THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES (AUDIT) 4.3, vs KARNATAKA STATE BEVERAGES CORPORATION LIMITED
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
TH
RESERVED ON 11 NOVEMBER 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 18 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
WRIT APPEAL NO. 1153 OF 2025 (EXCISE)
C/W
WRIT APPEAL NO. 677 OF 2026 (T-RES)
SALES TAX REVISION PETITION NO. 15 OF 2026
IN WA No.1153/2025
BETWEEN:
1. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF
COMMERCIAL TAXES (AUDIT)
TH
4.3, DVO-IV, 4 FLOOR
VTK-2, KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU - 560 047
2.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF
COMMERCIAL TAXES
(AUDIT AND RECOVERY)
BELAGAVI - 590 001
…APPELLANTS
Digitally
signed by
VEERENDRA
KUMAR K M
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
(BY SRI ADITYA VIKRAM BHAT, AGA)
AND:
1.
M/S. SHREE RENUKA SUGARS LTD.
REPRESENTED BY ITS
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (FINANCE)
- 2 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
SRI RAHUL PATIL
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS
ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE:
ST
NO.7, 1 CROSS
KUMAR KOT ROAD
RACE COURSE ROAD CROSS
BENGALURU - 560 001
2. THE KARNATAKA STATE BEVERAGES
CORPORATION LTD.
(A GOVERNMENT OF
KARNATAKA UNDERTAKING)
NO.78, SEETHALAKSHMI TOWER
MISSION ROAD
BENGALURU - 560 027
3. THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (O)
THE KARNATAKA STATE BEVERAGES
CORPORATION LTD.
TH
4 FLOOR, TTMC 'A' BLOCK
BMTC BUILDING
K.H. ROAD, SHANTINAGAR
BENGALURU - 560 027
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI P.N. MANMOHAN, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI VINAY N., ADVOCATE FOR R-1 &
MS. SUMANA BALIGA, ADVOCATE FOR R-2 & 3)
THIS WRIT APPEAL FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
ORDER DATED 21.10.2024 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BENGALURU IN
W.P.No.9571 OF 2017 & ETC.
- 3 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
IN WA NO. 677/2026
BETWEEN:
1. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
OF COMMERCIAL TAXES (AUDIT)
TH
4.3 DVO-IV, 4 FLOOR
VTK-2, KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU - 560 047
2.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
OF COMMERCIAL TAXES
(AUDIT AND RECOVERY)
BELAGAVI - 590 001
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI ADITYA VIKRAM BHAT, AGA)
AND:
1. KARNATAKA STATE BEVERAGES
CORPORATION LIMITED
(A GOVERNMENT OF
KARNATAKA UNDERTAKING)
TH
4 FLOOR, TTMC, 'A' BLOCK
BMTC BUILDING, K.H. ROAD
SHANTHI NAGAR
BENGALURU - 560 001
REPRESENTED BY THE EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR (O) KSBC LTD.
2. THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (O)
THE KARNATAKA STATE BEVERAGES
CORPORATION LTD.
TH
4 FLOOR, TTMC A BLOCK
BMTC BUILDING, K.H. ROAD
SHANTHI NAGAR
BENGALURU - 560 001
- 4 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
3. M/S. SHREE RENUKA SUGARS LTD.
COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER
COMPANIES ACT, 1956
ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE
ST
NO. 7, 1 CROSS
RACE COURSE ROAD CROSS
BENGALURU - 560 001
REPRESENTED BY ITS
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (FINANCE)
SRI RAHUL PATIL
4. KARNATAKA APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR
ST ND
1 GATE, 2 FLOOR
M.S. BUILDING
BENGALURU - 560 001
...RESPONDENTS
(BY MS. SUMANA BALIGA, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 & 2;
SRI P.N. MANMOHAN, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI VINAY N, ADVOCATE FOR R-3)
THIS WRIT APPEAL FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
ORDER DATED 04.09.2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BENGALURU IN
W.P.No.25944 OF 2025 & ETC.
IN STRP NO. 15/2026
BETWEEN:
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
VIDHANA SOUDHA
BENGALURU - 560 001
- 5 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
2. THE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF
COMMERCIAL TAXES (APPELS)-4
ND
2 FLOOR, BMTC BUILDING
SHANTINAGARA
BENGALURU - 560 027
3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF
COMMERCIAL TAXES, AUDIT-4.3
TH
DVO-4, 4 FLOOR
ROOM NO.404
NEAR NATIONAL GAMES VILLAGE
KORMANAGALA
BENGALURU - 560 022
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI ADITYA VIKRAM BHAT, AGA)
AND:
1. M/S. KARNATAKA STATE BEVERAGES
CORPORATION LIMITED
TH
4 FLOOR, TTMC 'A' BLOCK
BMTC BUILDING
SHANTHINAGAR
BENGALURU - 560 027
2. M/S SHREE RENUKA SUGARS LTD.
REPRESENTED BY IS MANAGER (ACCOUNTS)
SRI RAHUL PATIL
HAVING ADMINITRATIVE OFFICE AT:
ST
NO.7, 1 CROSS
KUMAR KOT ROAD
RACE COURSE ROAD
BENGALURU - 560 001
...RESPONDENTS
(BY MS. SUMANA BALIGA, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 &
SRI P.N. MANMOHAN, ADVOCATE FOR R-2)
- 6 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
THIS SALES TAX REVISION PETITION IS FILED UNDER
SEC.65(1) OF THE KARNATAKA VALUE ADDED TAX ACT, 2003
PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 12.09.2025 PASSED
BY THE HON'BLE KARNATAKA APPELLATE TRIBUNAL IN STA
NO.297 OF 2017 PRODUCED AS ANNEXURE-A & RESTORE THE
ORDER DATED 31.03.2017 PASSED BY THE JOINT
COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES (APPEALS)-4 IN
CST.AP.No.60/2016/2017 PRODUCED AS ANNEXURE -T AND ETC.
THESE WRIT APPEALS AND SALES TAX REVISION PETITION
HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT, COMING
ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS
PRONOUNCED AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE)
1. For the reasons stated in the applications seeking
condonation of delay, I.A.No.1/2025 in W.A.No.1153/2025 and
I.A.No.1/2026 in W.A.No.677/2026, the same are allowed. The
delay in filing the said appeals is condoned.
2. With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the
appeals were heard together.
- 7 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
3. The principal order was passed by the learned Single Judge
in W.P.No.9571/2017 (Excise). It directed the Karnataka Appellate
Tribunal [ KAT ] to dispose of the appeal being STA No.297/2017,
which was at the material time pending before the learned KAT, in
favour of the Karnataka State Beverages Corporation Limited
[hereafter KSBCL ]. This order is appealed in W.A.No.1153/2025.
4. While the said appeal was pending, the KSBCL filed a writ
petition being W.P.No.25944/2025 (T-RES), essentially seeking
implementation of the order passed in W.P.No.9571/2017 (Excise).
The said petition was allowed by the order dated 04.09.2025. This
order is impugned in W.A.No.677/2026. The consequential order
was passed by the learned KAT on 12.09.2025, which is impugned
in STRP No.15/2026.
5. We note that there is no delay in filing STRP No.15/2026. It
is apparent from the above that the State had not accepted any of
the orders which are impugned in W.A.No.1153/2025,
W.A.No.677/2026 and STRP No.15/2026. As noted above, the writ
order, which is appealed in W.A.No.677/2026, was a follow up of
an earlier order, which was the subject matter of a pending appeal.
It is apparent that the Revenue had not accepted the orders
- 8 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
passed by the learned Single Judge and was pursuing its
remedies.
6. The Revenue (Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes)
has filed W.A.No.1153 of 2025 impugning an order dated
21.10.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge in Writ Petition
No.9571 of 2017 (Excise).
7. Respondent No.1, M/s Shree Renuka Sugars Limited
inter alia,
[hereafter SRSL ], had filed the said petition, praying that
₹
KSBCL be directed to refund an amount of 56,07,738/- recovered
by it pursuant to invocation of the indemnity bond dated
17.08.2013. SRSL also sought directions for KSBCL to release an
₹
amount of 1,32,97,074/-, which according to SRSL was payable
and outstanding.
inter alia
8. SRSL had furnished an indemnity bond, ,
indemnifying KSBCL in respect of any liability that may arise from
an export of spirits through KSBCL. Since the Revenue had raised
a demand under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 [ CST Act ] and
the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 [ KVAT Act ], KSBCL
had invoked the indemnity bond.
- 9 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
9. During the course of the proceedings the Revenue was
impleaded in the Writ Petition. According to the learned Single
Judge, the demand raised by the Revenue under the CST Act and
the KVAT Act was not sustainable as the goods in question (spirits)
had been exported. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ
petition and further directed that KSBCL’s second appeal (STA
No.297/2017), arising out of the demand raised by the Revenue,
be disposed of by the learned KAT in favour of KSBCL.
10. The Revenue preferred an intra Court appeal,
W.A.No.1153/2025(Excise), against the said order. The Revenue
is essentially aggrieved by the said decision, as according to the
Revenue, the taxes were payable as the necessary forms (Form-
H) had not been furnished by the KSBCL. The question whether
filing of the said form is mandatory, was pending consideration
before the learned KAT, which was foreclosed by the learned
Single Judge by directing that the said appeal be decided in favour
of KSBCL.
11. The KAT did not dispose of the KSBCL’s second appeal
(STA No.297/2017) as directed by the impugned order dated
21.10.2024. The Revenue also filed an appeal against the
- 10 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
impugned order dated 21.10.2024. This led KSBCL to file writ
petition, W.P.No.25944/2025, inter alia, seeking a direction for the
learned KAT to comply with the impugned order dated 21.10.2024,
passed in W.P.No.9571/2017. The learned Single Judge allowed
the said writ petition (W.P.No.25944/2025) by an order dated
04.09.2025 and directed the learned KAT to comply with the
impugned order dated 21.10.2024.
12. The learned KAT disposed of the second appeal, STA
No.297/2017 in favour of KSBCL as directed by the order dated
04.09.2025. The Revenue has filed the revision petition, STRP
No.15/2026, under Section 65(1) of the KVAT Act impugning the
order passed by the learned KAT.
13. It is material to note that the learned KAT had allowed
KSBCL's second appeal solely for the reason that it was directed to
do so by the learned Single Judge and not because it found any
merit in the KSBCL's appeal.
14. As noted above, the impugned order dated 04.09.2025
passed in W.P.No.25944/2025 rests on the impugned order dated
- 11 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
21.10.2024 passed in W.P.No.9571/2017, inasmuch as it
essentially directs compliance with the said order.
15. Thus, the principal challenge in STRP No.15/2026 and
W.A.No.677/2026 rests entirely on the challenge to the impugned
order dated 21.10.2024 passed in W.P.No.9571/2017.
16. The principal question to be addressed is whether the
impugned order dated 21.10.2024 is sustainable.
17. The controversy in the present appeals arises in the
following context.
inter alia
18. That SRSL is a public company, , engaged in
manufacture and sale of white sugar and denatured ethanol
anhydrous which is an allied product. SRSL has obtained a
license for manufacturing the same under the Karnataka Excise
(Denatured Spirit and Denatured Spirituous Preparations) Rules,
1967 [hereafter the Denatured Spirit Rules ].
19. SRSL received an export order from M/s. Kolmar Group AG,
Metalli, Baarerstrasse 18, 633 Zug, Switzerland [hereafter M/s.
Kolmar Group ] for supply of 3000 MT of denatured ethanol
- 12 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
anhydrous to be delivered FOB Mumbai Port. M/s. Kolmar Group
also issued a purchase order dated 23.07.2013 for export of the
said goods.
20. Admittedly at the material time, under Rule 4 of the
Denatured Spirit Rules, denatured spirits could be exported only
through KSBCL, which was appointed as a licensee. The KSBCL
issued a Circular bearing No.135 dated 19.06.2007 setting out the
“Sourcing Policy for Rectified Spirit and Denatured Spirit” [ the
Circular ]. The Circular sets out a detailed procedure for sourcing
of the said products. In terms of clause 6 of the said Circular, the
manufacturers were at liberty to contact prospective customers and
conclude contracts for rectified spirit and denatured spirit at a
predetermined price. It provided that the validity and the quantity of
the contract would be in accordance with the allotment order that
may be issued by the Excise Commissioner and the KSBCL would
in turn place an order for supplies on the manufacturer and the
manufacturer would be obliged to deliver the same. The said policy
also expressly provided that the manufacturer would be liable for
compliances. It was also liable for all losses and taxes.
- 13 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
21. Under clause 16 of the Circular, the manufacturer/ supplier
was required to keep KSBCL harmless and indemnified in all
matters arising from the supply of spirit and its subsequent
disposal.
22. SRSL obtained the necessary No Objection Certificate
[ NOC ] from the Excise Commissioner for export of denatured
ethanol. SRSL also claimed that it issued a letter dated
19.08.2013 to KSBCL requesting for issue of an Order for Supply
[ OFS ] of denatured ethanol for exports. SRSL provided an
indemnity bond by an indemnity letter dated 17.08.2013
indemnifying KSBCL against any liability arising from the said
transaction.
23. SRSL claims that it transported the goods in question from
its manufacturing unit located in Athani Taluk, Belagavi District, to
Mumbai port during the period 21.08.2013 to 13.09.2013. SRSL
also raised invoices (263 in number) for the said supply on KSBCL,
where KSBCL was shown as a consignee of the said goods.
KSBCL in turn raised invoice-cum-delivery challan in favour of the
overseas buyer: M/s Kolmar Group.
- 14 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
24. The Revenue (The Deputy Commissioner of Commercial
Taxes (Audit)-4.3, Bengaluru) issued a notice dated 25.02.2016 to
KSBCL under Section 9(2) of CST Act, proposing reassessment of
the tax liability on the ground that it was not entitled to the tax
benefit as the deemed export turnover declared by it was not
supported by declarations in the necessary form – Form “H”.
25. KSBCL responded to the said notice and objected to the
same. However, the same were rejected and the Deputy
Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Audit)-4.3, Bengaluru passed
a reassessment order dated 21.10.2016 under Section 9(2) of the
₹
CST Act, determining KSBCL’s liability of 1,86,92,460/- which
was inclusive of tax and interest.
26. Since the demand was in connection with the export of
goods manufactured by SRSL, KSBCL invoked the indemnity bond
furnished by SRSL. It also preferred an appeal against the
reassessment order dated 21.10.2016 under Section 62 of the
KVAT Act read with Section 9(2) of the CST Act before the First
1
Appellate Authority [ FAA ] .
1
The Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Appeals-4, Shanthinagar, Bengaluru
- 15 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
27. The FAA dismissed the said appeal by an order dated
31.03.2017. The FAA rejected the KSBCL’s contention that it was
not required to furnish “H” Forms for claiming exemption of
deemed exports.
28. KSBCL impugned the order passed by the FAA by preferring
a second appeal, STA No.297/2017, before the learned KAT.
REASONS & CONCLUSION
29. It is clear from the above that KSBCL had invoked the
indemnity bond on account of the liability assessed by the
Revenue, and the Revenue had raised the liability as the
necessary declarations for claiming the benefit, that is, Form “H”
had not been furnished.
30. SRSL’s writ petition (W.P.No.9571/2017) was premised on
the basis that the KSBCL had erroneously invoked the indemnity
bond. SRSL also claimed that it had raised invoices showing
KSBCL as consignee and the sale was effected against the
declaration in Form-H. Thus, SRSL had neither charged nor
collected any taxes under the KVAT Act or CST Act. SRSL also
- 16 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
claimed that it had not violated any terms of the Circular and
therefore, the invocation of the indemnity bond was illegal.
31. In view of the controversy, the learned Single Judge was
required to confine the examination to whether KSBCL had rightly
invoked the indemnity bond and had withheld the amounts as
claimed by SRSL.
32. The dispute between SRSL and KSBCL was required to be
inter-se
addressed in the context of their obligations. The demand
raised by the Revenue could not be made the subject matter of
dispute as KSBCL had availed recourse to the statutory remedies
in respect of those demands.
33. It is also relevant to note that clause 15 of the Circular also
provided that any disputes between the parties may be referred to
arbitration.
34. In view of the matter, the question whether the Revenue had
rightly reassessed the liability on KSBCL was not a dispute that
ought to have been entertained by the learned Single Judge. The
said question was the subject matter of KSBCL’s appeal under
Section 63 of the KVAT Act, which was pending before the learned
- 17 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
KAT, (STA No.297/2017) and thus, the said question is required to
be considered by the said Authority.
35. The Additional Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Legal
Affairs) also filed an affidavit in W.P.No.9571/2017 affirming that
KSBCL had filed returns claiming deemed export of denatured
ethanol anhydrous during the period August, 2013 and September,
₹
2013 of a value of 13,04,70,000/- for the month of August, 2013
₹
and 12,22,16,250/- for the month of September, 2013,
₹
aggregating to 25,26,86,250/-. However, KSBCL had failed to
furnish the necessary declarations in Form-H in support of the
claim for deemed export turnover.
36. The Revenue has also produced the returns and revised
returns filed by KSBCL which clearly indicate that it had claimed
deemed exports against H-Form and it reflected the direct exports
as ‘0’ (Zero). It is the Revenue’s case that KSBCL was required to
furnish Form-H which had not been furnished.
37. It is also relevant to note that the Deputy General Manager
(Finance) of SRSL had also filed an affidavit stating as under:
- 18 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
“8. It is respectfully submitted that notwithstanding
that the First Respondent has acted only as a
canalising agent, by virtue of the fact that the First
Respondent has raised an Invoice in favour of the
foreign buyer, the sale by the First Respondent is
an Export Sale as understood under Section 5 (1)
of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (hereinafter
referred to as the " CENTRAL ACT "). Accordingly,
the First Respondent while filing its original returns
for the tax periods August, 2013 and September,
2013 had declared the said turnovers under the
Central Act as Export Sales. Thereafter,
inadvertently, or upon being wrongly advised, the
First Respondent filed revised returns for the said
tax periods declaring the said turnovers as being
deemed exports against declarations in Form-H as
envisaged in Section 5 (3) of the Central Act.
38. According to the Revenue, the said statement is incorrect as
KSBCL had reflected its direct exports in its return as well as in the
revised return as ‘0’ (zero). Further, there was no change in regard
to KSBCL’s claim for deemed exports in both original returns for
the month of August, 2013 filed on 17.09.2013 and revised returns
filed on 27.01.2014. Similarly, neither the original returns for the
month of September, 2013 filed on 07.10.2013 nor the revised
returns filed on 29.01.2014 reflected any direct exports.
39. The question whether it was mandatory for the KSBCL to
furnish Form-H was neither the issue in the writ petition nor has the
said question been addressed by the learned Single Judge. The
- 19 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
learned Single Judge had proceeded on the premise that there is
no dispute that the goods had been exported and therefore the
demand raised, is not sustainable.
40. In our view, the learned Single Judge had erred in directing
the learned KAT to dispose of the second appeal in favour of
KSBCL. First of all, it was not apposite for the learned Single
Judge to have entertained any question regarding KSBCL’s tax
liability, which was the subject matter of pending proceedings
before the learned KAT. More importantly , the learned Single
Judge did not address the principal issue that was pending
consideration before the learned KAT; that is, whether it was
necessary for KSBCL to furnish Form-H for claiming benefit under
deemed exports.
41. In our view, the impugned order inasmuch as it holds that
there is no dispute that since SRSL had exported the goods in
question, KSBCL’s claim for exemption would have to be accepted,
cannot be sustained as it fails to address the question whether it
was mandatory to furnish the necessary declarations in the
prescribed forms.
- 20 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
42. The said impugned order insofar as it directs the
transactions between the SRSL and KSBCL to be considered as
deemed export and the KSBCL to be relieved of its liability in this
regard is also not sustainable for the reason that the said direction
has been issued without considering the relevant rules and the
principal question whether such an exemption can be granted
without furnishing necessary declaration in Form-H, as required.
43. It is also material to note that the impugned order records the
Revenue’s contention that the transaction is not revenue neutral as
Form-H was not furnished by the KSBCL, as it was necessary.
However, as mentioned hereinbefore, the learned Single Judge
had not considered the said issue.
44. It is also noted that the impugned order rests solely on the
basis that the KSBCL is not liable to pay tax and interest as
assessed by the Revenue. Since the learned Single Judge’s
decision in this regard is ex-facie erroneous, the impugned order
cannot be sustained.
45. We, accordingly, set aside the impugned order dated
21.10.2024 passed in W.P.No.9571/2017 (Excise) and remand the
- 21 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
matter to the learned Single Judge. All contentions regarding the
inter-se dispute between SRSL and KSBCL are reserved.
However, the learned Single Judge shall also examine whether it
would be apposite to entertain this dispute in proceedings under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
46. We may also note that if SRSL has derived any
consequential benefits from the impugned order, the same would
have to be reversed.
47. In view of our decision, the impugned order dated
04.09.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge in
W.P.No.25944/2025, which is impugned in W.A.No.677/2026 is
also set aside. Consequently, W.P.No.25944/2025 does not
survive and stands disposed of.
48. Since the learned KAT had passed the order dated
12.09.2025 in STA No.297/2017 solely in compliance with the
aforementioned impugned orders (impugned orders dated
21.10.2024 and 04.09.2025), the said order is also liable to be set
aside.
- 22 -
WA No. 1153 of 2025
C/W WA No. 677 of 2026
STRP No. 15 of 2026
49. The Revenue’s Sale Tax Revision Petition - STRP
No.15/2026, is accordingly allowed. The said appeal (STA
No.297/2017) is restored before the learned KAT for a decision
afresh, uninfluenced by any order passed by this Court in these
proceedings. We clarify that nothing stated in this order shall be
construed as our opinion on the question whether filing of form H
was mandatory and whether KSBCL is entitled to the benefit of
deemed exports.
50. The appeals, W.A.No.1153/2025 and W.A.No.677/2025 and
the Sale Tax Revision Petition, STRP No.15/2026 are allowed in
the aforesaid terms.
51. Pending applications also stand disposed of.
Sd/-
(VIBHU BAKHRU)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/-
(K.S. HEMALEKHA)
JUDGE
KMV