE DECEASED THROUGH LRS & ORS.
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Rajesh Yadav, Sr.
Advocate with Mr. Tanmay
Nagar, Mr. Gurpreet Singh
Sethi, Ms. Shamli Verma and
Mr. Kapil Kumar, Advs.
versus

R.K ASSOCIATES .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sachin Gupta and Ms.
Anupriya, Advs.

CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 1 of 17

J U D G M E N T
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
CM APPL. 24996/2024 (Recalling of the order dt. 28.07.2023) &
CM APPL. 24997/2024 (Delay of 235 days in filing the application
in EX.F.A. 1/2023
CM APPL. 25390/2024 (Recalling of the order dt. 28.07.2023), CM
APPL. 25391/2024 (Delay of 235 days in filing the application) &
CM APPL. 25392/2024 (Ex.) in EX.F.A. 2/2023

1. The present Applications, CM APPL. Nos. 24997/2024 and
25391/2024, have been filed on behalf of the Appellants under Section
1
5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 , seeking condonation of delay in filing
the respective applications for recall and restoration, CM APPL. Nos.
24996/2024 and 25390/2024. The recall and restoration applications,
in turn, have been filed under Section 151 of the Code of Civil
2
Procedure, 1908 , seeking recall of the Common Order dated
3
28.07.2023 and restoration of the main Appeals, EX.F.A. Nos.
1/2023 and 2/2023, both titled Kishan Lal (since deceased) through
LRs & Ors. v. R.K. Associates , to their original numbers.
2. The Appeals were preferred under Order XXI Rule 58 read with
Section 151 of the CPC, assailing the distinct Orders, both dated
4
20.12.2022 , passed by the learned Additional District Judge-07,
5

South-East District, Saket Courts, New Delhi , in Execution
Application Nos. 146/2022 and 138/2022, both titled R.K. Associates
v. Kishan Lal (deceased) through LRs . By the said Orders, the
objections preferred by the Judgment Debtors were dismissed, and
directions were issued, inter alia , for taking possession of the subject

1
Limitation Act
2
CPC
3
Common Order
4
Impugned Orders
5
Executing Court
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 2 of 17

properties with police assistance.
3. The underlying execution proceedings arise out of decrees for
possession in respect of two plots of land measuring 600 square yards
and 200 square yards, respectively , forming part of Khasra No. 75,
situated at Village Zamrudpur, Delhi. EX.F.A. 1/2023 pertains to the
property measuring 600 square yards and the corresponding
proceedings in Execution Application No. 146/2022, whereas EX.F.A.
2/2023 pertains to the property measuring 200 square yards and the
corresponding proceedings in Execution Application No. 138/2022.
4. Both Appeals were dismissed for non-prosecution by this Court
vide Common Order, as none appeared on behalf of the Appellants
when the matters were taken up. The Order also records the
submission made on behalf of the Respondent that physical possession
of the subject property had already been recovered.
5. Since the Applications seeking condonation of delay and
restoration in both Appeals raise substantially similar grounds, they
were reserved for consideration together and are being disposed of by
way of the present common Judgment. The explanations furnished by
the Appellants regarding their alleged lack of knowledge of the
dismissal, the conduct attributed to their erstwhile counsel, the
engagement of new counsel and the subsequent retrieval of the case
files are materially similar in both matters.
6. Accordingly, the common questions arising for consideration
are examined together, while the facts and reliefs specific to each
Appeal are considered separately wherever necessary.

BRIEF FACTS:
7. The dispute emanates from execution proceedings initiated by
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 3 of 17

the Respondent, M/s R.K. Associates, for enforcement of decrees for
possession passed in its favour in CS No. 305/2009 and CS No.
304/2009, vide judgment dated 05.03.2011. The decrees concern
parcels of land measuring 600 square yards and 200 square yards,
respectively , forming part of Khasra No. 75, situated at Village
Zamrudpur, Delhi. In execution of the said decrees, proceedings were
instituted as Execution Application Nos. 146/2022 and 138/2022.
8. During the course of the execution proceedings, objections under
Order XXI Rule 97 of the CPC were raised on behalf of the Judgment
Debtors/ the Appellants herein. Vide Order dated 20.12.2022, the
learned Executing Court rejected the objections and issued
consequential directions concerning execution of the decrees,
including the taking of possession with police assistance. Aggrieved
thereby, the Appellants preferred the aforesaid Appeals before this
Court.

9. On 28.07.2023, when both Appeals were taken up together by
this Court, neither the Appellants nor their counsel appeared.
Consequently, by a common order, both Appeals were dismissed for
non-prosecution.
10. The present applications, each dated 23.04.2024, have been filed
in the respective Appeals seeking condonation of delay in filing the
recall/restoration application and recall of the common order, thereby
restoring both Appeals.
11. The principal explanation advanced by the Appellants is that
their erstwhile counsel, Sh. Shivom Garg, did not inform them about
the dismissal of the Appeals and did not provide the requisite case
files despite follow-ups. They contend that they continued to pursue
the execution proceedings under the impression that their interests
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 4 of 17

were being duly protected. It is further averred that one of the legal
representatives, Mr. Rajesh Kumar, is illiterate and belongs to a rural
background.
12. The Appellants state that they engaged new counsel in the first
week of February 2024, whereupon they learnt of the dismissal of the
Appeals. They further assert that the relevant files were ultimately
obtained on 20.03.2024, after which steps were taken to institute the
Applications for restoration of those Appeals. The Applications state
the delay as 235 days. The computation of the period of delay,
however, requires consideration with reference to the date of
dismissal, the prescribed period of limitation and the date of
institution of the Applications.
13. In the applications, the Appellants have also referred to
subsequent developments in the execution proceedings before the
learned Executing Court. They rely on these developments to support
their contention that the issues raised in the main Appeals are
substantive issues between the parties and warrant consideration on
the merits.
14. In these circumstances, the present Applications require
consideration of the explanation furnished for the Appellants’ non-
appearance and the delay in seeking restoration.
15. It is clarified that, at this stage, this Court is concerned only with
the merits of these Applications. The merits of the Appeals would
arise for consideration at a later stage, and only if the Applications are
allowed.

SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS:
16. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellants
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 5 of 17

would submit that the Appeals were dismissed solely on account of
non-appearance and were not adjudicated on merits. It would be
contended that the Appellants never intended to abandon their
challenge to the Impugned Orders and that their absence was neither
deliberate nor intentional.
17. Learned senior counsel would submit that the Appellants had
been relying upon their erstwhile counsel for conducting the litigation
and were not informed that the Appeals had been dismissed on
28.07.2023. It would be contended that the Appellants continued to
participate in the proceedings before the learned Executing Court
under the bona fide impression that their interests were being duly
protected. Their continued participation in the execution proceedings,
according to learned senior counsel, ought not to be treated as proof of
their knowledge of the dismissal of the Appeals.
18. It would further be submitted that the Appellants attempted to
obtain the requisite case files from their erstwhile counsel after
engaging new counsel in the first week of February 2024. However,
the former counsel allegedly failed to provide the files and represented
that the same could not be traced owing to the shifting of his office.
The Appellants state that the requisite files were ultimately received
on 20.03.2024, following which the present Applications were filed.
19. Learned senior counsel would also rely upon the subsequent
Orders passed in the execution proceedings, particularly the Orders
dated 13.01.2023 and 07.02.2024, to contend that questions
concerning the extent of possession delivered, identification of the
decretal properties and demarcation of the remaining land continue to
arise.
20. It would be urged that these developments have a material
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 6 of 17

bearing on the underlying Appeals and that the Appellants ought not
to be deprived of an opportunity to pursue their challenge on merits
solely on account of their absence on the date of hearing.
21. Learned senior counsel would contend that the delay was
neither deliberate nor attributable to any wilful negligence on the part
of the Appellants. It would be submitted that the expression “ sufficient
cause ” ought to receive a liberal construction so as to advance
substantial justice and that no irreparable prejudice would be caused to
the Respondent if the Appeals were restored and considered on merits.
22. Accordingly, the Appellants pray that the delay be condoned,
the Common Order be recalled, and both Appeals be restored to their
original numbers.
23. Besides the above, no other submissions were advanced on
behalf of the Appellants.

SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT:
24. Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondent would oppose the Applications and submit that the
Appellants have failed to furnish any cogent or satisfactory
explanation for the delay in seeking restoration. It would be contended
that the Appeals were dismissed on 28.07.2023, whereas the
Applications were filed only on 23.04.2024, and that the explanation
furnished does not account for the entire period of delay.
25. Learned counsel would submit that the Appellants seek to
attribute the delay entirely to their erstwhile counsel, Sh. Shivom
Garg, alleging that he failed to inform them of the dismissal and
withheld the relevant files. These allegations, according to the
Respondent, are inconsistent with the record of the execution
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 7 of 17

proceedings, which reflects that the erstwhile counsel continued to
appear on behalf of the Appellants after the dismissal of the Appeals.
26. In this regard, learned counsel would refer to the appearances of
the erstwhile counsel before the learned executing court on
04.08.2023, 06.12.2023 and 19.12.2023, amongst other dates. It would
further be pointed out that the Order dated 01.09.2023 records that the
Appeals had been dismissed for default. According to the Respondent,
these circumstances materially undermine the Appellants’ plea that
they remained unaware of the status of the Appeals.
27. Learned counsel would also refer to the proceedings dated
16.01.2024 and 22.01.2024 before the learned Executing Court. It
would be submitted that, on 16.01.2024, the Appellant, Mr. Rajesh
Kumar, appeared and sought an adjournment on the ground that
counsel was unavailable owing to illness. On 22.01.2024, Mr. Rajesh
Kumar is stated to have informed the learned Executing Court that the
Appellants intended to change their counsel and that their erstwhile
counsel was not providing the case file. The Respondent would
contend that these proceedings demonstrate that the Appellants were
aware of the difficulties concerning their representation before the
Applications for restoration were instituted.
28. It would further be contended that the alleged illiteracy and
rural background of one of the Appellants cannot, by themselves,
constitute sufficient cause for condonation of delay.
29. Learned counsel would submit that the Appellants have been
pursuing the underlying litigation and execution proceedings for
several years and have not placed satisfactory material on record to
demonstrate that the alleged conduct of their former counsel prevented
them from approaching this Court within the prescribed period.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 8 of 17

30. With regard to the subsequent Orders passed in the execution
proceedings, learned counsel would submit that the Orders concerning
delivery of possession and demarcation of the remaining property do
not explain the Appellants’ non-appearance on 28.07.2023 or the
delay in filing the Applications for restoration.
31. It would, accordingly, be prayed that the Applications seeking
condonation of delay and restoration of both Appeals be dismissed.
32. Besides the above, no other submissions were advanced on
behalf of the Respondents.

ANALYSIS:
33. This Court has heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
parties, and with their able assistance, carefully perused the material
on record.
34. At the outset, it is apposite to note that the present Applications
seek condonation of delay in filing the respective applications for
recall and restoration, and restoration of EX.F.A. Nos. 1/2023 and
2/2023 to their original numbers. The Appellants have also sought
permission to place on record subsequent developments and orders in
the execution proceedings, particularly those concerning the
identification and demarcation of the remaining decretal properties.
35. Since the grounds urged in support of the Applications are
substantially similar, the common questions arising for consideration
are being examined together.
36. It is noted that Article 122 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act
prescribes a period of thirty (30) days for an application seeking to set
aside a decree passed ex parte or to re-admit an Appeal or Application
dismissed for default of appearance or for want of prosecution. Insofar
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 9 of 17

as the application for restoration having been filed beyond the
prescribed period, the Appellants have invoked Section 5 of the
Limitation Act, which empowers the Court to admit an application
after the expiry of the prescribed period if the applicant satisfies the
Court that there was sufficient cause for not preferring the same
within such period.
37. The power to restore an Appeal dismissed for default is
traceable to Order XLI Rule 19 of the CPC, read with the applicable
procedural provisions and the inherent powers of the Court under
Section 151 CPC. The exercise of such power is, however, contingent
upon the applicant satisfying the requisite statutory conditions. The
jurisdiction to condone delay is discretionary and cannot be exercised
merely on the asking of the applicant. The Court therefore must be
satisfied that the explanation furnished by the applicant constitutes
sufficient cause and is consistent with the conduct of the party seeking
such indulgence.
38. It is well settled that the expression “ sufficient cause ” must be
construed in a manner that advances substantial justice, and an
application for condonation should not be rejected solely because the
delay is lengthy. But a liberal approach does not make condonation
automatic. The applicant must provide a bona fide , reasonable and
sufficiently detailed account of the delay, including the material
circumstances that prevented timely action and the steps taken once
the impediment ceased. The explanation should be assessed as a
whole and tested against the contemporaneous record, the applicant’s
conduct throughout the relevant period, and whether the applicant
acted with reasonable diligence.
39. The length of the delay is relevant but is not, by itself, decisive;
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 10 of 17

equally, the general appeal to substantial justice cannot cure
unexplained periods of inaction, material inconsistencies, or conduct
that indicates negligence or a lack of bona fides . The Court must
therefore determine whether the Appellants’ explanation is credible,
accounts for the material periods of delay, and, viewed in light of the
record and their conduct, establishes sufficient cause for their delay in
approaching this Court.
40. In the present case, the restoration is sought by the
Applicants/Appellants primarily by foisting the entire onus for the
dismissal of the Appeal on their erstwhile counsel, Sh. Shivom Garg.
The Applicant/Appellants allege that Sh. Shivom Garg failed to attend
to them properly, as a result of which they engaged a new counsel;
failed to inform them that the Appeal had been dismissed; and failed
to provide the requisite case files in a timely manner. It is asserted that
the Appellants came to know of the dismissal only upon engaging new
counsel and thereafter obtaining the relevant documents. The
explanation is sought to be supplemented by the plea that Appellant
Mr. Rajesh Kumar is illiterate and belongs to a rural background.
41. In the considered opinion of this Court, the aforesaid
explanation, however, cannot be considered in isolation from the
record of the execution proceedings. The material placed before this
Court by the parties indicates that the erstwhile counsel continued to
appear on behalf of the Appellants before the learned Executing Court
even after the Appeal had been dismissed on 28.07.2023.
42. The record reflects his appearance on, inter alia , 04.08.2023,
06.12.2023 and 19.12.2023. Further, the Order dated 01.09.2023
passed by the learned Executing Court specifically records that the
Appeals had been dismissed for default.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 11 of 17

43. The aforesaid circumstances assume significance because the
Appellants seek to attribute the entire delay to their lack of knowledge
of the dismissal and the alleged failure of their erstwhile counsel to
communicate the same. The continued appearance of the said counsel
in the execution proceedings, coupled with the record of those
proceedings, renders the explanation of complete ignorance
insufficiently convincing. The Appellants have not satisfactorily
explained how, despite the continued conduct of the execution
proceedings through their counsel, they remained unaware of the
status of their appeal for the period in question.
44. It is undoubtedly true that a litigant ought not ordinarily to be
made to suffer for a bona fide lapse on the part of counsel. However,
such a principle cannot be applied mechanically, irrespective of the
conduct of the litigant or the surrounding circumstances.
45. The Court is required to examine whether the litigant himself
acted with reasonable diligence and whether the alleged lapse of
counsel genuinely accounts for the delay sought to be condoned. A
general allegation that counsel failed to communicate an order cannot,
in every case, suffice to establish sufficient cause, particularly where
the contemporaneous record indicates continued participation in
related proceedings.
46. In the present case, this court is of the considered opinion that
the Appellants have not satisfactorily demonstrated that they exercised
reasonable diligence in keeping themselves apprised of the progress of
the Appeals or that the alleged conduct of their erstwhile counsel
prevented them from taking timely steps to seek restoration.
47. The fact that counsel continued to represent them before the
executing court is a material circumstance which cannot be
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 12 of 17

disregarded merely on the basis of the subsequent assertion that the
Appellants were unaware of the dismissal. In fact, the same is belied
by the presence of Mr. Rajesh Kumar in Court on 01.09.2023, on
which date the executing Court records the factum of the dismissal of
the Appeal.
48. Furthermore, the explanation that Mr. Rajesh Kumar is
“illiterate” is not borne out from the record. There is nothing to
substantiate the said assertion. To the contrary, the record is replete
with pleadings and affidavits of Mr. Rajesh Kumar, as in the present
Appeals, which he has signed in English. The record of the Executing
Court also shows that the JDs were making repeated payments to the
DH. Furthermore, the record indicates that the Applicants/ Appellants
were personally present during the execution proceedings on various
dates and appeared to be pursuing the same diligently.
49. The Appellants/Applicants were evidently aware of the
seriousness of the matter and diligently attended the execution
proceedings. This Court fails to understand or comprehend and cannot
discern any reason from the pleadings as to why no such diligence was
shown in respect of the Appeals. The fact that the erstwhile Counsel
Mr. Garg was attending to the execution proceedings and the JD/
Applicants/ Appellants were present personally with the said advocate
on various occasions is also contrary to the averment made that the
advocate was not attending properly to the Appellant/ Applicants. It is
difficult to believe that the Applicants/ Appellants herein were not
aware of the dismissal considering the entire conspectus of the facts.
The explanation furnished, therefore, does not adequately account for
the delay in approaching this Court.
50. The Appellants had been pursuing the underlying litigation and
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 13 of 17

were represented in the execution proceedings. In these circumstances,
the plea of lack of familiarity with legal procedure, without a
satisfactory explanation of the steps taken to remain informed about
the Appeal proceedings, cannot independently justify condonation of
the delay.
51. Further, the contention that the requisite case files were
obtained only on 20.03.2024 also does not satisfactorily explain the
entire period of delay. The Appellants assert that new counsel was
engaged in the first week of February 2024 and that the previous
counsel had failed to provide the files owing to their alleged
unavailability following the shifting of his office.
52. Even accepting that some time was required to obtain the
documents, the Appellants were required to explain, with reasonable
specificity, the circumstances that prevented them from seeking
restoration earlier and the steps taken by them during the intervening
period. The explanation, when considered alongside the continued
appearances in the execution proceedings and the absence of a
convincing account of the Appellants’ own diligence, does not meet
the requisite threshold.
53. It is also relevant that, on 22.01.2024, Mr. Rajesh Kumar is
stated to have informed the learned Executing Court that the
Appellants intended to change their counsel and that their erstwhile
counsel was not providing the case file. The subsequent engagement
of new counsel and the proceedings which followed do not, by
themselves, establish sufficient cause for the entire delay in seeking
restoration. The burden remained upon the Appellants to provide a
coherent explanation covering the material period of delay. In the
considered opinion of this Court, that burden has not been discharged.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 14 of 17

54. This Court is, therefore, unable to accept the explanation
furnished by the Appellants as constituting sufficient cause in law,
which is the sole criterion for determining whether the delay may be
condoned in the present circumstances.
55. The continued representation of the Appellants by their
erstwhile counsel in the execution proceedings, the absence of a
satisfactory explanation for the failure to pursue the status of the
Appeal, and the lack of adequate particulars demonstrating due
diligence collectively militate against the exercise of discretion in
their favour. The application seeking condonation of delay is,
accordingly, liable to be dismissed.
56. This Court also takes note of the fact that though serious
allegations have been made against the erstwhile counsel, there appear
to be no steps taken in furtherance of the same. There appears to be no
complaint made to the Bar Council or even a communication
addressed to the concerned counsel. The allegations, being
unsubstantiated by any action taken, do not inspire the confidence of
the Court.
57. Since both Applications, i.e., for Restoration/ recall of the order
of dismissal for non-prosecution, as also the Application for
condonation of delay in preferring the said applications, set out almost
identical grounds, the discussion above would encompass the
contentions raised in both.
58. The Appeals came to be dismissed on 28.07.2023 on account of
non-appearance on behalf of the Appellants. The Appellants seek
recall of that Order primarily on the ground that they were not
informed of the dismissal by their erstwhile counsel. For the reasons
already discussed, the explanation does not inspire the Court’s
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 15 of 17

confidence.
59. The Court is conscious that restoration of an Appeal dismissed
for non-prosecution is intended to ensure that a litigant is not denied
an opportunity of hearing where the default is satisfactorily explained.
However, restoration is not an automatic consequence of an
Application being made, nor can it be granted merely because the
underlying dispute concerns property or execution of a decree. The
applicant must establish sufficient cause for the non-appearance and
satisfy the Court that the request for restoration is bona fide . In the
present case, the explanation furnished by the Appellants, in the
opinion of this Court, is wholly unsatisfactory.
60. The Appellants have also relied upon subsequent developments
in the execution proceedings, particularly the Orders dated 13.01.2023
and 07.02.2024. The order dated 13.01.2023 records that possession of
650 square yards had been delivered against an entitlement of 800
square yards, while the Order dated 07.02.2024 refers to the need for
certainty regarding the dimensions and identification of the remaining
property and directs demarcation through the concerned SDM.
61. These developments may bear upon the manner in which the
decree is to be executed and the issues arising before the learned
executing court. They do not, however, explain the Appellants’ failure
to appear when the Appeal was listed before this Court or their
subsequent delay in seeking its restoration.
62. The issue before this Court, at this stage, is not whether the
subsequent execution proceedings raise questions concerning
identification or demarcation of the decretal property. The issue is
whether the Appellants have established a sufficient basis for recalling
the Common Order and restoring the Appeals.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 16 of 17

63. The existence of subsequent proceedings or Orders cannot, by
itself, cure the failure to establish sufficient cause for the default and
the delay. Any rights or remedies available to the parties in relation to
the execution of the decree would have to be pursued in accordance
with law before the competent forum.

CONCLUSION:
64. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds that the
Appellants have failed to furnish a satisfactory explanation for the
delay in filing the Applications for restoration. The record of the
execution proceedings, particularly the continued appearances of their
erstwhile counsel, materially undermines the plea that the Appellants
remained unaware of the status of the Appeal.
65. Independently, the Appellants have failed to establish sufficient
cause for their non-appearance when the Appeals were called on for
hearing on 28.07.2023. The alleged lack of vigilance on the part of the
Appellants cannot, in the facts of the present case, be converted into
sufficient cause merely by attributing the delay to their previous
counsel.
66. Accordingly, the Applications seeking condonation of delay in
filing the respective Applications for restoration are dismissed.
67. Consequently, the Applications seeking recall of the Common
Order dated 28.07.2023 and restoration of EX.F.A. 1/2023 and
EX.F.A. 2/2023 to their original numbers are also dismissed.
68. No order as to costs.




HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.

NOVEMBER 18, 2026/JK
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:18:41
EX.F.A. 1/2023 & connected matter Page 17 of 17