United Inida Insurance Co.Ltd. vs Kamlesh And Ors.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH Court OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M)
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. . . . Appellant
vs.
Kamlesh and others . . . Respondents

Reserved on: November 18, 2026
Pronounced on: November 19, 2026
Pronounced fully/opera :ve part : Fully

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA
Argued By:- Mr. Abhishek Goyal and Mr. Pradeep Goyal, Advocates
for the appellant-Insurance Company.
Mr. D.K. Sharma, Advocate for respondent Nos.1 to 3.
DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
The appellant–Insurance Company has filed the present appeal
assailing the award dated 21.08.2014 passed by learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Yamuna Nagar at Jagadhri (hereina 2er referred to as ‘the
Tribunal’), whereby compensa6on of ₹3,71,200/- along with interest @ 7.5%
per annum from the date of filing of the claim pe66on 6ll realiza6on was
awarded to the claimants on account of death of Madan Lal in a motor vehic-
ular accident dated 22.04.2011. The owner and insurer of the vehicle were
held jointly and severally liable to pay the compensa6on.
2. Briefly stated, the claimants, being widow, son and mother of
deceased Madan Lal, filed a claim pe66on under Sec6on 163-A of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereina2er referred to as ‘the Act’), pleading that on
22.04.2011, deceased Madan Lal had gone to Timber Market, Jagadhri, for
labour work and therea2er proceeded to village Bheel Chhappar for loading
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

6mber on tractor-trolley bearing registra6on No.HR-01C-5087, owned by
Parmod Kumar. It was alleged that the tractor-trolley was overloaded with
eucalyptus wood and when the deceased aGempted to move it out of the
fields, the tractor li2ed from its front side due to excessive load, as a result
whereof, Madan Lal got trapped between the tractor and trolley and died at
the spot. DDR No.7-A dated 23.04.2011 was recorded regarding the
occurrence.
3. The owner contested the claim pe66on, aGribu6ng the accident
to negligence of the deceased. It was, however, pleaded that Parmod Kumar
and his brother Surinder Kumar were jointly carrying on agricultural ac6vi6es
and other work and were jointly u6lizing the tractor.
4. The Insurance Company, besides dispu6ng the occurrence,
pleaded that the tractor-trolley was being used for commercial purposes;
that the deceased was driving it without a valid driving licence and that the
insured had violated the terms and condi6ons of the insurance policy. It was
further pleaded that the deceased was not a third party and, therefore, his
legal representa6ves were not en6tled to compensa6on under Sec6on 163-A
of the Act.
5. On apprecia6on of the evidence, par6cularly the statements of
PW1 Kamlesh and PW2 Sohan Lal, post-mortem report Ex.P1 and DDR Ex.P3,
the Tribunal held that Madan Lal died in an accident arising out of the use of
the insured tractor-trolley. Taking his age as 42 years and monthly income as
₹3,200/-, the Tribunal assessed compensa6on under the Second Schedule to
the Act and awarded ₹3,71,200/- along with interest. The plea of breach of
insurance policy condi6ons was rejected and the owner and insurer were
held jointly and severally liable.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant–Insurance Company has
assailed the award primarily on the ques6on of liability. It is contended that
the deceased was admiGedly a labourer working on the tractor-trolley and,
being its borrower or permissive user, had stepped into the shoes of the
owner. Consequently, his legal representa6ves could not maintain a claim
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 2 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

under Sec 6on 163-A of the Act against the insurer. Reliance in this regard has
been placed upon Ningamma and another v. United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. , (2009) 13 SCC 710.
7. It is further contended that the tractor-trolley was grossly
overloaded, inasmuch as PW2 Sohan Lal, brother of the deceased, disclosed
that it was carrying eucalyptus wood weighing more than 100 quintals.
According to learned counsel, the excessive load was the direct cause of the
accident, as the tractor li 2ed from its front side and the deceased got
trapped between the tractor and trolley. Such overloading cons6tuted a
fundamental breach of the terms and condi6ons of the insurance policy.
Reliance has been placed upon Ji !nder and another v. Munni Devi and
others, FAO-767-2004, decided on 30.04.2026, Law Finder Document ID
2919048 .
8. It is also submi Ged that the vehicle was insured only under an
Act policy and, therefore, the Insurance Company could not have been
fastened with liability in respect of the deceased.
9. Per contra, learned counsel represen 6ng the claimants has
supported the impugned award. It is submiGed that the Insurance Company
cannot be permiGed to travel beyond its pleadings and that the burden of
establishing breach of the insurance policy condi6ons rested upon the
insurer, which it failed to discharge. It is further contended that deceased
Madan Lal was employed by Surinder Kumar, brother of registered owner
Parmod Kumar, as is evident from paragraph 1 of the wriGen statement filed
on behalf of the owner. Learned counsel has also drawn aGen6on to
insurance policy Ex.R1, poin6ng out that an addi6onal premium of ₹25/- had
been charged towards coverage of one employee. It is, therefore, submiGed
that the Insurance Company cannot escape liability merely by describing the
insurance contract as an Act policy.
10. I have heard learned counsel for the par6es and examined the
impugned award as well as the material referred to during arguments.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 3 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

11. The occurrence itself is not disputed. The claimants produced
post-mortem report Ex.P1, DDR Ex.P3 and the tes 6mony of PW1 Kamlesh and
PW2 Sohan Lal to establish that Madan Lal died a2er geOng trapped
between the tractor and trolley. The Insurance Company did not lead any
contrary evidence. The Tribunal, therefore, rightly held that the death
occurred in an accident arising out of the use of tractor-trolley bearing
registra6on No.HR-01C-5087.
12. The main controversy concerns the liability of the Insurance
Company. In this regard, three ques6ons arise for considera6on: firstly ,
whether the deceased was a borrower, who had stepped into the shoes of
the owner; secondly , whether the alleged overloading cons 6tuted a breach of
the insurance policy condi6ons; and thirdly , whether the insurance policy
covered the liability arising from the death of the deceased.
13. The claim pe 66on was ins6tuted under Sec6on 163-A of the
Act, as applicable on the date of the accident. Under the said provision,
compensa6on was payable on the structured formula basis without requiring
the claimants to plead or establish wrongful act, neglect or default of the
owner or driver of the vehicle. In United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sunil
Kumar and another , (2019) 12 SCC 398 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court clarified
that the insurer cannot defeat a claim under Sec 6on 163-A by raising a
defence of negligence aGributable to the vic6m. However, the said provision
does not dispense with the requirement of establishing that the liability
sought to be enforced is one covered by the statute or the insurance
contract.
14. In the Hon’ble Supreme Court
Ningamma’s Case (supra),
considered the claim arising from the death of a person, who had borrowed a
motorcycle from its owner and met with an accident while using it. It was
held that the borrower, having stepped into the shoes of the owner, could
not maintain a claim under Sec 6on 163-A against the owner and insurer in
the capacity of a third party. The principle was reiterated in Ramkhiladi and
another v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. and another , (2020) 2 SCC 550.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 4 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

15. However, the aforesaid principle cannot be mechanically
extended to every person, who happens to be driving or opera 6ng an insured
vehicle at the 6me of the accident. A dis6nc6on exists between a person,
who borrows a vehicle for his independent use and a person who operates it
in the course of employment under the direc6ons and for the benefit of its
owner or employer. The status of the deceased must, therefore, be
determined from the pleadings and evidence rather than merely from the
circumstance that he was driving the tractor.
16. In the present case, the claimants specifically pleaded that
deceased Madan Lal had gone to Timber Market, Jagadhri, for labour work.
PW1 Kamlesh and PW2 Sohan Lal deposed that the deceased was working as
a driver on the tractor-trolley. Pointedly, in paragraph 1 of the wriGen
statement filed on behalf of the owner, it was admiGed that Parmod Kumar
and his brother Surinder Kumar were jointly carrying on agricultural ac6vi6es
and other work and were jointly u6lizing the tractor. The claimants have
asserted that the deceased was employed by Surinder Kumar in connec6on
with such work.
17. There is no evidence that the deceased had borrowed the
tractor-trolley for his independent use or was exercising rights over it in the
capacity of its owner. Merely because he was opera6ng the vehicle at the
relevant 6me, it cannot be presumed that he had stepped into the shoes of
the registered owner. The factual founda6on necessary for invoking the
principle laid down in Ningamma (supra) and Ramkhiladi (supra) has not
been established. Consequently, the conten 6on that the deceased was a
borrower of the vehicle is rejected.
18. The next conten6on concerns overloading of the tractor-trolley.
Learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance upon Ji !nder and
another v. Munni Devi (supra) , wherein this Court considered the
consequences of overloading a tractor-trolley. In that case, two heavily
overloaded trolleys carrying sugarcane were a Gached to the tractor, which
overturned into a canal, resul6ng in the death of a person travelling atop the
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 5 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

sugarcane. This Court held that a Gachment of two overloaded trolleys
materially affected the balance, braking capacity and maneuverability of the
tractor and cons6tuted a fundamental breach of the insurance policy
condi6ons. Accordingly, the direc6on gran6ng recovery rights to the
Insurance Company was upheld.
19. The aforesaid judgment supports the proposi6on that gross
overloading, par6cularly when it materially contributes to the occurrence of
an accident, cannot be treated as an insignificant irregularity. In the present
case also, the claimants themselves pleaded that the tractor-trolley was
overloaded with eucalyptus wood, due to which the tractor li2ed from its
front side and the deceased got trapped between the tractor and trolley.
Thus, the causal connec6on between overloading and the accident is evident
from the claimants' own version. The appellant's conten6on regarding
overloading, therefore, cannot be brushed aside merely because the insurer
did not independently establish the precise weight of the wood.
20. Nevertheless, the legal consequences of overloading must be
examined in the context of the insurance contract and the nature of the risk
covered thereunder. In Ji !nder (supra), the deceased was travelling atop the
loaded trolley and the claim pe 66on arose under Sec6on 166 of the Act. In
the present case, the deceased was opera6ng the tractor in connec6on with
the work, for which he had been engaged and the claim pe66on was
ins6tuted under Sec6on 163-A of the Act. Moreover, the claimants have
specifically relied upon payment of an addi6onal premium of ₹25/- towards
coverage of one employee. These circumstances dis6nguish the present case
from insofar as the nature of the insured risk is concerned.
Ji !nder’s case
21. Sec 6on 149(2) of the Act, as applicable at the relevant 6me,
enumerated the statutory defences available to an insurer. The burden of
establishing a defence founded upon breach of policy condi6ons lies upon
the insurer. In Na !onal Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh and others,
(2004) 3 SCC 297, the Hon’ble Supreme Court emphasized the necessity of
establishing a legally relevant breach before the insurer can avoid its liability.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 6 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

Therefore, although overloading may cons 6tute unsafe use of a vehicle, the
insurer must also establish that the circumstances bring the case within a
defence available under the statute or the insurance contract.
22. In the present case, the Insurance Company has not iden6fied
any specific condi6on contained in policy Ex.R1, which en6tled it to avoid
liability on account of the load carried in the trolley. Nor has it established
that the alleged overloading cons6tuted a statutory defence available under
Sec6on 149(2) of the Act. The finding in based upon the
Ji !nder (supra),
par 6cular facts and policy condi6ons involved therein, cannot dispense with
the requirement of examining the policy applicable to the present vehicle.
Accordingly, notwithstanding the fact that overloading contributed to the
occurrence, the appellant has failed to establish that such overloading, by
itself, absolved it of liability.
23. The appellant - insurer has also ques6oned the use of the
tractor-trolley for transpor6ng eucalyptus wood. The Tribunal rejected the
conten6on that such transporta6on necessarily amounted to commercial
use. In Fahim Ahmad and others v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. and
others, (2014) 14 SCC 148 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that mere
transporta 6on of goods in a tractor-trolley, without adequate evidence
establishing use contrary to the permiGed purpose, would not necessarily
jus6fy exonera6on of the insurer.
24. In the case at hand, the owner had pleaded that the tractor was
jointly u6lized by him and his brother for agricultural ac6vi6es and other
work. The Insurance Company did not establish that transporta6on of
eucalyptus wood was undertaken as an independent commercial carriage
ac6vity in viola6on of any par6cular condi6on of the insurance policy. In the
absence of such evidence, the Tribunal rightly declined to presume a breach
merely from the nature of the material being transported.
25. Coming to the nature and extent of insurance coverage, Sec6on
147(1)(b) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, provides for compulsory insurance
against specified third-party risks. The proviso to Sec6on 147(1), however,
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 7 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

recognizes liability arising under the Employees' Compensa 6on Act, 1923, in
respect of specified categories of employees, including a person engaged in
driving the insured vehicle. In Na !onal Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Prembai Patel
and others, (2005) 6 SCC 172 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court clarified that the
compulsory insurance coverage in respect of such employees extends to the
statutory liability under the Employees' Compensa 6on Act, whereas liability
beyond the statutory requirement depends upon the terms of the insurance
contract. Thus, an Act-only policy does not necessarily exclude liability
towards an employee, but neither does it automa6cally extend to the en6re
compensa6on payable under Sec6on 163-A of the Act.
26. In the present case, insurance policy Ex.R1, valid from
11.02.2011 to 10.02.2012, is described as a ‘Liability Only Policy’. However,
its premium schedule reveals that, apart from the basic third-party premium
of ₹800/-, an addi6onal premium of ₹25/- was charged under the head ‘WC
to Employee 1’. The policy, therefore, expressly contemplates coverage of
liability towards one employee. Consequently, the appellant's conten6on
that no employee-related risk was covered cannot be accepted.
Nevertheless, in the absence of any endorsement extending such coverage
beyond the statutory liability under the Employees' Compensa6on Act, the
addi6onal premium cannot be construed as an undertaking to indemnify the
insured against the en6re liability arising under Sec6on 163-A of the Motor
Vehicles Act.
27. Further, the deceased was opera6ng the tractor-trolley in
connec6on with the work for which he had been engaged. The fact that the
tractor was registered in the name of Parmod Kumar, whereas the deceased
was stated to have been employed by his brother Surinder Kumar, does not,
by itself, establish that the deceased was an unauthorized user or borrower
of the vehicle. The wriGen statement filed on behalf of the owner specifically
acknowledges that both brothers were jointly carrying on agricultural
ac6vi6es and other work and were jointly u6lizing the tractor. In these
circumstances, the deceased was opera6ng the vehicle in connec6on with
the work of the persons jointly u6lizing it. The appellant has not established
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 8 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

that the employee coverage under Ex.R1 was restricted to a named
employee or that the deceased was excluded therefrom.
28. Nevertheless, the endorsement ‘WC to Employee 1’ cannot be
construed as an undertaking to indemnify the insured against the en 6re
liability arising under Sec6on 163-A of the Act. The premium was specifically
charged towards workers' compensa6on liability, and there is nothing in the
policy establishing that the insurer had undertaken any wider contractual
obliga6on in respect of the deceased. Consequently, although the insurer
cannot claim complete exonera6on, its liability must be confined to the
compensa6on payable under the Employees' Compensa6on Act, 1923, as
applicable on the date of the accident.
29. The ques6on which, therefore, survives is the extent of the
insurer's liability under the Employees' Compensa6on Act, 1923. The
deceased was aged about 42 years and his monthly income was assessed by
the Tribunal at ₹3,200/-. Under Sec6on 4(1)(a) of the Employees'
Compensa6on Act, compensa6on in the case of death resul6ng from an
injury is calculated at 50% of the monthly wages mul6plied by the relevant
factor specified in Schedule IV, or the prescribed minimum amount,
whichever is higher. For the completed age of 42 years, the relevant factor
prescribed under Schedule IV is 178.49.
30. Accordingly, on the basis of monthly wages of ₹3,200/- as
assessed by the Tribunal, the compensa6on under the Employees'
Compensa6on Act works out as follows:
 
Monthly wages ₹3,200
 
50% of monthly wages ₹1,600
 
Relevant factor (age 42 years) 178.49
 
₹1,600 × 178.49 ₹2,85,584
31. Thus, the compensa 6on calculated under Sec6on 4(1)(a) of the
Employees' Compensa6on Act comes to be ₹2,85,584/-, which exceeds the
statutory minimum applicable on the date of the accident.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 9 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

32. The Tribunal has awarded total compensa 6on of ₹3,71,200/-
under Sec6on 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act. However, in view of the
limited employee coverage under policy Ex.R1, the appellant–Insurance
Company cannot be fastened with liability beyond ₹2,85,584/- towards the
principal compensa6on. The balance amount of ₹85,616/- shall remain
payable by the owner of the vehicle. The claimants' en6tlement to the total
compensa6on awarded by the Tribunal shall remain unaffected by such
appor6onment of liability.
33. As regards interest, the Tribunal has awarded interest @ 7.5%
per annum from the date of filing of the claim pe66on 6ll its final realiza6on.
Since the present appeal concerns the extent of the insurer's liability under
the insurance contract and not the quantum of compensa6on awarded to the
claimants, the direc6on regarding interest does not call for any interference.
The appellant–Insurance Company shall be liable to pay interest at the
awarded rate on its share of ₹2,85,584/-, whereas the owner shall be liable
to pay interest at the same rate on the remaining amount of ₹85,616/-,
subject to adjustment of amounts already deposited or paid.
34. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeal is partly allowed.
The impugned award dated 21.08.2014 is modified only to the extent that
the liability of the appellant–Insurance Company shall stand restricted to
₹2,85,584/- along with propor6onate interest as directed above. The
remaining compensa6on of ₹85,616/- along with propor6onate interest shall
be payable by the owner of the tractor. The total compensa6on awarded to
the claimants, namely ₹3,71,200/- along with interest @ 7.5% per annum
from the date of filing of the claim pe66on 6ll realiza6on, shall remain
unchanged.
35. Any amount deposited by the appellant–Insurance Company in
excess of its liability, as determined above, shall be liable to adjustment or
refund in accordance with law, a2er ensuring that the claimants' en6tlement
under the award is not prejudiced. The Tribunal shall undertake the
necessary exercise regarding adjustment and disbursement of the amount.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 10 of 11

FAO No.9635 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC:203712

36. Pending miscellaneous applica 6on(s), if any, shall also stand dis-
posed of.

(DEEPAK GUPTA)
JUDGE
November 19, 2026
Sarita
Whether speaking/reasoned? : Yes
Whether reportable? : Yes
Uploaded on: November 19, 2026
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 11 of 11