Khushal Singh vs Ramlakhan Sharma
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
1 SA-2352-2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ASHISH SHROTI
SECOND APPEAL No. 2352 of 2024
CNR No.: MPHC030222372024
KHUSHAL SINGH
Versus
RAMLAKHAN SHARMA AND ANR
Appearance:
Shri N.K. Gupta - learned Senior Advocate with Shri Anugrah Gupta -
Advocate for the appellant.
Shri S.S. Kushwah - learned Government Advocate for the
respondent/State.
Shri Vivek Kumar Mishra - Advocate for respondent No.1.
Reserved on : 06.11.2026
Delivered on : 17.11.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Appellant has filed this appeal under Section 100 of CPC challenging
the judgment and decree dated 27.07.2024 passed by Second District Judge,
Dabra, District Gwalior in RCA No.47/2022 whereby the learned appellate
Court has set aside the decree of permanent injunction issued vide judgment
and decree dated 30.08.2022 by the Second Civil Judge, Junior Division,
Bhitarwar, District Gwalior in RCSA No.26/2016 and has dismissed the suit
filed by appellant.
2. For the purposes of convenience, the appellant shall be referred to
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
2 SA-2352-2024
as 'plaintiff' while respondent no.1 shall be referred to as 'defendant' in this
order as per their respective status in the civil suit. Further, the suit property
in this order would mean the land bearing Survey No.232 ad-measuring
0.460 hectares situated at village Dhakad Khiriya, Tehsil Bhitarwar, District-
Gwalior.
3 . The plaintiff filed the present suit inter-alia alleging that the suit
land was owned and possessed by one Bharosilal. On account of his need for
money, Bharosilal agreed to sell the suit land to plaintiff for a total sum of
Rs.2 lakh out of which he received Rs.1.50 lakh and executed a sale
agreement on 21.06.1998 (Ex. P/1). As per plaintiff, it was agreed that the
balance amount shall be paid at the time of execution of sale deed. The
possession of the land was also given to plaintiff and till sale deed is
executed the plaintiff was to give 1/4th of crop to Bharosilal. The plaintiff
further averred that after about one year, Bharosilal asked for balance
amount of Rs.50,000/- which was also paid by him. He assured plaintiff that
he shall execute sale deed as soon as documents are arranged by him. The
condition of giving 1/4th of crop was ended at this stage.
4 . The plaintiff further averred that since Bharosilal died on
06.05.2013, the sale deed could not be executed in his favour. However, he
continued to enjoy the land as owner thereof. He further averred that the
defendant illegally submitted an application for mutation of his name over
suit land before Tehsildar styling himself to be the nephew of Bharosilal
which was allowed by Tehsildar without notice to plaintiff. When the
defendant tried to interfere with plaintiff’s possession over the suit land, he
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
3 SA-2352-2024
filed an application under Section 145 Cr.P.C. before Sub-Divisional
Magistrate wherein also the plaintiff was found in possession of the suit land.
5. Averring that he is in cultivating possession of suit land for the last
20 years and defendant is trying to interfere with his possession without any
right, the plaintiff filed the present suit seeking declaration of his title over
the suit land and for a decree of permanent injunction restraining defendant
from interfering with plaintiff’s possession over the suit land and further
from encumbering or alienating the same. The defendant denied plaintiffs’
claim over suit land by filing written statement. Besides alleging that the
agreement dated 21.06.1998, is forged and fabricated, the defendant averred
that Bharosilal was unmarried and has died without leaving any Class-I heir.
He claimed that he is the nephew of Bharosilal and asserted his title over the
land on the strength of a registered Will dated 15.04.2013 (Ex. D/1)
allegedly executed in his favour by Bharosilal. He asserted his own
possession over the suit land and further that his name has already been
mutated in revenue records on the basis of Will.
6. The learned trial Court vide judgment and decree 30.08.2022, partly
decreed the suit. The Court held that execution of the agreement dated
21.06.1998 has been duly proved and pursuant thereto the plaintiff is in
possession of suit land since the date of execution of agreement. The
payment of Rs.1.50 lakh was also found proved, however, payment of
remaining Rs.50,000/- was not held established. The trial Court also declined
to declare plaintiff to be the owner of suit land on the basis of sale agreement
and also on the basis of his adverse possession. However, finding that the
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
4 SA-2352-2024
defendant is trying to interfere with plaintiff’s possession, the learned trial
Court issued a decree of permanent injunction restraining defendant from
interfering with plaintiff’s possession over the suit land without due process
of law. It is also noted that the trial Court did not accept the Will allegedly
executed by Bharosilal in favour of defendant. The defendant, being
aggrieved filed the appeal challenging the judgment and decree passed by
trial Court which is subject matter of this appeal.
7. It is informed by learned counsel for parties that the plaintiff has
also filed separate appeal challenging part of judgment and decree of trial
Court whereby he has been denied relief of declaration of title. The same is
subject matter of RCA No.50/2022 and is pending before Second District
Judge, Dabra as informed by learned counsel for parties while the appeal
filed by defendant was disposed of by learned Second District Judge, Dabra.
8. The appeal was admitted by this Court vide order dated 06.11.2026,
on the following substantial question of law:
“Whether the learned First Appellate Court grossly erred in
finally deciding the appeal filed by the respondent by relying upon
the additional documents filed by the respondent under Order 41
Rule 27 of the CPC and rendering its own findings on the basis of
those documents in the judgment, without following the procedure
prescribed under Rule 28 thereof ?”
9. The learned Senior counsel for plaintiff at the outset submitted that
when two separate appeals were filed challenging the same judgment and
decree of trial Court, they were required to be heard by the same Court so as
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
5 SA-2352-2024
to avoid conflicting judgments. He further submitted that the learned
Appellate Court allowed application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC and took
additional documents filed by defendant on record. As per his contention, the
appellate Court ought to have remitted the matter to trial Court affording
opportunity to plaintiff to rebut these documents. However, the appellate
Court allowed the appeal considering the documents filed by defendant. The
learned senior counsel argued that the documents filed by defendant and
relied upon by appellate Court relates to period after filing of suit and,
therefore, the same cannot be relied upon for purposes of deciding issue of
possession of parties over suit land. He contended that the issue of
possession is required to be decided as on the date of filing of suit and,
therefore, the application was incorrectly decided by the appellate Court. The
senior counsel submitted that after allowing the application by appellate
Court, the procedure as prescribed under Rule 28 of Order 41 CPC ought to
have been followed by the Court. He thus prayed for setting aside of
impugned judgment and decree.
10. On the other hand, the learned counsel for defendant supported the
impugned judgment and decree passed by appellate Court. As per his
contention, since the documents which were filed by defendant were only
certified copies of revenue record, the same could have been relied upon by
appellate Court for deciding the appeal. It is further submission that since the
additional documents filed by defendant are necessary for deciding the issue
of possession of parties, the appellate Court rightly allowed the application.
It is his further submission that the impugned judgment and decree is legal
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
6 SA-2352-2024
and valid and does not call for any interference by this Court in this appeal.
11. Considered the submissions made by learned counsel for parties
and perused the records.
12. It is seen that challenging the judgment and decree passed by the
trial Court, two appeals were filed. The present one was filed by defendant
which was placed before Second District Judge, Dabra, while the appeal filed
by plaintiff (RCA No.50/2022) was initially placed before Third District
Judge, Dabra and the same is now pending in the Court of Second District
Judge, Dabra. Consequently, the present appeal got decided first while the
appeal filed by plaintiff is still stated to be pending. There can be no quarrel
on the issue that whenever cross-appeals are filed challenging the same
judgment and decree, they should be heard by the same Court so as to
obviate possibility of passing of conflicting findings and judgments. In the
case in hand, it is not clear as to whether the information about pendency of
other appeal was brought to the notice of appellate Court or not. The finding
about execution of sale agreement dated 21.06.1998 (Ex. P/1) after payment
of Rs.1.50 lakh by plaintiff to Bharosilal has been affirmed by appellate
Court also in this case. The agreement has been held proved.
13. The Appellate Court has also affirmed the finding of the trial Court
that the Will dated 15.04.2013 is not proved. Regarding possession, the
learned Trial Court found plaintiff to be in possession. It is also noted that
the trial Court had found plaintiff’s possession over suit land based upon the
admission of defendant witness- Jagdish (DW-2) and Ravindra (DW-3).
However, the Appellate Court has reversed this finding relying upon the
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
7 SA-2352-2024
documents filed by defendant under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC. It is seen that
some of these documents, filed alongwith this application, relates to the
period subsequent to filing of suit. Relying upon these documents,
particularly the order dated 22.06.2018 passed by SDO under Section 250 of
MPLRC, the appellate Court has held the possession of suit land to be with
defendant. The scope of Order 41 Rule 27 CPC was explained by Apex
Court in the case of Union of India vs. Ibrahim Uddin, (2012)8 SCC 148,
wherein the Court held as under:
“47. Where the additional evidence sought to be adduced
removes the cloud of doubt over the case and the evidence has a
direct and important bearing on the main issue in the suit and
interest of justice clearly renders it imperative that it may be
allowed to be permitted on record, such application may be
allowed.
48. To sum up on the issue, it may be held that an
application for taking additional evidence on record at a belated
stage cannot be filed as a matter of right. The court can consider
such an application with circumspection, provided it is covered
under either of the prerequisite conditions incorporated in the
statutory provisions itself. The discretion is to be exercised by the
court judicially taking into consideration the relevance of the
document in respect of the issues involved in the case and the
circumstances under which such an evidence could not be led in
the court below and as to whether the applicant had prosecuted his
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
8 SA-2352-2024
case before the court below diligently and as to whether such
evidence is required to pronounce the judgment by the appellate
court. In case the court comes to the conclusion that the
application filed comes within the four corners of the statutory
provisions itself, the evidence may be taken on record, however,
the court must record reasons as on what basis such an application
has been allowed. However, the application should not be moved
at a belated stage.”
14. It is thus evident that under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, the discretion
should be exercised by the Court judicially taking into consideration the
relevance of the document vis-à-vis the issues involved in the case. The
circumstances under which such evidence could not be led before the trial
Court and as to whether the party concerned had prosecuted his case before
the trial Court diligently and as to whether such evidence is required to
pronounce the judgment by the appellate court, are the important and
relevant considerations before the appellate Court while considering the
application. If the Court comes to a conclusion that the application filed
comes within the four corners of the statutory provision, the evidence may be
taken on record, however, the Court must record reasons as to on what basis
such an application has been allowed.
15. Keeping in view the aforesaid legal position, the documents filed
by defendant before appellate Court needs to be considered. Firstly, in the
application filed under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, except stating that the
documents were left out from filing before trial Court and that the documents
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
9 SA-2352-2024
are certified copy of revenue records, no reason is assigned for not filing the
documents before trial Court. The first document filed by defendant is the
order dated 18.02.2014 passed by Tehsildar permitting mutation of
defendant’s name in revenue records on the basis of Will dated 15.04.2013.
This document is already filed before trial Court and marked as Ex. P/3. The
other document is the order dated 14.04.2016 passed by SDO affirming the
Tehsildar order dated 18.02.2014. This is also available on trial Court record
as Ex.P/4.
16. The defendant also filed copy of order dated 22.06.2018 passed by
SDO whereby the order of Tehsildar dated 29.09.2014 passed under Section
250 MPLRC has been set aside and the possession of the land was directed
to be delivered to defendant from plaintiff. Pursuant to this order of SDO,
Revenue Inspector submitted report regarding delivery of possession to
defendant on 15.11.2018. Apparently these documents relate to period after
filing of suit and therefore, could not have been an evidence for recording
defendant’s possession over suit land as on the date of filing of suit.
17. Pertinently, the plaintiff has filed I.A. No.10592 of 2026, an
application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC before this Court alleging that the
possession was never taken from plaintiff in compliance of SDO order
22.06.2018. The possession delivery report and the possession receipt are
stated to be prepared sitting in office without actual delivery of possession.
The order of SDO has been challenged by plaintiff before Commissioner,
Gwalior, and the proceedings are still pending. The plaintiff has also asserted
his possession over suit land in view of the fact that the defendant has again
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34450
10 SA-2352-2024
filed an application under Section 250 MPLRC before Tehsildar which is
subject matter of Case No.008/2024-2025/A-70, seeking possession of suit
land. The application was rejected by Tehsildar vide order dated 05.12.2024.
The application and order sheets of Tehsildar are also placed on record. From
the aforesaid, it is evident that the learned appellate Court erred in allowing
the application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC filed by defendant without
considering the relevancy of documents for decision of the case. The
application could not have been allowed as the documents are not relevant
for just decision of the case. The possession of parties over suit land needs to
be decided on the material as obtaining on the date of filing of suit. In view
of the aforesaid, the substantial question of law is answered holding that the
Appellate Court erred in allowing the application under Order 41 Rule 27
CPC filed by defendant. The application is accordingly rejected.
18. In view of aforesaid, the judgment and decree dated 27.07.2024
passed by Second District Judge, Dabra, District Gwalior, in RCA
No.47/2022 is set aside. The matter is remitted to learned Appellate Court to
re-decide the appeal. The matter be placed before Principal District Judge,
Gwalior for assigning the present appeal to be decided along with RCA
No.50/2022 filed by plaintiff by one Court for analogous decision.
19. With the aforesaid, the appeal is allowed.
(ASHISH SHROTI)
JUDGE
VC
VARSHA CHATURVEDI
2026.11.18 11:59:33 +05'30'